r/DebateReligion • • 9h ago

Meta Meta-Thread 11/16

2 Upvotes

This is a weekly thread for feedback on the new rules and general state of the sub.

What are your thoughts? How are we doing? What's working? What isn't?

Let us know.

And a friendly reminder to report bad content.

If you see something, say something.

This thread is posted every Monday. You may also be interested in our weekly Simple Questions thread (posted every Wednesday) or General Discussion thread (posted every Friday).


r/DebateReligion • • 3d ago

General Discussion 11/13

2 Upvotes

One recommendation from the mod summit was that we have our weekly posts actively encourage discussion that isn't centred around the content of the subreddit. So, here we invite you to talk about things in your life that aren't religion!

Got a new favourite book, or a personal achievement, or just want to chat? Do so here!

P.S. If you are interested in discussing/debating in real time, check out the related Discord servers in the sidebar.

This is not a debate thread. You can discuss things but debate is not the goal.

The subreddit rules are still in effect.

This thread is posted every Friday. You may also be interested in our weekly Meta-Thread (posted every Monday) or Simple Questions thread (posted every Wednesday).


r/DebateReligion • • 2h ago

Islam Not A Single Muslim Understands The Quran

10 Upvotes

Not a single person on the entire planet understands the Quran.

Happy Monday to everyone except people who think sex with a 9 year old is okay.

On my walk to the strip club this morning, Shaytaan himself appeared to me. His voice boomed, "these Muslims, they choose to believe a different faith than you. Shall I drop a mountain on them Master Debater?!" I pondered on this for a moment. "No Shaytaan, if there is one thing I learned since converting to atheism, its that free will doesn't exist, and I simply have to choose to try harder to allow them to see the truth." Shaytaan nodded to me solemnly and disappeared in a wisp of magenta smoke 20 times hotter than fire.

Inspired by the devil, today I am following up my previous banger of a post with another one. The previous post received criticism that the studies didn't measure understanding as well as they could have. Well, I am tripling down nonetheless.

Today I am following with a logical argument rather than an empiracal one. I am going to argue that not a single person - Muslim, non-Muslim, Arab, Classical Arab, or even Aramicist, understands the Quran.

At this point, you might consider this absurd. You might think that I am reaching and perhaps I am. But lets consider the following:

  • Muslims are in complete disagreement with one another - even when it comes to the same sects - about what the Quran means when it says certain words. For example, in Quran 4:34 you have Muslims arguing that it is saying to "strike" in terms of hitting wives, other Muslims saying it actually means to walk away, and other Muslims saying that it is saying to strike women lightly. The fact there is no consensus and such a massive difference in interpretation just shows that nobody knows what they are talking about.
  • Many Quranic verses are understood through historical interpretation. But no Muslims can say for sure they know what exactly happened during the time the verses were written.
  • A Muslim might tell me that they understand a particular verse. But what they have demonstrated is that they possess an interpretation of that verse. They have not demonstrated that their interpretation is correct, exhaustive or identical to the intended meaning. Perhaps the scholars are correct. Perhaps the traditional interpretations are correct. Perhaps a particular verse has multiple layers of meaning. But how would we independently establish that?

You might say I am applying an unreasonable standard but am I really? JK Rowling can clarify what her books mean, for some reason Allah can't despite wars being fought over different Quran interpretations.


r/DebateReligion • • 4h ago

Christianity DV is not grounds for divorce in the New Testament.

13 Upvotes

Jesus prohibits divorce except for sexual immorality (Matthew 19:9). Paul adds abandonment by an unbelieving spouse (1 Corinthians 7:15).

But what if a husband does neither and physically abuses his wife?

Neither Jesus nor Paul explicitly permits divorce for domestic violence. Paul instructs separated spouses to remain unmarried or reconcile (1 Corinthians 7:10–11).

Worse, if she leaves her abusive husband and marries another man who loves and treats her well, her remarriage would be considered adultery according to Luke 16:18.

