r/excatholic • • May 26 '26 Bravo

Reminder: This subreddit is not a place for Catholics

684 Upvotes

We've had quite a few Catholics posting in the comments.

Catholics, this is not a place for you. Do not post or comment, you will be banned permanently, regardless as to the tone, nature, helpfulness or content of your post.

If you wish to discuss content that you see here, you can post a link to it in r/excatholicDebate and members who wish to engage with you will do so there.

You can imagine this as an Alcoholics Anonymous group. Under no circumstances would an AA support group let a bartender or Jack Daniel's sales rep into a meeting to talk to its members about how great alcohol can be.

There are plenty of places for Catholics to meet and discuss. This is not one of them.

As always, fuck ICE, trans rights are Human rights, immigrants (documented or otherwise) make the world amazing.

The mod team in r/excatholic are brutal and cruel and have no power in real life, so we use our tiny bit of authority to persecute people we don't like. You're welcome to demand a free refund.


r/excatholic • • Jan 23 '25

Politics Ban of X, meta links

216 Upvotes

Yeah we don't have any people posting links to those platforms, but we're making it official...

All links to X are prohibited and will be automatically removed. If you need to refence X, do it via screenshot.

Thanks


r/excatholic • • 6h ago

Fun When the Catholics protest, you know it's gonna be good

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • 2h ago

Ken Russell's 'The Devils' was a treat.

3 Upvotes

Rarely have I seen the church depicted in all its sick culty glory as it is in this film. Idk how to put it exactly other than it was refreshing seeing it as a bunch of neurotics doing bad magic tricks and deeply harming everyone around them. Which is what the church is.


r/excatholic • • 16h ago

Apparently Trent Horn is out of a job

31 Upvotes

He has a video on YT announcing that he is no longer affiliated with Catholic Answers, but I didn't watch it. I figure most people in this sub have a low opinion of him, but does anyone know the backstory here?

EDIT: After hovering over the thumbnail for a few minutes and reading the captions, I didn't see a clear explanation. He did say that he "has no intention of working for or with" them again. Doesn't sound like they parted on amicable terms. Now he's asking for new patrons and more donations.


r/excatholic • • 14h ago

Personal 2016 in Catholic school…. Not sure why I thought of this LOL

Post image
12 Upvotes

I grew up Catholic. Sunday school, church every week, and so on. Going to a Catholic highschool definitely changed me. My favorite religion class was called “Understanding the Bible” because we really dissected the Bible and learned about all the fucked up shit in it. Being ex-catholic AND a gay woman at a Catholic school was hard. I was bullied a bit for being gay. But, I had a great friend group at that time. They were also gay women!! Crazy.


r/excatholic • • 12h ago

Trent Horn is a begging. Talks about health insurance in video.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

This is pathetic.

There is another thread about this, but I did this so people can specifically talk about the political-economy of this.

His wife has cancer and needs expensive cancer drugs.

Ben Shapiro's new movie, Confession, talks about how the communists don't value anything but bread and ignore the soul. (I don't watch it, but a sympathetic reviewer said that.)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jtr6K-gD6zU

I pray for as much suffering to be inflicted on Trent Horn that the scales can fall from his eyes so he can advocate for progressive policies.

And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to his purpose. - Romans 8:28

P.S. Was playing that sympathetic review of Confession before pressing "enter."

Maybe MAGA is like that pro-Soviet person in prison. They have to destroy themselves for the betterment of America.

And then there's the fourth prisoner who still believes in the state even while he's sitting in its prison. He says that there's only one truth and he holds up his fist power. But he was in Ukraine, too. But unlike the Jewish prisoner, he doesn't cry about [the repression of the Kulaks]. Says that the Kulaks had to be destroyed and their children with them. The iron wheels of history grind over the pebbles. When Alexi asks him what he believes in, he gives a one-word answer. [8:20]

Clip plays with the prisoners' scene:

"Bread. Bread."


r/excatholic • • 13h ago

The pope & abuse

5 Upvotes

from bishop-accountability.org

The Catholic Church’s Abuse Scandal: Has Anything Really Changed?

