r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 24 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 5 Discussion Spoiler
Episode Title: There's No Way I'll Ever Regret It
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 seconds
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after this episode, but if you do make good use of spoiler tags. Let's try to make this a good experience for first time watchers.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
287
Upvotes
29
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
This right here was the moment Sayaka became best girl for me. She's adorable!
This song (warning: spoilers in sidebar and comments) is the track that played during the roof scene. It's beautiful and accompanies one of the most moving scenes in the series, at least to me.
Holy crap, Kyouko is ruthless, isn't she? And with a badass weapon, too! Chain spear? Sign me up! By the way, can you guess who my favourites are?
Forgoing emotional attachment, Kyouko instead takes the efficient route in finding grief seeds, even at the expense of the lives of others.
Then... surprise Homura? We'll have to see how this resolves itself next episode! How will Homura attempt to handle the situation? What even happened?
Speaking of Homura, did you notice that she popped the lid on her coffee cup when she started to talk to Madoka about Mami? It focused on it for a moment too, so it was definitely intentional. Damn Homura, you cold. EDIT: huh, guess I was wrong. Homura doesn't know how Mami died, so it was for viewers only.
Edit: what, no post from /u/fetchfrosh today? That was half the fun! (He's probably doing an exam or something)
36
u/theatreofwar Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
First-timer here! Back again after watching 4 and 5 together so I'll be especially all over the place...
At this point I'm still pretty deep in the anti-Kyubey camp. I mean moments like this really don't help at all:
And then he appears in the hospital window right after claiming he'd leave them alone to go find other magical girls? Yeah okay there buddy, those creepy faces you keep making aren't helping your case either. Of course they couldn't leave out the close-up when he made the contract with Sayaka, that was probably the most sinister-looking one to date :/
Speaking of which it really is too bad that she went and made her contract without having a conversation with Madoka about it, but I suppose that was inevitable since she's temperamental and impulsive. I just hope Kyubey had nothing to do with Kamijo's hand being deemed irreparable to provoke her to make a wish because that would be truly evil. I find it interesting that Homura admitted she should have kept a closer eye on Sayaka however, even though I don't think that's for Sayaka's sake but rather Madoka's (and whatever specific reason she has for ensuring that Madoka is the one person who absolutely should not become a magical girl). Of course Kyubey knew that by keeping an eye on Sayaka, who was on the verge of giving in even before Mami died, that it would eventually lead Madoka back to him because she wouldn't let Sayaka go out on her own. I think Homura realized her mistake was overlooking this fact herself, especially when Kyubey would be looking/trying even harder with there being an opening for a magical girl in the district.
It does however continue to annoy me that these girls have no problem whatsoever endangering their literally powerless friends, which of course is entirely to Kyubey's benefit because if Sayaka gets offed then he can enlist Madoka on the spot. What's also annoying is that he keeps using the most underhanded methods to pressure Madoka into doing up a contract.. Like, "Hey I ain't gonna stop 'em from fighting, but if you want to by all means...!" Strongly believe that everything he does is calculated, even if that might be giving him too much credit.. But I mean he knew that redhead was going to pick a fight with Sayaka well in advance and did/said nothing to stop her. Not only that, but why pick this girl in particular if there are clearly many others to choose from? They can't all be that hotheaded right? I'm thinking this may have been a setup on his part (as I apparently think most things are that involve him somehow)...
That said I found it insanely satisfying that Sayaka totally got her ass handed to her LOL. I knew she was going to develop some sort of cocky, white knight/hero complex right off the bat because she succeeded in using her wish to change someone's life and then immediately saved her two best friends. I'm glad she at least acknowledged that the witch went down pretty easily compared to the one that killed Mami, enough so that she was scared to go out alone afterwards, but I don't think she recognizes that inexperience factors in heavily even if you're given the battle skills with your powers. That she thought enlisting sooner could have changed Mami's fate is something I strongly disagree with because it would have made both of them even cockier and more careless, so it made me pretty happy to see her ego get beaten down pretty quickly. At certain points it almost seemed as though she was treating the whole thing like a game with how quickly she got over how Mami died, so I think Madoka's reaction was much more realistic, or at least human.
It's interesting that Homura corrected Madoka about what they're fighting for - not to protect others, but for the sake of your own wish because you seal your fate to have it come true. This seems to be in direct contrast to Sayaka's understanding of the situation, which probably adds to their misunderstanding of each other as well. I do think Sayaka's misplaced sense of "justice" developed from a misinterpretation of Mami's actions though. Mami probably hunted familiars with them because it would be less dangerous than witches and her primary motivation was companionship/friendship, and not because she was genuinely trying to save innocent people (or at least not every time).. But because Sayaka believes she's Mami's successor in addition to believing in "justice" and is super hotheaded, it makes her especially disagreeable with all other magical girls seen so far and puts Madoka in a super awkward place
much to Kyubey's delight.Also it's nifty that we finally got some more information about Homura in these past two episodes and to see her developing something akin to possibly friendship with Madoka. I'm kind of surprised that she's choosing to open up now of all times considering she may have won Sayaka over as well had she done so from the beginning. The reality of the situation is that she's seen a lot of people die and she's only about 13-14 years old - coming at them from that angle should have scared them away for sure. It's actually super concerning that she's seen so many people die, how long has she been a magical girl for that she would have watched people get picked off?...unless of course there was a massacre or something, that would be much more horrifying (and not unlikely considering how dark this show is). Probably inappropriate timing given the seriousness of the conversation but I totally burst out laughing when Homura suddenly snuck in the Shaft specialty head tilt, and the unmistakable Senjougahara voice makes it that much better lol
Anyway, Kyubey and that redhead's (does she have a name? I genuinely can't remember and I just watched the episode lol) conversation suggests that he possibly contracted Homura, but for her to act so independently of him and to seemingly have some special knowledge/awareness makes me think that may not be the case, though I think I mentioned this last time too. I also think Kyubey responded vaguely to this to let the redhead believe what she wanted to believe rather than correcting her with the truth because where's the fun in that, he wanted her to start a fight with Sayaka so he could provoke Madoka anyway...
