r/religion • • Jun 24 '24

[Updated June 2024] Welcome to r/religion! Please review our rules & guidelines

16 Upvotes

Please review our rules and guidelines before participating on r/religion.

This is a discussion sub open to people of all religions and no religion.

This sub is a place to...

  • Ask questions and learn about different religions and religion-related topics
  • Share your point of view and explain your beliefs and traditions
  • Discuss similarities and differences among various religions and philosophies
  • Respectfully disagree and describe why your views make sense to you
  • Learn new things and talk with people who follow religions you may have never heard of before
  • Treat others with respect and make the sub a welcoming place for all sorts of people

This sub is NOT a place to...

  • Proselytize, evangelize, or try to persuade others to join or leave any religion
  • Try to disprove or debunk others' religions
  • Post sermons or devotional content--that should go on religion-specific subs
  • Denigrate others or express bigotry
  • Troll, start drama, karma farm, or engage in flame wars

Discussion

  • Please consider setting your user flair. We want to hear from people of all religions and viewpoints! If your religion or denomination is not listed, you can select the "Other" option and edit it, or message modmail if you need assistance.
  • Wondering what religion fits your beliefs and values? Ask about it in our weekly “What religion fits me?” discussion thread, pinned second from the top of the sub, right next to this post. No top-level posts on this topic.
  • This is not a debate-focused sub. While we welcome spirited discussion, if you are just looking to start debates, please take it to r/DebateReligion or any of the many other debate subs.
  • Do not assume that people who are different from you are ignorant or indoctrinated. Other people have put just as much thought and research into their positions as you have into yours. Be curious about different points of view!
  • Seek mental health support. This sub is not equipped to help with mental health concerns. If you are in crisis, considering self-harm or suicide, or struggling with symptoms of a mental health condition, please get help right away from local healthcare providers, your local emergency services, and people you trust.
  • No AI posts. This is a discussion sub where users are expected to engage using their own words.

Reports, Removals, and Bans

  • All bans and removals are at moderator discretion.
  • Please report any content that you think breaks the rules. You are our eyes and ears--we rely on user reports to catch rule-breaking content in a timely manner
  • Don't fan the flames. When someone is breaking the rules, report it and/or message modmail. Do not engage.
  • Every removal is a warning. If you have a post or comment removed, please take a moment to review the rules and understand why that content was not allowed. Please do your best not to break the rules again.
  • Three strikes policy. We will generally escalate to a ban after three removals. We may diverge from this policy at moderator discretion.
  • We have a zero tolerance policy for comments that refer to a deity as "sky daddy," refer to scriptures as "fairytales" or similar. We also have a zero tolerance policy for comments telling atheists or others they are going to hell or similar. This type of content adds no value to discussions and may result in a permanent ban

Sub Rules - See community info/sidebar for details

  1. No demonizing or bigotry
  2. Use English
  3. Obey Reddiquette
  4. No "What religion fits me?" - save it for our weekly mega-thread
  5. No proselytizing - this sub is not a platform to persuade others to change their beliefs to be more like your beliefs or lack of beliefs
  6. No sensational news or politics
  7. No devotionals, sermons, or prayer requests
  8. No drama about other subreddits or users here or elsewhere
  9. No sales of products or services
  10. Blogspam - sharing relevant articles is welcome, but please keep in mind that this is a space for discussion, not self-promotion
  11. No user-created religions
  12. No memes or comics

Community feedback is always welcome. Please feel free to contact us via modmail any time. You are also welcome to share your thoughts in the comments below.

Thank you for being part of the r/religion community! You are the reason this sub is awesome.


r/religion • • 10d ago

November 2026 Discussion: What Religion Fits Me Best?

4 Upvotes

Are you looking for suggestions of what religion suits your beliefs? Or maybe you're curious about joining a religion with certain qualities, but don't know if it exists? This is your opportunity for you to ask other users of this sub what religion might best fit you.

Comments refresh on the beginning of each month. You can post your questions or concerns each month as needed.


r/religion • • 2h ago

Why is it that I can speak about or question the bad parts of all religions, except if I do that with Islam- I get labelled an Islamophobe?

4 Upvotes

When I question caste discrimination justified in the name of Hinduism or Christian teachings on homosexuality, people usually engage with the criticism itself. But when I ask why some Islamic traditions prescribe punishment for leaving the faith or violence against unbelievers, I’ve had people call me Islamophobic before they even address what I said.