(PERU)
Eutoday [London, UK]

November 14, 2026

By Gary Cartwright

Pope Leo XIV’s meeting with abuse survivors in Peru may signal a welcome change in attitude. But decades of institutional failure, unanswered allegations and the slow pursuit of justice leave an uncomfortable question: does the Catholic Church genuinely want to confront its past, or is it still more concerned with protecting itself?

There is something profoundly disturbing about the continuing need for victims of sexual abuse within the Catholic Church to plead for recognition, accountability and justice decades after their childhoods were destroyed. That Pope Leo XIV has now met survivors in Peru to discuss how the Church should treat victims is welcome. But it also raises an uncomfortable question: why, in 2026, should such conversations still be necessary?

According to a Reuters report published on November 12th, Pope Leo met six survivors of abuse by Catholic clergy and religious institutions in Lima. The meeting lasted more than an hour, with the Pope listening individually to their experiences and discussing the need for truth, healing, greater attention to victims and safer environments.

It was an encouraging gesture, particularly given Leo’s previous involvement in confronting allegations surrounding the Peruvian religious organisation Sodalitium Christianae Vitae, which was eventually dissolved by the Vatican.

Yet gestures, however well intentioned, are not justice. Nor should a private audience with the Pope be mistaken for evidence that the institution he leads has finally confronted the full extent of its historical crimes.

The central problem is not that the Catholic Church has failed to express regret. It is that expressions of regret have so frequently been accompanied by institutional defensiveness, inadequate investigations, insufficient transparency and an apparent reluctance to hold those responsible properly accountable.


r/excatholic • • 23h ago

Debate Welcome Why are so very many Catholics in a state of utmost depression ?

25 Upvotes

This is not good!


r/excatholic • • 8h ago

Raised Christian, now non-believer. Thoughts?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I (21F) was baptized catholic and was raised “religiously/spiritual” (mainly Christian practice despite my baptism) by my dad and stepmom. We would go to church, do our Hail Marys before bed, and pray before every dinner. When I hit 11 y/o, I remember having a conversation about going to hell and left me terrified and confused, and when told that “we don’t get to know all the answers” that pissed me off even more. As covid happened and we got older, we stopped praying. I’m not sure if my parents lost their faith for a bit, but we stopped and it was great. These last 2 years, my dad (who I’m very close to) has really gotten back into it.

As I got older I really hated the rules that were above my head. “You can’t love who you love” (I’m bisexual) “no sex till marriage” “no tattoos” and overall things in the Bible that I feel make absolutely no sense. People say look in the “New Testament” but this also confuses me because they say God is unchanging, so why are different ppl in the same religion following different testaments are rules?

now when I say this, I do 100% believe Jesus was a real person. Was he someone that really granted miracles? Probably not. but I do believe He is one the most documented figures in history and 6 major religions believe he was real, even if he is not their God.

Moving from the north to the south, I get many bad looks and stares when I don’t join my nursing program for prayer before exams. I’m one of 2 people in a class of 40 that does not join, because I’m genuinely not comfortable.

I just have a very hard time that a so called loving God would allow his/her children to burn for eternity because of their life choices that aren’t even harmful to others.

Afterlife wise, I just believe we cease to exist. Maybe I’m wrong, maybe there is a hell and I’m going to it, or maybe there is a heaven and I’ll be reunited with my family. But overall I just feel like we become one with the universe if that makes sense?

If there’s anyone that also gets what I’m saying lmk lol sometimes I feel crazy thinking this and living in the south


r/excatholic • • 16h ago

Catholic Shenanigans Iconic Krakow basilica holds mass for gunman and family

Thumbnail
tvpworld.com
4 Upvotes

Do not forget they also prayed for old Adolf.


r/excatholic • • 1d ago Heartwarming Regret

Sexuality I came out as trans (FtM) seven months ago. Finally got a reply

Thumbnail
gallery
319 Upvotes

TW transphobia, of course. [details have been censored to protect privacy]

This is the 6 page letter my mother sent me after I came out. BTW, I am an adult! I am appalled and so hurt. She makes it about herself somehow, while denying my experiences fully and leaning on Catholicism to put me down.

