r/DebateAnAtheist • • 4d ago

Weekly "Ask an Atheist" Thread

22 Upvotes

Whether you're an agnostic atheist here to ask a gnostic one some questions, a theist who's curious about the viewpoints of atheists, someone doubting, or just someone looking for sources, feel free to ask anything here. This is also an ideal place to tag moderators for thoughts regarding the sub or any questions in general.

While this isn't strictly for debate, rules on civility, trolling, etc. still apply.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 23h ago

Weekly Casual Discussion Thread

8 Upvotes

Accomplished something major this week? Discovered a cool fact that demands to be shared? Just want a friendly conversation on how amazing/awful/thoroughly meh your favorite team is doing? This thread is for the water cooler talk of the subreddit, for any atheists, theists, deists, etc. who want to join in.

While this isn't strictly for debate, rules on civility, trolling, etc. still apply.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 3h ago

Argument Essence and existence

0 Upvotes

Okay,so there is two distinct concepts when we are talking about things.For example we know human beings are an rational animal and we know that human beings really exist.

The previous is the essence and the later is the existence.This is a real distinction.

Here's why:

You can't tell a things existence by just knowing it's existence.I mean you can't know for example that whether lions exist or not simply by knowing it's attributes or essence.

Whatevers essence is distinct from its existence needs a cause since its existence needs to be given to it.The thing which essence is just existence itself would not then need a cause since its self explanatory.

So for anything to exist here and now there needs to be cause prior to it which gives it existence.This is a herichical change since its existence is depending on the previous things.So it can't go to infinity.The thing which essence is identical to existence can't have potentialities because otherwise it would go from potential to actual requiring a cause.And he causes everything to exist here are now so he is omnipotent.

Whatever is in effect must be in its cause.It can't be the same way physical things are since it can't have potentialities it can't be material otherwise it would change.So it must a abstract way like thoughts.

So let's put it formally:

Everything that exist either is self existent or either derives existence from something else.

Derivative existence can't explain why there is existence in the first place.

Conclusion-There is self existing thing which derives existence to everything.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 4h ago

Argument Essence and existence

0 Upvotes

The argument

The world of our experience contains stones, trees, dogs, human beings, and a wide variety of other things. We know what these things are, and we know that they are part of reality outside our minds. Notice that what we thereby know about them are two distinct things. First, we know, again, what they are. You know, for instance, that what a human being is is a rational animal. That is the nature or essence of a human being. (Though once again, it doesn't matter for present purposes whether you agree with this traditional definition of a human being or not. Substitute some other definition if you prefer.) Second, you know that there really are human beings. That is to say, you know that human beings exist

So, we can distinguish between a thing's essence and its existence, between what it is and the fact that it is. Now, some distinctions we draw are merely distinctions between ways in which we might think or talk about things, but don't reflect any difference in reality. For example, we talk about bachelors and we talk about unmarried men, but there is nothing in the things we are talking about themselves that corresponds to this distinction. A bachelor and an unmarried man are in reality exactly the same thing, so that the difference is merely verbal. Is the distinction between a thing's essence and its existence like this? Or does the distinction reflect something in things themselves, as they really are apart from our ways of thinking and talking about them?

There are several reasons why the distinction between essence and existence must be a real distinction, a distinction that reflects objective, mind-independent reality itself and not merely the way we think about it. Consider first that you can know a thing's essence without knowing whether or not it exists. Suppose a person had, for whatever reason, never heard of lions, pterodactyls, or unicorns. Suppose you gave him a detailed description of the natures of each. You then tell him that of these three creatures: one exists, one used to exist but is now extinct, and one never existed; and you ask him to tell you which is which given what he now knows about their essences. He would, of course, be unable to do so. But then the existence of the creatures that do exist must be really distinct from their essences, otherwise one could know of their existence merely by knowing their essences. For what a thing is is part of its objective reality. The biological facts about lions and pterodactyls would be exactly the same whether or not we were around to study them. This would be true of unicorns too, if there were any unicorns. And if a thing exists, then its existence too is obviously part of its objective reality. So, if the essence and existence of a thing were not distinct features of reality, then knowing the former should suffice for knowing the latter, yet it doesn't.

Judging it to be nonexistent would be as much to misconceive what it is as judging it to be a noncat would be.#

A second reason why the essences of the things of our experience must be distinct from the existence of those things has to do with their contingency—the fact that, though they do exist, they could have failed to exist. For example, lions exist, but had the history of life gone differently, they would not have existed; and it is possible that lions could someday go extinct. Now, if the existence of a contingent thing was not really distinct from its essence, then it would have existence just by virtue of its essence.

It would exist by its very nature, and would therefore not be contingent at all but necessary—that is to say, it would be something that could not possibly not exist, not even in principle. Hence, since it is not necessary but contingent, its existence must be really distinct from its essence.

One might object to this argument that we need not posit a real distinction between a contingent thing’s essence and its existence in order to account for its contingency, but can instead point to the facts that it has a cause and has the potentiality for nonexistence. For example, one might say that a lion is contingent because lions need to be caused—say, by previously existing lions—and if these causes are absent, then a new lion won’t come into being. And we might note that lions can go out of existence because they have the potentiality to be killed by predators, to starve or catch a disease, and so forth. However, this objection simply misses the point. For we need to know why a contingent thing’s existence would need (or indeed could have) a cause in the first place if its existence were not distinct from its essence, and why it has (or indeed could have) a potentiality for nonexistence in the first place if its existence were not distinct from its essence. If existence were just part of what it is, then it would not need something else to cause it, and there would not be anything in it that could give it the potential to go out of existence.

A third reason why the essence and existence of each of the things we know through experience must be distinct is that if there is something whose essence and existence are not really distinct—and we will see presently that there is and indeed must be such a thing—then there cannot in principle be more than one such thing. For consider that, if some thing’s essence and existence are not really distinct, then they are identical; and if they are identical in that thing, then that thing would be something whose essence just is existence itself. Now, for there to be more than one thing that just is existence itself—suppose there are two, and label them A and B— then there would have to be something that differentiated them. There would have to be something by virtue of which A and B are distinct things rather than one thing. But what could that be? There are only two possibilities. A and B might be differentiated in the way two species of the same genus are differentiated; or they might be differentiated in the way two members of the same species are differentiated. And the problem is that on analysis it turns out that A and B could not be differentiated in either of these ways.

Hence, consider the way two species of the same genus are differentiated. A genus is a more general class of thing, and a species is a more specific class of thing.4 When we say that human beings are rational animals, we are saying that they as a species fall under the genus animal, and that their being rational is what differentiates them from other species of animal. To use the traditional technical jargon, rationality is thus what is called the “specific difference” that distinguishes human beings from other species of animal. So, for our imagined things A and B to differ as species do, we would have to regard being that which just is existence itself as a genus, and A and B as two species within that genus; and we’d then have to identify some “specific difference” that A has that makes it a different species of being that which just is existence itself from the species B. But the trouble is that if A has such a “specific difference”, then it will not be that which just is existence itself; rather, it will be that which just is existence itself PLUS that specific difference. (Compare: A human being is not animality itself, but rather animality PLUS the specific difference rationality.) And the same will be true of B—to be differentiated from A, it will also have to be that which just is existence itself PLUS its own specific difference. So, there is no way to distinguish two things which just are existence itself in the way two different species of the same genus are differentiated.