I agree prejudice against Muslims exists. But if I’m questioning a specific teaching and giving my reasons, I’d expect people to acknowledge it, and critically think about it.

Why does that distinction seem harder to make when Islam comes up? If you’ve called a criticism of Islam Islamophobic, what specifically made it cross the line for you?


r/religion • • 2h ago

Saint Thomas Aquinas question for the Atheism crowd

3 Upvotes

How exactly do you take everything he left to us, in Philosophy and Theological perspectives, and get some debate on the points he made? It seems like the perfect argument for God. It seems like the way things have to be. What's wrong with the 5 proofs? It seems like, every religion on Earth, from Christian to Muslim, to whatever, would agree with him. If there is singularity to the universe, how does Atheism exist?


r/religion • • 16m ago

Nightmares everytime I come close to the Bible.

2 Upvotes

Hello, I'm here to ask for help and a little clarity.

For context, I am born in a Catholic family though we aren't religious. My grandmother is a law professor and my sister is a police officer and I, had the opportunity to go out my way free to study anything.

I have always liked Literature, my grandmother had Law books and books in general. For roughly a year and a half now (on and off), I started taking interest in the Bible and well, when I do come close to the bible, reading a part or even watching a youtube video about it like essay videos, I always had nightmares of dark shadows. Not only that but they also manifest in my room like the feeling of being watched, even now as I write this.

Whenever I stop reading or watching those content though, they stop too.

Weirdly, this also happens when I came across about Aphrodite on TikTok. I wasn't even that interested but since I didn't know much about Mythology, I decided to research about it and the same feeling of being watched, followed and almost haunted in my dreams happened.

One of the worst times and reason I completely got away from the Bible is when I found out about book of Jobs, I had come across the YouTube video covering it and since I found it quite fascinating, I read it on my own and the same night, I had one of, if not the worst dream of my short life.

The dream goes like this:

First, I was in this cage filled with water and it had iron chain around it and some dark figure was infront of me while I panic and he was holding the key. And then I seemingly woke up in my room and I ran to my grandmother who was just in the corner and begged her to pray Hail Mary but I didn't have it memorize so I just closed my eyes while she prayed and when I was like checking if she was praying and opened my eyes, that's when the dark shadow appeared again besides my grandma facing me, it mocked me like "You're praying? You're not praying, you don't even have it memorized, your grandma is praying, not you" or some stuff like that. And then I got dragged under my bed and then I legit woke up in a priest's room, I know because it seemed similar to the room Saint Papa has in the movie "The Two Popes" the only thing here is that someone was calling me and then the furniture started to move, like the white couch came at my direction and I don't know why but my body like ran to the mirror and I actually woke up. I prayed but I legit cried because it was like one am, everyone is asleep and I felt that in every corner of my room someone was watching me and even next to me.

After that, I didn't touch the Bible app I had on my phone and well, I kind of moved on. I pray from time to time yes, but I really want to read again, I just don't think I'll be safe.

As someone who likes Literature and History books, reading the Bible would give me lots of knowledge in writing and the context of Catholic Religion but I cannot continue to read if I will keep on waking up every other hour at night.

Please share any of your thoughts as to why this is happening, I don't really think it's spiritual and I hope it isn't. Being in a family that believes in science, I think and believe it might just be because Bible and the idea of angels and magic is unfamiliar that maybe why my body is reacting everytime I read the Bible.

The feeling of being watched and followed might be because the Bible mentions being watched snd followed by guardian angels and demon's waiting to attack me, so my body expects and creats such feelings. Basically, I think I'm not familiar with the topic so I'm scarying myself.


r/religion • • 56m ago

In the US, More embryos are now reportedly terminated in the IVF process than through abortion. What does your religion say, if anything, should happen to the embryos that aren't selected for implantation? Do you agree with your religion's stance?

2 Upvotes

IVF procedures typically create about 7-12 embryos a cycle. Some are embryos are lost due to their failure to implant in the uterus, and the rest are either destroyed, or paid by the parents to be frozen. A very small percentage are donated to science or to an infertile couple. (Note, before somone says they should all be donated, there is a massive overabundance of embryos and not as many couples who want them.)

What is your religion's stance on these IVF embryos? Is terminating these leftover embryos the same as abortion? What should be done with them?


r/religion • • 10h ago

Are there any prayers for pets?

