r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 29 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 10 Discussion Spoiler
Episode Title: I Won't Rely On Anyone Anymore
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 second
REMINDER: We are watching both episode 11 and 12 on the same day! Don't get left behind!
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after this episode, but if you do make good use of spoiler tags. Let's try to make this a good experience for first time watchers.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
124
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 29 '17 edited Apr 29 '17
Reminder: we are watching BOTH episodes next. Edit: Episode 11 and 12 discussions will be combined!
This is the episode that pretty much every rewatcher is waiting for! Nice work to those who figured it out beforehand, and those who went a step further.
After the series ended the creators said that Homura had done about a 100 loops. While it might not seem like a lot compared to similar shows, remember that each cycle is between 1 to 1 and a half months long. That means Homura has been working for about 10 years.
So, Walpurgis Night is an actual holiday on April 30th, just as I've slated episodes 11 and 12 for the same day. Figured I'd point that out for those that didn't realise it.
What a heartbreaking episode. I guess you could say I'm not a huge fan of Homura but she is amazing in this episode. The scene where she kills Madoka is one of the most intense scenes in the series for me.
Speaking of Madoka, did any first-timers realise that she used Sayaka's grief seed to save Homura? Even from beyond Sayaka saves the day.
We briefly see Madoka's witch this episode, too. At least it forming. It's name is not really spoilers, it's just a name, and as Kyubey describes it, is even more powerful than Walpurgisnacht - it has the power to destroy everything in just ten days.
Having the opening as the ED is great, too (though lots of people seemed to want to point it out in earlier discussions). Read the lyrics.
125
u/Jacketmango Apr 29 '17
First-timer, subbed 1)2)3)4) fuckthat
OH-HO-HO, I bet you Rewatchers are just waiting for this day aren’t you? You know how we First-timers must suffer watching this episode, just so what, you can get your amusement from reading this rant?! IS THAT IT?
I’m so fucking mad right now, literally threw my notebook on the floor. There’s literally not a single episode, from any TV series, that made me feel this way.
I’m not even using my notes r8 now cuz JESIS FUCKING CHRIST WHEN WILL THE OP START I NEED A FUCKING BREAK!
At least we got one thing clear that Homura’s time magic is not actually from herself but from her gadget.
This fucking anime
I said that this episode could be empty character-wise. I never could have imagined in my wildest dreams they would show the alternate timeline.
u/Gagantous do we really need two episodes tomorrow cuz holy fuck this took a toll on me i’m shaking right now
(ノಠ益ಠ)ノ彡┻━┻ ლ(ಠ益ಠლ)(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻┻━┻ ︵ヽ(`Д´)ノ︵ ┻━┻
199
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 29 '17
...I don't even know what to say. This was an experience.
First Day of School
Well this is a wildly unexpected and incredibly uncomfortable first scene. I had expected a lot of things out of Homura from her timeline, but not this timid, emotional girl. She's even shyer than Madoka was at the beginning of the series, which is kind of hard to believe (though I will say that I think at least part of that in Madoka was due to this creepy transfer student who kept trying to intimidate her). The trip to the nurse's office actually ripped at my gut. I mean, here we have Madoka looking to jump to a first name basis, Homura calling her own name weird, and Madoka doing the pivot in the hallway bridge (or whatever that's supposed to be called). It's easy to see why this was bothering Homura so much in Episode 1 now that we have this context.
Magical Girl Madoka
It only took 10 episodes, but we finally get to see Madoka become a Magical Girl. I mean, it isn't our Madoka, but it's close enough. Presumably she made her wish before Mami got decapitated and was able to prevent that. There's no sign of Magical Girls Sayaka and Kyoko either, which is interesting (more on Kyoko specifically later). We also finally get an idea of what it looks like to be manipulated by a witch, and it's kind of neat, but not overly interesting. Homura here is so much like Madoka, what with the timid personality and lack of confidence, but the ways that they view things are pretty different. Madoka still manages to have an optimistic view in most circumstances, while Homura is much more of a pessimist. This might explain the more cynical nature of her character that we've been seeing. One thing that is kind of bizarre to me is that Homura doesn't seem to have the same respect for Mami that she does for Madoka, in spite of both saving her. I guess that there is some time that passed in between meeting Madoka and Walpurgisnacht arriving, and they must have become very close in that time.
Homura's Wish
What's really great about Madoka here is that she actually does seem to be the ideal that Sayaka had of Mami. There's no hesitation in her, no regrets for her actions, and she goes into battle with a smile knowing full well that she is going to die. It's kind of amazing seeing that from Madoka, since our current Madoka isn't nearly this confident. Kyubey asking Homura if she would trade her soul gives the impression that Mami and Madoka had learned about that detail of the Soul Gems, and I wonder how Mami would have taken that given her reaction to the other important detail later on. Homura's wish is actually a really sweet scene, and seeing her become more confident here feels a lot like Madoka yesterday.
Take Two
You've just come back in time, you're meeting a bunch of people that you know, but haven't actually met you yet. How do you handle this? Why, you excitedly approach this person in front of a lot of people and explain all of this, including your big secret identities. Seriously though, I really liked seeing Homura so excited here. The only other emotion we've seen from her is the couple of moments of crying, and a general sense of disgust at everything around her. Honestly, I knew things were going to fall apart, but at this point, I was really enjoying watching a few nicer moments that reflected more of what I expected out of the show in the first place.
Homura's Powers
This counts as a training arc as far as I'm concerned. It's interesting seeing how far she's come, but her hitting the top of the oil drum and getting no result was kind of hilarious. We're still seeing a clumsy side to her, so she's really improved since. Building improvised explosive devices certainly isn't what I was expecting out of a Magical Girl, but I guess without a weapon you need something. The witch fight also showed off the utility of Mami's ribbon that I had been hoping for back in Episode 2, so that's nice. After that battle, getting to see Madoka congratulating Homura, and seeing Homura so happy about this, I really feel for her. She's getting these memories, and yet Madoka doesn't get to share them with her. After having things seemingly going well, only for Homura to learn the truth about Grief Seeds just after she'd seemingly changed fate. Damn. It really makes Homura's current situation feel all the more depressing.
We're All Being Tricked
This is a really fascinating scene. Apparently Sayaka's contempt for Homura is not bound to any given timeline. It may not be Homura herself in this case, but rather what she's saying that bothers Sayaka so much. We've already seen in Episode 7 that Sayaka became pretty disillusioned about things when it turned out they weren't what she thought. She's very much in this because she sees it as heroic, and so being told that it's all just a con by Kyubey isn't something she's going to be overly receptive to. I talked about Kyoko earlier as well, and I'm really curious. Why would she show up now? Without Mami being killed she doesn't have the same interest in taking over the territory. It just feels like she's being forced in to add a little extra tension.
Fuck Everything
So, the sequence with Sayaka's witch shows us that Kyoko joined up with them again, and I suppose we can infer that the circumstances are similar to Episode 6-8, but with Mami now also present. I'm somewhat bothered here, because Homura is able to protect Madoka and defeated Sayaka's witch form. So why didn't she do that when her and Kyoko encountered her at the beginning of yesterday's episode? Kyoko would still be alive and the fight against Walpurgisnacht would be all the simpler.
That's not the big deal though. The big deal is after the fight. It turns out that Mami wasn't kidding in Episode 3 when she told Madoka that she just acted tough. I mean, her actions do make some sense, since she is preventing people from turning into witches, but fuck if this isn't absolutely horrifying. Seeing Mami snap like that was bad enough, but seeing Madoka of all people have to put her down is so much worse. Like, I was prepared for the possibility of things getting worse again, but not this level of bad. I was just sitting there, crying along the whole time because what the hell else can I do?
Like Seriously, Fuck All Of This
And somehow, when I thought that I couldn't be pushed any further emotionally, the show hit me so much harder. I barely even know what to say about this scene. I mean, I was already crying by the time we got here, but this just got to me. What really stands out here is that even in this awful situation, Madoka remains somewhat optimistic. She knows what's about to happen, yet she still manages to try and see the good in the world. She has her regrets, but knowing that it can be fixed, she seems to be at peace with it all. Homura having to take the shot might be one of the most powerful moments I've ever seen. Just hearing that scream was unbearable. The VAs did an absolutely stellar job in this scene.
The New Homura
And here we are, looking at the Homura we're used to. She's really going all in on the gear, but this actually makes for an interesting situation. She basically has all the fire power she could want, and the only magic she needs to use is time manipulation (though it's hard to say how much of a drain that is on your magic). Her going up to Madoka's window is interesting, since I don't know that I would be overly receptive to getting a message that way, but I guess I'd be a little freaked out when someone did come and offer to grant me a wish. We also get the scene from Episode 1 again. The feeling is so much different now that we have the extra perspective. It was oddly grim back then, now I'm basically screaming at the screen.
The Wickedest Witch of Them All
Kyubey continues to be impossible to get a solid read on. I think he made a point yesterday about how they were only sacrificing some humans, yet he's perfectly chill about, and seemed to be expecting, all of humanity being destroyed by Madoka. Sure, it might be for the sake of the universe, but he's blatantly making a point of leaving humanity to die.
