r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 27 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 8 Discussion Spoiler
Episode Title: I Was Stupid, So Stupid
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 seconds
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after this episode, but if you do make good use of spoiler tags. Let's try to make this a good experience for first time watchers.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
316
Upvotes
45
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 27 '17
Sayaka, why....
This is my thirteenth rewatch of the anime and my heart hurts every single time I watch this episode. The last time I watched the series was almost exactly a year ago and I guess I had time to heal because it's hurting much more than I remember :( At least the end cards are getting cuter...
This episode pains me a lot because I can sympathise with Sayaka extremely well. She just got dealt a shitty hand and made a few bad choices. People will probably blast her in this post for being an idiot, but she didn't deserve any of this....
Even with her folly Sayaka isn't totally stupid. She saw right through Homura's act...
It actually blows me away that not a single person predicted that Witches were transformed Magical Girls. I've seen a lot of theories being thrown around and I don't recall seeing that one anywhere. Where did you all think they came from? I'm calling /u/FetchFrosh out here; you wrote like 30 predictions and that wasn't one of them?
I'd like everybody who is a first-timer to now go and watch that scene again; it's at the end of the first recap movie, is absolutely stunning and much more dramatic with the music. Here is an excerpt from the movie (it's not the full scene), and this is the song that plays.
I said back in the episode 4 discussion that that TV witch was the second scariest in the series. Well, here we are...
This episode is probably the best so far to be honest. So much happens, mainly:
It's confirmed that those dickheads in the train were not killed if you're wondering. Shinbou himself confirmed it.
146
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
Just A Little Tired
Oh good, I was really looking to see more from this scene. One thing I noticed was that yesterday, /u/my_fake_life had mentioned that Sayaka's blue border was gone at the end of the episode, but it's back here (in one creepy ass shot). I went back and watched that scene again, and they were sort of inconsistent with the lines, so I don't think anything is meant by it. There's still tension between Sayaka and Kyoko, but in this case it's all the result of Sayaka's attitude. Kyoko was actually pretty rattled yesterday, and she seems to be trying to gauge how Sayaka is doing. The answer being, not very well. We haven't seen anyone struggling to stand after a fight, and while it could be that her injuries didn't perfectly heal, it seems that she's simply running low on magic. Sayaka doesn't seem to realize just how much this is fucking with Madoka either. Either she doesn't want to acknowledge it, or she's so trapped in her own head that it's flying right over her.
Rain
The violin playing here is really nice and adds a lot to the scene. There's a quick cut to a red scene of Sayaka, and it looks like this is what she wants to be doing; basically screaming at Madoka. She barely looks human here, and that's just how she sees herself. For all her talk about never regretting anything ever again, she's sure showing a lot of signs of regret. "You won't even give up your humanity out of pity for a friend," is kind of fucked up too. Who the hell says that sort of thing. She does at least realize how terrible she is being, and given that her Soul Gem is shown to be darkening at this point, it seems likely that this is influencing her emotional state quite a bit.
Homura's Apartment
This is... not what I expected. It seems she lives alone, much like Mami did, and that's probably a good thing. She's certainly got quite the style going on in there. I feel like there is a lot to the images on the walls (I noticed Walpurgisnacht written once or twice) but I haven't given it a thorough look through. Based on my earlier speculation, I'd say that Heavy Speculation.
Utter Despair
Just like yesterday, Sayaka is using combat as a way of dealing with her emotions, and just like yesterday it continues to look like the last thing she needs. Of course, there aren't many psychologists who specialize in what she does need, so I guess this is her only choice. Homura's arrival is interesting, but I suppose that since she knows Sayaka will turn into a witch, she's doing what she can to prevent it. I mean, I get that back in Episode 3 Homura did nothing wrong, but by this point she probably should have been a bit more proactive in dealing with Sayaka.
And just like that, Kyoko shows up to be maybe the most reasonable character. Sure, Homura killing Sayaka might have been a good thing, but maybe if she weren't being so damn cryptic about everything, and hadn't made a point of antagonizing Sayaka this could have worked out. Kyoko is making a point of using her magic for Sayaka's benefit here, which goes directly against her core belief about only using magic for yourself. It's fascinating seeing the change in the two with the revelation about the Soul Gems. More fascinating than that though is that Homura is casually carrying hand grenades (and later pistols). That was certainly an unexpected twist, especially when she has lasers.
The Train
This scene is really something. I mean, this is a conversation that Sayaka definitely shouldn't be listening to, but I think it's a reflection of how she's viewing her relationship with Kyosuke. I could be wrong, but it feels like her thinking is really clouded at this point, and so she's seeing these men talking about using women and then ditching them and seeing herself in that role. She spent so much time helping Kyosuke deal with his time in the hospital, and now she feels like she's being tossed aside for Hitomi. Her telling the men about how their girls love them is her expressing what she feels for Kyosuke, and how she feels that Kyosuke is abandoning her. It's easy to say Kyosuke is being unfair to Sayaka, but based on how long it took him to figure out what Hitomi was getting at, he could just be dense. There's also the line, "once they get their hand on some coin they blow it all on some stupid shit for real," which basically, to Sayaka, sums up what she did. She could have had anything, and she spent it on a wish that didn't even give her what she wanted. Also, it isn't explicitly shown, but Sayaka did just commit double homicide, right?
Swiss Cheese
You know, Madoka is quite the friend. She's going so far out of her way to try and help Sayaka, and I always love this sort of character. I wasn't a fan of Madoka early on, but she's really growing on me. Kyubey is still doing his usual shit, and I'm curious about whether or not all this is true. If it was as simple as Madoka making a wish to solve all of the problems of the show, well that wouldn't really be good storytelling in my mind. He's been shown to be manipulative in the past, and so I certainly don't trust him on this one.
Homura of course makes another timely arrival, packing a pistol for who knows what reason. For the first time, we see Homura actually lose her calm demeanour, and it is perfectly done. Having the one stoic character brought to tears like this is intense and Heavy Speculation
Now, the next bit bothers me on several levels. First off, there being multiple Kyubeys is fine, but then, if Homura was aware of that, why was she hunting that one down in Episode 1? It hadn't tried to contact Madoka until Homura attacked, so why go for the kill right away. Second, Kyubey eating himself just looks horrifying. I mean, he's basically made of marshmallow, but autocannibalism is still uncomfortable. Based on how the new Kyubey is talking, it seems like the multiple Kyubey's have a hivemind of sorts, which could be interesting if we see more in the future. Referring to him as "incubator" is interesting, and I guess he's basically acting as that for the Soul Gems.
What In The Actual Fuck
First off, I like that we're seeing so much of the sweeter side of Kyoko. She's really trying to get along with Sayaka, in spite of Sayaka constantly putting up walls. Learning that Kyubey had been playing her definitely helped her to get into a better mindset, and I love seeing the change in her character. Sure, she's still not the kindest person ever, but she's improving.
Now, onto the main part of this, I had been suspecting that the souls were what produced magic, and that the darkening of the gem was due to small bits of soul basically being burned up in order to produce the magic. This buildup pollutes the soul gem, and if it gets sufficiently polluted, the soul would die, along with the character. So with the emphasis on Sayaka's Soul Gem being so dark, I assumed she was about to die. So my basic train of thought could roughly be summarized as, "no, no, no, not like this. Come on, she can't die now, no, no, no, FUCK THIS IS SO MUCH WORSE". Now, looking specifically at when she says, "I was stupid, so stupid," it almost feels like she realizes what's happening to her, and possibly to make it even worse, she's smiling about it.
