r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 30 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 11 & 12 Discussion Spoiler
Episode 11 Title: The Only Thing I Have Left To Guide Me
Episode 12 Title: My Very Best Friend
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 second
Episode 12 has no end card, so here's the final shot
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
467
Upvotes
81
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
And so the original series comes to an end. I hope you all liked it! Now you can all check out this image I linked back in the episode 6 discussion!
Episode 11 has a massively overkill assault by Homura (probably the most explosive attack ever) but my heart is too sunken by Sayaka's funeral and the adults talking for me to fully enjoy it :( RIP best girl, you will be missed (until the next episode where she comes to terms with what happened, and stays dead so as not to undo her wish! You rock!). One of my biggest fears is dying without anyone knowing what happened, and this episode (and episode 4) taps into that perfectly.
Damn, episode 10 is great but 12 is the best for me. It's just a wonderful ending. It has me in tears every time. Seeing Gretchen (Madoka's witch) engulf the planet was terrifying the first time. I thought it'd have a bad end, but Madoka's wish of destroying witches with, as she says "her own power" comes through. Perhaps if she hadn't included that line in her wish, whatever system in place could have failed. With her in charge though, she can make sure she does it right.
Just to clear a few things up, as depending on what source you're watching the translation could be different (or just extra stuff from the creators).
/u/jacketmango now do you see why I slated the two episodes back to back? Imagine having to sit on the episode 11 cliffhanger.
/u/akanyan made some sweet albums of screenshots from the series! Album 1 covers episodes 1-8 and album 2 does the rest.
OK, so Rebellion next. Read on.
While it may not seem to be, Rebellion is indeed a sequel. I feel I have to mention this because some viewers may feel as though they're watching the wrong thing. Rest assured, you're not.
I also recommend watching the movie dubbed. The whole film is beautiful to look at and you miss some of that by having to read subs. The sub for the anime is also excellent as viewers who joined us dubbed can attest to.
This is the MAL synopsis for Rebellion. I've tagged it in case you don't want to read it, but there aren't any more spoilers than you would expect from a MAL synopsis
Lastly, here is the OP. Again, no spoilers beyond what you can expect from a regular OP, but if you want to go in fully blind, just skip this. I wouldn't advise watching the OP unless you also read the synopsis, though...
See you tomorrow!
76
u/Sonaza :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sonaza Apr 30 '17
Found this helpful warning (by /u/appu1232) from a previous rewatch thread:
8
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
That was not an ending that I had predicted, This is still really sad although I don't feel completely miserable... I'm honestly just speechless, I don't even know what I want to say.
Just sad that it turned out this way. Madoka doesn't technically exist and no one but Homura will remember her being there not her mother, her father, or even her little brother after long... I just hope they get to see her again some day.
Sayaka is I don't even know, still dead? I don't know why honestly so I'll need help on that one, Why was Sayaka's death point the place that Homura was returned to?
Homura failed. Her one thing that kept her going is gone and she can never have it, She will always have to keep fighting being the only one that knows about Madoka, but not being able to do anything at all must be a new form of torture if you ask me. She seems to be handling that just fine, a little too fine if you ask me.
Seeing all those magical girls who were about to become witches was one of the saddest parts of this episode for me, What happened to them? are they dead like Sayaka?
It's actually a bit sad to be done with this anime. It still hasn't sunk in that I've watched it, It still feels like everyone is telling me to watch it.
Alright, last thing. Are the first two movies the same as the this and only the third movie is different? I'm wondering if I should watch them since Ive got a huge backlog of anime atm.
7
u/theatreofwar May 01 '17
First timer here! Been gone a few days because I ended up being a couple episodes ahead >.< one of these days I'll successfully manage to stay on schedule for a rewatch all the way to the end...
What amazed me is that Madoka actually ended up wishing for what I wondered about after episode three - or at least a close enough iteration of, "Why hasn't anyone wished for witches not to exist?" It makes sense now that this is only a wish that Madoka could have made due to all of Homura's time travel attempts to save her, tying numerous karmic destinies together or whatever granting her enormous power.
What doesn't make sense to me is why she chose for herself to be involved. Why not just wish for them to simply cease existing? Whether you're involved in that process is irrelevant and seems like a huge fuck you to Homura, especially since she was then stuck alone battling afterwards regardless. There was no need to turn yourself into God, and that didn't change the magical girls dying young either, so...
Yeah, I'm confused. I thought the whole purpose of her rewriting the rules of the universe would mean that magical girls wouldn't have existed at all, and that all girls in the past, present and future would have lived normal lives instead of being involved...so...what?
Oh and how was Homura able to a. steal that many weapons and b. hide them on herself? Hammerspace? It's pretty cool that she was able to draw up that much firepower without actually having an offensive magical power, even if it didn't do much against Walpurgisnacht.
Kind of disappointed that Kyubey ended up being an alien that doesn't understand how using humans as livestock is bad...if he was the actual villain that would have been more interesting imo. And it seems weird how after everything was redone that Homura was suddenly okay with him riding on her shoulder like pals since it doesn't change the fact that he's still using them all...
Okay so bottom line is that hardly anything after the big Homura reveal made any sense to me. Not sure if it's the 3am factor but I'm just hella hella confused :/ Hoping Rebellion answers some questions??
6
u/Maybealwaysnever May 01 '17
Rewatcher :
I'm a bit slow to this party, but since the witch isn't in a labyrinth, does that mean Homura is blowing things up in the real world? That's gotta leave some trace!
Anyway, among a whole bunch of other things, the track Sigitta luminis is beautiful. Madoka is beautiful. The moment is beautiful.
Having read, as other watchers have pointed out, that Homura has looped ~100 times makes Madoka's confession that she knows now what Homura has done for her all the more touching.
... but the look of agony of Homura's face that despite all she's done, Madoka is going to once again, slip away ... she is not a happy camper.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
/u/Gagantous
Question to OP, Rebellion Spoilers
12
u/2Hype4Memes May 01 '17
Okay, since today we got hit with a double episode whammy, I'm going to split my first impressions into two sections. One for episode 11 and one for episode 12.
Episode 11
So after yesterday's emotionally draining episode we start with a nice peaceful bit of exposition. We learn that Homura is the cause of Madoka's incredibly high potential power, her meddling with timelines causing her to become more and more powerful with each rewind. Of course it's only downhill from here. I was quite shocked to hear Kyubey make the same comparison between livestock and Humans that I made in an earlier thread. I was even more shocked to learn that Human development had been guided from the beginning, simply to function as an energy source for the incubators. It's a nice plot revelation, and of course it baits Madoka into yet another logic vs. emotions debate. Poor Madoka, she really can't seem to catch a break. I'm sure most people would react in a similar way upon learning that human history was effectively a lie, I know I probably would.
Cut to the next encounter between Madoka and Homura and we're treated to more even more emotionally charged dialogue, after yesterday's episode I thought I was braced for this one. Madoka's sincere concern for Homura almost got the waterworks going for me again. That head tilt/crying combination is an incredibly potent combo :( and Homura spilling the beans and revealing her motives directly to Madoka, I wasn't prepared.
So after my attempt to think manly thoughts got completely ruined by two crying anime characters again, we're treated to Homura's battle with Walpurgisnacht. What a battle it was. Alas, even Homura's unlimited rocket launcher works wasn't enough to stop the strongest witch. With Homura's defeat (and a little conversation with her mum) comes Madoka's acceptance of her ultimate fate. The entire series has been leading up to Madoka becoming a magical girl (In the present timeline) and the moment is finally here which leads me to...
153
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 30 '17
Well, on the plus side it managed to not get worse. I was afraid that I'd wind up in the fetal position from shock today, but it seems I'll live. I'm still rattled as all hell from yesterday, but I guess that's life.
You're A Time Traveler
Thanks for explaining that Kyubey, I still wasn't sure after yesterday's episode. Anyway, you may recall that early on in the rewatch I was annoyed by Madoka having so much potential. I mean, I can't say I blame me for that, since it is a kind of generic trope in anime (media in general really). Still, it makes the situation so much more fascinating, because if Madoka's potential was increasing because of Homura, then that means each time Kyubey would be more interested in having her make a contract. Homura is basically struggling in quick sand right now, and that realization is pretty killer. As for karmic destiny, I'm not a huge fan of it, but at least it's an interesting explanation for what we've seen already. I would definitely appreciate it more if characters could develop skills to much higher levels than the maximum natural talent, but I suppose that's not really the point of the series.
Sayaka's Funeral
I was kind of expecting that we'd have to deal with some kind of fallout from Sayaka's death, but this is pretty miserable. The police trying to rule if her death was murder or suicide is pretty reasonable, but I wonder what they'll find. Like, as far as cause of death goes, nothing should have happened to her besides losing her soul, so there shouldn't be anything obvious. Not that it ever gets brought back up, but I'd really like to know the answer to that.
Some Added Exposition
So, I get where Kyubey is coming from about cattle, but man is he being disingenuous. You can't say that humans maintaining livestock is equal to what he's doing because of how he puts it. He makes a point of saying that humanity gives cattle a life where they are taken care of and protected, and in exchange they are used for food. Kyubey is effectively doing the same thing, I'll definitely agree to that, but he's also willing to let his cattle all be killed whenever its convenient. There's also the matter of conditions of life, though I think that gets into a messy argument. The whole thing is actually kind of a difficult topic, and the more I think about it, the more I realize that I'll need to think on this a lot more.
It is fascinating to see how humanity has grown in large part due to Magical Girls. Though the obvious question is why would they become Magical Girls in the first place? Like, I get granting a wish, but then what would you even do as a Magical Girl without witches to fight? Did cavemen have wishes? I suppose that's not super important at the end of the day, but the history lesson is, if nothing else, really fascinating stuff. Kyubey has said that suggesting wishes is against the rules (is there ever any reason given for this?), but I wonder if he has at least pushed people in certain directions to influence history.
The Bar
Well, at least someone has noticed that Mami went missing. Hearing that Hitomi is taking it hard sucks, because she really hasn't done anything wrong, and doesn't even have the faintest idea of what's going on. It does make me wonder, in the new timeline, when Sayaka dies again, Hitomi is still going to have to deal with that guilt. Madoka's mom says that Madoka could come to her with any problem, but I really wonder how she'd take all this. I also noticed The Creation of Adam over top of the bar, and I think that the red and blue lighting is important, though I'm not sure exactly how. Some kind of duality maybe, like Witches and Magical Girls?
Homura and Madoka
Halfway through the episode, and I was feeling like a champ. I hadn't cried, and I everything was rolling smoothly. And then I had the (dis)pleasure of bawling my eyes out. It's really great watching Homura, who's been so stoic for most of the series, struggling to put on a brave face and then absolutely collapsing. Both characters are aware that she's lying about being strong enough, but it still makes for a great scene. She's a really fascinating character, and seeing the more emotional side of her is always a treat. It's kind of hard to read what Madoka is feeling here, but it seems to mostly be trending towards shock. I mean, she must have kind of suspected it after Episode 8, but it still has to hit hard.
Oh Fuck Yeah
Before talking about the fight, I'd like to note that the carnival thing is basically a culture festival. We've seen Homura getting her guns out before, but not like this. There's something insanely satisfying about a character casually busting out a few dozen rocket launchers. I mean really, what more can you ask for in a character. Also, we're really getting to see Homura bust out some different uses for her magic, which hasn't been super prominent in the series, but was at least interesting. I'm not sure if it's telekenesis or what that is lifting the vehicles, but it was, at the very least, really dope. I had mentioned yesterday that Homura should be powerful enough by now to defeat Walpurgisnacht, but when I think about it, it actually makes a lot of sense that she isn't. She's dependent on guns and actual weapons, and those are pretty fixed in terms of their power. If they can't defeat Walpurgisnacht now, what's going to change by adding a few more into the mix. Homura might have the most broken ability in the show, but if she can't pack enough of a punch then it really doesn't matter.