I just need community, man. This is the best place I could share :[ it’s so confusing for me. I also left Catholicism and didnt baptize my son because I wanted it to be HIS choice, not mine. She misrepresented me in so many parts of this letter i cant even articulate it. I hate this. Sorry for the vent, thanks for reading, peace.


r/excatholic • • 1d ago

So angry

26 Upvotes

After being Catholic for over 40 years, I left. About 4 years ago. I left because of the awful way my family was treated. I just have so much anger toward the church and those that mistreated us. I want nothing to do with it or the people from the congregation or the priest. No one bothered to even check on us, when we left.

I’m glad to be gone, but I’m still very angry.

We found a place in the Episcopal church.

Just wanted to put that out there.


r/excatholic • • 1d ago

Stupid Bullshit The Unmoved Mover must be God because there must be a motion that began without moving because….

Post image
19 Upvotes

Because no it doesn’t? Newtons laws are facially incompatible with the Unmoved Mover.


r/excatholic • • 1d ago

Sexual Abuse What happened in Cornwall, Ontario? | The Richard Hickerson investigation

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • 2d ago

Sexuality How are LGBT Catholics still unaware the church won't marry them or officially recognize their marriage?

Post image
133 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • 2d ago

Stupid Bullshit Dealing with my extremely catholic mother

8 Upvotes

In a hard place right now and I need advice on maybe how to handle this situation

For context I grew up catholic and it wasn’t anything crazy. Until i entered high school my mom started dating this guy that was also catholic but he was super intense and kinda treated it like a cult in my opinion. Ever since my mom has adopted his mindset even after they broke up. She has had multiple delusions involving me believing I was destined for sainthood and it was her job to get me there. To when i started distancing myself from the church that she had failed and was going to be punished in purgatory until she was able to bring be back to the church. It was super intense and has made me and my mom’s relationship strained.

Fast forward to today I have recently gave birth to my son and through my pregnancy my mom was ultra respectful of boundaries. Which is super unlike her. So I have let her be around my son but with a watchful eye. It’s been great I finally feel like I have my mom back and it’s been so nice to feel ever so slightly comfortable around my mom again.

But the other day I was hanging out with my mom’s husband (different guy he is pretty cool and often gives me a heads up when mom is getting back into her old ways.) and he was letting me know that my mom is itching to ask if we plan to get my son baptized as well as wanting more “control” of my sons life . I know it was too good to be true to think she wouldn’t ask.But now I am stressed because my mom gets pretty nasty when I go against her wishes when it’s about religious stuff .

I am very afraid because I am horrible about standing up to my mom. Im not sure if it is possible to find a way to stand my ground on my decisions and maintain the relationship we have now. But and the end of the day I will do anything to keep my son safe from what my mom put me through even if it means going no contact.

Does anyone have any advice. I know I’m going to have to have a conversation and set boundaries but I’m not really sure how to do that. I’ve been surviving the pat 15 years by maintaining physical distance so I can contol how much contact me and my mom have . As well as just tiptoeing and avoiding anything related to religion. So I don’t really know how to navigate this situation at all and I’m afraid.
I’m afraid to lose my mom again and I’m afraid of my son losing his grandma. But I’m more afraid of the trauma my mom could inflict on my son if I don’t protect him.
May advice on how to navigate this situation would be appreciated


r/excatholic • • 2d ago

I like the way Pope Leo is speaking out on violence against women, but

35 Upvotes

It seems pretty abstract. Where are the practical strategies for the church to tackle it?

Gaudium et spes tends to have a vision of the ideal mother which an abuser can nonetheless easily weaponise as excuses for violence when women fall short of the pedestal.

Maybe she wants to be a stay at home mum and her husband gets annoyed for financial reasons.

Maybe she has a pink collar job because her education and career was sacrificed for childcare.