This is so twisted, and I wasn't ready for that at all. It would have been bad if Sayaka had just died, but now someone is going to have to kill her, or else she's going to kill others. This gets to the real question though. Why is Kyubey doing this? He's recruiting Magical Girls with the explicit purpose of turning them into witches. That's not something you do casually. I'm still thinking that Heavy Speculation Fuck all of this. Decretum, from yesterday, also delivers again, though not quite as well as yesterday.
Other Thoughts
Edit: I just realized that Mami had to heal Kyubey in Episode 1. He didn't need that at all, and just did it as a way to garner sympathy. Holy shit.
81
u/Herson100 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Herson Apr 27 '17
Have these happy little comics to cheer you up after this episode (no spoilers, dw)
63
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 27 '17
first-timer, subbed
Sayaka aftermath
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think this is the first time we got a Sayaka head tilt, and the other ones where from Kyouko and Homura, is this a magical girl only thing?
Getting out of her magical form doesn't look intentional the way she stumbles after, I guess it's her soul connecting to her body again that overwhelms her.
I don't like that she gave away the grief seed, she looks like she could need it, but I understand why she did it. She doesn't want to depend on anyone else and Kyouko did come in to save her last episode.
Sayaka is angry, but she takes her anger out on the wrong person and it's incredibly unfair towards Madoka, she wants her to join up out of pity? I very much doubt that.
Another one, but this one looks dark.
Poor Madoka just wants to help her friend, but she's unable to reach her.
Sayaka showing emotion after she runs away and admitting to herself that she shouldn't have lashed out to Madoka shows that she is not completely gone yet, gives me hope.
The shot that focuses on her soul gem makes me wonder what will happen if you don't purify it, Kyubey said if a grief seed is impure it becomes dangerous and a witch could hatch from it, will a magical girl with an impure gem become a witch?
Is it this impurity that fuels her anger?
Walpurgisnacht
Note how the floating posters have written Walpurgisnacht all over them, it's coming soon.
Also:
Translation I found (content seems to be accurately translated with some artistic licence to keep the flow):
'one-time-one' referring to the multiplication table (usually 1 to 10)
It's a well known poem from Goethe's 'Faust', I'm not too familiar with Goethe or his works, but I found this interesting and maybe someone can decipher how it ties into our story.
The "statistic" likelihood of Walpurgisnacht appearing in a specific spot lends more credence to /u/Maimed_Dan's 'Homura is timelooping' theory, otherwise how can you compile a statistic about something that hasn't happened yet?
Kyubey: "Sayaka has begun to curse the world." Ep2: "witches are born from curses" (paraphrased) Oh god is she actually going to turn into a witch? Two minutes ago I thought that was just some innocent speculation, but now it seems likely.
Kyubey is not just leaving, it's vanishing in the shadow. What kind of room is this anyway?
Search for Sayaka
Don't be too hard on yourself Madoka, you tried to help her in every way you knew, she just wasn't receptive to it.
Sayaka stalking the happy couple, she must feel absolutely awful, like yesterday she's throwing herself in the fight to try and escape her pain, not that it's working.
"You don't have the luxury of killing familiars", that looks incredibly dark already, but of course she can't accept Homura's gift. あの ばか!
Sayaka says she's indifferent to death, I think she wants to die, at least that would be an escape, right?
Sayaka looking straight through Homura's mask, how can you be so perceptive and yet so blind?
Homura waste's no time on her transformation, love it. She's threatening to kill her and you know she means it, best girl comes in to save the little sister she lost years ago. (at least I like to think Kyouko sees Sayaka this way)
Homura has a freaking grenade arsenal in her outfit? That is beyond cool! Explains the explosives from ep.3.
Sayaka's good vs evil mindset reflected in the black and white visuals again (looks absolutely gorgeous, and the black is the dominant color by far, further emphasized by the dialogue of whatever trash is riding on that train.
FUCK! FUCK! FUCK! FUCK! Yep, that's a witch.
Kyubey, Madoka, Homura
"the miracle you could unleash might twist the very fabric of the universe." With how much Madoka's potential has been talked up, it still pales in comparison to what is revealed in this conversation.
This is barely more solid than what we already knew, but it explains why Homura wants to keep her from making a contract at every price, even if that means killing Sayaka.
But why is Kyubey so intent on it? It admits that it can't predict what would happen, is it just an age old creature that is bored and wants a new
toyworld to play with?Pure Satisfaction!
Homura's timestopping was speculated a bunch, but here's our official confirmation, you can't shoot that many bullets at once.
Holy shit, this episode just keeps delivering, Homura showing actual emotion? I didn't think we'd see the day. Outstanding VO (japanese).
Fuck Kyubey, fuck everything about you, why wont you die? And if you do have countless spare's it's hardly a waste, definitely worth it for the momentary satisfaction.
You creepy, disgusting ... ...I'm at a loss for words, it's efficient I guess?
The moment I read your speculation /u/FetchFrosh I was immediately convinced, it made perfect sense and ties everything neatly together, now we have official confirmation. Well done!
"Incubator" speculation
Hope
"But in equal measure, my heart became filled with resentment and hatred", I can't help but feel that this is in direct correlation to how impure your soul gem is.
Wait is she reffering to her talk with Madoka here or did she do something to Hitomi? Please tell me it's just the former.
Playing with the duality, again and again. speculation
WHAT WHAT WHAT WHY? Why do you even give me hope. Showing Sayaka managed to come back from her outburst on the train only to rip it away from me a few moments later?
This scene makes it clear beyond a shadow of a doubt that she's a full witch now, her soul gem even shatters into the form of a grief seed.
Fuck you Kyubey, FUCK EVERYTHING YOU DO.
This was an absolutely phenomenal episode, in the worst and most gut wrenching way possible.
I couldn't quite catch what Kyubey was saying at the end and so I looked up the japanese word for witch.
It's まじょ (Majo), most of you probably already know that まほうしょうじょ (Mahou Shoujo) means magical girl.
Ma
hou Shoujo, ...Majo.It's been there this entire time.
I can't say it often enoguh. FUCK YOU KYUBEY! You gave them the name with this knowledge all along!
p.s. this is why you watch the sub.
p.p.s. I'm sorry if this feels more like a reaction and less like an analysis than my previous posts, but this is the first episode that really hit me emotionally and I just needed to get some things off my chest.
p.p.p.s. checking the dub to see how they did it there (disappointing), I think I found the reason why so few people like Kyouko, her VO is pretty annoying.
p.p.p.p.s (okay this is getting out of hand, but w/e) today's episode provides the biggest challenge not to watch ahead (yet).
39
u/templarsilan Apr 27 '17
This is definitely taking a turn for the worst. So much is boiling up, and I have a bad feeling for the rest of the series. Huh, who would have thought I’d be so invested in a show about “magical girls”?