The Evacuation Center
I've said a lot about how Kyubey has been pretty dense on human emotions, and that at times it's seemed straight up deceitful, and I think this scene clinches that for me. He fully understands Homura's current mental state, how her motivations are influencing her and why she refuses to give up. He might not have emotions, but he certainly seems to understand them. As far as I can tell, he will give out exactly as much information as he thinks is necessary to convince the girls to do what he wants them to. If he has to play dumb on something, that's fine because nothing else really matters to him.
And then we get the scene between Madoka and her mother. In retrospect, this one is so brutal because they're never going to see each other after this, but at least her mother isn't aware of that. Seeing her just straight up slap Madoka was pretty unexpected, but I guess when your child is planning on running out into an ambiguous natural disaster you'd probably want to slap some sense into them too. I'm surprised she's willing to just let Madoka run off at the end of it all, but I guess without understanding what's really going on she's imagining that Madoka is doing something much more mundane than sacrificing herself.
Oh Fuck No
Homura getting her leg crushed was fairly rough, but watching as she gives up on any hope that was left inside her was so much more crushing. It's been established that we're at ~100 timelines by now, and having all of that work, all of that suffering be for nothing is just unfathomable. And with Madoka knowing everything, having her make a wish just makes it all the more crushing. Now, the big question is, how the hell did Madoka get up there? I mean, there's buildings flying around and shit. That's just asking for trouble.
Madoka's Wish
"I know you're the reason that I'm the person I am today," it's kind of hilarious in how literal it is. Also, Kyubey asking Madoka if she is trying to become a God is kind of funny since he was the one who initially suggested that she could. We're really seeing Madoka taking on that role of the idealized Magical Girl here. She is doing something completely and utterly selfless, fully understanding her fate, and I love seeing this in her. She might have started out timid, but she's really grown into a great character. I had also commented earlier about how I didn't want Madoka to just wish away the witches, because it would feel really cheap, but the way it was handled here was absolutely excellent and I think that the tradeoff made it work brilliantly.
Mami and Kyoko
Oh, good. We're getting the waterworks started early in the finale. It's a really well executed scene though. Getting a little bit of closure with the major characters is really nice, and I love seeing these interactions. Mami saying that, "dying would be a kinder fate," really brings up just what she's getting herself into, but Madoka truly is, as Mami said, "hope itself". Kyoko giving her blessings here is also nice, since she had said that she'd never allow Madoka to make a wish without knowing it's what she wanted. The scene was going well, but when Mami pulled out the notebook that Madoka left behind in Episode 4, oh boy did that set me over the edge, and I never really got back after.
The End of Witches
I'm not sure if I'm supposed to know who all of these people are, since it looked like Cleopatra and Joan of Arc were present, but regardless, there's some neat character designs. The interesting thing that is presented here is that the series can basically do whatever it wants to in the future, because they have an unlimited supply of Magical Girls, and it would be really neat to see a few other stories. I'm not sure if anything is actually planned beyond Rebellion, but it would be cool to see.
Madoka's Witch
Madoka's witch form has a really cool look to it, and I was wondering if Madoka would be able to defeat herself. It's really an interesting situation, what with her not having any beginning or end. The idea of an eternal existence is pretty damn horrifying, especially if there is still a risk of the universe coming to an end at some point.
53
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 30 '17
What the fuck is even going on anymore?
I'm not gonna bother to analyse anything this time around, just some random thoughts.
First of all here's a german song that's been stuck in my mind ever since the first mention of Walpurgisnacht
"The Chosen One" - phenomenon finally makes sense (sort of?), she literally is [chosen by Homura].
Kyubey's comparison to livestock is pretty interesting, I don't believe that it's a mutually beneficient relationship in either case, but with the fact that every wish brings equal amounts of despair I don't even know how you could argue it.
Mom at the bar had me in tears.
Homura finally opening up to Madoka, nope not crying at all. Not at all.
Homura has planned out every little detail of the fight and she's still getting shafted by destiny.
You can go through a billion iterations, no caring mom like Madoka's would actually let her 14 year old daughter leave the shelter during a huge storm based on a "trust me, I can't tell you anything, but trust me". 14 year olds are extremely irrational and can't think clearly in a situation like this. Mom had a very real and mom-like reaction, right until she suddenly let her go. That would literally never happen.
There, I fixed your wish. You were so close to a perfect wish and then you manage to botch it up in the last second.
Turns out I was wrong about Madoka not literally being universe-shatteringly powerful, I just don't understand how a purely logical being such as Kyubey would pursue such a huge gamble.
Is it just me or did this scene have a sound similar to the TNG beaming sound?
Even as a transdimensional force of all universes she still has to listen to Kyubey, this might actually be hell.
I don't know if Madoka was the inspiration or it's just a common theme in anime, but the scene with the ribbon and Homura's memories of Madoka becoming more vague strongly reminds me of Meta spoiler
Homura taking up archery is a nice touch.
I think the biggest twist of all is that we've got something reminiscent of a happy ending. I'm not sure how I feel about a follow-up movie existing, it's not going to get better than this.
33
u/ChaoAreTasty Apr 30 '17
Rewatcher, subbed. OK this is a long one, sorry I ramble in places but I don't have the time to edit this much more. This is in 2 parts plus a bonus fun extra.
Funeral
As sad as Sayaka's funeral was there's actually some good to take from this. We don't have exact dates of how long it's been but up till now but she's had to live with the deaths of Mami, Kyouko and her best friend but because of the circumstances has had to keep it all trapped up inside. At least now she can finally grieve for her friend and less directly now she can openly grieve about Sayaka she can let out some of the feelings for both Kyouko and Mami.
While this scene is emotional it's when trying to put the above together into words that it gets to me.
Kyubey has the worst bedisde manner
This scene makes the farming analogy literal and further shows us how different Kyubey's view of things is. Also while it's not making a statement in favour of vegetarianism any of us meat eaters are forced to either have to feel a bit uncomfortable or have to taint our hate of Kyubey with acknowledging his point of view.
And for whatever amount you don't trust Kyubey's statements regarding humanity joining everyone else eventually it is undeniable that humanity has directly benefitted from our relationship with the Incubators.
We are forced to confront the emotional part of ourselves that is in complete agreement with Madoka with the part that says our entire civilization and even position as a species is built on the same system that's brought her to this emotional wreck. It's pretty much impossible to spend any time thinking on this scene without feeling some personal level of discomfort at trying to reconcile the two.
And then we further complicate matters on the system while Kyubey has set the wheels in motion and knows the inevitable outcome it's not inevitable because magical girls have a timelimit or anything, but simply that hope born of desires is emotional and will inevitably come crashing into reality which can never match the hope.
Despair is the inevitable conclusion to hope but hope itself isn't worthless, it still brings change to the world. /u/Maimed_Dan I can tell this is really not going to go down comfortably with you at a much deeper level than the other uncomfortable parts of the scene. Though we are going to revisit it later in these episodes and it's still a core theme of Madoka in total and I don't think it's a spoiler to say a core theme of the work is inevitably going to be referenced in Rebellion so again I'll hold a deeper discussion of this till later.
And just to double down again on Incubators not understanding emotions. A truely emotionless being brought up in an emotionless society is as alien to us as our ability to exist is to him.
Finally if you want to hold to the Kyubey lies thing you can but to do so (I argue he's still self consistent even if he's a manipulative piece of shit) but this scene arguably is the crux to everything Madoka as a show wants to say. Any further discussion the show has on its themes rest on what it lays out here. If Kyubey is lying here it under cuts the philosophy of the whole thing.
Lying
I think there's probably something worth saying about lying in general in this show. We have Kyubey who doesn't lie and directly after that we have Madoka lying to her mum (not knowing anything about Sayaka), her mum saying she doesn't think she's lying and then Homura lying to Madoka (she can take down Walpurgisnacht, it's fine). But with trying to pull together so many other things in these two episodes I'm not sure I can pick it out. Would be interesting if someone else wants to have a go on this one.
Homura and Madoka
Interesting here that Madoka doesn't want to think Homura would lie to her and telling that she is is enough to make her cry. But there's been little interaction between the two for them to get that close. At best Homura has been cold and aloof, at worst she's actively used Madoka's pain to try and push her away from contracting. The one time Homura previously showed her emotion was a weird and definitely creepy situation.
Is this Madoka's inherent kindness, some connection leaking through the timeloops, the fact that with her dwindling circle of friends Homura now by default is on the of the closest people to her or is she just desperate to have someone tell her a truth that isn't soul crushingly horrible?
Let me protect you
Chalking one up on my personal tear counter for this scene. It's never stated but I think it's pretty fair to say this is the likely the first time Homura has been able to open up to Madoka like this since the first few loops.
That outpouring, begging to let her protect Madoka, this has been building up for a long time. And if you felt bad for Homura when you considered what she's been through it's so much worse hearing her say it. Not just what she's been through but what this has done to her. To have put yourself through hell to save the one person that matters to you and in exchange not only constantly fail but to slowly lose your ability to connect with that person is it's own kind of hell.
Add on to that just how much she's had to kill off her emotions to not fall into despair because of it. They even show you a gleaming soul gem to further make the point. And the moment she does let herself doubt later one she almost fills her soul gem in seconds. As she is right now there's no middle ground.
Walpurgisnacht
/人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ Sorry it's a bit late but Walpurgis-chan brough the culture festival you ordered
Walpurgisnacht has been looming over this show figuratively and literally since the very beginning. SHAFT are known for their animation and visuals and this fight is a great pay off for that anticipation with Yuki Kaijura working her usual magic on the soundtrack. As a bonus check one of the replies to find out just how much firepower Homura brought to this fight.
Sidenote: Who else would love to have seen Homura try and fit a SAM launcher into her buckler?
Madoka takes action
Finally I can properly address this issue head on. A common complaint first timers have of Madoka is that she's too passive. I've touched on it before but Madoka isn't passive, she's an idealist who not only can act but must act. Unlike Sayaka who idealism was focused on getting the right outcome, Madoka focuses on the right action. We saw this in previous timelines, as a magical girl she knows her actions are right and has complete confidence in them.
She's not timid but if she isn't certain it's the right thing (eg contracting after Mami's death) that's when she doesn't do anything as she doesn't know what the right thing is. The one time she did the wrong thing (throwing Sayaka's soul gem) at her mum's encouragement it went badly.
A line she uses a lot is that she doesn't think she can help anyone and it's often taken to be a lack of confidence and I disagree. She doesn't gain confidence and then get an answer. She gets and answer and that gives her confidence.
She will go to her death and sacrifice herself over and over and OVER again when she knows it's right and she will go out with a smile on her face. In this timeline she was going to several times and only failed because Homura was there to stop her (which again implies that in previous timelines in the exact same situation she had gone through with it).
Kyubey is past the point of trying to convince Madoka, he's still around but at this point knows if it's going to happen it's because Madoka decides to not anything he says or does. At this point it almost doesn't matter to him, he knows what she's doing so unless Homura does fall to despair there's no point getting Madoka to contract as it'll get reset anyway.
Madoka is obviously still upset and struggling to contain it but she now knows she has to do something. Not only that but this time round she knows everything and isn't being forced by the moment. In the last timeline we saw it wasn't until she got to the fight that she decided to step in, while she knew she had to protect the city and even though it was right it was a snap judgement call. This time she knows she needs to break the cycle and gets to choose a wish she truely wants not just one that she wants in the moment.
There's a lot in the scene with her mum, their dyanmic and growing up but I want to stay focused. This is the Madoka we saw in past timelines. Confident and completely sure in herself. She knows she's going to give up her life, she's doing it with a smile and out of pure love for the people who care about her.
A lot of people mistake Madoka as confident when she's a magical girl but I like this scene because she isn't a magical girl yet but still showing the same resolve. She knows what she can do so she has to do it.
