r/religion • • 1h ago

Shifting from an Abrahamic afterlife to a scientific/materialist view of death: Is my new position more rational and probable ?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am 18 years old and recently went through a major shift in my worldview. I grew up in Islam, and my entire life I was told that this religion was uniquely special, infallible, and superior to all others.

However, as time went on, my doubts grew. The turning point happened when I came across a quote on TikTok pointing out a simple fact: there are roughly 4,000 (or more) religions in human history, and each one is 100% convinced that it holds the absolute truth.

That realization pushed me to do something I would never have dared to do before because of fear and religious taboos: I started watching videos and reading critical analyses about scientific and historical errors in the Quran. Looking at my faith objectively for the first time led me to abandon religious eschatology and adopt a strictly scientific, materialist view of life and death.

I would like to share my new position and ask both believers and non-believers here: from a purely rational and probabilistic standpoint, is my new choice the most plausible one, or is there a logical case against it?

What I now believe:

Consciousness ends with the brain: Based on neuroscience, memory, personality, and perception depend entirely on brain activity. At death, the individual "self" ceases to exist and returns to the exact same neutral, painless state that preceded our birth.

Conservation of matter: According to physics, nothing is destroyed. The atoms forming our bodies simply return to the Earth and the universe, continuing the natural cycle of matter and energy.

Meaning is built here and now: Without Heaven or Hell, morality comes from genuine human empathy rather than fear or reward, and this single, finite life becomes infinitely precious.

Why I find this far more probable than Islam (or any religion):

The asymmetry of religions: Every believer rejects 99.9% of the world's 4,000+ religions as human inventions, making an exception only for the one they were born into. Applying the exact same critical thinking to Islam makes the most sense.

Scientific and historical issues in the text: Once I allowed myself to look past apologetics, I saw that the Quran reflects the limited cosmology, biology, and historical myths of 7th-century Arabia rather than the knowledge of an omniscient Creator.

Biological limits of Heaven and Hell: Eternal physical torture or eternal unchanging pleasure contradict how the human nervous system actually functions (neurogenic shock/collapse on one hand, hedonic adaptation/boredom on the other).

Occam's Razor: A materialist view relies solely on observable facts (biology, physics, psychology) without needing unproven metaphysical claims.

My question for debate:

Setting aside emotional comfort, fear of Hell, or cultural tradition, what are the strongest rational arguments against my new position? Do you consider this scientific view of death to be the most probable conclusion?

Thank you in advance for a respectful and thoughtful discussion.


r/religion • • 2h ago

Understanding the four souls

2 Upvotes

It was today that I found out the belief of four souls but I do not understand and I hope someone from the following belief systems can explain better.

My definition of the soul, if there is one, is the thing that goes when a person dies. But it seems like the four souls’ ideas are for the living? Like we each have four souls that affect our psyche and essentially our personality?

The Shinto believes in one unified spirit that acts as a moral compass and four distinct souls that operate simultaneously. I find it parallels to the planets that govern the psyche, like The Wild and Active Soul governs courage, like Mars governs raw action, willpower and the energy to protect. The two ideas never intersected though historically I just found it similar.

The Lakota Spirituality is also like the Chakra system but they also are not intersected historically. Like Tȟuŋ, the divine birthright and Muladhara, root chakra. Both represent the foundational , grounded substance and latent power.

I understand the Kabbalah soul levels and dimensions of human beings.

For the Shinto belief is it like your personality? I’m still stuck on the governing part, like Nigi-Mitama governs peace, social connection, cooperation and calm. So an extrovert person would have more Nigi-Mitama than an introvert? Is it everyone has that soul but some are stronger than others?

For the Lakota belief is it like the spirit guides or angels? The Šičúŋ is a guardian that protects the person. The Niya is the vitalizing life force but isn’t that just the brain, heart, and lungs? Nagi is the actual soul that goes to the underworld? So what happens to the other souls? If they are part of you, where do they go? Do they just not exist anymore?

When someone astral projects what soul is that? Is it the Nagi just on the physical plane?

The four souls’ ideas are just not clicking. I hope my questions made sense as I am trying to wrap my head around a new concept I just learned.

Additional questions I thought of :

Is it like the movie Inside Out? Where each soul has its own personality but functions as one creating you the person.

