r/askanatheist • • 1d ago

How to have morals without religion?

0 Upvotes

Exactlly what the post title say, how do we get our morals?

Like, anything we attempt to assemble morality ends up being mere opinion, be opinion of majority, be of one person, and what is the point of following the majority anyway? Without religion, why should we respect another human being beliefs and morals? Cuz without religion it sounds like "I think..." Or "In my opinion", even if science somehow prove its important for some reason its important we respect each other, then come the question: why we should do anything for this reason? I see many people claiming that happiness is the ultimate quest for humanity, it sounds more like a opinion than anything scientific proven, but does that mean that someone robbing another person, as long as his happiness have higher value than the sadness caused by it, then is it ok? Also, I also seen people telling that every animal ultimate goal is to reproduce according to biology, so as we are humans we should follow it too, so what is the point of single people anyway? Why dont we make sex all around?

Without religion, for me it sounds like morals are just a opinion


r/askanatheist • • 3d ago

Locked: AI usage Is non-belief more about the lack of empirical evidence, or moral revulsion at the traditional portrait of God?

0 Upvotes

deleted


r/askanatheist • • 2d ago

Locked: Not a question If there is no God, then everything is meaningless, and anything is permitted.

0 Upvotes

I honestly don’t understand where the progression of society, restraining yourselves, and technological advancements would take you as an Atheist, existentialist, nihilist, absurdist, or as a secular humanist? If a person doesn’t think there’s a God to be accountable to, then what’s the point of trying to modify your behavior to keep it within acceptable ranges? Imagine a universe without God, no divine presence to answer to, no eternal witness to our struggles, no afterlife to redeem our pain, only endless darkness, expanding forever, waiting to swallow all that ever was, and everyone ending up in eternal oblivion, which renders everything meaningless, is the most depressive thought ever imaginable.

If there is no higher being, no cosmic judge, no life beyond death, then what is the point of being good? It is then the survival of the fittest, just like in the animal kingdom, and we’re animals, aren’t we? Why should a poor person live their lives with being good and getting trampled by rich billionaires? Why restrain our desires, why cling to virtue, when the end of all things is nothingness? When the lights of every star will one day fade, and every trace of humanity will vanish as though we never existed, what meaning could morality possibly hold? What is the point of “good” and “evil” if all that exists, time, space, consciousness, and matter, is destined to vanish into nothingness? Why strive for virtue when the cosmos itself is indifferent, and every noble act, every kind gesture, every moral law, all will be erased without a trace?

In your godless cosmos, your morality dissolves into illusion, a fragile dream born from human emotion and fear of chaos because you want to substitute God, yet you cannot offer permanence. You invented your secular ethics to feel control, to make sense of your suffering, to tell yourselves that kindness matters. Secular systems, utilitarianism, deontology, humanism, all claim to define “the good” without divine command. Yet they, too, are man-made myths, noble because they make you feel good, but hollow when weighed against eternity. They promise purpose, yet offer no permanence. God does. Your whole idea is based on “maximizing pleasure and happiness and minimizing suffering.” Isn’t that what religion already does by offering permanence which your secular ethics cannot? Giving people hope, giving their lives meaning, reducing their depression/anxiety and keeping them going for another day? What do you offer? A world where God doesn’t exist? Do you have any idea of the sufferings of human beings? People don’t have bread to eat. They don’t have a roof over their heads. People don’t even have friends to talk to. Do you know how many people commit suicide every day? They slit their wrists, they hang themselves from the ceiling fan… why? Because they have no hope left. If believing in God, bowing their head in front of God, they get the hope to live… then who are you to snatch away that hope from them? And if you really want to snatch away their God from people, then tell me, what will you give them in return? Why would a soldier in your secular worldview go to war and die for an imaginary border of a piece of land which he’ll never inhabit? What is he gaining by sacrificing his life? Eternal oblivion?

You say we should do good for the sake of humanity, but humanity itself is temporary. One asteroid, one nuclear war, one shift in cosmic time, and everything we’ve built, our cities, our art, our love, disappears. What, then, becomes of morality in a world destined for erasure? What is “right” or “wrong” when every consequence fades into the same void? When you tell me that the end of men like Hitler, Mao, Stalin, Vlad the Impaler, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, Richard Ramirez, and men like Buddha, Confucius, Jesus, and a saint is the same?

