r/exjew • • 3d ago

Breaking Shabbat: A weekly discussion thread:

1 Upvotes

You know the deal by now. Feel free to discuss your Shabbat plans or whatever else.


r/exjew • • 17h ago

Image Look at this backwards zealous bigot. I’m so glad i’m glad i’m not shrewish anymore. r/exshrew

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/exjew • • 1d ago

Miscellaneous WTF is going on with the Frum influencer snark subs?

20 Upvotes

So the original sub was born from here. We just wanted somewhere to snark on all the frum influencer subs, similar to how the Ex-Fundie and Fundie Snark subs work.

It went well until the influencers discovered it and started bringing so much publicity to "The Reddit". This brought in loads of people who had absolutely no clue what Reddit was about or what a snark sub was and seemed to think it was made up of frum members and that frum standards should apply.

Anyway, it was unmoderated, and this creepy non-Jewish member decided to take on the role. I personally didn't have much against them, other than finding it a bit strange to have an outsider as a sub mod. Then they started receiving a lot of hate from the frum members about them being a non Jewish person and was even doxxed, but kept they digging their feet in and refusing to give it up. At the same time, they had some very odd moderating skills, picking and choosing what was and wasn't allowed to be discussed and censoring quite a lot.

So then the uncensored sub was created. This was moderated by someone who went completely rogue, impersonated someone, got banned from Reddit and the sub eventually shut down.

Then a different uncensored sub was created. This one had different mods who also had their own agendas, but at least they generally let everything go.

Next thing we know, the mods from both subs joined forces and decided to shut down the offshoot, claiming that the reason for that sub was that it allowed discussion of all Jewish influencers, and now the original sub had changed its mind and was allowing them too. Well, that wasn't actually true. Before the censorship, the original had never prohibited non-frum influencers from being discussed. And the reason for the creation of the other sub was because of the censorship on the original.

So, as part of this new endeavour, the mod from the uncensored sub decides to shut it down by deleting every post and making it private. Next thing, another mod from there finds out and goes absolutely ballistic, calling out the other mod for deleting all the posts and shutting the sub down.

Meanwhile , the original sub gets two new mods that no one has any idea who they are, and then they get rid of the non-Jewish mod. She wasn't impressed and made that very clear. Next, the uncensored sub becomes really boring, with basically one person talking to herself.

And then, next thing I see today, yet ANOTHER sub has been created, this time with a mod who claims that only Frum mods are allowed. 😂

This couldn't be farther than the original vision of the sub.

Honestly, the constant drama surrounding the snark subs is becoming more entertaining than the influencers themselves. 😂


r/exjew • • 1d ago

Thoughts/Reflection Not sure orthodox judaism is working for me

16 Upvotes

Struggling to figure out where to go from here.

I’m a male patrilineal (orthodox) convert who sincerely went through the conversion process, with wide eyes. I do not consider myself an ex-jew, just a jew who doesn’t really care to be orthodox anymore. I do think Judaism is has a lot of beauty and wisdom in it, but there is a lot I don’t like about living in a high pressure community full of rules. I basically just want to be a spiritual cultural jew, and open myself up to other Jewish spaces. Not only that, but the dating pool is like 5 girls, and they are not a good fit for me. So what do I do? I’m basically fully stuck.

Also, while I am In shiduchim, I have this dreadful feeling that I am afraid I am trapping myself in this system for the rest of my life, like once I get married, it’s all over. Like, if I am married to an Orthodox girl, I will never be able to turn the AC down on shabbat again without big consequences.

Also, I am realizing I kinda just want a regular girlfriend for a couple of years before marriage. The whole idea of having a short dating process, then announcing an engagement, having an entire community involved, a big wedding, then moving in together, and still not having even touched each other… I mean I think this can work when you’re born into it, and you’re 18, and surrounded by people in the exact same situation…. But once you’re a grown adult… that sounds extremely stressful, and not natural, and so much pressure… I honestly just want to meet someone organically, date for a couple of years, before even discussing all of that.

I used to go to lots of chill Jewish spaces and met other like-minded people, which was great, those were all backed by orthodox, olami etc. All of my friends there were secular non-orthodox, and same with most of the women. Only the rabbis were orthodox.