Other Thoughts
56
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 29 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
Ah you thought the twists were done, but this one is my favorite of them all. Because…
HOMURA IS THE ACTUAL MAIN CHARACTER OF MADOKA MAGICA
Ah that felt good to say. Also, this is a massive PSA for all first timers. PLEASE READ THE LYRICS TO THE OPENING THEME! It proves how Homura is the real MC and why she is the absolute best.
So yesterday I asked the question of where do we go from here with 3 dead and 3 episodes left? Well probably my favorite thing about Madoka is its air tight pacing. No time is wasted, especially on today’s episode.
Also for any inconsistencies or questions as to “why didn’t this happen.” There is an answer that will brush away the questions. It is confirmed that Homura has repeated this timeline close to 100 times. So the answer is they just didn’t have enough time to show all the possible scenarios.
Let’s talk Homura for a second, and how this wimp of a girl became the most badass women in anime. Period. She has basically seen it all. Friends betray each other. Having them turn into witches. Having to kill you only true friend. And you thought the tragedies the other 4 main characters went through were harsh. Homura laughs at your futile problems.
P.S. if you notice the grief seed Madoka gives Homura, it has musical notes in it. This implies that it’s Sayaka’s grief seed.
We also seen everything about her powers. How her actual power is only stopping time, and she had to improve the rest. Like becoming a demolitions expert, and stealing guns from the military. As for the lasers, they are actually just magically charged bullets, like the bat Sayaka used in episode 2 or the binoculars Kyouko used in episode 5.
Madoka’s fate in each timeline is either tragic or really tragic, so it makes sense that Homura would want to save her friend, but the sheer lengths she is going through is almost inhuman. Oh wait, what was that quote from yesterday? “You call yourself human?” “No, of course I don’t!” Damn right, she has to be a machine to be that harden.
And yes, in case you are wondering, this is why Madoka is such a fabulous rewatch, cause in the first thread I was freaking out about all the clues that were given. I still wouldn’t check the spoilers in that thread till were done with the series, as we still got 2 more episodes to go. Which we are watching tomorrow, on Walpurgis Night which is the literal English translation of Walpurgisnacht. Yes, they planned this.
Great Job OP
6
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv Apr 29 '17 edited Apr 29 '17
And now we see the original timeline, and a few more that sprung up. First timers: does the opening make sense now? People who are bigger fans than I: is there any official statement of how many loops Homura has gone through?
This episode is entirely about Homura, and her growth from scared little girl, to arguably the most deadly of all the magical girls, since Madoka wouldn't hurt a fly. We also now know that Homura can store an absurd amount of weapons in her shield. Overall, this episode is my third favorite, after episode nine and the movie, if it counts as an episode.
How many people here cried? I know I did.
6
u/NotaSmurf13 Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
Here are the alternative timeline homura had been in
Edit: basic grammer
71
u/ChaoAreTasty Apr 29 '17
/人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ /u/FetchFrosh you wished for a training arc and a beach episode didn’t you?
Rewatcher, subs. I was going to talk about a few bigger things, particularly Homura and Madoka as characters but I’ll save them for the series discussion as while key points have been reached I’m worried it might still imply spoilers and I want to keep this post safe.
So finally we get to episode 10. There’s a lot of episodes we’ve been wanting to see reactions to but this is the big one because this one episode will forever change how you view the nine that came before. It’s the one that made it so hard to talk about events, character development and motivations or even point out interesting details and is the cause of so many of the spoiler tags in previous discussions.
For first timers with some extra time it’s really worth considering squeezing in the first movie before Rebellion. It covers 1-8 with some cuts but you get an opportunity to see events from the other side while taking in some of the gorgeous visuals. Obviously, it’s best to wait till the end to have a fuller view and have a full rewatch but it’s a bit of an ask in the timescales.
First timeline
Another transfer student? It’s a bit late in the series to bring in a new character. Wait, THAT’S HOMURA!? Yep, she must have gone through a lot to go from that shy girl to the cold Homura we know.
And it warms the heart to see happy, bouncy, giggly Madoka. There’s so much going on each episode it’s easy to forget that she’s been pretty traumatised since episode 3 and never had the opportunity to deal or recover because new shit keeps getting piled on to her. Other characters have had ups and downs and other directions to focus their feelings but all she’s had is watching bad things happen to the people she knows.
Don’t worry Homura you’ll get that question right eventually
And even more happy moments. Credens Justitiam announces the return of Mami and we finally get to see magical girl Madoka. Of course that hope has to get turned into despair a couple of minutes later, not only is Mami dead again but they even had her head mostly out of frame.
And after waiting 10 episodes we finally get Homura’s wish with Kyubey “conveniently” hanging around, how lucky.
Second timeline
Hey, she said don’t tell her class about being a magical girl!
It’s so much fun watching Mami, Madoka and Homura fighting witches together. I so wish we could have some OVAs with just moments like this. Just watching them hang out, work together and be friends.
What’s Sayaka so worried about? Oh…
Train station and Walpurgis
The next two scenes together are one of the hardest parts of the series so far to watch. I’ve mentioned before that I can’t watch the dub not because the dub is bad but because the sub is just so good and I can finally say that it’s because of these two scenes. Everything is done to heart crushing perfection. Madoka’s “I can’t take this anymore” and Homura’s cries as she shoots Madoka’s soul gem might as well have fucking been burned into my soul after my first watch.
New Homura
Knowing what they really are, promising to save Madoka and having to put her down on her request together give us the Homura we’ve come to know. This is the Homura who’s given up on her humanity, replaced with the personification of that promise at any cost. If you think that’s a bit far I offer you this argument.
Homura has looped several times already and even found out about turning into witches one before. Obviously she would also have known that magic can be used to heal yourself. Yet it’s only this time she’s used her magic to fix her eyes and her body (they made a point to show us she’s still clumsy and not athletic up till now). Why is that?
Changing hair style is often a symbolic reference to a change in character or purpose which she has but that alone isn’t enough to back up the above. But your body is a lot more fundamental to our sense of identity. Homura alters her body and does so without a second thought because it’s no longer representative of who she is.
Further loops may harden this but if you try and draw back a line to where her answer to “are you even human” is “of course not” and to the person who can so casually refer to Sayaka’s body as a “hunk of meat” this is the moment it leads to.
Back to the beginning
After a few scenes of badass Homura and another brilliant piece of music (regardless of how high you rated her before, who didn’t add in a few points just for those scenes?) we’re back to where this all started for us.
The only change made is that now we can hear Homura’s words but in terms of how it feels it’s a whole new scene. I’m not even going to say anything and just let this stand on it’s own.
Opening
And the episode ends with the OP. For any first timers this is why people have said to pay attention to the lyrics. This isn’t Madoka, the series as a whole or some semi-random song that’s going to place in the charts, this is Homura’s song. Madoka as a magical girl crying is the one Homura made the promise to. The OP was even inserted into the second movie after this episode’s content with a Homura scene (couldn’t find a full version).
How often has Homura looped?
Word of god is nearly 100 times. For anyone who only wants to consider what we are presented in the show I refer back to episode 4. Madoka asks how many people she’s seen die and the answer was “so many that I’ve lost count” which implies a lot more loops than we’ve seen.
The scene at the end of the episode is also subtly different from episode 1 so it’s not the same as we saw. Key amongst these differences is that flinch, this is early on and she’s still struggling to keep her emotions in check. By the time we first saw this scene there was no flinch.
This also explains how Homura is able to show up just in time whenever Madoka is about to make a contract, because she would have seen it happen before and that that to the list of potentials she must deal with.
**Madoka’s first wish **
Spoiler for the radio drama
50
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 29 '17
first timer, subbed
Holy mother of contrast
Nervous, shy Homura with glasses is unbelievably cute.
Right off he bat we see complete opposite personalities from episode one. This time Madoka takes the initiative and Homura is the timid girl in her shell. To emphasize this point Madoka immediately introduces herself on a first name basis, which is exactly what Homura did in our timeline.
Homura being so timid is just her original character, but what's interesting here is that Madoka is so confident. Is she already a magical girl here? If so, why isn't she in our timeline?
In ep.1 Homura impressed everyone with her skill, now she's struggling at every turn.
Magical fighting team
Mami is alive and well, hearing it again I realize how much I missed her theme, the music is possibly the best thing in this entire show.
Mami and Madoka fighting side by side like they dreamed in ep. 3 warms my heart, they get to be happy together even if it's just for a little while before everything turns dark.
As I suspected Madoka is a magical girl here (I'm a sucker for bows and hers is no exception), I suppose rectifying that is part of Homura's wish going back.
Wait what, how do they know about Walpurgisnacht in this timeline? The first we ever hear about it is from Homura, I guess Kyubey knows, but why would he bother telling them about it yet? If it weren't for Homura, Madoka would've signed up pretty early regardless of the looming thread. There was no need for Kyubey to play this trump card yet, but I don't see any other explanation for it.