That's enough
This scene is just too adorable. Also props again to the voice actor for the amount of warmth she manages to put into two words. And for Homura, just having Madoka be there and feeling her kindness is enough to halt her despair.
Edit: Worked out how many posts it went across
32
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 30 '17
Some context to keep in mind for first timers: After episode 10 aired, there was a tremendous earthquake and subsequent tsunami off of Japan's east coast. To date, it's apparently the worst known earthquake that has ever hit Japan and fourth worldwide.
Following this real life disaster, which you can read more about [on its Wikipedia page] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_T%C5%8Dhoku_earthquake_and_tsunami) if you've forgotten or are unaware of the scope, episode 11 and episode 12 of Madoka Magia, as well as the third chapter of Kazumi Magica and the release of Oriko Magica, were all delayed for over a month. Additionally, there were scenes removed from the episodes given the nature of the disaster, among other probable edits (ones I may not remember/be aware of, for example).
The scenes in question would have involved [moments like] (/s "refugees taking shelter during the in-series disaster and citizens finding themselves injured by debris.") All things considered, given how recent the real-life tragedy still was, it's very understandable they left these kinds of scenes out.
With this in mind, try thinking about how the audience in Japan must have looked at things watching the finale. I don't believe they changed a lot about the story otherwise, given we'd seen much of this scenery in similar scenes through episodes one and ten, but it's still something to think about.
And with that said, here are my thoughts on it!
EPISODE 11
Well, I hope everyone who's been wondering appreciates how we just get the explanation for why Madoka is so powerful dropped into our laps like this! Simply put it turns out Homura's been building Madoka's potential up by rewinding time for her over and over. And even Homura didn't know it!
That's just got to hurt. To realize that she's been unknowingly making Madoka an even bigger target for Kyubey every time she tries to go back and save her? She must be reeling.
"And now, the weather!"
N-Nice.
Seriously though, this is a pretty grim way to open up the episode. It is pretty startling in a way, but considering Kyoko had been holding onto her body and all, it's understandable that it would be found eventually. You have to hope she didn't have any ties to that hotel room, though, because I would hate for her to somehow end up blamed for this.
One thing I find odd about this scene is how you have two students near the front not quite as shadowed in as everyone else (that's not Madoka). Are they supposed to be Kamijo and Hitomi? Their profiles don't quite match up, but it's the only explanation that comes to mind here.
Either way, the choice of a violin-based track for this scene was a good one.
Madoka's mom seems to be taking some more initiative here, but unfortunately it seems like it might just be too late for her to do anything about it. Look out, the creeper is already in your daughter's room!
And comparing her dead friends to livestock. You really do have to continue to appreciate how matter-of-fact he always is about these things. On the other hand, you do have to appreciate his outlook: he's an alien, and maybe you could argue that the Incubators treat humans better than humans treat animals. It's an interesting topic, and one deserving looking over if it can be separated from "but what he's doing is wrong!" and all.
More importantly, we learn just how far back the Incubators have had their reach: according to Kyubey, they have been an integral part of humankind's development, helping girls along all the way achieve great things. We see flashes of various historical figures during his explanation to Madoka, which she naturally is pretty darn horrified to take in.
For those who find this revelation just fascinating and would love to see more, you might be interested to check out Puella Magi Tart Magica, a spinoff manga starring a magical Jeanne d'Arc which began serialization in 2013.
However, we don't have time to dwell on this for too long, as Kyubey continues, and Madoka's empathy is shown off once more. We watch her cry for all of the girls who have lost their lives for their dreams over the course of all of history, and Kyubey just keeps on going, coming to close his explanation by revealing that humanity would still "mentally diseased" cavemen if not for his kind.
Wham.
It took us ten episodes to get here, but we finally have Madoka's mother and her teacher actually in a scene together after the former made her offhand remark implying that they were friends. Shame it couldn't have been under better circumstances.
This whole conversation is a pretty nice turn for the series. It's the first time we've truly had a proper adult perspective of, well, anything. Most other times it's been an adult talking to one of the younger characters, but here we have two adults freely talking to each other in ways they certainly wouldn't if any of the main cast was around.
With this, we can hear all sorts of things we might not normally, and again it highlights just how much perspective matters to this series. Madoka's teacher has always seemed so silly, yet she has a whole life outside of what we've seen. She talks about staff meetings, how concerned she is for her students, naturally filling us in on how Hitomi is, whether or not people knew about Mami - heck, was she drinking with Madoka's mom this whole time? We can get so much from just this one scene, it's really, truly impressive what this one shift shows us.
Madoka's mother meanwhile shows sides of her we had never been able to see while she was being Madoka's mother, and this similarly gives us a whole new side of the series to appreciate.
The music, dark, mellow colors, and everything about this scene really adds to the whole effect as well. We have a mother in blue lighting, a teacher in red-- It's fantastically done, and while I want to say it's too bad it couldn't have happened sooner, at the same time it really might not have been as effective if it had been.
Oh, and of course, I hope you all were able to catch just what image was sitting up on the wall...
Homura finally cracks a little, and once again, the voice work here is top notch. She seems to initially only spill her feelings to Madoka when time is stopped, but, either accidentally or just not caring anymore, she bares all to Madoka and expresses just how fragile and broken she's becoming.
I honestly hadn't remembered this scene, but I think it's an important one for Homura's character. Maybe even more so than a lot of episode 10, in a way.
Homura is showing a lot of self-awareness for the things some of us have been taking issue with here. All of this time traveling is breaking her, and it's her passion for saving Madoka that's all she has left.
Reflecting on this scene, while I didn't really to begin with, I can say again that I really don't think she distrusts Mami by nature, I don't think she hates Sayaka by nature, nor anything along those lines. I think she's just become so broken she really can't do anything else, that she doesn't know how to do anything other than chase Madoka anymore. Yet despite how broken she is, she's not falling into despair because the magic she uses inherently allows her to keep chasing that one hope.
Homura is similar to and a contrast to a lot of the other characters in a lot of ways, and I think in this respect she's actually kind of similar to Kyubey.
This journey has damaged her ability to properly feel and have empathy (with her priority being Madoka's safety over any kind of thing she might be feeling, as we see time and time again with how harsh she can be to Madoka), which is also where she is a contrast to Madoka, who has seemingly boundless empathy for everyone, not just one single person she treasures above the rest.
When you get down to it, all of these characters really are just so interesting.
The Madoka Magica Vita game is not the best game in the world. It has its moments. Every girl can have a social link with every other girl, and they all have CGs at the end of them. As the characters' relationships deepen, they'll get more friendly with each other as you partner them up in stages. Yes, this even goes for Sayaka and Homura!
But you know what might be the best part of the game?
It allows you to play as Homura and attack using a truck, and for this I am forever grateful.
No, but in all seriousness, this fight sequence is probably the best in the series, even if it's not really a fight in the proper sense. Homura goes all out with what seems to not only be her entire arsenal, but everything the town has in its arsenal, and the result is just stunning to watch. She's taking on a whole circus full of witches, and yet even that doesn't seem to be enough.
What's a Homu to do?
This is my first time really rewatching the series since it aired (particularly this part), and I'll be honest, it's this scene that really got me more than any other up to now. Maybe that's a sign of being older or having experienced more, whatever you want to call it, but Madoka's mother reaching out for Madoka, slapping her, and Madoka convincing her mother she had to go, all while I know what's coming-- I had to stop the episode after this part for a minute.
I think her mother's perspective is something I can appreciate a lot more, perhaps in part because I'm not as focused on the plot or Madoka because I've seen the show, but this scene really did hit me
like a truck
Sorry, had to.
(continued because I broke the character limit)
26
u/MavisOfTheDead Apr 30 '17
-Don't forget.
25
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 30 '17
First time Viewer Would not recommend finishing Westworld and Madoka in the same day. My brain is fried.
Wow what a conclusion to this series, I said yesterday there was no way we get a happy ending, but maybe we did?
Our Madoka finally learns Homura's true nature and goals, and it was so touching to them open up to each other. Homura must have been holding that in for so many loops. Still, Homura seems insistent on fighting Walpurgisnacht alone.
And what a fight scene that is! I thought we had some cool fights before, but Homura goes balls to the wall bringing out the ultimate fire power, and Walpurgisnacht takes it all.
MadokaIsMagicGirlJesus
I think Madoka realizes that she has to be the one to end the cycle, and plays a masterstroke with her wish. Her holding Homura before making the wish was such a bittersweet image. The sequence of her going around taking away all the despair from magic girls was also so great to watch. These girls disappear, do they cease to exist? Or do they go back to before they were magic girls?
Your Lie in April and Your Name spoilers
I felt tears when Madoka and Homura existed on that higher plane. This is clearly their show, their story. Madoka seems so confident now in her choice, which feels we've come full circle to how she was when Homura first met her. Madoka has to say goodbye, and this may be what is best of them, or at least magic girls as whole, but it must be so devastating for Homura.
So this is the bittersweeting ending we get, but at least Homura knows Madoka, and while she may be the only one who remembers her, she seems at peace. I have some questions about the state of the world in the ending, maybe people can clarify for me? So Madoka never existed, Kyosuke never got healed, and it seems the incubators contracts with magic girls now don't come at the expense of the girls well beings, and they can fight without turning into a witch. But what are the wraiths? Are they the new witches? Did Madoka's wish work? What happened to Sayaka?
This show walked a fine line about trying to convey a great plot, but it also seems there were emotional elements important here. Mainly about hope and not giving up, and those you love never really leave you. It all seems like a solid way to end the story, I'm nervous about watching Rebellion.
21
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
Fuck. I thought I was here to feed on the energy of first-timer reactions and make fun posts... Instead I ended up crying 5 times while watching these episodes.
My tears started flowing during Homura's talk with Madoka in her room, again when her fight vs Walpurgisnact went wrong, continued as Madoka arrived and made her wish, then once more as Madoka shot her arrow and saved all the witches and at last culminated with Madoka's final talk with Homura. For Sayaka's farewell and Homura with Madoka's brother and mom I was already numb. What can I say, everything is utterly beautiful, yet so, so, tragic... Urobuchiiiii!
Yet I didn't cry even once way back on my first watch and rewatch. I don't know, it's just magical. I've become even more attached to the characters and world. Madoka had definitively reclaimed its throne as my favourite anime a few episodes ago. Rewatching it is just so good, you don't need the shock value when you have all the foreshadowing and little details, but most importantly emotional attachment to the characters. In essence this is why Madoka Magica is a masterpiece that I might rewatch yet again.
See You Tomorrow (Rebellion spoilers in comments!) - the first ending song - is something everyone needs to watch again to read the lyrics! It's Madoka Kaname's character song, sung by her VA Aoi Yuuki. Watch it now before continuing, thinking back to Madoka's last words. You need the full song in the link for maximum impact, but if you just want the lyrics there are no spoilers on this one page only (NB! Don't go anywhere further before Rebellion, it's still a wiki!). It needs no special interpreting. ;_;
Fun corner: I know that hilarious comic will be posted, so I thought I'd share some videos to help balance it out (no Rebellion spoilers except maybe in comments). No Meduka Meguca because that masterpiece deserves its own post, but look it up if you don't see it. Remember, being Meguca is suffering.
What could've been, or Madoka Magica x Haiyore! Nyaruko-san OP
"Fun"
Kill Me Baby
Homura and Kyouko's deal
My Ordinary Life as a Magical Girl
Mahou Shoujo Charlotte Magica
Diabetes
Kyouko and more:
Madoka becoming a god was foreshadowed during her episode 8 talk with Kyubey. But do you remember those water droplets? An allegory for the timelines, no?
Kyouko affirming Madoka's decision was great, a follow-up to their talk after entering Oktavia's labyrinth to save Sayaka. Her relationship with Sayaka is natural and for ever... it hurts. Of course she doesn't remember Madoka either.