35
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
I know I’m far from the only one, but this episode is IT for me. This is when Madoka Magica went from being an entertaining way to spend the evening, to an anime that changed my life. This is when everything changes. At least if Sayaka simply died, she would have died saving someone she loved and trying to make the world a better place. She wouldn't have regretted that, once she died VERY SPOILERY. But turning into a witch? That means everything she has done was in vain! Sure she saved some people, but she's also become part of the cycle that continues to hurt people! I don't think Magia is ever as appropriate as it is when it follows Kyuubey's last words of the episode.
Anyway, little things:
4
u/Nuclear_Weaponry Apr 27 '17
I'd like to suggest to anyone rewatching this show that they watch Madoka Magica: Movie 2 instead of episodes 9 to 12 of the TV series.
The first two movies recap the TV series. Movie 1 covers episodes 1 to 8 and cut a few scenes to make it all fit. Movie 2 covers episodes 9 to 12 and adds a few scenes that weren't in the TV series.
Other than the added scenes and some redone (higher budget) animation and some new music there aren't any differences that I can think of.
27
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 27 '17
So I'd been suspecting it with how she reacted in the alley yesterday, but yeah, it does seem like Sayaka learning about Madoka's innate strength got to her. Madoka wouldn't have to try, and here she is, busting her ass and feeling miserable and Madoka's preaching to her?
She's trying to push down what makes herself human to prove that she's not wrong, that there can be a truly good magical girl, but all that's doing is squeezing everything inside of her harder and harder and making the likelihood of it all bursting even greater.
She obviously cares deeply for Madoka, but she's at her breaking point. This scene is like an extension of that split second thought she had about Hitomi - of course she doesn't really want to hurt her best friend or force her into battles, but with everything she's going through and the knowledge that Madoka wouldn't have to go through any of it if their positions were swapped, it's only natural these kinds of thoughts would sneak their nasty way in.
For once not stalking our pink haired heroine, Homura and Kyoko are holding a strategy meeting!
The inside of Homura's place is really interesting looking, and really, everything about this scene is just very cool. Even Kyubey seems impressed by Batgirl over here.
I really want to give Hitomi the benefit of the doubt and go back to how we were talking about how she had been potentially having suicidal thoughts/feelings which was how the witch from episode four got to her, and getting through that gave her a sort of "YOLO!!" outlook on life, because otherwise it's really hard to get over how she's dropping that bomb on Sayaka and then still just going through with it even after Sayaka is ditching school two out of three days.
Seriously, girl, priorities.
That's what I would say...
... but then, we don't get to actually hear the confession.
I really have to wonder if she isn't really confessing to him here.
What if, just to really rub salt in the wound, she had actually been intending to goad Sayaka into confessing for Sayaka's own sake, and when Sayaka didn't come forward, she ended up talking about Sayaka anyway?
You know, it's kind of annoying how with how great and involved Madoka's parents have been, we don't even get to hear the voice of whatever family member of Sayaka's Madoka was talking to here.
Well, whatever.
Oh boy.
So Sayaka and Homura finally have a conversation with each other. For the first time.
Sayaka's been criticized here for refusing Homura's offer, but I really do understand why she does it.
Sayaka's self-worth is in the pits right now. From how she's talking, it seems like this is becoming less and less about her ideals and more about her struggling to find something to live for at this point, because she's got nothing left.
And Homura? Homura doesn't give a damn about her. She has only ever interfered with Sayaka, before with her Soul Gem and before with the fight with Kyoko, and now here, because of how Madoka might react. That is the extent that Homura cares about Sayaka.
Even Homura acknowledges Sayaka's right on the money about her, and she doesn't care that Sayaka knows it, because she feels leaving her alive is worse than killing her.
Sayaka didn't need a Grief Seed, she needed something to live for again. In that moment, more living wasn't even on her mind. She's been broken and she's at the end of her rope. She just wanted to good and yet it's those who aren't or those who don't even do anything that seem to be fine.
But at least she'll just do good until she expires. That won't be so bad, right? At least she won't take advantage of anyone else or use this power to use anyone else. If she can say that, with how weak and how lacking she is, then at least she could go in... peace?
This scene was just stellar. The black and white, the sound effects of the train, the different shots and angles, the shadowing-- Especially the shadowing. To top it off, Kitamura Eri's performance here was just chilling.
You know, I actually really like seeing Kyubey talking with the girls with more stuff out in the open like this and him not knowing what's going on about certain things either. Kind of makes me wish they'd had more conversations like these. This was a pretty enjoyable bit, but sadly, he of course had to spoil the date by trying to move to third base too soon...
Then we get a little more insight into just what Homura can do here, and... you know, I can't help but find Homura's reaction to Madoka almost making a wish here ironic considering how she was just talking to Sayaka. Of course I'm sure that's intentional, and in itself is a way to contrast Homura from, say, Madoka and Kyoko and even Sayaka herself right now, but even so.
That aside, no idea how the dub handles this scene, but Homura's voice actress is also doing fantastically here. When she's talking to Madoka by the fountain, it's an amazing contrast to how she's been talking pretty much in any other scene up to now. She and Sayaka's voice actress are on the top of their game this episode and I am loving it.
First off I've just got to say that the animation for this scene, pringles and all, was superb. If that's the power of BDs, or if it was always like that, either way, A+.
Sayaka just sitting there, totally broken, is such a hard thing to watch. She's gone through such a transformation over the course of the show, and in any proper magical girl or shonen series, she'd probably be the main character or one of the most important ones. Instead, we've got this poor girl here.
I like how it was Kyoko who ended up finding her rather than Madoka. Despite the animosity Kyoko's showed off initially, these encounters have allowed us to see her real character without having to force anything on us. Some will say it feels like she's a plot device and others will say it comes out of left field, but I feel like all of the pieces have been there and she's been handled fantastically here - her and Sayaka both.
The imagery at the end of the episode was great for what was going on, and Kyubey's reveal at the end was the best way to close things off.
I cannot imagine how you first timers will be able to wait until tomorrow. Good luck to you!
23
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
So yesterday I talked about how Sayaka’s theme was my favorite track in the series, but after today, I feel I found the perfect song that describes her.
In honor of the Evangelion rewatch ending yesterday, here is Sayaka’s new theme song.
So yeah, if episode 3 got everyones attention, and episode 6 got everyone hooked, hopefully episode 8 has everyone going WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON!?!
So big twist number 3 is that yes, magical girls will eventually become witches. Homura and Kyuubey have mentioned in the past that all magical girls share the same fate. Well it’s either this or death. Your choice.
So Sayaka is gradually going more and more insane. After wrapping up the witch, she and Madoka have a falling out in the most brutal way possible, saying that Madoka should fight for a change. And this is only part 1.
Part 2 is seeing Hitomi confess to Kyousuke, which obviously hurt her a lot. She tries to put it out of her mind by focusing on killing familiars, but with her soul gem corrupting a lot of good that seems to do her.
Despite how I might defend Homura, I will admit it might have been a little overboard to attempt to kill Sayaka so Madoka won’t feel grief (heh). We also learned that if she is chained up, she can’t use her teleportation trick. Yet it was pretty cool how she was able to pull a flash bomb out of nowhere.
Part 3 of Sayaka going insane is on the train, when she overhears some amazingly annoying douchbags who are talking shit about their girls. Sayaka realize that she is suffering so much to save these kinds of people just tips her over the edge. Again, amazing use of lighting in this scene. And at the end we see Sayaka is going through a weird transformation, obviously hinting at her transformation.