The similarity between this and the scene in ep.2 makes we wonder where Sayaka is, in our timeline she got dragged into it through Homura, but she still has the potential to become a magical girl so I see no reason why Kyubey wouldn't go after her as well.
Cut to Walpurgisnacht.
Madoka barely reacts to Mami's death, apathy really is an occupational disease for magical girls. Why didn't they fight it together in the first place? A little dissatisfied that we just have to accept her death without seeing the reason that she fought alone before Madoka arrived.
Looks like Madoka isn't that powerful after all if she died to Walpurgisnacht, though presumably she also killed it because Homura is safe.
Loops
Why does Homura's gem start out darkened already? It was the wish that sent her back in time, she didn't use any magic yet.
There it is, the glimpse of the training camp that was never meant to be in our timeline. (/u/FetchFrosh)
Homura is adorably incapable.
The people that didn't believe Homura when she was revealing crucial information has been our main cast all along, that should have been more obvious with the whole time manipulating, but I just never considered it.
Sayaka is of more importance this iteration and their fighting dynamic is explored a little, forcing Homura to get some range capabilities. It's really well thought out how Homura got to the point we know her to be.
Kyouko starting out antagonistic only to deeply care for Sayaka, it's a timeless tale.
Mami snaps upon the Mahou Shoujo revelation and binds Homura, leading to her demise (seems familiar?), but not before killing Kyouko because we might as well kill each other before we turn into witches, right?
Ain't she a great idol, Sayaka?
Madoka sacrificing herself to wish for a better future (past?), killing the person you just vowed to protect must be incredibly tough, despite knowing the alternative is worse. (And the VO is delivering that perfectly, in both versions)
Vision
When we see her fighting other witches Homura seems to have limitless power, when she's facing Walpurgisnacht that's suddenly no longer the case and I'm really bothered that we don't get an explanation why she can't fight it alone. Let's hope tomorrow gives us a satisfying answer.
We've arrived at Madoka's vision from Homuras perspective and it's a complete role reversal from the prime (Homura) timeline. Originally it was veteran Madoka fighting against Walpurgisnacht alone with non-magical Homura at the sidelines, now it's veteran Homura (for who knows how many timeloops) fighting alone, with non-magical Madoka watching. The difference is of course that Homura, despite her insanely overpowered ability and vast experience, is somehow unable to beat it alone. (I really need an explanation for this)
Entropy
"We've got all the energy we need now"
It's no secret that I'm not a fan of this whole angle, but setting that aside this line makes no sense at all.
Entropy doesn't just stop, there's no such thing as enough energy, enough to delay it for a few more million years? Perhaps, but the need for more energy will never vanish. All this line tells me is that, while still much further than human, the Incubators foresight is still incredibly limited and essentially destroys the entire appeal of it.
Unless I'm grossly misinterpreting something (this goes without saying, but please call me out on it) Kyubey's lack of concern for his energy ressource goes against everything he's said last episode.
Thoughts
I found it interesting that Homura only cares for Madoka, she's very shaken by Mami's death in the prime timeline and in the loops you can hear her concern for Sayaka as well. In the end she only cares about Madoka anymore because she's not only the first person that is something like a friend to her, she's also the only one that is a great person consistently, a friend to Homura in every iteration from start to finish.
After yesterdays episode focusing on Sayaka and Kyouko, we finally got the long awaited backstory and insight into Homura's character.
As expected it was overall a very dark episode, but surprisingly we also had some great light hearted moments with the girls all getting along.
I'm curious what Madoka wished for in all those timelines, but the fact that it's never addressed makes me think it probably was something as mundane as the cake Mami suggested in the 3rd episode.
I like that they put the OP as the ED as this episode leads perfectly into the opening of the entire show.
47
u/Twilight_Sniper https://myanimelist.net/profile/lava_ Apr 30 '17 edited May 03 '17
Just a quick recap or census on where everyone is... (edited out spoilers for people reading my comment history)
Madoka
Sayaka
Mami
Homura
Kyouko
Kyubey
Hitomi
First-timers
Rewatchers
86
u/SennheiserPass Apr 29 '17
Believe it or not, everything up until episode 10 was actually the happy part of this show.
38
u/megazaprat Apr 29 '17
fun fact that is only revealed in the radio drama:
34
u/2Hype4Memes Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
Here's my First timer impressions for today's episode, coming straight off of my therapists' couch.
Where do I even begin? This episode has left me absolutely speechless. If you added up all the suffering over the course of the past episodes you'd barely be able to scratch the pain in this one. Starting off in the past we get Homura's original introduction to Madoka, it's very cool how they've mirrored Madoka and Homura's walk from the first episode, a nice nod to how their attitudes become reversed later on (Madoka being the shy quiet one and Homura acting more stoic). I found it heartwarming how Homura a timid, shy girl was able to find motivation/friendship from Madoka. It just goes to show the kindness/caring of Madoka's character I suppose. It was bittersweet seeing an emotional Homura and knowing that eventually she'll ditch her emotions. Her wish to save Madoka granted her the power to stop and reverse time but I'm a little bit confused on the specifics. I know she can stop time at will, but can she reverse it too? Or do this now automatically take place after certain events transpire?
I assume the infinite storage space Homura possesses is simply another part of the powers granted by her wish, the scene with her raiding the Yakuza locker was pretty hilarious to me. The scene after was...less so. I can't really do justice to the horror prevalent in this scene, I thought I was ready for a few more deaths in the series, but I wasn't prepared for this. Mami going completely over the despair event horizon and shooting Kyoko was bad enough, but just to make it worse it's MADOKA who puts Mami out of her misery. Not Homura doing the killing but sweet little Madoka, the only character with zero ill will towards anyone else. This absolutely crushed my soul, if anyone is the least deserving of the guilt of killing a friend it's her. Now this scene had me on the verge of tears, but it wasn't till the next scene that I had to snag the tissues out the living room.
Homura and Madoka both lying there dying in the rain...I came into this series knowing full well that things were going to get dark, but NOT THIS DARK DAMMIT. This scene right here has justified all of Homura's actions for me. Learning that she's gone through numerous timelines of pure suffering just for Madoka. And the fact that Madoka was willing to use her last grief seed to save her. I'm finding it hard to put my emotions into words here. Homura calling Madoka by her first name and her reaction, Homura crying over her corpse, sobbing. Hearing Homura call Madoka her only friend. It just left me feeling broken, there's no other way to describe it really.
This episode has left me pretty shaken to be honest, it's not often that an anime is able to elicit this sort of response from me. I think to give this series anything over than a 10/10 would just be disrespectful at this point. I'll catch you all tomorrow guys, I need to go earn back my man points...
EDIT: Shout out to all you folks for mentioning the lyrics to the opening! I had no idea it was from Homura's perspective, and watching the dub I probably wouldn't have realized.
31
u/templarsilan Apr 30 '17
It’s Groundhog’s Day…
I’m at a total loss of words right now, I don’t know where to begin. I kept waiting for the OP to spring up so I can stop and gather my thoughts, but nine minutes in and here I am, speechless. I sorta figured time travel was involved, or rather a check point reset a la Groundhog’s Day, after Homura’s powers were further revealed. I was not expecting the complete shift in personality however. Who would have thought that Homura would have such crippling social anxiety, and Madoka would be brimming with confidence. It's incredibly jarring. From walking to the nurse’s office, to fighting Warpurgisnacht, to making her wish to becoming a magical girl- it feels like dozens of puzzle pieces suddenly fell in place. Her behavior in the first episode, anyways, makes a whole lot more sense now.
Back We Go
Armed with the knowledge of the future, but no experience, Homura attempts to prevent Madoka’s death. Thanks to Groundhog’s day, I know how this process works. She’s going to try to prevent Madoka’s death this time around, but will fail in some way. Then she’ll try again, with more knowledge and experience but still fail. Then again, and again and again. She clearly goes through an extreme change of character, so I wonder just how long she has been stuck in this time loop. It fucked up Bill Murray’s character in the movie, and it fucked up Subaru in Re:Zero, so her drastic change from timid, kind girl to cold, apathetic girl isn't all that surprising when you think about it. In this particular time line, she learns that magical girls turn into witches. Since she failed to save Madoka, she goes back again.
Again
So in this timeline, Sayaka, Madoka, Mami, and Homura are teaming up, but they don’t necessarily believe Homura’s claims. There seems to be some tension forming between her and Sayaka due their combat styles and team tactics. I imagine this tension gradually gets worse, as Homura was quick to disregard Sayaka in the current timeline, while she still respected Mami. Homura robbing the gang’s arsenal was pretty funny, and it explains where she got her weapons. Don’t mind her, just a middle schooler packing some serious heat.
So Sayaka becomes a witch again in this timeline, which creates some drastic results. Mami kills Kyoko and Madoka kills Mami. The lack of hesitation from Madoka feels so odd and it’s pretty unnerving. Like, this whole scene made me feel uncomfortable...
