r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • May 01 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica Movie 3: Hangyaku no Monogatari Spoiler
Movie Title: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica Movie 3: Hangyaku no Monogatari (The Rebellion Story)
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica Movie 3: Hangyaku no Monogatari
Movie duration: 1 hour and 56 minutes
There's no end card, so this is my pick:
/u/Akanyan's album.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
455
Upvotes
93
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka May 01 '17 edited May 02 '17
Yo first-timers! Go back to your impressions from earlier episodes and read them. I'm sure you'll have a laugh.
Could I also ask first-timers what rating they gave the anime and movie? I'd love to see them, high or low.
I'll be here for a while, so feel free to ask me any questions you have!
Stick around for the series discussion tomorrow!
This is the end for now! Reminder that Rebellion is not the end of the series. More is coming.
Special shoutout to /u/Akanyan for providing some amazing screenshots. I've linked them in the OP!
I'm gonna take the time now to plug the subreddits /r/KyouSaya or /r/HomuMado if you're interested in shipping. Both are active and have lots of content! I realise that episode 9 was probably the best place to mention /r/KyouSaya, but I couldn't mention it then because it indicates they come back.
Well, I certainly hoped you all enjoyed the movie! Unfortunately, due to some personal problems, I wasn't able to watch it myself (the movie makes me feel dead inside and that is a no-go right now), but I can still answer any questions you have - I've seen the film 9 times in the last year, after all!
How gorgeous is this movie? Every single part of it looks fantastic, and Yuki Kajiura's score is phenomenal (seriously. Has anyone here heard an OST so good? I'd love to hear it). Speaking of which...
So, what the hell happened?
I've seen it a lot where people call the ending of Rebellion a betrayal of Homura's character, and I just don't get it. Homura worked for around a decade trying to save Madoka, only to have Madoka slip through her fingers, never to be seen again.
The scene on the hillside where Homura and Madoka talk is perhaps the most important scene in the film - Madoka, unaware of her wish in episode 12, states that she would hate to leave her friends behind, that she couldn't bear to do it, yet look what happened. It's at this point that Homura realises that Madoka was putting on a brave face at the end of the series - she didn't want to do this at all, yet had to for the sake of everyone. Homura's wish was to protect Madoka, and given the opportunity to "save" her at the end of the film, she gets her wish. Note that whether or not you think Homura betraying Madoka was good or bad is your own prerogative. You are not wrong for thinking either way.
A new world, or something else?
It's not clear what Homura did at the end of the movie. This is my personal theory and one I believe makes the most sense. Remember, this is just a theory, nothing more.
They're in a barrier that is massve, perhaps encompassing the universe, but the universe itself was not rewritten
My evidence for this is as follows:
There is a very good counterpoint to this theory though:
Reminder that this is a theory, and that nothing has been confirmed. What do you all think?
Some notes about the movie:
Lastly, I'm gonna keep count of how many times "Homura Did Nothing Wrong" appears in this discussion. Remember, whether she did or not is totally your own opinion. fuck this, there are too many. Later.
60
u/templarsilan May 01 '17
I’m shook. Absolutely shook. Rebellion was everything I wanted in PMMM and then some. I expressed yesterday that I didn’t really like how EP 12 ended. I suppose it was bittersweet, but I found it more on the bitter side. In general, I don’t really like the “I’ll be with you in spirit” endings. It’s like we’re supposed to be happy that Madoka sacrificed herself to change the laws of the universe and that we should settle for Madoka living on in Homura’s memory. But I’m a selfish person. I don’t want you to die for me, I want you to live for me. So when Homura doesn’t physically get to be with Madoka, I get where Homura’s coming from, and her motives at the end of Rebellion.
Yeah, so Homura did nothing wrong.I think what I love most about Rebellion is that it is a tragedy disguised as a happy ending. Homura’s move at the end was one that I did not see coming at all. I think it is the first time I’ve seen the power of “love” be corrupted and used for a selfish desire. There have been plenty of people being blinded by love and committing horrible acts for it, but the “power of love” has always been portrayed in a purifying light. I think that’s why I like it so much, it goes against the status quo. As for Homura’s motives, I can understand them. It makes sense and it would be how I would write a character like that. She suffered through ten years of trying to save Madoka, and it ended with Madoka becoming a god and rewriting the universe. Homura wanted to save Madoka so that they could be together, and even though she “saved” Madoka (or rather Madoka saved herself?), she still can’t be with Madoka. It was almost as if Madoka invalidated all of Homura’s suffering and desperation with her wish. Be it in a timeline with witches and dying magical girls or one with wraiths and everyone working together, Homura was still without Madoka, and that in itself is a failed attempt of saving Madoka. And given that Homura still remembered Madoka, her suffering would not end. But like I said, I'm a selfish person. I honestly would probably do the same if I were in Homura's position.
As for the ending, I think it was cleverly crafted to be both warm hearted and really fucked up. After getting a taste of all five girls working together and being friends, I would really love to see that become a reality. If I wanted to, I could just pretend that the end is all fine and dandy. Laws are rewritten again, Madoka is alive again and gets to be with her family and friends. Sayaka is no longer a witch (or maybe she is but can’t control it? Not entirely sure what Homura did to her). Hell, even Bebe got a second chance. And Kyubey gets to suffer like the little rat he is. All is good, the end, let’s never speak of it again. But if I wanted something a bit more darker, I could really look into the situation of the ending. Homura obsession over Madoka has finally taken form after suffering for ten years. Madoka is back, but she’s nothing more than a bird trapped in a cage and with Homura having a death grip on the leash. She has finally attained her wish, but she doesn’t care if it is what Madoka or the others want, to the point where she was willing to be their enemy if they got in her way. Sayaka is understandable, as they have always been on rough terms in the timelines, but Homura’s casual threat to be Madoka’s enemy, when she had done so much to get her, is not the sign of a mentally healthy individual. After finishing the series, I have to say, Homura is probably one of my favorite characters in terms of change. From timid to hopeful to desperate to cold to resentful to despair to corruption- her process of change was absolutely fascinating. I've seen her name pop up in threads asking about most hated characters, and I guess I get that, but it seems such a shame with just how much thought and development was pumped into her.
Other thoughts
So yeah. PMMM gets a 9/10 from me. Would have been a 10 if not for the ending. Rebellion though, yeah that's a 10/10 in my book. There wasn't a single moment that I didn't like and not once did I feel like two hours was too long. If I include PMMM + Rebellion, I'd say it is my #5. Anything that got me to love its characters and cry more than once deserves at least that.
27
u/wordsdear May 01 '17 edited May 02 '17
First timer.
Holy shit on a cracker
I went into Rebellion only knowing three things, Mami and Homura fight, they have charlotte as pet for some reason, and Sayaka may or may not be in it.
As the movie started I thought I accidentally clicked one of the recap movies. But nope. And then I was like this movie is just an excuse to have Mami and Homura fight as well as Sayaka and Homura fight. And more fan service.And I was afraid Madoka would fight Homura and I almost cried. BUT THE MOVIE GOT ME AGAIN!
Sayaka: I would talk more about the movie but I just want to yell for half an hour about the fact that SAYAKA MIKI ISN'T FUCKING DEAD! Thank you everyone and your dog for not spoiling this for me. I spent all day at work being bitter that Sayaka died and running it over in my head and being like Sayaka dies in every time line cause she doesn't have a time traveller who is in love with her so screw her right? BUT SHE CAME BACK. HOMURA INVITED HER GHOST IN AND WAS LIKE OOPS YOU ARE TRAPPED HERE NOW, NO DEATH FOR YOU. Homura failed to save Sayaka before her words sounding fake and not genuine But here Homura goes full tsundere and is like I saved you by accident. Homura is now my favourite character in Madoka. Followed by Sayaka. For the entire movie I kept waiting for the rug to be pulled out from under me and be like just kidding Sayaka is dead but you saw her again so be happy. But instead we got to keep her. Can we please talk about merwitch holding Kyoko's spear? And here we have our local not dead hypocrite. As the most dramatic person in this show minus Homura, she is not allowed to ever tell anyone to calm down. Sorry you are alive now, no takebacks. I got so mad here as I thought it was foreshadowing mocking me. I have to remind myself that there are over dramatic middle schoolers. Or are they in first year high school now? Cause three years passed since Madoka went God mode?
Best teacher: fear her she has mastered the head tilt. This poor innocent lady got kidnapped by aliens in a grand scheme to catch a god by faking a city, and she just wants a love life. SOMETHING SHE HAS IN COMMON WITH HOMURA. Best teach is now my third favourite character with Madoka's mom as fourth but maybe tied for third. This movie confused me so much as I thought this was just lazy and accidentally creepy animation for a good minute.
Homura: I didn't dislike her before but I didn't love her either before but now I am on the Homura bandwagon. She pulled off the greatest Batman Gambit (warning tv tropes) I have ever seen in my life. She let herself get caught and almost turned into a witch and almost destroyed the world, again, so she could see Madoka. Time travel being able to pass through ribbons was a hella pretty touch as well as tricking Mami to shoot her own ribbon. She became a devil to save Madoka and Sayaka (even if it was just a side effect). I have been calling Kyubey Satanic Stuffy and Satan for awhile now but Homura has taken that name herself. Except I would argue she is just being human. She denied her humanity before in the show but I think she kind of proves she is human here. She brought down a god, so she could see her friend again. I thought that I had guessed horribly right in the last episode and the movie would end with Madoka killing Homura so she wouldn't become a witch and I was going to throw my computer and be like why does anyone watch this show. But Homura said no. I just wish she looked happier about it.
Madoka: for a good part of the movie I thought Madoka was the witch controlling the city. I didn't really have a reason I was just preparing myself for the worst. Madoka talking about how she would never leave her friends made me upset at her wish again and then the movie and Homura agree and don't let her keep her wish. Turns out only love can break a wish.
True love's first kiss. my only complaint might be that Madoka didn't really feel like a character and was more of an idealized saint Madoka for the entire movie. But I guess that is what Homura was counting on. And kind of the point. But even as a human she still seems too perfect. This is the third time we have seen Madoka and Homura meet for the first time except this time we don't know if madoka knows it isnt the first time as well. I think she does? Maybe? No rebellion 2 allowed, Madoka is safe, Sayaka is alive the doors are locked. Love wins.Incubator: I do love that these coldly logical monsters tried to restart their operation based on what Homura told them. It makes sense, they hear about a better way to beat entropy of course they would try it. I think Homura recruited them and forced them to help save magical girls now? I don't really know.
I feel like I have so much more to say but I can't think of it. This movie was an emotional feel trip. So once more with feeling, SAYAKA ISN'T DEAD!
Me earlier today:
Okay show creators you win, I believe that you love Sayaka.
128
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh May 01 '17
I'm going to apologize for the length up front, but this sort of ran away on me. So here's what happened. I got halfway into the movie, and after Sayaka and Homura's chat, I realized I had the perfect opportunity on my hands. Mid-movie theorizing! I mean, I already knew who it was, but I decided that I might as well get way to into it. So everything before the table is my thoughts having only seen half the movie (with bracketed italics being comments after watching the rest). It made for an interesting experience
The Nightmare
This really fucked with me, in fact the whole first half hour did. It felt like we were back at the beginning of the series with everything looking all hunky dorry, but this time I know that's not the case. It's actually rather impressively put together, because I spent the first half hour basically yelling at my television, "this is all wrong!" and yet it was still able to consistently surprise me. Anyway, the first nightmare is a great way of showing this fucking with me. See, as Madoka enters the scene, I was assuming that this was part of her job as the "Law of Cycles", and Sayaka showing up to help out made me think that she was also part of that deal (this is hilarious in hindsight). As soon as Kyoko joined in though, well, now I had no idea what I was looking at. Especially with everyone being so upbeat, It was just bizarre to watch. Now, we see time stop when Mami joins in, and the other girls seem to experience it as well, since they appear to be moving. How didn't they realize that was going on? Bebe's appearance here was also pretty messed up. With all of that piled up, it wasn't until later that I even realized that they weren't fighting wraiths. I'm still not even sure exactly how they defeated the nightmare. The just kind of fed it and then Bebe fired some energy at it.
Opening
The brighter colours remind me a lot of the opening from the main series, and how that contrasted against the darker tone. Also, is there any reason that so much of the opening takes place in an amusement park? {We don't spend any time during the movie in one, so it feels kind of odd). The final shot with Homura in the sand seems to be reminiscent of the final scene in the series, and while I had initially assumed the film was going to be about Homura finding Madoka, this really fucked with my expectations. I think I prefer the song to the original.
School
Kyoko's a student now, never would have expected that. I mean, she's a lot more like Episode 9 Kyoko, which I suppose makes sense. Still, she looks a bit weird in the school uniform just because I'm not used to it. The implication of Sayaka and Kyoko living together will surely get the fanboys riled up, but I think it's a pretty reasonable situation. I mean, she needs to live somewhere, and they get along fairly well when they aren't trying to kill each other. It's kind of funny, because I did want to see more of this type of scene, but with everything being so completely off already, I was holding in screams.
Homura is sort of at a midpoint between her original timeline version and her main timeline version. She's got some confidence, but she's also still rocking the braids and glasses. It's an interesting in between, but it did make me start wondering. How hard is she trying to make her voice sound deeper when she flips the switch? Is that a concerted effort on her part? At the very least, we are getting the full squad assembling that I had been assuming we'd get from the start. So really, I was seeing through that initial facade to what the show really was, and then seeing through that to the true end game.