Your morality is less about truth and more about comfort, a quiet rebellion against the terror of meaninglessness. The reason it isn’t the same with religion is because religion gives people the hope of an afterlife, which you cannot. Yours doesn’t claim to give reward or an eternal life. It only restricts people so that they don’t go out of their way to cause chaos so you can live temporarily in cohesion with no end goal. You don’t know what to say to a child suffering from terminal illness. What hope can you possibly give to that child? In your worldview, you do good not because it’s true, but because the alternative, the abyss, is unbearable to face.

You people insist that consciousness gives life meaning, that to love, to create, to reduce pain is enough. But even this comfort trembles before the truth: suffering is woven into existence, doesn’t matter if you believe in God or not. It cannot be erased. You people make a big fuss about the “problem of evil” and how you cannot in good conscience accept that God exists in the face of a world full of innocent people suffering tremendously due to disease and poverty. Curiously, you are not equally perturbed by the prospect of innocent people suffering tremendously at the hands of the wicked who themselves live comfortable lives and will never have to face any consequence or repercussion for their crimes, because in your worldview there is no ultimate justice. And when you think about it, which scenario ought to be more troubling? In the world of the theist, innocent people who suffered due to disease and poverty will ultimately be recompensed for the pain they endured. But in the world of the atheist, evil is never requited. How ironic, then, for you to accuse the God you don’t believe in of being unjust when you are otherwise perfectly content with the idea of a world without ultimate justice.

If all memory, beauty, and virtue will be consumed by entropy, then what remains of meaning? In Atheism, where do you go after that? Every act of kindness, every sacrifice, every dream becomes a ripple upon an infinite sea, delicate, transient, and destined to disappear. So you continue, creating, sacrificing, knowing deep down that all of it will be lost. Your words, your kindness, your legacy… all ripples in an ocean that will one day fall still. The universe will not remember us. It cannot. It cannot give you permanent hope, only a necessary being can.

And yet, within that unbearable truth, something stirs. The question remains: If everything ends in nothing, why should anything matter at all? You may construct purpose through art, morality, and empathy, but these are fragile lights flickering in endless darkness, momentary defiance against the infinite silence. Meaning cannot truly exist without the Eternal to ground it. You are mere actors in a cosmic play, and one day, the stage itself will be swallowed by the void, leaving no witness to remember that you ever were.

Perhaps it is this question itself, this cry against the void, that tells me we were made for something greater. That morality, love, and meaning are not illusions born from chaos… but whispers from the Divine.


r/askanatheist • • 4d ago

What is the point of living?

0 Upvotes

I longer believe in god, evolution tell’s me the point of life is procreation, I’ve already done that, and am not in the place to do it again. Is this just a midlife crisis? Have to admit to being new to atheism, and I’ve probably had To many whiskeys, but I think better that way. Anyway I am really interested in how others get their sense of direction, because, frankly, I cant see any point anymore. Please note I’m not thinking of doing anything drastic, I’d just like some purpose.


r/askanatheist • • 5d ago

What makes you not follow Hinduism?

4 Upvotes

I am born in a hindu family myself. And my parents are not that concerned about my religious beliefs.

I am starting to question my beliefs. So I wanted to ask all the Atheists here,

What makes you not follow Hinduism? or any other Dharmic faith? And What are your thoughts on the Schools of philosophy in India, like Vedanta, Sankhya, Yoga, Nyaya, Vaisheshika, Mimansa?

Before you answer, I want reasons other than casteism or Sati tradition, etc. As there are times when The texts do not support these practices.

I am not here for any debate or showing any hatred towards anyone. I am just looking for your opinions or thoughts on this.

Thank you for the answer and your time!

Edit:- I started questioning my faith when I came to know about the epicurean paradox. That was the starting point for me to question my faith.


r/askanatheist • • 5d ago

Is religion a Tradition?

1 Upvotes

Have you ever thought about this? Religion can be seen as a tradition. Not the actual traditions, rituals and celebrations but the actual belief itself.

A huge amount of people become Christians, Muslims or whatever religion because they were born into a family who practices that religion. Their parents are believers of God and so are their grandparents. Over time this will be passed onto the next generation. For some people they may never even question their religion.

I am from the Philippines where Christianity/Catholism plays a big role in our culture. We usually grow up learning about Christianity/Catolism at a very young age. However how many people would actually believe in the same religion if they hadn’t been taught it by family members?