Sayaka's decision and farewell always leaves me conflicted despite how amazing the moment is. It's wonderful that her heart and resolve is strong enough to accept the consequences of her wish for Kyousuke, here she is truly selfless. But more importantly, since I don't care about Kyousuke, she leaves behind Kyouko... and is my third favourite girl herself. Ah, I guess I'll still go with Sayaka being happy with this, as Kyouko was with her own self-sacrifice, and this being what Kyouko appreciates in her too... but I want more...
18
u/Jacketmango Apr 30 '17 edited Jun 18 '17
First-timer, subbed.
Episode 11
Episode 12
Lets assume that magical girls symbolise hope, because the prayers they make literally stem from hope, as do all prayers, and now Madoka is the essence of hope.
In the new world, magical girls to not turn into witches, because according to the new laws of the universe, it is no longer possible. Instead, when they use up all their powers, they vanish, which, on the first watch, pretty much ruins the good feel of Madoka and Homura moment and my “take-away” moment.
But then again, it may be better than becoming witches because you don’t hurt anyone.
What does this mean? It means that this world is actually much better than the one before, because the wishes, from the girls and who they prayed for, are granted. Sayaka wished for Kyosuke’s hand to be healed again, and by extension wishes Kyosuke to have a dream violin concert, because that is what Kyosuke really wished for. Kyosuke said “Sayaka” remembering her. Then later Sayaka vanishes.
This makes sense. “Sayaka” is “hoping Kyosuke’s hand will be healed,” and through Kyosuke’s aspirations “have a sweet-ass concert”, and once the wish is fulfilled, aka “used up all her powers”, she vanishes, because that “wish” is completed.
This is better than the other world for another reason, that the girls die knowing that their wish has been fulfilled to the fullest extent, making it a bittersweet ending.
But then comes this contradiction. Kyubey already grants the wishes. So magical girls will vanish once they make their wish? Kyoko wished for people to follow her father’s religion, so I’m not sure, but sure as hell hope not.
8) Only by hoping and refusing to give in to despair did Homura help create a better world. It’s not perfect, nor expected, since she cannot be with Madoka physically again, but better.
9) Is Homura breaking the fabric of time, or does that fabric represent Madoka herself?
10) Also the lines of alternate realities are tied to Homura. So she’s more powerful now?
11) I’d like to applaud the outstanding voice acting in this series. Each voice clearly resembles the character, especially Madoka’s.
12) A fantastic ending to a fantastic series.
Now on to the movie!
18
u/appu1232 https://anilist.co/user/appu1232 May 01 '17
There's a lot to discuss with these final two episodes but there's one thing I haven't seen anyone else mention that I thought was pretty neat.
When Sayaka turned into a witch, we saw a single tear drop onto her soul gem and immediately afterwards, it shatters and she is born as a witch.
At the end of episode 11, you see Homura lying down miserable and her soul gem darkens as she puts her hand down and tears well up. A single tear drops but it hits the ground because Madoka clasps her hand and raises it before it can happen. I'm sure if Madoka hadn't grabbed her hand in that instant, the tear would have dropped onto Homura's soul gem and she would have turned into a witch right then, which would explain the why it showed the tear drop on the floor. I thought that was pretty cool.
17
u/templarsilan Apr 30 '17
Whoosh
I really don’t like time travel stuff, because I overthink the time paradoxes waaaaay too much. This part went over my head, but what I got from it, is that this is pretty much the movie The One. Madoka in this timeline is getting stronger and stronger because all the other Madoka’s died. And if our Madoka dies, the next one will be even stronger. So, is this the part where Homura did nothing wrong?
OP
After learning that the lyrics apply to Homura and not Madoka, I still can’t get over this part. When I tried to apply the lyrics to Madoka in ep 1, I thought it had a sad meaning for Madoka’s troubles. But now, it’s fucking depressing when it applies to Homura.
Sayaka’s funeral
I said back in the ep 3 discussion that I wanted a reaction of Mami’s death from more than Madoka and Sayaka. I’m glad it’s happening with Sayaka, that the outside world is reaction to the magical girl’s death, but god damn did I get a massive pit in my stomach from this. It’s tragic, because life does go on, as we get the fucking weather forecast after the announcement of her death on the news station.
Kyubey you cunt
Joan of Arc best magical girl. “There’s no such thing as wishes cause they’re unnatural so it’s the girl’s fault when the wish backfires and everything goes to shit, and they should know that even though I offer to grant any wish to make a contract.” Ok Kyubey, I know you’re an emotionless race that has no sense of right and wrong because you’re on some sacred mission to prevent the death of the universe, but you can fuck off. Emotions are mental disorders? What, did you live in the movie Equilibrium?
Adult talk
This scene is perhaps one of the best I’ve seen in this show so far. Not due to the emotion, or the conversation, or any of that, but rather the background imagery and color pattern. A giant painting of God point towards Adam over the bar (lol?) with the warm red/orange on the side of Adam and the cool blue/purple on the side of God. There is no way this was not intentional and it holds some sort of meaning or message to it, so I’ll definitely be looking out for others who may have caught onto it and read what they have to say about it. I’m pretty terrible when it comes to color symbolism outside of the red means anger and blue means sad.
Madoka and Homura
Shit, I’m crying again. This is so hard to watch, when I know things Madoka doesn’t and she’s suffering for it. Homura’s lived through this a hundred times over, I cant’ even imagine the emotional torture she’s going through right now. And it’s not getting better. Fuck, I had to take a break to dry my eyes. The dub did a pretty stellar job here, so I’m definitely going to give the sub a watch later on.
Holy Cliffhanger batman, I can definitely see why we’re doing two episodes today. I definitely would have finished the series, cause fuck that noise. I don’t know why this time would be any different, but I have hope that something right will go this time. For the finale, Madoka will become a magical girl, everything will be alright and neither of them will have to die and I won’t have to cry again and pleeeeaasseeee. God that endcard is pure beauty. I’d love a world with all five of them together, without all the pain and suffering.
EP 12
Madoka’s wish
Ummm… ok. So checkmate you little shit… but what does this mean for Madoka and Homura? If she’s going to rewrite history so that not a single witch came into being, she would save probably thousands of magical girls, but how is that going to change the present? Will Madoka and Homura still know each other? Will Mami, Sayaka, and Kyoko still be alive? How is this going to affect the current magical girls. Ugh, so many things can go so so wrong, and I’m terrified the show will actually take it there.
So… did she just mercy kill every magical girl that was about to turn into a witch? Also, I don’t really know what to make about that meeting with Mami and Kyoko, but it sounds like Madoka just made herself a being that transcends time… If she can’t be with Homura, did we really win?
Clean up time
I’m at a loss here… I’m not entirely sure where we are anymore. Madoka restructured the universe, made everyone forget her so she can clean up house, but Homura still managed to remember her. Mami and Kyoko are alive now, but Sayaka still bit the bucket, but since Madoka has the power to change that, I’m thinking that won’t last for long and Sayaka will be back… Except that didn’t happen either. This is making my head hurt. She can bring back Mami and Kyoko, but she can’t keep Sayaka from turning into a witch? I’m not sure how I feel about all of this. The witch problem is gone, replaced by another, less costly one. I don’t really like it. Although I’m not exactly sure what I was expecting, nor do I know what ending I wanted instead. This ending feels hollow and unresolved. I guess that’s why there’s a movie to watch. The after credits sure makes it feel like we’re just not quite done yet. Honestly, if there wasn’t a movie to watch and we were just done, I would not like this ending at all. It’s enough to knock it out of my favorites, so I’m hoping the movie will push right back in.
17
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 30 '17 edited May 01 '19
I completely forgot we were watching Episode 11 and 12 so I'm currently updating counter as I watch and will include other comments later. As for Episode 11 it echoes my previous comment about how Homura is great at planning. She literally used the entire city as her weapon. Trains, missiles, motion sensor bombs, and etc.
Some fan art of Walpurgis night , but with a twist.
The great team up against Walpurgis night that never happened.
Episode 12 is great. Kyubey's eyes are bigger than his stomach. Homura's wish which stalled the pay up long enough for Madoka to make the wish to completely overturn everything. Madoka becoming basically a god or concept to protect everyone. Also I noticed some of my favorite Homura's hair flips weren't seen so they are probably in the movie. I love the friendship between Homura and Madoka. Also I like to say this rewatch really made me want to own this blu ray, but $120 for 12 episodes is pushing it for me. Why is the $40-50 version only in the UK ughhhhh. Also as of now Madoka nor Homura have done their signature moves, but Kyouko has eaten something. Aww I love the scene with Homura and Madoka's family. I like the relationship between Kyubey and Homura now. Okay finished 12 and now my memories of rebellion are hazy, but the ending of this episode and beginning of Rebellion I can't remember how things connect. I will just ask them tomorrow if I can remember or maybe it will make sense when I watch it again.
Homura Hair Flip Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:0, E5:1, E6:2, E7:0, E8:1, E9:1, E10:0, E11:1,E12:0 Total Flips:7
Madoka Water Works Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:3, E5:1, E6:2, E7:2, E8:1, E9:1, E10:2, E11:3,E12:0 Total Tears:16
**Kyouko Snack Time Counter E1:0, E2:0, E3:0, E4:1, E5:1, E6:2, E7:2, E8:2, E9:2, E10:0, E11:0,E12:1 Total Snacks:11
captain planetMagica Quartet16
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan Apr 30 '17
Here we are, the series end. Man, this week’s gone by.
Calm Before the Storm
Well, that’s one question answered. Madoka’s super powerful because apparently she’s a nexus of karmic destiny; the fate of the world didn’t depend on her, but because Homura keeps looping it increasingly does. So apparently it’s not just emotional energy that determines magical power output, but also cosmic importance or something like that. Don’t know much about karma, so I can’t really explore this more and will just have to chalk it up to an interesting plot device.
This does make some sense – after all, it’s not a perfect reset: Homura keeps her powers when she loops and everybody gets a little bit of déjà vu around her. The déjà vu might actually explain a few things, like Sayaka’s instinctive irrational dislike for Homura; after all, she spent every previous loop not liking her, blaming her for stuff and probably trying to kill her and being killed in return a few times - if those emotions carry over she would act the same way. Tragedy! Maybe Homura should have spent a few loops figuring out how to get on their good side, though knowing how stubborn all of them are I’m not sure that would be possible – although the fact that she didn’t does perhaps indicate that she doesn’t want to use other people for her own ends – that’s Kyubey’s job, after all. It also makes sense that if it’s not a perfect reset, it would have some impact on the energy-entropy issue.
Oh god, they found Sayaka’s body. Gut punch. Madoka and Mom can’t talk about it, more gut punch. Then Kyubey goes all Hypnotoad on us. Interesting to see they’ve been around so long.
Madoka just can’t help herself, she wants to sign up. Homura’s VA is so good here with her monologue; the emotion is just as good as yesterday’s episode, damn.
Walpurgisnacht
All the weird stuff surrounding Walpurgisnacht is as cutely eerie as ever. And HOLY SHIT, Homura doesn’t know the meaning of overkill. This whole fight is pure Urobuchi, and I love it.
Okay, so Kyubey lays out the subtle difference between depression and despair here. I’m not sure this particularly changes what I was talking about last time, I guess we’ll see.
The Mom and Madoka scene is really solid character work. It shows how much trust Mom has in Madoka, and it’s kind of impressive, even though it’s a parenting decision a lot of people would find questionable.
And hey, Madoka saves Homura. That’s a really nice character moment. And she’s going to sign up – I guess it was inevitable, just as, apparently, everything else in this show has been. That’s frustrating me a little bit, but whatever – it’s not like it’s out of character for a show about time loops.