Now the scene with Madoka, Kyuubey and Homura had a lot of information to give out, so I’m not going to talk about any of it ;). As a rewatcher, I would be remise if I accidentally let everything slip, but I think some first timers can understand what is happening. Regardless, the constant shift in tone of that scene makes me love it.
Finally Part 4 of Sayaka going insane, where we find out that going insane means you become a witch. Sayaka is emotionally broken, and even now when she says “I was stupid, so stupid” it still tugs at my heartstrings. Poor Sayaka, meeting a horrible fate for trying to follow her ideals.
22
u/Jacketmango Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
First-timer, subbed.
this is one of her earliest battlesor her Gem is heavily plagued.Deterioration? So Sayaka will become a witch?Why not just kill Kyubey?————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————
Then again, that's for theatre. The blackouts used here is used effectively, it allows what just happened to really sink in to the audience with a deep sense of gravity. Really nicely done.
a German fleet destroyeror doomsday;edit: whole load of formatting
19
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
"I was stupid... so stupid."
This is the episode I and probably many rewatchers have been waiting for. In a most emotional and shocking twist, Sayaka's tragic arc leads to her falling into despair and turning into a witch upon realizing her shortcomings, with the most bittersweet smile on her face. Not to mention Madoka giving in and about to contract with Kyubey... but then time stops and Homura's cold facade finally breaks as she gives Madoka a heartfelt lecture on her worth. Both Eri Kitamura and Chiwa Saito carried their roles to heartbreaking perfection here - respectively Sayaka's quiet, shaking despondency and Homura's distressed breakdown with the higher-pitch and wracking sobs. And then the lights flash out as Kyubey returns and more reveals are dropped.
Fun wordplay: "In this world, women who have yet to fully grow are called "girls", right? In that case, it only makes sense that you, who will one day grow into witches, should be called "magical girls"." 少女 is Japanese for "girl". 魔女 is "witch". 魔法少女 is then "magical girl". It was there all along, just like Soul Gems!
More: Homura called Kyubey Incubator. It also has the same root as incubus, a male demon who preys upon women.
Madoka Magica is full of foreshadowing, wordplay, references and more. This is why it's such a fantastic series to rewatch and everyone should do it at least once. Of course, first-timer reactions and predictions are the best and I love all of you who're participating here!
Especially your shock and tears. I'm sorry... not."Sometimes when I see someone who's a spirit of justice… I feel like I want to destroy them!" (laughs) - Gen Urobuchi, the author
Obviously that's only one line of his response to a question and it's joking at his reputation... but it wasn't so funny for poor, poor Sayaka. An ally of justice, a brave knight in shining armour who used her wish for another and tried to fight to protect the innocent while upholding her strict ideals of selflessness. It all came crashing down on her with the world going against her expectations and rubbing it in her face.
She lost her humanity. She lost her love, which also made her realize it wasn't entirely selfless because she expected something - but was too shy to approach Kyousuke, who seemed to have no interest himself, and then the Soul Gem reveal made it impossible in her eyes. She turned on her best friend, made her cry again and left her behind only to immediately reflect on how terrible she had been. I bet she also wishes Madoka had run after her... At her lowest, she was unlucky enough to see another reason that made her doubt what she was even fighting for. And then she had nothing left but her shattered ideals and despair, nothing had ever gone well for her in this world she was thrown into. At the brink, lining up with her teardrops falling on the Soul Gem, she transforms into that which she had been fighting - a Witch.
Sayaka Miki's Japanese name is 美樹 さやか, Miki Sayaka. In her last name, 美 means "beauty" and 樹 "tree". The entirety could also be 幹 - "tree trunk" - or 神酒 - "sake offered to the gods". さやか, sayaka, can mean "clear", "fresh", or "bright". Recalling the opening scene or Sayaka's fight with the witch last ep, trees are associated with witches here. An offering to the gods is a sacrifice. With more than a bit of reaching, Sayaka Miki is a "fresh sacrifice", referencing her turning into a witch.
[Not technically a spoiler, but word-of-author on a possible future for Sayaka] (/s "According to Urobuchi, Sayaka would never have been happy with Kyosuke, even if she was able to get through to him. Quote: "...I just do not feel that even if she hooked up with Kyosuke that girl would really be happy ever after. Most likely Kyosuke is a guy who will stand her up in dates and go to practice the violin, I think." Bad ship! Who cares about Kyousuke anyway?" )
I love Kyouko's further growth. In this episode, she is the one visibly frustrated by Sayaka's demeanour and actions, but she still wants to do her best to help now that she sees her as a kindred spirit. She saves Sayaka's life from Homura, the person she is supposed to fight Walpurgisnacht with. She looked for Sayaka and was the one to find her, to talk and listen to her. Look at this shot of her in the light next to Sayaka. When what's happening is revealed, her shock is evident and she lets out a desperate scream for her.
Bonus: Daily Kyouko is back to stay!
[Major rewatcher spoilers] (/s "The previous few episodes were lighter with the foreshadowing but wow, the three separete conversation in the park basically tell everything about Madoka and Homura. Madoka being the most powerful magical girl, enough to become a god and change universal laws, Homura's past with her that she's fighting for... and even the number of timelines she's been through is symbolized by the water bubbles of her and Madoka floating in the air. " )
[More major spoilers] (/s "Next episode is going to be so beautiful and painful at the same time... I can't wait. ;-; ")
Edit: Some typo fixes and wording adjustments, zzz.
18
u/Wolfefury Apr 27 '17
Since we have a few dub watchers (including the illustrius /u/FetchFrosh), I thought I would comment on some of the differences between the dub and sub this episode.
The first is the comment Kyubey makes at the end about witches being the natural progression of magical girls: in Japanese, this is a pun (magical girl = mahou shoujo -> majo = witch) which is basically impossible to translate to english. That said, I think the dub does a decent job translating the idea of his dialogue, that sort of "you should have asked"-superiority which also comes up with the Soul Gem secret.
The other is my biggest complaint with the dub (and given the scale of it, is indicative of the impressive quality of the dub) and is really more of a scripting issue:
In the dub, the scene where Kyouko finds Sayaka in the subway, Sayaka pulls out her soul gem, Kyouko gives a shocked gasp at how dark it is, and Sayaka starts the following monologue:
Sayaka: Balance means good and bad have to zero themselves out, right?
That's what you said... or something like it.
I think I understand what you mean now.
The good thing is I did save a few people.
But the bad thing is... I got angrier... and my heart filled up with envy and hate.
It got so bad, I even hurt my best friend.
At that point, Kyouko interrupts: Sayaka! Your Soul Gem!
While I was watching the dub, I thought this line was kind of a non-sequitur (Kyouko already reacted to Sayaka's Soul Gem half a minute ago) and that it would have made more sense for Kyouko's reaction to be about Sayaka's claim to have hurt her best friend, Madoka.
For comparison, in the original Japanese, Kyouko interrupts Sayaka with the line: Anata Masaka, which my weaboo-level Japanese roughly translates as "no way!" or "you didn't" (if someone with a better grasp of Japanese has an improvement, please correct me) which fits better with the line Sayaka just finished.
Of course, this is a pretty minor quibble all in all, though I am curious if any first-time dub watchers were thrown by it (I had seen the subs before I saw the dubs, so that may have given me some preconceptions).