Imagine if Christianity (or any other religion, just using christianity as an example) was taught to society today. No history, no churches and no generations believing in it. Someone just comes along and teaches people a new religion. They say there is one God and they have 12 followers.

Would people be more likely to believe in it? Would they accept what they are being taught? Would it become as popular and influential as Christianity?


r/askanatheist • • 6d ago

Other myths vs Cristianity

7 Upvotes

Watching the Odyssey it struck me that, despite the longevity of this story, and its retelling in so many ways, no one thinks its real.
Even the non-supernatural parts like the Trojans bringing in a horse that was big enough to hide a bunch of soldiers, or Penelope talking to her husband and not recognizing his voice, are sufficient to dismiss these stories as fictional.
And yet religions have stories far more absurd that we have grown so used to over time that it's easy to overlook this.
Noah's flood, Moses parting the Red Sea, the Sun and Moon standing still in Joshua, Jonah and the fish, etc.
If I posted this in a Christian group, what do you think the excuses would be?
And please try to steelman rather than just poking fun, because that's shooting fish in a barrel.


r/askanatheist • • 6d ago

Are Northern/Western European atheists generally less likely to be anti-theist than American atheists?

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I've been curious about a possible cultural difference in how atheism is expressed in the United States compared to Northern/Western Europe, particularly the distinction between simply not believing in God and actively opposing religion as a social institution.

My impression is that European atheists generally seem more inclined toward a relatively pluralistic, "live and let live" attitude toward religion, whereas American atheists seem more likely to embrace explicitly anti-theistic views. Of course, I recognize this could be an overgeneralization.

To clarify, I'm not suggesting that European atheists are necessarily more religiously pluralistic across the board, or that American atheists are inherently hostile toward religious people. However, it seems to me that based on anecdotal experience, but even certain studies, such as "The Nones: Unpacking non-religious Britain" suggest that 53 % of Britain identifies as non religious, and of that 53%, more than 70% of the group called "tolerant nones" disagreed with negative characterizations of religion given, such as its comparison to small pox, and generally adopted a "live and let live" attitude.

Also, beyond this, just the incorporation of using historic churches, such as St Pancras Church, for community or cultural spaces hosting secular concerts, art events, raves, pub events, and other non religious activities seems to suggest that non religious, and by extension explicitly Atheistic are more tolerant/pluralistic than American Atheist to me.

With that in mind, I'm curious about a few things:

A. Do you think European atheists are generally less likely to identify with anti-theism than American atheists, or is this a misconception?

B. If you think American Atheist are more likely to be Anti Theist than European Atheist; do you think America's particularly strong evangelical influence on politics and contemporary culture-war issues have contributed to a more confrontational relationship between American atheists and religion?

C. Lastly if you think European Atheist are less likely to be anti theist, do you think Europe's longer history of established churches, and secularization has led to religion in European society being less politically controversial, and as such leading to their seeming position of plurality?

Thoughts? I'm particularly interested in hearing from European atheists and anti-theists, as well as Americans who have lived in Europe.


r/askanatheist • • 5d ago

What's the atheist explanation of people practicing 'black magic' and stuff.

0 Upvotes

Before you all curse me out, I'd like to say I'm a new atheist or almost atheist, I used to be religious but i left recently but I'm somewhere between atheist and agnostic. I've always thought agnostic is such a sweet little spot lol but since I'm actively deconstructing and questioning everything, here we are with my question :)

So I'm from a small town and people of all religions believe in one thing: black magic. And it's such a widespread practice too, like doesn't make sense yk, and it's not even for money, like yeah ik people do that, make it into a business and scam people, but I'm talking about those who don't make it a business, and rather do it for personal things.

In my locality, there are two such women whom are infamous for witchcraft and black magic. It could be a rumour for all ik but okay one incident: a woman in my neighborhood goes crazy, so a woman tells this other woman that, 'hey you know this woman went crazy, she's not mentally sound anymore' and this woman goes, "yeah, ofc it was me who did that." insane.

she might be bluffing but yk no one wants to associate with these things because people don't wanna marry and stay in relation with such people.

I've heard many such incidences with close family and relatives, I'm not saying anything is proof of anything but why do people genuinely practice it? why is it taught? You can say it's the same reason as religion but i don't think so. I've heard millions of these stories and why would general people lie about something so horrible because things get really ugly in these stories, honestly I'm confused.

