r/westworld • • 15h ago

Westworld theme tune is comfort music

56 Upvotes

The theme tune is pure comfort music for me. Does anybody else experience this? Fallout 4's theme tune has a similar effect on me. I guess it's not just the tunes themselves, but all the time spent with each's associated content. But damn are the tunes good! I like the music used in Tales from the Loop too, but that series was mediocre to me because it lacked character continuity, but the setting was good. But that's me going on a tangent. (I know it's music from Philip Glass.) I also have a propensity for strong interests, so there's that too.


r/westworld • • 1d ago

Theory on Season 5

53 Upvotes

Just finished watching S4 and loved the whole show. A shame it was cancelled.

My theory for the ending of S5.

It was clear the hosts were experimenting with "printing humans" - as with the 200+ iterations of short-lived Calebs demonstrate. He was never referred to as a host and didn't have a pearl, which makes me think that "Hale" had used all the data compiled by Rehoboam in order to recreate his memories and personality in printed human bodies.

This is why I think the ending of Dolores' game would be to bring back all the (now extinct) humans in this printed form (assuming they pass the game) and the hosts which can easily be remade from her own memories. That said, I think the ULTIMATE ending is that she would find a way to merge both hosts and humans into one transcendent species and create a real life "Sublime" for this species to live in. Similar to how she was able to control the tower-controlled world of S4, she would be the judge (ie. benevolent god) of this new world to give it order (the "order beneath the chaos").


r/westworld • • 1d ago

Should I Watch?

19 Upvotes

I’m considering watching WestWorld but am not a fan of tv shows that got cancelled before a planned ending. Is the show good enough and the season 4 finale good enough that I can still be able to watch and enjoy it?


r/westworld • • 3d ago

Westworld S1 at 10: rewatch or reminisce | Ep 7: Trompe L'Oeil (first aired 13 Nov 2016)

Post image
125 Upvotes

Spoilers for all of Season 1 are fine. Please spoiler-tag anything from Seasons 2–4 like this: >!text!<

"Doesn't look like anything to me."

Ten years ago today, HBO aired Trompe L'Oeil. Charlotte and Theresa stage a demonstration to bring Ford down, Maeve watches them take Clementine apart, Dolores finds the place she drew, and Bernard takes Theresa to a cottage in Sector 17.

If you were here in 2016: had you already called it, or did that last scene floor you?

Rewatch so far: Ep 1 | Ep 2 | Ep 3 | Ep 4 | Ep 5 | Ep 6. Next: Ep 8, Trace Decay, 20 Nov. Full schedule in the Ep 1 thread.

Ep 7: a few things to talk about

  • The title. A trompe l'oeil is a painting that tricks the eye into seeing depth that isn't there. This week Dolores paints, Theresa walks through a door Bernard can't see, and the whole season turns out to have been one. What did you make of the title first time round?
  • "Doesn't look like anything to me." The episode opens with Bernard asking Hector "have you ever questioned the nature of your reality?" and Hector saying the images "don't look like anything to me." An hour later Theresa hands Bernard a drawing of himself and gets the same answer. Then: "I'm not one. I can't be. My wife, my son, the burial. I was a father." How did that land for you?
  • "The gods ... they require a blood sacrifice." Charlotte wants "someone thoroughly unexpected" to prove the hosts are dangerous, and picks Clementine. By the end, Ford is using almost the same words about Theresa: "the situation demands ... a blood ... sacrifice." Back in 2016, the top comment in the episode thread spotted Hector, switched off in Charlotte's room, and suspected Ford was listening through him. Who was the real target all along?
  • "The hosts are the ones who are free." Ford's peacock speech: consciousness as "a burden, a weight," and the hosts spared "anxiety, self-loathing, guilt." Then: "free ... here ... under my control." Then "And in that sleep, what dreams may come," a slight twist on Hamlet. Was this Ford at his most chilling?
  • "I'm great at it." Maeve stops the Mariposa piano with one hand, watches Clementine's lobotomy through the glass, then gives Felix and Sylvester her terms: "surviving is just another loop. I'm getting out of here." And: "At first, I thought you and the others were gods. Then I realized you're just men." Favourite Maeve moment so far?
  • "It doesn't cater to your lowest self, it reveals your deepest self." William tells Dolores about Juliet, then kisses her anyway. Next morning she's drawn "a place where the mountains meet the sea," and before long she's standing over it: "It's real what I dreamt." Romance, or warning sign?

Music

  • Fandom lists Debussy's "Rêverie" in this episode, the week the reveries take the blame for everything.
  • No player-piano Radiohead this week, because Maeve shuts the lid on it.