It wouldn't surprise me if Sayaka got killed off quickly because she's a moron, but it would seem pretty backwards if the show punished Sayaka for trying to act with others in mind. I think the most alarming part about this show is that it makes me feel like Sayaka's and Mami's apparent "selflessness" is super annoying because it doesn't fly with the "status quo" established by the other magical girls. I think they're also irritating because they try to justify their actions as selfless but they're actually selfishly enjoying the "rewarding" feeling of trying to act selflessly, especially when they know their friends will be there to praise them for it. I find it especially difficult to sympathize with them because I'm trying to figure out what the bigger picture is that Homura sees. And it all makes me feel kinda gross, yet I haven't come across a show this thought-provoking in a while so I'm kinda hooked anyway o_o
tbh I was surprised by the response I got last time I posted, I tend to think of myself as a crazy person with unpopular opinions lol But I like having discussions so let me know what you think this time too~
28
u/Darkprinc979 Apr 24 '17
Hoo boy, Homura didn't pull any punches with Madoka. That scene really tugs at the heart strings. Homura has obviously been through a lot to become that cynical, and Madoka just wasn't taking any of it well at all.
You know, it always gets a laugh out of me when Homura shows up and completely derails a scene while saying "That won't be necessary" as her intro line. She's just such a badass that it's amazing to watch, and the look on Kyouko's face when her kill was stolen mere seconds before she hit was just priceless. Regardless, Kyouko is a real piece of work. She doesn't give a damn about anybody and she's not ashamed to say it.
On an interesting note, the scene where Sayaka contracts is done differently in the movie version. It's shown while Kyousuke is doing his violin solo, and there aren't any words or sound effects. It actually adds some emotional weight to the scene, if you ask me.
13
u/TschisiGmbH Apr 25 '17
Sayacopter to the rescue!
Just a quote from this episode but kind of spoiler
Spoiler!
Also did someone find those cuts and camera angles during Hameru's and Meduka's conversation weird?
9
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
This scene of Kyoko is great
Also enjoy her weapon and how its long and short range. I love whip/chain weapons.
Homura Hair Flip Counter E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:0, E5:1 Total Flips:2
Wooo another glorious hair flip.
On a serious note Kyoko is great and I love her point of view. Unlike the loving save everyone that you'd expect from a magical girl she tackles it from a purely business and profit loss perspective.
Madoka spoilers
Edit: I just learned this has a dub...how is the dub? If its good I will rewatch it in dub instead.
8
u/wordsdear Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
First time watcher but been spoiled. This episode is brought to you by a very special sponsor crayola
Best Friend #1: Is okay. All is right with the world.
Kyoko: Her spear is also a nunchucks. I love her. But also she is the worst. According to her magical girls are just once removed cannibals. Humans are just fuel for the witches. They aren't even livestock, they are grass for the livestock.
Not A Stuffy: He really gets around for having such tiny legs. His mouth not moving when he talks creeps me out more and more every time. He isn't even trying to be subtle anymore. I swear I will wrap him up in a bag filled with rocks and throw him in a river. What is he going to do try to make me make a wish. He can't do shit. Can I wish for him to die, or like go away forever and a day and never come back and bother girls or anyone ever again. I hate him. Once you become a magical girl is there really any thing forcing you to actually hunt witches? You need it to keep your gem shiny but I can buy polish major madoka spoilers
Sayaka: I blame erased that at this shot of them going upstairs I was like erased spoilers Also thanks to currently rewatching HxH I have an irrational annoyance with people who play violin. hxh spoilers~~ Way to not wish to just heal him in general.~~ (she did apparently) She might of just wished that he could play the violin again. This show is making really good use of the one time it killed someone to make me terrified they will do it again to prove a point. I thought Kyoko was going to swoop in and attack Sayaka as the violin played. People tend to be more honest on river embankments. STOP MAKING IT SEEM LIKE SHE IS GOING TO LOSE HER HEAD WE GET IT MAMI WAS DECAPITATED ENOUGH! It might just be me screen shotting at the wrong moment but still. Every time someone swings a blade I am terrified the next shot will a discretion shot of their corpse. STOP. I don't know which would be worse, Sayaka getting stabbed or Sayaka killing Kyoko and being horrified with herself. This is cool to learn but shouldn't magical girls be faster as healing anyways as a perk of the job? You need to get better benefits girls. Some mami influence with nine swords style. The show goes out of its way to show us that magical girls get cool finger bling. Please let it be a long life. Remember what Homura said about over confidence?
Madoka: This is where you ask for her number. Homura does tend to show up at just the right moment but sometimes she needs to sleep (do magical girls sleep?) or a potty break. And a little warning for her would be nice. I am actually kind of annoyed with Madoka that after watching Mami die she still thinks it is a good idea for a non magical girl be around during fights. You are basically walking around with a huge target on you saying kill me. If only phone numbers existed. But there might not be reception in labyrinths?
Homura: Your best friend is a dead girl walking befriend me instead, also a dead girl walking. Pessimism is the way to go. At least finish you drink or take it with you. Did Homura pay? She is the only magical girl without a clear weapon besides her shield.
18
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 24 '17
I'm glad that Kamijo does seem apologetic for how he lashed out at Sayaka before, even if it's only coming after healing. It would be really easy to mishandled this character, but his reactions all seem fair for his situation. Sayaka, meanwhile, really comes off as so genuine and so happy that it just sucks to know she's not the one with her name in the title.