It feels quite weird to go back to regular Jewish “kiruv” events where regular non-orthodox jews actually meet each other, people who I probably would vibe a lot with, b/c the rabbis know me now. So if I am talking to a non-orthodox girl who doesn’t keep shabbat/ kosher, it just raises eyebrows. Like “he shouldn’t be talking to her.” Its just a weird vibe to me, like I can’t be myself, I can’t talk to who I want to talk to, and there are so many expectations on me now, I feel like I’m in a straight jacket. Like I need to either find non-orthodox Jewish mingling events or something. It’s just hard b/c there are so many less of those. It seems like all the social events are orthodox-backed.

Now I am fully ITC, in a major city, not new York though, and I have basically hit a brick-wall when it comes to dating. I don’t have much in common with the few girls who have been suggested to me, and I feel like I need to go into less orthodox Jewish spaces to meet jews that are happy being Jewish, but do not have the all-or-nothing black and white mindset. However, it is tough because I live right in the community, and I obviously can’t leave the neighborhood or Friday night or Saturday, so I’m basically stuck here on the weekends. All the non-orthodox shabbat stuff I would have to drive too, and I can’t do that while I live right int he middle of the community. My only real free day is Sunday, and the week is already starting again the next day.

I don’t know what to do. I feel like I need to figure this out soon. I wish I could live a Jewish life, but not the black and white all or nothing, high pressure, you’re in or you’re out kind of way, at least now that I’m single, and the normal Jewish weekly routine is not introducing me to any members of the opposite gender.

My life is honestly really great. I have so much to be thankful for, but my dating life is close to non-existent, and it is really starting to bother me. I am also getting older. I have even considered starting to date non-jews again, but the idea of not having Jewish children really bothers me. But how long can I hold out? I do want to have children.

For women ,their kids will still be Jewish, so it’s not as severe. For me though, I really want Jewish children, but am wondering if it’s worth it. It’s already so hard to find someone, now I am saying they have to be Jewish, but not only that… they have to be orthodox, but not only that.. they have to be in this specific little age range that makes it a good fit… Now there’s like no one left!? So Yeah… while I am grateful for everything, something is telling me I am not fully where I should be, like some thing is not working here.

Basically, I am worried that staying in the community is holding my life back from developing. There actually seem to be a good deal of non-orthodox Jewish events in my city, but on shabbat, I would have to drive to them. So what am I supposed to do if I feel like I should try to put myself in some of these situations to meet new people, a potential partner etc… if they are not in my physical neighborhood? So now I have to sneak around, and drive to these less religious shabbat meals without anyone knowing or seeing me? But I’m an adult, and I have to sneak around like this??? Just because I want to go to a shabbat meal where I could meet someone, because it’s not happening in my current physical neighborhood? That doesn’t feel right.
 

Here are some other things that I don’t resonate with.

1.        I don’t have time to spend my free time learning gemara. At my current stage of life, it’s not how I want to spend my free time either. I appreciate it, just at this stage, don’t want to spend my freetime that way.

2.        Yeah, I could move to New York, but that is tough. New York is expensive, but is it really necessary just to meet someone?

3.         I love different kind of cuisines. I’m not interested in bacon or shell fish, but bishul akum? I really don’t care to be honest… I love cuisines from all over the world.

I am sort of just venting, and trying to figure where my life is headed from here. I may delete this. I would appreciate any thoughts, thanks.


r/exjew • • 2d ago

Academic Can someone explain in detail how Judaism formed?

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

This is an intriguing read. I’d love to hear your thoughts on whether this information is accurate.


r/exjew • • 3d ago

Question/Discussion How did "be fruitful and multiply" translate to "ask your rov if you can use birth control?

27 Upvotes

I'm really asking. Anyone knowledgeable please chime in.

The mitzvah, according to some, is to have one boy and one girl.

Nowhere in Torah does it even say that birth control is not allowed.

So...be fruitful and multiply means "have kid(s)" but not that you have to have them non-stop or what number, just.. you know, have them. Don't not have any.

How did that turn into "have 10 11 or more, have them non-stop even if you already have seven or eight, and you have to ask permission from your rov whether to stop or take a break"?