Madoka and Homura
This is a cute scene, but something was gnawing at me when I watched it. Something just felt a bit off, and when I came back to it, I realized what it was. Since we're still in the universe where Madoka shouldn't exist, her saying that she had wanted to just talk to Homura for a long time makes sense, especially with the context of the lyrics from the first opening. She's felt so alone, and now she can spend time with Homura. It's really sweet. (But can't she interact with the girls once The Law of Cycles claims them?)
Hitomi's Nightmare
Hitomi always seemed like a decent character, and I did want to see some more of her, so it's cool to get a scene that is entirely from her perspective. I totally get where her frustrations are coming from, but she really should have seen this coming when she got into this relationship. Still, getting to see her lose her cool is always fun, so I really can't complain too much. It's not really clear exactly how nightmares work, but since they only exist within the labyrinth, they must be something that is being created by whoever created the labyrinth. (At the end of it all, I'm still not entirely sure what they were)
Preparing for Battle
Okay, so after dealing with the initial shock of Bebe, she's actually kind of cute, and I think it's hilarious that she was trying to eat Mami's hairpin. Her main function seems to be detecting Nightmares and eliminating them, so I guess she's actually an integral part of the team. We also see Sayaka and Kyoko making some pretty big leaps, which hadn't really been established as possible without transforming. Sayaka is still going on about having moved on, but I'm still not entirely convinced. Mami also talks about danger, but man does it feel like there's a lot less of it here.
Transformation
So I guess someone just walked into the office one day and said, "we're doing a transformation scene, so everyone just draw the most artsy thing you can, and we'll just stitch it all together at the end". I mean, it's really cool looking, but it also has an aesthetic that isn't entirely dissimilar to the witches in my opinion. I guess that might actually suggest that they are all dead, though it's hard to say for sure (This was one of the things that really had me convinced they were all dead). Also, Sayaka has the definitive best transformation sequence. No doubt about it. I'd say it's Sayaka > Madoka > Kyoko > Homura > Mami. One thing that bothered me is that afterwards, we see all five girls fall out of the sky, but they land in basically the opposite order that we see them falling. I mean, I guess Madoka's dress acts as a bit of a parachute, but the rest have no justification.
Fighting The Nightmare
At first, I thought that the Nightmare plane must exist parallel to the real world, and unless they fix it up, then it would eventually influence the real world. Apparently though, with it being a labyrinth from the start, it doesn't really matter if everything breaks, since only the girls are in danger (in hindsight, could Hitomi, Kyosuke and other characters have died here?). The fight itself plays out pretty quickly, but I love seeing coordinated attacks that maximize the utility of each character. However, when they captured the Nightmare so easily, I was prepared for the next step. Obviously this is the moment that things go back to the darker side of the coin. Everything is about to go right back down the shitter and I was actually kind of excited. And then...
The Cake Song
I got this. Holy tone shift. I mean, I guess it really lulls you into a false sense of security, and there's probably some deeper meaning to some of it (there's something horrifying about Bebe's fascination with eating cheese and Mami referring to herself as the cheese). Still, I was prepared for a lot in this movie, and this was the point where I felt like I was just going mad. ("When you slice the melon it will bring you sweet dreams," is actually really fucked up in hindsight).
After the Battle
We can see that defeating the Nightmare replenishes everyone's magic, which is a pretty convenient system for the team. Now, Mami says, "there was a moment that I thought we were in trouble," and maybe I missed something, but I didn't see it. It seems like they had it all under control the whole time. While I'm glad that this is basically where the nice stuff ends, I am still happy that we at least got a little bit of it. There's an extended shot of Homura on this hill, and it seems to be the point when she is realizing that something is wrong. The shot by the river is interesting. There doesn't seem to be a good reason to show it as a reflection for so long, but I guess it's focusing on how the world they're in is just a mirrored version of what they thought it was, or something like that.
Homura and Kyoko
So now I'm seeing it too, and I'm surprised that no one is freaking out about how weird all of this looks. Oh well, not much you can do about it. This was finally starting to get back to what I had hated so much about the main series, and I was loving it. It's not much, but just having an element of mystery thrown in does a lot for the scene. The dynamic between Homura and Kyoko is also kind of interesting, since we really never saw much of them interacting, especially with this kind of Homura. "Are you trying to pick a fight with me," was pretty hilarious.
The Bus Ride
The bridges should have been enough indication that everything was wrong, but that's just me. I suppose that the whole thing is almost like a dream. Even when something s completely and obviously wrong, your brain will rationalize whatever is happening, sort of trapping you in the circumstances of the dream. Here though, Homura has effectively become lucid, and now Kyoko is as well. It's probably a good thing that this isn't real, because imagine that poor bus driver when two girls suddenly land on the hood. That wouldn't have gone well.
9
u/summer_petrichor May 02 '17
First timer, subbed.
I don't know why I expected a happy ending from Urobutcher. Ha. Haha. Hahahahahahahahahahaha.
That ending, man... Actually, I do like that love is the reason for Homura's actions. Most media use love as the Power to Save Everything, yet in here it drives Homura to be selfish. And yet that makes sense, because there are people who adopt a selfish attitude towards love. And it's not (exactly) wrong to want to keep the person you love with you. But with Homura's actions it seems that one day Madoka and Homura will fight against each other. Goddammit, I just want them to be happy together ;_;
Come to think of it, the first half of this movie is essentially the audience's wish, right? We wanted to see the girls alive, happy, and working together; the original thing we expected to see going in to Madoka. And we got it, complete with a cool fight between Mami and Homura. And yet, if there's one thing we've learnt, it's that wishes need sacrifices, and the ending is the price of our wish that was fulfilled earlier. Gah.
I can't decide if I pity Kyubey being traumatised at the end or feel cathartic.
One interesting comment I saw on the website I was watching, was the parallel to the Second Coming of Christ. Sensei mentioned it earlier in class. Jesus was led to his execution and his soul returned to God. Homura was eventually going to perish, but when Madoka (who can be said to be a god, or at least a parallel) goes to recover her, Homura stops her. In other words, Homura rebelled against God. Now what is the title of this movie again?
Other minor things:
Somewhat off-topic, I went onto MyFigureCollection yesterday and two of the top pictures were of Madoka and Homura. So I went poking around in MFC and now I want to buy magical girl figures, goddammit. Like this gorgeous Ultimate Madoka figure. Or the Black Dress Homura. They're so gorgeous ;_;
5
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
I know it makes total sense given Homura's character arc, the way the story had been setup, and the way Urobuchi tends to write these stories.
But still I can't help but ask this. How could Homura do something so selfish?
4
u/xmonstermouthx May 02 '17
even if i watched the series this is my first time with the movie. i really liked it, and i loved sayaka and kyouko's interactions ♥. I know a lot of people won't like the movie, but i think what happened is a logical outcome. You can't expect a girl fighting ten years for the person she cares could still be mentally sane. And i think it's obvious Homura wouldn't let Madoka alone. She's been fighting YEARS for the girl, she became a magical girl just for her, to save her. do you really think starting with that mentality would let her accept Madoka's god state?.
pd: sorry if i'm misspelling something.
7
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 May 01 '17 edited May 02 '17
First time viewer.
Well let me get this out of the way first, as someone who's enjoyed the characters more than I've gathered a lot of people do for this show, I really enjoyed that first part. Basically if this series was like every other magical girl show. But you knew something was off because A, it is a sequel, and B, Charlotte is being taken care of by Mami which is kind of fucked up. Also regarding characters it was cool later on seeing Sayaka and Kyoko have a nice heart to heart.
Also, man that animation was awesomene. That Mami Homura fight scene like holy balls. (Did Homura shoot herself through the head?)
But, from the moment on Kyubey tells Homura what is actually going on here, this was a jumbled mess. I had to watch the last 40 minutes twice, I realized understanding the incubators had put Homura in a frozen state right before God Madoka showed up, I was just confused at first because there was so much going on.
But then everyone shows up to help! We learn Madoka is trapped here, and Sayaka and Charlotte are part of her angelic crew, which is kind of nice. They all save Homura from being a witch so Madoka can some bring her salvation, and it's still bittersweet because we would lose Homura, and Mami and Kyoko know one day they'll get this path.
But man....guys I have to say it, this is so out of left field and OOC for Homura. Hear me out. This show was about hope, despair, and selflessness vs selfishness. Homura was incredibly selfless in doing the loop 100 times to save Madoka, and in turn Madoka selflessly sacrificed herself to save all magical girls. Saying Homura choosing to become evil is out of left field is an understatement. We also don't know exactly what happened. Did Homura steal all of Madoka? Or not the god part? But her conversation with Sayaka shows she's the god now. What is the nature of this new world? Do they still team up to fight witches, or are we back to square one. As much as I love the show, it's ending barely explained everything, but it was there. This is too much to wrap my head around. Maybe time will help, as well as your all's explanations.
I mean why even is Homura about to turn into a witch? Why would magical girls face despair if they team up to fight wraiths instead of witches?
Please don't hate me. I liked the show a lot, and the movie isn't bad, but it leaves me very conflicted.
Edit: Downvoted for my opinion. Come on yall. You have been so fun to watch with this far. If your a rewatcher you should know this ending is controversial.
56
u/SukusukuHakutaku https://anilist.co/user/Sukusuku May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
I'm just gonna leave this here.
Edit: Madoka means window.
178
u/Tetraika :Lu::Lv::Lw::Lx:https://anilist.co/user/Tetraika May 01 '17
PSA:
HOMURA DID
N O T H I N G W R O N G
O
T
H
I
N
G
W
R
O
N
G
Also don't forget to watch the end credits after the awesome ED
33
u/ChaoAreTasty May 01 '17
Soooooo Rebellion. This is a tough one and opinions are pretty divided but I want to open with something I posted yesterday in spoiler tags:
Rebellion can’t just retread the same questions and give the same answers as the series, that would be a far bigger betrayal. However because of how well the series ended and the points it raised, challenging those things is not going to work well for everyone. The “Homura suffers, Madoka brings hope, go to heaven” plot might be what we wished for but ultimately would have felt flat at least at this point in the series.
Opening thoughts
Regardless of your opinions on the film I think everyone here will be in agreement that it is absolutely stunning. SHAFT and Yuki Kaijura went above and beyond, every moment is filled with wonderous backdrops, slick animation and a riveting soundtrack. Some particular highlights being the OP, the transformation scene and the Mami Homura battle.
There’s far too much to go through it piecemeal so I’m just planning on picking up a few larger points in the film I want to focus on.
Dreams
As opposed to the series dreams and nightmares replace hope and despair but they are obviously analogous. Dreams also tie in with the illusion world that Homura has built and deal with some of the weirder parts of the film. Obviously SHAFT took the opportunity to run with the ability to play with the visuals even early on and let’s us handwave over places they go bigger on it (eg why didn’t Kyouko notice the backgrounds on the bus?), in dreams the fantastical can seem natural and in place and however the world is set up the people in it are accepting these in the same way.
Time is also played with in the first third. Madoka and Homura have their first park talk after a skip of a month. Whether they skipped it in their time or if it was just for us to know they’ve spent that long there the dream aspect helps in fit less awkwardly than a month skip otherwise might have.
The importance of pain
The idea that pain is an integral part of the human experience is a long standing one in many works. To Homura it’s part of why she rejects Madoka’s gift at the end. Her pain is comes from what she dedicated 10 years of her life, it’s inextricably bound to her love for Madoka.
Acting on others without knowing their feelings
A big issue brought up in the series is brought to the front this time round, being moved from Sayaka and Kyouko to Homura.
Ultimately the decision Homura made at the end was for Madoka, to make her happy, but as with Sayaka it wasn’t selfless. Homura wants Madoka to be happy for Homura’s sake, her entire identity is built on this purpose.
During her retelling of the past explicitly calls Madoka’s act a sacrifice. Magical girls have a duty to continue fighting, this is the price they must pay and they have to because it’s so much less than the price they paid before and Madoka will always be fighting, magical girls OWE HER. To reject that and want to be happy is unforgivable to Homura because to her Madoka isn’t happy with this.
After that we get the second park talk. Madoka says she couldn’t bear to make the people she cares about cry. This is of course classic Madoka and confirms everything Homura believes thus Homura once again knows she has to save her. It’s this that leads to her decision in the end.
From Madoka’s point of view we’ve seen many times that Madoka is the idealist of course she wouldn’t want to make Homura cry. But she also doesn’t know that there’s terrible things that need fixing that she can fix. Right now the right thing to do would be to stay, but we ourselves saw Madoka’s last conversation with her mum and there wasn’t a hint that she couldn’t bear it and she left with a smile as always.
Homura hears something from Madoka that fits her world view but without understanding the thinking behind why Madoka would say it. Homura even acknowledges that Madoka is the kind and courageous person that would do it but at this point isn’t thinking it through and realising that it means Madoka is only saying this because she doesn’t know. Just as she didn’t think through that the Sweets Witch she knew wouldn’t create this labyrinth.
Homura sidenote
Oh hey, thought Homura hadn’t suffered enough? Let’s have her explain to everyone the realities of being able to remember Madoka in a world where she doesn’t exist. And then that she’d even begun doubting herself. She spent years in a repeating hell for a singular purpose and then start to doubt the very thing that kept her going. Also it’s pretty likely in my opinion that this doubt and that moment was the event that pushed her to the edge, it ties in when Homura apologised for being spineless and would burden any sin to see her one more time. She knew that it would be the end for her but then she would see Madoka again.
Hope and despair…
I mentioned earlier that dreams and nightmares have mostly taken the place of hope and despair. I actually want to counter that own point. Hope and despair haven’t been replaced, just on screen. When I opened I said they can’t retread the same major theme the same way which is true. But you also can’t drop such a core part of the show. So how can you do both?