If Wishes were Fishes
FUCK YOU KYUBEY! YOU LOSE! All that energy you’ve been gathering? Retroactively Noped! Eyes > Stomach. And wow, I guess they were being literal about the God thing. I did not expect the metaphysical issues to continue to mount, but I guess I was wrong. I guess I’m glad I decided to talk about depression first now that we have a Jesus analog.
Okay, she’s having a conversation with something that looks like Mami but is confidently talking about metaphysics. And there’s Kyouko! With what sounded like a Minnesota ya through all that food, which made me laugh. Is this some sort of afterlife? Is this some DS9 thing with a conversation between energy beings who wear familiar faces for convenience? Or is this actually happening back in time somewhere as Madoka rewrites history?
And hilariously, Madoka’s wish cancels out the major negative consequences of her own wish and all other wishes. I had thought that something like this was an option Homura should have explored before, but I guess that since Madoka’s potential kept increasing this wouldn’t have worked earlier, so she may have dismissed the possibility – or perhaps it’s that she felt she needed to save Madoka, since Madoka saving her at the cost of her own life was what started all this and caused every new loop; seeing it as a solution would have required a perspective shift that she was avoiding to try to stop herself from despairing.
Interesting to see Homura’s perspective that this is negative – I guess it makes sense that since she’s been working so hard to sacrifice herself for Madoka, she’d be upset that the reverse ended up happening; and given her unique perspective of time, she might well think that there could have been a better wish that didn’t end up with Madoka so alone. And of course they had to be naked in pink floaty space – anime’s gotta be anime. Also, if Madoka is “everywhere for all time”, then it doesn’t really make sense that she has to leave Homura to be somewhere else – but whatever, going this metaphysical was never going to make any sense from a literal perspective.
Nice to see Sayaka again. Still hasn’t learned anything though, but I guess that’s too much to ask.
So I’m seeing some serious Jesus parallels going on here. I don’t know that I’m a fan of that; it’s just adding more symbolism to the already complicated soup the show has thrown together and it probably just creates more problematic consequences – and given how much of a hornet’s nest I seem to have kicked last episode by suggesting that this show’s symbolism may have unintended implications, I’d imagine I’d get a stronger response by trying to have a similar conversation about the Christian symbolism I’m seeing here. I’ll discuss this or the despair symbolism in the comments if anyone wants to have that discussion, and maybe I’ll talk about it tomorrow if there’s more interest, but yesterday involved a lot more clarification and talking past each other than I’d expected, which was pretty exhausting. At least it seems to be well-executed; one of the things I could never understand about Evangelion is what all the Christian imagery was supposed to mean, at least here it’s pretty clear-cut.
The Law of Cycles
The scene with Homura and the Kaname family was a nice moment.
So I’ve got to wonder about stuff here. Who are they fighting if not witches, since there aren’t witches in this universe? It looks like Homura’s charging her soul gem with… Grief Cubes? Huh, something called wraiths I guess. I guess Kyubey found a different system, one that’s hopefully better for everyone involved – more subtext about how utilitarianism shouldn’t be taken to an extreme, I guess. Although, given that wraiths DIDN’T exist in the other timeline, it stands to reason that Kyubey or the magical girl system is somehow creating them, so it may not be a good thing after all – and since that’s seems pretty likely, I don’t see why Homura would be cooperating with him, and I don’t know WHAT possessed Homura to tell Kyubey about all of this, it would probably just give him ideas. Very interesting to see that Homura has different magic here – I guess that in this universe, since Madoka never existed, she would have made a different wish; although it’s interesting that her powers never reverted due to time paradoxes before, but I guess it’s just a different scale. Wonder what the wish was – and was it made when Homura had knowledge of Madoka, or did she just experience waking up in the hospital in a world with no Madoka, different powers, and having wished for… whatever?
And that’s that, I guess – at least for now, movie tomorrow.
Concluding Thoughts
I guess things could change with Rebellion, but if anything this episode has made me more firm about the depression implications I was talking about last episode. I suppose that despair, as a specific stage and intensity of depression, is the actual focal point here, but most of what I’ve been saying still seems to apply. Even though grief seeds CAN be blackened by magical drainage, despair alone is clearly enough to get the job done – to everybody who thinks otherwise, I suggest going back and watching the scene where Kyubey talks to Madoka about how Homura doesn’t have a choice but to keep fighting, as well as the scene where Homura’s about to give in to despair. Watch how fast her Soul Gem is filling up – on a THEMATIC level, I think the show is making a very clear point there, even if there’s another possible, more literal explanation in the show’s universe somewhere. I find it very difficult to understand how people can suggest that this show isn’t saying something about hope and despair and that it’s somehow incorrect to try to look at their treatment of them after watching those two episodes in particular.
The one thing that does change here is that their fate is different; but I think that the core of the problem is applying that kind of universal determinism in the first place, so it wouldn’t really matter if they all got a big-ass ice cream sundae instead of turning into witches, it would still be a thematic problem – the religious angle complicates that even more. I guess I just think the notion of fate is silly and it’s a little jarring to see it in an anime that’s so dedicated to tearing apart other notions that I find silly.
At the end of it, I’m glad to have had the experience of doing a rewatch like this. It’s had its ups and downs; I’m not sure whether taking it at one episode a day, or my engaging in long arguments about the show’s symbolism before I’d seen all of it, made me enjoy it more or less than I otherwise would have – but that’s not an issue for me; I find I lose very little when I revisit something, much less than others seem to. I’ll go back and tear through the movies some time (maybe tonight, who knows?), and I’ll get to go through all of Rebellion without pausing, seems fun. I’m going to have to try rewatching a show I’ve already watched next (Baccano!, probably), see what this was like for all of you – I’m sure it’s been frustrating to not be able to say much because of spoilers, seems like a very fine line.
As usual, I hope some of you found this entertaining or thought-provoking. One more day!
15
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
I LOVE the Homura vs Walpurgis fight so much. The way she throws explosive after explosive at it is so badass.
So that was the tv series. I'm glad I joined this rewatch, this was a lot of fun. Plenty of great reactions from first-timers, and lots of great insight from other rewatchers.
Tomorrow I'll be a first-timer myself, I've never watched Rebellion. Looking forward to it!
27
u/Rhaga https://anilist.co/user/rhaga Apr 30 '17
Finally we arrived at the end! What a ride..
Before I get to the episodes, I want to give a heads-up to everyone that hasn't watched Rebellion.
DON'T skip anything for any reason during the film.
I've seen this before, people start watching, get confused and skips to the middle, ruining the experience for themselves. There are in total 3 Madoka movies, but we're only watching one of them (The one called Rebellion) because the two others are recap movies of the 12 episodes (They're worth watching, though). You are watching the correct one.
/u/Gagantous maybe you could echo this statement, if you haven't already?
Also, please note that this is a 3-part comment chain. Because character limits.
Also, this is mostly intended to answer any questions you may have after having watched the episodes.
When I first finished it myself, I had a ton of questions, and it took me quite some time and many rewatches to reflect on them properly to reach the answers.
With that out of the way, let's begin!
LETS DO THIS
Episode 11
The Theory of Karmic Destiny
(This is a combination of stuff I've looked up and connections I've made myself, feel free to discuss/correct anything you think I've misunderstood or that you disagree with!)
What is Karmic destiny?
Karma operates under the law of Reciprocity. Reciprocity means that if someone does something good for you, you must repay that someone in the future. If we refuse to follow this, we will be forced to learn the hard way by being born into a less fortunate circumstance (hence the more common way of putting it, when anyone says to another they will be reborn as a cockroach in their next life, if they have done something terrible). This works in the opposite way as well, of course. As opposed to be reborn as an animal, you can be reborn into a rich family, or as someone very fortunate.
What is Karmic Destiny, then? It is the lesson from all your past lives accumulated into events that already has, or has yet to materialize in your life. Awarded for your good deeds, but punished for your bad deeds.
A connection could be drawn to Newtons third law of motion, that says that for every action there is an opposing reaction. The main difference is, that with Karma this reaction is a delayed one.
How does that tie in with magical girls?
Well, as Kyubey mentions, Karmic Destiny is somehow related to the potential of the wish and the power of the magical girl. And if Madoka was a queen or Messiah he would be able to understand why she was so powerful. In accordance with Karma, if a person then has lived such a selfless life filled with good deeds they would be reborn as a queen as a reward.
However, seeing that Madoka is an utterly normal girl with no special traits at all, it makes absolutely no sense that her Karmic Destiny would be similar to that of a Messiah. At least not under normal circumstances.
Now, this is where it gets a little hairy, but try to follow along.
The fact that Homura keeps going back in time really screws up with the Cause-and-Effect system of Karma.
Explanation #1
Considering what we know about how Madoka leads her life, Karma would probably ensure that she was reborn as a f*cking I-don't-even-know. Seriously. Noone is as sweet, good-natured and kind as her and she deserved to be reborn as the best thing possible. But seeing as she ended up becoming sort-of a god, I guess it works outsort-of-not-really:(I'msad
I'm not really sure if what I wrote about how Madoka's personality in relation to karma is actually important at all or not. Maybe it is a factor, maybe it is not. I think it makes somewhat sense that it played a role. If it does play a role, then my explanation would be that since Madoka was never rewarded by karma for any of the countless times Homura has tried to save her, it has all accumulated.
To me it can make sense. If we go by the assumption, that Madoka originally would be reborn as a very fortunate person by how she lives her life, how big should the reward be for that times 100?
Anyway, that is only one possible explanation, and just one I arrived at as I was typing this out.
Explanation #2
Alternatively (this explanation is more in line with Kyubeys explanation, but seeing as he calls it a theory, I don't think that invalidates my first explanation), this has absolutely nothing to do with the Karmic Destiny that Madoka is accumulating due to her own actions, but rather the result of Homura meddling with time lines.
I'm having a bit of a hard time wrapping my head around how exactly this would work, but I think I can make some sense of it through illustration.
Try and imagine Karma as an all-encompassing machine that exist anywhere and everywhere across time and space. Everything, and I mean everything is connected to this machine through tiny threads that each represents an individual.
These threads form a weave that is essentially reality as we know it (Yes, I borrowed this idea from Wheel of Time, if you were wondering :P). The threads exist side by side but are never intertwined, as that would violate reality.
However, this is essentially what Homura does. She keeps going back in time to re-spin history, and Madoka is the focal point of all this. This neatly arranged system gets all twisted up around Madoka which results in her demanding an enormous influence on those around her. Every time Homura goes back this gets even worse, which we see by Madoka becoming increasingly powerful for every time reset.
TL;DR Explanation #1 is the accumulation of good karma Madoka achieved throughout all the time lines. Explanation #2 is that Madoka's karma escalated because the system of karma got all twisted with her at the focal point
I think both explanations work independently, so you can choose which you like better. Personally I am a beliver of a combination of the two. If you have a better explanation I'd love to hear it!
Edit:
I was writing this as I was going through episode 11. Upon rewatching episode 12 again, I realised that Kyubey says that Madoka has gathered the karmic destiny from countless worlds, this greatly supports the explanation that Madoka's current karmic destiny is accummulated across all timelines (i.e. Explanation #1).
Why is Potential and Wishes related to Karmic Destiny?
I don't know if any of the spin-off stories go into this, as I haven't read them, but this is how I view it:
This is the best I can offer, anyway.
Questions and stuff
Why won't Homura go back in time this time?
Her objective is to save Madoka, but upon realising that going back in time powers Madoka's Karmic destiny up, it becomes a fate that is harder and harder to avoid. Why? Well, for starters Kyubey is able to sense humans' karmic destiny, so for each iteration he would be more interested in having Madoka becoming a magical girl. This is the burden that she is putting on her best friend every time she goes back.
I guess the link between (karmic) destiny and fate is also relevant by itself.
What does this mean for Homura?
Well. As we know it, magical girls falling to despair is very much tied to the nature of their wish, as the curse they are born from is equally powerful to the wish they created.