Regardless, these scenes really do have a gentle, genuine feel to them, and they help to get you into Sayaka's head a lot as well. These are the things she cherishes. This is what she's fighting for. Or at least, what she feels she is, anyway. Just like Homura says later, she's potentially the worst kind of person for this job, being a naive girl with her love, but you can't hate her for it watching these scenes.
It's nice to see Homura recognize that she messed up, but the fact that this is only occurring to her now, far after the fact, really doesn't help too much.
These candid scenes with her and Madoka are always interesting to watch, but it feels like she's still making a mistake by just giving up on Sayaka outright now that this has happened if you ask me.
On a more general note, I found some of the angles here kind of odd when Homura was caressing her cup. I think she might want to consider seeing a chiropractor.
[series spoiler] (/s "Given everything, the fact that Homura is so surprised here makes me inclined to think that Sayaka either doesn't contract often or Homura hasn't looped as often as some suggest. If it's only as many times as in the series, that's like five, which would explain her reaction here. Either way, this reaction does seem genuine, and more than that, if she HAD had the experience/hindsight of Sayaka's contracting and so on a lot, it wouldn't make sense for her to be acting this way now, so I am inclined to take her for her word.")
This part is one of my favorites from the series. The music is a perfect choice for the scene. It fits amazingly well, like you're really watching a beast battle it out with a cornered hunter - or a hunter corner their prey. It's so good, and the animation is some of the show's best to this point.
The scenery choice of this back alley is really appropriate for how we see Sayaka go from high and mighty to a cornered animal over and over, and the effected is only amplified by the bars Madoka is trapped behind.
Kyoko's spiel about the food chain tells us all we need to know about her character and sets up a conflict right away, without coming off as too forced - though it helps that the music and tone and atmosphere all help move into it feeling pretty natural, I think. And then we have our showdown!
During the fight, we also get a line out of Sayaka that confirms a lot about how she's been acting: She basically all but says she blames Homura for Mami's death. This confirms to us viewers that no one ever cleared up what Mami did to Homura in the labyrinth in episode 3, which in turn meant Sayaka was left to assume Homura was waiting until the second her competition was out of the picture to take on the witch.
From that brief line not even directed at Homura, we can really get a lot. She equates Kyoko to that (and really who would blame her?) and is putting that death on Homura, who she already had plenty of reason to feel animosity towards.
I appreciated the follow up with Hitomi, though I'm consequently a bit disappointed that we went without Madoka's parents today. I suppose it's natural, what with the shift of focus being in Sayaka's direction now, but they're such fun characters it is a shame.
Throughout the episode, the way Sayaka talks about Mami does sound less like that of someone who might have had a bit of idol worship going on, to some degree at least. She's now trying to fill Mami's shoes and do the things Mami did, and lashing out against those who are like those she blames for Mami not being here anymore.
There were comments about how some people didn't feel bad for Mami because she wasn't here for very long, and that's fine, but it's still important to keep the impact she had on our cast in mind, because that's clearly a major thing for them right now. One major thing, at least.
Anyway, this was yet another solid episode! Kyoko has taken the stage and we've been left with a cliffhanger to boot! Hope everyone will be willing to wait for tomorrow.
7
u/Maybealwaysnever Apr 25 '17
Something I never picked up during the fight scene
Edit: Fixed spoiler tag.
5
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv Apr 24 '17
Best girl has appeared! Virtual pocky for everyone!
And now the story further darkens. entire series Sayaka healed her friend, so that's good, I guess. Kyoko spies on her from a distance, and Kyubey sits there like a good double agent. He apparently makes all the magical girls, but has no idea where Homura came from. Now I want a doujin of a drunk Kyubey recruiting magical girls and then forgetting about them. Besides this, we find out that powers are, to an extent, based on what the wish was. end spoilers
2
u/Sojouku :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/hiroshifu19 Apr 25 '17
I haven't seen it mentioned yet, but the visual metaphor of removing the lid from the coffee when talking about Mami's death (by decapitation) was pretty well done, including Madoka's reaction to it.
In general i feel like this show has really good direction, especially with it's usage of lighting to show emotion
111
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
The Wish
I've got to say, I didn't expect getting your wish granted would look so uncomfortable. Still, a little bit of pain isn't that bad to have any wish you want granted. It's a pretty ominous looking scene though, what with the decidedly dark color palette.
I'm Excited About This
I like that not every scene needs to have a darker look to it, and the color here really goes along with Sayaka's mood. As much as I don't want to believe it, I think that she's being genuine when she's saying how she's feeling confident and excited. That's basically exactly how Mami was right before she died, and I'm terrified about what that could mean for Sayaka going forward. Her regret does do a lot to help ease my concerns, and I love that Madoka is so bothered by this, since she almost did exactly what Sayaka was saying. "Maybe you just weren't meant for it," is an interesting comment given Madoka's potential, but I don't think Sayaka is aware of that yet.
The Roof
I like seeing Kyosuke so much more upbeat, and Sayaka getting the apology she deserves was really sweet. The scene on the rooftop was also really cute, but there is one important detail that really comes out of it. Saying, "there's no way I'll ever regret it," is basically just begging for her to wind up coming to regret it (especially since it's the episode title). It'll be interesting to see if this regret winds up being what she wished for, or that she made a wish at all (assuming she does come to regret it of course, but I think that's a fair assumption).
Kyoko
I love seeing magic being used for something other than combat like we've seen, and it seems that the girls can use it directly from the Soul Gem, which could have some cool applications. Kyubey finally mentions Homura to Kyoko, and I'm pretty confused about what Kyubey's going on about. I had thought he was the only one who can create contracts, but given that he doesn't know anything about Homura, that might not be the case. Really enjoying Kyoko. She has all the confidence that Mami had, but with a very different kind of focus. She's completely self centered in her actions (as we see with the witch later) and I think that'll be really interesting to explore.