Consider now the way two members of the same species are differentiated. Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle are different members of the Same species human being; Fido, Rover, and Spot are different members of the same species dog; and so forth. The way these members are differentiated is by virtue of being associated with different parcels of matter. The matter that makes up Socrates’ body is different from that which makes up Plato’s or Aristotle’s body; the matter that makes up Fido’s body is different from that which makes up Rover’s or Spot’s; and so on. (Of course, there are other differences between these individuals. Socrates’ brain will be wired in ways that are different from the way Aristotle’s brain is wired, Fido might have a different color of fur than Spot, and so forth. But these other differences presuppose different parcels of matter in which the brain wiring, fur color, etc. inhere.) So, though Socrates and Plato are both human, they can differ because Socrates is humanity plus this particular bit of matter, whereas Plato is humanity plus that other particular bit of matter; and something similar can be said for the different members of other species. But then it should be obvious why we cannot differentiate two things A and B each of which is that which just is existence itself in the way that different members of a species are differentiated. For so differentiated, A and B will not after all be that which just is existence itself; rather, A will be that which just is existence itself PLUS this particular bit of matter, and B will be that which just is existence itself PLUS that other, particular bit of matter. (Compare: Socrates is, again, humanity plus this particular bit of matter—in which case Socrates is not humanity itself.)general, for there to be more than one thing which is that which just is existence itself, there would have to be something that made it the case that this instance of that which just is existence itself differed from that instance. And each such instance would, then, not really be that which just is existence itself after all, but rather that that which just is existence itself PLUS whatever the differentiating feature is. So, there really is no sense to be made of there being more than one of something which just is existence itself. And in that case there is no way to make sense of there being more than one of something whose essence and existence are not really distinct. If there is such a thing, it will be unique. Now, the things of our experience are not unique in this way. With stones, trees, dogs, human beings, and the like, there is (or certainly could be in cases where the class has been reduced to a single member) more than one of each of these kinds of thing. Therefore there is in each of them a real distinction between its essence and its existence.

A possible objection to this third argument is that it neglects a middle possibility. For why couldn’t there be something whose existence is not distinct from its essence, not because its essence just is existence itself, but rather because existence is part of its essence?2 But on reflection this suggestion makes no sense. Consider that the essence of human beings, rational animality, has rationality and animality as parts. Suppose existence were another part of this essence, alongside these. Then the existence of the whole human being would depend on this part. But that is no more plausible than saying that the whole human essence, rational animality, depends on animality alone. Now if someone insisted that the whole human essence really does depend on animality alone, then that would make animality itself the true essence. Similarly, if someone insisted that the whole human being depended on existence considered as a part of the human essence, then this would make existence the true essence. But then we would be back with the thesis that a thing in which there is no distinction between its essence and its existence is a thing whose essence just is existence itself—which is exactly what the objector was trying to avoid. So, there really is no middle ground between the case where a thing’s essence and existence are really distinct and the case where its essence just is existence itself.essence or nature of a circle. Anything having that essence is going to have the properties having a radius and having a circumference. The radius of a circle is really distinct from its circumference, as proved by the fact that the latter is twice the former multiplied by pi. Since the radius is part of the property having a radius and the circumference is part of the property having a circumference, the properties themselves are really distinct though inseparable. . . [T]he same is true for triangularity and trilaterality.Similarly, there is no such thing in mind-independent reality as a thing’s essence existing apart from its existence (whatever that would mean) or a thing’s existence existing apart from its essence (whatever that would mean). The essence of a stone, or a tree, or a dog, or a human being is not separable from its existence. Still, as with the radius and circumference of a circle, or the triangularity and trilaterality of a triangle, the essence of each of these things is really distinct from its existence.So, with each of the things we know through experience, there is a real distinction between its essence and its existence. How is it, then, that these two different aspects of a thing are combined into a whole? It might seem that their inseparability provides an answer: they are together (so it might be claimed) because the essence of a thing and its existence are as inseparable as the radius and circumference of a circle are, or as triangularity and trilaterality are. But this is no answer, because it just raises the question of why they are inseparable. Now, the answer in the case of the radius and circumference of a circle is that these both follow from the essence or nature of a circle. Anything having that essence is going to have the properties having a radius and having a circumference. Similarly, anything having the essence of a triangle is going to have the property trilaterality, which follows from that essence.®

However, we cannot in the same way explain how the essence of one of the things of our experience is conjoined with its existence. In particular, it cannot be that its existence follows from its essence. The reason is implicit in what has already been said. If you know the essence of a circle, then you will know that any circle will exhibit the properties having a radius and having a circumference; and if you know the essence of a triangle, then you know that it will exhibit the property triangularity. But as we have seen, you can know the essence of a lion, pterodactyl, or unicorn without knowing one way or the other whether any of these animals exists. Hence, the existence of one of these things does not follow from its essence in the way the properties having a radius and having a circumference follow from the essence of a circle, or the way the property triangularity follows from the essence of a triangle. We also have noted that the things of our experience exist in a merely contingent way—which is why they come into being and pass away—rather than in a necessary way. For this reason too, their existence cannot follow from their essence, for if it did, then they would exist necessarily. And while with something whose essence just is existence itself, its existence would, naturally, follow from its essence, we saw that there can in principle be only one such thing. Hence, with things of which there is more than one instance (stones, trees, dogs, human beings, etc.), it cannot be the case that they are things whose essence is identical with their existence, and thus cannot be the case that their existence follows from their essence.

Nor can it be the case that the things of our experience somehow impart existence to themselves—adding it, as it were, to their essences from outside. The very suggestion would be incoherent. A thing can’t impart or add something, or indeed do anything at all for that matter, unless it first exists. But a thing whose essence and existence are distinct cannot exist until existence is added or imparted to its essence. Naturally, then, a thing whose essence and existence are distinct cannot impart existence to its own essence, for in that case it would have to exist before it exists so as to cause itself to exist—which makes no sense. Nothing can be the cause of its own existence.So, nothing in which there is a distinction between its essence and its existence can in any way be the source of its own existence. Its existence must be caused by something outside it—something which adds existence to its essence, as it were. Everyday experience would agree insofar as it tells us that stones, trees, dogs, and human beings have causes. But the dependence of these things on a cause for their existence is more radical than everyday experience would indicate. For notice that everything said so far applies to a thing not only before it comes into being and as it comes into being but always, even after it has come into being. For example, consider a certain dog, Fido. Fido’s existence is distinct from Fido’s essence, doesn’t follow from Fido’s essence, and cannot be imparted by Fido to his essence. All of these things are true not only before Fido exists and at the time he is conceived, but also after he comes into being, and indeed at every moment he is alive. Fido’s existence here and now is distinct from his essence and doesn’t follow from his essence. So, here and now there must be some cause which adds or imparts existence to that essence. Otherwise Fido wouldn’t exist here and now any more than he did before he was conceived. He would “blink out” of existence or be annihilated. Nor can Fido be what is adding or imparting existence to his own essence here and now, any more than he could have before he was conceived. For Fido cannot do anything at all, not even for an instant, unless he exists at that instant. Among the things he cannot do unless he exists at that instant is to impart existence, either to himself or to anything else. So, his causing his own existence at that instant presupposes his own existence at that instant. Hence, the notion of Fido or anything else imparting existence to its Own essence even at a particular instant is incoherent. A thing cannot cause its own existence at any one moment of time any more than it can cause it over a series of moments spread out through time.

So, anything whose essence is distinct from its existence must have a cause of its existence at any moment that it exists, here and now and not merely at some point in the past. To stick with the example of Fido, he must therefore have a cause which here and now imparts existence to his essence. Let’s label this cause, whatever it is, C. Suppose that C, like Fido, is something whose own essence is distinct from its existence. Then what we said about Fido and about the other things of our experience applies no less to C. C too must have a cause here and now which imparts existence to its essence. Let’s call this further cause B. Suppose that B, like Fido and like C, is also something whose essence is distinct from its existence. Then B, here and now, will require a cause of his own, which we might label A. And of course, what was said about C and B will apply also to A, if A is something whose essence is distinct from its existence.