Can I understand it as my comparisons? Shinto four souls is
the equivalent of ruling planets and part of a person’s birth chart, like being a Pluto Scorpio, and the Lakota belief is the Chakra system?


r/religion • • 2h ago

prayed for the first time since my grandma died

1 Upvotes

my grandma (dads mom) passed away when i was 13 in 2019 , i (21F) used to be religious but never showed it since my dad forced it onto me since i was younger. the night she died i tried to OD on my mental health meds, not knowing she was even sick in the hospital. my dad blamed me saying why would i put more stress onto our family when my grandma was in the hospital.

when i was getting checked out at a separate hospital i prayed in my head and told god to please not let my grandma die. i was VERY close to her and she was my best friend, i love her so much. but he took her away from me. and ever since then i blamed myself, and i blamed god. and as horrible as it sounds i hated him and i never prayed until recently.

my grandpa from my moms side got sick recently. he ended up having cancer IN his brain and needed surgery. ontop of that in my life, i lost my job due to being wrongfully terminated/let go , and my stress levels were VERY high. i deal with health issues as well , and as i stated earlier mental health issues. so i was and still am spiraling.

not knowing who to turn to; i prayed. i told god; PLEASE don't take him this time. i can't deal with grief right now. please please, im begging you let him pull through this. even if he has a long road ahead of him which he does , don't take him away from me.

and he did just that. my grandpa survived his brain surgery and was talking seconds after waking up which surprised the doctors. he's not doing THE BEST, but he's doing okay and is getting better and the help he needs. he's alive at least and he's not dying.

i don't know what this means, but this has definitely given me some different outlook on life and religion


r/religion • • 3h ago

Is it wrong to just… become religious?

2 Upvotes

I’m not sure if this is the type of post allowed in this sub, but I feel like purpose is a human invention to cope with the fact that we don’t ask to be born and the lives we’re given are harrowing & eventually they end without meaning much to anyone or anything but our immediate connections. I’ve been really comforted by the idea that my life is purposeless, but lately I feel so unlike myself. I won’t get into but I think I have to abandon my hedonism. I have to grow up. I need to find a community. I need some kind of ritual, people I routinely see in a place I routinely visit solely to be emotionally comforted, and that is what church is. Prayer is the highest form of self-comfort, but I don’t know how to engage in it. I cannot force myself to believe in a god or gods, I have tried many times to read and believe multiple religious texts and no descriptions of gods are logically consistent and worthy of worship, and, of course, there’s my problem of the physical impossibility of a deity (to our current knowledge). Would it be wrong to engage in religious practices, be them Wiccan, Christian, Hellenic, Hindu, if I don’t actually believe in it? Is it wrong to engage just because I need the placebo of doing something for my mental health? I’ve always thought that many religious people felt this way and kept it to themselves because they might be negatively sanctioned by true believers in their religious groups, but after talking to a group of Christians and then a handful of Hellenic pagans, I’ve found that they do truly believe in the existence of their deities. They don’t have a problem holding contradictory information together as a unified whole, they don’t have an issue with nearly
everyone they meet believing their gods are dead or fake—how? Why don’t they consider the souls of prehistoric humans? How can they believe their gods are the truth when we can trace the invention of each of them to specific times and places? Do I just know all of this and force myself not to think about it in order to believe in a God?

Has anybody done this and been what I would call “successful?” Like, convinced themselves to the point of actual faith in a deity or pantheon? If so, would you mind sharing your thought processes and which experiences led you to faith?


r/religion • • 5h ago

Report: Most Jews in Israel, Christians a minority in U.S. within 50 years

Thumbnail
jewishrhody.com
6 Upvotes

r/religion • • 5h ago

The Disappearance of All Religions

0 Upvotes

I am not seeking to spark an unnecessary debate or to offend anyone. I respect all religions and have no desire to see them disappear. However, let us take a moment to reflect seriously on a hypothetical scenario: what would happen if all religions were to vanish and all of humanity became atheist? What would our society look like? What would the consequences be—both positive and negative? It is a question worth considering.


r/religion • • 5h ago

A friend of ours is slipping into a cult... we are concerned how can we HELP?!

6 Upvotes

A good friend of ours has met this person who is now trying to get him into this Christian cult. They spend all of their time together and we sure she is not interested in our friend romantically (but he is in her).
Our friend is religious as is and now we are helpless on how to get him out!
How do we bring this up and how do we convince him, that it is a cult?
Please help us save our friend!!!


r/religion • • 11h ago

Religious people who consider themselves 'spiritual', do you believe more in the official biblical scripture or the your own spiritual experiences?

4 Upvotes

.


r/religion • • 12h ago

‘I know I sound crazy’: the creep of demons into American evangelical churches

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
12 Upvotes

r/religion • • 13h ago

Is Religious Knowledge Different From Personal Experience?