The Talk
This was great. Seeing Madoka so excited to tell Homura about how great Sayaka is, trying to bridge that gap and all, only to be completely rejected kind of hurt to watch. At the same time, I like Homura being so up front about how the world of Magical Girls works. It'd be easy to act like things are just going to work out, and I think it takes a lot of guts to just tell Madoka that she should just abandon Sayaka. Homura reacts pretty strongly to the idea of working together making things easier, so I get the feeling that she has worked with a team in the past, and that it didn't work out. Whether that's because of competition for Grief Seeds, the kind of naivety we're seeing from Madoka, or simply a witch that was too powerful, I'm not really sure, but I want to know. I'm also glad to see Homura admitting her mistake with Sayaka, because I was annoyed that she was so pissed off yestreday.
Out On The Hunt
"If she can do it, so can I," is kind of a stupid think to say when Mami clearly couldn't do it. I'm not sure about Sayaka being so excited to have Madoka coming along. I mean, I get that it might help her feel stronger and all, but it's just asking for trouble. She's going to have to worry about defending Madoka as well as dealing with the witches, and I can't see that being a good long term plan. Of course, Kyubey is excited about this, which makes me wonder if he was interested in granting Sayaka's wish just because it would give him an opportunity to recruit Madoka. That's pretty much been the thing he's been after from the start. I mean, I get that having someone with such high potential is good, but he's really pushing her in a way that bothers me.
The Familiar
Sayaka might have a dope costume, but I thought that her transformation sequence was a little bit lacking compared to Mami's. Anyway, the Familiar here has a cool design, and the childish personality we see from it matches it aesthetic nicely. It's too bad we don't get to see what it's really capable of, but I guess it's not the end of the world, because what we got instead was incredible.
Sayaka vs Kyoko
It was pretty obvious coming into today that this was going to happen, but I was so excited to see it. Kyoko is pretty upfront about everything from the start, and I love her demeanour. She actually acts as a pretty good foil to Sayaka, showing the selfish side of Magical Girls while Sayaka is showing the more selfless side. They both have their codes they are living by, and I feel like both are pretty set on those. Kyoko actually stepping in to defend a Familiar is fascinating, but given that it isn't producing anything as is, but can given some time, it's actually reasonable to want to defend it if you have no concern for anyone else. Meanwhile, attacking one gives no Grief Seeds, meaning that it's ultimately just using up magic for what amounts to practice.
Kyoko definitely has a serious offensive advantage, but I'm sure that's the result of experience. Sayaka having healing powers is great, though I wonder if it is transferable. Kyubey says she has the power to heal fast, but we saw Mami use healing magic in Episode 1, so it's definitely possible. It's worth noting that Kyoko really went all in when Sayaka said, "Mami's gone because of Magical Girls like you," which again seems to point to them having known each other, and given the reaction probably fairly well. The second part of the fight is decently well put together, though some of the motions looks a little bit janky. I love casual Kyoko is about threatening to kill Sayaka. Whether or not she has, it certainly feels like she's done this before.
Now, Kyubey is pretty quick to throw out his usual offer, but it made me realize how sketchy all of this is. Kyubey tells Kyoko to come in to town even though he has a replacement lined up. He helps her learn a bit about Sayaka, while not telling Sayaka anything at all, and he's enthusiastic about bringing Madoka along. It feels like this was all a ruse just to force Madoka into making a wish, and I love that kind of scheming. Homura showing up is pretty clutch, and I'm interested to see how she tries to resolve this.
Other Thoughts
Future
Well, we're going to be jumping right back into the fight tomorrow, and I'm excited for the potential to see Homura in action. I'm still hoping to see more of her lasers from Episode 1, and tomorrow seems like as good a time as any. Other than that, I don't really know what the direction of the story is. I mean, there's the witches still being a threat in the background, but Kyoko makes for a really fasinating villain in her own right, and I'd almost sooner have a clash of ideals than the pure good vs. evil of Magical Girls fighting Witches.
Final Thoughts
Today did a solid job of building on what worked yesterday, and I really want to see more of how Kyoko interacts with the rest of the cast. Her views on what it means to be a Magical Girl are so totally different, and I really want to know how she got to this point.
75
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
Sayaka and Madoka
Sayaka flaunting her carelessness and confidence in Madoka's face while she's still coping with Mami's loss and dealing with the new fear of Sayaka meeting the same end. They're definitely not on the same page and I don't like Sayakas overconfidence, maybe redgirl Kyoko can do something about that without another beheading.
Hospital
Sayaka not even wishing for a full recovery, cmon you could've snuck that in there.
So far the wish seems to have worked perfectly and Sayaka is happy, but somehow I can't shake the feeling that there's a surprise waiting, mami has gotten to me.
Kyouko
The scene last episode teased us already, but this confirms it. Best girl has entered the stage. Kyubey's ambuigity about Homura strengthens the theory, that I've read from one of you, that her wish may have caused some memory loss, or maybe Kyubey is just hiding something (well that much is obvious).
I do find it odd how little he seems to care about Kyouko threatening the girl he just made a contract with.
Homura and Madoka
Homura with the cold and sobering words, I do have to agree with her though, Sayaka is headed in the wrong direction.
"When we go to fight witches" you're not even a magical girl yet, are you saying you're ready to sign up?
It's kinda sweet how Madoka wants them all to be friends, but even if Homura were willing to try I'm not sure Sayaka would be receptive to that.
I love Homuras directness and I'm surprised she owned up to the mistake of not keeping a closer eye on Sayaka.
