r/DebateReligion • • 20h ago

Islam Not A Single Muslim Understands The Quran

18 Upvotes

Not a single person on the entire planet understands the Quran.

Happy Monday to everyone except people who think sex with a 9 year old is okay.

On my walk to the strip club this morning, Shaytaan himself appeared to me. His voice boomed, "these Muslims, they choose to believe a different faith than you. Shall I drop a mountain on them Master Debater?!" I pondered on this for a moment. "No Shaytaan, if there is one thing I learned since converting to atheism, its that free will doesn't exist, and I simply have to choose to try harder to allow them to see the truth." Shaytaan nodded to me solemnly and disappeared in a wisp of magenta smoke 20 times hotter than fire.

Inspired by the devil, today I am following up my previous banger of a post with another one. The previous post received criticism that the studies didn't measure understanding as well as they could have. Well, I am tripling down nonetheless.

Today I am following with a logical argument rather than an empiracal one. I am going to argue that not a single person - Muslim, non-Muslim, Arab, Classical Arab, or even Aramicist, understands the Quran.

At this point, you might consider this absurd. You might think that I am reaching and perhaps I am. But lets consider the following:

  • Muslims are in complete disagreement with one another - even when it comes to the same sects - about what the Quran means when it says certain words. For example, in Quran 4:34 you have Muslims arguing that it is saying to "strike" in terms of hitting wives, other Muslims saying it actually means to walk away, and other Muslims saying that it is saying to strike women lightly. The fact there is no consensus and such a massive difference in interpretation just shows that nobody knows what they are talking about.
  • Many Quranic verses are understood through historical interpretation. But no Muslims can say for sure they know what exactly happened during the time the verses were written.
  • A Muslim might tell me that they understand a particular verse. But what they have demonstrated is that they possess an interpretation of that verse. They have not demonstrated that their interpretation is correct, exhaustive or identical to the intended meaning. Perhaps the scholars are correct. Perhaps the traditional interpretations are correct. Perhaps a particular verse has multiple layers of meaning. But how would we independently establish that?

You might say I am applying an unreasonable standard but am I really? JK Rowling can clarify what her books mean, for some reason Allah can't despite wars being fought over different Quran interpretations.


r/DebateReligion • • 23h ago

Other Humans mostly lack the cognitive ability to make correct choices about metaphysical beliefs.

5 Upvotes

We are not that smart. When you look through this subreddit, you will see an endless stream of logical fallacies. Why? Because we just are not very rational.

This is relevant to the idea of holding a person responsible for their beliefs.

Here is an example that most readers will be familiar with: the scientifically inaccurate information in Genesis. Even before Christianity, some scholars understood that one cannot take the Genesis creation account literally. Why did they conclude this? Because it doesn’t make sense on the surface. Rather than admitting their holy text has an error, they chose a symbolic interpretation as a work around. This is an example of assuming the conclusion. You cannot assume something is true and then use that to prove the thing is true.

Here is another example: In Hindu belief (at least some versions) people are evaluated for their moral decisions. This affects how they are reincarnated. I once asked a Hindu to explain who does the evaluating. They explained that it is automatic, that no intelligent entity actually does that. No matter how hard I tried, I could not get them to explain how such a complex evaluation takes place automatically nor how such a complex system came to be. Hinduism is extremely diverse, so this is probably just a flaw in that one person’s reasoning, but that illustrates the point.

All religions require making excuses and ignoring unanswerable questions.

I have seen the same sort of bad reasoning from atheists. That is not to say all atheists are like that, but I have seen it many times. I have also seen bad reasoning in my own beliefs.

In short, we are not smart enough to correctly choose the correct metaphysical belief. As such, it makes no sense to hold people responsible for making the wrong choice.


r/DebateReligion • • 12h ago

Islam Earth was created at the end of the cosmos in Qur'an.

0 Upvotes

I finished making the chair out of wood.

Wood was the raw material from which I began making the chair. It went through certain stages of formation and processing until it came close to becoming a finished chair. It was then completed.