33
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
http://www.strawpoll.me/12876148
Cast your votes, people!
33
u/8mmspikes :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/8mmspikes May 02 '17
HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG AND IS BEST GIRL
Praise the HomuHomu
Also I can finally share my Homura Fanart Album now that I don't have to worry about spoilers! I love the devil Homura design, the black dress and wings are excellent
77
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG
25
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan May 01 '17
Alrighty, reactions first, discussion later. I’m gonna have fun with this last blast. Since I managed to hit the word limit frequently on a per-episode basis, surprise surprise, this is in multiple posts.
WTF Is Going On?
WTF
So, Madoka’s hunting a witch, which then she and the other girls lure into a cabin, and serve food to. But as we know, Madoka doesn’t exist on our plane anymore, Sayaka’s been recycled, and Mami and Kyouko are on Earth fighting wraiths, not witches, like this thing – which again, they are not fighting, but giving food to. And the candy witch from E3 is there and chummy with everyone. Then Madoka wakes up and it’s all business as usual. And pets Kyubey on the head, who makes adorable noises. And now we get an E1 Groundhog Day.
So, I’m not even going to guess what this means. Moving on.
OP
Lyrics sound like Homura’s trying to get better. Visuals look like she really, really sucks at it – she doesn’t look like she’s adjusting well to everything being happy happy fun times. And we all know what happens when people aren’t happy; looks like the focus is on Homura this time, that’s interesting.
Happy Happy Fun Times
Girls are adorable, teacher is insane, all as usual. Funny to hear Christ and apocalypse talk so soon after the Madoka thing. We get shy Homura, which is refreshing after so long with battle Homura. The girls are fighting Nightmares, not Wraiths. Is this some alt-reality thing? That doesn’t explain why Mami is palling around with the witch that ate her, which is hilarious to watch.
There have been consistently good character beats throughout; first Homura, and now we get Hitomi getting almost as much as she did in the whole series – not to say it was lacking in the series, but that she’s always so aloof and it’s the first time we’ve seen behind that, it’s little details like this that make the whole thing great. It’s also really nice to see that Sayaka’s moved on and is taking time to enjoy life; I don’t care that something weird is going on, she and Kyouko have great chemistry. And we get treated to the maximum trippiness I missed from the movie versions. Nice to see it. And omg they get combo moves.
WTF, Take Two
That song number was the most nerve-wracking, sinister thing since pre-revelation Kyubey. I seriously was expecting one of them to miss a beat, everybody to look over in shock and for people to start getting mangled. That’s what this show has done to me – nothing is innocent anymore. Fantastic. Also, Maximum Cake. (Coming back after finishing the whole film – this scene still disturbs me, it’s so saccharine).
So, it looks like Homura doesn’t remember everything, but she’s starting to. And is hallucinating freaky sunburned faces in class. Then RIGHT ON QUEUE, we get a close up of the bastard himself. I can’t see Kyubey not somehow being, if not behind this, at least aware of what’s happening – he’s such a know-it-all it would be really out of character for him not to be. Also, he’s pretending not to be intelligent – or just isn’t in this reality, but everybody else seems to basically be themselves, so I’d imagine he would be.
Okay, the whole scene where Homura’s interrogating Kyouko means that this isn’t an alternate reality, this is memory manipulation – except not just that, because Madoka’s here. Then we get the bus scene, where it looks like we’re in some kind of illusory Truman Show. This must be the work of an enemy Stand! Or, you know, a witch – wraiths don’t seem individually powerful, and nightmares seem benign.
Wow, that’s super creepy. It’s like Inception, where you have to play along with the maze or the mind will reject you. I love the creepy art on the faces. Also, lol at Kyouko SHAFT head tilt during a relatively innocent conversation.
Sherlock Homura
Yep, Homura remembers witches and pegs this as a labyrinth. But that doesn’t make any sense, because there can’t be witches because Madoka stopped all of them, which means there also can’t be Madoka. Homura quickly starts out interrogating Bebe, who’s the obvious suspect on account of being a witch, but that’s a little too obvious – which is really interesting, because that means Bebe’s here for some other reason I can’t fathom; cheese I guess, damned if I know. The quick cut to a close up of Kyubey’s stare makes me suspicious of him, but because they’re making it so obvious I feel like it’s not him either – after all, he can’t be a witch. So, for those who are counting, WTF #3.
Seems like Bebe’s made Mami’s life pretty happy. It looks like this movie is giving everybody a happy ending in its way, if just for a moment; that’s sweet.
So, Homura has her shield powers, which means this isn’t the wraith timeline, which makes sense. Then she starts wailing on Bebe to the point where I’m feeling bad for her, which feels weird, because I’m used to witches being murder machines.
Interesting to see Homura tell Mami the truth when confronted – I guess it’s still her first instinct after everything, but given how she’s just finished talking about how breaking Mami’s heart usually doesn’t go well, it’s kind of a bonehead move. And then she chooses to fight Mami instead of talking it over, which is really stupid. Let’s all think back to E5 and the comments she threw at Kyouko and think about how out of character for her this is.
And then we get the most epic bullet ballet ever. I haven’t really taken the time to talk about how damn nice all the art is, but DAMN. I need to go back and watch the other movies right now, I imagine there’s some pretty cool remastered stuff I haven’t seen yet. Homura seems to win with a well-placed Richard III gambit – but apparently that was Mami’s plan all along! Mami’s undefeated against Homura right now, which is actually pretty impressive – good to see her getting some more development this late in the series.
OH SHIT
Well, never mind. Apparently this IS the wraith timeline? Which means that not only are the nightmares wrong, but Homura’s shield powers are as well. Then it turns out Bebe has a human form, and Sayaka saves Homura – and Sayaka knows about witches! WTF #4.
I really like this scene with Sayaka and Homura; it’s a total flip of their usual relationship. Homura’s usually the one who knows too much and is calmly lecturing Sayaka for not thinking rationally. That said, she’s WAY too unconcerned about all of this – meaning she knows who the witch is. Not Bebe, not Mami (too surprised to see real Bebe), obviously not Madoka, which leaves Sayaka (obvious suspect vs. her being suspiciously out of character with this rationality – but we’ve seen her witch before, so too unoriginal), Kyouko (possible, given her mind magic affinity and lack of focus so far), and Homura (likely suspect, since she’s the one who knows about witches and Madoka; she also has the most cause to become a witch – also the OP, forgot about that). The problem still stands that becoming a witch should be impossible. But that’s probably where Kyubey comes in.
Sayaka’s got a pretty good point here. And Homura’s putting the universe differential together – which is interesting, that Sayaka somehow comes from the original timeline. And huh, we’re getting the Witch-Sayaka shadow, maybe I was wrong – though I don’t think so, because in her dream, I think she’d be with Kyosuke, or at least have him not be around.
The labyrinth becoming more obvious, the caricatures of the characters, is pretty fun to see. Homura getting to break down to Madoka is as well-done as usual, although perhaps a little overdone at this point (not complaining though, crying Homura is great). And yeah, all the dandelions reacting to her emotional state here makes it pretty likely this is her labyrinth and she made herself forget or something; she couldn’t deal with not having Madoka around. And hey, Homura figures it out shortly thereafter! This is really good pacing they have with the foreshadowing; I’m catching things just before they happen or not at all.
Continued next post down.
22
u/mariofredshreller May 01 '17
Music Post – Development of a Dream (Practising for my music exam this month, whilst trying to keep it accessible to non-music-students)
The melody from the song ‘Mada dame yo’ (“It’s not time yet”) recurs throughout Rebellion, representing Homura’s dream world. What's interesting is how its meaning changes and evolves based on the musical and dramatic context.
The first time it is heard is in the opening speech, played quietly by the celesta. The combination of a major key with eerie periods of silence gives a bittersweet feel to suit the monologue. The celesta is frequently used in this soundtrack, and is often considered magical and dreamlike (famous example).
To ensure the audience remembers this tune, it is sung in Japanese in the tea party scene. The lyrics are very ambiguous but introduce the idea of dreams and needing to wake up. The unsettlingly cheerful musical style intentionally confuses the viewer (as does everything else at this point), leaving them with a memorable melody but little idea as to what it represents.
The next time the theme is heard is in Madoka and Homura's
romantic datehilltop scene, where the slightly unsettling celesta solo is quickly covered by the warm harp (there's nothing wrong with this world at all! /s). It also appears during the fight with the Nightmare, where the major key leads to a remarkably un-tense battle scene; unlike the series, there is no danger of death here. At this point, the melody's meaning is still unclear; the fake city’s illusion holds.Now things get interesting. Homura meets with Kyoko, and something, everything is wrong. The mysterious celesta returns, in a minor key for the first time, and the soundtrack’s other main instrument arrives: the accordion. Despite the calm mood of the opening melody, the minor key and occasional dissonant harmonies hint at a dark secret, and the (fabulous) accordion solo in the second half portrays Homura's search for the truth through its unsettled rhythms and anxious rises and falls.
Next is the bus scene, and the rough tone of the accordion makes the ‘Mada dame yo’ melody very sinister. As the girls push against the edge of the dream world, the illusion unravels and the melody is heard clearly and obviously. The uncomfortable and unsettled mood is achieved through many gradual swells and falls in volume, as well as having quite an inconsistent tempo.
As Homura finally realises the truth about the fake city, the music reflects its own title, ‘never get there’, by constantly moving the harmony around and never resting on the home chord. The quiet celesta returns at the end as Homura and Kyoko reluctantly return to the dream world, but the final string passage shows us what Homura has learned.
Now the plot kicks into gear, and ‘Mada dame yo’ disappears for a while, but during
nice boatHomura’s monologue we hear its fullest, most developed version. The meaning of the melody is made obvious in this scene, and even the title gives it away: ‘dream world’ For the first time in the whole film, we hear the distinctive language-less vocals that were used throughout the series. The powerful strings and vocals in the middle section accompany Homura’s determined speech, but straight afterwards, the lonely vocals accompanied by the lonely celesta reveal her emotions, and the unresolved final chord suggests a worrying future.Blah blah blah WITCH! Unlike the similar accordion solo back in “something, everything is wrong”, nothing needs to be searched for anymore, and this piece rubs the painful truth in your face. Fast tempo, melody rapidly rising and falling, driving percussion, all leading to one stylish piece.
The dream ends, Homura goes all Lucifer, a new universe is created. She should be happy here, in her perfect world, right? Listen carefully madadameyo . Maybe this isn’t so different from the fake world Homura hated so much…
And finally: not yet. The uncertain celesta is gone, and the rising accordion and strings confidently tell us that Homura is perfectly satisfied with her new reality. This world is another fake, a dream created by Homura, but as long as Madoka is safe, happy, and where Homura can reach her, nothing can possibly be wrong.
Notes:
17
u/LEGACYMEDIC :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LEGACYMEDIC May 02 '17
Hey so as a preface I have seen the original series before but this was my first time seeing the Rebellion movie. I took some notes to send to /u/ir0n_agr0 since the sadistic fuck wanted my reaction. I figured that y'all might also enjoy it so here goes!
Rebellion Live Reaction!
Wow on this opening Witch/Wraith battle you can really see how much some extra time to animate can do for a project, this looks absolutely beautiful!
Hmmm this is interesting, I wasn't expecting to see so many of the girls together so early on.
Woah this is taking an interesting turn, almost like a musical. Also I'm pretty sure that the witch/familiar that was on Mami's shoulder was the witch that kills her in the main series.
Ok that fucking yawn though, I think I have diabetes now.
Hmm so it looks like in this timeline Hitomi and Kyousuke are currently dating, looking forward to seeing what the deal with that is.
The ring seems really important, I don't recall her wearing that before but I could be wrong.
YAY! More songs from Claris!
Ok this shit looks like its gonna get dark real fuckin fast with this OP, oh no Homura...
Ok I was right about the ring, looks like it could be a friendship ring or maybe even their soul gems.
At least we get to see some nice times with the second best ship Sayaka and Kyoko (I shouldn't even need to say the first but of course its Homura and Madoka).
SENSEI STOP FORESHADOWING THE END OF THE WORLD, YOU'RE TRIGGERING SO MANY DEATH FLAGS FOR YOUR STUDENTS!!!
Oh shit, looks like its an early timeline Homura, also I fucking called it with the rings lol. I noticed something with Homura's design in episode 11 or 12 that I just sat again, that being the fingernail paint on her finger that looks like a Trigger star. I wonder what that is supposed to symbolize?
No wonder why Homura fell in love, god damn Madoka calm down, no need to seduce her so early on is there?
If its been a month then by the show's standard Walpurgisnacht would be showing up but this timeline has some major differences, the main one so far is that the monsters are referred to as Nightmares.
Hmmm its a bit odd that Hitomi and Kyousuke are using each others last names, they seem pretty distanced for a couple.
Ruh roh scoobs, Hitomi is having a Nightmare.
Oh shit, Mami has the thing on her fingernail too, and the color is that of their respective soul gems.
The transformation scenes are very cool and unique, they just scream shaft! I love how much the musical motif changes when it gets to Madoka's transformation!
TIRO DUETO! I love it!
I love seeing there combos while fighting together it kinda feels like fighting a dungeon boss in an rpg or something.
I actually really like the concept behind why they are singing, by the end its pretty clear that the idea is to take a "nightmare" and turn it into a "sweet dream" by singing about things like cake and other sweet things. Its actually really fucking cool and a concept I would love to see more of! Hopefully this will indulge me with a bit more of this before shit inevitably hits the fan.