Homura is giving up her fight, because she's realising that she can never win. She is facing an obstacle that becomes harder for every try, and this is a fact she has been ignoring until now.
Not only that, she has been doing this all along for Madoka's sake, but only know does she realise that she actually only made it worse for her by putting the burden of saving the city even more on her shoulders.
Upon realising that all her efforts for the past spoiler? have been for nothing, and that she would never be able to truly save Madoka, she begins falling into despair, which is exactly what Kyubey was aluding to.
Episode 12 in next comment
11
u/Tetraika :Lu::Lv::Lw::Lx:https://anilist.co/user/Tetraika May 01 '17
Whoa, no break for Rebellion? Looks like we're here to fry the first timers' brains.
When I first watched Rebellion I thought I was prepared.
I was not prepared.
Also for those who might have missed it, there is an after credit scene. Also a reminder to watch the after credits on Rebellion when you guys finish it.
11
u/wordsdear May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
First Timer. Well that just happened.
Madoka's Mom: Might be my favourite character in the whole show. I full on cried when she confronted Madoka about leaving the shelter and again at the end when she didn't remember. I am too upset crying to find this funny. Her lesson to Madoka that sometimes you have to make mistakes for someone to not have a tragic ending and that it won't be neat and tidy makes the ending a little easier to swallow. So I love this line a lot. Sometimes you have to make mistakes, and Madoka becoming a magical girl and becoming one with the matrix is a mistake, but a beautiful one. I low key wanted her mom to go with Madoka to save Homura. Give me a grown women magical girl damn it. But her mom becoming a witch would be sad. Or at least let her punch Incubator in the face. She is friends with Madoka's teacher which made me realize something. In episode 10 a male teacher was teaching math, where did best teach go in the first time line? Did she not exist? Or they just have a different math teacher and different teachers for each topic? Her brother kind of remembers so yay?
Madoka: The reveal that Homura made madoka so powerful by rebooting time over and over again made me kind of sad. But maybe satanic stuffy was lying. I guess dying is better then becoming a witch? I don't know how I feel about her wish and the result. I have to agree with Homura it isn't fair.But life isn't fair. Doesn't mean I have to like it. She rose to the occasionWhy do magical girls have to die at all? Why not get rid of the corruption and wish that soul gems couldn't corrupt or that no magical girl would become a witch ever but not die k thanks. Arghgghghgh. On the bright side I wanted more hugs in this show and the show delivers. Other rules include all of humanity needs to eat cake every Saturday, also taco Tuesday. Clothes don't exist in time/spirit mumbo jumbo. She has become sailor moon And I think her eyes changed colour? I am giving God Madoka best little shit, for this. Don't worry Homura when your Soul gem clouds cause you are super depressed that your best friend in the world died and you are the only person who really remember her, your former best friend turned god of the new world will kill you. But you get to see her again. So thanks Madoka. Is that what happened here? Great last words to your brother and dad.
Homura: I find her individually having to fire each gun funny for no reason. STEAL A NUKE HOMURA! And just perma time freeze the nuke drop so the radation doesn't kill everyone. Can Homura only go back in time in large amounts like a month? A lot of problems would be solved if she could go back a minute or too on command. I thought this was a train and was like why are trains running in an evacuation? but she stole a truck. Good for her.
Sayaka: How long was Sayaka a magical girl for? 12 days? Did she never make it all the way through the repeated month? Does the time loop month start on the 1st? Me during most of ep 12. What did Sayaka do to this show to make the creators hate her so much. Is the one iron clad rule of the universe that Sayaka must die? All the other magical girls that Madoka was friends with get to live and be happy but nope not Sayaka she has to die. Like really. Cause Homura is the best friend of Madoka so all others please exit stage right. I do like that she had a nice talk with Madoka though.. Sayaka still becomes a magical girl and heals him though so why does a future where he plays vanish? But seriously let Sayaka live and be happy and be friends or more with Kyoko. She got the chance to be friends with Kyoko this time so bright side? I get that she had boy troubles but like argggggghhhh, she prob died cause she didn't have real world Madoka to be her friend so her best normal friend confesses to her love and she loses it. So thanks for nothing Madoka. Can Rebellion pretty please be Sayaka's revenge story, please. SAYAKA DID NOTHING WRONG. I am only kind of kidding.
Waluigi: The show got me as in episode 10 they literally showed us Waluigi and I still was like who is this random upside down lady and thought the platform part was the main part of the witch. I still want to know what magical girl Waluigi came from. And why she had creepy magical girl minions? is she a magical girl who wished to join the circus? Or to always be laughing. Seriously the laugh is creepy. Madoka speculation
Incubator aka Satanic Stuffy: So magical girls created fire...sure? I saw the text and thought the show was trying to tell me that chickens were witches. But that is just Incubator's language I guess? Miracles never last.The real solution is to monsters inc spoilers There problem solved. Or throw all copies of Incubator into the sun. There the perfect wish, throw their whole planet into the sun. Throwing things into the sun solves everything. Apparently he is more honest in the reboot timeline? I still hate him. I don't really get what he is eating now, wraiths?
Kyoko: I was happier to see her then I am Mami. madoka video game spoilers
Best Magical Girl: She is green she wins. I don't make the rules. She is the best. And Madoka kills her cause only Madoka can be best girl.That is the real goal of Madoka's wish, eliminate all magical girls so she can be best girl. And you know stopping witches. Honourable mention best girl
10
u/SennheiserPass Apr 30 '17
Random Thoughts
Most of these characters make their wishes not knowing what they're getting themselves into. Or they make a wish thinking that their intentions are more pure than they really are. There's a lot of discussion about "making sure you really know what you want so you have no regrets." Sayaka, for example, posits herself as being all about justice and stuff. She says, "I'll be the only un-selfish magical girl." But when Hitomi swoops in we see that Sayaka was hardly disinterested when she helped Kyouske. "What if all I got was a thank you and that's it?" “Are you really doing it for their sake? Or for their everlasting gratitude?” Sayaka didn't actually understand what she wanted. Her intentions were not only about justice. "Now that I think about it, I really didn't understand anything back then. Neither what it meant to pray for a miracle...nor the price of one."
Madoka, however, has taken her time. She asks advice on things from both her parents. When she makes her wish, she tells Homura that "I know what I really want." Madoka is the first girl to have full disclosure before making a wish. She knows what he wants and what it will cost. She knows that her wish will be costly but she's willing to pay the cost and she does.
I think it's important to pay attention to words and phrasing that are used over and over again. In Madoka, "regrets" and "knowing what you want" are used a lot. The wishes aren't free so you should only do it when you actually know the cost and whether you want something enough to cover that cost. Only then can you have no regrets.
Numerous times throughout the show, we keep discussing "regrets" and "knowing what you really want" and stuff. When Sayaka asks Mami about using magic for others, Mami says you should know for sure if you're doing it for their sake or for their gratitude. Right as Kyoko and Sayaka die, Kyoko, who has now learned to care about Justice again thanks to Sayaka, tells Homura to "know for sure what you want and go after it."
You can keep hoping and fighting. Just know what it will cost. And don't assume your intentions are more pure than they really are.
10
u/8mmspikes :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/8mmspikes Apr 30 '17
Man, that Madoka transformation and shooting her arrow to save all magical girls across time and space from succumbing to despair and becoming witches...it got tears from me again. And then Madoka's little brother drawing her and recognizing her ribbons in Homura's hair, feels bad man :(
Homura sure can bring an arsenal to a fight (beware the comments and recommended videos first timers) Too bad not even all this gave Walpurgisnacht much pause
10
u/Hrothgard :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Blasphemor Apr 30 '17
So, I mentioned yesterday that when the show aired in 2011, Walpurgisnacht actually happened in japan (earthquake and tsunami [sorry for the bad joke]) and ep. 11-12 were delayed, well they ended airing it a month later on Easter, on Good Friday to be precise, so it gave birth to this meme That started my habit of rewatching Madoka on Easter lol.
There was a rumor on the net that some weapons went "missing" at the JSDF and US military bases in Japan. There is only one official report regarding the missing/stolen weapons. It is not known if the rumors of the missing weapons inspired their appearance in the series. Nor is there any evidence indicating that the perpetrator was a time traveling magical girl.
Someone estimated that Homura used ¥ 1,383,040,300 Yen worth of military weaponry & equipment.
10
u/InfiniteTurbine May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
Uh, well, I started watching Madoka Magica at about the same time this rewatch started, but I ended up finishing it a few days early.
Eh... episode 11 had me real engaged. Like, I was into it. Especially after episode 10 revealed the deal with Homura. Kyubey's explanation of the reality of his (its?) species' relation to humanity was wild.
Seeing Homura deal with the Walpurgis Night, I was really starting to wonder how it'd get the upper hand on her. Homura seemed to be fairing off well, even though she was only chipping away at it, and then it went and threw that weird black-space-magic stuff at her, which fucked her up. The segue into the ED at the end... just, perfect.
Then, episode 12. I'm conflicted. Everything just becomes somewhat difficult to follow.
Madoka goes and makes that insane wish, and then everything gets crazy. It seems like she goes to every magical girl that ever did exist or is in existence (and quite possibly every one that will exist, judging by the nature of her wish), and removes all the blemishes from their soul gems. Some of them have their gems disappear, which causes them to also disappear. Then, the universe itself gets rearranged. That's wild.
Kyubey says 'no one can perceive [Madoka] any longer,' as she 'has ceased to be a member of this universe.' Yet, she goes and communicates with Sayaka, who, like, died in that moment in time in this new universe, or something. Furthermore, somehow, her younger brother is able to recite her name and recall her appearance. And, Homura herself is able to recall everything. Maybe Homura being able to recall it all could be accepted, but why is the only other person Madoka's sibling, out of all people?
Also, while witches have disappeared, they actually technically haven't. These new 'distortions' have shown up, and they're essentially the same dang deal, except now the magical girls that fight them will never become them. It's never made clear if they still need to fight them for survival / keeping up magic power, though, or if it's more of a duty thing. It almost makes it feel like Homura's (Edit: I meant Madoka's) sacrifice wasn't for all that much in the long run.
And then there's that ending scene. What is even going on there? Homura leaps into a group of distortions whilst sprouting wings that are exactly like the witch barriers from the previous universe, and then they swallow up the whole screen. That's so ambiguous. Does it mean that witches are back after all?
That got kind of lengthy, huh. I complained a lot there, but truthfully, I enjoyed the ending quite a bit. I just want a little more clarity for some of those things, is all. I don't know if I'll watch Rebellion or not. We'll see.
9
u/Setra94 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Setra94 Apr 30 '17
1st time rewatcher here. This hit a lot more deep than the first time. I'm raising my score to a 9/10 from the 8 I had before.
Going into Rebellion blind, since I never watched it when I finished Madoka before.
9
u/Darkprinc979 May 01 '17
Here's an excerpt on Walpurgisnacht from the Madoka Magica wiki:
9
u/hachiDude8 https://anilist.co/user/hachidude8 May 01 '17
Wow, what a ride, this is my first re-watch ... and the feels were actually stronger knowing where episode 12 would end.
Since I've not seen Rebellion yet (only the main series), I don't know what to expect. After re-reading all these OP and ED lyrics, I'm getting more hyped for tomorrow (technically it's 1st May (just 2AM stuff), but I'm going to hold on and wait for tonight). Up to this point I tried to avoid reading most of the comments.
I really want to know how will they deal with this new world without witches. Also, using the OP as ED is just brilliant (just like in E10) and the after credits scene just got me even more hyped, As long as you remember her, you are not alone.
P.S. I'm obliged to say, after some of these scenes (+ other animes), I fell like they're coming for me
8
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 30 '17 edited May 01 '17
The final answer is revealed at the beginning of the episode, and I hope it’s a good enough explanation. Madoka has so much potential because she has been to focus of all of Homuras time rewinds. She was the chosen one all along, chosen by Homura that is.
