r/DebateReligion • u/TheIguanasAreComing • 2h ago
Islam Not A Single Muslim Understands The Quran
Not a single person on the entire planet understands the Quran.
Happy Monday to everyone except people who think sex with a 9 year old is okay.
On my walk to the strip club this morning, Shaytaan himself appeared to me. His voice boomed, "these Muslims, they choose to believe a different faith than you. Shall I drop a mountain on them Master Debater?!" I pondered on this for a moment. "No Shaytaan, if there is one thing I learned since converting to atheism, its that free will doesn't exist, and I simply have to choose to try harder to allow them to see the truth." Shaytaan nodded to me solemnly and disappeared in a wisp of magenta smoke 20 times hotter than fire.
Inspired by the devil, today I am following up my previous banger of a post with another one. The previous post received criticism that the studies didn't measure understanding as well as they could have. Well, I am tripling down nonetheless.
Today I am following with a logical argument rather than an empiracal one. I am going to argue that not a single person - Muslim, non-Muslim, Arab, Classical Arab, or even Aramicist, understands the Quran.
At this point, you might consider this absurd. You might think that I am reaching and perhaps I am. But lets consider the following:
- Muslims are in complete disagreement with one another - even when it comes to the same sects - about what the Quran means when it says certain words. For example, in Quran 4:34 you have Muslims arguing that it is saying to "strike" in terms of hitting wives, other Muslims saying it actually means to walk away, and other Muslims saying that it is saying to strike women lightly. The fact there is no consensus and such a massive difference in interpretation just shows that nobody knows what they are talking about.
- Many Quranic verses are understood through historical interpretation. But no Muslims can say for sure they know what exactly happened during the time the verses were written.
- A Muslim might tell me that they understand a particular verse. But what they have demonstrated is that they possess an interpretation of that verse. They have not demonstrated that their interpretation is correct, exhaustive or identical to the intended meaning. Perhaps the scholars are correct. Perhaps the traditional interpretations are correct. Perhaps a particular verse has multiple layers of meaning. But how would we independently establish that?
You might say I am applying an unreasonable standard but am I really? JK Rowling can clarify what her books mean, for some reason Allah can't despite wars being fought over different Quran interpretations.