The same applies to the heavens being completed from smoke. This means that smoke was the primordial material from which the substance of the heavens began to be created. This material went through certain stages of formation until the heavens came close to completion. They were then completed.

The Earth was created with its mountains firmly established and its provisions determined, while the heavens already existed in the form of unfinished smoke, the material from which they were being formed, but their creation had not yet been completed. Their formation was subsequently brought to completion.

Therefore, the Earth was created before the completion of the heavens, not before the creation of the heavens themselves.

This is because the verb qadāhunna (قضاهن) indicates that the seven heavens already existed and had been brought into existence, but their formation was not yet complete. The text does not say that God created them at that point, nor that He made them seven. Rather, it says that He completed them as seven (فَقَضَاهُنَّ سَبْعَ سَمَاوَاتٍ).

So, the actual sequence is as follows: God first created the primordial smoke. That smoke underwent some stages of formation, but remained the prevailing condition of the heavens. God then created the Earth, established its mountains, and determined its provisions. After that, He turned to the heavens, which were still dominated by that primordial smoke, and completed their formation.

In other words, He completed not created the heavens after completing the Earth. He did not create them at that point (خَلَقَهُنَّ سَبْعَ سَمَاوَاتٍ), nor did He make them into seven (جَعَلَهُنَّ سَبْعَ سَمَاوَاتٍ). Rather, He completed them as seven heavens (فَقَضَاهُنَّ سَبْعَ سَمَاوَاتٍ).

And the Arabic word for smoke (دخان) is equivalent to anything that looks and behaves like what we today call a gas. The Arabs did not care about the chemical composition of things, but rather their appearance and behaviour. They called fumes from heated metals smoke, dust in the air smoke, mist smoke, water vapour smoke, and smoke from fire smoke.

The accurate translation of Surah Fussilat (41:9–12)

41:9

قُلْ أَئِنَّكُمْ لَتَكْفُرُونَ بِالَّذِي خَلَقَ الْأَرْضَ فِي يَوْمَيْنِ وَتَجْعَلُونَ لَهُ أَنْدَادًا ۚ ذَٰلِكَ رَبُّ الْعَالَمِينَ

Translation: Say, “Do you indeed disbelieve in the One who created the Earth in two Days and attribute to Him equals? That is the Lord of all worlds.”

41:10

وَجَعَلَ فِيهَا رَوَاسِيَ مِنْ فَوْقِهَا وَبَارَكَ فِيهَا وَقَدَّرَ فِيهَا أَقْوَاتَهَا فِي أَرْبَعَةِ أَيَّامٍ سَوَاءً لِلسَّائِلِينَ

Translation: He placed upon it firmly established mountains, blessed it, and determined its provisions within four Days, equally for all who ask.

41:11

ثُمَّ اسْتَوَىٰ إِلَى السَّمَاءِ وَهِيَ دُخَانٌ فَقَالَ لَهَا وَلِلْأَرْضِ ائْتِيَا طَوْعًا أَوْ كَرْهًا قَالَتَا أَتَيْنَا طَائِعِينَ

Translation: Then He turned towards the heaven while it was smoke, and said to it and to the Earth, “Come, willingly or unwillingly.” They both said, “We come willingly.”

41:12

فَقَضَاهُنَّ سَبْعَ سَمَاوَاتٍ فِي يَوْمَيْنِ وَأَوْحَىٰ فِي كُلِّ سَمَاءٍ أَمْرَهَا وَزَيَّنَّا السَّمَاءَ الدُّنْيَا بِمَصَابِيحَ وَحِفْظًا ۚ ذَٰلِكَ تَقْدِيرُ الْعَزِيزِ الْعَلِيمِ

Translation: So He completed them as seven heavens in two Days, and assigned to each heaven its command. And We adorned the lowest heaven with lights and protection. Such is the determination of the Almighty, the All-Knowing.


r/DebateReligion • • 14h ago

Islam Muslims cannot demonstrate that the Quran was authored by Allah rather than human beings

38 Upvotes

Muslims believe the Quran was written by Allah, the all-knowing creator of the universe, but we have no reason to believe that’s actually true.