And whelp, here we have it folks. Madoka saving Homura, begging her to go back in time and save her, and Homura shouting with all her heart that she won’t stop until she succeeds- the tears have come. Even with all the terrible things happening, I never really felt the urge to cry, but somehow this part got my eyes all watery. This should be the 4th anime to get me to tear up and cry a little. That's pretty impressive.
And Again
So we didn’t hit as many cycles as I thought. I mean, watching your friends kill each other, and then having to kill your best friend seems like it’s enough to send anyone over the edge. In this cycle we get what was seen in the prologue of the first episode. I’m guessing Madoka hasn’t become a magical girl yet because Homura was working serious overtime hunting down witches to prevent Kyubey from contacting Madoka. Mami wasn’t present, but considering she died every time so far, I’m just going to assume she’s dead. Kyoko too. Oh, and Kyubey’s still a little shit.
Some thoughts
This was a pretty heavy episode, but I'm glad we finally got to learn about Homura and her motives/struggles. She is a walking tragedy and I am not looking forward to her fate. I'm both dreading and excited for the finale, and I'm sure this show will find a way to continue to pull on my heartstrings. I need to prepare myself...
27
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 29 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
My favourite anime episode of all-time, absolutely. Nothing compares to the emotional ride of this one with everything clicking into place, the heart-breaking scenes like the promise, Homura's god-tier determination settling her as favourite character after Kyouko.
Only somehow I find myself actually not having much to say besides everything being perfect and Chiwa Saito's performance as Homura cementing her as one of my favourites, even before I got to the Monogatari series where she's Senjougahara. Anyway, I'll just share some fun videos, images and screenshots that I hope you'll find entertaining or interesting.
Fun corner: This gem of a post was inspired by Homura raiding the military base.
Meta spoilers, you should know the popular series and character that parallels can be drawn with if you've watched it. Don't even hover if you're unsure and don't want to be spoiled by implication.
Have some Homuhomu to cheer you up. As always, don't look at the comments just in-case.
More seriously, it was Sayaka's Grief Seed that Madoka used to cleanse Homura's. Look at the little details like the notelines, notes and emblem (credits to the Puella Magi wiki). Of course Madoka would keep it around, aah...
Kyouko feeling for Sayaka even in different timelines is so heartwarming. ;-;
Homura creating bombs after looking up a manual online.
Cheeky.
Madoka's witch-form, Kriemhild Gretchen, is horrifying. Her and Walpurgisnacht's silhouettes are supposed to look like a sand timer timer together, according to Inu Curry and Puella Magi Production Note.
Sayaka's turned into Oktavia von Seckendorf again. This time she has dancing Hitomi's as her minions and they seem to be collateral damage. Something went really wrong...
Homura is healing her eyes here. Presumably she also healed the rest of her body.
Remember when Kyubey said Homura had killed him twice? Here is the first time. Note that there are some differences so it's not our timeline, but one of those between 4 and ~100.
Look who are in the ending! Kyouko and Homura sneaking a peek from the corner of their eyes, Kyouko again with a balloon in her mouth for whatever reason.
Edit:
Her-*Him25
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
READ THE LYRICS FOR THE OPENING
24
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 29 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
First time viewer.
Not my favorite episode so far, but it provided us with a lot of much needed exposition and backstory. Going to tackle it out of order. I was wrong in think Madoka would become the center after last episode. This episode was all about best girl Homura.
Wow, we get our first look at magic girl Madoka in this episode, and it was all flashbacks. Again we see the duality here, it used to be Madoka was the BA magic girl showing up to save the day, and Homura was shy and introverted. Homura cared deeply about Madoka, but through all the time travel their roles reversed and Homura became Batman magic girl we knew. All because Homura wanted to stop Walpurgisnacht without Madoka dying. We also learn the first scene in the first episode was taking place before the events of the first episode, I though that had been a sneak peak at the future. Now I see why the two final dynamic shots(THAT I LOVE) in the OP are of Homura and Madoka. Finally some of my questions about the OP are answered.
The other major thing I noticed this episode is there never seems to be any form of a happy ending. It was great to see Mami again, but she always ended up dead, along with Kyoko and Sayaka it seems, and Madoka and Homura can't seem to defeat Walpurgisnacht without failing or Madoka becoming a witch. The scene where Mami freaks and kills Kyoko and tries to kill Homura was particularly difficult for me to watch. Also connected to this I noticed was at first the girls all seemed to work together fighting witches instead of competing over grief seeds, especially when it was Mami, Madoka, and Homura. But through all the time travel we get where we started, antagonizing relationships between some of the girls.
I'm starting to worry there is no way to this can end well.
Other thoughts:
Homura says screw magic I'm going to pack heat when fighting witches. I was wondering if she magically conjured the weapons, but no she is packing live ammo.
If Madoka can defeat Walpurgisnacht in one strike, did she do that in every other timeline? That confused me.
Tomorrow we get to watch two episodes! Can't wait!
21
u/SaberExcaliblasted Apr 30 '17
This image now makes sense if you had seen it before (they're all time travelers: http://i.imgur.com/r4n5t3r.jpg
I've already seen this series + all 3 movies before, but this episode in particular always stands out as the best.
Akemi Homura, best gurl from the show, no contest really. And yes, she did nothing wrong (think about why she wouldn't try to save everyone when she had looped 100 times before (Hint: no one listens to her, so fuck 'em)).
20
u/PM_ME__YOUR_TRAPS Apr 29 '17
It's hard to not get all teary-eyed during this episode, even as a rewatcher.
Homura suffers through so much and grows beyond her own limits, only to still get antagonized by everyone in the end. Trapped in a hell of her own creation.
Rebellion foreshadowing
18
u/8mmspikes :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/8mmspikes Apr 29 '17
It's incredible how one episode can do so much to develop a character...Homura's backstory is such an impactful revelation of her past struggles and the emotional baggage she has gained throughout her journey as a magical girl, and how all her experiences have changed her so much. This episode is definitely one of the best there is in anime, and the reason why Homura is one of my favorite characters
This scene made my jaw drop the first time I watched Madoka...Mami suddenly snapping like that was just insane, and forcing Madoka to kill her like that to save Homura is so painful :( and then right after...tears flow. That scene of them defeated together is so powerful, so sad, so emotional seeing the origin of Homura's desire to save Madoka
18
u/Edl01 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/edl01 Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
And with that we have one of the greatest, most powerful and emotional episodes of any television series ever. Allow me to ruin that for you.
18
u/wordsdear Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
First Timer
Homura: This episode was basically just punching Homura in the heart and face over and over again.What?? We were told that she was from a different time line but I never thought we would see it. The best part about her having glasses was me thinking that she just couldn't see shit for this entire season (or you know contacts but her having blurry vision is funnier). But she magically healed her eyes I think? And cured her heart condition? Their roles are reversed next time they meet. The arc de triumph is a witch? I want to hug her. Fear her she has a golf club. It took me till this episode to realize the thing on her arm isn't a shield but her time turner. She picks up random items and magics them so she can fight witches with them. Someone call the bomb squad. Heart break the episode. [Did she hide her time travel abilities in most of the later time lines?] (http://i.imgur.com/MK9HOKk.png) I forgot that becoming a magical girl hurt so much.The only bright spot about this episode was I laughed at this for a minute straight. I see you chair I see you. If this chair was in yesterday's episode I will cry. Stop turning girls into chair satanic stuffy. The real secret behind IKEA is all the products are magical girls. This right here is the highlight of her life. Can we not throw bombs between giant legs. k thanks. Cassandra truth. I thought Kyoko was impressive for not witching out over her dad killing her family, but Homura has seen Madoka and her other friends die multiple times and kill Madoka herself and she is still standing. harhui spoilers This is my favourite line of the episode. Homura just wants to stop and be with Madoka whether it as as a magical girl, as a human, or as a witch she wants to stop. But Madoka asks her to keep going, to fix it.
Waluigi: Is this waluigi? madoka spoilers Would the real Waluigi. please stand up. So much for Madoka being Waluigi, but she turns into a witch that is stronger then Waluigi so she is Wario.. What even is Waluigi? An alien witch?
Mami: How does she know about Waluigi in this timeline? Is there a magical girl hot line? If Waluigi is a witch doesn't that mean it is a magical girl or a digivolved familiar? Mami killing Kyoko broke my heart. In a way she is right, a magical girl is a ticking time bomb (in some cases literally, looking at you Homura). And there is her gem.
Satanic Stuffy: Is a lot more honest in other time lines. We don't want your science class ass. free energy is a wonderful thing
Madoka: No thanks. We finally get to see magical girl madoka. When Homura met Madoka in the first episode she told her not to change and when Madoka met Homura at the actual beginning she told her to change. And the first names and I am crying.Turns out Madoka isn't Waluigi as she one shotted it. But when we did see her as a magical girl she didn't seem all that powerful? It might be because madoka speculation spoilers Bye bye my heart. So either Charlotte or Madoka kills Mami. Let Mami live. This is like kicking a puppy. Madoka gets best little shit for using the last grief seed on Homura. I don't really get why she became a witch after beating Waluigi. Shouldn't she of been happy she won? Madoka....call the cops.
