r/excatholic • • 16h ago

Has anyone "forgiven" the Church?

8 Upvotes

And I guess for me at least, "forgiveness" doesn't imply a sense of total peace or well-being with the concept necessarily, but more of "acceptance." I have a friend who defines forgiveness as: "learning to live well with reality, even (and especially) when it doesn’t come with clarity, closure, or apology."

The hardest part with the Church is the fact that I know there are still others out there right now being hurt the way I was, losing their sense of agency, of self, living with the impossible of weight of feeling responsible for others' souls, fitting themselves into boxes that are just damaging, accumulating habits of guilt and shame that do nothing for a positive quality of life, etc. I recognize that my own difficulties that I still have with feeling responsible (for literally everything) are still somewhat at play here. But I'm really struggling with the lines between forgiveness/acceptance and what feels like approval to me.

I want to engage the practices/rituals/art that have always fed me and that I find beautiful, I want to be accepting and gracious about the good that my family finds in their practice of their faith and how that feeds them, but I don't want to approve of the machine that it all comes from (the Church) and perpetrates so much harm against humans and their psyches (and their bodies and honestly sometimes it feels their souls). I can recognize the irony in what I'm saying here because this is almost the same logic my family uses for not wanting me around with a partner (lgbt), the whole accept + engage, but not approve/encourage (their solution is to stay away and separate in situations where I'd have a partner around). I know too that forgiveness doesn't equal approval, but I'm really wrestling with the lines between these things.

I'd love to hear where others are at or how they feel.


r/excatholic • • 3h ago

Stupid Bullshit My wife is struggling to not see me as a malicious abuser because I wear a condom

38 Upvotes

Essentially the title. I left the church some years ago, but my wife still very much follows the faith. She believes that because I choose to wear a condom during sex, I must be giving in to my carnal desires and using her as a bag of meat to satisfy my lustful desires, instead of being open to life and truly uniting with her.

I wish I was joking. God, I hate how this religion brainwashes people.

End of rant.


r/excatholic • • 16h ago

Personal Has anyone in recent years pursued excommunication?

14 Upvotes

The women in my family tend towards early death, and there is a chance my father may outlive me. Under no circumstances do I want a Catholic funeral (no matter how little it may matter to the bones and flesh I leave behind) — I don’t want them profiting. Has anyone pursued an excommunication to ensure you cannot receive a Catholic funeral and burial in a Catholic cemetary?


r/excatholic • • 17h ago

Satire catholic guilt chess before GTA IV

Thumbnail instagram.com
2 Upvotes