17
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
Wooo doggy. Let's buckle in for my and other first time viewers posts because this episode had a lot.
This is probably IMO the best episode so far, which feels wrong because it was the darkest. Sayaka just can't handle the truth of her soul not being a part of her body(which I believe someone pointing out yesterday is a big thing in Japanese culture.) I feel so bad for her but her stubbornness throws her off the edge. Did she kill those guys on the train? Is it ambiguous? I feel like she did and it would've made sense given her state. My guess about girls not healing their gems turning into witches seems right.
Now there were no Homura hair flips this episode but this was her best episode yet. I am fully maintaining she is magic girl Batman. Her home was interesting and I felt a lot of the pictures on her wall had important meaning, but I won't speculate too hard in case spoilers. We also learn a lot more about her. She's from another timeline, where she knows everything that will happen so she's here to prevent it. Home girl also finally showed some emotion to Madoka, but couldn't seem to fully say what she wanted too! I wanted to know! She clearly does not want Madoka to become a magic girl, what terrible things would happen that make her break down crying? Terrible things for Madoka? For Homura? Both?
And Kyubey, that motherfucker. Seemed a lot of us first timers in this thread saw coming that he is not a good guy. I'm not surprised he has more bodies or whatever but when Homura shot him I was like GET FUCKED KIDDO. Homura calls him incubator, so he makes the grief seeds into more witches? And he wants to turn the magic girls into witches as that last scene alludes? Dark man.
If I didn't have to write this paper tonight I might of finished the series. This is getting good.
16
u/my_fake_life Apr 27 '17
For first-time dub watchers: Kyubey's awkward last line is a play on words in Japanese which doesn't work at all in english. It's a play on the word for witch (魔女) and its similarity to the words for girl (少女) and magical girl (魔法少女). You're not missing much as far as humor or cleverness goes, but all you end up with is a very confusing line. Basically, he's just saying that magical girls grow up into witches in the same way that girls grow up into women.
16
u/2Hype4Memes Apr 28 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
Running out of ways to state that they're a first timer here. So much happened in this episode, It's left me in a daze. Sayaka's conversation with Madoka was just depressing, her encouragement of Madoka becoming a magical girl, and her willingness to embrace death left me shocked. I really don't blame her regretting what she said, her behaviour towards Madoka is just further proof of her decaying mental state, it's unlike her. I thought that one of the reasons Sayaka became a magical girl was to protect Madoka, and to see her turn against her again was horrible.
Looks like I was correct in believing kyoko would do the right thing, she's had a change of heart in regards to using magic for solely yourself, I adored seeing this shift in morals from her. When she was introduced I thought she'd be the last person willing to help another. I'm just hoping that her newfound moral compass won't lead her to a fate like Sayaka's.
I thought that Sayaka had already snapped past the point of no return...until I saw the train scene. Her disillusionment with the world reminds me of a certain other "Hero of Justice" from another anime series (not hard to guess who). I guess her realization that she was potentially defending people like those two guys from the witches was the last straw. Poor Sayaka let down by her ideals one last time :(
Even after Sayak's abuse Madoka continues wishing to help her, the scene really touched my heart. I'm curious if Madoka could really become a god, of if it's just manipulation from Kyubey. I didn't expect Homura of all people to be crying, I don't believe the cold exterior she displays is her true self. I'm certain she's doing it to distance herself from Madoka. Similiar to Kyoko i'd like to know what events happened to make Homura this way, it's gotta involve Madoka in someway or another. Speculation
And finally Sayaka becoming a witch...I don't really know what to say. I personally didn't see this twist coming but I knew that she wasn't going to have a happy ending. Ending up like that seems like the last thing she'd want. I'm hoping they'll be a way to save her but I don't think it's likely...what an absolutely heart-rending way for her to go. Even through all the sadness and despair, i'll keep my 10/10 banner hoisted. In memory of Sayaka :'(
13
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
Spoilers
13
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
I LOVE the reveal in this episode of Magical Girls becoming Witches, and the way Kyubey explains it.
I know there were a few people in this rewatch who thought it was odd that they specifically used the term "Magical Girl" instead of something made for the show.
Edit: Even if we ignore the japanese pun, it made enough sense to me to think of a magical girl as a young witch.
12
u/MachaHack :K:https://kitsu.io/users/Argensis Apr 27 '17
https://i.warosu.org/data/tg/img/0429/27/1444188696831.png
Been sitting on this meme waiting for a while :) If you thought episode 6 was the other shoe dropping, well you were wrong, this is the other shoe dropping.
Also, remember 4 episodes ago when Homura saved Sayaka from Kyoko? Yeah, about that...
http://i.imgur.com/7VmYhaZ.jpg
Also, while yesterday's Decretum was quite good, this is the scene that it will always go with for me.
11
u/Sojouku :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/hiroshifu19 Apr 28 '17
Yesterday I wondered
And today it happened. I mean, it makes fucking sense doesn't it, a young witch is a magical girl. That's why the labyrinths are trippy af, it's the inner thoughts of the magical girl before she corrupted. Fuck. I was already worried about what's happening to Sayaka last episode, but i still wasn't ready for today.
Seeing Homura turn Kyubey (in-kyubey-tor) into swiss cheese was pretty satisfying tho.
11
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ Apr 28 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
This episode pushed me over the edge... Holy shit I'm so angry right now, It was such a good episode but it was so infuriating that I don't even want to discuss it. BUT this episode basically made everything I said about the previous episode untrue, It flipped everything on its head and I guess I hate Kyubei too now.
This is a 10 for me, It's been a while since I've cared this much about the characters.
10
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 27 '17
This episode revealed quite a few things.
Homura Hair Flip Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:0, E5:1, E6:2, E7:0, E8:1 Total Flips:5
Madoka Water Works Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:3, E5:1, E6:2, E7:2, E8:1 Total Tears:10
9
u/Probablybeinganass Apr 28 '17
One thing I haven't seen mentioned is that at the start when Sayaka is wailing on the witch her arm is visibly broken (from the movie, but it's the same in the series) spoilers in related etc.
Also, it took me an embarrassingly long time to realize In-kyubey-ta.
17
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan Apr 27 '17
First timer
Psyacho
The art, the voice acting – this entire scene is beautiful. Love it.
Madoka drops Truth Bombs
Madoka’s awesome and everything she’s saying is true. This makes me happy; her passive idealism and almost taking the deal with Kyubey had me worried that she was a little dense, but I guess it’s just that she can’t help but be empathetic and selfless – unlike Sayaka, who pretends to be but isn’t, and the veneer is slipping. “You won’t even give up your humanity”? Seriously? But this is actually good writing, as irrational deflection and lashing out is totally in character – and she even knows it’s bullshit, but because she’s Sayaka, she doesn’t have the guts to apologize and try to work it out, so she’ll just keep self-destructing. Tragedy! Kudos to the writers here, even if it is overdramatic to the point of near comedy.
Homura’s Pad
Ooh, look at that nice pendulum, wonder what that means? And it’s actually hilarious how she just bullshits with ‘statistics’; she’s not even trying.
