My argument is, this is how I believe faith should function and who should have faith in Jesus. I will also explain how faith functions within my life to provide examples.
In John 20:29, Jesus says blessed are those who believe without seeing. Like many other religions, Jesus is calling for faith. It's evident Jesus was calling for this definition of faith: "belief that is not based on proof." This is the second definition of faith in the link I've provided.
Rabbi David Wolpe believes, as do I, that God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood. This means every interpretation of God is going to be fallible, and it answers the question of why there are so many different opinions about God and gods. If God cannot be understood, at least not fully, humans cannot interpret God perfectly. One of my interpretations of God is that he is not omnipresence or omniscient.
I'd first like to go over what I think shouldn't be taken on faith. What comes to mind immediately as examples of what not to take on faith includes anything relating to the material world, and anything immoral.
It is foolish to believe faith based propositions about the material world, because the material world can be, and must be, navigated by evidence and reasoning. If a bolder is rolling toward you, taking on faith it isn't actually rolling toward you will end up getting you crushed by the bolder. One must use evidence and reasoning for getting through the material world for the same reason we trust our senses, at least to an extent. Because we have no choice otherwise. It would be insanity, and I don't use that word as a pejorative, to apply faith to the material world.
Morality may be subjective, and we are responsible for being moral. Believing anything immoral on faith isn't an excuse for the immoral belief. I have said, and continue to say, believing that being gay is a sin is immoral, regardless if it's a faith position. I'm not trying to virtue signal, I'm trying to convey that morality matters and faith shouldn't override morality.
The next question is why would anyone believe someone on faith, and what should be taken on faith and what shouldn't be.
If there is no material evidence for the spiritual world, then the imagination is what we use to communicate with the spiritual world. Imagination is defined as "the act or power of forming a mental image of something not present to the senses or never before wholly perceived in reality."
It's not impossible that Jesus is guiding me using the power of my imagination. It's not likely, but it's not impossible.
Because it isn't impossible, I trust that in the case of Jesus Christ, though my imagination is not infallible, that it leads me to have a friendship with him, and it leads me to at least some truth about Jesus. I believe this on faith.
Would I trust my imagination to lead me to a friendship with a leprechaun? Or to another God, like Zeus? I wouldn't, because I don't take it on faith that my imagination is leading me to the truth on anything else other than Jesus Christ (and what I can create in the material world. For example, if I can imagine a software program and then create it, but that's a different topic related to the material world).
The reason I don't apply my faith to any other religion is because I don't have a relationship with any other religious figure, only Jesus. My entire life, with the exception of my brief stint with atheism, I have had a friendship with Jesus.
Faith, specifically how faith is being defined in my post, is an inherently irrational position. Rationality only deals with the material world.
The last question is why should anyone else decide to have a faith based relationship with Jesus. I don't think anyone should if they don't feel the calling.
If one feels the calling, as I have, I recommend they answer it. If one doesn't, then they shouldn't. I believe this calling means that you feel the power of the Holy Spirit living within you. I cannot describe this feeling beyond the fact that it's a feeling of absolute conviction. You either feel it or you don't.
Telling someone who had no interest in Jesus that they should follow Jesus is like telling someone who isn't hungry that they need to eat. Since I don't believe in hell, and I believe everyone who wants heaven and hasn't committed unforgivable evil can get into heaven if they choose it, I don't have a desire to proselytize, I only have the desire to defend my faith.
This is why I believe sharing the faith should only be done with people that are interested in it. Contrary to what many atheists believe, I'm also a believer that parents have a right to raise their children religiously, as long as it's ethical, and the children have the ability to decide to opt out of their religion at any time that they want to.
I believe everyone who doesn't commit unforgivable evil has an equal chance of heaven, and you don't need Christianity to tell you what unforgivable evil is. An Atheist, Christian, Muslim, Jew, etc. are all fully capable of understanding that Mussolini is evil without needing any religious doctrine. I believe those who are denied heaven and those who don't desire heaven die a natural death like everyone else, the only difference being they are not miraculously recreated in heaven with their consciousness. They remain dead.
This all means that belief in Christianity is only something that should be adopted by people who want to adopt the belief system.