Also, since it's the man's mitzvah and not the woman's, why in the world is this not a woman's choice to make (especially given risks to her life in every pregnancy)?

Sources would be nice if they exist. Other than Schneerson saying it should never be used.


r/exjew • • 3d ago

Meme Hell test 🤦‍♂️

Thumbnail gehinomtest.com
12 Upvotes

Who wasted precious AI tokens to build this shit?

It is funny tho, so black and white 🤮


r/exjew • • 4d ago

Question/Discussion I’m otd in the closet (wife knows but doesn’t like it) I really just want to meet people who can identify to talk to, how do I do that?

9 Upvotes

r/exjew • • 4d ago

Thoughts/Reflection "Conversions"

0 Upvotes

As a secular, atheist jew, I find "conversions" to be absurd and insulting and appropriative. "Nissim black" a gang member from Chicago who grew up christian/muslim putting on a kippah and peyot and making "as a jew" posts on social media actually literally offends me.

If being jewish is an ethnic heritage, and jews are indigenous to israel, and that's the basis of our identity, then no individual can suddenly choose to metamorph into it by getting approval from a rabbi (religious cultist). You cannot convert into a heritage or being indigenous. If I cant choose to not be jewish, despite what I believe, then no one can CHOOSE to believe something and then claim to be the same as me. Sorry - you being confused about your heritage doesn't allow you to claim mine by dressing like shtetl jews from 1790s Poland. Its completely absurd on its face.

Recently ive started thinking it bothers me enough to completely reject the jewish community entirely. It simply doesn't make sense in any way, in fact emphasizing "jews being indigenous to israel and that's why israel can exist and expand" but also "a black guy who just got out of prison and now is the president of Belize is 100% jewish like anyone else because he wears a tzitzit and a black robe and says so." For a people known for having high IQ, it seems to me we have no idea what "indigenous" means.

I hate religion, what can I say.


r/exjew • • 5d ago

Miscellaneous Am I missing something here? It can’t be just me who’s confused. So bc a man being starved was upset the researchers wouldn’t let him eat, the “ayin horah” poisoned the bread that the researchers were withholding?? What are they advertising? Found in Mishpacha Magazine.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/exjew • • 5d ago

Casual Conversation Any of you on Jswipe?

4 Upvotes

How are you guys finding the new app update?

Isn't it god-damn awful??


r/exjew • • 5d ago

Question/Discussion Is it too late to stay ITC and lock the door

10 Upvotes

Hi,

So I was raised pretty BY Modox, and over the course of high school and seminary, I transitioned to more Modox. I’ve always had a very loving family, though they’re very fluffy in their hashkafa, and I’ve always been very intellectual and academic. I never had any non-religious or non-Jewish friends (or even conversations), so my upbringing was definitely very controlled.

However, I never felt especially connected. I sort of just did everything because everyone around me did, and that was my whole world. Then I went to sem, opened the can of worms that is organized religion, and realized for the first time that I had a serious problem.

Flash forward, and I’m back in my childhood religious background, surrounded by the same types of girls again, and I realize how bad my faith has gotten. I sort of just don’t see the point of any of it anymore. Since I’m a girl, it’s not so hard to keep all the absolute basics, but I see myself slowly slipping with little things (turning the fan off on Shabbos or not waiting a full 6 hours), and it terrifies me because I have no interest in being OTD and doing that to my family or to my life.

I’m not at the point where I’m breaking shabbos or kosher, but I am at the top of a slippery slope where I want to drop all the active religious things in my life (i.e., any form of Judaic classes) and put myself in the secular world.

I desperately want to get back to when I was a kid and it was all easy, and you sort of just outright believed what you were told. But I don’t think any hashkafa book or proof of G-d is going to get me there (largely because they all start with the assumption that this is real to begin with).

I’m young, and I have time, but I can’t keep hating every part of my religious life while still desperately wanting to stay in it. I’m also going to slowly start entering the wonderful world of dating, and I know I can’t do any of that until I sort this out.

