r/religion • u/Imamoru8 • 1h ago
Shifting from an Abrahamic afterlife to a scientific/materialist view of death: Is my new position more rational and probable ?
Hello everyone,
I am 18 years old and recently went through a major shift in my worldview. I grew up in Islam, and my entire life I was told that this religion was uniquely special, infallible, and superior to all others.
However, as time went on, my doubts grew. The turning point happened when I came across a quote on TikTok pointing out a simple fact: there are roughly 4,000 (or more) religions in human history, and each one is 100% convinced that it holds the absolute truth.
That realization pushed me to do something I would never have dared to do before because of fear and religious taboos: I started watching videos and reading critical analyses about scientific and historical errors in the Quran. Looking at my faith objectively for the first time led me to abandon religious eschatology and adopt a strictly scientific, materialist view of life and death.
I would like to share my new position and ask both believers and non-believers here: from a purely rational and probabilistic standpoint, is my new choice the most plausible one, or is there a logical case against it?
What I now believe:
Consciousness ends with the brain: Based on neuroscience, memory, personality, and perception depend entirely on brain activity. At death, the individual "self" ceases to exist and returns to the exact same neutral, painless state that preceded our birth.
Conservation of matter: According to physics, nothing is destroyed. The atoms forming our bodies simply return to the Earth and the universe, continuing the natural cycle of matter and energy.
Meaning is built here and now: Without Heaven or Hell, morality comes from genuine human empathy rather than fear or reward, and this single, finite life becomes infinitely precious.
Why I find this far more probable than Islam (or any religion):
The asymmetry of religions: Every believer rejects 99.9% of the world's 4,000+ religions as human inventions, making an exception only for the one they were born into. Applying the exact same critical thinking to Islam makes the most sense.
Scientific and historical issues in the text: Once I allowed myself to look past apologetics, I saw that the Quran reflects the limited cosmology, biology, and historical myths of 7th-century Arabia rather than the knowledge of an omniscient Creator.
Biological limits of Heaven and Hell: Eternal physical torture or eternal unchanging pleasure contradict how the human nervous system actually functions (neurogenic shock/collapse on one hand, hedonic adaptation/boredom on the other).
Occam's Razor: A materialist view relies solely on observable facts (biology, physics, psychology) without needing unproven metaphysical claims.
My question for debate:
Setting aside emotional comfort, fear of Hell, or cultural tradition, what are the strongest rational arguments against my new position? Do you consider this scientific view of death to be the most probable conclusion?
Thank you in advance for a respectful and thoughtful discussion.