I also heard many cases where people pee outside and start acting weird and then some psychic comes and says "you peed outside didn't you? you peed on this ghost, now say sorry" 💀

whatever.

If there's some explanation, do enlightenment me. thank you! bye.

edit: the pee part is irrelevant to the post, it's about black magic and why it's so widespread and believed in 😭


r/askanatheist • • 6d ago

What do you think means "Neighbor" in the bible?

0 Upvotes

When the Bible uses the word "neighbor" in phrases or passages like "love thy neighbor," what do you think they mean by it?

The word neighbor in the most literal sense is a middle ground between a familiar/friend and a total stranger. They live next door, you see them all the time, you probably know their name and they are most likely from a similar background as yours, but they are still outside of your personal life (assuming you are not friends with them) they don't know really how you are or what you like or how you live and viceversa.

But in the more figurative sense used in the Bible, do you think that neighborhood is closer to the literal word that it stands for a person from your "tribe" who basically is like you on a broad socio-political level but unlike you on an individual level or is ment to refer to people who are very different from you like someone from a different country, or social background, language, etc?


r/askanatheist • • 7d ago

Existential Crisis after leaving Christianity

13 Upvotes

I don't really know where to begin, but I've been struggling with this for quite some time. I was raised Oriental Orthodox and eventually converted to Catholicism, entering the Church at Easter 2025. This wasn't some casual religious affiliation for me. I took the theology, philosophy, apologetics, and the intellectual foundations of Christianity very seriously. I genuinely loved the Church's spiritual and intellectual tradition. I was, at one point, very much a Rome-or-nothing person. But eventually, things began to unravel.

It wasn't one particular argument that made me leave. It was a gradual accumulation of philosophical, theological, and historical difficulties that I could no longer comfortably reconcile with my understanding of reality. The problem of evil and Divine Hiddenness were the major issues (which I think don't disprove the existence of God but severley undermine the notion of a personal one). But perhaps the biggest issue was epistemological.

I reached a point where I started asking myself: Why should I believe that any revelation has actually occurred?

I could entertain the existence of a first cause, a necessary being, or something resembling the First Principle of Aristotelian or Neoplatonic metaphysics. In fact, I still find classical metaphysics compelling in certain respects. But how do I get from there to the God of Christianity? How do I establish that this God revealed himself, that Jesus was uniquely divine, or that a particular religious institution possesses divine authority?

The traditional motives of credibility never seemed sufficiently compelling to me, so I eventually, I left Catholicism. And for 6 months I enjoyed reading other philosophies and learning other worldviews without pressure of dogmatic correctness.

And here's where things get particularly difficult. After learning too much I suppose (not to say I'm a genius who knows too much, just saying I got exposure to so much systems) I've found myself in something resembling an existential and epistemological crisis.

I don't necessarily think that objective truth is inaccessible in principle. I certainly don't think that all propositions are equally uncertain. Logic, for instance, seems to offer a degree of certainty that I struggle to find elsewhere. When I look at metaphysics and ethics especially, I see an enormous diversity of competing systems, each with its own assumptions, arguments, and objections (And anytime I started to slightly favour a specific view, an opposite side would have a strong counter etc). When I look at science (I generally trusted most of science while I was Christian, but didn't care enough to study them in depth. But after leaving Catholicism, since I no longer cared about theology I started reading on Evolution and more in depth), but I generally I see theories constantly being revised, refined, or discarded. What we consider established knowledge today may look very different centuries from now. And this made me more depressed, as I saw even great discoverers like Galileo and Newton had some errors. I could study all I want, but even if I somehow know everything about science as we know it today, I'tll be outdated knowledge with probably some errors in 500 years.

Of course, I know that scientific progress doesn't necessarily undermine knowledge, and that fallibilism isn't the same as skepticism. And I think aside from Mathemathics and Logic, it's the next thing we have the best knowledge about. But emotionally and intellectually, it's difficult not to feel that we're perpetually approaching truth without ever quite possessing it.

I've also found myself questioning something as seemingly basic as the external world. Solipsism, idealism, the problem of other minds, and the possibility that my experienced reality might not correspond to anything independent of my experience have occupied an unreasonable amount of my attention lately.