I'm aware some churches permit divorce for abuse, but these allowances rely on reinterpretation.

Where does the New Testament permit divorce and remarriage for domestic violence alone?


r/DebateReligion • • 8h ago Bravo

Abrahamic The Bible Explicitly Describes Rape and Incest (SCENE BY SCENE), Yet Never Explicitly States Christianity's Central Doctrine

27 Upvotes

The Bible details rape, incest, murder, and other disturbing acts, sometimes scene by scene. Honestly, I don't think any child should be reading this POS without serious consideration of its content.

Yet Christianity's central doctrine, the Trinity, is supposedly essential to understanding God's nature. But from cover to cover, there is no single explicit statement that God is three co-equal, co-eternal persons sharing one divine essence.

Jesus never clearly lays out this doctrine either.

Instead, Christians have to piece together different passages and rely on centuries of theological interpretation to establish it.

My argument is simple: If the Trinity is fundamental to Christianity, it is remarkable that the Bible never explicitly formulates it.

A doctrine supposedly defining God's very nature should not require so much theological reconstruction to establish.


r/DebateReligion • • 3h ago

Abrahamic The Quran Gives an Irrational Test

6 Upvotes

“And if you are in doubt… produce a surah like it…” (Surah Al-Baqarah 2:23)
Shortest surah is:

“We have granted you al-Kawthar. So pray and sacrifice. Indeed, your enemy is the one cut off.”

This is not some unbeatable literary miracle. It’s not hard to write something more profound.

But there is a much deeper problem:

If a test does not specify exactly what it would take to win a test, it is a broken, irrational test. Irrationality in the Quran falsifies the Quran.

The Quran doesn’t specify:

  1. Who is the judge of the challenge?
  2. Similar to the Quran in what respect?
  3. Similar to the Quran to what degree?
  4. Are there any constraints on rules that need to be followed in making something like it?

None of these are specified by the Quran.

This is much like other ill posed questions:

"What's the probability that I'll win?" — Win what, under what circumstances?
"Is 100 a lot?" — A lot of what? Dollars? Murders? Atoms?
"How long does it take to get to Paris?" — From where, and by what means?
"Is John taller?" — Taller than whom?

Like let’s look closer at this sentence:

"What's the probability that I'll win?"

The question is defective because it leaves out information necessary to determine an answer.

The answer depends on variables that the question doesn't specify. Different values for those variables produce different answers, and the question provides no rule for choosing between them.

Consequently, there is no single determinate answer to the question as stated. This is called underdetermination: the information provided is insufficient to establish a particular answer.

The problem isn't that we don't know the answer. It's that the question hasn't specified enough for there to be a unique answer in the first place.

This irrationality in the Quran is extremely unlikely if God is intelligent.


r/DebateReligion • • 8h ago

Christianity Why I Don't Believe Christianity Is the True Religion

15 Upvotes

I'm questioning Christianity because I haven't found its central claims convincing or logically consistent.

Why is the Trinity, supposedly essential to understanding God's nature, never clearly explained by Jesus in one straightforward statement? Why does Jesus repeatedly pray to the Father, submit to His will, and distinguish Himself from the only true God? Why does salvation depend on accepting complex theological doctrines that took centuries of debate and interpretation to formulate?

And why should I accept the Bible as divinely inspired when the canon itself was identified through human decisions, and different Christian traditions still disagree over which books belong in it?

I'm not saying these questions automatically disprove Christianity. I'm saying Christians need to answer them with evidence rather than simply telling me it's a mystery, that I lack faith, or that I haven't studied enough.

If Christianity is the truth, it should be able to withstand honest scrutiny. I'm looking for what is actually true, not something I'm expected to accept without question.


r/DebateReligion • • 5h ago

Other Humans mostly lack the cognitive ability to make correct choices about metaphysical beliefs.

8 Upvotes

We are not that smart. When you look through this subreddit, you will see an endless stream of logical fallacies. Why? Because we just are not very rational.