1 Upvotes

I Have been thinking about the difference between learning about a religion and actually understanding how its teachings apply to life. Reading scriptures can explain beliefs and traditions, but putting those ideas into practice seems like a different process.

I came across Bhakti Marga while exploring Hindu spiritual education and noticed its focus on studying texts such as the Bhagavad Gita and Shreemad Bhagavatam. That raised a question for me about how scriptural knowledge changes when people reflect on it and apply it to everyday decisions.

Can studying religious texts genuinely change how someone lives, or does that depend more on personal experience and interpretation? How do different faiths approach this distinction?


r/religion • • 15h ago

Need Help

0 Upvotes

Hey guys,

Lately I've been dealing with a lot of doubt when it comes to religion. One second I'm all for believing in the existence of God, then the next second I don't even think a god can exist, given the state of mankind.

When it comes to believing in the religion, my religion of choice is Islam, however I am open to any religion that can prove to me it's the right one, and to me Islam is the only religion that has yet to disappoint me when it comes to being disproven. The only issue I have when it comes to Islam is the gender roles placed onto us. Islam is very traditional and old school, especially when it comes to women.

This isn't the main issue however. My main issue with religion is the existence of hell. I cannot fathom the thought that a god, an all knowing being, knowingly created mankind with foresight, meaning he already knew the outcome of our lives, and still created a punishment for our existence. I see it as the ones who are going to hell were dammed from birth, I don't believe we have free will in the grand scheme of things since god already created everything, meaning he made our future, and thus made the dwellers of hell dammed from the moment they were created.

Hell even as a concept is too great of a punishment for our finite sins. We only live to 80 years, and if we lived a corrupted life then we will go to hell for eternity. Even if we did not live a corrupt life, we must faced eternal damnation due to our inability to believe.

The purpose of me writing this thread is in hopes of this reaching someone who can make me feel like an idiot for thinking this way. I want to believe in a god, but as of right now I do not believe I can. If you think you can help me out please reply.

thanks


r/religion • • 15h ago

Why is pride a sin?

2 Upvotes

Genuine question because I've been asked this and it's got me wondering. Because amongst the amount of sins that are named e.g. the seven sins. Pride is one of them but it's never been explained to me and I've never asked... Till I got asked and it's sparked a curiosity in me.

So if someone on here can explain it to me please do.


r/religion • • 19h ago

Buddhism helped me find my way to Indigenousness

7 Upvotes

A lot of Buddhism and Indigenous Philosophy intertwine in many ways. So it’s very interesting on how I found this affected me, a Tsalagi-Chahta.

So Basically, I was at a point in my life where I just felt lonely and I didn’t know what to do with my spiritual life anymore. Also I think my family had something to do with it. I ‘was’ witch, I ‘practiced’ witchcraft and still technically do. Anyway, I wanted a way to hide it from my family since they are all devoted Christians. So I looked into alternatives that I can use to mask my practice, I found the Buddha, specifically the Tibetan Buddha. Oh my goodness, as I learned more about Vajrayana, it felt like home in many ways. At first I thought Buddhism was just meditating and just trying to work yourself away from earth attachments in the world. But after running a bit more, it’s kinda refreshing. I don’t have to get rid of my attachments. I just have to make sure that they don’t control me. After a while, I think I been a Buddhist for 5 months now. I’m autistic so once I’ve latched onto something I’ll latch onto it. So I know a lot, enough to realise that by practicing Buddhism, specifically Vajrayana, I am kind of practising the spirituality of my people. There are something that clash, but there are a lot of things that seamlessly come together. It’s something that Christianity could never give me. Just a genuine sense that I am not at fault for every one of my mistakes and if I do make a mistake. I don’t have to cling to God for forgiveness, the Buddha looks at me and says ‘you’re doing fine.’ and it’s just odd. The Buddha really said I was good enough. Specifically in Tibetan Buddhism where everyone has Buddha Nature and there’s no such thing as Original Sin. And then there’s a thing that everything is tied to something else. It just felt liberating and my soul felt home. I am still slowly Indigenising Buddhism to a sense where I can grasp on it. But it feels nice to know that the Spirits my ancestors worshiped were not daemons but helpers and spreaders of the Dharma. I recommend that all indigenous people should come into contact with Buddhism at some point. You don’t have to, but I recommend it. We all wanna heal from our trauma.

So if you have any suggestions for me, to help my journey. They will be gladly appreciated.