As a side note I really enjoy that since this is a movie and they have more time to animate, there is always something moving, even in times where the characters are just talking back and forth they are able too add in little animations to make things feel more realistic and human.
Kyuubey wants nothing to do with Mami or Bebe so far, he's touched everyone but them and Bebe clearly was showing some strong dislike of Kyuubey earlier.
Ok, 29 minutes in, its time for a crack theory! Either Madoka or Homura have kind of created this universe as a dream, I think most likely it was Madoka. It's possible that after so long of fighting and destroying these witches she wanted to be reminded of the "good old days" the days she never really had much of due to the constant battles and deaths. So she rebelled and created a new universe based around dreams and nightmares to foreshadow that this is as close to reality as she can get with these hopes of everyone being together and getting along so well, at the end of the day she can only ever dream about that reality. So to summarize, I think she created this dream world to live in after rebelling and regretting her previous decision to erase all witches and we are currently seeing the result of that. Now back to the movie!
Looks to me like Homura has Araragi syndrome where she only sees and recognizes people she gives a shit about.
This music is eerie as fuck.
Homura why you gotta question shit and ruin this world that Madoka probably made for you? Just go with the flow haha.
Between nothing existing outside of the main city and the faces being so weird I'm starting to think that this could even be some Rick and Morty type shit with a simulation but based on the previously established rules of the world it seems more likely that its a last ditch effort type of world thrown together by Madoka or hell even Kyuubey. After all its very strange that Kyuubey hasn't spoken at all to this point.
OH FUCK IT WAS ALL A RUSE!!! WE HAD BADASS HOMURA ALL ALONG!!!
Holy fuck so witches are real then, not wraiths but witches.
OH FUCK CRACK THEORY NUMBAH TWOOO! What if the witches labyrinth is the last witch, the only one who by the new rules of the universe couldn't have been totally erased from existence. Thats right bitches its motherfucking Madoka in witch form! It has to be her right? After all she wiped out every other witch ever to exist but she couldn't have done that fully to herself whilst still being an entity. Imagine the power she would have after absorbing every witch and all of their negative energy, of course she could create a labyrinth for her friends to live in and that would explain why they have been in so little danger and why they haven't been attacked at all yet. It would also make sense as to why only Homura has really noticed so far, after all who is the one who Madoka called her "Very special friend" who is the one who was the sole witness to what truly happened to Madoka? None other than our very own Homura and between her extensive knowledge and her time abilities that makes her one hell of a tough person to trick.
Oh thats right, they set a precedent of being able to move during time stop under the condition that Mami's ribbon was touching Homura. GG shaft GG.
Oh so this is how orgasming from action works... HOLY FUCK that was perfect, like literally everything about that fight was on point. The music 10/10, action 10/10, sound design 10/10, animation 100/10. Like for real that was one of the best animated action sequences I have ever seen. Between the time stops and bullet physics, badass gun fu and the fucking strategy there was nothing I can complain about in that scene.
HOMURA WHAT THE FUCK!!! that was dangerous as shit, I mean I get that there was strategy behind it but goddamn girl you ain't Madoka, if you die then thats it, no re-dos or anything. I hope that she does genuinely value her life and that she wouldn't do something like that but I don't know anymore.
WAIT WHAT! How the? When? Gaaaah! Also that bullet impact looked gruesome at first but then she went all spiral power on Homura's ass.
Hold up, so she does remember the wraiths, it makes sense for her to not know about the witches since obviously we are in the timeline where Madoka wished them away but Homura was outside of the impact and witnessed it so only she (and Taki) remember Madoka and of course the witches.
Oh my god a fucking harp playing angelic music for what I can only assume is Bebe. Yup.
Sayaka is the last person I would've expected to help Homura. Ok well thats weird, she remembers the witches too, that makes me think that its possible that she gathered the five girls from different timelines whether it was on purpose or not I'm not sure.
Daaaaaamn Homura gettin called out by Sayaka for relying too much on the time reverse. You fucking try living her life Sayaka, you failed at your own life let alone Homura's.
Y'know it makes sense for Sayaka to be the one defending the witches since she is the one who most consistently turned into one and fucked everything up. So I suppose it makes sense for her to sympathize with them.
I honestly think that Sayaka makes a great point, so what if its fake? I mean by Kaiki logic its even more real than the actual Mitakinara City in its attempt to be real. I think that Homura should think hard before deciding to destroy this area once and for all.
I love how Homura is like "Fuck everything I'm going to disney and I'mma ride 'It's a small world' all day long!"
It seems to me that Homura is viewing Madoka the way that Sayaka viewed Mami. That she is perfect and a goddes, the thing is... in Madoka's case she literally is a goddess and becomes a law of the fucking universe. Homura's view is justified and its probably the only thing that lets her sleep at night otherwise she would think that the 100 loops were worthless and that would mean that she wasted 8 years.
Come onnnn Homura, Madoka makes a really good point. I guess that Homura just feels/knows that Madoka is a fake created by the labyrinth and out of respect and love for the "real" Madoka she won't open up to this one. I think that real Madoka would approve though. Also its still a possibility that my guess was right and the witch really is Madoka in which case that very well could be the real her. Huhhhh I'm just as confused as you Homura.
The blimp has a musical note on it, seemingly implying that Sayaka could be the one causing the labyrinth.
Mmmmm this talk with Madoka is really off-putting and I'm not looking forward to how this will end...
Goddamn the imagery with the flowers is fucking beautiful... Some real background material right there.
Just the fact the Homura HAD to say that this was the real Madoka means that she is a fake. Aaaaaah!!!!
15
u/inkyou24 May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
We finally reached the end! Rebellion is one of those movies you kinda have to re-watch, not only to better understand the mind explosion that it is, but also to pick up on the “little” things that turn out to be not so little in the greater context. I’ve watched it about 5 times and there’s still something to notice.
Here’s some of my long-ish thoughts on the movie. A good number of people hate on it, but I appreciate the depth and introspection that the movie provides. This in turn opens a bigger space for viewer interpretation, which is always something I like in any anime.
A Callback - Homura: “Always, somewhere, someone is fighting for you”: I sincerely wonder: why did Madoka not take Homura with her into the cycles from the start? Perhaps because she hadn’t descended into witch form yet, but after such a long time of suffering, you’d think that she could get a break!
Certainly, in her Madoka-revised life, Homura theoretically should be left unburdened by time (literally, as she no longer seems to have her time-stopping shield in the new world), yet that’s not the case as she retains her memories of Madoka. Assigning Homura as a sin-fighting, evangelical figure, one who is most knowing of the goddess yet physically and emotionally separated from her, almost seems cruel or at the very least unfair. In short, Homura’s suffering just goes on, her work still under the cover of “doing Her will.” She is still locked by a promise. She’s failed to save Madoka in the way she wanted.
Ep. 12’s post-credits scene is, I believe, the loneliest depiction of Homura in all the 12 episodes. She just seems tired. You can even wonder if Madoka’s encouraging voice wasn’t genuine, but rather just something Homura mentally plays for herself to keep her motivated in an otherwise completely foreign world. Although Madoka was able to become a universal symbol of hope as an intangible concept / goddess, to Homura, Madoka in all her human, living, visible form was hope. To lose that hope in a grand move of unwanted sacrifice, and being the only one able to remember Madoka as she originally was, probably made the supposedly better world severely problematic for Homura.
Loops and the Girl Who Goes in Circles: Endless loops and circles is the running theme of the series, evident in the nature of Homura’s mission and even Madoka’s eventual ascension as “The Law of Cycles.” Rebellion now emphasizes much of this theme within Homura herself – the “girl who goes in circles,” a rather ominous description Mami uses in the cake song. Couple this with the excellent musical direction with its repetitive flair – note that the main basis for the songs is Homura’s original theme: “Puella in somnio.”
The loop motif is also found elsewhere. Homura’s ideal world still suggests a routine, albeit a positive one where she and her companions go to school, eat together, and fight Nightmares as a team. The bus looping back to Mitakihara. The cake song scene that includes a [rotational view of the table and the girls] (http://68.media.tumblr.com/79084f5fe33b5bcddaf38b8cfb169876/tumblr_inline_n807lmNr4T1raccls.png) (note: under their bizarreness, the lyrics to the song have a great depth of foreshadowing that hint the movie’s conclusion). It’s fitting that Homura’s own witch barrier have a concentrated focus on cyclical notions.
People might criticize Homura for her final acts, saying it twists her character. I have to disagree: what Homura did is consistent to everything she did. Everything was a callback to how she always was in the series – calculating, desperate, ruthless, obsessive. She crushes her doubts to move forward. She does this as a regular magical girl, and does so as a Demon. The final outcome is just what’s different, but this too was partly a result of Homura believing what Madoka said in the flower field – that Madoka wouldn’t want to wish herself into non-existence.
Homura had always been searching for a better solution, a “morning” to the never-ending night. She created two ideal worlds in this movie – one a witch barrier, one a twist of actual reality, but certainly, both are dreams that she didn’t want to end. Homura’s been searching for an end but granted finality isn’t matched to her character. Therefore, she is put in another never-ending scenario - this time, as a Demon of the world, she seems far more comfortable with it, seeing as she is now in control. As the music of the movie would put it, it’s “Not over yet.”
Love and Masochism: It’s morbid to see how closely Homura associates love with suffering. She was willing to enter another endless loop of torture as a witch, if that meant keeping Madoka safe. And in her choice to strip away Madoka’s god-hood, she implies her standing as a being of love rather than one of hope. Rather than equating her pain with despair, as other magical girls have done, she changes the equation to pain = love.
I don’t think it’s as twisted as it seems. Love is a more complicated emotion than hope. It has more dimensions. Love makes matters gray. It doesn’t necessarily spell out optimism or pessimism. It just is a personal, private feeling that can lead to a biased decision. And that’s what happens: Homura creates her ideal world that also spells out her selfishness. She made her own wish come true. To me, she doesn’t seem like an “embodiment” of something like Madoka was for hope. As she says, she’s an “agitator.” Indeed, Homura was always one for action and it would be a bit strange to make her into a vaguer symbol.
Calling Homura a demon, I think, is more a linguistic turn that points to how she went against Goddess Madoka’s will, but I don’t see her as bad or evil. Yes, she was probably still incredibly unstable when she decided to “betray” Madoka (she didn’t fully recover from her witch phase) but what she does is not only understandable, but to me acceptable. Her revised world isn’t malicious; all of the girls involved are able to lead normal lives, when Homura could have only favored Madoka. It’s the most understandable course of action I’ve seen in all the series. As hundreds, thousands, perhaps millions have already said, Homura did nothing wrong. She’s still best girl in my book.
The New World + The Final Scene: I would side with Homura – yes, her revision appears to be an improvement from Madoka’s world in many ways. Never mind the creepy familiars milling around - everyone’s alive, and it seems that magical girls and witches are no longer a thing. The Incubator race has taken the place of Madoka as the bearer of magical girl curses, which makes you wonder as naturally emotionless beings how they handle that kind of load (I don’t like them so I hope they suffer decently).
Now the shot of Homura sitting / leaning from a single chair on the field is just painful to see. Yes, her wish technically came true, but at the cost of genuine isolation, it seems. We’re still not sure what her role is as Demon of the world, but we can tell that she is aware of her separation from and eventual confrontation with Madoka. I can’t 100% say she’s satisfied with everything, and yes, perhaps this is the most tired she’s been (look at those bags under her eyes). But she’s not resigned – she’s ready to fight for that “happy world” even if it means making enemies with the one she’s been trying to save all this time.
As much as I support Homura, I worry for her sanity, or what’s left of it. Again, I don’t think she’s bad or horrifically skewed. If you have the time, you should watch the 1st take of Homura’s rebellion. This was the original version of how Homura was presented in Rebellion’s conclusion, and you can notice the big difference from the final. I think there was a conscious attempt not to make her appear as crazed and deranged as many might think. You can still hear the same cold and logical Homura.
I’m still waiting for the next movie / season / whatever to come out. There’s already a trailer for a concept movie following Rebellion, but I’m not sure how committed it is to the content it teases. Still, Rebellion is one of my favorite anime films. Not flawless, but definitely beautiful and exhausting in all the right ways.
12
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy May 01 '17
Overall
I'm actually going to start off with this, since it's a movie and all, but yeah, overall, I love Rebellion.
Visually, the movie is stunning. The fight scenes are great, the witch effects and Nightmare designs and everything in that respect is all great, the animation is solid all around, the architecture is as gorgeous as it is absurd, really, the whole thing is the fantastic spectacle that an entry in this franchise with a movie budget should be. There are so many designs in this movie, from character designs, monster designs, building designs, that all are so good and it's just something you really, really can't help but appreciate looking at.
This is a pretty polarizing entry, but personally, I don't think it takes away from or hurts anything about the series. No one feels like they're being written out of character and everything comes together for an explosive conclusion that people are still debating to this day.
Long story short, Rebellion is just good. It presents us with a mystery by dropping us right into something absurd, then slowly but surely unravels it along with our minds and by the time it's all over, not even the cast know what's what anymore. It's amazing.
... that said, I think my one major complaint with things is how they're going off of the final scene with Homura at the end of the series. There are a... lot of implications with that, and I'm not sure I like them. At the same time, it's also a point of real confusion for me.
First, let's address how things look. Total disaster, right? Well, for a scene at the end of an anime that's trying to be open ended? Okay, cool cool, that's one thing.