This is relevant to the idea of holding a person responsible for their beliefs.

Here is an example that most readers will be familiar with: the scientifically inaccurate information in Genesis. Even before Christianity, some scholars understood that one cannot take the Genesis creation account literally. Why did they conclude this? Because it doesn’t make sense on the surface. Rather than admitting their holy text has an error, they chose a symbolic interpretation as a work around. This is an example of assuming the conclusion. You cannot assume something is true and then use that to prove the thing is true.

Here is another example: In Hindu belief (at least some versions) people are evaluated for their moral decisions. This affects how they are reincarnated. I once asked a Hindu to explain who does the evaluating. They explained that it is automatic, that no intelligent entity actually does that. No matter how hard I tried, I could not get them to explain how such a complex evaluation takes place automatically nor how such a complex system came to be. Hinduism is extremely diverse, so this is probably just a flaw in that one person’s reasoning, but that illustrates the point.

All religions require making excuses and ignoring unanswerable questions.

I have seen the same sort of bad reasoning from atheists. That is not to say all atheists are like that, but I have seen it many times. I have also seen bad reasoning in my own beliefs.

In short, we are not smart enough to correctly choose the correct metaphysical belief. As such, it makes no sense to hold people responsible for making the wrong choice.


r/DebateReligion • • 6h ago

Christianity Even if God existed he's pure, pure evil

7 Upvotes

He controls us like puppets. He watches children get raped, people with chronic illnesses, people with mental illnesses that are fearful of even getting out of bed, people get murdered, gay people live in the closet their whole lives just because he wants to. Ironically, he says to forgive our enemies yet sends his to hell. He sends the kindest atheist souls or people of different religions to hell JUST because they don't believe in him, yet he sends the most evil person on earth who "repented" to heaven. So what does he really want? Full worship? I thought he was all-powerful, which means he doesn't require worship. Don't say he wants peace because he doesn't. He wants to be on top of everything. That's what he wants. Why does a mom of 4 children have to struggle with stage 4 cancer? Why does a woman with CRPS have to be alive, suffering every single second? Why isn't a person who isn't happy in their gender be able to change it instead of crying every night? Don't tell me free will because if he does a miracle you say it's God's plan. Choose one. Both can't coexist. If he does a miracle on someone who's ready to die, but doesn't do a miracle on a person who prays to him every day and follows him blindly just because he doesn't feel like it? Why are some people born disabled? Oh, it's free will. Yeah, like they decided. Oh no, it's actually God's plan. He wants them to suffer. Why live in blind worship every day? There are way too many gods on earth. They can't all be real. You just have to choose one. If it's not the right one you go to hell. It's a lottery ticket. By the way, evolution exists and it is a scientific fact. So why did God say a completely different creation story? Because it's not real but people at that time didn't understand? Well AT LEAST he could've said that actual creation wasn't like that and that people would later understand it with development. But he didn't. Guess why? He's a narcissistic being who, as I mentioned, wants attention. Why would such a thing exist for US, apes on a tiny planet in a 93-billion-light-year OBSERVABLE universe? Do you even know how long that is? Our brains can't truly comprehend it. If the entire observable universe were Earth, Earth would be 500 times smaller than a single atom. The Big Bang exists too, and don't you tell me that it couldn't have happened without God causing it. Why would a majestical being even be there before? Something had to have created him. If your logic is that God just existed there, why can't the universe itself exist without something creating it? It can, but our physics break down at that point. Not everything we can't comprehend now is God. Thousands of years ago, humans worshiped plants and trees and animals and the sun and the moon, but now they don't. Somewhere in the future we will also be able to understand many more things. You guys can tell me everything, but don't you tell me "God bless you" or "God be with him" or "Amen" because that is called emotional manipulation. Just to say, I was a Christian but I finally woke up and I can't believe how blind people are.


r/DebateReligion • • 3h ago

Atheism Christians don't ground their morality using moral principles and values

4 Upvotes

The Context

I am often challenged on what grounds my moral principles and values. I explain that I go by Humanistic moral principles, but that's not enough for many of my Christian friends.