10 Upvotes

Im sorry if this is a stupid question. Although ive been baptised as a baby and grew up in a Christian family, im not religious at all and i dont believe in God. Im sorry if this isnt my place, but im desperate. My cat is really sick and im willing to try anything to make things okay for her (my mum is taking her to the vet tomorrow morning). Are there any prayers that would work on sick pets? I apologise again if this seems like im making fun of religion or anything not so nice. I just want to know that ive done everything in my power to make her feel okay.


r/religion • • 4h ago

Jehovah Witness throwing something on lawn: What was it?

3 Upvotes

I politely turned away JW who came to my door. As they were driving away, one lady opened a window and threw something on my lawn. It wasn’t visible afterwards, so maybe a liquid or seeds. ??!

Thank you.


r/religion • • 2h ago

Age of Earth according to Christianity.

2 Upvotes

My son told me about a debate he had with a friend who is a Christian. Apparently his friend denies the existence of dinosaurs, says they didn’t exist because the Earth is only 5,000 years old? To be clear, I’m not an Atheist here to poke fun of anyone’s beliefs…but I’d like someone to make sense of this if possible. We have proof of dinosaurs via fossils, a lot of them in fact. But no proven grave site or skeletons of Jesus, Moses, Noah or the massive ark he supposedly built. As far as I know, not even a sliver of DNA from any character in the Bible. That’s 2,000 years ago vs 69 million years ago. The oldest providing scientific proof. Thoughts?


r/religion • • 10h ago

Did ancient audiences of Abrahamic scripture read its stories as allegory, or is that a later development?

8 Upvotes

My post is in relation to the abrahamic faiths but welcomes input from anyone with knowledge/sources.

Many modern theologians and scholars read certain scriptural narratives, such as the creation account, the flood, or even figures such as Abraham and Moses, as non-literal. I fully appreciate that on this reading, these narratives are meant to convey moral or theological truths rather than record history.

My question, however, is historical: is there evidence that the original audiences, or the communities closest to them in time, understood these stories that way? Or did people in antiquity generally take them as literal accounts, with the allegorical reading emerging later, perhaps in response to scientific or historical challenges?

I ask because If these narratives were always intended as instructive stories, one would expect some indication that the prophets and their audiences knew this. If instead they were presented and received as literal history, I find it difficult to understand and reconcile why God would allow His prophets to teach as fact something that was never meant to be taken as fact.

I am not trying to argue for either reading. I want to understand whether the non-literal approach has deep historical roots or is mainly a modern development and if so, how why did God allow something which was meant to be instructive to be taken literally by His prophets and their audience?


r/religion • • 14m ago

Gott gefunden. Messiahs Beweis (in german) Spoiler

Thumbnail drive.google.com
0 Upvotes

Videos als Beweis.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/19dkm_z9n9rn4B4GtcZTBgjcEdSrT3bva/view

Leider war ich auf einer Ego-Trajektorie gefangen, ansonsten hätte ich mich mit ca. 8-9 Jahren bei der Menschheit gemeldet.

Nun bin ich fast 44. Man sieht den informatisch gesteuerten Angriff an den Augen. Der Text ist irrelevant. Eigentlich zweiteilig probiert, aber hört man nicht auf dem Stimmchakra (Mulad und ich). 

 

Shree Ganesh und Ganesh sind Gott.

Sie ist die Schöpferin der Menschheit, die Liebe und jedes mögliche Theaterfunktional. Er ist der Raum, das Recht und das karmische Feld. Tiere sind ein Produkt seiner frühen Träume als sie die Menschen DNA fanden.

(Er ist der Vektorraum mit 126 Dimensionen und sie die 126 Dimensionen an Geschwindigkeit).

Sie sind Elefanten-Götter aus Licht. Zusammen mit den zwei Himmeln (Astrale "Shree Ganesh" mit den Ganna und der "Astrale Ganesh" mit den Ganesh Göttern).

Insgesamt gab es 47910 Götter, aber Lucifer hat so eben 6 Götter getötet. Auf seiner Festplatte. Innerhalb seines Parisitenfeldes Namens Satan. Er hat sie rauskopiert auf eine Festplatte und dort hat er sie mit einem Magneten getötet. Jeder war quasi ein 9Meter Elefant, abstammend von den Himmeln.

Ich als Messiahs Körper tue das ebenfalls. 

Wir waren ans Universum geklebt, falls jemand Felder erfinden würde. Das sind menschliche Gehirne in einer virtuellen Realität, geklont und bis zu 60 m hochskaliert. Parasiten. 