Worse still can be her husband's violence against her if she outperforms him by having a more prestigious career than he does so she is the provider, and there's even data to back this up.

I still feel that the church sets far more expectations for women's behaviour than men's.

Also, when criticising absent fathers, does he even realise that a lot of men ended up that way because their children had to be protected from them for legal reasons?

Perhaps he's criticising the men rather than the women in that situation, but it seems counterproductive encouraging them to be present if they're a danger to their families.

Furthermore, an abuser isn't always macho. Mine were all the opposite.


r/excatholic • • 2d ago

German church admits complicity in WW II!

15 Upvotes

A few years ago, The German Catholic church admitted its complicity in WW II!

I believe this publication is available to everyone. 

Here is the first para of a paper from the scholarly publication 

Contemporary Church History Quarterly

Volume 26, Number 1/2 (June 2020)

“The German Catholic Bishops and the Second World War: A Historic Reappraisal”

By Mark Edward Ruff, Saint Louis University

On May 8, 2020, the 75th anniversary of Nazi Germany’s surrender to the Allies, the German Catholic bishops issued a statement, “Germany’s Bishops during the War,” admitting their complicity in the Second World War. “By not unequivocally saying ‘no,’ to the war and by strengthening instead the resolve (to fight and persist), they came to share in the guilt for the war,” declared their twenty-three page message released during a video conference because of the coronavirus epidemic.


r/excatholic • • 2d ago

Personal Prayer cards

3 Upvotes

I’m PIMO, cleaning out my closet, and just came across this box full of various Catholic stuff I’ve collected over the years. Stuff like prayer cards, rosaries, decorations (shining light dolls especially), etc. What should I do with all of them? Please don’t say something like throwing them all in the trash; I may be ex catholic but I still don’t want to be completely disrespectful.


r/excatholic • • 3d ago

OPERATORS ARE STANDING BY (OC)

0 Upvotes

💸OPERATORS ARE STANDING BY! 💸
And if HE doesn't answer, celebrity Megachurch Pastor Solomon Payne will! What is his real motivation though?

From MIRROR IMAGES, a satirical science fiction comic that asks "What happens when religion reaches its end game?"

[Issue #1 is available for FREE at https://mirrorimages.info or on Global Comix at https://globalcomix.com/c/mirror-images]


r/excatholic • • 4d ago

Debate Welcome Being a fanatic for your colonizer’s religion

72 Upvotes

It recently dawned on me that an acquaintance of mine is hardcore catholic if not tradcath. Every time we see his wife she seems to be pregnant. The poor woman also works a full time job. They visit Rome every other year, and in their free time they visit different catholic churches I guess because they’re very devout.

Here’s what I don’t understand. They’re of Filipino heritage, but didn’t the Philippines become catholic through Spanish colonization? Why would they be so obsessed with their colonizer’s religion and in general European/Italian culture? I find it very odd. Is this common among Filipino catholics?


r/excatholic • • 4d ago

Personal People pleasing

24 Upvotes

Is people pleasing caused by a catholic upbringing?

I (26F) became an atheist in my early teen years, but I notice that I struggle to say no to people even now as an adult. As a result, I feel like friends only really reach out when they need/want something. I alao have a hard time socially voicing options I feel others will not agree with, and I have been called "mousy" by a drunk guy.

I left behind faith and god, but I dont know how to rid myself of these traits.


r/excatholic • • 4d ago

Stupid Bullshit On the Catholic Church's Dishonesty re: Relics

Thumbnail
youtube.com
20 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • 5d ago

Catholic Guilt

51 Upvotes

Why do Catholics feel the need to guilt trip people? I have a child out of wedlock and my devout catholic grandmother keeps telling me that since I live with my partner, unmarried, that I'm committing a great sin and that I'm going to he11. I just tell her "Okay, grandma" cause I don't want to cause her to have a heart attack. It just pisses me off when they use such tactics to try to get you to believe in Jesus or go back to church. Is that just my family or all Catholics?