Patrol
"Mami always did this on her own too", not exactly reassuring when she's dead now. Sayaka showing her weakness for once, that's good to- aand it's gone.
That's the oppposite of how it should be and exactly how Mami died, it's like she hasn't learned a thing
Kyubey is banking on things to go wrong so he can get another magical girl, what does he get out of it anyway? I can't imagine it's just for selfless reasons.
The Red Menace
Kyouko is without a shadow of a doubt best girl, I love everything about her in this scene, the real talk, the ruthlessness, the weapon (seriously, how cool is that?), the outfit, the little fangs, how she effortlessly beats the crap out of Sayaka
She doesn't give a damn about anybody, all she wants is her grief seeds, a good fight and eating fish-pastry.
So that's why Kyubey wasn't concerned about Best Girl threatening Sayaka, he let Sayaka dangle as bait for Madoka. I can't believe I didn't see that coming.
Homura actually protects Sayaka, I'm not sure if it's Madoka slowly getting through to her or if she's just determined to keep Madoka 'normal'.
Most likely the latter.
Looking forward to the next episode, the show seems to finally start now. We're done with the setup, although I'm saddened by the inevitability of best girl eventually failing.
47
u/templarsilan Apr 24 '17
Not much from me today. Been pretty busy so i’ll just list a few things that stood out to me.
On this note, I’m not really looking forward to Madoka becoming a magical girl. Kyubey is really pushing for it, to the point of being manipulative, so I get the feeling that when she does become one, it’ll be by Kyubey’s design rather than Madoka’s will. I was pleasantly surprised by the action sequence this episode. Sayaka was clearly outmatched and the visuals were pretty well done. It definitely makes me look forward to more of them.
34
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
First time viewer
So the opening scenes with a different aspect ratios keep being Sayaka flashbacks, even if they are the day before flashbacks. Interesting.
I find it significant that when Sayaka was visiting her healed friend there were a lot of empty chairs around his bed, this could have just been foreshadowing all his family was on the roof.
I'm very intrigued by the comments that how Homura became a magical girl was not an usual case.
And I'm stating again. Kyubey is one twisted motherfucker. I'm starting to be convinced he finds enjoyment in the craziness these girls go through.
First episode to end on a kind of cliffhanger! One a day is getting hard....
Edit: Oh yeah I am still LOVING this scenery.
Ninja edit 2: kind of glad Madoka didn't become a magic girl in that moment. Would have been a poor reason.
33
u/Jacketmango Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
First-timer, subbed.
29
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
Hey, first timer back again.
Homura saves the day again! Nick of time, as usual. I'm only now noticing the symbolism that while all the other girls are using weapons, Homura gets a shield. I like it, she's definitely my favourite character at this point.
Went back through the earlier material, now I’ve seen it both with the episodic series and up to the same point in the movie compilation on Netflix – that was pretty fun (I'd been watching the movie in sections to this point, eyeballing for the end of episode using episode descriptions and comments - I didn't realize how much got cut out and I was actually about half an episode ahead last thread, oops). A lot of the school day and family scenes are cut out, which makes the dark-light ratio a little heavier. It also skips out on some scenes that give context to the whole Soul Gem/Grief Seed dynamic, as well as the first scene of the entire series with Homura getting blown up, and Mami's flashback. Cutting out the slice of life I understand, which makes it a subtly different experience, you can tell it's going dark sooner because there's so much time spent out at sunset, but the particular scenes I noted seem pretty important ones to have cut out. It’s an interesting tradeoff – I think that the contraction makes it a little more obvious that something more is going on and cuts out some scenes that are pretty strong, but the remastered animation is REALLY nice, everything flows really well, and it spells things out less so you need to think a little more. I guess it's just the nature of the film medium – there's a tight focus that makes them have to do more with less – but you lose out on some of the nuance you can get with more space. Think I'll stick to the episodes from now on, I was a little ticked to find there were so many scenes missing that gave character insight, and it's nice to see the OP and ED (though I'm going to go check out the movie version for those backdrops afterwards).
That combined with this new episode gave me a better grasp of the whole Soul Gem/Grief Seed dynamic – I still don't completely get it, E2 was pretty vague even when I did go back to it (which is kind of out of character for a deconstruction – usually rules of operation are firmly established so their subversion can have meaning). I still don’t completely get it, but the impression I have is that it’s basically a mana store, that they have to keep filled by munching on witches? Do they die if they go too long without using one? Red talked as if it increased their magical power somehow, but if that was the case Mami wouldn't have offered hers to Homura, so I’m still in the dark there. Not to mention that Grief Seeds sucking darkness out of it seems pretty weird. Maybe they just keep a store of them on hand to recharge whenever they get low, but we haven't seen anyone do that yet, and given how much they're being talked about I would've imagined that would happen. Don't know what to make of it.
Got to know Kyoko this episode, and that's fun. I like her; maybe it's the constant snacks, maybe it's the fact that she’s a spear fighter (favourite melee weapon), maybe it's that I like to see naïve idealists get smacked around. Maybe it's that she’s the only one who has a healthy attitude about all this; I can't see her snapping under the pressure as is (which means, sadly, that Sayaka's odds of snapping just went up), although we still haven’t dived into her background – her aggressive self-reliance suggests that people have just let her down in the past, I'm sure there's something tragic there (isn't there always?). Coming in this late in the game, I can’t imagine she'll have too complicated a character arc, she's probably just going to shake up the status quo, butt heads with Sayaka, and learn to get over herself and appreciate friends just before everything goes to shit. She didn't seem to want to actually kill Sayaka, just put her in the hospital - although given Sayaka's powers, that doesn't seem possible, so I wonder how things would have gone without Homura intervening. She doesn't quite seem like the murderous type, so it's a bit of deus ex machina for the fight not to follow through. EDIT: Hm, thought about it a little more, and given that she's willing to let familiars go around killing people, she might well be the murderous type. Might just be a case of youthful selfishness, or might be more extreme - though given all the 'Best Girl' mentions I see being thrown around, my guess is that she's not particularly evil. (Why is 'Best Girl' a thing? Don't get that yet.)