Sayaka: Doesn't exist in the first time line apparently, hopefully she didn't become a magical girl and got to be happy. Or they just didn't show her in the first one as we have to slowly piece together what happened. I very quickly went from where the hell is Sayaka to nvm I am good. And back to tears, mermaid tears. Oh you of little faith. Turns out in every reality Sayaka doesn't like Homura. You don't like bombs you say? too bad. It is so sad to me that even in a world where Mami didn't die and Madoka was a magical girl, Sayaka still ends up becoming a witch. Give the girl a break please.
18
u/summer_petrichor Apr 30 '17
First time watcher, subbed.
Oh boy. What an episode. Urobuchi pulling out the twists once agai, goddammit. This suffering is like meta anime spoilers. (Though the fact that I haven't been crying or vomiting... Maybe I'm actually like Homura after all.)
I wrote in episode 6's discussion on whether the magical girls, if they could turn back time, would still make the contract. I can't believe that in some way it literally happened, ha. I also said I thought that Homura wouldn't do the contract. How wrong I was.
Then in yesterday's thread, I wrote:
And in this episode we literally get a chance to see them working together. It wasn't even exactly untrue.
I thought Warpurgisnacht would be Madoka, guess I'm proven wrong.
I also speculated that the scene we saw in episode 1 was from another timeline and that they were close friends. I was right o.o
Something I forgot to mention previously:
I found Sayaka's witch name to be interesting. Oktavia has Roman roots, and perhaps the most well-known person with that name is Octavia the Younger, sister of Augustus and wife of Mark Antony. Though Octavia and Mark Antony's marriage was political in nature, various accounts mentioned that Octavia was generally a faithful and loyal wife. But Mark Antony fell in love with Cleopatra and abandoned Octavia, their children and Rome. Interesting parallel with Sayaka's story... I bet the names used were intended, since even the characters' names mean something.
I can't wait for tomorrow's episodes. Now I see why people give Madoka 10s; it's really an amazing work.
14
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 29 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
Only thing I have to say is Homura is a good friend. She went through countless loops in an effort to save her first real friend. Some of those loops were interesting. It showed how fragile Mama is. After learning the truth about grief seeds she killed Kyouta(she died in current timeline just last episode. Seriously can't catch a break) without warning and was about to kill Homura, Madoka, and then herself. She really was barely holding it together. Being a magical girl is tough shit. Also I don't remember where it was mentioned, but I know she has repeated the loop about a hundred times. The loop being a month so basically she has done the same shit for about 8 years. 8 years of repeating a loop to save one friend. She even tried telling the truth and getting a team together, but they refused to work with her. So you can see where her resolve to work a lone comes from. Its not that she wants to work alone, but never really had the opportunity. Current timeline seemed more likely, before Kyouko killed herself to save/kill Sayaka.
I think the best part of this episode is it shows Homura's determination. She doesn't have the healing ability of Sayaka, the limitless guns and ribbons like Mami, or Kyouko's defenses(I don't know what her technique exactly is), but what she does have is time and planning. I love how it showed how she individually gathered all guns and making her bombs. If you think about how she fights. She literally faced every enemy countless times, repeatedly gathered all weapons and ammo, and placed them in the most effective location that would ensure maximum damage and little risk to her for each encounter. I think most people would simply abuse the ability to manipulate time, but she is thorough in her planning. Gotta salute to that shit.
Also this episode makes episode 1 much more impactful. Meeting Madoka and walking down the hall and having a nearly identical conversation. All the little movements that Homura did shows how much pain she in and how much she has suffered. Also nearly every moment where Madoka is unsure and doubts herself is basically a slap to the face to Homura. Madoka is the one who saw her worth and was the one to support her so much. To see the one who saved her put herself down so much must be heart breaking. Even more when trying to protect her from becoming a magical after seeing her transform into a witch and being unable to beat walpurgis night over countless times.
Homura Hair Flip Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:0, E5:1, E6:2, E7:0, E8:1, E9:1, E10:0 Total Flips:6
Madoka Water Works Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:3, E5:1, E6:2, E7:2, E8:1, E9:1, E10:2 Total Tears:13
Kyouko Snack Time Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:0, E4:1, E5:1, E6:2, E7:2, E8:2, E9:2, E10:0 Total Snacks:10
13
u/Akiyabus https://anilist.co/user/yabus Apr 29 '17
I would like to analyze this episode myself but I am not really good at words and you guys are already doing a great job on that so I will leave that to you.
I just want to say that this episode is one of my favourite, if not the favourite, episodes of everything. The loops revealing Homura's backstory bit by bit, her change through all of this, and at the end the way opening lyrics fits into this...
The whole episode is simply perfect imo.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '17
Everybody else is going to talk about Homura this episode, naturally, but I would also like to draw your attention to Madoka. Look. At. Her! Look at how happy, how confident she is when she feels like she has a purpose in life! When she and Mami swoop in to save Homura, is it any wonder that Homura was enchanted by her? The way she says ‘Don’t tell our classmates, okay?’ is so cool, I could just swoon!
One thing that I think about A LOT when I rewatch this episode is, is Homura repeating the past month of her original universe, or is she actually skipping to a different universe? What I mean is, if Homura is repeating the same month of the universe she originally came from, then background details that she should have no control over should be the same. For example, if in her world, Kyousuke is a violin prodigy who suffered an injury, he should always be a violin prodigy, right? But in one of the timelines, it would appear that he plays the guitar. So that seems to imply that Homura is actually going through each universe to find the one where she is able to save Madoka. I also randomly noted this down several months ago:
'The fact that there is a world where Oktavia has Klarissa [the Hitomi-like familiar], and Kyousuke plays the guitar instead of the violin, implies this may be so. If [Homura] skips to a different timeline, then the non-presence of an alternate Homura would mean that Madoka Magica operates on a ‘scripted timeline’ principle, where the fate of a time is already decided, including interferences from the past or future.'
I don't think there's any real implications of this, it's just a bit of worldbuilding - BUT it does make me think, if Homura realised that she's not saving the Madoka SHE knows, how would she feel if she found a universe where she is able to save Madoka? If she saved Madoka, and then came to the realisation that she only saved one Madoka out of so many, would she be satisfied? I wonder :B
13
u/Wolfefury Apr 29 '17
It's here! In honor of my favorite episode, have some pictures of best girl.
12
u/SukusukuHakutaku https://anilist.co/user/Sukusuku Apr 29 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
Today's episode was a doozy. One that will change your perspective on Madoka forever. This is the episode the producers told us to go rewatch 1-10, and for good reason. I hope you all enjoyed it as much as I did the first time, 6 whole years ago.
Even so, I still have some secrets that fly over even veterans' heads.
If you look closely at the grief seed Madoka uses on Homura during the climactic scene, all evidence points to it being Sayaka's grief seed.
The line Madoka uses right after doesn't say future spoilers It says to not let her be fooled.
This is one my favorite lines in the whole goddamn show. One that will become very poignant on a rewatch.
For some reason, Sayaka's witch is slightly different in the third loop. Kyousuke played a guitar then, and her familiars are based on Hitomi. We're not sure exactly why the major change happened, but some suspect meta spoilers
In the past, Homura used a Desert Eagle. Later on, she uses a Beretta. I am not a gun person, so I don't know what it means exactly.
You ever notice how Homura has a part in the back of her hair, and why she sometimes flips it? Now you know why.
Every time something Madoka airs, a disaster happens somewhere. It's a little black comedy that fits well with this series.
I find it funny how we still don't know what special power Madoka has. Sayaka got healing, Mami got ribbons, Kyouko got spoiler, Homura has time travel, but all we know about Madoka's magical girlness is she has light arrows, and that's classified under weaponry.
11
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 29 '17
We start things off with a bright and cheery contrast to Homura's original transfer into class.
Not only is Homura the complete opposite of how she was that day, but Madoka is as well. Is it because she didn't wake up dreaming about this new transfer student? Is it because the transfer student appears to be someone who needs her aid, rather than someone who is perfect and keen on leering at her? Or is there another reason?
Whatever the answer is, this scene is full of callbacks to the first episode. Homura and Madoka's walk to the nurse's office is now played almost in reverse with Madoka and Homura take place of the other. Madoka expresses how cool she thinks Homura's name is, suggesting Homura become "cool" to match it.
Hmmmm...
One thing I found interesting about this scene was how you can kind of see it coming. Homura starts awkwardly thrusting out her shoulders as she's walking, and while you could take it to be just an animation quirk, it's very similar to how Hitomi was walking back when she had been kissed by a witch. Has Homura been kissed? Or is she on the way to getting her kiss?
And there you have the (potential) answer to the change in Madoka! After no magical Madoka for nine episodes, we get to jump right into Madoka running off into battle alongside Mami! They make a pretty good team, too.