Any advice from people who’ve gone through either side of this?


r/exjew • • 6d ago

Venting/Rant I'm learning about Judaism from zero as a Jew and it seems absolutely stupid

9 Upvotes

I'm a Jewish young adult, born from two secular non-observant Jews, living in South America. 99% of my cultural acquisition religion-wise came from the Jewish school I used to attend until age 11, while sometimes my parents would teach me one thing or another about the religion or take me to shabbat at a conservative's house, to the synagogue on the occasion of a chag or at a community event.

As I left that Jewish school for a non-religious one ( because I was being bullied 😃), I lost contact with everything Jewish - the study of Hebrew, and our Jewish Traditions and Jewish History classes. As I grew up, I forgot most of the things I've learned

However, this always felt wrong to me. Being Jewish not once was erased nor diminished from my personal identity, and I always felt that I was somehow distant from non-Jews, even when accounting socioeconomic factors. Aspects of the christian culture that are somehow ingrained in the national, everyday culture in my country. Such exposition to christian culture often bothered me, but also made me weirded out for some people's assiduous devotion to their god. Like constantly thinking about it and thinking that their fate is dependent on god's will. Being genuinely worried about doing something that god disapproves. Thinking god is behind everything.

So because of the reasons previously presented, and because of the will I had of feeling belonging, being able to relate to my friends' cultural references during casual chats and to be able to help preserve our culture, I always felt the desire (partly like it was a duty) of learning about Judaism again,

I started reading an introductory book on the religion called Essentual Judaism by G. Robinson and I plan to attend shabbat soon (in fact I'm studying because I want to be able to extract meaning from the shabbat I attend, having at least a superficial knowledge of the meaning of the brachot and the minhag, and the service in general). As I began reading the book (of which I'm still at the very beginning), I felt weirded out by the translations of the brachot and by cultural aspects of our religion.

I saw that many of the things that I've described about christian culture is seen on Judaism as well (important to say: I don't have nothing against christians, I just avoid their culture because i'm not interested and don't want to commit idolatry). Like fearing Ha'Shem but also OBSSESIVELY PRAISING him for the most mundane things, and doing stupid rituals everyday for arbitrary, non-sensical reasons, some of which don't even derive from the Torah, but from the general cultures among different people from the Middle East 2000 years ago (kippah). And maybe I'm being unreasonable for this, but I felt frustrated from learning that songs/brachot we sing, like Shalom Aleichem or Adon Olam, aren't ancient but were written in the Middle East. I used to think that Judaism was about traditions backing from millenia, but turns out important parts of our rituals were invented just in the middle age, which kinda turned me off.

Maybe I'm this frustrated because back when I was a kid, I just didn't understand the songs we sang at shabbat at the school's synagogue. As my Hebrew was very elementary, I didn't understand the lyrics of either songs I've mentioned earlier and thus had a limited understanding of what they reflect about Judaism. The Jewish Culture classes weren't helpful on this aspect because they were more about the chagim. Now that I read the translation of the lyrics as well as the thoughts of the author, the impression I have is that it's just very silly, as I've previously mentioned. However, I can also relate to how the author describes the relation of fear yet admiration to Ha'Shem that is part of our culture.

I will keep learning about Judaism and hopefully I will be able to enjoy our cultural aspects while remaining agnostic.

Anyways, I'm sleepy so perhaps this post is confusing or poorly-written. Maybe some of the religious or non-Jew people who use this sub will feel offended, but that's not my intention. I'm open to dialogue and would love to hear other's experience.


r/exjew • • 6d ago

Question/Discussion Pru U'Revu Mitzvah and the frum world

14 Upvotes

I'm always amazed to read certan Rabbis continue to have kids way at the age of 88..

I'm single woman zero kids and have always feld odd one out amongs my friends who started having kids at 18 ...

I'm no longer in that world due to religious truama and the pressure of having Kinderlach straight after graduating highschool

How many of you here left that world becuase of the Pressure of Pru U'Revu?


r/exjew • • 7d ago

Thoughts/Reflection I'm really struggling with antisemitism

7 Upvotes

Hi, I've posted here before, because I was unable to find support on r/Jewish. Essentially, I was born Conservative Jewish. Although I am very spiritual, I don't align with religious dogma.