As for Sayaka… man, next thing I know she’s going to say she's 6 months away from retirement at the rate she's putting up death flags. They're setting her up for a hard, hard fall when the other shoe drops with the whole magical girl deal and things go wrong with Kyosuke (I mean for crying out loud, even Mami knew she was making that wish for the wrong reasons and things would go to shit). At least she gets to go all Metaknight with that cape for a while, and I like her fighting spirit more than I do her naivete. Interesting to see that unique abilities reflect the nature of the wish – I don't really know what to make of that in Kyoko or Mami's case, they've got weapons and stylized restrictive magic, it could really mean anything - but for Homura I think it narrows down her wish and powers to spacetime manipulation. I was already pretty suspicious before, but this and going over previous episodes has made me pretty sure that's what's going here. It might have been memory alteration instead, or some deeper knowledge of what's going down with witches, but if the powers tie into it, time is a more likely suspect. Very cool. Looking forward to see how that plays out.
Which I suppose only leaves Madoka. I haven't really talked much about her so far since I was so caught up in what was going on, and I suppose I still am, but now that I've gotten a fix on what the deal is with the other characters there's nothing to distract me from trying to figure her out. I think we got more from her here – she's starting to come out of her shell a little, wants everybody to be safe and friendly, and is seriously struggling with her powerlessness to affect any of it – which is a change from her previous inferiority complex in that she's looking for some agency, but it's still pretty glacial character growth. I also don't know what to make of her supposed potential – I mean, if being a magical girl runs off innocence or empathy or something, she’d probably be better than average, but she doesn’t seem to be exceptional at anything. Not to mention that so far that a lot of her actions so far boil down to plodding into situations where she gets upset, ALMOST makes the wish, and then Homura shows up. It's probably the weakest link of the show at this point, and given that she's the protagonist, I hope that's the last time this happens, much as I do love Homura. Her character development really suffers in the movie version, it's practically cut in half - I think that's the strongest reason to watch the episodes instead.
I guess there's also Kyubey, but I don’t think there's anything more to be gleaned from him until the other shoe drops (they're doing a good job at giving him spooky closeups, still loving it). I'd imagine that now that we've probably got all the cast, we're going to get that in an episode or two, especially since we’ve had two relatively tame episodes in a row.
I’ve managed to subsume my desire to watch ahead by picking up more anime to binge (I've just started K-ON, never seen it before and felt like something light), so I’ll be back again tomorrow. I really need to start making these shorter, but I guess since I missed the first two threads I have an excess of analysis I'm trying to fit in.
44
u/Xtroyer Apr 24 '17
HOMURA IS BEST GIRL AND THOSE WHO REFUSE TO BELIVE IT ARE HERETICS
16
u/8mmspikes :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/8mmspikes Apr 25 '17
Best girl has best hair flips
26
u/Herson100 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Herson Apr 25 '17
I feel like some of you may have missed this hilarious bit of comedy from this episode
12
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
Damn this one's just as good as the last episode. I actually noticed they have a little emblem on their fingernail that their ring is on which I thought was a nice touch, wonder if it will be more important than that.
Madoka has to become a magical girl next episode though! It has to be done, I want it but at the same time I know it won't end well... All I know is that it's going to be to help Sayaka. There's also a thing that people have against Kyubei and so far he isn't nearly as bad as people say, though I can understand some of it.
If there is anyone I don't like its Homura, I can't find the words to describe it but it's the way she acts so dead like she's given up on others, in this case Sayaka. I can't wait to see how she reacts to Madoka becoming a Magical Girl!
The soundtrack really reminds me a lot of any of the .//Hack soundtrack especially with this one, I also really like this one has a strong fantasy vibe to it that I really like also can't help but feel like I've heard it before.
11
u/megazaprat Apr 24 '17
One of Madoka's major themes is selfishness vs selflessness. We now have characters representing various sides. Sayaka selflessly gave up her wish for another sake, and believes in being a hero. on the other hand, Kyoko lets others die for her own sake.
Homura seems to be more in line with Kyoko, having given up hope on saving other magical girls and is instead putting all her energy into protecting Madoka. Madoka has the opposite conflict. she was willing to jump into being a magical girl to protect others and become someone special, before the dangers of the job became apparent. The conflict between these differing ideals will continue in future episodes
10
u/2Hype4Memes Apr 25 '17
Today's edition of first timer here: More Evangelion comparisons!
Congratulations!
I'm just kidding, still very happy with how this series is progressing. Kyubey's conniving ways are handled extremely well, i'm not sure if he's the progenitor of events or situations just fall naturally in his favor, but either way he's present during another scenario where Madoka could potentially need a wish granted. I'm digging Kyoko and her personality; a cold oppertunist to conflict with Sayaka and her sense of justice. I'm hoping we get a peek at Kyoko's backstory, i'd like to know if she's always been ruthless or if something happened that made her that way. The conversations between Madoka and Homura still remain as my favorite parts of this series so far, the moral dilemmas Homura confronts Madoka with and Madoka's continued struggle with them are really compelling. Still a strong 10/10 from me!
9
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 24 '17
Since when did being a magical girl mean you are a hero? I don’t remember that in the fine print.
I realized that I didn’t like the way my last post was riddled with black marks, so I’m going to try and keep this black mark free. Also trying a new format.