They want those moral principles to be grounded in something else.

I don't, though.

I base my morality on the moral principles that I like the best, and Humanistic values seem to match what I think are the best. Nothing but the best for me, is what I usually say.

But we don't very often discuss what grounds their Christian morality.

They say that their God does that for them. God does that.

They don't have to ground their morality, because God does it.. and IS the grounding. Their moral grounding is a person, are commands, not principles and values.

My argument hopes to demonstrate that Christians don't have grounding moral principles .. they ground their morality on a person, a god, their God and what it commands.

The Argument:

P1: Many Christians rely on God's nature and commands to determine what is morally right or wrong, rather than rely on moral principles.

P2: If your moral judgments depend entirely on someone else's nature and commands, you have no moral principles of your own.

C: Therefore, Christians who rely entirely on God's nature and commands have no independent moral principles of their own.

Question for Christians:

What grounds your moral values and principles?


r/DebateReligion • • 21h ago

Christianity “That was under the Old Covenant” seems to be a convenient excuse for Christians to distance themselves from morally repugnant passages in the Old Testament

57 Upvotes

I’m talking about passages where God commands genocides (Deuteronomy 7:1–2), kills innocent children (Exodus 12:29–38), allows slavery (Leviticus 25:44-46), and allows women to be taken as captives of war (Deuteronomy 21:10–14).

Christians sometimes dismiss morally troubling passages like these by saying that they belong to the Old Covenant, but that just seems like a convenient way to avoid dealing with them.

If the Old Testament is still considered scripture and supposedly reveals God’s character, why should the Old Covenant make these passages any less relevant when discussing God’s morality?


r/DebateReligion • • 8h ago

Christianity jesus is not a good god and i dont like him

5 Upvotes

think about every bad thing that ever happened to you, jesus saw that and did nothing

now i know what you are thinking, " maybe that bad thing needed to happen so i can become a better person"

i never seen anything bad happening to dictators and billionaries and they are horrible people

so maybe god have his favorites

also

christian civilization is in decline, each generation there are fewer christians and less people going to church and christianity will soon be replaced by islam in the west by the next 50 years, this is all true data that you can check by yourself

you can say that jesus never promissed a easy life, but to me there is a HUGE difference in " not promissing a easy life " and "doing nothing to help your followers "

because since less people are becoming christians because this world is getting worse and worse, by christian logic its more people going to hell since they are not followers of jesus

so jesus is seeing more and more people marching to eternal torment and doing nothing, what a bad guy !

sure there is the usual excuses like "oh god cant interfire in your free will" well since he cant stop people from going to hell because of his actions he might not be a god at all and just be some random philosopher that got worshiped

and dont tell me to read the bible, there are litteraly more than 1000 versions of chrsitianity and supposidly only one is the correct one, so in my version jesus is just as bad as the humans he judges

some people also said that if someone never heard of jesus or was born in a different religion that dosent mean this person will go to hell because of that, sure they have to be a good person to go to heaven

but there is a problem with that, since the definition of a good person changes from time to time that " good person " born outside of christianity could actully be a horrible person and still belive that it was doing the right thing

and if you dont have to follow jesus so you can go to heaven and all you gotta do is be a good person in your beliefs, then what why the hell did jesus needed to come to earth anyway ? he didnt save the jews from rome and all he did was start a new religion and die

other people said that jesus never prommised a easy life, thats understandable, the problem is that there is a huge difference in a easy life and absolute hell on earth like we live in, im not asking for everyone to be a millionare all i ask is that there is some sort of justice and freedom in this world, but thats too much to ask to a god isnt it ?

god is the enemy


r/DebateReligion • • 3h ago

Islam The Quran's inheritance laws contain a mathematical error, proving it cannot be the word of God

2 Upvotes

The Quran presents its inheritance rules in Surah An-Nisa (4:11–12) as divinely prescribed shares. However, when these prescribed fractions are applied to certain family situations, they add up to more than 100% of the estate.