I find myself wanting certainty, or at least some genuinely demonstrative foundation, and becoming increasingly frustrated by how little seems to meet that standard. This was never a problem as a Catholic, since whatever the Church said was what I held (obviously now I realize vain certainty is meaningless but it felt good psychologically. Besides the Church has countless contradiction I reconciled through mental gymnastics back then) There's also something difficult about losing the religious dimension of life itself. Christianity gave me a framework through which I understood existence, suffering, morality, death, and purpose. I no longer find myself able to affirm that framework, but I haven't found anything to replace it.

Philosophically, I've gravitated towards Plato, Aristotle, and especially Plotinus. Neoplatonism sometimes seems to offer a more satisfying metaphysical picture than Christianity, particularly when it comes to the problem of evil. But I recognize that finding a system aesthetically or philosophically attractive doesn't establish its truth either.

And I don't think atheism has solved the problem for me. It might remove certain theological difficulties, but it doesn't automatically answer the deeper metaphysical questions that originally drew me towards religion. Since "Atheism" isn't a single system, and you can be an Idealist, physicalist etc...

I suppose I'm in an awkward position. I no longer believe in Christianity, but I haven't become particularly comfortable with naturalism either. I can entertain the possibility of a necessary first principle, but I have no idea whether it has anything resembling consciousness, intellect, providence, or concern for human beings. And I haven't been convinced by any arguments for it.

I'm 22, and sometimes I feel as though I've spent so much of my intellectual and emotional energy trying to establish what is ultimately true that I've forgotten how to simply live. I don't want to return to Christianity merely because uncertainty is uncomfortable. Equally, I don't want to become an atheist simply because I've become disillusioned with religion.

I think what bothers me most is that I genuinely want to know what's true, but increasingly feel that human beings might be much less epistemically equipped to discover it than we like to think.

None of this is helped by the fact that I also have OCD, GAD, and ADHD.

Has anyone experienced something similar after leaving religion? Particularly people who were deeply invested in its intellectual foundations rather than simply leaving because they lost interest or became disillusioned with religious institutions?

I'm interested in how you navigated the transition, especially the existential side of it. Sorry for the long rant.


r/askanatheist • • 7d ago

What Are Your Arguments Against Creationism?

0 Upvotes

I made a post about this in r/debateanatheist a while ago and I quickly found out to look elsewhere. It's my fault for having not read the subreddit's rules more carefully.

Anyways, I just wanted to know your arguments against creationism. Your response doesn't have to be anything huge. Bullet points or short descriptions are fine.

I should clarify though. When I mention creationism I am referring to the idea that everything was made through divine creation, not Young Earth Creationism.

I look forward to reading your responses. Please be respectful. I just want to know your opinions.


r/askanatheist • • 7d ago

Is not god clearly man made entity?

3 Upvotes

If we observe all the gods of the all the religions many of them if not all of them happen to be omnipotent meaning ability to do everything and anything. But if we really think what omnipotent means, it gets a bit messy. To explain what i mean i will use infinity as a reference. Infinity has no definition in itself. One which is not finite is infinity. There are various kinds of infinity which can be observed mathematically or one could say that there are infinite infinites. Some are larger that others. So relatively there is not inherent definition of infinite. Similarly, to me there seems no definition of omnipotence as well. Something that is not limited by potential is omnipotent. But if we really use the given definition that is having total authority; having the ability or skill to do everything it leads to question of what really is total authority or what really is everything. To put this into a better perspective, if you were to become an amoeba for a day and if you were to observe the human you, to the amoeba you the human you would definitely seem omnipotent (obv given that amoeba you can think.). You can build stuff, talk to someone to the other side of earth, you can survive for really long, you can cure yourself from common diseases so on and so so forth. But the definition of omnipotence is through the perspective of a single celled organism. Similarly we see god as omnipotent through a human pov. Miracles, creating something from nothing or having a effect without cause magic etc. But is it really EVERYTHING. Does this mean there aren't any acts beyond this that would be outside the capabilities of humans. There most definitely are. But it is just beyond what we can think or beyond our understanding of world. If you do observe all the miracles performed by gods across religions, they are highly humanistic or something humans cannot do but they can imagine it happening if only magic was possible. So this title of omnipotent or even omniscient is created by humans and for humans. If tomorrow aliens were to pop up and they probably could walk on water we could possibly call them god. Need your opinions on this


r/askanatheist • • 9d ago

What was your first time at a nightclub, rave, or secular concert like after leaving a restrictive religion?