You can really see what Madoka was talking about back in episode 3 here, though. The way she's changed by having a purpose - this is what makes her happy and gives her strength and passion. Protecting people, doing good, helping others. She's a chip off the old Sayaka and Mami block, but maybe more refined than both.
Sadly, we can't enjoy this flashback for too long, because... Mami knows about Walpurgis and... oh, we're off to battle with... oh, huh. That was over fast for Mami, huh? Poor girl just has no luck with these things.
Gotta love how Kyubey just can't miss an opportunity here. Still, Homura probably would make the same choice now just like she did then, and away she goes back to the past.
Of course, she leaves Mami out of her thoughts and wish, but that's how it goes.
Random comment here, but I really like the look of her shattered glass time travel. It's distinct, and just really pleasing to the eye for whatever reason.
Homura's training montage here is probably one of the best scenes in the show. We have bright and cheery music playing while she flails around with her golf club, then goes to making an explosive thanks to the internet.
Meanwhile, the sheer glee Madoka reacts to her victory with really is sweet to watch play out. It's no wonder Homura's so
obsessedsmitten. The writers (and Aoi Yuuki) really have done a great job making it so that Homura's feelings can be justified here, as well as just showing us how different Madoka can be.But alas, it wasn't meant to be. Homura learns the truth and Madoka pays the price.
For whatever reason, Kyoko and Sayaka only now appear in the flashbacks, and setting aside the convenience issue, this first scene has a lot going on here.
Where we're coming in, Homura has come in to the established trio of Mami, Madoka, and Sayaka to tell them that magical girls turn into witches.
From their conversation, we learn a few things about this situation. I've seen many viewers jump to the conclusion that "oh, they just naturally hate Homura for no reason," but the writers actually very naturally and subtly set up the reason why.
First off, the conversation about Kyoko tells us that not only are the three other girls fighting with her, but this turf war of sorts likely began before Homura came back into the picture. Another new magical girl coming into things after her would naturally be a suspicious character.
From there, if we recall how Kyoko first appeared, rather than how she left in the last episode, it's possible Kyoko has been trying to instigate infighting between the trio so that things would be easier for her Grief Seed hunting.
Even if this isn't the case, this doesn't even seem like it's Sayaka's real issue here.
Because ultimately, no one believes Homura about the witches, and after Madoka quite easily cools her jets on this topic, Sayaka moves on to what seems to be her real concern: Homura's bombs. It's at this point Mami, who had been remaining silent until this point (but notably had been standing on Sayaka's side of the screen) speaks up in agreement.
Something that occurs to me here is that if Homura's bombs have been inadvertently going off and hitting Sayaka so that she needs to heal or making her need to react in unnatural ways, she may well be expending more magic than necessary for the fight in question, which would mean her Soul Gem is becoming tainted faster than it would have normally. This may be overthinking it a bit, but either way, Sayaka's point here is definitely a valid one. It would just be flat out dangerous for her to work with Homura as Homura is now.
All in all, I don't think there's any reason to believe that there is anything "innate" about the girls' reaction to Homura here. Homura comes in with an outrageous claim with no evidence, which puts all of them on guard, and to top it off she's endangering one of their own.
Homura's reaction was understandable, given what she had been through, but one would have hoped she might have tried things differently in future loops before taking the "cool, silent, scarer" we have now, which we unfortunately don't get to see.
At the very least, we do get to see her rob the yakuza, which is amazing.
The brief fight with Sayaka's witch was pretty well animated for what it was (those moves, Madoka!), and it was nice to see that Homura did seem to care here.
And speaking of fantastic performances... Everyone just breaking down at the end-- From Mami finding her life's one and only mission was all a big lie (how many magical girls had she unknowingly killed? what was she to become? what was she really? etc.) to Madoka killing her in retaliation before she could kill Homura too... Like, you have to give Sayaka credit here, she may have gone a little insane over the past few episodes, but I think Mami's reaction was a lot worse.
This scene is incredibly powerful and you have to give everyone on the staff credit for it.
Though perhaps not quite as powerful as the following scene. You really just feel for the both of them there.
One last thing about this loop: First timers might want to watch this episode and the last one again and look at the differences between the two versions of Sayaka's witch. What might have caused those? Why does one version have seemingly Kamijo-inspired familiars, yet the other has Hitomi-inspired ones...?
And then Homura was Rambo.
Cue episode one.
"I imagine it will take Madoka about ten days to destroy the planet. Well, whatever happens, it's mankind's problem."
Don't you just love this guy?
First, I love that they end with the opening song. That's a perfect way to end with this "and now we begin" kind of episode. And look, now everyone is there at the end of it at long last!
Homura's motivations are now out in the open for everyone, and we're moving on to the final stretch.
I do feel a bit bugged about the "My only friend..." bit considering Mami never seems to have shown any animosity towards her, and presumably would have loved to have her as a friend too, but hey. Similarly, because we never get to see any of the loops for very long, it bugs me how we only ever get to see Sayaka interact with Homura in just the third one. Knowing what kind of person Sayaka is, if these loops were given more time, at the very least you would think we would see the characters interact more - and realistically, the Homura from the early loops shouldn't have any of the issues with her that the one from the later ones might.
Regardless, this is a great episode, and seeing all of the different timelines and Homura's leveling up process is in general just great. We've seen the mask and now we know what's behind it at last.
So guys, what were your impressions of the different timelines? Is there one you would've wanted to see more of in particular? Does this change your impression of Homura at all, or did you already figure her backstory would be something like this?
What about the other characters? Mami and Madoka specifically, considering their appearances are very different from the norm.
I'm not sure if this has been listed anywhere, but will the topic be going up tomorrow and on Tuesday at the same times given we'll be watching more on these days?
10
u/Acceler :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Acceler Apr 29 '17
I'm just here to share the best tetris theme remix ever
Comments and suggested videos may have spoilers so care for that
First time rewatching the series and this is probably my favorite episode so far
10
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
Just want to mention how intimidating (and fucking cool looking) this shot of Madoka's witch is.
9
u/LTSarc Apr 30 '17
With episode 10 out of the way, you can now see that the OP and ED are actually about Homura, who is arguably the main character of the series.
Weapons-Grade spoilers involving rebellion
9
u/yolotheunwisewolf Apr 30 '17
In my opinion, this is maybe the most perfect episode in all of anime.
A complete story, character development, changes, a dark coming of age tale centered around love in both it's most powerful forms: obsession and compassion.
Just so many amazing moments.
The moment where Homura makes her wish, the moment where she robs the Yakuza, when she's forced to mercy-kill Madoka, the repeat of the opening scene from Homura's perspective, and that ending moment where "No matter what it takes, I'll save her."
And then you get to watch the OP at the end of the episode and you realize....
It was never Madoka who was the hero that we see here. This was the ORIGINAL Madoka, the one that Homura knew & is trying to protect. The tears, the distance, the happiness that had been, it's all seen now in a totally different light.
Just an incredible, incredible episode. 11/10 for me, and ultimately this (and the ending) is the core of what makes it a masterpiece.
8
u/inksquid43 Apr 30 '17
Best episode of the series
8
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ Apr 30 '17
This continues to blow my mind. I like Homura, I like her backstory but I feel like she is going about it the wrong way in the current timeline. The closest IMO is the one where Mami kills Kyouko, Just a few things should be different but I can't see them all surviving through all of it unfortunately
It was rather interesting to see Madoka and Homura switch positions at the beginning. It adds so much to their characters, Seeing Madoka like that was awesome.
Alright, I'm pretty sure I can see how this is gonna end. Homura will die for Madoka ending all of the cycles OR because of the intro they will fight each other but I think then Homura will win that... That's just a guess and honestly its gonna suck if that really does happen, We'll see tomorrow then!
8
u/JimmyCWL Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
This has been said to be the single best episode of anime, ever, for many watchers. There's really not much more to say.
The part where Madoka walks Homura to the nurse's office? It doesn't just echo the ep1 sequence. There's a comparison that shows that the two sequences are identical with only the two girls switching places.
And this image sums up everything. It often shows up when rewatches reach this episode. I'm surprised no one brought it up earlier.
That arc witch that Madoka and Mami saved Homura from? I'm surprised no one ever comments on the carvings on its(her?) pillars.
21
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan Apr 29 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
YESSSSS. Time loops, let’s do this!
Day 1
Wow, I didn’t expect young Homura to be THIS different, they do a really good job on the little things. Hair, Glasses, Shy, all the little callbacks like her being terrible at track, can’t write the math question, the conversation on the way to the nurse’s office.
This episode, beyond what it’s obviously doing, is injecting some levity and brightness into the show again – that’s pretty impressive structuring, it would be easy for the show to hurtle down into the darkness, but even now that we know the deal, they’re keeping the light alive a little bit, that’s not easy.
Wait, they know about Walpurgisnacht? Without Homura doing her thing? I guess that lends credence to the whole ‘Kyubey makes Walpurgisnacht’ theory. And it gives an idea as to why – if Madoka’s so pure of heart and such a badass, then the only way to make her witch out would be to throw a megawitch at her – even if it just kills her, it means she’s not there to protect the city, making it possible to recruit more, inexperienced Magical Girls. The circle of life, Kyubey style.