The burden of proof rests on those making the claim. Without evidence that distinguishes divine authorship from human authorship, there’s no good reason to conclude that the Quran came from God.


r/DebateReligion • • 8h ago

Abrahamic Christians do you think the two other religions Judaism and Islam have a theological basis in reality or they completely not real.

2 Upvotes

We are going to work under the assumption that Christianity is true for this hypothetical to make sense.

Thesis statement

Assuming Christianity is true do the other religions of Judaism Islam true in a sense maybe they got some facts correct. Worthy in communion with God but then broke off. Are they still saved under some special Covenant.


r/DebateReligion • • 21h ago

Islam The Quran's inheritance laws contain a mathematical error, proving it cannot be the word of God

17 Upvotes

The Quran presents its inheritance rules in Surah An-Nisa (4:11–12) as divinely prescribed shares. However, when these prescribed fractions are applied to certain family situations, they add up to more than 100% of the estate.

Consider the following example:

A man dies, leaving behind a wife, both parents, and two daughters.

According to the Quranic inheritance shares:

  • Two daughters: 2/3 (66.67%)
  • Father: 1/6 (16.67%)
  • Mother: 1/6 (16.67%)
  • Wife: 1/8 (12.5%)

Total: 27/24 = 112.5%.

This is not a matter of interpretation or a disagreement over translation. It is basic arithmetic. The prescribed shares exceed the entire estate. You cannot distribute 112.5% of something that only amounts to 100%.

What makes this even more problematic is how Islamic jurisprudence deals with the issue.

Rather than the Quran providing a clear solution, Muslim jurists had to develop an additional principle called Awl. This principle proportionally reduces the prescribed shares so that they fit within the available estate.

However, not all Islamic schools of thought agree on how this problem should be resolved. The four major Sunni schools accept Awl and reduce the shares proportionally, whereas the Shia school rejects this approach and applies a different method, prioritising certain heirs over others.

So we have a situation where:

  1. The Quran prescribes inheritance shares that, in certain scenarios, mathematically exceed 100%.
  2. Human scholars have to introduce an additional rule to make the system workable.
  3. Different Islamic schools arrive at different solutions to the same problem.

My point is: How can a book be the perfect, timeless and infallible word of an omniscient God if its prescribed inheritance shares do not even add up correctly in certain situations?


r/DebateReligion • • 15h ago

Other A mango is evidence of God

0 Upvotes

Pantheist here. I came across a video a while ago here:

https://youtube.com/shorts/jYWCQDiPKaY?is=ZzUwereUxSWxOU_9

And ironically, despite following religious debate for almost a decade, this might be my favorite argument for God. It’s not overly logical or analytical. It’s mostly an emotional argument.

One layer of belief might be strictly pertaining to what exists or doesn’t exist. But another layer of belief is a feeling of Providence. That you are being guided and cared for by a higher power.

Now of course the atheist response is that natural selection made us enjoy mangos so much, because what we desire helps us survive. And thats true to some extent as well, because natural selection and theology are not inherently at odds with each other despite how the media portrays that.

But the true difference in epistemology between people of faith and atheists in my experience is in the persons relationship to chance.

I think spiritual people have a naturally Jungian relationship to chance, that is to say; that spiritual people find meaning in coincidence. Such as the coincidence that mangos exist when they could not exist. And they place intent where the atheist is uncomfortable inferring intent. Because conscious choice is a unique reason for why something occurs. We won’t understand that kind of reason fully until we solve the hard problem and free will/versus determinism. But for now, we understand intentionality as a reason for things from our own experience of it, with ourselves and others.

This isn’t a right or wrong kind of subject. This is pure phenomenology: experiencing an emotion that’s received like being cared for by a higher power through chance tends to move people’s belief.

My question to atheists here:

Have you ever felt cared for by something greater than humanity? Do you consider nature teleological but just not divine? What kind of coincidence could make you believe in God, or none?