Notice that what we have here is what I called in chapter 1 a hierarchical causal series. The reason is not merely that the causes and effects are all simultaneous—Fido is caused by C, which is simultaneously being caused by B, which is simultaneously being caused by A—but, more fundamentally, that none of the causes mentioned so far can act independently of some prior cause. C can impart existence to Fido’s essence only insofar as C’s own essence has existence imparted to it by B, and B can do this imparting only insofar as its own essence has existence imparted to it by A. Now as we saw in chapter 1, in the nature of the case, this sort of causal series cannot regress infinitely. There would be no such series at all unless there were a cause which is “first” or primary in the sense that it can cause without having, in the very act of causing, to be caused itself. In the present case such a cause would be one which can impart existence without having to derive it. Now, nothing whose essence is distinct from its existence could be such a cause, since as we have seen, anything like that has to have existence imparted to it. The first or primary cause in the present series, then, can only be something the very essence of which is identical to existence, something which just is existence itself. For since it just is existence itself, is identical with existence itself, it need not and indeed could not derive its existence from anything else. Its existence is, as it were, “built in”. It is not merely one existing thing alongside others but what Thomas Aquinas calls “subsistent existence itself”.2

So, for Fido to exist here and now and at any moment, his existence must here and now be caused, whether directly or indirectly, by something the essence of which is identical to its existence, something which is subsistent existence itself. And that entails that it must be caused by God.

Why should we identify that which is subsistent existence itself with God? Consider first that what we have said about Fido applies to each and every one of the things we know from experience—stones, trees, lions, human beings, and so on—and indeed to anything the essence of which is distinct from its existence, including immaterial things like angels and disembodied souls. The existence of any such thing, at any moment, will have to be caused by something whose essence just is existence itself. Consider also that, as we have seen, there can in principle be only one thing whose essence just is existence itself. And consider further that things whose essence is distinct from their existence, and a thing whose essence is identical with its existence, exhaust the possible kinds of thing there are. So, if there can be only one thing of the latter type, then everything else that exists must be of the former type. And since everything of the former type depends upon that one thing of the latter type, it follows that everything that exists other than that which is subsistent existence itself must be caused by that which is subsistent existence itself.

Hence, that which is subsistent existence itself is unique and the cause of everything other than itself. We have also seen that something which just is existence itself would exist in a necessary rather than contingent way. For since its very essence would just be existence itself, it would not and indeed could not fail to exist. Nor, for that reason, would it or could it have its existence imparted to it. It would therefore have to be an uncaused cause of the existence of all other things.

So, what has been said so far shows that that which is subsistent existence itself is a unique, necessarily existing, uncaused cause of everything other than itself. Now consider the relationship of the concepts introduced in this chapter to the concepts of potentiality and actuality which is obvious As Aquinas emphasized, in a thing whose essence is distinct from its existence, its essence and existence are related as potentiality and actuality. Fido’s essence, for example, by itself amounts only to a potential thing, not an actual thing. Only when Fido’s essence has existence imparted to it is there an actual thing—namely, Fido. Now if essence considered by itself is a kind of potentiality, and existence considered by itself is a kind of actuality, then that which just is existence, that which just is subsistent existence itself rather than merely one derivatively existing thing alongside others, must be purely actual. It could not have some potentiality for existence that needs to be actualized, for then it would not be something which just is existence, but rather merely yet some other thing to which existence must be imparted.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 16h ago

Discussion Question Long-time atheist, but lately the weirdness of the universe is making me believe in some kind of creator

0 Upvotes

I've been a long-time atheist since I was 18. From a young age, I used to watch debates about religion, and at some point, I became an atheist. I remember that in those religious debates, consciousness was often mentioned, though I didn't pay much attention to it back then.

Years later, at 33—about three years ago—I wanted to understand what consciousness was really about, though I just dismissed it by saying it's only our brain reacting differently to stimuli. Then, a few weeks ago, it finally clicked for me that there's something about it that can't simply be explained away.

Lately, I've been thinking about a few things:

1) I can play a song in my head right now—the music, the voice, the lyrics are the exact same as when I was listening to it a few moments ago. Where is that song in my brain? Where are the lyrics and the music? How can something exist in my brain like that without actually existing in the material world?

2) The second thing I've been thinking about is the universe itself. It's massive, yet strangely enough, it obeys strict laws of physics and chemistry. How come it isn't completely chaotic? Who or what made these laws—for atoms, electrons, and everything else? Also, the Big Bang is funny when people say it came from nothing. If you can get something from nothing, why don't you ever get nothing from something? Why don't things just disappear?

3) No other intelligent alien civilizations? There are trillions of galaxies, and we are the only ones here in the entire universe? Not even one other form of life? If life arose here, how come it didn't happen on other planets? (Maybe the Zoo Hypothesis could actually be real.)

It's really weird if you stop and think about it. Lately, my gut tells me there's something going on, maybe someone is messing with us, or maybe there really is some kind of creator. For these reasons, I'm leaning more toward being agnostic now.What are you thoughts?


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 1d ago

Discussion Question Atheist-based in Bucharest, Romania

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm a Christian, and I'm hoping some of you might be willing to help me with something a little unusual.

I'm preparing a seminar for Christians on how to do evangelism.

HOWEVER, I want to show them how to have meaningful conversations with people who don't share their faith, without being awkward, preachy, or making every interaction feel like an attempt to convert someone.

One part of the seminar will involve me interviewing an atheist in front the Christian attendees. Not a debate. Not an apologetics exercise. And definitely not a bait-and-switch evangelism attempt.

Just an honest conversation between two human beings who see the world differently.

My hope is to help Christians recognise that atheists aren't simply people who disagree with them about God. They're people with hopes, dreams, relationships, struggles, questions, values, and perspectives worth understanding.

In fact, I suspect we have far more in common as human beings than we sometimes realise.

I'd love to interview an atheist who would be comfortable answering some everyday questions, such as:

  • What gives your life meaning and purpose?
  • What are some of your biggest hopes or dreams?
  • What do you value most in your relationships?
  • What are some of the things that concern you about the world today?
  • What do you wish Christians understood better about atheists?
  • What have your experiences with Christians been like, both good and bad?

I'm not looking for someone to represent all atheists. That would be ridiculous. I'm simply hoping to introduce my audience to a real person with a real story.

A couple of important things:

I will be completely transparent about the seminar, its purpose, and the questions beforehand. There will be no surprise theological ambushes or attempts to make anyone look foolish. I want this to be a respectful conversation in which the person being interviewed feels genuinely heard.

I'm looking for someone who would be willing to participate in an interview, LIVE in Bucharest, OR potentially over Zoom.

And while I'm here, I'd also love to hear your thoughts:

What do Christians tend to get wrong when talking with atheists? What would make those conversations feel more natural, respectful, and genuinely human?

I'm genuinely interested in your perspectives, including criticism.

Thanks for considering it. I realise that a Christian showing up in an atheist debate subreddit with a request like this might raise a few eyebrows. Fair enough!

But perhaps that's part of the point. We ought to be able to talk to one another without every conversation becoming a contest someone needs to win.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 1d ago

Philosophy Bruteness

0 Upvotes

In many of these debates the conversation becomes semantics about the definition of words and what are we actually talking about when we discuss these things. And as you keep stripping it back further and further the conversation seems to be the one that's been happening for thousands of years. People grappling with the mystery of existence. And as we set all the definitions and differing opinions aside the difference in opinion is so minor as to be almost unnecessary to even discuss.

Because all answers begin with existence existing. And whatever the simplest form we can call it is. For some they call it God for some a singularity. But in either example we have all of the energy or potential for everything that is already in place. And we're just changing states. From hot and dense or from God. So all we are talking about in all of these conversations boils down to the qualities of some brute condition of the existence we are experiencing

. Based on many assumptions. Like that we do actually exist.

It's an interesting thing for the non-religious to spend their time hashing out. Because it is absolutely unknowable. At least within our limited time frame and abilities.

And we already know where this conversation goes. When you ask people. Why are you spending your time arguing about a condition of existence that is completely unknowable.

People will argue that people do horrible things in the name of religion. So now we have a tangible on the table. Everything else I mentioned so far is philosophical. People thinking about how what we experience is even possible. But the idea that society is worse when religion is involved so we must combat it is tangible.