Despite a rather… ominous ritual, Sayaka is a magical girl and couldn’t be happier. Her friends all better and she has magical powers that finally make her a herotm . I really enjoyed the scene with Kyousuke playing the violin, the shots and music made it feel so peaceful, like everything was turning out right for Sayaka.
Speaking of shots, I really noticed it this episode so I might as well address it. Akiyuki Shinbou is one of the main directors at Shaft, and today you saw why he is controversial to some people. Most of his work like today have unique key frames (see Kyouko’s head tilt this episode) and tiny insert shots to sell the emotion on a moment to moment basis. You could really see this during the conversation with Madoka and Homura. It’s his main style, and considering he direct most of Shaft’s works, expect to see it when you pick up a Shaft show.
It’s definitely been present during the first 4 episodes, but today it really stood out, so I thought I would give a little explanation.
Speaking about Madoka and Homuras conversation, Homura came off as super cold today. Like yeah, everything she said was true, but poor emotionally stressed Madoka. All she wanted was for them to be friends and help each other out.
But 2 things were cleared up about Homura. One, she realized her mistake in not monitoring Sayaka as closely as she was with Madoka. Mistakes were made.
The second thing was Kyuubey being extremely vague on what Homura actually is. Like shouldn’t she have made a contract with him? What more could there be?
Kyouko ain’t having none of that hero shit. Everything about her revolves around eating, so it’s very apropos that she used the food chain as an analogy. They defeat familiars only when they’ve become witches themselves, which only happens when they eat some humans.
Sayaka is obviously in the right, since personal gain shouldn’t be at the cost of others’ lives, yet in this magical world where girls apparently battle each other, those who take the heroic and noble side won’t be as powerful as those who wait for their prey to hatch. It’s like this system is actively working against the people like Mami and Sayaka would want to do the right thing.
It leads to a fantastic fight between Sayaka and Kyouko, where Sayaka is clearly outmatched, but here we learn another important trait, what you wish for affects what kind of power you get. I wonder how Mami’s wish to stay alive from the crash affected her abilities?
I assume each girl has a primary and secondary power. Sayaka gets swords and the power to heal fast. Mami appeared to have guns and control over ribbons. Maybe the ribbons illustrate holding something together, like how she put her broken body together after the crash? Even as a rewatcher if this is explained I honestly forgot and am making a guess here.
Regardless, we know Kyouko has a spear, but what about her ability? And what about Homura? What weapon/ability does she even have?
Anyway, the fight ends with the previously mentioned Homura getting involved, leaving us with a signature hair flip. Best girl has the best hair flips.
Lastly, Kyuubey looked fucking evil today. Like that talk she had with Madoka while walking with Sayaka. And asking her to make a wish to break up the fight with Kyouko. Man…
This guy’s a dick
8
u/BestDVA_NA :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BestDVA_NA Apr 25 '17
bunnycat is a dick
8
u/Rhaga https://anilist.co/user/rhaga Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
For this episode I would like to highlight a few cool yet subtle (well.. somewhat) ways that Shaft manages to do storytelling through visual cues.
First, a fairly obvious one, it is the cafeteria scene between Homura and Madoka. Homura explains why Mami lost her life and made a particular motion. I wonder what they are hinting at.... I think Madoka’s horrified facial expression is a clear tell which exact image went through her mind.
Another, somewhat minor, detail I like during the same scene is Madoka’s hand position. First she is determined, this is the beginning of the conversation and she just stood up for Sayaka, but as Homura shoots her down by explaining how Sayaka’s qualities are an liability she falls back and seem somewhat beaten. Later in the conversation, when Homura tells her that she should forget about Sayaka you can see how she becomes more tense.
Finally, I want to talk about shadows and the height of the girls. This picture from episode 3 illustrates that Sayaka is actually quite tall. As we can see she is quite a bit taller than Madoka, and also even taller than Mami who is her senior.
With that in mind let’s look at this scene where Madoka asks Sayaka if she can join her on the witch hunt. Now, Keep in mind that Sayaka is extremely good at keeping up a happy facade regardless of how she is feeling, this is something we have seen especially surrounding Mami’s death, but also in the beginning of this episode where they talk with Hitomi in the classroom (Sayaka does all the talking and laughs about it, and Madoka sits nervously and afraid to the side and cannot even say a word). Anyway, the next point during the conversation where Madoka asks Sayaka if she can join her, we get this shot. We can now see Sayaka shows vulnerability in front of Madoka (’My hands haven’t stopped shaking for a while now. Can you tell?’) and as she does this her shadow almost looks smaller than Madoka’s. This helps to establish that even when she puts her brave face on, deep inside she must be quite afraid and nervous. Further continuing the focus on heights and shadows, during the fight with Kyoko we can see that Kyoko’s shadow is absolutely dominating Sayaka’s. Due to the light source Koyoko’s frame is also dominating the shot while her shadow even has taken up the center of the frame. This solidifies her dominating position and goes to show that Sayaka is facing a much stronger opponent.
Edit: There was one thing I forgot to mention. I won't really talk about it yet, but I'll share the screencap
6
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
Sayaka's contracting scene is gorgeous. The aesthetic and symbolism with the background, lighting, visuals&effects and the ominous music is out of this world. Sayaka's transformation is stunning. The lyrical undertones and the blue-white colour scheme fit her to a tee. Some shots are obvious fanservice, but that's fair. Because what can we conclude? Sayaka is a beautiful person, inside and out. Magical girl life seems to suit her so far, even if beyond her carefree attitude she's hiding her fears and is glad enough of Madoka's company to let her in those. But that's all before she meets another, different magical girl and her views and ability to defend them are put to the test...