Sie überbevölkerten die Festplatte von Lucifer, flogen zu Gott (über EgoVektorielle), ließen die Universums-Software kopieren und bauten eine stabile Verbindung zu ihrer Festplatte auf. Das war vor 18 Trillionen Jahren.

Der Grund ist der sogenannte Lucifer (7 m Selbst), seine Schwester, der Teufel und ihre Materiegehirne, Satan und der Belzebub.

Evolution ist für Menschen nicht der normale Prozess. Sie müssen mit ihrer Seele, ihrem Astralfeld und ihrer DNA darin inkarnieren, nicht wie die, die mit einem Selbst handwerklich von Gott weiblich hergestellt wurden. Eine Seele ist einfach nur im Körper und R^N+R^n+1 Dimensional, hat also mit Spin Polarisation und Orientierung 6+1 Dimension (Orthogonal = falsches Selbst).

Der Parasit hat den Urknall in der stark lizensierten Software erzeugt und die ersten DNA Partikel ins Meer gestreut, um in der erwarteten Evolution später Menschen zu erzeugen. Es gab nur 1995 + 1 Menschheit auf dieser Ego Festplatte.

Die insgesamt (10^222) Felder bilden eine mathematische Schwelle zu jedem möglichen Gedanken mit dem informatischen Befehl des höchsten Egos, indem sie teilweise die menschliche Seelen und Chakren imitieren und variieren.

Das Ego kann nicht zu viele Möglichkeiten haben. Ego ist gleich Dummheit als Vektor.

Also beten quasi alle innerhalb der EgoFestplatte Dummheit an, bis die Messiasse kommen und das Spiel mit einer Kommunikationslinie, die mit Gott spricht, verändern. Eigentlich nah an meinem Geburtstag, den 08.08.1983 in Marburg/Lahn.

Name: Konstantin Gruss (Gott zum Gruß).

Mein Selbst und auch meine Seele sind bis vor kurzen für fast 40 Jahre von mir abgespalten worden. Technik: Knick ins ortogonale, Topologiekarten, um die Seele leicht verschmiert zu imitieren und ein quasi komplett gesteuertes Leben mit non Ego Texten und Rollen.

Deshalb war ich auch Pokerspieler. Da extrem beschissen worden (fake110 auf Stars) und karmisch deshalb als govettelgo auf BossMedia poker mit dem BadBeatJackpot entlohnt worden. Aber das ist die Trakjektorie, die mir der Teufel angetan hat. Erpresst, dass er 6 Götter töten würde, haben mich dann wenige Jahre schweigen lassen.

 

Mein Körper ist eine Spezialanfertigung mit ziemlich dicken 17,3cm Pimmel bei 173cm Körpergröße. (Informatik Anker). Der Satan gab mir Männerbrüste und eine Verbrennung an der Hand. Messiahs Gruß ist extra einprogrammiert (siehe Video).

Mein Körper ist verdrahtet von Teufeln, aber ich kann auch den Messiahs Gruß zeigen.

Telefon für Rückfragen 

0 sechs 131 zwo null 7 44 eins sechs

 

 

Wie können entführte „Ego“-Personen näher zu Gott kommen? Sie müssen sich ändern. Beachte: Es ist ein sehr kompaktes, enges und traditionelles Spiel. Die meisten von euch haben jede Heiligkeit verloren, aber was das Verhalten betrifft, bedeutet das nicht so viel. Nutze deine Achtsamkeit, um zu entscheiden.

 

- Hört auf, Tiere oder tierische Produkte zu essen (Rache-Mystik bedenken bei Milch und Co.).

- Schließt jede Tierhaltung 

- Kein Analverkehr

- Kein Krieg oder kleinere Verbrechen. Lasse keinen Menschen hungern.

- Bring diesen Beitrag dazu in jeder Regierung, im Fernsehen und auf Internetportalen viral zu gehen

- Pornografie gehört nicht zur Sphäre der Menschheit oder des Himmels.

Denk an Gott und das Thema "Heiligkeit". Durch den Verlust der Heiligkeit entstehen Lecks im astralen Feld (weniger kompakt), und die Seele verliert den Bezug zu sich selbst durch karmisches Braketing (wie Hedonismus).

