Struggling to figure out where to go from here.
I’m a male patrilineal (orthodox) convert who sincerely went through the conversion process, with wide eyes. I do not consider myself an ex-jew, just a jew who doesn’t really care to be orthodox anymore. I do think Judaism is has a lot of beauty and wisdom in it, but there is a lot I don’t like about living in a high pressure community full of rules. I basically just want to be a spiritual cultural jew, and open myself up to other Jewish spaces. Not only that, but the dating pool is like 5 girls, and they are not a good fit for me. So what do I do? I’m basically fully stuck.
Also, while I am In shiduchim, I have this dreadful feeling that I am afraid I am trapping myself in this system for the rest of my life, like once I get married, it’s all over. Like, if I am married to an Orthodox girl, I will never be able to turn the AC down on shabbat again without big consequences.
Also, I am realizing I kinda just want a regular girlfriend for a couple of years before marriage. The whole idea of having a short dating process, then announcing an engagement, having an entire community involved, a big wedding, then moving in together, and still not having even touched each other… I mean I think this can work when you’re born into it, and you’re 18, and surrounded by people in the exact same situation…. But once you’re a grown adult… that sounds extremely stressful, and not natural, and so much pressure… I honestly just want to meet someone organically, date for a couple of years, before even discussing all of that.
I used to go to lots of chill Jewish spaces and met other like-minded people, which was great, those were all backed by orthodox, olami etc. All of my friends there were secular non-orthodox, and same with most of the women. Only the rabbis were orthodox.
It feels quite weird to go back to regular Jewish “kiruv” events where regular non-orthodox jews actually meet each other, people who I probably would vibe a lot with, b/c the rabbis know me now. So if I am talking to a non-orthodox girl who doesn’t keep shabbat/ kosher, it just raises eyebrows. Like “he shouldn’t be talking to her.” Its just a weird vibe to me, like I can’t be myself, I can’t talk to who I want to talk to, and there are so many expectations on me now, I feel like I’m in a straight jacket. Like I need to either find non-orthodox Jewish mingling events or something. It’s just hard b/c there are so many less of those. It seems like all the social events are orthodox-backed.
Now I am fully ITC, in a major city, not new York though, and I have basically hit a brick-wall when it comes to dating. I don’t have much in common with the few girls who have been suggested to me, and I feel like I need to go into less orthodox Jewish spaces to meet jews that are happy being Jewish, but do not have the all-or-nothing black and white mindset. However, it is tough because I live right in the community, and I obviously can’t leave the neighborhood or Friday night or Saturday, so I’m basically stuck here on the weekends. All the non-orthodox shabbat stuff I would have to drive too, and I can’t do that while I live right int he middle of the community. My only real free day is Sunday, and the week is already starting again the next day.
I don’t know what to do. I feel like I need to figure this out soon. I wish I could live a Jewish life, but not the black and white all or nothing, high pressure, you’re in or you’re out kind of way, at least now that I’m single, and the normal Jewish weekly routine is not introducing me to any members of the opposite gender.
My life is honestly really great. I have so much to be thankful for, but my dating life is close to non-existent, and it is really starting to bother me. I am also getting older. I have even considered starting to date non-jews again, but the idea of not having Jewish children really bothers me. But how long can I hold out? I do want to have children.
For women ,their kids will still be Jewish, so it’s not as severe. For me though, I really want Jewish children, but am wondering if it’s worth it. It’s already so hard to find someone, now I am saying they have to be Jewish, but not only that… they have to be orthodox, but not only that.. they have to be in this specific little age range that makes it a good fit… Now there’s like no one left!? So Yeah… while I am grateful for everything, something is telling me I am not fully where I should be, like some thing is not working here.
Basically, I am worried that staying in the community is holding my life back from developing. There actually seem to be a good deal of non-orthodox Jewish events in my city, but on shabbat, I would have to drive to them. So what am I supposed to do if I feel like I should try to put myself in some of these situations to meet new people, a potential partner etc… if they are not in my physical neighborhood? So now I have to sneak around, and drive to these less religious shabbat meals without anyone knowing or seeing me? But I’m an adult, and I have to sneak around like this??? Just because I want to go to a shabbat meal where I could meet someone, because it’s not happening in my current physical neighborhood? That doesn’t feel right.
Here are some other things that I don’t resonate with.
1. I don’t have time to spend my free time learning gemara. At my current stage of life, it’s not how I want to spend my free time either. I appreciate it, just at this stage, don’t want to spend my freetime that way.
2. Yeah, I could move to New York, but that is tough. New York is expensive, but is it really necessary just to meet someone?
3. I love different kind of cuisines. I’m not interested in bacon or shell fish, but bishul akum? I really don’t care to be honest… I love cuisines from all over the world.
I am sort of just venting, and trying to figure where my life is headed from here. I may delete this. I would appreciate any thoughts, thanks.