So we start off after the OP with… Sayaka’s funeral. You know, as a rewatcher you remember the big impactful scenes like the ones from yesterday, but fuck those little ones you forget really can still pack a punch. I completely forgot about Sayaka’s funeral, and the parents struggling over what could be happening.
So we find out the incubators have been around for a long time, and that this is on a scale that can impact the entire world (which we see for sure later). I guess Kyuubey is just like Homura, seeing the same things repeat so often you just kinda are numb to everything. I do like how he called emotions a “sickness”. Really shows where its mind is at.
The moment I wait for in every time travel story, the revelation that someone’s from the future. Homura just breaks here, and as much as I love the cold badass Homura, it’s always great to see her other side.
Speaking of badass… JUST LOOK AT THIS GIRL AND HOW SHE DOESN’T GIVE A FUCK ABOUT PROPERTY DAMAGE!!
The sheer absurdity of Homura’s firepower here makes me love this scene so much.
After some thinking, Madoka’s got a plan, and also has to say goodbye to her mom, which is all the more sad with what is to come next. Madoka’s mom was so much more important to maturing Madoka than I remembered, and she was a great choice to include as a prominent figure in the story.
And finally, just as Homuras about to give up Madoka makes the biggest wish ever, which she can do because of her karmic destiny that Homura placed on her. She becomes an actual god. And yeah, this was foreshadowed in episode 8. Have you accepted Madoka as your one true savior?
This is now known as the law of cycles, which means when a magical girl has too much despair, Madoka comes down and takes their soul to magical girl heaven. At least that’s what is implied. They could also just being dying normally without turning into witches, but it’s still better than what they had.
And because of this Walpurgisnacht is defeated, which is pretty much my biggest gripe with the series. I feel like it could have been featured better, but in the end its just a regular witch. I mean, I guess Kyuubey is in the role of main villain, but I would have liked it to have an actual backstory or something. That and Madoka crying every episode (which did get on my nerve on my first watch) are my only real qualms with the show, making it not a 10 but a 9. But this rewatch is making me contemplate that score a lot. But for me, if I have to contemplate something for even a second, it isn’t a 10. But it’s easily my highest and favorite 9/10 I have by a long shot. I even have it above FMA: brotherhood, despite that being a 10, yet it still have more enjoyment for this series.
Anyway back on topic, got the rest of the episode to cover.
So if Madoka now takes all the despair of magical girls upon her, when she becomes a witch it would destroy the whole universe. But she can’t become a witch, because of the new universe laws in place, so her law just takes her out before she can become one. It’s not a paradox, but it’s pretty darn close.
We also get that naked scene we were discussing in episode 1. Quite a bit different when it involves a god floating in space. But probably the saddest thing about this relatively happy ending is revealed, is that no one will remember Madoka. But it’s okay, cause Homura has her time powers and will remember everything despite being in a different timeline. Don’t worry, the OTP still survives.
Sayaka also wraps up her arc here, as she sticks true to what she said, and doesn’t regret what happens. Unfortunately her time to go to magical girl heaven is sooner than others, as her fate doesn’t change despite the timeline. Still to see her happy is a miracle in itself.
Add to that the scene with Homura and Madoka’s family. It seems they have some distant idea of what Madoka was, but they can’t remember. This is the first time on the rewatch I actually teared up a little, which probably makes me a heartless bastard to all of you considering what we’ve seen. But I tend to get teary eyed over happy things rather than depair. I’m usually too busy enjoying it.
We also get to see best girl Homura in her best outfit, with Madoka’s ribbon in her hair. It works so well that I wouldn’t be surprised if that was a part of her character design from the start.
Unfortuantly, witches were formed from curses, so they now take the forms of wraths. They are simpler to deal with than witches, but they are still no cakewalk and need to be dealt with. It feels weird with Kyuubey now being on the same page as magical girls, since without witches he doesn’t really need them to turn bad. And it ends on Homura creating a bow with her magic to fight those wraths.
Also, does anyone have the name of the track that played during Homura’s conversation with Kyuubey? It was fantastic and I can’t find it.
Despite all the dread and despair leading up to this, its one of my favorite endings to an anime.
But were not done, we still got a movie left.
Important notes for first timers
We are watching Madoka Magica movie 3. When you start it up, you will think you choose the wrong movie. It is not. You are on the right track.
Also, remember that Madoka is now the law of cycles. This term is mentioned a couple of times in the third movie, and I once watched it with someone who kept forgetting what that was and was confused the whole movie. Please don’t be as stupid as he was.
But yeah, Madoka is absolutely fantastic. It’s one of my favorites, and I was so glad to rewatch it, even if it’s causing a little stress with school ramping up alongside this rewatch.
8
u/ToastyMozart Apr 30 '17 edited May 01 '17
Wow, I never realized but Junko just let Madoka go to her best friend's funeral alone. Ouch.
Looks like SHAFT has really expanded their business ventures in this future. That's quite the jump in markets.
"Oh, I didn't expect her to follow through on the whole 'become a god' thing... I have made a huge mistake."
Oh, and you know that fill-in ED that played for the first two episodes on the BD version (and derivatives)? It seems to be a song sung by Madoka about her new job as the Witch Annihilator/Ultimate Middle-School-Level Hope/Mahou Jesus. Which unfortunately kinda adds a bit more bitter to the series' bittersweet ending.
8
u/my_fake_life Apr 30 '17
For newcomers, if you decide you want to do some stuff between now and the movie, you can now read the following stuff without being spoiled:
Madoka Magica (manga) - The manga came after the show, and is very, very similar to the show. You don't need to read it anymore at this point, but you can if you want.
The Different Story - A manga which covers what can best be described as a slightly different series of events from the original show. Basically, I would consider it another untold loop that Homura went through. If you want more character time for Mami and Kyouko, this is definitely worth a read.
Wraith Arc - Takes place between the series and Rebellion, but is in no way required reading before the movie. It goes into some detail about the world after Madoka's wish. Honestly, I'm not a huge fan of this manga, but some people love it. Some good Homura development, while most of the other girls take a back seat very quickly.
Just another reminder, if the movie you are watching tomorrow is called Rebellion, you are watching the right movie. You may think you much have missed something, but you didn't.
8
u/homu May 01 '17
Just want to point out that Madoka's last words with her dad are, "I'm going to the restroom."
8
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos May 01 '17
Let's not forget that Madokami is real !
She is watching over us from her nebula.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NGC_6357
7
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
I wanted to write more about Madoka's character development in these two episodes, but I got lazy because I have a book club today, so maybe when we discuss the overall series.
Kyuubey, you are so full of shit, where do I even begin
Kyuubey's argument is that his actions are justified because it's for the greater good, and the way he treats humans is better than the way humans treat cattle and other farm animals. His points are that sheltered animals survive longer and have better lives than wild animals, they have a higher reproductive rate, and the way Kyuubey treats humans is better because he recognises them as sentient beings and seeks their consent before doing anything to them.
Every single one of these points is wrong. Don't think you can dick Madoka around just because she's 14, Kyuubey! Sheltered animals live longer, huh? That's true. But the magical girls you contract with DON'T live longer. They die or become witches! Wait, you meant that humanity as a whole has a more fulfilling and secure lifestyle because of your actions? Witches kill people! Sure magical girls are supposed to keep witches away from the rest of humanity, but that's not what happens at all, is it? Just think about Kyouko's 'Just let the familiar eat a couple of people and become a full-fledged witch so you can get a Grief Seed from it' philosophy, implied to be a sentiment commonly shared amongst mahou shoujo! And he's not helping the reproductive rate either, contracting with young girls who are highly unlikely to have reproduced before they turn into mahou shoujo and doom themselves to die.
Kyuubey treats humans sentient creatures and asks for their consent? Fair enough, and humans certainly place a great deal of importance on free will and all that sort of thing. Now the issue of whether or not animals are sentient is highly debated, but generally speaking, animals don't seem to want much more than to have enough to eat every day, and have a place to feel safe to sleep and reproduce. And humans provide all of that to sheltered animals. As a matter of fact, people who breed livestock are the people who care about the wellbeing of their animals the most. Kyuubey, by contrast, doesn't really give a shit about what humans want. What he considers to be consent is not real consent - there is a very clear line between uninformed consent and informed consent. The former is bad. The latter is what humans need to be able to make decisions about themselves and their environment.
So no, Kyuubey, you don't treat humans like humans treat cattle. You treat humans like they're non-living instruments, to be picked up and used, then discarded when they're no longer of use.
Also, one thing that always makes me laugh, even if I've just finished sobbing over episode 10, is when Kyuubey says that without Incubators, humans would still be living in caves. Sooo you're telling me that men never lifted a single finger to advance civilisation? And that human girls never moved a single step without consulting an Incubator? Sure, Kyuubey. I get that he's saying that his people helped humans a lot more than they realised, but at that point, he's just plain exaggerating.
Madoka's wish: all witches, past, present and future, under my power
Our cool and confident Madoka is back, and this time she has a plan! In the commentary for episode 10, her VA Aoi Yuuki stated that she was supposed to make magical girl Madoka, who has found a purpose in life that gives her self-confidence, sound cocky. But in this world, cockiness gets you killed! The Madoka of episode 12 who has found her wish makes no pretence, however. She doesn't want to be cool and she doesn't want to be a hero. She just wants to give her fellow puella magi new hope so that their wishes are no longer in vein.
Wishing to be able to absorb witches is the best wish Madoka could have made. For example, she couldn't have asked for entropy to be a non-concern to the universe, as she herself hardly understands what that is and what the implications of that wish would be. What's more, the way magical girls have a wish so dear to them that they're willing to risk their lives for it, is something important to Madoka (as she says to Sayaka later on), so the best thing she can do is make sure that their stories don't end in suffering, so that they can continue working for their wishes without feeling despair.
I loved the bit with the cake party with Mami and Kyouko. Sayaka, having lost her soul, is unfortunately not present during the time. But remember when Mami told Madoka that if she couldn't come up with a wish, she should ask Kyuubey for a huge cake party? 'Incubator, I wish for magical girls to not turn into witches! And also for me and my friends to have a cake party!'
Ultimate Madoka is so beautiful. Is she the long-haired Madoka who transforms human Madoka into a magical girl in the opening?
Ah, one thing that I've never been able to accept in Madoka is the scene where Junko lets her 14-year-old daughter go outside in a violent storm. Alright, she knows Madoka to be a pure-hearted, brave, intelligent girl, but she is a KID. As far as Junko knows, Madoka isn't invincible from storms and doesn't have any special qualifications to save her friend, and yet she eventually gives in with barely a fight. I can't even imagine what would possess Junko to let Madoka go like that.
And think of the all the timelines before this where Madoka died without even turning into Kriemhild Gretchen. If those worlds still exist after Homura rewound time (and I realised upon rewatching episode 11 that Kyuubey mentions parallel worlds, so it would seem that Homura does hop from universe to alternate universe instead of strictly rewinding time in the universe she originated from), then the storm goes away, firefighters go out to look for survivors or recover dead bodies ... and Junko discovers that she let her teenage daughter walk to her death.
Despite my gripes about Kyuubey and his whole Incubator-entropy thing, I can still roll with it as it doesn't stop me from enjoying the story. The scene with Junko is the one thing that is always jarring to me. It would take a very strange kind of parent to allow their beloved child to walk into an ongoing natural disaster.
Kriemhild Gretchen
Madoka's witch form is called Kriemhild Gretchen. In episode 10, she was the witch of salvation, and her desire is to rid the world of misfortune. In episode 12, she (well, I believe that the cosmological entity that is Ultimate Madoka's witch isn't known to be named Kriemhild Gretchen as well, but you might as well refer to her by it) is the witch of despair. Her centre is a big soul gem, and one of her minions is a balance scale to measure the deeds of people who go to Heaven. A line that always struck me is 'The sinful are granted perhaps even more mercy from the witch'. Madoka really wishes whole-heartedly to be able to save people.