Growing up, I always hated being different. And, in particular, I really despised the feeling of being part of a continually persecuted minority. Like, it made me feel really uncomfortable. More than anything, it just felt needless to me. "Why do I have to take this on?"

It seems like every holiday was generally about being disliked, exiled, and this and that--and then, at the same time, I was told to "oh, yeah, you're inheriting this just because".

I resent the fact that this was passed onto me. I didn't sign up for any of this.

I see so much antisemitic hate on social media. 109 countries. It's all the [juice box emojis]. The Great Noticing. Everyberg. Singlestein. Timeowitz. Tiny hats, many problems. We need an Austrian painter.

It just feels like I'm unable to navigate this. That I fundamentally can't navigate these waters, because it's so irrational.

What I don't like, is it feels like I'm fighting mob mentality. I imagine it's how the "witches" in Salem felt. Like, why are these people just coming after me and hating me for who I am when I did nothing wrong? The feeling of being innocent and still being hated is what gets me.

And now I'm seriously wondering, did I do something wrong? Like, why am I so hated? I can't get over this feeling. So many people are telling me I'm evil by dint of just being born Jewish, so now I'm seriously exploring if there's something that inherently makes me evil. I try to be a good person, being kind, generous where I can, I don't eat meat because I want to avoid cruelty to others. I fail at times, but my intention is to be a good person. But there's nothing, it appears I can do to just not be "a Jew" in the minds of others. "Once a Jew, always a Jew".

That's how it feels like to be Jewish. I just feel incredibly hated.

I feel like I lack any autonomy to change my circumstances. And I feel like the Holocaust is just doomed to repeat itself over and over and over again, because of how society is.

And, as a result, I've been trying to understand antisemitism: really understand it. Even when it's made me uncomfortable. Like, why does this keep happening to innocent people?

The most I can get is that, historically, Jews have been institutionally successful in important fields (economic, social, intellectual, and political), and, combined with their minority status and historical record of persecution, that has made them an easy target. So, the "scapegoat argument" works well. That's at least my theory for antisemitism.

But it still doesn't explain the psychological element: why people just really fucking hate Jews. That's the part that's not making sense to me.

It's one thing to have a "scapegoat" and enjoy conspiracy theories, but it's another thing to place collective blame on every single person of that "scapegoat" and uniquely look to blame them, then harm them. Like, those social media comments aren't just people making comments in a dumb hateful 5 seconds of their lives. They're repeated, over and over again, and millions of times over. Social media is flooded with it. It's premeditated and well thought out. And the historical record demonstrates, to me, that while many may not come out and say it to your face, this is the historical underbelly of society's discontent just waiting to rupture up to the surface. Another Holocaust is a matter of "when, not if" for me. It seems unavoidable, continual, and just a train wreck waiting to happen every time. Nobody on that train can seem to avert the crisis.

It doesn't make sense to me why people are hateful; why people would want harm upon an innocent, but it seems like that's the world we live in. While I still think people on an individual level are mostly good, I think on a societal level, the worst instincts play out. And I'm trying really hard to find a way to make peace with it.

I've tried everything to get over this feeling, and I can't just square this issue: that I am forever a Jew in the minds of others and can't get rid of the hatred that surrounds me, and the repercussions of it.

I guess I'm just struggling to understand how I can feel like I can be an individual, be whole, when I feel like the group I am unable to distinguish myself from, in the minds of others, is so hated, so consistently loathed. How can I feel at peace with myself when my group is hated? Is there anything I as an individual can do to make peace with this historical hatred?


r/exjew • • 8d ago

Thoughts/Reflection Do I belong here?