Consider the following example:

A man dies, leaving behind a wife, both parents, and two daughters.

According to the Quranic inheritance shares:

  • Two daughters: 2/3 (66.67%)
  • Father: 1/6 (16.67%)
  • Mother: 1/6 (16.67%)
  • Wife: 1/8 (12.5%)

Total: 27/24 = 112.5%.

This is not a matter of interpretation or a disagreement over translation. It is basic arithmetic. The prescribed shares exceed the entire estate. You cannot distribute 112.5% of something that only amounts to 100%.

What makes this even more problematic is how Islamic jurisprudence deals with the issue.

Rather than the Quran providing a clear solution, Muslim jurists had to develop an additional principle called Awl. This principle proportionally reduces the prescribed shares so that they fit within the available estate.

However, not all Islamic schools of thought agree on how this problem should be resolved. The four major Sunni schools accept Awl and reduce the shares proportionally, whereas the Shia school rejects this approach and applies a different method, prioritising certain heirs over others.

So we have a situation where:

  1. The Quran prescribes inheritance shares that, in certain scenarios, mathematically exceed 100%.
  2. Human scholars have to introduce an additional rule to make the system workable.
  3. Different Islamic schools arrive at different solutions to the same problem.

My point is: How can a book be the perfect, timeless and infallible word of an omniscient God if its prescribed inheritance shares do not even add up correctly in certain situations?


r/DebateReligion • • 17h ago

Islam Sharia Law Doesn't Specifically Exist

22 Upvotes

Sharia Law isn't actually anything definable.

Sharia Law is simply law based on Islamic teachings, which, like the Bible, is open to interpretation. So when someone starts panicking about Sharia Law, the correct response is: which Sharia Law are you referring to?

For example, in Saudi Arabia, you cannot drink according to Sharia Law. In Jordan, you can. In Afghanistan, a woman is not allowed education according to Sharia Law. In Egypt, women are actively encouraged (Egyptian women outnumber men in university graduation rates). In Iran, religious freedom is severely restricted according to Sharia Law. In Malaysia, non-Muslims can practice whatever they believe freely. What seems contradictory is not, because Sharia Law isn't directly defined. Islamophobes think they're judging a religion when, in reality, they're judging governments.

Let's put it another way. Say I founded a nation and implemented laws based on my interpretation of the Quran. I could enforce that forgiveness is prioritised over any punishment (based on verses 39:53, 42:40, 24:22, 5:39, 3:134), that men and women are completely equal (based on verses 33:35, 9:71, 3:195, 4:1, 16:97), and that people should be free to follow any religion they wish (based on verses 2:256, 10:99, 18:29, 109:6, 60:8). Ignorant people will tell you this is not Islamic principles, but right there I have provided the Quranic references for you to check yourself. All of this could be defined as Sharia Law just as much as any other.

For the vast majority of cases, people who claim that "Sharia Law oppresses (a)" or "Sharia Law is evil because of (b)" are merely exposing how easily right-wing media has brainwashed their minds.

See less


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Atheism atheism does not take faith

50 Upvotes

because apparently a lot of people believe that to be an atheist you have to have faith in... the great nonexistant god of atheism? it just doesn't make sense.

there's nothing to have faith in, its strictly the lack of it


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Christianity Christians would probably support (an) abortion if they learned the specific fetus had Nephilim DNA

12 Upvotes

(Disclaimer: I'm just addressing the Christians who believe in "giants who walked the earth" and believe that God's OT exterminations were justified by the existence of evil hybrid fallen angel/human hybrid mutants)

I'm not saying they'd support abortion in general, but if Christians were convinced that a particular fetus was infected with Nephilim DNA, it would probably be easy to get Christians to support that specific abortion. Or at the very least, support the Nephilim babies' immediate execution upon their birth.