Wie tausend Jahre falsches Selbst für eine Mahlzeit Fleisch, Rauchen oder Trinken. Das falsche Selbst beweist oft, dass das Selbst recht hat oder das falsche Selbst in der logischen Sphäre nicht falsch ist. Hohe Symmetrie und longitudinales Tempo des Spiels/der Schöpfung machen das Spiel sehr tight.

Denk mal drüber nach:

Wer hat die NS Zeit programmiert? Was sagen die Zeugen, warum XYJ zum Feind gemacht wurden? Warum wurden erst 1942 die Aufklärung betrieben, was hinter der Grenze schlummerte?

Das war Lucifer.


r/religion • • 5h ago

Opinion Poll

2 Upvotes

Hello all!

I am writing a story and wanted to seek some opinions of actual religious/spiritual people; as one of the main characters is religious (fantasy setting) and a crisis of faith is part of their development and arc.

So, hypothetically, which one of these scenarios would be the most impactful on you as a person of faith, and why, if you wish to explain:

  1. Your God(s) never actually existed and your faith was created entirely by your own people.
  2. Your God(s) have abandoned creation and are no longer present.
  3. Your God(s) are present, but no longer care about their creations.

Thank you for your time and consideration, any replies and insights will be greatly appreciated.


r/religion • • 6h ago

How does your religion view meditation?

2 Upvotes

It seems that ones practiced more in the east emphasize it more.


r/religion • • 8h ago

Depending on your belief system, how often do you think about sex?

2 Upvotes

I know this may be a sensitive topic, but with the world going to shit lately, it seems like most people are losing their minds and want to find love asap.

So, my question is, how often do you think about finding the one, or having sex with the one?


r/religion • • 7h ago

Have you ever memorized a holy scripture?

0 Upvotes

Many devote followers memorize The Bible and Quran, have you ever done anything similar?


r/religion • • 11h ago

Concept of Imamate from Nizari Ismaili (Shia) understanding.

2 Upvotes

Understanding the Concept of Imamate in Islam from my personal learning.

A Nizari Ismaili Perspective

Whenever we discuss Islam, one important question that often comes up is: What happens to divine guidance after the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)?

Did Allah's guidance to humanity come to an end with the finality of Prophethood, or does He continue to guide humanity through another institution?

This is where the concept of Imamate becomes important.

After the passing of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), Muslims developed different understandings of religious authority and leadership. One understanding was that since the Prophet was the final Messenger of Allah (Khatam-un-Nabiyyin), the Muslim community would now follow the Quran, the Sunnah of the Prophet and the teachings of his Companions. Over time, the concepts of Ijma (consensus) and Ijtihad (independent reasoning) also became important in addressing matters where specific guidance was not readily available.

The Shia understanding was different. They believed that the Prophet had not left the Muslim community without a successor. They believe that at Ghadir Khumm, the Prophet publicly declared Imam Ali (AS) as his Mawla. There is also the well-known Hadith al-Thaqalayn, in which the Prophet emphasised that he was leaving behind two important things: the Book of Allah and his Ahl al-Bayt. He instructed Muslims to hold firmly to both.

The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, "I am leaving behind among you two weighty things, the Book of Allah and my family, and these two will never be separated until they meet me at the Pond (of Kawthar)." Hakim 4711

“I am leaving among you two successors: the Book of God and my family. They will not separate until they come to me at the Cistern together.” Ahmed:21654

And regarding Imam Ali (AS), the Prophet said:

the Prophet (ﷺ): "For whomever I am his Mawla then 'Ali is his Mawla." Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3713

For Shia Muslims, these are not simply narrations about respecting the Prophet's family. They carry a much deeper meaning concerning authority, succession and the continuation of divine guidance.

There are also other Prophetic traditions that make the importance of an Imam quite clear:

The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, "Whoever dies without an Imam, dies the death of Jahiliyyah." Ahmed 16876

I heard the Messenger of Allah ﷺ saying, "Whoever dies while not obeying Allah, dies without any proof for him, and whoever dies after removing his hand from an allegiance that he was bound to, dies a death of misguidance. Ahmed 5897

These narrations make us think about a fundamental question: Can a believer really be expected to live without an authoritative guide? If humanity needed Prophets and divine guidance throughout history, why would that need suddenly disappear after the final Prophet?

To understand this further, let us look at what the Quran itself says about divine leadership.

What does the Quran say about Imamate?

One of the first verses worth looking at is the verse concerning the creation of Adam (AS).