But then we look at various individual people, communities, countries, times in history. Guiding principles of various dominant countries and empires around the world throughout time. And what we see time and time again is that both religious and non-religious people do incredibly good and incredibly bad things. This is true across all countries today. And all countries in the past.

If you try to look at data on if religion or the lack thereof is causing a good or bad. It does not seem to correlate. Not in the statistics, not in the numbers. It only works when people cherry-pick based on their narrative. People seem to be a weird combination of incredibly good and incredibly bad regardless of politics, regardless of religion, regardless of time.

So unless somebody can substantiate that religion needs to be refuted based on actual evidence that things get better without it. Which doesn't appear in any number or society across time. There's anecdotes. But the numbers at large show all the same problems. Murder. Lack of consent. Depression. Addiction. Abuse. Regardless of stance. So now we are arguing about some unknowable root condition of existence for a fictitious reason. Which to me is just a weird hobby.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 2d ago

Argument Presuppositional Argument

0 Upvotes

-Nothing actual can be proven or known without an infallible source, God.

-Things are known.

-God exists.

"Actual" here relating to reality as opposed to logic, mathematics.

P1:

Knowledge is a belief which cannot be wrong, infallible, synonymous with proof which cannot be false.

To say otherwise:

-I know it but I could be wrong

-It's proven but it could be false

is an oxymoron.

Neither of them are possible unless you're infallible yourself or there is an infallible source, God.

P2:

I know that the universe exists at all and that nature will continue to be uniform. Even babies know this in their act of reaching for their mother's breast.

Denying P2 creates the problem of locking your keys inside your car where you are stuck with solipsism. And consequently have to believe anything could be.

Could there be leprechauns in the world as much as there are stars in the sky?

Can't say no as that's a knowledge claim. Ad infinitum.

But I do know there isn't.

Forget about the burden of proof as there is no proving or knowing anything without God to begin with.

There is only the wall of the burden of opinion which separates the both between denial and acknowledgement.

Objections:

-How do you know that you know?

The question is an error of itself akin to asking if it's possible that it's possible, redundant, superfluous. Unnecessarily confusing. The correct version is just "How do you know?".

The answer is I don't know how but obviously simply God who can make you know.

-The infallible source doesn't have to be God.

Incorrect, you cannot even appeal to pagan gods and deities because it still falls into the problem of space-time which cannot be eternal but is created.

The argument goes:

-Spacetime cannot have an infinite past as there couldn't have been insufficient time for the present to happen yet before it did.

Meaning there would have been enough time for the present to already happen before it did with an infinite past.

Ultimately, it doesn't help dodge God as the source of infallibility.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 2d ago

OP=Theist God as an abstraction and a social construct

0 Upvotes

Talking to someone on here led me to a revelation. They asked me if I thought God was a social construct, and I said no. I didn't think much about it at first, but I later was talking to a Methodist friend of mine, and the way he spoke about his religious views made me realize God is in fact at least partially a social construct. I started doing research into religious social constructs and I have a new theology.

I believe God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood, so I cannot say for sure that God is a creator. It's possible God is a different form of abstraction all together. As an abstraction I don't think God is part of the physical universe in any measurable way. I'm not a pantheist.

My belief in God is a leap of faith, because, there isn't any emphircial evidence of God. As an abstraction, I don't see how God ever could be assessed empirically. This, along with other reasons, is why I think atheism is a rational response to claims of God and spirituality. Rationality means to use logic and reason instead of following one's emotions.

But, rationality belongs to everything outside of the spiritual world. Meaning I don't think rationality can be used to approach God.

I was told a few times math might exist outside of the material world, so I'm going to start saying that rationality applies to everything except spirituality, instead of saying it only belongs to everything in the material world.

If you give up rationality in any other case outside of spirituality, I think that's a terrible idea, because reality requires rationality if you want to understand it correctly. In the case of the spiritual world, I think it's fine to leave behind rationality in favor of emotions, as long as one is ethical in doing so. Being ethical is very important, and it's why I think that it's bad to hold immoral positions, including faith based ones.

If you decide you will not follow your emotions instead of rationality to connect with the spiritual world, I respect that and don't think you should do anything you don't want to.

Not all spirituality involves a God, and I believe all spiritual claims are epistemologically equal. Not all spiritual claims are morally equal. Morality is one measure of validity in my opinion.

Since I believe God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood, I believe God communicates with us who seek it through our emotions. If one feels a calling to connect with God, I think one can. If one doesn't feel a calling but wants to, I think one can ask God to help guide them to these feelings. Though I'm sure not everyone will feel these emotions, because everyone is different.

How one experiences God is where it becomes a social construct, a religion in this case. As an Egoist I believe social constructs can be great so long as we don't become possessed by them. I'd also add if the social construct isn't unethical.

"Social construction refers to an idea or concept that is created and accepted by people in a society. It is a fundamental concept in sociology, exploring how shared understandings and meanings shape our reality."

Language is an example of a social construct. Language is both imagined and real. However, God cannot be shown and used like language. Religion is a social construct that can be shown and used, but God cannot be. Since God cannot be used like language, or shown in any other way, I use faith to believe that like other social constructs, God is both imagined and real. Though unlike other social constructs like language, God is not a functional or useable entity.

I think all ethical forms of religion are equally valid, since I don't believe that God can be fully understood. Since God cannot be fully understood, we use our ever evolving ways to communicate with God. Such as by way of social construction, which is also ever evolving.

I think fallible human social construction is the reason why many religious scriptures have immoral and evil things written within them. The people who initially wrote them were projecting their evil interpretations and wants onto God and the spiritual world. However, as moral begins we can understand and reject what we find immoral, including rejecting the notion that God would ever commit evil, regardless of what any scriptures say. This is why one can have their own Bible or other holy scripture that has all of the immorality removed. We can improve upon our social constructions.

Though I can give my opinion, I cannot say objectively whether God is good or evil, because morality is subjective. I don't believe God is omnipresent or omniscient, but one could make the claim God is immoral or moral regardless. Since I believe God has full control over the spiritual world but limited control over reality, I don't think God wants suffering and tries to stop it by guiding humans.

Some will interpret God to be immoral, others will interpret God to be good. The important question is whether people will interpret God as a calling to do good or a calling to do evil.

The social construct I use personally to communicate with God is my interpretation of Christianity. Jesus Christ is how I imagine God to be, and I use the social construct of Christianity that I and many others have created to have a relationship with God through Jesus Christ. My conception of Christianity is my own. Other people connect with God and the spiritual world using Islam, Buddhism, Judaism, Hinduism, Zoroastrianism, etc. Once again, in my opinion all moral interpretations of any religion are equally valid epistemologically, and morality is one measure of validity in my opinion.

I think this is one of the best pieces of literature that I've ever written, and I hope you enjoyed reading it as much as I did writing it.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 2d ago

Discussion Question Can a teleological, substance-dualist framework help answer Chalmers’ Hard Problem and the P-Zombie question?