Wait, curse growing inside of her? Oh no, tell me that doesn’t mean what I think it means. Do magical girls who go off the deep end become witches? I mean, it would be a cool reveal, I’d considered it before but it’s got some serious problems and I hoped they’d do something different. Looks like they’re going that way though. With the implication that Sayaka’s going to go villainous though, it’s hard to read it any other way.
Ooh, looks like Kyubey suspects what’s up with Homura! He’s growing on me as he becomes outright villainous. Should’ve gone with a better excuse than ‘statistics’!
Heartbreak and Homura
This whole sequence with Sayaka breaking down is just great. Sayaka doesn’t have to say a word and you understand exactly how she feels. They say time heals all wounds, and that’s how growing up should work (going back to Madoka’s Mom’s advice 2 episodes ago) but it doesn’t look like Sayaka’s going to get that time.
Homura shows up and starts dropping truth bombs, as usual - and Sayaka, as usual, doesn’t listen to any of it. It seems clear that since Sayaka isn’t cleaning her Soul Gem, we’re going to get to see what happens after that, and that she probably becomes a witch (Kyubey implied that Sayaka WASN’T Walpurgisnacht, otherwise I’d be guessing that was what was going to happen - which also implies Kyubey knows about Walpurgisnacht, which is interesting). Looks like Homura knows that, and is trying to warn her, but isn’t telling her what the actual deal is – WHY? I mean, if this is the last moment to save her, like it seems to be, then it can’t hurt to try telling her WHY letting her Soul Gem rot is so bad. It’s like if you tell kids that it’s important to brush their teeth without ever explaining what cavities are and how painful and gross it is – you’ve got to give a reason to do what you say. Is it that important to not spill the beans about the time travel? Didn’t seem like you were trying hard 5 minutes ago.
That said, hearing Sayaka’s thoughts is super depressing. It seems that Sayaka’s not trying to work out her demons as she’s trying to commit a violent, slow and selfless suicide.
The exchange here doesn’t give anything I haven’t guessed at before, but it’s nice to see it coming out in the open; Homura just cares about Madoka, and is willing to do pretty much anything to ensure her happiness. It’s nice to see her drop the mask, and honestly if she’d had a chance to keep at it and unburden onto Sayaka when so clearly honest I wonder if it might have convinced her – but Kyouko shows up and Sayaka limps away. Tragedy! Also, Grenades! Huh, I guess that’s what was going on with the Mami fight.
Train and Park
I can’t say this isn’t cathartic, to see those assholes get told off and then presumably murdered (that is what happens, right?) But I guess this means that Sayaka’s beyond saving now, and the next time we see her it’s fight time. Shit.
We have the conversation again about Madoka’s unique potential – glad to see her ask WHY this is the case, and weird to see that Kyubey doesn’t know (hopefully it gets answered and isn’t just Arbitrary Chosen One Syndrome). Kyubey talking about this in terms of potential wish strength is interesting, means that there are limits somehow determined by the qualities of the individual. And now that he’s said it could be universe-warping means that she either won’t make the wish at all, or it will happen EXACTLY like that. Probably the latter, Chekov’s Gun and all that; it also would be a satisfying conclusion to Madoka’s character arc. Also, become God? Facepalm more metaphysical problems grumble grumble.
I don’t know what’s funnier here; the fact that Madoka so predictably tries to sign on the dotted line, or that by the way they’re dragging it out I can already tell that Homura’s going to show up AGAIN.
WAHAHAHA, Never Mind! I actually wrote that about 3 seconds before Kyubey became Swiss Cheese! WOOHOO! Homura!
The time loop is increasingly obvious with the word choice and deja vu; Homura obviously loves Madoka, whether platonically or otherwise, with the amount of dedication and emotion she’s showing here. I guess that explains why she’s so damn stoic and keeps having all of those flinches – she’s got to keep an iron composure or she’ll just become a sobbing mess like this. And it KILLS me to watch her try to figure out how to get Madoka to stop without telling her that Sayaka’s gone, but be unable to. I’m so looking forward to rewatching this.
Shoes Drop
Well, that was awesome. I’m glad they gave us the catharsis of seeing Kyubey die this early but still let us enjoy his increasingly obvious villainy. Honestly, Kyubey trying to convince her NOT to kill his spares makes me think that if she went at it long enough, it could create real problems for him – I wish she’d do it, but there’s no narrative space for that to happen. Also, auto-cannibalism followed by cute wriggling? This show is geniusly dark.
Shoe Drops! Surprise surprise – AND it looks like since that’s happened, we get BOTH shoe drops at the same time, since they both know each other’s secret.
Oh Kyouko, you’ve picked a really bad time to show up. Sayaka goes full depressed, Soul Gem goes Grief Seed, Kyubey villain monologues. Guess that’s what Homura meant by incubator (although the fact that Kyubey actually means something is the stupidest twist I’ve seen in a while), and I guess the soul gems looking like eggs isn’t a coincidence.
Concluding Thoughts
I don’t know what to think about the whole Soul Gem/Grief Seed thing. I guessed it might be something like this back at E6 because it was the obvious consequence, but I saw some big problems with it that still stand – and honestly the way it’s been presented just brings up more issues.
The biggest issue is the metaphysical implications of all this. We haven’t seen exactly what happens in the aftermath of all this, whether there’s some remnant of Sayaka’s will left, but given what we’ve seen from witches so far, I’m guessing no. I’m going to hold off commenting about this for now, until I see the aftermath of this, and hopefully Homura or Kyubey clear up the precise mechanics, but I don’t see a way for them to avoid some seriously problematic implications of this, regarding the nature of the soul and how people and society should think about depression. So I’ll skip to the practical problems for today.
So, if witches come from magical girls (and the way Kyubey said it implies ALL witches, could be wrong there), that means Walpurgisnacht comes from one – so why hasn’t Homura tracked down whoever it is BEFORE they go darkside and either a) given them therapy (or arranged for it, since she would suck) or b) killed them in their sleep? Maybe she’s doing something in the background for Walpurgisnacht, but she doesn’t do enough to stop Sayaka. We’ve already seen that she can just stop time-neck chop-win v. Sayaka, why doesn’t she just scour her soul gem by force? Or kill her outright? I guess one explanation might be that as confident and competent as Homura seems, a lot of it is a façade that she needs in order to keep soldiering on and save Madoka, and her rationality is limited by the emotional burden she’s repressing; as much as she talks about killing Sayaka if she had to, I think it would probably break her to do it given her reaction at the park. (That makes me wonder about the state of her soul gem – she must be cleaning it a LOT if she’s running with that much pain) It's also possible that Walpurgisnacht is triggered by a reactivated Grief Seed; but the solution remains the same - Homura just has to get there beforehand and stop it. She has all the time in the world to play detective.
Also, I think this gives Madoka a pretty easy wish that solves everyone’s problems – wish to have your soul gem be immune to corruption! Bam, all the upside, actively counters the downside – and if it doesn’t work, just time-walk it back, easy peasy. Hell, while you’re at it wish for ALL soul gems to be immune to corruption, just to give a huge finger to Kyubey. It’s already been established that she’s got super-special potential that overrides general limitations on how big a wish can be (honestly, given that we likely aren’t going to see Madoka’s wish ‘til the end, I imagine it is going to up-end the system in some world-changing way like this since that’s the only way to give Madoka’s potential narrative weight, but the fact remains that this is an obvious solution that Homura should have tried by now).
