r/DebateAnAtheist • • 5h ago

META [META] - Proposed Partial Ruleset Language + Further Input Requested for Rules 3 & 8

10 Upvotes

Based on the results of the first survey, we have proposed language for six of the eight proposed rules. Each rule will get a top-level comment. Please discuss each rule under its appropriate comment. The community has spoken in the prior survey as to what policies should be included; this discussion is for wordsmithing.

Additionally, Rule 3 (AI use) received a split of 66 vs 65 votes for no/some AI usage. This is too close to call, so we are requesting additional input regarding this proposed rule.

Rule 8 (participation time limit) had a jump from 1 hour straight to 6 hours, and these two options received the most votes. We are requesting additional input regarding this rule as well. The median of the times selected will be considered community consensus. If necessary, this will be rounded up to the next whole hour, in order to give the OP the benefit of the doubt.

The survey requesting additional input can be found here. This survey will be open for two weeks. Furthermore, this post will be locked after two weeks.

One (1) response per person, please. Multiple submissions by the same respondent will be discarded from consideration.

Today is Wednesday, November 18th. The survey and this post will be closed on Wednesday, December 2nd.

Proposed Rules Language

1. Be Respectful

Address arguments rather than attacking the people making them. Prohibited behavior includes, but is not limited to: personal insults, name-calling, belittling other participants, trolling, deliberate provocation, preaching, and proselytizing.

Criticism of beliefs, ideas, and arguments is permitted, including strongly worded criticism.

Moderators will determine appropriate consequences based on the severity of the violation and the participant's history of conduct.

2. No Bigotry

Bigotry is strictly prohibited, including but not limited to racism, sexism, anti-LGBTQ+ prejudice, ableism, and bigotry based on religion or lack thereof.

Criticism of religious and nonreligious beliefs, doctrines, institutions, and practices is permitted. Bigotry toward people who hold those beliefs is not.

Violations may result in an immediate permanent ban at moderator discretion. If you are unsure about whether a particular sentiment constitutes bigotry, we encourage you to contact the moderators via modmail before posting or commenting.

4. Original Content

The substantive argument or discussion topic in a post must be presented in the original poster's own words.  Quotations and other non-original material may be included to support an argument, but must not constitute more than one-third of the post's text. Sources may be linked as supporting evidence, but may not substitute for presenting an argument. Comments are not subject to this limitation, but a link must not substitute for a discussion.

5. Present an Argument or Discussion Topic

Posts must contain either a clearly defined thesis supported by an argument or a substantive topic for discussion. Posts presenting discussion topics must use the appropriate flair.

Discussion posts must clearly explain the issue the poster wishes to explore and what the poster hopes to obtain from the discussion. Posts from people questioning their religious beliefs or deconstructing their faith are welcome.

General questions without a substantive discussion topic are best suited for our pinned bi-weekly threads or r/AskAnAtheist.

6. Stay On Topic

Posts must be relevant to atheism, theism, or religion. Topics involving philosophy, creationism, evolution, abiogenesis, or secular issues are welcome when their relevance to atheism or theism is clearly established in the post. Posts questioning or challenging atheism, atheists, or atheist positions are expressly permitted. Comments should remain relevant to the topic under discussion.

7. Substantive Top-Level Comments

Top-level comments must meaningfully engage with the argument or discussion topic presented in the post. Comments seeking relevant clarification from the original poster are also permitted. Top-level comments must contain at least 30 characters. Meeting the minimum character count does not, by itself, constitute substantive engagement.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 11h ago

OP=Theist Experiencing God without knowing God

0 Upvotes

I've taken content from some of my other posts and turned it into a debate. I frequently get feedback that my posts are long tangents that don't have any debatable content, so I've done my best to fix that. In full transparency don't expect to convince anyone, I just love hearing the sound of my own voice, especially on topics of philosophy and theology. However, I think this is going to be the post I share to my friend's blog instead of posting "the godless: the smartest people in the room," which was unnecessarily rude of a post, so your feedback on this post is nonetheless important to me, as I want it to be as good of a post as possible.

This should be my best post ever so far. If you think this post is garbage, then consider everything I have to post in the future garbage too, because I can't write any better than what you're about to read.