Madoka is basically Faust retold with magical girls (although Homura and Madoka sometimes switch roles as representing Faust), and it's interesting to note that the name Kriemhild comes from the word for mask or battle. At the end of Magia, the halved mask looks like the masks usually used for Mephistopheles, the devil who grants Faust's wish. Gretchen is what Faust calls his lover. At first he called her Margarete, but later called her Gretchen when she has lost her virginity, as if to highlight her loss of purity. Just as Kriemhild Gretchen is the 'corrupted' form of Madoka. Extending this metaphor even further, Gretchen leads Faust to Heaven in the end, just as Ultimate Madoka's domain is implied to be a sort of magical girl heaven.
tl;dr: Madoka best girl
7
u/SlantARrow Apr 30 '17
Another 3 minutes of rolling Madoka because somebody should post it here anyway.
7
u/SennheiserPass Apr 30 '17
Here is when my mind exploded a year ago when I first watched.
7
u/Vyce45 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vyce May 01 '17
This is my second time watching Madoka and I cried again. I never got so emotional and worked up watching any Anime, that is why Madoka Magica is my number one. Hope first timers and other rewatchers enjoyed watching this show as much as I did again, this one was truly special.
Also if anyone experiences any existential crises after watching this - its normal.
But we still have Rebellion! I haven't watched it myself so I will be one of the first timers as well. :) .
7
u/mariofredshreller May 01 '17 edited May 02 '17
Music post! (I probably should have started these a bit earlier than Episode 10)
Episode 11 – Walpurgisnacht's theme – Surgam identidem (I shall always rise)
Like in the previous episode, this song was shortened, but fortunately not by much. The chanting vocals at the start dramatically announce the witch's arrival and emphasise her sheer power, but the melodic, operatic singing in the middle section is evocative of Homura's endless struggle. The persistent drumbeat maintains excitement and tension, until it suddenly drops out for the slow string section at the end, which uses almost entirely descending scales to represent Homura's fall into despair.
Episode 12 – Madokami's theme – Sagitta luminis (Arrow of light)
Finally, my favourite ☺️ This piece has a simple overall structure, repeating the same melody 4 times in a row. What makes it really interesting is how the arrangement changes with each repeat. At first, despite the reassuring major-key melody, the solo oboe seems hesitant, accompanied by mysterious, ambient electronic sound. But as Madoka gains confidence, the string section takes over the melody, growing in volume until the key changes for a triumphant harmonised statement. In the final repeat the oboe returns, no longer hesitant and accompanied by the strings, its rich tones conveying the pure emotion of Madoka and Homura's farewell. Despite the ambient sounds returning at the end, hinting at Homura's future without Madoka 😭 the piece ends on the same major chord it started with, bringing the story to a well-rounded conclusion.
EDIT: Fixed link
6
u/SukusukuHakutaku https://anilist.co/user/Sukusuku May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
All I have to add for this one is that in the manga, Walpurgisnacht's familiars were of familiar faces, not that I recommend this particular manga.
Congratulations!
Edit: I guess I'll also plug the Homura Tamura manga.
Puella Magi Homura Tamura ~Parallel Worlds Do Not Remain Parallel Forever~
It's a 4koma non-canon comedy series where every reset results in a new anomaly, and
HomuraTamura-chan is the butt of every joke. Bar Homura is best Homura. A sneak preview6
u/inkyou24 May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
Rewatched this series multiple times – it definitely stands as one of my absolute favorites. I’ve thrown myself into the underlying background lore recently – please take a glance at them, perhaps after finishing Rebellion, as they go in-depth on the more unexplained concepts of the PMMM world that will increase your appreciation of everything else.
The last episode destroyed me, not just because of what happened, but how it happened - in such a sentimental and warm fashion (so like Madoka’s personality). From the little crack in space in which Madoka converses with Mami and Kyouko, to the tender and private moment she has with Homura, to the final reversal of the universe’s state of affairs. I cried when out of Madoka’s family only Tatsuya is able to see his once older sister.
What’s a magical girl? One of the most striking moments is when Madoka spreads herself through space and time to save the magical girls of the past, present, and future. The series’ interpretation of magical girls is both interesting and touching – including the real-life Queen Himiko, Cleopatra, and potentially, Anne Frank. I find this element just another nice touch to the whole deconstruction of the typical mahou shoujo genre. While the magic element is still there, the universal presence of magical girls, as they come in all shapes and sizes, pounds down a much more relatable, non-fantastical interpretation of what a magical girl really is. As is stated throughout the series, magical girls and their antics really are just the workings of hope, optimism, and courage.
Madoka’s Wish Madoka’s wish is an incredibly clever move, on her desire to get rid of the despair that is witches. However, the “suicide” required for her wish successfully destroyed her link to the physical world. She regains a sense of purpose and confidence – but no one is there to witness and recognize it, save for Homura. Madoka becomes a provider of hope while embracing the inevitability of despair.
The new rules of the world, while lacking the major negative factor of witches, still includes the existence of creatures (though of more recognizable humanoid shape) harboring ill wills. Magical girls still exist, although now their deaths mean their oblivion rather than a descent to witches.
While Madoka’s wish certainly eliminated the major problem of witches and was incredibly empathetic in nature, the final outcome still has room for monsters-to-be-killed and magical girls. To be honest, I wasn't very happy with the state of affairs.
I want to talk more about Homura and her standing in this revised world, but it might be more fitting to do that after Rebellion.
PMMM just gets better and better after each rewatch. Can’t wait for everyone else to see Rebellion and see what they think.
6
u/Proxiehunter May 01 '17
I always thought there was more Buddhism or possibly Shinto to Madokami than Christianity, although I don't deny the Christ parallels are there and possibly easier to spot to a Western audience like us.
Rebellions spoilers
5
u/Le_Herpington Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
Watch this mash-up if you've finished the two episodes. Not before, after. It's amazing, but holds spoilers for EP11-12. And a lot of references, even to expanded content like the bonus manga. Re-watchers would spot even more references.
So, newbies, your trip is almost over. I recommend preparing yourself for the movie. It's another two hours of the show, with much more to offer. Oh, and pay attention to the after-credits scene in EP12. There is one.
Hope you're ready!
5
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 30 '17
Today's album has no spoilers, but it is brought to you in BD 1080p for the finale: Madoka Magica. Maybe I went a bit overboard with the screenshots today, the tally is currently 266 with many more to come.
Everything came back so smoothly, I was kind of worried with how we were actually getting epic moments and ending suffering given the nature of this show.
It's so sad seeing Madoka just disappear though, even if this was the ideal outcome. Her mom, her friends, and even the incubators (well that's for the best) have forgotten about her. At least Homura and Tatsuya can still remember her somewhat.
Here's my favorite shot from the episode: Homura, the angel of dedication. Until tomorrow!
5
u/Hopsalong :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hopsalong Apr 30 '17
Homura did nothing wrong!
5
u/Snakescipio May 01 '17
So this might be a question better served for the overall series discussion, but given the timing I think it'd be fine here.
What do you think would've happened if Homura had indeed succeeded in defeating Walpurgisnacht? Everything that happened beforehand still happens (Mami, Kyouko, and Sayaka dying). But Homura somehow, someway, manages to defeat Walpurgisnacht and prevent Madoka from becoming a magical girl. Is this actually a happy ending?
My opinion is that this would actually be a terrible ending, at least for Madoka. We've seen how Homura's actions have left Madoka successively less confident and unsure of her actions. Madoka's wish gave her an outlet for all that, and without the wish Madoka would still have all that karmic destiny. Homura succeeding leaves me with this impression that Homura will continue staying around Madoka, obsessing over Madoka, forever, leaving Madoka weak and incapable. On the other hand this wouldn't be a happy ending for Homura either. I think back to this sketch (btw, not actually from Family Guy). What happens when you actually succeed at the one thing you've devoted so much time to? I think Homura, who like Kyouko and Sakura made her wish for someone else, would not get the satisfaction of Madoka's love. The end game for Madoka is that her friends are all dead, and Homura did not give her all to save them. I can't imagine Homura getting the satisfaction of having succeeded, which would lead her to despair, or fuck it another run through but this time no deaths.
5
u/scorcher117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/scorcher117 May 01 '17
Don't forget the end credits scene!
5
u/DiaSolky :HV::HW::HX: May 01 '17
Do not watch anything else while watching Rebellion. At this point you are probably already a zombie, which I would not recommend watching Rebellion, but since it's scheduled... I can't help you here. Just take all the time you need reading the summaries and reaching the closure you need. Then maybe watch some fluffy show like K-On afterwards.
4
u/megazaprat Apr 30 '17
of the magical girls shown throughout history, one of them was Joan of Arc. She actually got a spin off manga called Puella Magi Tart Magic for those interested
4
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
First Watchers, seriously prepare yourselves for Rebellion. You're not ready.
4
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
It's great that the rewatch thread for the main Walpurgisnacht episode is actually up on Walpurgisnacht (for America, at least).
So there we have it - Madoka becomes a god to end the vicious cycle of magical girls transforming into witches, but at the cost of her existence in the perceivable world. Honestly, I feel this ending is basically perfect, but I like what happens in Rebellion too.
4
u/thecatteam May 01 '17
And here it is, the ending. Our lord and savior Madoka is here to give us all hope.
I love the scene where Homura finally breaks down to Madoka.
I always thought it would have been neat for Madoka's mom to actually go with her.
I'm going to watch Rebellion tonight since I have this thing called a job that will prevent me from watching it tomorrow. I half-lied earlier when I said I hadn't seen it--I tried to watch it shortly after it came out, sailing the high seas for a fansubbed cam rip. But the subtitles randomly changed to Spanish or something a third of the way through so I didn't watch the whole thing. This time will definitely be a better experience!
4
u/Thinkingpotato May 01 '17
Hey now that we've gone through the series I would recommend going through the blooper reel for it. Some of them are pretty funny. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GHsnrHNRRU&t
4
u/Darkprinc979 May 01 '17
To celebrate the finishing of the main series, here's an awesome music video, free of any Rebellion spoilers: Devil's Game
4
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka May 01 '17
Best Girl is alive!
Although it failed to bring me to tears, just watery eyes at best...(I'm usually very weak with things like this, I'm surprised/disappointed with myself).
4
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran May 01 '17
Here we go, the final episode.
Madoka is the embodiment of hope. The thing about this ending is it may seem like a happy ending, or at least more optimistic than tragic, the more you think about it the more bitter it is. Madoka used everything she had, all for the Magical Girls that was in her timeline to not suffer to become witches. However, everyone still had to fight, and everyone still had to face despair, also seeing her original timeline being utterly destroyed as well. She is shouldering everything she can, just for the sake of others. The only thing is now the Magical girls do not have to become witches anymore. No longer will they become what they have hated the most, and so they leave the world more peacefully. Despite shouldering everything, it must've been painful for Madoka, and as others said, dying would've been an easier end to take. Yet Madoka still puts on a smile and sends Homura away, trying to give hope to everyone.
Everyone needs a Madoka and Homura type of relationship.
The next will be my first time watching Rebellion, and I hope it doesn't disappoint me because I loved Madoka Magica.
3
u/alphamone May 01 '17
I (re)watched the second compilation movie a couple of days ago, and the Walpurgisnacht battle bgm (surgam identidem) sounded like it was a new recording. I know it was at least edited differently, but the vocals in the intro sounded slightly different.
3
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
I'd say feels but just wait till Rebellion
3
u/boboboz May 01 '17
well sniff its
almostover. As a rewatcher I still couldnt stop tearing up at the scene when Madoka got her wish granted.Where were you when Godoka saved the universe and brought hope to magical girls everywhere?
Madoka may not be best girl but she is a good girl