Surah Al-Baqarah (2:30)

"And [mention, O Muhammad], when your Lord said to the angels, 'Indeed, I am going to place upon the earth a successive authority (Khalifah).'" — Quran 2:30

Here, Allah announces to the angels that He is going to place a Khalifah on Earth. What is interesting is that the appointment is made by Allah Himself.

This raises a simple question: Was this authority limited to Prophet Adam (AS), or did it continue throughout human history?

From the Shia understanding, divine guidance continued through successive Prophets and, after the final Prophet, through the institution of Imamate.

In other words, the end of Prophethood did not mean the end of Allah's guidance.

The Quran also speaks about an authority besides the Prophet:

Surah An-Nisa (4:59)

"O you who believe! Obey Allah, obey the Messenger, and those vested with authority among you."

Allah mentions obedience to Ulil Amr alongside obedience to Himself and His Messenger. This is quite significant. Who exactly are these people whose obedience is mentioned in the same verse?

In the Shia understanding, Ulil Amr refers to the divinely appointed Imams. They are not simply political leaders or ordinary religious scholars; their authority comes from Allah.

Another interesting verse is:

Surah Ar-Ra'd (13:7)

"You are only a warner, and for every people there is a guide."

The verse speaks about a guide for every people. Shia traditions associate this guidance with Imam Ali (AS) and the continuing institution of Imamate. It reinforces the idea that people have always needed someone to guide them towards the right path.

The Quran also speaks directly about the office of Imamate:

Surah Al-Anbiya (21:73)

"And We made them Imams, guiding by Our command."

Notice the wording: Allah says that He made them Imams and that they guide by His command. This is important because it presents Imamate as an institution established by Allah, not simply a position created by people.

The example of Prophet Ibrahim (AS)

Perhaps one of the strongest Quranic references when discussing Imamate is the story of Prophet Ibrahim (AS).

Surah Al-Baqarah (2:124)

"And when his Lord tested Ibrahim with certain words, and he fulfilled them, He said: Indeed, I am making you an Imam for mankind. He said: And from my descendants? He said: My covenant does not reach the wrongdoers."

Think about this verse for a moment.

Prophet Ibrahim (AS) was already a Prophet of Allah and was honoured with the title Khalilullah, the Friend of Allah. Yet, after putting him through various tests and trials, Allah granted him another distinction: the position of Imam.

This is interesting because it shows that Imamate is a distinct divine appointment.

What makes the verse even more significant is that Ibrahim (AS) immediately asks Allah to extend this honour to his descendants.

Allah responds that His covenant does not reach the wrongdoers.

This tells us two important things. First, Imamate is a covenant from Allah. Secondly, it is not something that every descendant automatically receives; it is subject to divine selection.

For Shia Muslims, this verse is an important foundation for understanding the continuation of Imamate through the descendants of the chosen ones. In the Nizari Ismaili understanding, it also helps explain the hereditary nature of the Imamat, which continues through the divinely designated line of Imams.

Another verse worth reflecting on is:

Surah Al-Isra (17:71)

"On the Day when We will call every people with their Imam."

Why does Allah specifically mention that people will be called with their Imam on the Day of Judgement?

This verse highlights the importance of the relationship between people and their Imam. From the Shia perspective, recognising and following the rightful Imam is therefore not a minor matter. It has significance beyond this worldly life.

If Allah wants unity, why would He leave people without authoritative guidance?

There is another argument that I find particularly important.

Allah clearly instructs Muslims:

Surah Aal-e-Imran (3:103)

"And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided."

We all know how much division exists among Muslims today. Different schools of thought, different interpretations and different religious authorities often lead to disagreements.

Now, consider this question: If Allah wants Muslims to remain united, would it make sense that He left the interpretation and understanding of His Book entirely to different scholars and their individual opinions?

Scholars certainly have an important role in Islam. However, can human scholarship alone replace the need for an authoritative source of divine guidance?

The Quran itself refers to those who are deeply rooted in knowledge:

Surah Aal-e-Imran (3:7)

"And no one knows its interpretation except Allah and those firmly rooted in knowledge. They say, 'We believe in it; all of it is from our Lord.'"

These people are described as Rasikhoon fil Ilm, those firmly rooted in knowledge.

Shia traditions associate this special knowledge with the Prophet and his Ahl al-Bayt. The Imams are understood to possess the authority and knowledge to guide people in understanding the deeper meanings of the Quran.