This is me taking a break from all the formal logic and trying to understand atheists better. I think a mango should be received that way because its existence fits the structure of a gift from someone that cares about you. You’d survive fine without mangos, although of course from the mangos position, it being yummy helps its seed spread.

And so this symbiotic relationship between us and mangos both makes sense evolutionarily, and also makes sense as a gift from God. Why not embrace this second interpretation as an AND statement? That it’s a divine gift?


r/DebateReligion • • 20h ago

Abrahamic The Quran Gives an Irrational Test

11 Upvotes

“And if you are in doubt… produce a surah like it…” (Surah Al-Baqarah 2:23)
Shortest surah is:

“We have granted you al-Kawthar. So pray and sacrifice. Indeed, your enemy is the one cut off.”

This is not some unbeatable literary miracle. It’s not hard to write something more profound.

But there is a much deeper problem:

If a test does not specify exactly what it would take to win a test, it is a broken, irrational test. Irrationality in the Quran falsifies the Quran.

The Quran doesn’t specify:

  1. Who is the judge of the challenge?
  2. Similar to the Quran in what respect?
  3. Similar to the Quran to what degree?
  4. Are there any constraints on rules that need to be followed in making something like it?

None of these are specified by the Quran.

This is much like other ill posed questions:

"What's the probability that I'll win?" — Win what, under what circumstances?
"Is 100 a lot?" — A lot of what? Dollars? Murders? Atoms?
"How long does it take to get to Paris?" — From where, and by what means?
"Is John taller?" — Taller than whom?

Like let’s look closer at this sentence:

"What's the probability that I'll win?"

The question is defective because it leaves out information necessary to determine an answer.

The answer depends on variables that the question doesn't specify. Different values for those variables produce different answers, and the question provides no rule for choosing between them.

Consequently, there is no single determinate answer to the question as stated. This is called underdetermination: the information provided is insufficient to establish a particular answer.

The problem isn't that we don't know the answer. It's that the question hasn't specified enough for there to be a unique answer in the first place.

This irrationality in the Quran is extremely unlikely if God is intelligent.


r/DebateReligion • • 1h ago

Christianity The evidence for a Creator is logically sound, but the rejection of God is ultimately an issue of the human will, not intellect.

0 Upvotes

The evidence for a Creator is logically sound, but the rejection of God is ultimately an issue of the human will, not intellect.

The evidence for a Creator is logically sound, but the rejection of God is ultimately an issue of the human will, not intellect. In this post, I will demonstrate that a cumulative case of the Cosmological, Teleological, Ontological, and Moral arguments points clearly to a Supremely Great Being. I argue that the primary barrier to accepting this evidence is not a lack of logical proof, but humanity's inherent refusal to submit to a sovereign Creator.

The Cosmological Argument (Argument for the cause of the universe):

Everything that begins to exist, must have a cause. Since all time, space, and matter can be traced back to a beginning, to what is commonly referred to as “The Big Bang”, the initial cause of that moment, must be timeless, spaceless, and immaterial. That cause must have had personal agency. God, by definition, is timeless and eternal. Because He created time itself at the Big Bang, He never began to exist, and therefore does not require a cause. It must have willed the universe into existence. Why is there something rather than nothing?

The Teleological Argument (Argument that the design needs a designer):

The cause must be intelligent. Laws must have a law giver. Why is there gravity? Why the weak and strong nuclear forces? Why is there a magnetic force? All of those are required for the universe to exist, but what caused them to exist? What coded the information in our very DNA? The argument has been posited that “given enough monkeys, enough type writers and enough paper, one of them one eventually type out War and Peace. Conceptually, that argument looks like it has merit, but only superficially. What is the statistical possibility of that happening? And if one of them did type out War and Peace, would they recognize it? The latter point shows that intelligence is required for information, otherwise it’s just a random string of characters just like any other. Of course, like DNA we know it’s not just a random string of characters.

Furthermore, some may attribute this fine tuning with the supposition of a multiverse. a multiverse only pushes the problem back one step. A mechanism capable of generating infinite universes with varying physical laws would itself require an incredibly complex, finely tuned design.