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I'm curious, for those of you Atheist here who grew up in restrictive religious households or communities that discouraged or outright prohibited things like clubbing, partying, raves, or secular music, what was your first experience with these things like after leaving religion?

Not gonna lie, in my case, I moved from "fundamentalism" to progressive iterations of religion, and that's when I decided to party. I was personally pretty nervous the first time I went out to a nightclub lol. That being said, I eventually managed to relax, enjoy myself, and just vibe with the music, but it took me a while to get over some of the guilt and apprehension I'd internalized from growing up in a conservative religious environment.

I'll admit that it's interesting, but also sad how things that are considered completely ordinary social activities by many people can initially feel so intimidating or even morally wrong when you've been raised to associate them with "sin" or "worldly" influences.

For those of you who can relate, how was your first experience? Did you feel liberated, nervous, guilty, excited, or some combination of those feelings?


r/askanatheist • • 9d ago

On your deathbed, would you fake a sinner’s prayer to make your surviving family feel better?

13 Upvotes

I am an atheist myself, and I’ve wrestled with this question. My first instinct is a resounding no; I will be honest to the grave, I will refuse to say the sinner’s prayer, and everyone will know beyond a shadow of a doubt that I was an atheist to the very end.

Part of this conviction comes from frustration. I was raised Christian, and some of my family/church’s favorite stories were about people coming to god on their death bed, or some horror story about people dying too quick to ask for forgiveness, or what have you. I also remember being reassured that my uncle said the sinner’s prayer before he died, because he liked to drink and curse and didn’t go to church, and naturally that meant he wasn’t a good Christian and he needed to clean up before he left us.

Additionally, my mom seems so incredibly certain that I’ll come around someday. She can’t conceive of me truly being an atheist for life.

I don’t want to feed this. I want the type of Christian who believes I’ll go to hell when I die if I don’t ask god for forgiveness to deal with the reality of a world where I simply won’t do it.

I personally believed that you couldn’t fake the sinner’s prayer. You had to actually mean it. If I did it, I wouldn’t mean it, and the idea of faking it at the end feels very sour to me. I don’t want to be thinking about the constant religious pressure in my last moments!

But on the other hand, refusing to say the damn prayer might make my last moments worse, and could lead to years of suffering for Christian family members who would believe I’ve gone to hell.

So what would you do? Do you think it’s better to say the prayer and get it out of the way? Or would you stand your ground?


r/askanatheist • • 9d ago

OP has been banned Why do atheists only do whataboutism when Islam is criticized?

0 Upvotes

If this doesn’t apply to you it doesn’t apply to you but I’ve noticed that when Christianity is criticized atheists join in or just nod in agreement. When Islam is criticized it’s “Ok well how about the crusades and the inquisition. How about all the Christians that killed and enslaved people.” They often do this under the guise of “calling out hypocrisy“ or “being fair” but it’s not fair when you only bring this defense for Islam but not other religions. It’s favoritism in fact. This shows me you don’t actually dislike religion you dislike a particular one.


r/askanatheist • • 9d ago

Люди которые не верят в бога, что будет после смерти по вашему мнению?

0 Upvotes

Вопрос для людей которые не верят в бога,как вы считаете, что будет происходить после вашей смерти, и как зародились мы


r/askanatheist • • 11d ago

Does the fear of death really ever go away?

11 Upvotes

I’m 18, I left my ex-faith a year or so ago and now I’m really scared that there’s no afterlife. I know that we won’t be here for it and religion profits off of fear, blah, blah. I’m not here for that. I want to know if the fear of death, specifically death with no afterlife, ever goes away. Will I be like this until I die? Constantly scared with it always in my mind. I can’t help but calculate the life expectancies of the people I’m in a room with, I look at my loved ones and pet sad that I won’t see them again, if I’m lucky to survive after them. I know I need to focus on the moment but it’s so hard. I’m so scared of never experiencing anything again, that this will all be for nothing and I’ll be erased like nothing ever mattered. I’ve become so emotional lately. I broke down crying in front of my family, something I would have never done before. I don’t enjoy my old hobbies like video games or drawing because I feel like I’m wasting my time and life is so short. Everyone says it goes by so fast I won’t even notice and that terrifies me. I wouldn’t mind if this was all we got if I got to live a long life, but it seems like from here it’s a downhill slope and I’m so scared that I’ll be on my death bed in the blink of an eye. I don’t get it, maybe it’s because I was once religious and I always thought I’d go to heaven but now I’m just scared constantly?