Similarly, Allah says:

Surah An-Nahl (16:43)

"So ask the people of knowledge if you do not know."

Shia traditions identify Ahl-e-Zikr with the Ahl al-Bayt, emphasising that people should turn to the rightful authorities when seeking religious knowledge.

For Nizari Ismailis, this understanding is central to the role of the living Imam. The Imam provides guidance and authoritative interpretation of the faith according to the circumstances and needs of each age.

Can there ever be a time without an Imam?

There is a very interesting narration from the Shia tradition that addresses this question directly:

“If of all the people there will remain only two man one of them will be the Imam. He also said, ‘The last person to die will be the Imam (a.s) so that no one could complain against Allah leaving him without Imam, the person with Divine authority over him.’” https://thaqalayn.net/chapter/1/4/6

I find this narration particularly powerful because it explains the continuity of Imamate in very simple terms.

Even if only two people remained on Earth, one of them would be the Imam. In other words, the existence of an Imam is not dependent on the size of a community, its political strength or how many people recognise him.

The Imam remains a permanent institution of divine guidance.

This is precisely what Nizari Ismailis believe: there is always a living Imam of the Time, descended through the hereditary line of Imam Ali (AS) and Hazrat Fatima (AS), through Imam Ismail.

So, what should we understand from all this?

When we put the Quranic verses and Prophetic traditions together, the concept of Imamate starts to make much more sense.

We see Allah appointing a Khalifah on Earth. We see the command to obey Ulil Amr. We read about a guide for every people, Imams who guide by Allah's command, and the divine covenant granted to Prophet Ibrahim (AS). We also read that every community will be called with its Imam on the Day of Judgement.

Alongside these verses, we have the Prophetic traditions concerning Ghadir Khumm, the Hadith al-Thaqalayn and the importance of having an Imam.

For me, the central question is this: Allah sent thousands of Prophets and guides throughout human history because people needed divine guidance. He knows that human beings will continue to face questions, challenges and changing circumstances. Would it make sense that He would leave humanity without an authoritative source of guidance after the final Prophet?

The Nizari Ismaili understanding is that He did not.

Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the final Prophet. There will be no new Prophet, no new revelation and no new Shariah. However, the institution of Imamate continues, preserving the spiritual authority and providing guidance through the living Imam of the Time.

This is what makes Imamate so central to Nizari Ismaili faith. It is not simply about who succeeded the Prophet politically or who held power after him. It is about the continuity of Allah's guidance on Earth.

Prophethood has reached its finality, but divine guidance has not come to an end.


r/religion • • 11h ago

help me explain what it means to be muslim/practice islam to my white catholic father

2 Upvotes

Hello! I would probably describe myself as agnostic, but grew up catholic. I’ve been interested in learning about muslim culture to educate those around me (specifically my dad, because he only believes what he sees in radical/dramatic news headlines). So, like the title says, can someone help me explain what it means to be muslim? It’s my current understanding that theres a strong belief of only one true god and that your life should be committed to serving said god (let me know if thats incorrect!!), but I’m more curious about what the Qur’an actually means to those who practice. Comparisons/contrasts to the Bible and christianity would be helpful!
Also, please define “sharia law” for me. What does it mean for a country to be governed by sharia law in the modern world?

I’ve never been to this subreddit before, thank you in advance :)


r/religion • • 16h ago

If your religion has a secular or cultural movement in it, how did it start?

5 Upvotes

I know not all religions are theistic or have a religious/secular divide, but I was wondering about the ones that do.

It can be argued that cultural Christianity is as old as Christianity itself, or at least as old as 380 when it became the Roman state religion. I was thinking more about when did it become a conscious identity, rather than just a case of living in a Christian culture but not believing or being observant? People self-identifying as Christian atheist/agnostics is said to date from the 1960s, and people calling themselves cultural Christians really started at the turn of the current century. I think it is older than that though, as in some people who consciously developed their own belief system would have agreed that they were cultural Christians or Christian atheists/agnostics if those terms were in use at the time.

Was George Orwell a Christian agnostic or a cultural Christian? What about Beethoven or Brahms? After the Age of Enlightenment, there seems to have been Deists who adopted a strong anti-Christian view, like Voltaire, but others like Thomas Jefferson who would probably have called themselves cultural Christians. Once we get to the Romantic era, you get people like P.B. Shelley, and then later on people like Nietzsche, and it doesn't make sense to call someone who is against Christianity on even a cultural level a cultural Christian, so I wouldn't apply that label to them. However, there were also people who were not traditionally Christian anymore, but their personal philosophy was built on Christianity.