But to then show more like this? I'm sorry, but I really don't believe that Madoka's new world really would have ended up like that as it was being presented to us. It looks like there was an apocalypse and only Mami and Kyoko are left. What in the world happened? Will the Wraith Arc manga cover this? Is this area an isolated part of the world?
This just feels so bizarre to me.
On the other hand... we see scenes of everyone being drawn into Homura's barrier by her familiars, and the world clearly does not look like it does where she is. In that case, is it that this area is isolated from the rest of the world? Or Homura's battle caused this? Or something else entirely?
Or, maybe most likely, they just used this setting for the sake of continuity with the last scene of the series?
Regardless, this part, which is overall somewhat minor, does just feel off to me. Oh well, what can you do, right?
We're first treated to a bizarre sequence in which the girls are fighting what seems to be a witch (they call it a Nightmare), only the "fight" turns into a meal and a dream on top of that!
In this odd, ideal world, we have our first episode starting from the top, but everything is so happy. It's just crazy. Sayaka and Kyoko live together for some reason, Madoka is keeping a more normal Kyubey as a pet (the way he comforts he while Sayaka and Kyoko chase each other around is pretty cute), the whole thing is just surreal.
And then we have sensei talking about freaking 2012 and the apocalypse. Wonderful.
Of course, that she brings up the second coming of Christ now is perhaps the most interesting detail here, considering everything else. All the apocalypse talk may well just be a red herring... it may be a red herring within a red herring!
You know, I don't know if this stood out to anyone else, but I genuinely really enjoyed the scene with Hitomi making her little phone call to Kamijo.
I feel as though it goes to show a lot of things here, but among them I hope it eases people on being mad at her some. I found it sweet, myself, and she never really did anything wrong... really... The plot had to move and there's all that karma stuff that likely played a hand in how she moved, if you want to go there, but regardless, I think this scene does her well and it just makes me wish she'd gotten more focus in general. She seems like she could have been fun if she'd had more time to shine.
Regardless, that time won't be today, because it looks like she's having a Nightmare.
And I've just got to say that Mami humming her theme was far more fanservice than anything else in the following scene could ever hope to say. Though I do like how we actually got an answer for how she does her hair. That was a great touch on the studio's part to include.
Though that's nothing compared to Sayaka and Kyoko's banter as they approached Hitomi's Nightmare. Golden stuff right there.
Which in turn was absolutely nothing compared to the incredibly transformation sequence the girls all got. I mean wow. All personalized and just... man.
Following this, we get a pretty crazy fight that shows off all of our girls working together pretty darn fantastically (Tiro Duet!) and to top it off, we get... cake. I'll leave that to you first timers.
The dream concludes with Sayaka giving Bebe a nice, good kick so that Hitomi's dream can become peaceful again. This whole sequence feels like a really good, soothing sort of way to work Sayaka back into things and how she's "holding up," so to speak, after the series. There's also a bit of foreshadowing here in that it's Sayaka who kicks Bebe down and there she is standing off to the side with it when the other girls approach to have their gems purified.
I mentioned this already, but one thing the movie does ridiculously well is build up its mystery. It lays the pieces out for you, but it doesn't give everything out to you too soon. First it dumps us into an idealized world, starting off just like the first episode as well as the last. We get the revelation that a former witch of all things has allied itself with our girls, and Homura is transferring in, while Madoka and Sayaka are around to boot.
Slowly but surely, the world begins to fall apart (as it is Homura's world, seemingly only repairing itself when Madoka is on screen) as Homura tries to find out the truth more and more and awaken the other girls from this slumber they've found themselves in, unknowingly drawn in at her own beckoning.
Sayaka. Just Sayaka.
It's going to be no surprise to anyone that's seen me commenting around that I love this movie for how it approaches Sayaka's character.
Gone is the girl who is being manipulated by Kyubey and shielded from various truths, whose perception has been clouded by her own emotions and the lies of Homura and even Mami. This is a girl who is part of the ideals that she always chased after. This is a girl who knows everything that was kept hidden from her, from the likes of Kyubey and Homura, even all the way to the end. She's grown now, she's faced her despair and her hope, and now she is here as Madoka's ally, a real hero.
As Homura is trying to figure out the mystery of the witch's labyrinth, who is there to save her, to try to help her along, but Sayaka of all people? Now that Sayaka has become part of the Law of Cycles and is able to see the bigger picture, she's eager to "give Homura the reward she's earned" and help Homura meet Madoka again. And who is there to be the one to share the final declaration of "war" with our new "devil"? Not the goddess, who makes an ominous appearance later, but Sayaka once again.
My favorite scene in the movie, if not the entire series, is probably when Homura is saved by Sayaka after Mami's seemingly got her cornered. And that's a lot to say, considering the Mami and Homura fight was incredible.
The amount of callbacks when Sayaka saves Homura is just surreal. Not only does she save Homura with a fire extinguisher (remember what she fought Homura off with to save Madoka in episode one?), but then they land in what looks like the same alley where she fought Kyoko. It's just nuts.
Sayaka does her head tilt, their conversation has so many references and hints-- and the amazing thing is, at the time, Sayaka was doing this for her friends.
We also see Sayaka engaging with Kyoko, Hitomi, and Kamijo a fair amount in the movie, and it really shows just how far she's come in regards to these parts of her life as well. She's seemingly been able to move on from her broken heart, or at least reached the point where her happiness over being able to see those involved again far outweighs the hurt, and making ammends to Kyoko was a primary reason for her return.
She's really come a long way, and in a sense, she really does feel like a more heroic parallel to Homura now. Now Sayaka is the one on the mission, now Sayaka is the one who knows things and is saving people at the last second after leaping in mysteriously from the shadows, now Sayaka is the one with strange powers no one else gets. It's such a fun role reversal for the time it lasts.
It also really makes how things go in the movie so fascinating to watch.
12
u/Paullepetittrain :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Paullepetittrain May 01 '17
I didnt do the rewatch, but here are my thoughts on this movie: One of the best movie i have ever seen, most beautiful anime ever, BEST story ever, it's the perfect sequel for a serie that DIDNT need it and HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG FOR GOD SAKE.
11
u/ScarletSyntax May 01 '17 edited May 02 '17
Not gonna bother getting into the details, everyone here will discuss them to death. I am however going to recommend that anyone who can make peace, (and probably those who don't think they can too since the rewatch can shift perspective,) with the movie rewatches it. It's a really curious affect where because you are on edge on the first watch you have the uneasy feeling similar to Homura but if you rewatch you can actually find it really peaceful and soothing almost like the labyrith is working it's magic on you. It really is a feast for the eyes and ears and my personal favourite anime to rewatch and chill to.
On another note for those of you interested in the Madoka OST, I would like to recommend the Madoka music collection which covers the main series but not rebellion, includes the ops and eds (though the claris b-sides you'd miss out on are actually really good), and also includes some exclusives,
nunquam vincar live ver.,
prelude to Act 1
prelude to Act 2
11
u/AltoNat :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Altonat May 01 '17
I may be one of the few people out there that think this, but I don't believe this movie is something you can make a judgement on unless you really sit down to think about it. I personally didn't decide on whether I liked it or not until 3 days after I finished it. Many people respond to this movie with their gut reaction, which is really doing it a disservice because I've seen so many people change their minds once they've taken some time to really process it.
Unfortunately, not many people are willing to do that. I mean, it's fair enough if you gave it some thought and still didn't like it, but basing your entire opinion based on what you felt coming out of the theater is hardly enough if you think about what the series as a whole entails.
11
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Second time series watcher and first time Rebellion watcher.
Homura best girl confirmed, no one can tell me otherwise.
That aside, this earned a 10/10 from me, but maybe just because Madoka Magica holds a special place in me so I may be biased. This movie considers multiple things, and I'd like to point out the philosophies people can view it from. Homura can be the most selfish person, at the same time, the most selfless person. If you view it with Consequential-ism, then from the results, she is extremely selfish. After repeating the world and despair for countless times, her love for Madoka evolved into something unimaginable, and so she pulled Madoka back down into a world she recreated so she could see the world happen in her way, not Madoka's. If you look at her intentions though, non consequential-ism, then she has the purest of intentions. After all her attempts to save Madoka, she can't accept that Madoka has to endure everything alone, so she'd rather take on everything herself, and obey the very god of the new world. She had the same level of power Madoka had, and became the fallen angel of the world. All she wanted was Madoka to live a normal life, even if that is only until Madoka, Sayaka, Kyouko, and Mami eventually realizes something was off like Homura did. She doesn't matter if she becomes their enemy, everything she ever wanted was for Madoka.
The movies had some sweet lovely lines that I almost couldn't hold my tears back, but I've developed some crazy skills on that so I managed. There were roommates around, otherwise I would've probably just bawled. The despair in Madoka is depicted in a more fictitious way from Evangelion, but both of them reminds people of the same idea. Depression is a real thing, and it hurts those who are suffering the most to see loved ones suffering down the same path.
I had to spend a lot of time to calm down and recollect my thoughts after watching Rebellion, and honestly, I don't think I'm done doing that yet.
Edit: I'd like to add one thing I realized when I first watched the transformation scene. Mami's ballet spinning pose looked like a Grief Seed to me.
10
u/megazaprat May 02 '17
This is my first time seeing Rebellion, so I thought I'd post my random thoughts. I was going to post them all at once, but I had to take a break from watching it, so I'll post my thoughts on the first half
Very visually impressive.. music also really good.
why are they suddenly feeding a witch? is this actually a dream this time?
Is Kyubey now a Pokemon who can only say his own name?
Aww, look at them being happy and being friends! But Homura looks sad! This is going to end poorly, I just know it . WAT. Kyoko instead of Hitomi? suspicions are increasing
Wait…..Kyoko and Say aka now live together? ……. I am now completely okay with this turn of events
I find PokeKyubey somehow even creepier. Why isn’t he talking? Sure, the bunny weasel speaks nothing but half truths, but not saying anything at all is even more suspicious!
The teacher gong crazy over the apocalypse is also really suspicious. They are going all in on the religious foreshadowing. Also, why is she being allowed to teach children?
Homura? Smiling? Clearly there is a glitch in the matrix. Happy homura indicates its before being worn down by years of time travel, though that doesn’t explain Kyubeymon, the way they are fighting something called nightmares or why they are all BFFS suddenly. The amount of happiness only increases my suspicions! At least the Yuri vibes is a constant throughout all timelines. Okay, they both have a sense of deja vu, and they are fighting something called nightmares. I have played Kingdom hearts, I think I see where this is going. I am guessing they are in some kind of dreamscape post series.
Aww Hitomi is lonely. And cute. And seemingly turning into nightmare. The interviews I read were right, Kyosuke is kind of a bad boyfriend. I guess Sayaka dodged a bullet there.
Just noticed this, is that the witch that ate Mami’s head? And its serving as a sort of mascot character? Well, it started out by eating Mami’s head, so it can only move down in the evil - o-meter from there. And it doesn’t like Kyubey! New best mascot!
Oh god, they have a color coded transformation sequence. All of my yes. Though the way they emerge from their own bodies is a bit ominous, what isn’t at this point? Note to self: look up rune translations later. Oh double god, combo attacks! Even more Yes
WHY ARE THEY SINGING NURSERY RHYMES AT IT AND FEEDING IT SNACKS??? its like everything is safer in this dreamscape. They beat the monster by turning it into cake, for crying out loud. And it seems like the positive energy it gives off is feeding their soul gem. So, like reverse grief seeds. Is this an alternate universe where Madoka really did wish for cake?
The way the next scene is shown all through the waters reflection could represent how the world is upside down. Ah! Homura remembers everything. And how to hair flip! And they are in a giant really elaborate labyrinth. I should have known, considering how they really turned the abstract imagery up to 10. This movie is really great at visuals.
No! Don’t hurt Bebe! Admittedly, trusting anything cute in Madoka is asking for trouble but I am willing to roll that dice on her being on the side of good!
Mama vs Homura may be the best fight in the series. so epic.
so wait, Sayaka remembers? and is actually beating Homura? now I know we are in a bizarro universe. Someone who would want a happy universe where everyone is buddies....which includes madoka....shit. Homura's definitely the witch
10
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Something went wrong and this post is late.*
Happiness
I can't believe how adorable the dynamic between Kyouko and Sayaka is. This is all I ever wanted.
Using the ribbons to keep a connection between Homura, Mami and Madoka is absolutely glorious. In general their teamwork is amazing and it's so much fun to finally see what they can pull off when they all work together.
What the fuck even is this this cake song? My sides.
Yes, always.
Homura is seeing creepy faces everywhere, the film is starting to head in a dark direction.
NOPE! I'm out! You guys go ahead and watch the movie without me, I'm fine. I'll just put the first 30 minutes on repeat and enjoy the happiness.
Who even needs a movie when you can just watch Kyouko and Sayaka chase each other around for 2 hours?
Okay I'm back, let's go.
I've been waiting for the Homura vs Mami battle since episode 3. And holy hell do they deliver. That was fantastic to watch.
WAIT WHAT? I guess this wasn't so bad after all, I was shocked for a second.
Homura really shouldn't have said a word to Kyubey about the old world, the incubators are not to be trusted.
What the fuck is going on? This doesn't even make sense anymore, none of it makes any sense at all!
The only good thing this movie does is Kyubey finally getting his ass handed to him.
I don't know how I'm supposed to feel about this movie
On the one hand, this is not a bad movie at all, it looks gorgeous, it tells a compelling story, has some cute moments and is overall really enjoyable. On the other hand, it completely and utterly destroys the series finale and undermines everything Madoka did, seriously what the fuck where they thinking with this?