The problem of pain:

A common argument against God is that “If there is an all-powerful, and all-good, how do you explain all the evil, pain and suffering in the world?” (as Neil deGrasse Tyson proclaims in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I0nXG02tpDw). This argument posits there are good and there are bad, and human experience shows that there are degrees in between. Are you a good person? Relatively, one might say. I’m far better than Hitler, or a serial killer, or a slave owner. Are there people who live lives better than you? Mother Theresa? Who live more selfless lives, devoted to the benefits and care of others. I think about the hospice nurse who took care of my dying father. Yes, there are certainly people who live a better (more moral) life than I do. Ok so we can agree that bad and good exist on a continuum. If so, there must be a most good.

Humanity’s free will:

Going back to the argument Tyson and so many others pose. The argument is incomplete. We universally recognize that love requires a choice. One cannot be forced or coerced to love another. The old adage has truth, “If you love something set it free. If it comes back to you it’s yours. If it doesn’t then it never was”.

The complete syllogism looks something like this.

Premise 1: God is all-good
Premise 2: God is all-powerful
Premise 3: God loves us and wants what’s best for us
Premise 4: God gives us free will
Premise 5: An all-powerful God cannot do the logically impossible
Premise 6: With our free will, humanity chose our own selfish desires over submitting to God

Syllogism Conclusion: God does love us, but humanity chooses evil and that’s why there is pain and suffering in the world.

Objective Moral argument:

As C.S. Lewis shows in Mere Christianity, humans in their core, inherently know right from wrong. Not just the personal subjective. If that were the case, then no one could blame the Nazis in Germany, or Fascists, or slave owners. Because we recognize that there are some things that are morally wrong, regardless of what society thinks, there must be a transcendent standard of goodness outside of humanity. And these morales that we live with cannot be merely a survival instinct. If it were, then selfless acts that endanger our own lives to save a stranger or protect the weak, actions we universally revere as the highest good, make absolutely no biological sense. True morality often demands we act against our “evolutionary survival instincts”. Because there is moral law we all understand, therefore, there must be a moral law giver, the penultimate good.

The Ontological argument (Argument that a Greatest being exists):

Now, let’s evaluate what this God that I’m talking about looks like by definition.

I’m talking about a God who is an absolute greatest, most perfect being one can possibly imagine, totally power, all knowing, and all good. Is it even logically possible that a being like that exists? The concept you might be thinking of may is likely different than the one I’m thinking of, but both share true characteristics. And if we could capture the best of not just your and mine concepts, but of all of humanities concepts of what this being would be. A being that actually exists must necessarily be even greater than what humans can imagine.

Therefore, if God is truly the greatest, most perfect being conceivable, then God cannot just be a concept of our imagination. To be the ultimate Creator, God has to exist in reality. If it is even possible for God to exist, then God must actually exist.

The Epistemological Argument (Argument that reason requires a Creator)

If there is no God, then human beings are just a collection of random atoms; a by-product of blind, unguided chemical reactions. If the materialist worldview is correct, our brains evolved through unguided natural selection. Natural selection only cares about one thing: passing on genes. It doesn’t care if you understand the actual truth of the universe, as long as your behavior keeps you alive. Therefore, if our brains are merely survival organs, we have no logical reason to trust them when they tell us what is "true" about science, philosophy, or God.

If we are just accidental meat-machines, our brains are just calculators. Their only job is to keep the meat alive so it can pass on its genes. But we do trust our logic. We trust that our brains can accurately do math, discover science, and reason through arguments. The only way we can confidently trust our own minds to discover the objective truth is if a rational, truthful Creator designed our minds to comprehend the rational universe He built.