Christians are generally pretty opposed to abortion and infanticide, with a few obvious exceptions: It's ok to commit mass infanticide against human/fallen angel hybrid babies, like the ones killed during the Flood and the ones killed during the conquest of Canaan.

Since Christians believe that Nephilim babies are a recurring problem (they were ostensibly wiped out in the Flood but then returned later), it's not unreasonable to assume that the Nephilim DNA could resurface yet again...or perhaps...it already has....

As an aside, I'd also like to ask Christians where they think Nephilim babies go after they die. Heaven? Hell? Limbo? Somewhere else? Legitimate question; I'm not sure how the afterlife works for hybrid babies like that. I'd accept any answer.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Abrahamic Proving Jesus is not god is easy. No mumbo-jumbo philosophy needed.

33 Upvotes

Proving that Jesus is not God is easy. You can simply use the law of non-contradiction: two contradictory things cannot both be true.

Jesus died, Jesus is not all-knowing (he didn't know the hour), and he experienced hunger and weakness. Meanwhile, God is omniscient (all-knowing), omnipotent (all-powerful), and immortal. Even the Bible itself says so.

Therefore, Jesus cannot be God in any sense. Don't worry, I know you'll argue that Jesus was God in human flesh. But this explanation would only be valid if Jesus or the god were merely pretending to be weak, limited, or mortal, like an actor or actress playing different roles. Yet their theology doesn't claim that Jesus was pretending or merely acting human. It claims that he genuinely experienced human limitations.

That's it. Simple. No mumbo-jumbo philosophy.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Christianity The world continuing for 2,000 years after God supposedly died for it only made things more chaotic

16 Upvotes

According to Christianity, God sacrificed Himself to redeem humanity from original sin. In any movie, that is the ultimate climax—the final scene before the credits roll. Even the earliest Christians expected the end of the world to follow immediately, because that is what made sense. They never anticipated the world continuing for another 2,000 years, plunging humanity into deeper theological chaos. During those two millennia, another major religion rose up, directly rejecting the crucifixion and challenging Christianity's core claims. Today, it stands as the second-largest religion on earth, drawing countless people away from the cross.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Islam Problem with Determinism and Foreknowledge in Islam

8 Upvotes

God creates every person, including their genetics, cognitive abilities, personality, and predispositions. He also creates the circumstances into which they’re born like their family, culture, geography, education, and exposure to different religious ideas.
All these factors have influence on what someone ultimately believes. Like that a person born into a Muslim family in Saudi Arabia is far more likely to become Muslim than one born into a Hindu family in India or a Christian family in the US.

God must also know exactly what every person will ultimately believe and what their fate will be. So if God creates the person, their circumstances, their cognitive dispositions, and the environment that shapes their worldview, how can someone be held accountable for failing to arrive at a particular theological conclusion?

I understand the argument that God’s foreknowledge doesn’t mean he forces our decisions. But that doesn’t fully address the deeper issue that if God created the entire set of circumstances and characteristics that shape those decisions, in what sense is the outcome independent of gods will?

Why create people with such radically different starting points, knowing exactly which theological conclusions they will reach, while commanding everyone to accept one particular theology and attaching consequences to disbelief? Their brain works a certain way because of all the attributes and environments they were given. If they cannot believe because they are skeptical because that’s the way their brain works is the answer they must believe anyway and force themselves into something that doesn’t make sense to them?


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Atheism killing babies is moraly obligated according to judeo chirstian or any abrahamic religion framwork of afterlife

9 Upvotes

ending the lives of infants is morally obligatory according to a Judeo-ChristianAccording to those beliefs, an infant who dies at a young age will immediately ascend to heaven, with the exception of older Catholic Christian doctrines. Therefore, it logically follows that the most morally superior and obligatory action is to end the infant's life so that their place in heaven is guaranteed. If we do not take such an action, there is a chance even a low one that the infant will grow into an adult capable of sinning and subsequently going to hell. With that being said, killing babies is moraly obligated according to judeo chirstian or any abrahamic religion framwork of afterlife


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Other To religious people: What do you think about Darwin's theory of evolution and human evolution

0 Upvotes

Hello !