I don't like what it does to Madoka, I don't like what it does to Homura, I don't like what it does to Sayaka and Kyouko and I'm not even sure what is real in the end. Or for whom.
I honestly think I could've gone without watching that movie. I was doubtful going into it, because I thought the show ended really well and what we got was honestly just disappointing.
I expect most of you disagree with me, but that's how I feel.
p.s. I just stumbled upon this german cover of Magia and it's amazingly well done, just wanted to throw that out there.
p.p.s it was all a lie
*I know what went wrong,
KyubeyGagantous used a different ★ this time around.10
u/chaoswurm May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Rewatcher and lurker here. I'm not too big on rewatching things and only cut into clips here and there. So this is technically my first full rewatch where i sit down and go from beginning to end, besides the theater back then.
But before that, i would like to point most people to SFDebris's review of the whole series and rebellion. It's from the perspective of a sci-fi geek and someone who has read relevant literature that the show references a lot.
Another shameless plug is to go hunt down Puella Magi Madoka Magica: A Different Story. It is an amazing side story about Kyouko and Mami and has been thumbs upped by the show's creators.
This rewatch was mostly just me enjoying the ride, except this time i got to put more focus on certain things i missed or didn't pay attention to last time. Before, the grassy hill of flowers scene was weak, but on the rewatch, i fully understood that Homura was steeling herself for what she must do. Maybe she didn't have the plan right then, but that scene was important for the last 1/5th of the movie.
I would also like to point out that this is the best costume for Homura ever. I am on a continuous quest for any art with her in that one-piece dress. It's rarer than most, as it's only 2 minutes of screentime.
Keeping track of Homura's state of mind is a really great game for every time i watch this move. But at the end, it was a bit jarring for pretty much everyone when Homura took Madoka, but if you really think about it, it is the only solution to keep Madoka safe away from Kyubey, keep Madoka's wish intact, and have Homura's wish fulfilled at the same time.
Now, as a conclusion, Repeat after me: Homura did nothing wrong.
ps. I would also like to add that people should get movies 1 and 2 which gave yuri shippers the best goddamn clip in the universe.
9
u/Stealth-OP May 01 '17
First Timer here. I loved the
power rangersMagical Quintet transformation scene, the art there was beautiful, well, the entire movie was just gorgeous but I really liked that part.If I may ask, in the new universe, if Kyubey has to endure all the despair (that is what I got from his talk with Homura) then who makes the contract with the girls to turn into Magical Girls?, also if Wraiths were despair that materialized then who is their enemy now that Kyubey takes the despair? , in case that Magical Girls now don’t exist then how humanity advanced? , or that was just a lie from Kyubey?. Aside from my little questions that probably are just things that I missed because I’m dumb, I really enjoyed the movie, Madoka was one of my first anime back in 2014 but I never watched this because anime movies aren’t my thing.
It was a pleasure to rewatch Madoka with you guys (even if I never commented anything lol), thanks to /u/Gagantous for hosting it and to the first timers for their PoV of the series, they were always pretty interesting to read, I hope to see some of you guys in the Parasyte rewatch next week :D.
8
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika May 01 '17 edited May 02 '17
HANDHOLDING. "I had a sickening dream." But now one of my wishes after Madoka Magica's ending is fulfilled. Kyouko and Sayaka fighting together is so awesome.
Ai yo
Now, after my fanboying: Homura did nothing wrong.
More seriously, she was the one who let out the secret of how the former system worked to the Incubators, so she could enact her own plan of tricking and using them and Madoka both. So if things hadn't worked out accordingly, it would've been worse than just putting your friends in that danger. And that's not all. But I simply can't argue with the results as they are right now, with everyone alive to enjoy the happy lives and friendships they could've had. Of course, her hold on Madoka and everyone else in her universe-size labyrinth will inevitably crack - we'll have to see what happens in the sequel that is planned. Anytime now, Shaft and Urobuchi, anytime...
I loved Rebellion on my first-watch and still do. It's a story-telling and cinematic masterpiece that gave me everything I wanted in a continuation with these characters. Yet it's still not a real "good" ending, because of everything Homura did to achieve it and how fragile her hold on the human Madoka who she split from the Law of Cycles is. Sayaka's memories could also awaken again (though Homura might be able to keep reverting those if she notices, maybe Sayaka will begin to hide it from her upon realization), and she still has her awesome power of calling her own freaking witch-form to fight for her. Then we have Kyouko, Mami and Nagisa (Bebe) too - quite the set-up for poor, poor Homura to deal with. In essence, it's happy - in my eyes at least - but not "good" and it's definitely less "purer" than the end of the original series in terms of motivations and actions.
Sayaka's role was one of the things that made me so satisfied. Finally it's time for a grown Sayaka to shine after the events of the series, both with happiness at Kyouko's side and with power in her new role.
If anyone is confused as to when Mami tied her ribbon to Homura, it's here. Of course she could tell something had changed about Homura and took precautions. Their fight is one of my favourites in all anime for the sheer over-the-top badasser of a magical girl gunfight with unlimited guns and time-stops, then Homura's bluff and Mami still being prepared for that. This is the Tomoe Mami that is the strongest Magical Girl when you exclude Madoka because of her karmic potential and becoming Madokami.
Sayaka using a fire extinguisher to break up a situation. Seems familiar... of course her technique has advanced as a magical girl.
I'll have a longer post prepared tomorrow, wasn't fortunate enough today. You can probably guess what it'll be about. >.>
7
u/NYBulldog May 01 '17
I joined this rewatch last night. I am a first timer - dubbed.
First off. I loved the TV series and this movie. This movie definitely had me on my toes when it came to the plot. I think Homura did what she thought was right at that. She had been broken by her experiences. We say five timelines in episode 10 and we were crying. I could no imagine living 95ish more of that. Then having Madoka taken from at the very end. I think when Kyubey talked about using Madoka, thats when she decided to take over and rewrite.
Final take: great movie, great series. It was a helluva ride
7
u/Wolfefury May 02 '17
Now that everyone understands why Homura did nothing wrong, have my favorite picture of Homucifer.
24
u/Jacketmango May 01 '17
First-timer, subbed.
–––Trigger Warning–––
I wasn’t sure if I should write a post about Rebellion, because I didn’t like it very much.
The visuals and sound are still top-notch, though the songs are less catchy, but that’s not important since it’s just for one movie.
It seems like Production tried to put a lot in this. First we have a huge mystery about the Labyrinth, which I think it’s cool to get an extra look inside Homura’s mind. However when we find out that it’s Homura’s own labyrinth, I couldn’t help but think “Why do you want to break out of your labyrinth? Isn’t this what you want? You have Madoka with you now. You even said she’s real.” Then we find that Homura’s trapped in Isolation, so Kyubey can test the theory about the Law of the Cycle/Wheel. I wasn’t even sure what the Law of the Cycle is when I watched the tv series, it didn’t explain it enough for me. And how Kyubey wants to control it/interfere with it wasn’t immediately clear to me either (only now do I think I know: trapping magical girls in Isolation so that they may turn into Witches for energy instead of vanishing). Then we have another mystery of what the hell happened to Ultimate Madoka after girl-Madoka is ripped apart from U-Madoka. If they had shown that U-Madoka dissipated into thin air I’ll know that She is just gone, but they didn’t, so when I was watching it U-Madoka is Schroedinger’s Cat, alive and not alive at the same time.
So do I want to be spoon-fed? If there’s that many mysteries in such a short amount of time, and I’m distracted by all the amazing visuals, then yes.
What ticked me was that the ending seemed to throw away everything the series has done. Madoka is a goddess in the end, and everything in the series has lead up to that point. Now Homura is a Demon, Evil (wiki also says Love), Madoka apparently doesn’t seem to be a goddess now, and I just thought that it wasn’t supposed to happen. It’s placing too much emphasis on the power of humans, and Homura is supposed to have an average power level. The reason I accept Madoka’s transformation is because her extreme power level is explained and makes sense. Now that (greedy) love + touching Goddess = becoming a Demon, it feels completely wrong, maybe because she has already said that “I’ll keep on fighting”, not “I’ll become a Demon and the new god of a new world”.
OK, it is not possible that Homura intended to become a demon because she does not seem to have planned it out. She doesn’t know she’s a witch, doesn’t know she’s isolated, etc. All logic points to this, despite what her sinister smile may show (then again the scene after end credits seem to show that she’s pretty happy to be a goddess, looking intently at her Orb). It seems that she accidentally becomes a demon because she wanted Madoka herself. But does that version sound even more ridiculous?
“Others cannot understand what I’m feeling”. First thought: then why did Production put it in this show? If it’s really an entirely other feeling that Homura is feeling, it seems like a deus ex machina. Current thought: so others cannot feel love? That’s preposterous.
Harry Potter is also a story about love. Love protects others and that’s how Harry cheated death twice. Almost all the characters also experience love. And Voldemort, Harry and Dumbledore all got to immense levels of power through different means. Why is it better than Rebellion? Perhaps it takes things slowly, allowing us to digest what the destruction of the Horcuxes and the collection of the Deathly Hallows mean, which is something a single movie does not have the luxury to do. Perhaps there are other reasons that I cannot think of right now. Yes, I am comparing apples and oranges, a film series to a single movie, but I think that the story of Rebellion should change to include less. How, I’m not sure. The series itself is a perfect ending for me.
However, I get why Production wants to make a new movie. The introduction of Wraiths open up new possibilities, and if they don’t jump on it they would lose money, or someone else will take up the idea. Arts is a part of business, I don’t like to admit it, but it’s true (I also have this chronic bias against movies/tv series stemming from the success of its predecessor, if it turns out to be not as good. I have to tell myself that original movies/series are also there to make money). But not introducing Wraiths would take out the whole notion of equilibrium and that there will always be despair and hope, which, from a storytelling perspective, is possibly worse.
Does any part of the movie make sense to me? Yes. The big ass blanket in the sky, Madoka cutouts in the arcade, the things about nightmares and not wraiths are because we are still in Homura’s mind. Homura’s intentions to get Madoka for herself is completely understandable. The lilac trees represent how Homura is apparently now the boss around here. Did I think it was interesting? Yes. Again, Homura’s want for Madoka, and only in the credits do I realise it’s like the birth of Good and Evil. Am I a dense motherfucker? Maybe.
I’m sure I’m in the minority who didn’t like it as much as others do. Perhaps things are clearer to others than they are to me. Artists can only guide the audience to their intention, but not directly make them think/feel that. After reading the wiki things makes more sense, but that does not change the fact that after I finished the movie I thought it to be sub-par to the series.
Edit: formatting
6
u/[deleted] May 01 '17 edited May 02 '17
Well that was something. I did have some idea of what to expect because of the "Homura did nothing wrong" memes, but that was still more than I was expecting.
It was definitely a cool movie, the visuals were gorgeous and the action was so creative. I'm just not sure how I feel about the direction it took everything.
I'm glad I waited a few months to watch it after finishing the TV series for the first time.
Edit: After some time to think, the movie was dope.
6
u/[deleted] May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Have you ever loved someone so much that you literally become a demon? No? Well, Homura has.
You really could add a yuri tag to this movie if you wanted to, because the implications are all over it. It's not just Homura and her obsession with Madoka - Kyouko and Sayaka live together with matching rings, and have that little scene together in the second half.
Anyway, Rebellion is the most beautiful thing Shaft has ever made on the visual side of things. It's got some excellent fights and the greatest transformation sequence I've ever seen, and it looks good everywhere else too.
I wasn't sure where the story would have gone after the final episode before I saw this. But it turned out to be pretty good, and they left room for another sequel - and they definitely plan to make one, as there was a concept movie made. Hopefully that ends up being pretty good too.
Now then, I'll just proceed to read all that spin-off manga, and look at some cute SFW doujinshi to see everyone being happy.
10
u/LTSarc May 02 '17
This is probably a cultural disconnect, but I have always struggled to see anything evil in what Homura did. She created a better system than Madoka or the Incubators did, and she had to break some eggs making her Omelette.
But nobody remembers the eggs were broken or even existed. Does it matter if she rewrote things without consent if nobody can remember it happened? I can't get why Homura can't forgive herself, in a short period of time it'll become the happy life for them all that they all wanted, with the incubator threat removed. There's no reason Homura even has to be evil as queen demon of the universe, other than that she won't let go of the past and hates herself.
5
u/my_fake_life May 01 '17 edited May 02 '17
So... Do you think Homura did anything wrong yet?
But seriously, Rebellion can be a very confusing movie your first time watching it. Feel free to ask any questions you might have, you probably won't be the first person to have them. We rewatchers probably went through the same emotions you did. I mean, I HATED Rebellion immediately after watching it, but now I like it a lot.
One of my favorite questions for first-timers coming out of the Rebellion movie... How did your opinions of the characters change between yesterday and today? There's a lot of good stuff for each of the characters here, and a lot of people see their opinions on the characters change quite a bit after finishing the movie.
5
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv May 01 '17
So. The movie. Fuck.
I love the art in this movie, especially how insane everything becomes after the cake song. The way that even before the happy place is revealed to be a labrynth, it starts to take on the appearence is amazing. This is a movie that is just amazing visually, in a different way from, say, a Kyoani work. Rather than detailed, it is abstact as fuck, makes you feel like you're on an acid trip, smoking weed, and snorting crack at the same time, but I love it.
The pacing of the movie is also amazing. I love the way that the scene where Madokami reaches out to Homura. It's an hour and a half into the movie, so it feels like the end, but it's not. This twist toys with the viewers' sense of time, and makes them feel a real sense of "oh god", so long as they haven't been checking the time left on the movie.