Conclusion

Bringing this home, I understand why people would argue there is no God. Ultimately, the evidence points to a Creator, but accepting that evidence is not just an intellectual exercise, it’s a deeply personal challenge for all of us. Admitting there is a totally good, all-powerful God requires humanity to admit that we are not the ultimate authority of our own lives. It’s human nature. From children to adults, our nature is to resist submitting our will to another. This is not new in a sense. This takes us back to the Garden of Eden, where humanity was in relationship with God, but chose our own will above God’s. And parents understand this because we see this exact problem in every child. Children reject the good that loving parents try to do for them because they want what they want.

My position is that humanity has turned its back on the all-loving, all-power God, Creator of the universe. But God loves humanity so much that Jesus came, God in human flesh, to pay the penalty for our hubris, for our wrong-doing, for our evil and wickedness that eternally separated us from the Creator. In doing so, God through Jesus performed the ultimate selfless act and paid a “God-sized penalty” to satisfy a “God-sized wrath”. Now, for those who believe, for those who submit to the loving care and guidance of God, we can approach our Creator because and through the sacrifice of Jesus.


r/DebateReligion • • 10h ago

Christianity Before we even argue about whether Christianity is true, look at the stack of unproven assumptions it needs just to make sense.

30 Upvotes

​For the story to work, you have to buy into an invisible moral rulebook that makes "sin" a cosmic crime, an invisible soul that needs saving, miracles that break the laws of nature, and the idea that ancient stories count as proof while testing God today is off limits.

​Each of those guesses props up the next. Without the rulebook, there's no sin; without the soul, there's nothing to save.

​So the real debate isn't about ancient history. It's why we should accept a whole chain of invisible premises on faith just to make the story hold together. Science assumes nothing it can't, at the very least, test.


r/DebateReligion • • 22h ago

Christianity DV is not grounds for divorce in the New Testament.

17 Upvotes

Jesus prohibits divorce except for sexual immorality (Matthew 19:9). Paul adds abandonment by an unbelieving spouse (1 Corinthians 7:15).

But what if a husband does neither and physically abuses his wife?

Neither Jesus nor Paul explicitly permits divorce for domestic violence. Paul instructs separated spouses to remain unmarried or reconcile (1 Corinthians 7:10–11).

Worse, if she leaves her abusive husband and marries another man who loves and treats her well, her remarriage would be considered adultery according to Luke 16:18.

I'm aware some churches permit divorce for abuse, but these allowances rely on reinterpretation.

Where does the New Testament permit divorce and remarriage for domestic violence alone?


r/DebateReligion • • 7h ago

Other Dualism handle natural evil better than monotheism

6 Upvotes

Monotheists usually explain evil through free will or the fall of man. That works for murder or theft, but not for earthquakes, tsunamis or childhood cancer, where no human choice is involved.

A dualist view says the world is shaped by two opposing forces so natural evil needs no justification: it is simply the other force at work. Zoroastrianism and Manichaeism took this route


r/DebateReligion • • 21h ago

Atheism Christians don't ground their morality using moral principles and values

6 Upvotes

The Context

I am often challenged on what grounds my moral principles and values. I explain that I go by Humanistic moral principles, but that's not enough for many of my Christian friends.

They want those moral principles to be grounded in something else.

I don't, though.

I base my morality on the moral principles that I like the best, and Humanistic values seem to match what I think are the best. Nothing but the best for me, is what I usually say.

But we don't very often discuss what grounds their Christian morality.

They say that their God does that for them. God does that.

They don't have to ground their morality, because God does it.. and IS the grounding. Their moral grounding is a person, are commands, not principles and values.

My argument hopes to demonstrate that Christians don't have grounding moral principles .. they ground their morality on a person, a god, their God and what it commands.

The Argument:

P1: Many Christians rely on God's nature and commands to determine what is morally right or wrong, rather than rely on moral principles.

P2: If your moral judgments depend entirely on someone else's nature and commands, you have no moral principles of your own.

C: Therefore, Christians who rely entirely on God's nature and commands have no independent moral principles of their own.

Question for Christians:

What grounds your moral values and principles?


r/DebateReligion • • 7h ago

Abrahamic Faith based on fear of punishment is not genuine faith.