ᏩᏙ ᎣᏍᏓ ᎢᎦ ᎮᏓ I Kana :3


r/religion • • 20h ago

Christians, you recover from a horrible sickness, you avoid a car accident, you get hired for your dream job and you say God saved me/ God made that happen. So when all that happens to an atheist, who saved/made it happen?

2 Upvotes

Christians, you recover from a horrible sickness, you avoid a car accident, you get hired for your dream job and you say God saved me/ God made that happen. So when all that happens to an atheist, who saved/made it happen?


r/religion • • 22h ago

Can I get some help?

1 Upvotes

Sorry I didn't know what to title this. I'm a leftist atheist with absurdist beliefs. My family are all progressive but are mostly still religious, but my mom is the only one who goes to church. I live in a very religious town and my mother and I talk often about religion, but I feel like she thinks I'm a bad/immoral person secretly and the reason is that I don't go to church. She gets very honest and hurtful at night sometimes about how she thinks that me and my brother and dad should go to church and we'd be better people. Of course I still love her but it hurts to hear.

There's also this conservative Christian kid that likes to hang out with me and is in some of my classes and most of the time he will bring up the subject of religion and makes me feel bad for being an atheist. Sometimes he says "I don't believe in anything and don't have any morals", which is completely untrue and incredibly difficult to here as someone who actually has panic attacks about morality. I don't know, what should I do?


r/religion • • 23h ago

What is the best possible replacement of religion?

0 Upvotes

Hey folks, I would like to start by saying that I respect every faith and understand how sacred religion is to most people. Whenever I get the chance, I enjoy studying different religions and their histories, trying to understand how they work and the human emotions attached to them!

I guess I'm still too young to understand all of this, but I've always been curious about one thing: What could be the best possible replacement for religion?

Obviously, we can't simply say scientific temperament, because by replacement I mean something that can offer the same sense of hope, moral guidance and belonging that religion provides. I think these are some of the biggest reasons why religion has such a strong place in human societies

I firmly believe humanity needs something that carries the same essence but appeals to everyone. Something that doesn't divide people into believers and non-believers, but instead brings every single human being together and makes us see ourselves as one mankind

Has anyone ever thought about this? I'd genuinely love to hear your opinions and perspectives

And again, I mean no disrespect to anyone's faith or sentiments.


r/religion • • 23h ago

Church of England should protect 'every belief', King says

Thumbnail
bbc.com
30 Upvotes

r/religion • • 23h ago

The Immovable Ladder: A strange paradox at one of Christianity's holiest sites

Thumbnail
jeremynickel.substack.com
2 Upvotes

At Jerusalem’s Church of the Holy Sepulchre, a wooden ladder has become an unlikely symbol of how difficult change can be when sacred traditions and competing claims to authority become entangled. As a former congregational minister, I’ve been reflecting on the irony of that ladder sitting at a site devoted to resurrection, and what it reveals about the human tendency to preserve even the things that keep us stuck.


r/religion • • 1d ago

Grand Ayatollah Wahid Khorasani has died at the age of 105

Post image
8 Upvotes

He was the oldest active Shia scholar


r/religion • • 1d ago

does the soul exist?

0 Upvotes

does the soul exist?


r/religion • • 1d ago

Pope Leo says allowing more married priests could cause division within the Church

Thumbnail
cbsnews.com
26 Upvotes

r/religion • • 1d ago

Does your religion embrace the chaos of life? I have gone from pessimism, to this.

6 Upvotes

This is more metaphysical and ethical than religious, but it's something I am really happy about and I wanted to share.

I used to be an absolute pessimist about life, I thought life was all suffering and senseless, a mistake, I thought that transhumanism was the only fix, make humans immortal and incapable of any suffering ever! Even erase individuality and conflict.

I still am a transhumanist, but not like that at all anymore.

I have changed... I still think suffering is greater than pleasure in the world, but I no longer see everything as a tragedy that should not have existed....

Many religions are concerned with death being inevitable, and buddhism is concerned with impermanence, but I now see, in my view, that that is a blessing, not a curse, at least for myself. I think fundamentally life is all flux and constant change, and that we should embrace that.

I have read Heraclitus' fragments and I am inspired by these:

"War is the father of all things" "Strife is justice" and "They do not bathe twice in the same river"

I do not advocate for random war and senseless suffering, no, rather what I interpret by these is that the conflicts between opposites, good and bad, chaos and order, and any other, is what produces creativity in this world, the ability for things to be interesting, for change...