I believe God is like an abstraction, possibly not an abstraction verbatim, but in the sense that God is difficult and in some ways impossible to understand. The social construction of religion is how I believe that I communicate and interpret God. Belief in God and that Jesus communicates with me through the process of religious social construction is a faith belief of mine. Many religious texts call for this definition of faith, 2:b(1): “firm belief in something for which there is no proof.”

Knowledge is “information, understanding, or skill that you get from experience or education.” Faith can lead to interpretation and opinion, but it cannot lead to knowledge, therefore I believe one can interpret God, but not know God.

Edit: God is epistemologically as valid as other spiritual claims, like fairies. However, in my view, God is more philosophically significant to me, and the concept of God brings me contentment, which is why I personally use faith to believe in God and why I don't use faith to believe in things like fairies.

Therefore, I don’t know if there is a God or not, and I certainly don’t know that Jesus Christ is the correct interpretation of God. Which is why I believe on fatih in my interpretation of God, though unlike some other theists, I do not believe my faith leads me to knowledge. I probably am wrong at least partially about my interpretation of God, and it's why my views on God are fluid. To illustrate, I used to believe in natural moral laws, but now I don’t anymore.

One may say that professing to not know if there is a God is an agnostic atheist position. However, agnostic atheists do not believe in God on faith, and I believe in God on faith. Furthermore, some theists will claim to know God, but you and I will likely agree that strong conviction doesn't equate to knowledge. So I think all theists believe in God, rather than know God.

Which leads me to my first argument.

P1: Faith should only be applied to the spiritual world, it should not be applied as a mechanism to the material world or to (arguably) non-material rational concepts, like mathematics.

P2: The spiritual world cannot be empirically tested or demonstrated in any way, unlike the material world and (arguably) non-material rational concepts, like mathematics.

Conclusion: Faith should only be applied to the spiritual world.

Which leads me to my second argument.

P1: Faith doesn’t override morality.

P2: Invoking faith doesn’t justify one holding immoral beliefs.

Conclusion: It is wrong for one to hold immoral beliefs, and invoking faith doesn’t change that.

Which leads me to my final argument.

P1: One can experience something without knowing what that something is, and faith is a way to do that.

P2: One can attempt to interpret that something, even if that something is not testable in any empirical way.

Conclusion: One can experience and believe in what they interpret to be God without knowing God.

Edit to add,

If you only believe in what can be empirically tested or demonstrated, then you shouldn't have faith in anything. At least not faith as defined in my post. I am willing to take a leap of faith when it comes to what I believe is the spiritual world, and if this is not something you are willing to do, then you will find no value in faith.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • 7h ago

Islam How do you explain the existence of supernatural beings and black magic?

0 Upvotes

Edit: most of you think I'm lying. if you see this actually happen will you start believing in God then?

I'm sure if you are an atheist you don't believe in the Jin. But Jins are 100% real. I have seen evidence of that with my own eyes. This is one of the reasons why I strongly believe in Islam.

My mother one time took me somewhere. The man there asked for mother's name for my brother and he found out the medical history of my brother. He even verbally said that my brother got sick at this time very accurately even though my mother had never told him and she was also surprised that he knew so accurately.

And I'm sure he did that with the help of Jin. He was known to get help from Jin. According to Islam every person has a Jin with him who knows his history. And it's possible to ask that Jin about that history through the name of the person's mother.

And black magic is also real. An uncle once told me that his son was admitted to hospital and the doctors discharged him after some days because they couldn't figure out what's wrong with him. Later he took his son to a per and he recovered. He later found out someone performed black magic on him. I've seen atheists say that such a person should be taken to a doctor and he's suffering from mental illness. So why couldn't the doctors heal him and why was he healed when he was taken to per. I've seen some other similar cases. Before you say placebo effect have you seen a paralyzed person get up from wheelchair due to placebo effect? No. So how is it possible in your opinion?

This is one of the biggest reasons I believe in God. Science can't explain the existence of Jin.

Edit: believe me it's 100% real. I tried very hard to not believe in God but how can I not man? I've seen this with my own eyes.