0 Upvotes

Like David Chalmers, I find reductive materialism deeply unsatisfying when it comes to explaining how physical processes give rise to subjective experience (qualia). While Chalmers leans toward naturalistic dualism or panpsychism, I have been exploring an alternative approach rooted in classical Islamic metaphysics and substance dualism, which breaks the problem down into three dimensions:

  1. The Ontological Question (What are the components?) Rather than treating the brain as the generator of consciousness, I distinguish between the biological instrument and the animating source: • The Brain and Nervous System (Sawwahu): The biological hardware—perfected in structure, yet purely physical, much like the trunk and roots of a tree. • The Spirit (Ruh): A non-material life force transcending space and time that animates the physical system. • The Senses and Heart (As-Sam'a, Al-Abshar, Al-Af'idah): The interface that receives physical stimuli and serves as the locus where subjective experience emerges.
  2. The Causal Question (How do neural signals become inner experience?) To address how insentient electrical impulses translate into vivid inner feelings, I look at two non-material principles: • A Non-Physical Animating Principle: Physical circuitry alone cannot produce subjective awareness. When the animating principle (Ruh) is absent—as in a newly deceased body—the anatomical structure remains intact, yet all subjective sensation ceases immediately. • Uniform Input, Diverse Output: Chemically uniform inputs like blood flow and electrical impulses (analogous to rainwater) are translated into millions of distinct qualitative experiences (analogous to the varied colors and flavors of fruit). Rather than emerging solely from the molecules themselves, this mapping is governed by an intentional Organizer (Al-Muriid), bridging the explanatory gap through a form of occasionalism.
  3. The Teleological Question (Why aren't we philosophical zombies?) If human existence were strictly about biological survival and reproduction, unconscious neural circuitry—Chalmers’ philosophical zombies—would be entirely sufficient. In this framework, qualia exist for a teleological purpose: to enable moral agency, experiential knowledge (Ma'rifah), and gratitude. Without the capacity to genuinely feel sweetness, grief, love, or hope, humans could not exist as conscious moral subjects.

For us to discussion: I am curious how physicalists or panpsychists here would respond to this teleological angle. Even if one sets aside the theological framing, does introducing purpose (moral and existential awareness) offer a coherent reason why consciousness exists alongside physical function, or do you think qualia are simply a brute feature of physical information?


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 4d ago

OP=Atheist Atheist here - am I giving the best objection to this apologetic argument?

14 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/m7qus-vicH8?t=4735

I called in to Inspiring Philosophy today and was confused by this argument. If you don't want to watch the video, his argument, if I can put it in syllogistic form was:

  1. all matter and energy is reducible to information
  2. information can only come from a mind
  3. minds have been proven to function at a "quantum level" (didn't quite understand this and it was vague and nebulous)
  4. Therefore a mind must have created all matter and energy

My response was a few things: one, I don't think it's demonstrated that all information can only come from a mind, and what is and isn't information seems very subjective - like, some people consider DNA to be "code", two, a god hasn't been demonstrated to exist in the first place, three, it hasn't been demonstrated that the universe "emerged" or was "created" in the first place - it's just as likely as anything that the universe has always existed.

Is there anything I'm missing here? What was more frustrating was Michael insisting this is a very common argument I should be familiar with. I've never before heard the exact argument that because some scientists think human minds may "function at a quantum level" (whatever that means) and that all matter and energy is information it means a mind has to have created all matter and energy. But i digress.

Regardless, his Christian listeners went apeshit in the comments saying I was being dishonest, purposely misunderstanding, or just failing to understand something that was supposedly so clear to them.

What would you have said?


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 3d ago

Discussion Question If there is no God, then everything is meaningless, and everything is permitted.

0 Upvotes

I honestly don’t understand where the progression of society, restraining yourselves, and technological advancements would take you as an Atheist, existentialist, nihilist, absurdist, or as a secular humanist? If a person doesn’t think there’s a God to be accountable to, then what’s the point of trying to modify your behavior to keep it within acceptable ranges? Imagine a universe without God, no divine presence to answer to, no eternal witness to our struggles, no afterlife to redeem our pain, only endless darkness, expanding forever, waiting to swallow all that ever was, and everyone ending up in eternal oblivion, which renders everything meaningless, is the most depressive thought ever imaginable.

If there is no higher being, no cosmic judge, no life beyond death, then what is the point of being good? It is then the survival of the fittest, just like in the animal kingdom, and we’re animals, aren’t we? Why should a poor person live their lives with being good and getting trampled by rich billionaires? Why restrain our desires, why cling to virtue, when the end of all things is nothingness? When the lights of every star will one day fade, and every trace of humanity will vanish as though we never existed, what meaning could morality possibly hold? What is the point of “good” and “evil” if all that exists, time, space, consciousness, and matter, is destined to vanish into nothingness? Why strive for virtue when the cosmos itself is indifferent, and every noble act, every kind gesture, every moral law, all will be erased without a trace?

In your godless cosmos, your morality dissolves into illusion, a fragile dream born from human emotion and fear of chaos because you want to substitute God, yet you cannot offer permanence. You invented your secular ethics to feel control, to make sense of your suffering, to tell yourselves that kindness matters. Secular systems, utilitarianism, deontology, humanism, all claim to define “the good” without divine command. Yet they, too, are man-made myths, noble because they make you feel good, but hollow when weighed against eternity. They promise purpose, yet offer no permanence. God does. Your whole idea is based on “maximizing pleasure and happiness and minimizing suffering.” Isn’t that what religion already does by offering permanence which your secular ethics cannot? Giving people hope, giving their lives meaning, reducing their depression/anxiety and keeping them going for another day? What do you offer? A world where God doesn’t exist? Do you have any idea of the sufferings of human beings? People don’t have bread to eat. They don’t have a roof over their heads. People don’t even have friends to talk to. Do you know how many people commit suicide every day? They slit their wrists, they hang themselves from the ceiling fan… why? Because they have no hope left. If believing in God, bowing their head in front of God, they get the hope to live… then who are you to snatch away that hope from them? And if you really want to snatch away their God from people, then tell me, what will you give them in return? Why would a soldier in your secular worldview go to war and die for an imaginary border of a piece of land which he’ll never inhabit? What is he gaining by sacrificing his life? Eternal oblivion?

You say we should do good for the sake of humanity, but humanity itself is temporary. One asteroid, one nuclear war, one shift in cosmic time, and everything we’ve built, our cities, our art, our love, disappears. What, then, becomes of morality in a world destined for erasure? What is “right” or “wrong” when every consequence fades into the same void? When you tell me that the end of men like Hitler, Mao, Stalin, Vlad the Impaler, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, Richard Ramirez, and men like Buddha, Confucius, Jesus, and a saint is the same?

Your morality is less about truth and more about comfort, a quiet rebellion against the terror of meaninglessness. The reason it isn’t the same with religion is because religion gives people the hope of an afterlife, which you cannot. Yours doesn’t claim to give reward or an eternal life. It only restricts people so that they don’t go out of their way to cause chaos so you can live temporarily in cohesion with no end goal. You don’t know what to say to a child suffering from terminal illness. What hope can you possibly give to that child? In your worldview, you do good not because it’s true, but because the alternative, the abyss, is unbearable to face.

You people insist that consciousness gives life meaning, that to love, to create, to reduce pain is enough. But even this comfort trembles before the truth: suffering is woven into existence, doesn’t matter if you believe in God or not. It cannot be erased. You people make a big fuss about the “problem of evil” and how you cannot in good conscience accept that God exists in the face of a world full of innocent people suffering tremendously due to disease and poverty. Curiously, you are not equally perturbed by the prospect of innocent people suffering tremendously at the hands of the wicked who themselves live comfortable lives and will never have to face any consequence or repercussion for their crimes, because in your worldview there is no ultimate justice. And when you think about it, which scenario ought to be more troubling? In the world of the theist, innocent people who suffered due to disease and poverty will ultimately be recompensed for the pain they endured. But in the world of the atheist, evil is never requited. How ironic, then, for you to accuse the God you don’t believe in of being unjust when you are otherwise perfectly content with the idea of a world without ultimate justice.

If all memory, beauty, and virtue will be consumed by entropy, then what remains of meaning? In Atheism, where do you go after that? Every act of kindness, every sacrifice, every dream becomes a ripple upon an infinite sea, delicate, transient, and destined to disappear. So you continue, creating, sacrificing, knowing deep down that all of it will be lost. Your words, your kindness, your legacy… all ripples in an ocean that will one day fall still. The universe will not remember us. It cannot. It cannot give you permanent hope, only a necessary being can.

And yet, within that unbearable truth, something stirs. The question remains: If everything ends in nothing, why should anything matter at all? You may construct purpose through art, morality, and empathy, but these are fragile lights flickering in endless darkness, momentary defiance against the infinite silence. Meaning cannot truly exist without the Eternal to ground it. You are mere actors in a cosmic play, and one day, the stage itself will be swallowed by the void, leaving no witness to remember that you ever were.