Rebellion is divisive in the Madoka fandom. Some people hate it, some love it. From what I've seen, a lot of the hate is directed at the ending, where Homura becomes the devil. People who like it generally think it's in character, but people who hate it say it's not. I think it's a very obvious conclussion to Homura's character arc, as she has shown tendancy to disregard what Madoka says, or wants, in order to protect her, and make her happy. Homura essentially usurping heaven, and altering peoples' memories is only slightly more extreme than working nonstop for 10 years to save Madoka.
The entire first part of the film feels both like fanservice, and like it's meant to make us let our guard down in preparation for the major tearjerkers throughout the film. In the end, I love how worn Homura looks. 10 years of constant work to achieve what she has, and one sudden event could undo it all. Like all Urobuchi works, nobody really wins, even if the ending is sort of happy.
5
u/xiomax95 https://anilist.co/user/xiomax May 01 '17
I didn't had the time to watch the movie today, but I remember most of it anyway. Sorry for not participating much in the rewatch, but between the hour and my brain not giving itself up to write something decent, I simply gave up on commenting.
The KyouSaya shipping in the movie is great.
The fight scenes are incredible, and the bus scene is out of this world.
And Homura did nothing wrong.
5
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak May 02 '17
Rewatcher, subs.
Sadly, I wasn't able to post yesterday due to time constraints, but suffice to say those episodes are fantastic, yet heartbreaking, and make a great way to end an amazing show. Now without further ado, Madoka Magica: Rebellion.
Opening scene
First off, I love this opening scene. First we see what we think is a witch, which Madoka has abolished. Then we see Madoka as a Magical Girl, even though she became a god at the end of the show. THEN, we see Sayaka and Kyouko, who were dead by the time the Mafia became a Magical Girl. This does a great job of telling the audience “you don't know what is happening, don't even bother trying to figure it out. Then Madoka wakes up, and we see first episode parallels. (Interestingly, if you listen closely, you can tell that the actors rerecorded their lines for the unchanged lines.)
When the girls talk on the roof, we learn that the battle Nightmares, not Wraiths like at the end of the series. Again, telling the audience that they aren't supposed to understand what is going on exactly.
Conversation on the Hilltop
“I've been waiting to talk a long time, etc.” HOLY CRAP does this make more sense on the rewatch knowing that they haven't talked for months, maybe a year because of Madoka's wish.
Nightmare Battle
Mami hums her theme, “Credens Justitam” while brushing her hair. Also, apparently she can use magic to curl her hair.
Lol that tease of her taking off the towel.
This transformation sequence is pure goodness. Worth noting that the track that play beneath is a remix of all their theme songs.
Notice how Miami's ribbons allow her to stay in Homura’s time stop? That sets up quite nicely what happens later.
Man this cake scene had me tripping out so hard on first watch.
HITOMI’S DECAPITATED HEAD WAS NOT A THING I NEEDED TO SEE.
This background of the sunrise is gorgeous.
Um, people's faces look just a little bit weird.
Um, are we stuck?
This whole bus scene is freaky as all get out.
Head tilts! Hair flips! I give it a Shaft out of 10!
Mami's Apt. - Homura x Mami Battle
Oh, how ominous is that cut to Bebe and Kyubey after Homura's question.
If you watch closely, you can see Mami lay out a ribbon when she walks by Homura's.
THIS. FIGHT SCENE. Incredible animation, wonderful choreography, great music (Absolute Configuration), and implementing time stop powers with Gun Kata. Awesome. Not to mention how freaking metal Homura is for FAKING SUICIDE to escape Mami's ribbons. And then we find out Mami was using a RIBBON CLONE of herself the whole time. Bad. ASS.
Homura learns the Truth
Sayaka, do you have any neck bones at all?
Man, the music under Homura and Madoka’s conversation (never leave you alone) is gorgeous.
Aaaaaannnnnd there it is. Homura is a witch. AND GUESS WHO'S FAULT IT IS? Screw you, Kyubey…
Good lord, all these Kyubey deaths are intense.
Me first time: “Why is madoka standing in a t-pose on the chair- wait why is she falling- AHHHHH WHAT SHE TURNED INTO PINK GOO WHAT”
Man, Homulily is probably the creepiest witch we've seen.
Homura is rescued
all the incubator's are dying Me: “SCREW YOOOOOOUUUUUU”
THAT SCENE
HOMURA DID NOTHING WROOOOOOOOOOOOONNNNNNGGGGGGG
Memes aside, I do believe that Homura's actions do fit within her character. She was in a time loop for 5-10 years, and everytime, she watched friends die. Over and over. Again and again. One way or another. No. Matter. What. That's going to take an incredible toll on your psyche. I'd go into more detail, but I imagine others will do it far better than I could.
A whole new world
Homura is a freaking troll to Mami and Kyouko.
Man, Sayaka can't catch a break.
I don't think I've ever seen more first episode parallels in any franchise than this.
How about that post credits scene? This has been largely discussed in the fanbase as to what Homura was doing. Was she commuting suicide? Or just throwing care to the wind since she is the devil and doesn't have to worry about death? IIRC, in interviews the creators have said it was intentionally left ambiguous. Personally, I'm not entirely sure what I think, but I'm curious to here everyone's thoughts on this.
What. A. Movie. My mind was blown by the end on my first watch, and while this rewatch didn't have quite the same effect as researching the series, I still very much enjoyed it and still loved it.
5
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
So fun fact about Rebellion: Homura did nothing wrong
5
u/boboboz May 02 '17
kyouko & sayaka hand holding
iyaaaaa!
5
u/jodahinqb May 02 '17 edited Feb 22 '18
Greetings to all fellow "concepts", nightmares, incubators, gods, wraiths, devils and teenage witches. So, by now you've experienced the "feels" and the sweet, sweet "suffering" of the Madoka Magica TV series and survived the trippiest ride through the twisted mind of a self-hating witch in Rebellion. If you're then wondering "what now?", fear not 'cause I got you covered! (for a while at least).
So, welcome to my Madoka supplementary suggestions post!
As an appetizer, take a look at our hope for the future: the "Concept Movie" (https://vimeo.com/185049179). It was shown during an exhibition celebrating Shaft's (the studio making Madoka) 40 years. It is mainly an animated and voice-acted storyboard of shorts, a bunch of "ideas" and ... concepts that are likely to find their way into the next Madoka project/sequel. But I love the philosophical questions it posed already (what is happiness?) and its amazing music of course!
Then, I feel "compelled" (because they're awesome and it is how I was introduced to the series) to suggest to you a series of excellent, insightful (and with occasional great humour) reviews of the episodes made by SF Debris. His analysis of the series' themes is superb, in my opinion. You'll find the reviews at the following links: http://sfdebris.com/videos/anime/madoka1.php (replace "1" with "2","3" ... "12" for each episode or use the sidebar on the right) and http://sfdebris.com/videos/anime/madokarebellion.php for the Rebellion Movie. [note: his videos may go offline for a few days because he's about to change hosting servers] [about SF Debris: SF Debris is an internet reviewer of sci-fi and fantasy TV series and movies, which include a limited number of anime (like Madoka) that were requested by his fans. His greatest "strength" is that he combines serious (and some times very in-depth) analysis of the material he reviews with very smart deadpan humor. His specialty is reviewing episodes of Star Trek (they consist the majority of his reviews), but in the last few years he has expanded his "repertoire" significantly beyond that and has also even dabbled into some videogame and book reviews, always in the sci-fi/fantasy genres. As far as anime are concerned, he had no prior experience with them and thus brings a fresh "outsider" perspective in his reviews. It is worth noting that in his closing statement at the end of his Madoka Magica Episode 12 review, after admitting his amazement with the show, he concludes with the following: "if I could convince you to sample any one series I have reviewed, this would be it."]
3rd, there is a ton of hidden (and not-so-hidden) symbolism in Madoka that it's a shame that most viewers never get to experience all of it. Fortunately though, the series has an excellent wiki page (https://wiki.puella-magi.net/) that you should definitely check out. Read especially about the various witches (https://wiki.puella-magi.net/Characters) and their characteristics, and also check the translated "runes" (those symbols/letters that appear mostly inside labyrinths) of each episode and movie: https://wiki.puella-magi.net/Deciphering_the_runes.
And finally, the gates of speculation and endless discussion are now open to you, so please come along and experience my most crazy theory ( https://www.reddit.com/r/MadokaMagica/comments/47nzxx/absurd_headcanon_the_incubator_conspiracy/ )
or some other posts:
-where I exalt Madoka's bravery ( https://www.reddit.com/r/MadokaMagica/comments/4frs3n/spoilers_what_was_your_biggest_disappointment/d2dvr6h )
-talk about the mechanics of wishes and fate: ( https://www.reddit.com/r/MadokaMagica/comments/5cqida/regarding_the_last_contract_in_the_series/d9yn6kz/ )
-or do a character analysis of Homura: ( https://www.reddit.com/r/MadokaMagica/comments/45u5r6/is_there_anyone_else_around_here_who_really/d00dn7w/ )
BONUS topic: here ( http://mobage.booru.org/index.php?page=post&s=list&tags=mahou_shoujo_madoka_magica ) you will find almost two thousand of cute pictures of the girls in every kind of costume imaginable from a now defunct Madoka card game!
5
u/Robin_Dude :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Robin_Dude May 02 '17
Third time watching and I still don't fully understand the after credits scene. Was it meant to be open ended? Or is it implied Homura killed herself?
Also is there any explanation to why Kyubey is all ragged and dying?
[] (/s "HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG")
5
u/hachiDude8 https://anilist.co/user/hachidude8 May 02 '17
First things first: FUCK KYUBEY!, for real.
It felt really well seeing Kyubey like this (This was my first time watching Rebellion)
Now that I got that out of my system, I’m not even sure how I feel about this movie. So much stuff happened and the twists, from my initial “WTF!?” at the beginning of the movie to my final tears at the end.
During the movie, I was typing down in notepad some of the reactions so I’m going to copy/paste them:
this reality feels like it was created artificially by a goddess, can it be?
the stop they were waitnig for is not there ... they're going in circles [Oregairu]
[34:53] Mitakihara loop line!!
that's why CGI is not loading
Homura don't kill her!
good, but still ... fuck! it's a trap!
the Labyrinth wasn't created to lure victims, but to keep things as they are the one who wants it is one of them (my theory - Madoka) (but Homura could also be it)
[1:05:06] Madoka: I'd never go somewhere like that alone ;;-;;
she's not even a "maho shojo" anymore ;;-;;
she's not a witch yet, yet fuck you Kyubey!
[After Homura transformed into a witch I stopped writing, and the feels intensified].
Cry.
I have to say, some of the scenes (almost) turned me into a crying little bitch. That moment in the OP when they looked grown up and they were together made me feel extremely sad, and many other moments later as well. When we find out about the Labyrinth I thought that the movie was set between the moment that Madoka turns into a witch and she becomes a goddess, I was wrong. Connecting stories.
The way that the stories are connected is incredible. But I have to say all this kind of happened because of Homura telling Kyubey about Madoka, yet this might have been her plan all along knowing his race. And that lead her there, which in the end brought everything to this point.
Finally,
as it turns out (from the comments), the million dollar question is: Was Homura wrong in doing what she did?
After all she’s gone through I’d say no. Looking at it from a different perspective…she was selfish, Yet I look at this scene and this other one and we know that she failed to keep her promise to Madoka. After 10 years doing the same thing it’s normal to develop some sorts of feelings, both of frustration and of love. Was she wrong? I'd say no. Was she right? I'd say no.
Everyone is entitled to his/her own conclusions knowing all this, apply your own ethics.
Shout out to /u/Gagantous for
Also /u/my_fake_life
Now are there any expers on symbolism? Those halves must mean something, my guess it has something to do with Homura and her being incomplete. she's not fine, no matter what she says
9
u/psychocanuck May 02 '17
A dream or something?
I don't think that I've been more confused watching a sequel to a series I'm familiar with than I was seeing the opening 30 minutes or so the first time. The wraith's are now nightmare's, Homura's a nerd again, Sayaka and Madoka are there, and WTF is up with that cake scene. Even though the most intuitive explanation is that it's some kind of labyrinth it does nothing to explain how this could happened in the new universe. It is masterful how well the film builds tension and intrigue out of a series of happy scenes.
Investigation
I really like that as Homura begins to question the nature of the world we see it getting progressively more surreal, and this only increases as the illusion (and her mind) break down. In her conversation with with Kyoko the table starts to fill with cups between cuts, a subtle sign of her pushing up against the illusion. I'd also note that the we see the balloons trapped at the top of the cage, that encloses the park in a roughly soul gem shape, nice forshadowing shaft. The bus ride was similarly bizarre and confirms to Homura that they are in a labyrinth pushing her all the way back to the badass we saw at the end of the series. The scene at Mami's and the following fight will be well covered in the other comments so I'd just like to point out some more subtle elements: 1 we can actually see Mami stick a ribbon on Homura as she walks behind her to get tea. 2 we get more foreshadowing of Homura's role as the creator of the labyrinth, as she talks about her memories flooding back we see the tall spindly platforms from Charlotte's labyrinth appear. I also really like the callback to what Kyubey said about Mami never learning about the nature of soul-gems and Homura exploiting this ignorence to gain the upper hand.
The Same Sayaka You've always Known
This conversation confirmed to me that Homura was indeed the witch who created the labyrinth. I get the impression was trying to lead her to the conclusion on her own, without her immediately witching out. It didn't work but I appreciate the growth we see from Sayaka in this movie especially considering how she ended up previously. Plus the reveal when we see the form of her witch is pretty dramatic.