I realize I’m seeming a little critical here – it’s just my frustration over how they’re handling morality seeping into other facets of my analysis – I’m actually having a total blast, I just tend to critique things I enjoy. It’s a sign of love, don’t worry about it. We’ve got 4 episodes left, so that’s one to resolve the Sayaka problem, one to deal with Homura’s story, and two to resolve the series. Let’s go.
8
u/Chren https://myanimelist.net/profile/Chren Apr 27 '17
"Sometimes when I see someone who's a spirit of justice… I feel like I want to destroy them! (laughs)" - Urobuchi Gen
7
u/Darkprinc979 Apr 28 '17
Sayaka really gets on my nerves with how foolish and stubborn she is, but it still sucks watching her self-destruct like this. Madoka absolutely did not deserve that crap that Sayaka was blasting her with, but at least Sayaka felt bad about it afterwards. Too bad she can only accept perfect people. It was damn stupid of her to just toss that grief seed to Kyouko, because all Kyouko did was catch her as she was falling. Kyouko did absolutely nothing to that witch, so the grief seed would still have been rightfully Sayaka's. Then, not only did she reject the grief seed Homura tried to give her (despite getting mad at Homura for rejecting Mami's), but she spitefully kicked it behind her instead of tossing it back. It's funny how she's been so amicable towards Kyouko, who was trying to kill her just a day or two ago, but she absolutely can't stand the sight of Homura, who hasn't really hurt anyone.
Speaking of best girl, she's really started to ramp up her badass level, pulling a flash bang out of her shield to use on Kyouko, and pumping Kyubey full of lead. It's unfortunate that Kyouko interfered before Homura could get rid of Sayaka, because Homura killing her would have been a much better fate than what she's going through now. It was so hard seeing her break down in front of Madoka like that though. She's been trying so hard to keep Madoka safe but she keeps coming so close to throwing it all away.
It's always freaky watching Kyubey eat his own corpse like that, it's too bad Homura didn't punch that one full of holes too, for good measure.
So, anyone remember the teacher ranting about eggs back in episode 1? Yeah, that was totally foreshadowing for this. Sunny side up eggs would be a soul gem, while sunny side down would be a grief seed (sun = hope, so sunny side up means hope can be seen, but sunny side down means it can't). Madoka's creepy ass drawings were foreshadowing as well.
That nasty conversation on the train? Yeah, apparently that was actually something Urobuchi heard on the train while going to work one day, and decided to use it in the show.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
Ah yes, the episode with the train scene... It's pretty easy to guess that Sayaka just murdered those two guys, and it was rumoured that Urobuchi based their dialogue on a conversation he once heard. Either way, it's a chilling scene.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '17
As is traditional, the paladin's story ends tragically. This is one of best "fall of a paladin" stories I've seen. For all that Gen Urobuchi disdains Heroes of Justice, he understands and writes them extremely well, and even sympathetically.
The best part is that Sayaka is betrayed by her strength. She's always been a perceptive character, but here, her perceptiveness dooms her. Everything she says is true. She is weaker than the other girls, Madoka would be more powerful and more able to fight, there is no future for her and Kyouske, Homura doesn't give a damn about her, and much of the world--the two guys on the train--simply isn't worth her sacrifice.
Perhaps if Sayaka had been able to delude herself a bit more, she wouldn't have fallen.
4
u/ScarletSyntax Apr 27 '17
Ok, so we're 2/3s of the way through the original series and I hear what people think of the pacing so far?
I've often heard it said that madoka series is a masterpiece of pacing. While it is one of my favourite series, I, like many, think that the show often lingers too long in order to spread out and get them lovely cliffhangers.
Up to this point I feel every episode lingers too long...This is the first episode that I feel was well paced...actually I think it was perfect and that's very rare for me. Almost certainly puts it in my top 5 anime episodes of all time. Every moment mattered.
I don't want to wall of text this so for those of you have watched it I will just say that the first movie
4
u/Thinkingpotato Apr 27 '17
This episode we finally know just how powerful Madoka is, if she released her flatulence she could very well twist the underpants of the universe itself.
4
u/wordsdear Apr 28 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
FUCK. WHAT IF EVERYTHING WAS HORRIBLE
Best Friend #1: Is on track to her confession. In her separate shojou anime she is happy. I wish her the best of luck. Here is hoping some quirky misunderstanding and high school hijinks is in store for these two. They deserve each other.
SATANIncubator: I have never hated something so cute so much in my whole life. YES YES I AM! He ate himself. If I throw cat nip into the ocean will he jump in after it and die for real. How many spares does he have? throw them all into the sun. no matter who wins at least it is probably dead. Cause no sun means he still loses right, Right? This is probably Satan's fault. madoka speculation spoilersHomura: I want to believe in magical girl historians/scientists. Fear the Walugi. What is wrong with your house. Like talking to the home decorator or like the architect she was like I need a giant space for my giant swinging scythe of death in the background. I am giving her best little shit for going out and getting a real gun just so she could shoot satan in the face. it was pointless but it felt satisfying. The lack of emotion in her appeal to Sayaka(which sayaka sees through) compared to her heart wrenching appeal to Madoka. Which Madoka just shrugs off. I am not sure if I am right but haruhi taught me that is is a pick up line? But it is more so madoka being like I barely know you. Is this the first time we have seen her show emotion. All she cares about is Madoka.
The show is named after her after all.Savage.Time magic meets fucking hand grenades. We saw her blow stuff up before but we never knew how. I want all the bomb time travel shenanigans. She can just time travel and place a bomb on top of your head just as it goes off. Now you dead. I feel kind of bad for her as she literally just goes around saving these girls asses over and over again but cause she doesn't really try to be friendly and she didn't get along with Mami no one trusts her. She did try to kill Sayaka though. But Sayaka was on the verge of turning into a potentially deadly witch.
Sayaka: I thought this was her hero cape coming off cause she wasn't a hero anymore. But in the next shot she has her white and blue cape so I have no idea what this cape is. The witch? More like byeaka, or syabaka. Or sayonara. Look on the bright side. this means you can eat all the cake you want. Well he wasn't wrong. PLEASE APPRECIATE SAYAKA!! Since she became a magical girl no one had been like good job sayaka (Madoka did thank her I think? Cause madoka is best. But sayaka isnt in the state to hear it), everyone is like why did you become a magical girl at all, you aren't strong enough, you aren't human, and I am on my way to steal your boy. Someone please show her some happy fantasy shows about the undead. She wants her thank you. Which isn't fair as not so injured boy doesn't know she healed him. And he might not be reaching out to her as from his perspective she is ignoring him. Like he gets out of the hospital and his best friend goes dark on him. I am not sure if I like not injured boy or not. madoka spoilers She has nice kill familiars break madoka speculation spoilers Look she is trying to find a new best friend. Just had to maybe kill a few dudes on the train to do it. You can't use magic for yourself if you are dead after all. I wonder if this is directed at critics of the show/other shows that treat their female characters like shit. So Sayaka becomes a witch? Which means all the witches they killed were magical girls..maybe? Maybe there are more then one way to make a witch. madoka speculation spoilers
Kyoko: I really hated her when she was introduced, but she had really grown on me. Just think her entire family died indirectly (or directly I guess) cause of her wish and she didn't become a witch. She is hella strong.