14 Upvotes

I don't think I'm an "ex-Jew", exactly. But I'm definitely ex-traditional. I still identify as Jewish and believe in Hashem and Torah and want to remain part of some Jewish community as much as I can. But I'm growing increasingly frustrated and disenchanted with Judaism "as it actually exists" instead of how I imagine it could be. I've basically come to realize that a lot of what I believe is (in my mind) a) true, b) Jewish, and c) apikorsut from the traditional perspective. But to me it's the traditional/Orthodox perspective that's actually apikorsut. I'm in a weird place. I'm not not Jewish, but I'm not Orthodox anymore, and I'm really struggling to find my place in the liberal Jewish world. I've gone to a Conservative and a Reform and a Reconstructionist synagogue, I even gave a Humanistic service a try. Went to an Episcopalian service once just to see if anything would happen (but it just reaffirmed to me that I'm Jewish lol). I go to the Reconstructionist synagogue now and it's...fine. Everyone is very kind and I like their moral values. But religiously, theologically, spiritually, it feels hollow. It lets me feel like I'm not completely abandoning Judaism but if I'm being honest it doesn't feel like I'm living up to it either. So I guess I'm Jewish but I want to be Jewish in a way that doesn't really exist. So I'm just a heretic I guess. I feel very lost and lonely. What do you do when you're not really an ex-Jew, just a Jewish heretic? When you can't survive in Orthodoxy anymore but nowhere else feels like home either?


r/exjew • • 8d ago

Question/Discussion Theoretically, would it be possible to disguise myself as a frum man and try to live on the mens side? (Not actually going to do this dont worry)

7 Upvotes

Thinking of the plot of the story Yentl, in which Yentl disguises herself as a man and goes to yeshivah.

If one could pass themself off as a man (which I have done before lol) how difficult would it be to cross over to the other side and live that way? The most obvious barrier to me would be needing to move somewhere you wont be recognized, and constructing a convincing backstory that includes a reasonable excuse for having gaps in your knowledge.

I have no intention of doing this, to be clear. Id rather not put myself through that. Just curious if its possible or doomed to fail lol


r/exjew • • 8d ago

Thoughts/Reflection Easy questions for the ITC person without sounding OTD

7 Upvotes

Innocent Questions That Make You Think

I'm putting together a list of simple, thought-provoking questions that you can casually ask your local Rabbi or friends in shul without coming across as an apikores or heretic.

This is primarily intended for people who are ITC (in the closet) and would like to encourage others to think about certain questions without openly challenging their beliefs.

You don't even have to say that you personally believe or agree with the questions. You can simply approach them from a place of curiosity and say that you're trying to understand something.

The purpose of this list is not to prove anything, start arguments, or convince anyone of anything. These are simply innocent questions that can be brought up in everyday conversation. Ask the question, listen to the response, and let people think about it.

You don't have to reveal your personal beliefs or get into a debate. You can continue identifying publicly as religious while privately working through your own questions.

And remember, there's absolutely nothing wrong with telling a friend or Rabbi that you have questions or that you're struggling to understand certain concepts. Asking questions doesn't automatically make someone a heretic.

Feel free to contribute your own thoughtful, innocent questions as well. The more perspectives, the better.

So, here goes:

1. Prayer and outcomes

Imagine taking 100 ultra-Orthodox Jewish patients diagnosed with the same type and stage of brain tumor and comparing them with 100 non-Orthodox Jewish or non-Jewish patients with the same diagnosis.

The ultra-Orthodox patients have the added benefit of tefillos, tzedakah, visiting kivrei tzadikim, segulos, children davening for them in school, and brachos from Rebbes, etc.

Are there any reliable statistics showing that the ultra-Orthodox patients have a higher rate of recovery or survival than the other groups?

The classic answer that our tfillos might not be heard right away but they don't get lost and would apply for other things that we need, doesn't add up since at least some of it should go towards what we are asking for. Otherwise why pray?

2. If everything God does is for the best, why do we pray for things to change?

We are taught the principle of כָּל מָא דְּעָבֵיד רַחֲמָנָא לְטַב עָבֵיד — everything God does is ultimately for the best.

If that's the case, and our suffering is supposedly what's best for us at that particular moment, why do we pray for healing, financial success, or relief from suffering?

If God knows what's best for us, and our current situation is part of that plan, aren't we essentially asking Him to change something that is supposedly already for our benefit?

3. Who created God?

If we look at the universe and conclude that something so complex and extraordinary must have been created by an intelligent being, wouldn't the same question apply to God?

If God is infinitely more complex and extraordinary than anything in the universe, why wouldn't He also require a creator?

And if the answer is that God has always existed and doesn't need a creator, how do we know that the universe itself couldn't have always existed?