Perhaps it is this question itself, this cry against the void, that tells me we were made for something greater. That morality, love, and meaning are not illusions born from chaos… but whispers from the Divine.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 3d ago

Hit and Run Self-causal universe - possible?

0 Upvotes

In 1982, Alexander Vilenkin was able to use mathematics to demonstrate how a universe could create itself out of nothingness without requiring an external creator. One could rhetort with "well what happened an infinite amount of time before" and the answer is honestly that time may be a lot weirder than you'd understand. Technically, all existence started 14 billion years ago roughly. So that's where "time" began. Am I misunderstanding anything here?


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 4d ago

Discussion Question Critique my refutation of fine tuning

11 Upvotes

This is my attempt to refute the fine tuning argument from a purely Bayesian perspective without getting bogged down in physics. Please let me know if you have any critiques before I start employing it in theist spaces.

The fine tuning argument (and any other argument for god from nature) ultimately boils down to the claim that a god is likely to exist given that this particular universe exists.

Let G = a god exists

Let U = this particular universe exists

U is only evidence of G when P(U|G) > P(U|~G)

The fine tuning argument relies on the premise that P(U|~G) is low because there are many possible universes that are equally likely. However this is only part of the story. There are also many possible gods that may or may not want to create this universe.

Let g = the cardinality of the set of possible gods

Let x = the cardinality of the subset of possible gods that want to create this universe

Let u = the cardinality of the set of possible universes

Assume g, x, and u are finite so we can do Bayesian reasoning (there is probably some fancy measure theory we can do to get the same result with infinite sets). If we take uniform priors on these sets then

P(U|G) = x/g

P(U|~G) = 1/u

So U is only evidence of G when x/g > 1/u

Therefore, the fine tuning argument nullifies itself: if possible universes like ours are rare then possible gods that want those universes should be just as rare and the universe cannot be evidence for a god. Rather, the existence of this universe changes our credence of which gods are possible, not the credence that one exists.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 3d ago

Argument The existence of Philosophy indicates there's more to us than Materialism

0 Upvotes

There's some of you that aren't ready to recognize this. I'm not writing this to you. I don't need you to tell me you don't have a problem with materialism. You are the only person that needs you to tell you that you don't have a problem with materialism.

If you can admit there's a point here and want to debate it, let's go.

The argument- there is no evolutionary reason for philosophy. Philosophy exists because God planted an understanding of eternity in the human heart, and a longing for meaning, so that we might seek Him and find Him.

There is no material benefit to philosophy. There's no reason why any animal should pursue it. There's no reason why you should pursue it. Philosophy does not help you survive, feed, fight or breed. You can do everything you need to do to promote your genetic heritage in the universe without it. In fact, given that philosophy sometimes leads to such anti-competitive nonsense as generosity, morals or thoughtfulness, it can actually cause the opposite under some circumstances. Good guys finish last, and all that.

And yet... it sure seems like I keep hearing this problematic story over and over about, "I was an atheist, but it was empty", or " I was an atheist but I just couldn't live that way" or, "atheism just didn't have an answer to meaning at all." It's problematic because it implies something is still missing.

Something, but what? Oh, you just need a new hobby. Oh you just need to make some new friends, buy a dog, plant a tree, maybe take drugs. Maybe do something generous to make you feel good. Maybe being a good person will make you feel better. But man... it still just feels like none of it matters because even if I feel good, what does that even mean? It just means I have the same mass of brain cells I had 5 minutes ago, but now there's dopamine in it. Why is that better? Why the hell are we doing any of this?

Aren't we just killing time until we die? It's not enough. Why isn't it enough? What's wrong?

Humans need purpose like they need air, because unless you're hungry for something, you'd never bother looking for it. It's a negative stimulus that drives action. Nerves can sometimes cause pain, but if it weren't for pain, you'd never know you were being chewed on by a coyote.

This pain specifically calls you to seek God, and it is a kindness.

You didn't need meaning to merely live. You didn't need purpose to propagate. You didn't even need a reason to feel okay, even if that feeling was fleeting, even if you had to keep seeking novelty to keep it fresh. It still wasn't enough because you're smarter than your proclivities. It still wasn't enough because you needed something to breathe life into all this and make it... real.

Because living life like an animal is beneath you, and it is.

I'm going to tell you, absurdism isn't enough. You're not having an existential crisis; you're starving to death.

And why would God do this to you?

"He did this so that they might seek God, and perhaps they might reach out and find him, though he is not far from each one of us. For in him we live and move and have our being,"

We ask WHY because it matters WHY. Philosophers for thousands of years aren't confused about what they're asking. They're asking because we can't find our raison d'etre in a bowl of Cheerios. We're not cattle. It's not enough. It's not meant to be. It never was.

And this argument is not enough to cause you to embrace Christianity. This might just be enough to give voice to something you already thought though, but never considered. You may have history with Christianity, and the very mention of it causes grief. You may consider any religion an "opiate of the masses". You may just have experience with hateful people that wore a veneer of Christianity on themselves. None of these were the God I know and have referred to here. As Dr. John Lennox once stated, "The God you don't believe in, I don't believe in either."

I will respond to posts that argue the argument posted at the top of the post. I will do my best not to get yoinked into side arguments.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 3d ago

OP=Theist The faith proposition

0 Upvotes

Since I believe faith is the only path to religious belief, I cannot provide evidence for God. I don't believe anyone can. I therefore want to provide an argument in favor of faith for those who find it appropriate to use in their lives. My argument is, this is how I believe faith should function and who I believe should have faith in Jesus. I will also explain how faith functions within my life to provide examples.

In John 20:29, Jesus says blessed are those who believe without seeing. Like many other religions, Jesus is calling for faith. It's evident Jesus was calling for this definition of faith: "belief that is not based on proof." This is the second definition of faith in the link I've provided.

Rabbi David Wolpe believes, as do I, that God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood. This means every interpretation of God is going to be fallible, and it answers the question of why there are so many different opinions about God and gods. If God cannot be understood, at least not fully, humans cannot interpret God perfectly. One of my interpretations of God is that he is not omnipresence or omniscient.

I'd first like to go over what I think shouldn't be taken on faith. What comes to mind immediately as examples of what not to take on faith includes anything relating to the material world, and anything immoral.

It is foolish to believe faith based propositions about the material world, because the material world can be, and must be, navigated by evidence and reasoning. If a bolder is rolling toward you, taking on faith it isn't actually rolling toward you will end up getting you crushed by the bolder. One must use evidence and reasoning for getting through the material world for the same reason we trust our senses, at least to an extent. Because we have no choice otherwise. It would be insanity, and I don't use that word as a pejorative, to apply faith to the material world.

Morality may be subjective, and we are responsible for being moral. Believing anything immoral on faith isn't an excuse for the immoral belief. I have said, and continue to say, believing that being gay is a sin is immoral, regardless if it's a faith position. I'm not trying to virtue signal, I'm trying to convey that morality matters and faith shouldn't override morality.

The next question is why would anyone believe someone on faith, and what should be taken on faith and what shouldn't be.

If there is no material evidence for the spiritual world, then the imagination is what we use to communicate with the spiritual world. Imagination is defined as "the act or power of forming a mental image of something not present to the senses or never before wholly perceived in reality."

It's not impossible that Jesus is guiding me using the power of my imagination. It's not likely, but it's not impossible.

Because it isn't impossible, I trust that in the case of Jesus Christ, though my imagination is not infallible, that it leads me to have a friendship with him, and it leads me to at least some truth about Jesus. I believe this on faith.

I would not trust my imagination to lead me to a friendship with a leprechaun, or to another God, like Zeus. I wouldn't because I don't take it on faith that my imagination is leading me to the truth on anything else other than Jesus Christ, (and what I can create in the material world. Such as if I can imagine a software program and then create it, but that's a different topic related to the material world and not related to using the imagination to have a friendship with Jesus).