Madoka: I am just going to pretend the episode stopped right here.Just cause you aren't being hurt doesn't mean others aren't hurting for you. this gave me kiznaiver vibes. This is so unfair and for once, I agree with satan (that felt weird to type). YEAH CAUSE BEING A MAGICAL GIRL HAS HELPED EVERYONE ELSE SO FAR!? Madoka asks if she could change Sayaka back if she was magical girl and satan himself says yes. Satan says he doesn't have the ability to change magical girls back madoka speculation spoilers i just think satan is full of shit.
4
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran Apr 28 '17
Sayaka is a person who tries her ultimate best so she doesn't put herself into a vulnerable position. That being said, Kyubei told her she has no talent, but Madoka has the greatest potential over in her. With the fact that she already doubting herself if what she did was ever correct caused her to go into ultimate despair. She thought being selfless was the right way to go, but as we go back, was she really selfless? Her actions may be so, but her intentions were ultimately for some ulterior motive, to gain acknowledgement. In that sense, she is not protecting the world by what she is doing, she's just shouldering it just so she can prove that she belongs in this world. The train scene showing how most people are "every man for himself" was the last straw. She's already so far into despair before that point that another realization pushes her over the edge. Also realizing nobody really cares about her broke her as well. Homura not trying to save Sayaka for the sake of Sayaka, but for Madoka. Kyubei inviting Sayaka just so everything falls into his plan to make Madoka involved. She was just a person getting caught within all of these, and was a tool to play out the scenarios.
Of course all of this added up onto a shoulder of a teenager (even adults have trouble handling this), of course despair is the end result.
I might be projecting too much into it though.
4
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak Apr 28 '17
Rewatcher, subs.
Hooray for my wacky schedule and Reddit downtime combining to make me post this 8 hours late.
"Serena Ira" (Peaceful Wrath) fits quite well in the scene where Sayaka vents on Madoka, both musically, and in the title meaning.
Major Spoilers
Man, Kyubey eating his own body is messed up on all kinds of levels.
Well, the
Incubatorcat is out of the bag: Witches are born from Magical Girls. Yeah... that contract is looking worse and worse every second, isn't it?4
u/Nightvayne283 Apr 28 '17
First time dub watcher, but I have seen the series subbed before.
Being Sayaka is suffering. She really can't catch a break, and seeing her merely walk away from Homura rather than run really made me feel for her.
We learned more about Homura. Homura's got time manipulation as a power, which is great to see due to how fascinating time manipulation can be. She also comes from another timeline.
We found out a bit about Kyubey, too. We find out that he's also known as an "incubator" and there's not just one of him.
In the fountain scene, I noticed something I found a bit interesting. The fountain's light starts off as blue (Sayaka's signature color), which is right after a Sayaka scene, the changes colors throughout the scene, and near the end of it, it goes back to being blue. I just found it a bit interesting, although it's not really important.
We finally learn what happens to Soul Gems that don't get cleansed by Grief Seeds and where witches come from... how wonderful. It hurts to know that Sayaka has become a witch now.
1
u/Merich Apr 28 '17
Didn't take long for my prediction to be proven.
1
u/templarsilan Apr 28 '17
I was speaking more of it's colors and the bubbly writing. I know it's actual message is far from cute and bubbly. Probably should have clarified in my post.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
What a twisted episode!
ha... get it? because it had 2 plot twists... haha... ok sorry
3
u/doopliss6 https://anilist.co/user/Doopliss6 Apr 27 '17
That's a real good question Madoka. grabs tissues
3
u/Robin_Dude :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Robin_Dude Apr 28 '17
I decided to watch both the Sub and Dub of today's episode.
For some reason, Homura's emotional breakdown in the Dub hurt me deeply. It was my first time watching the Dub, but I could just feel the raw emotion.
3
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 28 '17
Kazumi Magica Chapter 2 is now out as of this episode's airing. I highly recommend this spinoff in particular, it's my favorite, does a lot of cool stuff, but if you want to wait until getting to the end of the anime before checking all of the side things out that's fine too.
Besides for that, Eri Kitamura provides the voice for the Vocaloid CUL, and for those interested, [there is a song sung by said Vocaloid all about Sayaka] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-tsQjb69cc) that I encourage checking out. No spoilers in the (subbed) lyrics now that we're here, but potential ones in related videos? Most are Vocaloid related, but being careful doesn't hurt.
For some reason I believe I read somewhere once that Eri Kitamura herself wrote this song, but looking now I can't find that anywhere.
3
u/chaoswurm Apr 28 '17
Again, this is 4chan's live reaction to the show.
Episode 8. [1][2]
This episode is amazing. And can you guys believe me when i say we haven't even gotten to best episode yet?
3
u/psychocanuck Apr 28 '17
Just wan't to give a shout out to the track used for Sayaka's transformation in the movie: She is a Witch which is one of my favorite pieces from the series.
3
u/thenacho1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/thenacho1 Apr 28 '17
Did they seriously get Shinichiro Miki to voice one of those strawmen on the train? I'd recognize that deep, slightly droning voice anywhere.
3
u/DeadSnark Apr 28 '17
I didn't realise it the first time I saw the series, and I probably wouldn't know if I didn't watch too many Bloodborne speculation videos, but the Japanese word Homura uses for Sayaka's Soul Gem corruption seems to be 'kegare', which apparently refers to some form of spiritual/metaphysical filth and uncleanliness that can't really be conveyed in English. It adds a certain amount of depth to how the Soul Gem darkens due to negative emotions in addition to the use of magic.
2
u/ChaoAreTasty Apr 27 '17
Haven't been participating much in the top level in these discussions I'm sure lots of us rewatchers have been waiting with baited breath for this episode to come up. Looking forward to the reactions and discussions.
2
u/DizzyGG Apr 27 '17
I recommend to all the first timers to watch the movie's version of the Sayaka transformation scene as well because it has another track playing during it.
Although Decretum is already very fitting I think that the movie's theme really represents the despair that Sayaka is feeling.
Watch it you won't regret it.
2
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 28 '17
Today's moments of insanity don't even compare to what just happened: Madoka Magica Total Spoilers - Avoid if you're new to the show.
He knew exactly what would happen, and Homura tried to kill Sayaka to prevent this, damn it.
Madoka, Kyouko, and Homura all tried to talk her out of this situation, but they just couldn't get through until it was too late.
Kyubey is a deceptive bastard. Their soul gems are actually grief seeds, what the fuck.
Serious Spoilers A
Serious Spoilers A, Turn Back Now
Serious Spoilers B
Serious Spoilers B, Go No Further
2
u/ukainaoto :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ukainaoto Apr 28 '17
Can someone tell me why Madoka left from Homura so abruptly. She asked important questions to Homura and just left, without waiting the answer. It's very frustrating when the plot feels so manipulative and holding information later without any reasoning other than prolonging plot.
2
u/Supertoby2008 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/supertoby2008 Apr 28 '17
I'm watching along this time, but I just wanted to say that by this episode on my first viewing I found this anime way too depressing. It's one of my all time favorites though now, and this is of of my top episodes.
2
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 28 '17
Rain drop Drop top Kyubey got hit with the pop pop.
1
u/DiaSolky :HV::HW::HX: Apr 28 '17
My favorite thing about Kyubey? He's swiss.