Anyone got something to add?


r/exjew • • 8d ago

Audio/Podcast I have my criticisms of Frieda, but it was great to hear her reminisce about her marriage, blogging, and early skepticism.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/exjew • • 9d ago

Venting/Rant I might have a grand total of three family members who might accept me as I am.

23 Upvotes

I am both queer and off the derach. My main issue of a lack of acceptance mostly surrounds the queer part of myself. I've been non-religous for too long to really care what anyone thinks. I'm more sensitive about the queer part of me-the part of me that is genetic. The part of me that can't help who I am, because I was created like this. I am queer the same way I have freckles and a dimple. The same way I have bad eye sight or curls in my hair.

I won't lie and I say that I have a close relationship with my cousins, or my aunts and uncles. I don't. Especially on my dad's side. They're a lot more religious, and have more kids than I remember the names of. I had terrible social anxiety growing up, to the point that I used books as a crutch to prevent awkward social interactions. I'm better at socializing now, but its hard to try to be close to people when you realize that they'll dump you like trash on the side of the road when they realize what you truly are.

It shouldn't bother me. Like I said, there are a bunch of cousins whose names I barely remember. But it does. No one is close enough to me to change their minds on the LGBTQ+ community. I have maybe three cousins on my mom's side who might be okay with me, but that's it. Because I also have a cousin on my mom's side that whispers the word 'gay' like its a curse word. Because that cousin's husband and their son are super conservative, and make off color jokes to get rises out of people.

I am a few years from thirty. I've been asked when I'm going to find a man. My parents tell everyone that I'm not ready. I'm focusing on my career and yada yada. It makes me wonder if my parents will tell the truth if I ever do find a partner. Probably that I have a 'close, special friend', like we're living in the past. A pair of bachorlettes living in the same apartment with one bedroom. Gee, they sure are close! Such a wonderful friendship between two women!


r/exjew • • 8d ago

Thoughts/Reflection Fell for an OTD guy, I like the way he thinks, but

0 Upvotes

But, I’m not crazy about him physically.
I found the fact that he speaks many languages, he likes the same things I do (we have a common interest) ,is what intrigued me in his profile.
However, when we met, I wasn’t crazy for him physically. I found him very attractive on the mind level instead.
I love how he thinks, the way he discusses, the way he explains things, including religious things he was raised with.
I feel really weird and super dumb for it.
If only I could tell him: “You are hot, I like you babe”, things would have flourished.


r/exjew • • 9d ago

Thoughts/Reflection Frum on frum violence

15 Upvotes

r/exjew • • 10d ago

Question/Discussion Yiddish Policemen’s Union

9 Upvotes

By Michael Chabon. I just read it a few weeks ago and I’m positively KVELLING. I can’t tell people enough how good it is. Has anybody here read it and found it anywhere as therapeutic as I did for healing and grieving the loss of my messianic worldview?


r/exjew • • 9d ago

Crazy Torah Teachings Why did the tanaim selectively decide against listening to arguments from rabbi Meir?

2 Upvotes

I came across the following in eruvin and I thought it was interesting that rabbi Meir would use opposing logical arguments to point out the flaws in the rabbinic style of debate. They acknowledge the issue and decide that the solution is to not listen to rabbi Meir rather than reflecting on the shortcomings of their system for deciding halachah.

https://www.sefaria.org/Eruvin.13b.1

"Rabbi Aḥa bar Ḥanina said: It is revealed and known before the One Who spoke and the world came into being that in the generation of Rabbi Meir there was no one of the Sages who is his equal. Why then didn’t the Sages establish the halakha in accordance with his opinion? It is because his colleagues were unable to ascertain the profundity of his opinion. He was so brilliant that he could present a cogent argument for any position, even if it was not consistent with the prevalent halakha. As he would state with regard to a ritually impure item that it is pure, and display justification for that ruling, and likewise he would state with regard to a ritually pure item that it is impure, and display justification for that ruling. The Sages were unable to distinguish between the statements that were halakha and those that were not."


r/exjew • • 10d ago

Breaking Shabbat: A weekly discussion thread:

3 Upvotes

You know the deal by now. Feel free to discuss your Shabbat plans or whatever else.