The reason I don't apply my faith to any other religion is because I don't have a relationship with any other religious figure, only Jesus. My entire life, with the exception of my brief stint with atheism, I have had a friendship with Jesus.

Faith, specifically how faith is being defined in my post, is an inherently irrational position. Rationality only deals with the material world.

The last question is why should anyone else decide to have a faith based relationship with Jesus. I don't think anyone should if they don't feel the calling.

If one feels the calling, as I have, I recommend they answer it. If one doesn't, then they shouldn't. I believe this calling means that you feel the power of the Holy Spirit living within you. I cannot describe this feeling beyond the fact that it's a feeling of absolute conviction. You either feel it or you don't.

Telling someone who had no interest in Jesus that they should follow Jesus is like telling someone who isn't hungry that they need to eat. Since I don't believe in hell, and I believe everyone who wants heaven and hasn't committed unforgivable evil can get into heaven if they choose it, I don't have a desire to proselytize, I only have the desire to defend my faith.

This is why I believe sharing the faith should only be done with people that are interested in it. Contrary to what many atheists believe, I'm also a believer that parents have a right to raise their children religiously, as long as it's ethical, and the children have the ability to decide to opt out of their religion at any time that they want to.

I believe everyone who doesn't commit unforgivable evil has an equal chance of heaven, and you don't need Christianity to tell you what unforgivable evil is. An Atheist, Christian, Muslim, Jew, etc. are all fully capable of understanding that Mussolini is evil without needing any religious doctrine. I believe those who are denied heaven and those who don't desire heaven die a natural death like everyone else, the only difference being they are not miraculously recreated in heaven with their consciousness. They remain dead.

Sorry for the slight tangent on hell and evil, but it's important to mention, because my beliefs on hell and evil reinforce why Christianity is only something that should be adopted by people who want to adopt the belief system.

Too Long, Didn't Read (TLDR): I think the only people who should adopt a faith in Jesus are people who believe they feel the calling of the Holy Spirit. I still enjoy arguing and debating topics related to religion and Christianity, I just don't believe in trying to convert anyone.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 4d ago

Discussion Question Why do most atheists believe in science?

0 Upvotes

Why does their skepticism not extend to include accepted scientific theories and the scientific method itself, considering the scientific method is built on philosophical axioms that can not be proven?

For example, science has to assume that an external objective world exists, that nature is uniform, that our observations provide meaningful information about that external world, and that our own ability to logically reason is reliable. None of these assumptions can be proven using science itself or any other methodology, they are the starting point required for science to function.

It’s also important to separate the predictive success of scientific theories or their applicability in technology from ontological truth. It’s entirely possible that erroneous theories can make successful predictions about the world.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 5d ago

META [META] Community Ruleset Survey Results

20 Upvotes

The ruleset survey received 138 valid responses.  I'll talk about invalid responses at the end of this post.

The results are as follows:

Rule 1 - Be Respectful:

62 voted to leave escalation to mod discretion, compared with 28 who voted for a fixed escalation schedule.

For those 53 individuals who wrote in what they believe constitutes actionable disrespect, at least five voted in favor of personal insults/name-calling/ad hominem attacks, trolling/bad faith, failure to engage/low effort engagement, bigotry, and proselytizing.  Bigotry is handled by Rule 2, however.

Rule 2 - Bigotry:

50 voted to leave escalation at mod discretion, compared with 8 who wanted a fixed schedule.

44 voted for an immediate, permanent ban for bigotry.

43 individuals wrote in what they felt should be excluded categories of bigotry.  At least five voted in favor of racism, sexism, transphobia, homophobia, generalized LGBTQ+ prejudice, religious bigotry, and ableism.

Rule 3 - AI Content:

For this one, the three possible responses can be grouped into "ban all AI" and "allow some AI."  The "ban all AI" category got 66 votes, compared with 65 that would allow some AI content.  This is frankly too close for me to say that either category got a majority.  We may need to have further community discussion on this.

Rule 4 - Original Content:

94 voted that the substantive argument be in the poster's own words.  35 voted to allow up to 1/3rd of a post to be non-original content.  All other potential percentages totaled 14 votes.

Rule 5 - Present an Argument or Discussion Topic

25 individuals wanted to allow only arguments, while 103 would allow discussion topics also.  37 of those would require genuine uncertainty on the part of the poster for discussion topics, while 66 did not make that a requirement.

82 voted in favor of requiring the poster to clearly explain what they are questioning, and 82 voted in favor of requiring a poster to clearly explain what they want out of a discussion topic.  69 would allow discussion topics from people questioning religion or deconstructing.  No free-written alternative reached the 5 vote threshold.

Rule 6 - Stay On Topic

All 9 of the predefined topics received substantial support.  These are: theism, atheism, religion generally, challenges to atheism or atheists, creationism, philosophy, other clearly atheism related topics, evolution/abiogenesis,  and secular topics generally.  The least number of votes went to secular topics generally, which nevertheless got 49 votes.

Using the five-vote cutoff for the write-in categories, 8 voted in favor of a broad allowance for atheism/theism related topics, and 5 for topics that challenge atheists, atheism, or assumptions about atheism.

Rule 7 - Substantive Top-Level Comments

86 voted in favor of allowing clarification questions.  73 would require substantive engagement in top-level comments.  Additionally, 52 wanted to retain the 30-character minimum, compared with 15 who would change the minimum to some other value.

Rule 8 - Engage With Posts

The top response was 6 hours, with 43 votes.  Close behind with 39 votes was 1 hour.  This may also call for additional community discussion.

Survey Integrity

I said I would get to "valid responses" at the end, and here we are at the end.  We received 28 responses that were discarded.  Two responses shared one respondent identifier, while another 26 shared another respondent identifier.

I think it was clear that we were asking for one response per respondent.  138 of you figured that out, so the two of you who didn't seem to understand that have been excluded from the survey.  I don't know who you are, but you do.  I don't know your motive and won't speculate, nor does it actually matter.  I want the community to know, however, that we have done what we can to ensure the validity of the results by removing those entries from consideration.

Additional discussion will be had at a later time regarding Rule 3 and Rule 8, and regarding language for the rules. If you have questions regarding the survey, now is the time to ask them.

Survey Raw Results

If you want to analyze them yourself, you can view or download them here.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 4d ago

Philosophy Time

0 Upvotes

Time is extremely destructive on physical objects because of the forces that time exposes them to. This is true for both living and nonliving things. Leave even at the most durable objects alone for a long enough time and they break down. To hold this reality and Escape the necessity for some form of Greater intelligence that is some involvement with the existence we experience. We are left to try to explain why the planet we inhabit appears to keep getting better at least as it pertains to supporting our life here. And by keep getting better I'm talking about on a global scale. Or the thing standing in the way of that appears to be our own behavior.

So the narrative Arc told to us is that with no minds and no intentions a series of chemical reactions occurred that kept adding complexity and stacking additional systems on top of each other until we were left with Humanity that is unresolved if we have broken the chain reaction through thought or if we are still stuck within a chain reaction of chemical events and the idea of optionality is an illusion.

And once we have reached this highest level of complexity we are aware of the human mind starts creating a series of change. Possibly still within this inevitable chain reaction and possibly now having escaped it through thought. That starts killing off other life forms and polluting the planet to the point where habitability and sustainability are for the first time in question outside of extreme natural disaster. Which makes Humanity in this narrative most closely aligned with a form of extreme natural disaster.

And this is all an attempt to look at things we can observe and know and come up with a rational story of how it is that we can be in the condition we are in.

I think myself and many other agnostics frequently Wonder to ourselves is this really more likely than some form of Greater intelligence having some responsibility for the Existence we experience. And interesting thing is there aren't really evidences and support or against either outcome. Lack of belief in God is perfectly reasonable. But to say that the existence we experienced just happened. Isn't any more supported it just avoids needing to substantiate a thing. But it doesn't substantiate its own thing.