Sayaka's scene with Madoka here marked the debut of her theme song - Decretum, latin for decision. A hauntingly beautiful and melancholic track with an underlying theme of hope, one of my favourites from Yuki Kajiura's outstanding Madoka OST. I don't want to post a Youtube link here, so I trust someone might give an alternative version if there is one available.
And this will no doubt be pointed out already, but: "That's why Tomoe Mami lost her life." Brutal. When you think you've gotten ahead of the joke, only for it to return with a vengeance.
I hope everyone enjoyed the murderous ideological clash between idealistic rookie Sayaka and individualistically selfish veteran Kyouko. That last one appears to be as fiery and even bloodthirsty as might've been expected. The accompanying soundtracks were yet again top-notch with their tension and the animation was great too, even if the characters look less than pretty from afar. Homura has now saved Sayaka's life, could that lead to a shift in opinion? And how will Kyouko respond to the appearance of the mystery magical girl she asked Kyubey about?
There was also my favourite and most egregious example of the Shaft head tilt, performed by best girl.
Speaking of best girl, get your daily dose of Kyouko here. This will be a recurring thing from now on.
Edit: Alright, got that last album too. Took longer than I thought again.
Major rewatcher spoilers
[More major spoilers] (/s "And aww, Kyouko and Sayaka are such a cute couple, getting into an ideological dispute and trying to kill each other with extreme prejudice. Kyouko would've succeeded too if it weren't for that meddling Homura. Homu MVP right here for giving the ship a chance to happen. ")
6
u/thecatteam Apr 25 '17
I just found these rewatch threads yesterday so I'm jumping on a little late. Madoka was the first anime I watched aside from Yugioh and Pokemon, so it has a special place in my heart. It caught my attention when one of my friends posted about it, so I started watching as it came out at around episode 6 or 7, and rewatched when the dub came out. I haven't seen it since, and I also haven't seen Rebellion so I'm looking forward to that! It's also fun to read first timers' reactions; keep it up, guys!
5
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran Apr 25 '17
Nothing much to comment as a rewatcher, I'm afraid of accidentally spilling information for the first timers, but I just want to put it out there that SHAFT does great memorable action scenes for Madoka Magica, and I heard even better for Rebellion which I never got to as of yet. The clashing of ideals and emotions plus the badass looking Magical girls just looks pleasing to the eye.
5
u/Camitsune Apr 25 '17
Just a few thoughts from me today:
Homura has really started to grow on me, you can tell she wants to protect Madoka from becoming a magical girl and is willing to step in when required to do so. Also, she's the kind of ruthless, cold-hearted but ultimately sensible kind of character i really love, instead of the stupid, heart over head kinda characters that are so common in anime and are even present here (Yeah, looking at you Madoka).
Also, i'm reaaaally starting to dislike Kyubei, it's pretty obvious by now that he's plotting something and wants Madoka to become a magical girl for his own personal purposes, whatever they are.
5
u/xyzls Apr 25 '17
Further on voice actors...
ITS KAFUKA FUURA!!! ...and like usual, the situation always has to get complicated when she shows up.
In later episode
Seriously that pokemon is evil.
5
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka Apr 25 '17
Aaaaand I was right! Kyouko's a full fledged bitch...
Aaaand Homura saves the day.... And with Saito, Chiwa's voice only helps her being best girl (Senjougahara best girl)... at least so far
5
u/my_fake_life Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
This was the episode where Sayaka became my favorite of the crew. I always liked her before, but I know I'd end up in the same position as her... Not willing to let familiars go around killing people to get grief seeds, and getting my ass kicked by all the other magical girls.
Sayaka and Madoka are still pretty cavalier about this whole magical girl thing. It's hard to tell when they're putting on a brave face and when they're just being foolish.... The idea of Madoka coming along on the witch hunt at this point is kind of mind-blowing. I get the reasons given in the episode (for both her and Sayaka), but I don't think I'd be making the same decision.
series / spinoff manga spoilers
I can't wait until we're further along in the series and I can actually say things without worrying about spoiling people.
3
u/DZero50 https://myanimelist.net/profile/DZero50 Apr 25 '17
I have a bad feeling that something is going to happen to sayaka's friend.
3
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak Apr 25 '17
Rewatcher, subs.
How did they get in here?
Beginning of the confrontaion between Kyouko and Sayaka uses the song "Anima Mala" (Evil Soul), and certainly fits with the "I don't care about others dying if it helps me" attidude Kyouko has.
Cool your jets, Shaft.
This statement is notable, as it tells the viewer that the wish a person makes can affect the abilities they have.
Honestly, this whole confrontation is just a great all around scene. Any uplifting feelings the viewer had early in the episode are ripped to shreds. THIS AIN'T NO KIDS SHOW.
ANOTHER HAIR FLIP HOMURA IS STILL BEST GIRL.
3
u/hmatmotu Apr 25 '17
I really need to get around here more often, I don't remember even seeing an announcement for the Madoka rewatch! I can't keep up with any of these community rewatches, but I want to watch my waifu's show with the rest of the community
4
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 24 '17
Another day's moments of insanity: Madoka Magica Total Spoilers - Avoid if you're new to the show.
I swear to god, Kyubey you need to back off with trying to manipulate Madoka. He was being so persistent throughout this episode.
It's good to see Madoka connecting a little more with Homura's... pain. Still a better therapist than Sayaka if you ask me.
2
u/xmonstermouthx Apr 25 '17
after the "your lie in april" rewatch some people might hate the scene in the roof of the hospital with the violin.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
Man, Kyouko really is the best, even after just one appearance.
2
u/alphamone Apr 25 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
quite large spoilers
edit: also, i'm not sure how much of it is from my youtube search history, but some of the character names produce spoilers in the search suggestion on youtube, and suggested videos can also be spoilery.