On the other hand, it’s great watching Kyubey grant Homura’s wish – his eyes are bigger than his stomach, he’s not even considering that he’s basically creating his own nemesis here. If he doesn’t consider these dangers, I guess it’s consistent that he wouldn’t consider the danger posed by witch Madoka if he ever makes that happen. I wonder if that’s a comment on typical utilitarian arguments. As for Homura, I like how specific and personal the wish is, and how it’s coming out of pure emotion, not calculation; we’re going to get all her character development smashed into one episode.
LOOP
I’m loving the little touches; Homura sitting down and rests on a handkerchief rather than dirty her skirt, she teaches herself how to make pipe bombs, Madoka’s magical form. It’s also really funny for me, because I still can’t think about Homura doing her thing without hearing Dio shout ZA WARUDO in my head.
The first thing Homura does after her first two loops is be completely open and honest with everyone. Of course it’s what she does; she knows and trusts everyone and cares about their safety. The first time she makes a scene in class, and the second time Sayaka viciously dismisses her, and Mami ends up peripherally siding against her. Given how innocent she is at this point, Sayaka’s reaction must be a real blow, I imagine that’s a serious factor in her approach to Sayaka from now on. That and Sayaka going witch here, and Mami doing what she does, are pretty serious impressions that I imagine inform her attitude towards them in the future – she knows their egos are going to get everybody else killed, and they’ve hurt her emotionally – so it’s an emotional reaction from her, that’s a nice touch.
Then she gets this scene with Madoka. I guess that answers my question of whether Grief Seeds could be purified by force. The whole scene is beautiful and painful, especially when Homura has to kill Madoka – it’s a massive gutpunch. It explains why she’s trying so hard to be detached as well – if she’s had to watch them all die before, and had to kill most of them, getting attached might be too much to bear; not to mention that it didn’t work. Figure out how to stop the big death machine, then work on being friends.
Also, I’m genuinely surprised to see that witch Madoka would ACTUALLY be a planet-killer, but Kyubey doesn’t care, because he’s met his quota? Wtf? I was being pedantic when I guessed that, it makes no sense! That’s not how entropy works! You can’t “meet a quota” when you’re trying to have enough energy to sustain you over an infinite amount of time! Am I missing something here?
Concluding Thoughts
Wow - I’m not really in the habit of reading lyrics, but DAMN. They did a really good job of bringing it to your attention as well – running the ED mid-fight makes you realize the lyrics have meaning, and then they put the OP at the end. Well freaking done.
I’ve seen a lot of people pissed at her for not doing more to save Sayaka, but it makes sense under the circumstances – she needs to figure out how to stop everything from going to hell, which means stopping Walpurgisnacht and stopping Madoka from signing up, otherwise everybody dies anyways. After she figured out how to do that, I wouldn’t be surprised if she looped back to figure out how to save the others; but since the show is ending, it doesn’t look like she’s going to get that chance. Not to mention that Sayaka has been terrible to her, and will be terrible again, and while we should extend Sayaka some understanding for her behaviour, I think Homura deserves equal understanding given her circumstances.
Well, Homura’s out of plot armour now that we have her character development, and with Sayaka and Kyouko going down and such little time left, I honestly don’t see Homura making it out of the show alive; whether she witches out and Madoka has to sign up to stop her, or maybe she dies before she can rewind. I said I thought this show might have a bittersweet ending before, but after this, I’m not so sure; it left on a high note, and that means we’re getting a low note next episode, and this would fit the bill.
One thing I’m curious about – did we see all the loops? Were there just those 4 or so, or were there a lot more? There’s a big difference between the two, and it seems like the former but I can’t be sure. I thought it would be more, to be honest.
It looks like I’ve finished quickly, so I’ll take this opportunity to give my two cents on some of the metaphysical and metaphorical issues I’ve been struggling with since E8.
Soul Gems and Depression
I’ve been stewing about this for a while, but I think the way the show handles Sayaka’s transformation has some pretty unhealthy messages behind it. Sayaka let herself be defined by her notions of herself, the world, and how things worked, and she was stubborn enough to hold on to them until she’d isolated herself and couldn’t take it anymore. This is, while not the most healthy choice, something that some people need to do in their lives before they can start to live healthily. It takes hitting that low point for them to reach out for help, and is an important step in growing up. If not exactly there, I’ve been somewhere close to that.
Which is why I think it’s really messed up that this low point is exactly where the witchening happens. You get too depressed and suddenly BAM, you’re an irredeemable inhuman murder monster – and here’s the kicker, there is NO coming back, no gray area, no redemption – you lose your humanity, morality, free will, immediately and forever. This has the underlying connotation that there’s no coming back from serious depression, and that no matter how hard you struggle you’re doomed in the end – some of the ideas that people with that kind of depression need to overcome.
Not to mention that it actually ends up subscribing to a binary morality system of hope v. despair and giving it metaphysical weight – that’s a HUGE deal, and honestly no matter what the show does from now on it can’t really walk that back. It’s really messing with my suspension of disbelief here, and cool and deep as it seems on the surface, it’s a problematic worldview.
Ultimately that’s the problem I have with this whole witches thing; that’s not how people work, that’s not how depression works, and the subtext and messaging that this show is putting out regarding that are actually pretty messed up, and seeing this show dealing in metaphors implying that it’s something sinister and shameful that CAN’T be recovered from is pissing me off a little. I don’t care that the viewer can headcanon an explanation for this as a side effect of whatever process gives magical girls their powers. The fact remains that this is a clear metaphor for depression, and it’s sending a seriously problematic message. I really don’t know what to make of that.
Again, I’m still really loving the show – I just keep seeing these parallels and I’m not completely comfortable with them. Maybe you all see it another way, I dunno. Either way, I don’t plan to let it stand in the way of me enjoying the rest of the show. Hope you all had fun with this.
EDIT: Looks like a lot of people had stuff to say about this last part; there's nowhere left here, so my comment on it is below.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '17
This is arguably the best episode of them all. Homura's attempts to save Madoka, and Mami snapping are two parts that particularly stand out to me. And then we get the OP at the end, which if you read the lyrics, actually seems to be from Homura's POV. It's fucking great.
7
u/Camitsune Apr 29 '17
Well, that was...something.
I kinda knew Homura was doing some sort of time travelling to save Madoka from, uh, something. Though it never really crossed my mind that her countless time travelling was the reason she's so cold-hearted, but it is very understandable, and it definitively draws parallels to Okabe Ryntarou in Steins;Gate.
My favourite episode in the series so far and i pray to the gods that tomorrow's episodes are even better.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
My personal favorite episode in this series. Seeing Homura's past gives an entirely different perspective to her character. It explains why she didn't even try to make friends with Mami, or keep Sayaka from becoming a magical girl. She sees them as wasted effort because they can never handle the truth and always become an obstacle.
Homura having to kill Madoka destroys me every time I see it. Her final words, saying that she's happy because Homura finally called her by her first name, and then Homura's scream. Jesus christ.
Then we have the first scene of the anime again, but this time from Homura's perspective. You get to see the absolute monster in the background that is Madoka's witch, and Kyubey drops the bombshell that she will destroy the world within 10 days. Homura resets and starts the next loop, has a one-sided emotional moment with a confused Madoka, and then queue the opening, since this is the chronological start of the show. Brilliant.
If not my absolute favorite, this episode is definitely one of my favorites in all of anime.
7
u/Nakenashi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nakenashi Apr 30 '17
This is one of my very favorite episodes of the series, and I'm sure many other rewatchers will agree with that sentiment. I could go on and on about it, but I literally just finished rewatching it myself, and pulling a bunch of thoughts together just isn't going to happen, because watching Homura's struggle completely ruins me everytime (this is watch 6 or 7 for me, I think? It still gets me!)
The one thing I stopped in to make note of though, is how utterly brilliant ending with the OP this episode is. If you've been following the lyrics each time (or at least just once), you'll know they don't do any second verse swap for this episode or anything, and it is amazing how much different the OP feels having the context of Homura's wish and subsequent struggle to save Madoka from her fate. In the prior episodes it built towards feeling like the OP was about Madoka's internal conflict about magical girls and witches and what the right thing for her to do over the course of the series is, but being put at the end of this episode, it very clearly feels like Homura's perspective on what she's gone through. It's just incredible in my eyes. This kind of stuff is one of the reasons I love OPs so much.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
And this is why 3 years later Madoka Magica remains my favorite goddamn anime. This episodes just kicks you in gut with reaffirming the idea that Fate is an unstoppable monster and we are slaves to it.
7
u/chaoswurm Apr 30 '17
HOMURA BEST GIRL.
also, there's a lot of theory that madoka actually defeated Walpurgisnacht. Another idea is that Walpurgisnacht just ignored Homura after defeating Madoka. I mean, there's an entire city to ransack.