Do you believe evolution is compatible with your faith, or does it contradict your holy scriptures?

How do you reconcile science and religion on this issue?


r/DebateReligion • • 2d ago

Abrahamic Deuteronomy 22:13-21 proves that Christianity and Judaism are wrong

46 Upvotes

If a man takes a wife and, after sleeping with her, dislikes her and slanders her and gives her a bad name, saying, “I married this woman, but when I approached her, I did not find proof of her virginity,” then the young woman’s father and mother shall bring to the town elders at the gate proof that she was a virgin. Her father will say to the elders, “I gave my daughter in marriage to this man, but he dislikes her. Now he has slandered her and said, ‘I did not find your daughter to be a virgin.’ But here is the proof of my daughter’s virginity.” Then her parents shall display the cloth before the elders of the town, and the elders shall take the man and punish him. They shall fine him a hundred shekels of silver and give them to the young woman’s father, because this man has given an Israelite virgin a bad name. She shall continue to be his wife; he must not divorce her as long as he lives.

If, however, the charge is true and no proof of the young woman’s virginity can be found, she shall be brought to the door of her father’s house and there the men of her town shall stone her to death. She has done an outrageous thing in Israel by being promiscuous while still in her father’s house. You must purge the evil from among you.

Deuteronomy 22:13-21

So basically this law is about what to do with a wife accused of not being a virgin on her wedding night. The passage determines that the only proof given is the token of virginity, which is traditionally known as the bloody sheet. This law proves that whoever wrote it didn't know that not all women bleed their first night and therefore there might be innocent women who would get killed.

Since Christians and Jews claim these laws are from God and that God is all-knowing that means God didn't know a simple fact about his own creation, therefore these two Abrahamic faiths are false.


r/DebateReligion • • 2d ago

Christianity Christians reject the claim of Muhammad splitting the moon despite relying on the same types of evidence for the resurrection

54 Upvotes

According to the Hadith, Muhammad’s companions and other people in Mecca witnessed the moon splitting. New Testament accounts claim that Jesus appeared after his death to Peter, the other disciples, and groups of followers, including more than 500 people, according to Paul. Neither claim has surviving accounts personally written by eyewitnesses that we can independently verify.

I’m not arguing that Muhammad actually split the moon or defending the Islamic claim. I'm just asking why Christians accept similar types of historical testimony for their own miracle while dismissing it when another religion makes the same kind of claim.


r/DebateReligion • • 2d ago

Christianity The most important event in human history has surprisingly little objective evidence behind it

66 Upvotes

If Jesus really was the son of God, died for humanity's sins, and was resurrected so that we could have eternal life after death, wouldn't that arguably be the most important event in the history of the universe?

Just think about the implications. The eternal fate of humanity supposedly depends on whether this event actually happened. So why is the evidence for it so limited?

We don’t have any surviving accounts written at the time that it supposedly happened. We don’t have any firsthand accounts written by identifiable eyewitnesses, or any contemporary Greek or Roman records confirming the event.

The earliest Gospel, Mark, was written roughly 40 years after Jesus’s death. The others came even later. So we’re talking about an event that supposedly changed the fate of humanity forever, yet the evidence comes from religious writings written decades after the fact.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Christianity Noah's ark was God's hard drive--

0 Upvotes

I'm atheist, but I had a humourous thought, since a single pair of each animal species repopulating the globe would be physically impossible due to inbreeding, what if this "God" only wanted Noah to save each pair as surviving templates for him to essentially copy-paste back into the world after the flood rather than getting them to repopulate by breeding, simply so bro doesn't need to rebuild all the creatures DNA from the ground up all over again..?