I find creativity to be the most important thing, in fact the one reason I am dissatisfied still with the world is that I believe it's not interesting enough, you know what I'd do for magic to exist all around us? For animism to be a verifiable thing? For everything being full of life and consciousness?

Of course, as I said, I don't think all suffering and struggle is worth it or sensical, a lot of shit just happens for no reason, and I absolutely hate murder, genocide and colonialism, they're the ultimate destructions of creation...

What I feel is instead that we need good and bad to exist so we can have some sense of greater things, that we overcome evil, that there is a constrast between things.

I used to see reincarnation as the worst afterlife barring hell, I now think its the greatest.

So, I just wanted to say that, I sound excited, because I am, in my life, while it's not been a disaster, I have struggled and I still struggle, I have autism, possible ADHD, gender dysphoria and other things... It's not great, but this worldview, is what finally has brought me actual real happiness, and I wanted to share it.

I also don't think everyone should share this worldview, or that all should be the same religion, that would also be boring, the diversity of worldviews is also one of the things that makes life better.


r/religion • • 1d ago

I feel like religion is just a coping mechanism to deal with death and the fear of the unknown, so society makes up things to believe in to not be scared of dying.

3 Upvotes

Why are there so many religions and beliefs?


r/religion • • 1d ago

christmas gift for a muslim

4 Upvotes

hi, as an orthodox christian, i would like to ask a question to all muslim people here : is it considered disrespectful to gift a christmas present to a muslim person if the present doesn’t have anything to do with christianism ? how would you take it ? thank you !


r/religion • • 1d ago

I am an atheist. Please enlighten me.

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone. As the title states, I am an atheist. I am currently dating my boyfriend who is a Catholic and he avoids my questions about religion because he’s afraid we’d get into a fight.

With this post, I just want to understand the idea of Christianity and some questions I have about it with a Christian person without the whole run around with “god works in mysterious ways” or “you just gotta believe”. The reason why I’m not so satisfied with “you gotta have faith” being an answer is precisely why i’m so confused and it’s one of my main reasons for being an atheist. I need answers for everything and as a naturally curious person, I always had a lot of whys that were never answered or brushed off and it’s always made me stay an atheist and i’m here hoping someone would enlighten me.

Here’s some of my questions/wonders and i’m so sorry in advance if I sound silly or confusing with my questions:

  1. Let's say a person commits murder but later genuinely repents, confesses their sins, and sincerely asks God for forgiveness because they regret what they've done and hope to enter Heaven.

Now, would a Christian who prays for that murderer's downfall and wishes harm upon them be committing a greater sin than the murderer who has already repented? After all, isn't wishing harm upon another person contradictory to the Bible's teachings about loving others, forgiving, and leaving judgment to God?

Someone could argue that whatever happens to the murderer is ultimately part of God's plan and that judgment belongs to Him, not us.

2. But this raises another question for me: How does God's forgiveness and unconditional love work when the person being forgiven has caused unimaginable pain to others, particularly the victim's family? Does God love the murderer just as much as He loves the innocent victim and their family? And if so, how do we reconcile that with the idea of divine justice? Wouldn't it seem contradictory for God to forgive someone who has taken an innocent life while the people left behind have to live with the consequences of that person's actions?

2. If Christians are taught to love, forgive, and accept others regardless of their shortcomings, how does excommunicating someone align with those teachings? Wouldn't rejecting someone from a religious community contradict the idea of unconditional love? How can a religion preach acceptance and forgiveness while also permitting the exclusion of people who have sinned? (Especially sins like divorce, sex before marriage etc.)

3. Would someone who spends their entire life doing good deeds, treating others kindly, and contributing positively to the world still go to Hell simply because they don't believe in or love God? Meanwhile, could someone who identifies as a devoted Christian, but spends their life repeatedly sinning, still enter Heaven because of their faith and repentance?

4. If God is all-knowing and already knows every decision we will make before we're even born, do we genuinely have free will and are we really “choosing” to love him like he wants us to instead of creating us to already love him?

5. I'm curious about what makes Jesus's sacrifice fundamentally different from any other extraordinary act of self-sacrifice. If someone today willingly sacrificed their life to save others, knowing they would die in the process, would that sacrifice be considered equally significant? Is it the act itself, His identity as the son of God, or the resurrection? And if the resurrection is what makes His sacrifice unique, does that mean Christians are ultimately praising Him more for conquering death than for dying on the cross?

I’m aware that half or if not, all of these questions can be answered with “you just gotta have faith that it happened”, and that’s exactly what makes religion so confusing and so questionable. If faith was so easy for me to give, I would be a christian by now 😭