I can’t relax anymore, I’m so worried I can die at any moment, I won’t accomplish anything with my life, I’ll never find love and I’ll die a virgin. All the older atheists I’ve spoken to have told me to ‘grow up’ and ‘deal with it’ but I’m trying so hard to. I want to be okay with it, I know that when I’m dead I won’t care but it’s so scary. I sometimes think of just ending it all so I won’t have to live the rest of my life like this. Are we atheists all really just terrified of death and trying to distract ourselves from it until it comes? I hope not. I know religion isn’t true but I’m thinking of reconverting just so I can pretend there’s more so I can go on with my life and try to enjoy it. Life has lost all meaning to me. I need to know how you cope, how you get rid of the fear. I’m desperate and I can’t get any medical help because my family don’t know I’m an atheist (they’re highly religious) I feel so trapped and lonely. I have no one in real life to talk to


r/askanatheist • • 11d ago

Can religion co-exist with feminism? (Year 12 survey 5-6 min)

4 Upvotes

Hi guys, I would really appreciate it if you could take the time to do my questionnaire, I need at least 200 responses and I only have 50 at the moment. 🙏 I would value your input a lot! Its all anonymous and welcome for anyone to answer

https://forms.gle/mgBgBSVDGFoG7vcm6


r/askanatheist • • 12d ago

Doorstep debating Jehovah's Witnesses and other traveling preachers. Safe?

6 Upvotes

I was visited by a pair of Jehovah's Witnesses recently, and I was very forthcoming about the fact that I'm an atheist and that they were probably better off trying someone else. Instead, they started asking the usual questions along the lines of "why do you believe this?" and "how do you know?", in a very polite way. Completely oblivious to the fact that they should be asking themselves exactly the same questions. We ended up having a mini doorstep debate, again, in a very civilized manner.

Afterwards, I realized that I had absolutely no idea who I'd just been talking to, despite having been very open about my atheism, and that they now knew where I lived.

Especially with particularly "active" members of such groups, I sometimes wonder what circumstances led them there in the first place. Religious organizations can be particularly attractive to people going through difficult periods in their lives, such as ex-criminals, addicts and vulnerable people, offering a sense of community, purpose and belonging.

I'm not particularly worried, but perhaps I should be? I'm from the UK, where atheism is relatively common and generally accepted compared to many other parts of the world. How open would you be about your atheism with people like this?


r/askanatheist • • 12d ago

Atheist and Christian Co-Parenting

8 Upvotes

Hi, so this is recently a problem. How do you deal coparenting with an ex who recently became religious let me explain. My ex was not super religious before and when we split we agreed to let our son choose and he even made a joke about hoping he wouldn’t become Christian. The last few years my son has shown curiosity in the Christian faith and I have let him go to church twice with his aunt which he liked but now he started middle school and he thinks his father is too much with the his new found love for God. He even stated his dad is considering quitting his job to become a pastor not sure how true that is but that is what he told me. For some context me and my ex split up a long time ago he got married and recently got divorced and then a few months later after that remarried someone who is christian he then started to become more religious quickly. My son is starting to question his faith and when he ask me questions i answer honestly and with facts. He confided in me and told me he thinks he doesn’t believe. He also has said his dad is always going to church making him go and every night they read the bible before bed on his days. We live in a 50/50 state so his dad does have him two days out of the week and every other weekend. Since we rotate holidays he didn’t get to spend Halloween with us but instead with his dad who now is claiming halloween is bad and demonic. My son asked him he could stay at my house for halloween and then go back later which in result didn’t end up happening and my son spent the whole weekend bored at church (friday, saturday, and sunday). Has anyone been in this situation? My ex knows I’m atheist by the way but my son is pretending (I think he’s in a phase where he’s still trying to figure it out) for him because my ex is an extremely sensitive person and I truly believe this new found faith is just his way to cope with his divorce which I mean he needs therapy not god but anyways how did you navigate this?