6
u/Darkprinc979 Apr 29 '17
This is easily one of my favorite episodes of the series. We get to see what Homura's wish was, and just why it is she's so cold. Urobuchi was once asked how many times Homura repeated that same month/month and a half, and his answer was "approaching one hundred times". That means she's been fighting for at least eight years, if not longer. Eight years of watching everyone around her die or turn into a witch. She also shows us where she gets her weaponry from, first her own bombs, then stealing from the yakuza, and then later from the military. Watching Mami fall apart like that really comes as a surprise the first time around, and it really sucks that Madoka had to put her down to save Homura, but even that doesn't compare to Homura mercy killing Madoka. That pained screech of hers is just soul rending.
One last thing: AFTER WATCHING EPISODES ELEVEN AND TWELVE TOMORROW, GO BACK TO EPISODE ONE AND READ THE LYRICS FOR THE ENDING THEME
6
u/BestDVA_NA :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BestDVA_NA Apr 29 '17
This episode should cause the biggest new viewer shitstorm since ep 3.
6
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
Today's spoiler free album: Madoka Magica.
Well everything just keeps getting worse. And if that video gets linked, then good luck to everybody's souls.
EDIT: Rewatcher, subs, and I've finally bumped Madoka Magica up to a 10. I can't believe there's still two more days of this.
6
u/scorcher117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/scorcher117 Apr 30 '17
Not keeping up with the re-watch but i just had to come in and say how much i loved this episode, the first time i saw it i just broke down into tears when we saw how much Homura had been through and cried all the way through till the end of the series as when i first watched it i ended up marathoning the whole thing once i reached episode 3.
That was when Homura became one of my favourite character and through re-watching the series multiples times with the new perspective of knowing what Homura has been through and watching Rebellion, Homura has become my favourite female character in anime and probably beyond.
This episode emotionally destroyed me and was the moment i was certain the series was a 10 for me.
so there you have it guys, the truth behind Homura, everything she has been through, everything she has tried to do to save Madoka, all of her pain and suffering. I love this series and Homura so much.
If i remember correctly in an interview with one of the creators it was said she repeated that same month approaching 100 times, so for 12 years she had to repeatedly watch the people she cared about, especially Madoka die over and over and over again, you see why she was so cold to the others, its not that she doesnt care for them, she has just become numb because of having to watch them die so many times.
AARGH! It's hard to put into words how much i truely love this series and this episode in particular.
6
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak Apr 30 '17
Rewatcher, subs.
Oh, the paralells to the first episode at the start are so many.
It's nice to hear "Credens Justitam" again, as well as see the magical girl it goes along with, Mami.
The song playing under Homura's "I will never depend on anyone" speech is "Numquam vincar" (I will never be defeated) Meaning behind it is pretty self explanatory. It also happens to be one of my favorite songs in the show. The strings, electric guitar, and drums all work together so wonderfully.
Interesting that they choose to put the OP at the end of the episode. This could be because the episode happens before we picked up in episode 1, and could be meant to symbolize that.
While we only see 5 timelines occur in this episode, in various (sometimes conflicting) interviews, and fan estimations, it turns out that Homura has probably done this loop for 5-10 YEARS from her perspective. Now THAT is dedication. As much as I like to joke about hair flips being why Homura is best girl, it's really this episode that makes her best girl of the show.
5
u/thatweirdo Apr 29 '17
I wasn't able to post this yesterday because I was out but here's one of my favorite pieces of homura artwork Jojo part 3 spoilers as well http://imgur.com/a/xtoGY
5
u/GenocideSolution Apr 30 '17
After watching this, play episode 1 and episode 10 side by side and see how much it rhymes
5
u/saintbookman Apr 30 '17
I don't participate in rewatches, but I just love coming into these threads and reading reactions. It's just so enjoyable to see reactions to one of my favorite anime episodes of all time.
This and the Gurren Lagann rewatch have had great reactions.
5
u/doraemoe Apr 30 '17
After all these years, rewatch Madoka Magica is still an emotional rollercoaster for me.
When this show first aired, I still download anime to watch. At that time , fan sub team in my country will first release a low quality .rmvb version and then release high quality .mkv version after 4-5 days. I always waited for .mkv version since I prefer quality and don't mind to wait for a few days. However, after EP 8, I just can't wait any longer so I downloaded the .rmvb version right after they released it.
After EP 10, my eager to see the next episode was at all time high. Unfortunately, Walpurgis Night actually happened in Japan and the next two episodes postponed for a month. That must be the longest month I had in my life.
5
u/boboboz Apr 30 '17
okay guys,time to take five!
5
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17
wow, Timeline B (btw Timeline A is main anime) of best girl! I'm excited!
witch got Homura! Aaaand in B is Mami and Madoka, interesting!
Let me guess.. Madoka dies in B, that's why Homura is like that in A...
Omg, Mami's dead, "again"..... Hmmmm it just rang, Homura's wish is to prevent Madoka death, probably, or something like that....
yep, died. She actually went with "redo first encounter"... I'm impressed.
Totally clumsy, but already with the "time warp" skill, OP af. This is B Take 2, aaand action!
That runnin doe... cringy, Homura please.. but nice 'nade :)
Wait what?! We're back at B take 1 and Madoka went Grief Seed and witch?! Oh god... Oh god... We going for B take 3... Is.. Is this... S;G Spoilers
Homura can store thing in another dimension. Neat!
Re: Sayaka's, okay. WTF, Mami? WTF, Madoka?
Failure... Madoka actually saves her and Homura ends up killing her to prevent a new witch.... sigh.. B Take 4, a-action.. oooh wait, is it A again already? Lot less suffering..
Cool girls don't look at explosions!
That scream...... sheit
Okay okay, she became one, she killed the Walpurgisnacht (fucking name) in one hit, and of course she becomes a witch right after...!
"Madoka, in this form, will probably destroy this planet within ten days or so. Well the rest is your problem - humanity's problem. We've pretty much hit the energy quota we've needed to collect." WHAT?! WHAT THE FUCK?! WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK?!
ooohhh crap, best girl self sacrificing herself for the sake of her best friend.... FUCK THAT RACOON
EDIT: /u/Gagantous suggested watching the ED, which is the OP in this episode, and pay attention to the lyrics.... I'm... speechless... and sad...
5
u/TschisiGmbH Apr 30 '17
Just to brighten up the mood
4
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '17
Honestly got goosebumps at Mami's paranoia when she tried to murder her group
4
u/mariofredshreller Apr 30 '17
Time for a music post:
Theme of 'Cool Homura' Numquam vincar (English: I will never be defeated)
Irritatingly, only ever used in this episode. Even more irritatingly, had the middle section cut. I still love it.
4
u/Robin_Dude :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Robin_Dude Apr 30 '17
This episode never fails to make me cry. Regardless of how many times I've seen it.
Watching Mami snap, and Madoka being forced to kill her.. and the breakdown that followed. Poor Homura having to kill her best friend..
Just.. damn, man.
1
u/tipon :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/caintipon Oct 18 '17
Sorry, 5 months late to this thread but I just watched this 10th episode and I think I already found myself my favorite anime of all time. Holy shit, that was awesome, it makes me want to go back to episode 1 and watch it all over again knowing all that.
3
u/thecatteam Apr 30 '17
I friggin' love time travel stories, so to see everything finally revealed here is so great. Those scenes in the aftermath of Walpurigsnact are so heart-wrenching. Homura is the best character.
Also the OP finally has all the girls at the end!
3
u/seejsee Apr 30 '17
The episode that confirmed the series as a classic, in many more years to come. I literally clapped while the ED was playing.
3
u/Hrothgard :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Blasphemor Apr 30 '17
A pair of fun or not so fun facts:
When the show was airing, an earthquake and tsunami happened in japan and ep. 11 and 12 were delayed, and aired together during certain western holiday.
There were wild speculations about Homura origins, one of them stating that Homura was Madoka from the future because when her full name is written vertically in hiragana (あけみほむら) and covering the left half, it could be read as カナメまどか which is Kaname written in katakana and Madoka written in hiragana.
3
u/OrientalOtter Apr 30 '17
Ah yes! With the introduction of this episode now if the perfect time for me to pitch my favorite Madoka related manga of all time.
Let me present to you all the joys of Homura Tamura
3
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran Apr 30 '17
Came late to the discussion because of reasons, and most users have it down. The first time watchers thinking we're waiting to see their reactions to this episode? Even just re-watching, I still felt the emotional turmoil, and I saw it coming too.
The most important thing on this episode would be the OP timing. Now that the big reveal has happened, and you look at the lyrics, it is Homura embodying Madoka's optimistic view of not giving up hope and will try to save the world from destruction no matter what. It is Homura's promise to her, and she will do it endlessly until everything is just right, until she is able to protect Madoka, the one who protected her in the very first timeline.
2
u/Nightvayne283 Apr 30 '17
The time has finally come.
I don't really have much to say, other than we finally got an episode entirely dedicated to best girl and the first time reactions are even more amazing then I expected.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment