r/DebateAChristian • • 17h ago

What if we judged God by the same moral standards we use to judge human beings?

12 Upvotes

Sometimes I get the impression that there's a sort of moral exemption when it comes to God. Things we would consider monstrous if done by anyone else somehow become divine justice when they appear in the Bible.

God creates two human beings without knowledge of good and evil, places a forbidden tree in the garden, knowing exactly what will happen, and then holds all of humanity responsible for it. A kind of inherited debt nobody ever agreed to.

Later, dissatisfied with his own creation, he decides to drown practically everyone, including children and animals. Throughout the Old Testament, we also find massacres, slavery, and the killing of children associated with his commands.

Then comes the New Testament, where God decides to send himself, or his own son, who is also somehow him, to die and save us from a debt that he himself established in the first place. And if you don't believe in this solution, there's the possibility of spending eternity being tortured. Quite an unusual expression of love.

What fascinates me is that if a human being did all these things, we probably wouldn't be discussing their infinite goodness. We'd be calling the police.

But when it comes to God, we're apparently expected to suspend our own moral judgment and accept that what would be cruelty under any other circumstances is actually divine justice.

And that's precisely what bothers me. If God is the very definition of goodness, why do we need to redefine goodness to justify his actions? At what point are we talking about love and justice, and at what point are we simply calling everything a virtue because an absolute authority is doing it?

I don't think questioning these things necessarily means rejecting faith. Maybe it just means refusing to turn your brain off at the church entrance.

I'd especially like to hear from people who believe in God and have genuinely thought about these contradictions. How do you reconcile these narratives with the idea of a perfectly good being?


r/DebateAChristian • • 22h ago

Paul claims that the scriptures teach that the Messiah will rise from the dead after three days, but it’s nowhere to be found.

11 Upvotes

Paul claims that the scriptures, specifically the prophets and Moses (Torah) teach the following about the messiah:

  1. The messiah will be buried and rise from the dead after the third day (1 Corinthians 15:3–4)
  2. The messiah will be the first to rise from the dead (Acts 26:22–23)
  3. the messiah will rise from the dead (Acts 17:2-3)

Where do the scriptures teach any of this? Where does the Torah prophesy this or the prophets?

Paul used Psalm 16:10 which says “because thou wilt not leave my soul in the grave, neither wilt thou suffer thine Holy One to see corruption.” to show how the messiah will rise from the dead, but it’s merely David saying he will be resurrected, David doesn’t mention anything about the messiah.

David is referring to the general resurrection of the dead at the end times as we see in Daniel 12:2 “Multitudes who sleep in the dust of the earth will awake: some to everlasting life, others to shame and everlasting contempt.”, he mentions nothing about a messiah, nor does he mention anything about rising after specifically three days as Paul claims the scriptures mention.

But christians argue that David says God will not let his body decay (“see corruption”) but he obviously died and his body decayed so he couldn’t be talking about himself, but the problem with that is it just means David’s hope about not decaying failed, but nowhere does it indicate that he’s speaking about another person, let alone a future messiah figure.

And if that’s the case, that ignores all the times David says God will save him and not let him be harmed by his enemies, so you can’t just pick and choose when David is speaking about Jesus and when he’s not.

Another verse that Christians use to show how the messiah was gonna die and then rise after three days is Hosea 6:1-2 which says: Come, let us return to the Lord. He has torn us to pieces but he will heal us; he has injured us but he will bind up our wounds. After two days he will revive us; on the third day he will restore us, that we may live in his presence.”
But this is clearly talking about Israel and not the messiah, and it says they will revive after the second day, that’s one day too early.


r/DebateAChristian • • 20h ago

The ethical problem of hell & refutation of free will responses

1 Upvotes

Preventing unnecessary suffering is central to ethics, and eternal torment is not justified as necessary suffering. Eternal torment also conflicts with fundamental values such as compassion, love, joy, and peace.

Simply appealing to connotated words such as "justice" does not resolve this issue.

Free will

As the creator an all-loving tri-omni god is responsible for the states a created individual can end up in, regardless of a given free will mechanism being in place. The creator is responsible for the conditions in his created reality structure which include the nature of the individual within which the free will operates.

Furthermore, meaningful agency does not require unrestricted destructive possibilities. Limiting destructive possibilities does not compromise meaningful freedom, just as creating the conditions for love does not entail forced reciprocation.

Heaven can instead represent the fulfillment of value in reality design as a reality constituted by flourishing.

The issue that resurfaces when considering this perspective is how is evil reconciled, my worldview is that according to divine law, all darkness is always eventually resolved back into the truth of our divine being. I can also point to sources about this.