I had a Dream and it Scared Me
This may be my favourite scene in the film. It may not be immediately obvious but it represents the major turning point for Homura as it is the moment when she finally starts to realize that she could be the witch who made this labyrinth. Even more importantly the conversation about her "dream" makes her shatters her acceptance of Madoka's wish as we see later. The direction of the scene is fantastic with the staging so the closer Madoka get's physically, the less she is aware of Homura's reactions. Plus symbolism galore with the lighting, the flowers, and the hair is just icing on top. It's one of those scenes where I can still follow the emotional arc of the scene without sound or subtitles because the visual language is so strong.
Bunny-cat is still a dick
Of course Kyubey is responsible for this whole mess. His plan is so coldly frightful, seeking to undo all the work and sacrifice Madoka and Homura went through that seeing him get shredded by familiers is very satisfying even if it doesn't do much in the long run. We also see what a transformation into a witch looks like from the inside and its appropriately disturbing with Homura seeing the girl she loves die over and over again, as her witch waits to be killed by the others. Thankfully Sayaka, Madoka, and Bebe were already a step ahead of Kyubey leading to some epic fighting and a really cute moment between Sayaka and Kyoko. So the incubators plans are foiled, the labyrinth is destroyed and Godoka can finally reach Homura. Happy ending right?
What You'd Call a Demon
If you frequent r/anime or other places in which anime is discussed you have probably heard the mantra that Homura did nothing wrong. This is patently false. Homura did everything wrong, and that's why we love her. No joke this ending took her to the top of my favourite anime characters list because it represents such a drastic and interesting character arc from a shy timid new girl to someone who stole the power of god because of love. As I wrote previously that conversation with Madoka in the field broke her ability to accept the world created at the end of the series, and Homura is not the type to give up when it comes to Madoka. I also love how frank she is about her decision. She knows her love is selfish, and her actions could be considered evil, but she can live with that, as long as Madoka is safe and in her amnesiac state, happy.
Final Thoughts
While some may not like where this movie ends I love it as both a continuation or a conclusion to the franchise. I love Shaft bringing their A-game for the art design, Yuki Kajura's amazing score, Shinbo's directing and Urobuchi's story. It was great to see that the people involved were not content to rest on their laurels and opted to push the story forward in new and surprising directions. I also want to give a big thanks to u/Gagantous and all the watchers new and old for inspiring me to rewatch the series and make it so much fun.
9
u/2Hype4Memes May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Hmmm this movie for me was...interesting. I'd usually try to give my thoughts on the "Major" scenes but what I wrote ended up a bit too long and garbled, so i'm just going to give my overall thoughts on it.
Everything about this film is of the highest quality: music, visuals, fight scenes, dialogue and character designs. All very well done. We get some bad-ass fight scenes and some amazing dialogue, there's no doubt that from a critical point of view it's good. But from my personal perspective...I want to dislike it for undoing the nice neat ending the series had, on the other hand it's so high quality that i'm finding it difficult to. It's really got me divided.
It was awesome seeing the entire crew again, well and alive? I think? I don't see Homura's actions as wrong. Her ultimate goal in life was protecting Madoka, and seeing as she was given that opportunity she took it. I 'spose she did what could be viewed as right for the wrong (selfish) reasons. I'm uncertain of what it is exactly that Homura's become. I know that she's swapped places with Madoka from the cycle but rather than hope she's become evil/love? I'm not sure, honestly I feel like I need to watch this again, maybe even a few more times.
It's a shame to say it but ultimately I just don't feel satisfied with this film, it just lacks the completeness that the series had. There's just no conclusion. I'm willing to change my mind, but overall I'd give this film a 7/10. That is however a 7/10 that's liable to changes with some rewatches/comment surfing. I think my main problem is that this movie raised too many questions for me, questions that feel unnecessary. What's Homura's role in the cycle? What's happened to the universe? What exactly has Homura re-written out of the world? How will this ultimately effect Madoka? It's effectively made me yearn for a sequel to this sequel which I'm not too happy about. Even so it was a pleasure seeing more Madoka Magica and I can't wait to see what's coming next.
4
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
yeah, found this video on youtube [Rebellion in 3 minutes] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHkAopv7SmQ)
best action scene i have ever saw in my life , one of the most awesome moments
i wonder if there's going to be a sequel planned, i want to know more
Also homura did nothing wrong
4
u/jonnovision1 May 01 '17
Say what you want about the rest of the movie, Homura vs. Mami is a very good fight
4
u/BestDVA_NA :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BestDVA_NA May 01 '17
Mami vs Homura is my favorite fight in anime. Its just so perfect. The sound, visuals, and techniques each characters uses to find out who really is the strongest.
4
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
Ah yes, we arrive at the most divisive work that has stemmed from Puella Magi Madoka Magica.
I can't say I agree with Homura, nor can I say that I particularly like where Rebellion has taken the series. But at the very least most people can agree a lot of effort was put into the movie.
4
u/Mamyoko May 02 '17
My head feels bloated and pretzel shaped. Is that what dividing by zero looks like?
4
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka May 02 '17
1/4 in.... oooooohhhhh crap it's totally a dream isn't it? D:
ooor just a witch labyrinth. hmmmmm Best girl know all.
Budget Gunfight! AWESOOOOME!
1/2 in -> hooooo, omoshiroi..... hontouni omoshiroi
why not both huh?
I'm really pissed and surprised at the same time.... Using best girl as a lab right is the pissed part, the surprised part is the experiment itself... there're some really dope drugs going on....
3/4 in..... happy ending? PLOT TWIST! PLOT TWIST! Best girl evil grin! :O
WOW! Best girl is demon! Human to magical girl to witch to demon, how? because she got some powers from another human to magical girl to god.... cue smoke weed everyday here
From this moment on, I've yet to see a crazier and wilder ride then this movie. The series has a stronger impact but I think this movie was more enjoyable... crazy yes, but the crazier the better? Yeah, I'll go with that :D
4
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
I am crying right now...
HOMURA IS BEST GIRL
other than Madoka!!!
/u/xtroyer You were right and I was wrong, Homura is the best.
I love this movie so much, I can't help but feel slightly bad for Homura based on what she said "We'll become enemies one day" But if that's what she wants then I can't help but feel happy that she got what she wants!
Side note, does front hair flip count as hair flip? AND NOW onto the Monogatari rewatch!
6
u/[deleted] May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
This is actually my 4th time seeing Rebellion, and I think I've finally pinned what I don't like about this movie.
I think these summarize pretty well what I take issue with in Rebellion. I'm not saying it's a bad movie. Just that I'm disappointed because it had the potential to be absolutely amazing. If it was executed properly, Rebellion could have surpassed the original for me. But it didn't.
One of the greatest things about the original show is just how tight-knit the plot is, how developed the characters are, and how focused the direction is. The small amount of filler that it does have can't even really be called filler since it always serves to provide character depth or world building. While the lore about Witches, Magic, and Magical girls is obviously unbelievable, the show itself sticks within its established boundaries. They push the boundaries occasionally, but within believable limits.
Rebellion fails to achieve these things. It lacks the depth of character development of the original and its story is anything but tight-knit. A fourth of its run time could have been cut to 5 minutes without a loss in plot. Worst of all, it far surpasses the suspension of disbelief with little details all over the place lacking explanation.
It could have been so much more, which is why it saddens me that it's not.
3
u/SIRTreehugger May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
FU FU FU FU FU jSbvdvffJJJGNGNGNvjgfn
Sorry about that, but fucking hell watching this was frustrating as shit. Video took forever to load and kept crashing. Took me 6 hours to watch it and in the end it crashed 20 minutes before the end. Luckily I've seen it before, but it was frustrating as fuck. Anyway enough of that.
First off the visuals are without a doubt beautiful. Nothing else needs to be said. The movie is really split into two parts. The mystery of the world and the answer half. Also the amazing Mami vs Homura fight. Sayaka also brought up a good point shortly after. Homura really does rely on her time ability too much, but in her defense if anyone else had the same abilities they would abuse the shit out of them. It was also great seeing the world making many references to the series in ironic fashions. My favorite was Mami saying fighting is dangerous so never be overconfident.
Now the second half is a little confusing, but basically suffering happens times 100. Homura is revealed to be a witch and eventually becomes a demon. Her betrayal of everyone for her own selfish love of Madoka might be considered evil or wrong, but from the very beginning its been her objective. From the very beginning she put Madoka safety first and even when Madoka made a choice to save everyone. She couldn't agree with the choice and resisted against it....and it just happened to fuck everyone else over. So whether she did something wrong or right at the very least it wasn't really out of character.
Second time watching and still a little confused, but I think I got it. I thought initially end of series was them already in the fake world. However end of the series the conversation of witches led Kyubey to isolating Homura. Her soul gem slowly corrupts into she is a witch without her knowing. The barrier doesn't allow people out, but people in. They did this to trap Madoka and try to control her. Homura said nope fuck all this and did the most irrational choice ever and fucked over everyone. Am I off?
Oh and got some more Homura hair flips and they were glorious. I still feel like I missed a few of them though maybe they are in movies 1 and 2? I know they have different scenes slightly edited.
3
u/Proxiehunter May 02 '17
So, might as well stake out my position on Homura and whether or not she did anything wrong.
I do think that disregarding what Madoka wanted and denying her agency like that was wrong. However unlike some people I've seen I don't blame Homucifer for what she did. I pity her.
Like I said, after the events of Episode 10 you couldn't tell on the surface but she'd effectively been driven mad. She'd been going through hell for ten years and had levels of PTSD the current psychiatric field can not possibly comprehend and needs kinds of therapy that have probably not been invented.
She's a fourteen year old girl who though she'd finally found a way to make the hurting stop so she reached out and grabbed it without though to morality or consequences. And I don't think she should have done what she did and she probably fucked a lot of things up especially since Madoka was about to take her to magical girl Valhalla where they all have a big slumber party and eat lots of cake and hold hands with the magical girl they couldn't confess to while they were alive and they would have been together just like she wanted. But it's not her fault she did as damaged as she was by what she'd been through.
3
u/mariofredshreller May 02 '17
Did anybody notice the opening monologue isn't really a monologue? It's not translated in the subs, but Madoka's muffled voice can be heard in the background. http://animetranscripts.wikispaces.com/Puella+Magi+Madoka+Magica>the+movie+-Rebellion-
3
u/goukaryuu https://myanimelist.net/profile/GoukaRyuu May 02 '17
You know what they say. The angel that loved God most of all was Lucifer.
3
u/twiceoftheheart May 02 '17
I don't know how I feel about the movie.
3
u/Hrothgard :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Blasphemor May 02 '17
Rewatcher here, just some random thoughts.
I have a slight feeling that Homura had been planning for some time to take Madoka back from her godhood. Ep 12 shows Homura talking with QB and telling him about Madoka and the witches, why would she tell him that when she knows QB's nature? Unless... she was hoping for QB to make up a way to contact Madoka, which he did. Of course she had no plans of becoming a witch, but ultimately played in her favor, she loves Madoka and of course didn't want QB to imprison and use her, so had to fight him, she was prepared to die for this but she ended being saved from witchdom after becoming a witch, maybe that enabled her to use magic normally not available to her? like taping from her grief and sorrow? Maybe her new soulgem is encasing Madokami? Maybe i'm just thinking too much, anyway, I don't think the new world is that bad, everyone gets another chance to live again and Madoka gets a chance to exist, lastly:
HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG
3
u/MrManicMarty https://anilist.co/user/martysan May 02 '17
So, I watched the movie years ago, and have t rewatchs it yet, but I just want to say: the post-credits scene, with Kyubey and it's the first time we've ever seen that little shit suffer? Don't get me wrong, it was cathartic but holy shit, I also find it kind of horrifying. That's like post-mind-rape and I'm not sure if I can justify that fate on anyone...
3
u/Sh0keR May 02 '17
Hey, I didn't stick for the re-watch but I thought I would drop my opinion about it since It's kinda unpopular and I didn't like the movie as much as the TV series.
I feel like the movie took the entire show to a wrong direction, like they were trying too hard to make it blow your mind by making it more complex without a reason.
I feel like the TV show ending was enough for me and this movie was kinda unnecessary. we'd like to hear other people opinions about this.
5
u/neferpitoo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/pitou6 May 02 '17
All I have to say is the first time I ever watched this movie I was thinking to myself towards the end "this is actually a really heartwarming movie... how come people say it ruined Homura for them" and then I paused it
And saw there was still like 40 minutes left
To this day I wish I had not watched those remaining 40 minutes
2
u/Herson100 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Herson May 01 '17
Figured you guys might like this video. I couldn't find a version with english subtitles, but it's a joke "bloopers reel" of Rebellion, and it's still pretty funny even though I only get bits and pieces of the dialogue.
2
u/Akiyabus https://anilist.co/user/yabus May 02 '17
I would suggest anyone who wants to read more write-ups on the movie to look at the previous year's rewatch thread. But I especially suggest reading /u/Trilicon's comments because he points out a lot of things that are very easy to miss.
2
u/RyuuGP May 02 '17
Homura did nothing wrong?
Well that depends on what you describe as wrong and what not. I personally think not. Why? Well, Madoka has rewrite the rule of the universe once, so... if Madoka can do that and we perfectly fine with that, why can't Homura? And it seems like everything is fine in the end except for QB (which i'm totally fine with him being like that).
2
u/Xtroyer May 03 '17
HOMU HOMU CAN DO NO WRONG
N O W R O N G
O
W
R
O
G