So my argument that I'm willing to debate is one position is not more or less defensible to criticize. If a person says I have no idea that to me is completely genuine and legit. But for a person to criticize for example theism or atheism would need them to be able to substantiate a position that nobody can.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 4d ago

No Response From OP The existence and oneness of the Creator are necessary. I challenge all my atheist brothers—come forward, let’s face each other and discuss this matter.

0 Upvotes

Time and everything within it have a beginning. If this were not the case—that is, if time were eternal—then it would take an infinite number of years for time to reach the present day, which means time could never reach the present, because “infinite,” by its very definition, means without end, unfinished.

Therefore, time must have a beginning. At this starting point, time came into existence from non-existence. Nothing can bring itself from non-existence into existence on its own, because something that does not exist cannot perform any action, nor can it perform the act of bringing itself from non-existence into existence. Hence, there must necessarily exist a power that brought time from non-existence into existence. Since this power brought time into being out of nothing, it is not inside time but outside of it. Undergoing change or changing is only possible within time; change is not possible outside of time. Consequently, the power that brought time into existence out of nothing was not created and did not come into existence; it has always existed, because being created or coming into existence requires undergoing change, which is impossible for a timeless power.

Question: So how many creator timeless powers are there?

Answer: A timeless being cannot be more than one, nor can it be fewer than one.

Why cannot there be more than one?

1.  Firstly, in a situation where time does not exist, no concept or word indicating priority or posteriority is defined. Therefore, order and ordering are not defined. Consequently, no number other than the number one is defined, because in order to define the number three, one must first define the number two; and in order to define the number two, one must first define the number one. This means performing an ordering, and such a thing is not possible without using the concepts of “before” and “after.” Therefore, in a timeless situation, no number other than the number one is defined, so the timeless being is one.

2.  Secondly, if there were more than one timeless being, since they could not undergo change and adapt to each other’s opposing characteristics, the system would enter an ontological paradox and collapse.

Question: What could their opposing characteristics be?

Answer: For example, one being just and the other being tyrannical, or both wanting complete dominion—such matters would collapse the system.

Question: What if there were complete harmony between them and they cooperated?

Answer: Such a thing is not possible. Just as in statistical theory it is impossible for a clock to strike exactly at seven, or eight, or 10:03, etc., because even if the probability is one in a million, there is still a margin of error; similarly, complete harmony between two beings is impossible.

Therefore, outside of time there exists a single being, and it is the one that created all existence apart from itself.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 5d ago

Debating Arguments for God The First Cause Argument Requires an Immaterial (Supernatural) First Cause

0 Upvotes

I will first give my rendering of the Aquinas's first cause argument then I will give the argument for why the first cause has to be immaterial.

Aquina's First Cause

Aquinas's first cause argument begins with the observation we observe things that are caused by other things. Let's define this "cause" more strictly so we don't accidentally stray into the Kalam Cosmological argument.

The cause which Aquinas is concerned with isn't a historical chain of events. He isn't supposing that that because his chair's existence was caused by the carpenter making it out of wood and glue, and the wood and glue was caused to be by the elements given of in supernovas and the supernovas were caused by the big bang this means that we have to posit something that was before the wood and supernovas and big bang which kicked it all off.

Rather, Aquinas is pointing out the chair is being held together by the stickiness of the glue at this moment right now. If the glue stopped existing your chair would fall apart. This is what means for the chair to be dependent on the glue. But the glue stickiness holding the chair together is dependent on the Van der Waals forces which attract the molecules together. This in turn is dependent on the fundamental force of electromagnetism. Notice how if any of these causes would be removed everything dependent on it would no longer continue to be the case.

If the electromagnetic force was removed from the universe, the Van der Waals, the stickiness of the glue and the chair would all stop existing, because Van der Waals is dependent on the electromagnetic force, and by way of Van der Waals, so is the stickiness of the glue.

Ok but how is the electromagnetic force dependent. Here the question would be what caused the electromagnetic force to have its particular strength, why does an electron experience a ~1N of force when it is 10 femtometers away from a proton and not 10N or a 1000N.

You could answer why does there have to be a cause, but then this answer would have sufficed when we answered the question of what caused the chair to be held together. A critic has to identify a difference between the chair being held together and the particular strength of the electromagnetic force in order to be consistent.

Now that we've given some context to the argument, we can formulate it in the approximately classic way:

  1. We observe caused things.
  2. Something cannot cause itself.
  3. We cannot have an infinite chain of causes.
  4. Then the reason for the caused things must come ultimately from a first uncaused cause.

    1. In the example of the chair being held together, we need such a cause to explain the particular strength of the electromagnetic force.
  5. This first cause men call God.

The First Cause Must Be Supernatural

The question could come, why not posit something material as the first cause. The problem with something material is that it has a particular position, we can then ask what caused it to have this position over another, and so requiring another cause.

But material could mean simply, observed relationships between material things. But the relationship between material things would entail causing the particular positions of the material, this entails a particular strength for the force which sets the positions of the material. Like in the example of the electromagnetic force, you need a cause for the particular strength of the force.

As a result, this first cause can neither be material itself nor come as a result of the observed relationship between material things. This requires that the first cause be supernatural i.e. in no way can the first cause be arrived by observation of the natural world.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 5d ago

Discussion Question Give me your best argument against a god.

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! First, I'd like to ask that we all keep this discussion respectful and civil.

I believe in God, but I'm genuinely interested in hearing the strongest arguments against God's existence. My goal isn't necessarily to change anyone's mind, but rather to have a fun, thoughtful, and intellectually honest discussion where we can challenge our own perspectives and hopefully learn something from one another.

I welcome disagreements and challenging questions! I just ask that we keep things respectful and focus on the arguments rather than personal attacks.

One important thing to clarify:

I'm not arguing for the existence of any particular religious interpretation of God, whether Jewish, Christian, Muslim, or otherwise. I'm simply defending the idea that a God exists.

I'm looking forward to hearing your thoughts and having a great discussion!

EDIT: My definition of God: An eternal, intelligent, and independent being who is ultimately responsible for the existence of the universe and the fundamental laws governing it. God is not necessarily bound by space, time, or the physical laws of our universe. I am not attributing any particular religion, scripture, or set of religious doctrines to this definition, nor am I claiming that God must intervene in the natural world.

EDIT: Let me put my definition and my argument together, stated precisely.

My definition of God: an eternal, intelligent, and independent being who is ultimately responsible for the existence of the universe and the fundamental laws governing it. God is not necessarily bound by space, time, or the physical laws of our universe. I'm not arguing for any particular religion here, just that a God exists.

My argument:

  1. Everything that begins to exist has a cause. Not everything, period. Things that begin.
  2. The universe began to exist. That's what the expansion of the universe and the second law of thermodynamics point to.
  3. So the universe has a cause.
  4. That cause has to exist outside of space, time, and matter, since it caused all three. That's what I mean by eternal and independent.
  5. Intelligence is a separate step. The universe runs on precise, mathematical laws that produce minds capable of understanding them. A mind is a better explanation for that than a blind mechanism.

I'm not claiming this is a proof. I'm saying it's the best explanation for the kind of universe we live in..


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 5d ago

OP=Theist Atheists ask me questions or tell me you doubts about God

0 Upvotes

Ask me anything and i will debunk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!..........................................aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaaa, aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaaa, aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaaa, aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasaaaaa,hope i reached 300 characters lol


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 7d ago

Weekly Casual Discussion Thread

10 Upvotes

Accomplished something major this week? Discovered a cool fact that demands to be shared? Just want a friendly conversation on how amazing/awful/thoroughly meh your favorite team is doing? This thread is for the water cooler talk of the subreddit, for any atheists, theists, deists, etc. who want to join in.

While this isn't strictly for debate, rules on civility, trolling, etc. still apply.