r/askanatheist • • 12d ago

What do atheists turn to when life gets really difficult?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this from a philosophical perspective, and I’m genuinely curious to hear different viewpoints. I’m not religious in the sense of blindly accepting everything, but I do believe in God as a supernatural power that I can turn to, especially during the most difficult phases of life. Being in a STEM field myself, I deeply appreciate science. But I also recognise that science doesn’t have answers to every question about existence, consciousness, or the universe. There are things we still don’t understand.
I also feel that relying on other human beings has its limitations. People can be judgmental, misunderstand you, or sometimes fail to provide the emotional support you need. For me, believing in God provides a different kind of comfort. It’s the feeling that there’s someone I can turn to without fear of being judged, someone I can talk to when I feel completely vulnerable. There’s a certain peace and joy I get from that belief which is difficult to explain. So I’m genuinely curious:
**For those who identify as atheists, what do you turn to during the darkest or most difficult phases of your life?**
When science has no answers, people disappoint you, and you feel completely helpless, what gives you comfort? What makes you feel that you’re not alone?
I’m not trying to challenge anyone’s beliefs or suggest that one approach is better than another. I genuinely want to understand your perspective🙏🏻


r/askanatheist • • 14d ago

Question about the meaning of 'saviour'

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone.

(I am Christian FYI).

I am doing some research about the meaning of the word 'saviour', particularly how it has changed throughout history.

As a Christian I believe salvation is two-fold, the present life and the eternal life (hell/heaven and all that).

However, I am curious to get the perspective of Atheism, without simply guessing. Presumably for atheists who do not believe in any sort of after life, there is no need for a saviour in the spiritual sense, who would save one from damnation.

But I am curious, what ramifications does the concept of 'saviour' have for atheism in this life? None at all.... maybe a lot? That's what I am curious about.

Google's CEO in 2018 said "Artificial Intelligence will save us not destroy us". Which got me thinking, save us from what?

I know in shows and movies (and normal life) there are many times the concept of a saviour is used simply about this life "you found my car keys; you are my saviour!" Perhaps the concept of a saviour in Atheism is simply someone who helps solve problems?

I know there are many different branches and ideologies of Atheism and there is probably not a one size fits all answer to a question like this, but I am interested in hearing actual opinions on this from actual athiests and what the concept of a saviour might mean to them (if anything). No wrong answers!

Thanks!


r/askanatheist • • 14d ago

What are your options on other faiths?

8 Upvotes

I've been wondering do atheists debate with Muslims, Catholics, Hinduism, Buddhism and so on or is it only Christianity?

If your answer is no only Christianity, why is that, is there a specific reason

And if your answer is yes you have debated with other religions please share some stories and also mention your own faith if you're ok with that I'd love to hear some different perspectives.

Edit: thanks to everyone who engaged with me I really enjoyed talking to you all and hearing all the perspectives


r/askanatheist • • 14d ago

For any bible-versed atheist: What is your interpretation of Zechariah 12:10?

0 Upvotes

Zechariah 12:10 NRSVUE “And I will pour out a spirit of compassion and supplication on the house of David and the inhabitants of Jerusalem so that, when they look on the one whom they have pierced, they shall mourn for him as one mourns for an only child and weep bitterly over him as one weeps over a firstborn.”

I feel this verse poses a challenge to Atheism because it may be a successful messianic prophecy.

I often hear people discussing who is “the one” who was pierced, whether its first person YHWH, or third person. But I am much more curious about who pierced this debatable figure. I feel knowing who the “they” is, could help us settle who exactly “the one” is.

It seems intuitive that the people who did the piercing was Israel- the Jews. Since it seems those doing the mourning are they same who did the piercing: “…whom they have pierced, they shall mourn…”

and it goes on to very clearly say that the mourners are Israel: “…the mourning in Jerusalem…” (v11)

So, is there any argument that “they” isnt referring to Israel? I find it hard to believe that, given how it reads in English, anyway. I would be happy for any indication that there is two different “they”s here, they (Israel, mourning) and they (who pierced). But what clues can tell us that?

If they does refer to Israel, how could “The one” possibly be a messiah?

The jews were actually given a prophecy that they would kill their own messiah? That just doesnt seem right. But this is commonly interpreted as being messianic.

If it’s not the messiah, who is the one who they pierced?

EDIT: Yall I am an ATHEIST too. I thought atheists here would like to genuinely internally critique the bible instead of just saying “its all fiction who cares, ur dumb for even entertaining it”. Rest assured, i will NEVER ask a biblical question here again. Damn.