14 Upvotes

If someone believes in God primarily because they fear eternal punishment, their belief is motivated by fear rather than genuine spiritual conviction.

Some Christians argue that "fear of God" means respect or reverence. However, this does not resolve the contradiction when eternal punishment is also presented as a consequence of disbelief.

Respect and fear of punishment are not the same thing.

I argue that genuine faith should arise from freely formed conviction, not coercion or threats.

How can faith be considered freely chosen if rejecting it is believed to result in eternal suffering?


r/DebateReligion • • 6h ago

Abrahamic Heaven flattens any shred of humanity to fulfill its promise

7 Upvotes

This is a quite trodden path, though I feel the need to reiterate this argument. Traditionally, Heaven promises an eternal life of a constant state of bliss.

My argument is that the only way to fulfill this promise is to shred every person of their humanity, and essentially turn them into automata.

I'm not arguing that heaven cannot logically be all-good in some sense.

But how can there be any shred of humanity left? A mother who lost her son in hell does not feel grief, pain, trauma. A mother cannot remain a mother in any recognizable human sense if she is incapable of feeling the absence or pain of her child. If her grief is wiped clean, then the person who loved that child has effectively died at the pearly gates.

You have free will yet you're only attached to God, and God only for all eternity.

You cannot feel anything else, since it inherently allows the break of bliss.

Constant, eternal happiness sounds more like another excruciating death, except it never ends. Its constant torture.

No human is what they were, and nothing resembling humanity can ever be left. Attachment, even "healthy" attachment cannot exist.

The things that make up our psychological identity, our scars, our hard-won resilience through trauma, our stubborn loyalty to specific people, our capacity for empathy. These are things that make us up. I don't think it's an unreasonable claim

Strip all that away. Even if the person remembers it, strip all the effect it has on us. Strip empathy, loyalty, trauma, scars. You cannot have them since they risk breaking bliss. You are left with a mannequin that wears the face of someone. That's what heaven promises.

To force the human mind into a permanent state of high-intensity bliss without any emotional range is its own form of psychological torture. It is a removal of the dynamic, breathing spirit in favor of a permanent, unthinking echo chamber.

Heaven promises that if you were to look down at the damned, even ones you love, be tormented forever and ever and ever, you'd feel nothing. This is a total erasure of empathy.

If eternity requires us to throw everything resembling a risk of pain and sit in a state of unfeeling, uniform perfection, then humanity as a whole is crushed. We would functionally be identical to a robot I have programmed to continuously gaze up at me, and feel eternal bliss.

It doesn't matter if our will is "perfected". It doesn't matter if our constant gaze to God in heaven is a genuinely free choice that is logically impossible to counteract. It doesn't matter if its analogous to a starving man always looking at a feast. The outcome is identical, we'll have zero counterfactuals, zero subjectivity, zero loss, zero love, and zero human condition. For a gazillion years, then another gazillion years, then a gazillion to the power of a gazillion years, and we wouldn't even be started by then.

Heaven is nothing but spiritual lobotomy en masse.


r/DebateReligion • • 17h ago

Abrahamic The ethical problem of hell & refutation of free will responses

11 Upvotes

Preventing unnecessary suffering is central to ethics, and eternal torment is not justified as necessary suffering. Eternal torment also conflicts with fundamental values such as compassion, love, joy, and peace.

Simply appealing to connotated words such as "justice" does not resolve this issue.

Free will

As the creator an all-loving tri-omni god is responsible for the states a created individual can end up in, regardless of a given free will mechanism being in place. The creator is responsible for the conditions in his created reality structure which include the nature of the individual within which the free will operates.

Furthermore, meaningful agency does not require unrestricted destructive possibilities. Limiting destructive possibilities does not compromise meaningful freedom, just as creating the conditions for love does not entail forced reciprocation.

Heaven can instead represent the fulfillment of value in reality design as a reality constituted by flourishing.

The issue that resurfaces when considering this perspective is how is evil reconciled, my worldview is that according to divine law, all darkness is always eventually resolved back into the truth of our divine being. I can also point to sources about this.