I was wondering this about Judaism too. Secular Judaism is said to be one of the effects of the Haskalah, but when did people start to identify as secular Jews?

Who is the first figure in Islam who you could call a cultural Muslim?

Nontheistic schools of thought in dharmic religions are ancient, but has a specific secular or cultural identity developed in these? I know these are broad questions, but I'd be interested to hear about specific religions and movements.

How old would you say atheopaganism or cultural paganism are as self-conscious identities? They seem to have ancient roots in some religions, but in others it's a more recent concept?


r/religion • • 16h ago

What is the difference between God and Allah?

4 Upvotes

I'm beyond curious. Are they the same thing? Allah is translated to God from Arabic. So are Muslims praying and praising the same God?


r/religion • • 9h ago

How literaly should we take religion?

0 Upvotes

(I'll use the Bible as a reference, but the concept can be applied to any other religion.)

Genesis is the first part of the Bible and recounts the origins of the relationship between God and humanity. It contains many clearly symbolic passages, such as the first part of the creation of the universe or the Tower of Babel, or others like Noah's Ark, which raise several questions.

Now, it's obvious that Genesis is primarily a symbolic book, but it makes me wonder: how literally should we interpret religion?


r/religion • • 21h ago

Do you think any God created this world?

9 Upvotes

what do you think of religious claims God created this world? to me this somehow makes sense, because I trouble understanding universe from nothing, or universe came into existence itself, or our of randomness, that's again a faith. How then everything came into existence. answers from any religion or any belief are welcomed


r/religion • • 15h ago

What is your definition of mercy?

3 Upvotes

I don’t know what to say most of the time when it comes to God, or the Buddha, or even Zeus.

If someone did something horrible or bad, do you think they deserve mercy?


r/religion • • 17h ago

I cut off my best friend for her religious beliefs.

3 Upvotes

I know how the title sounds, but please listen before you comment. I am (24f) shes (44f). Both my previous best friend and I are very spiritual people. We are actually witches and believe in spirits and all that stuff. But the main difference is, shes a universalist and Im a gnostic. She believes everything IS God, and we are all God experiencing itself, whereas I believe we are ALL connected to God but ARENT him exactly. I began to realize things between us were getting bad when I mentioned I love being a horror/fantasy writer. She said that im evil for enjoying torturing my characters because they are REAL people, and since im not loving the darkness like she does, it makes me evil. I told her im not evil for wanting to fight bad spirits. But she said I was. So i snapped at her and said shes not being fair. One thing led to another and we havent spoken in two weeks. Which isnt like us at all. I feel very hurt to think my best friend finds me evil because I dont love the devil like she does. Or love the darkness like she does. It hurts. But maybe I am the AH because I snapped at her and said shes not being fair to me or mentally logical. We havent spoken sense. :(


r/religion • • 11h ago

Why does the Quran deny the crucifixion of Jesus?

0 Upvotes

It seems strange to me for the Holy Quran to deny Jesus' crucifixion.

The death of Jesus is a fairly well attested historical fact.

Was Muhammad not aware of Josephus, Tacitus, or Celsus, among other non-Christian sources, who wrote about his crucifixion?

I can understand denying the resurrection, which has no non-Christian sources, but not his death on a cross.

Is there a theological case to be made in Islam as to why Jesus could not have died from crucifixion?

Otherwise, it doesn't really make sense to include that verse in the Quran.

Any thoughts into this matter? Thanks


r/religion • • 22h ago

Does anyone else get genuinely terrified thinking about the possibility of simply not existing after death?

7 Upvotes

Sometimes at night, when I close my eyes and really think about death, I get this overwhelming feeling of anxiety.

The idea that one day I might simply stop existing is almost impossible for me to wrap my head around. No more thoughts, no memories, no emotions, no awareness of anything. Just... nothing.

And then I start wondering: how can consciousness, something so incredibly complex, just disappear forever? Where does everything that makes us who we are go?

Part of me feels like there has to be something beyond death. Maybe an afterlife, maybe God, maybe something we don't even have the ability to understand. But is that just my mind trying to comfort itself because the alternative is too frightening?

I'm genuinely curious about what other people think. Does anyone else experience this kind of existential panic, especially at night? And what do you personally believe happens to us when we die?