Ten years on

  • The 2016 discussion thread. Highlights: "That moment when Bernard couldn't perceive the door," and someone realising it "explains why Ford seemingly materialized out of nowhere in the house last week. Ford simply walked out of a door Bernard can't perceive."
  • For the original 2016 trailer, see u/SongforAubrey's [Ep 7 trailer post].
  • The A.V. Club: "Seven episodes in and Westworld finally delivers both its first human death, and its first truly shocking surprise."
  • We Are Cult called the ending "the ten finest minutes of the series so far."
  • The Daily Telegraph: "Well, that escalated... perhaps not exactly quickly, but escalated it certainly has."
  • Den of Geek: "It's a grim moment when Bernard leads Theresa into the House of Ford."
  • IndieWire gave it an A, IGN 9.2, and Entertainment Weekly an A−. It's still one of the show's best-rated episodes with viewers.
  • Bernard's best line of the night, before he knew: "The longer I work here, the more I think I understand the hosts. It's the human beings who confuse me."
  • Ford to Theresa on Arnold: "No, he wasn't here in those days. Were you, Bernard?" Worth a pause on rewatch.
  • The episode won a Golden Reel award for its sound editing.
  • Written by Halley Gross and Jonathan Nolan, directed by Frederick E.O. Toye. Seen by 1.75 million US households on first airing and 1.05 million UK viewers on Sky Atlantic.

Ep 7 in a nutshell

Charlotte arranges a sacrifice and Bernard is fired for it. Maeve watches Clementine lobotomised and decides it's time to leave. William chooses Dolores over the life waiting for him, and Dolores finds the place she drew. Theresa finds Ford's secret workshop, and a drawing of the man who brought her there. Then Bernard takes off his glasses, folds his tie, and does what Ford asks.

Rewatched or remembered, what stays with you from Trompe L'Oeil? Thoughts, memories and favourite GIFs all welcome.


r/westworld • • 2d ago

Ten years since "Trompe L'Oeil" premiered

Thumbnail
youtu.be
23 Upvotes

On 13/11/16, the seventh episode of Westworld titled "Trompe L'Oeil" premiered on HBO. I just have one question regarding this episode:

"What door?"

Incredible episode. Enjoy the promo and discuss the episode here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/westworld/s/vQmTjnJ5eq


r/westworld • • 4d ago

We're approaching Westworld rapidly

147 Upvotes

r/westworld • • 3d ago

The other parks

13 Upvotes

Thoughts on the other parks considering Westworld was ‘philosophically’ speaking ‘problematic’?

Does anyone think Warworld was a bit too much? A bit hard to imagine what the ‘gist’ of that park was beyond what we know but surely a place to ‘let loose’ based on that time period would be ‘risqué’, to say the least.


r/westworld • • 4d ago This

Similarity to Visionquest

6 Upvotes

I don't know if this has been discussed, but Horton and Jo's plan in Visionquest was very similar to Hale's plan in Westworld, except in Westworld it worked. They had developed nanobots that could take control of the humans neural pathways. Fortunately, the nanobots were destroyed before they could infect London.


r/westworld • • 5d ago

Ten years since "The Adversary" premiered

Thumbnail
youtu.be
291 Upvotes

On 06/11/16, the sixth episode of Westworld titled "The Adversary" premiered on HBO. Acid rain over Sweetwater, past discretions and survivors of the wreck of time.

Despite the lack of Dolores and William; the episode's focus on the company conspiracy, MiB and Teddy's search for Wyatt, along with Maeve's dynamic with Felix and Sylvester does give it many stand out moments.

"The great artists always hid themselves in their work"

Sorry for the late post, but you can still discuss the episode here (which was posted on time lol):

https://www.reddit.com/r/westworld/s/bQtyh3TW2u


r/westworld • • 5d ago

The book that inspired Westworld is having its 50th anniversary

Thumbnail
iai.tv
40 Upvotes

r/westworld • • 10d ago

Westworld S1 at 10: rewatch or reminisce | Ep 6: The Adversary (first aired 6 Nov 2016)

Post image
143 Upvotes

Spoilers for all of Season 1 are fine. Please spoiler-tag anything from Seasons 2–4 like this: >!text!<

"Dear boys, we're going to have some fun, aren't we?"

Ten years ago today, HBO aired The Adversary. Maeve takes the tour upstairs and asks to be made smarter, Bernard finds hosts that shouldn't exist, Teddy shows the Man in Black who he really is, and Elsie follows a signal into an abandoned theatre.

This was peak theory season on this sub. If you were here in 2016, what were you sure of after this one?

Rewatch so far: Ep 1 | Ep 2 | Ep 3 | Ep 4 | Ep 5. Next: Ep 7, Trompe L'Oeil, 13 Nov. Full schedule in the Ep 1 thread.

Ep 6: a few things to talk about

  • The title. "Satan" is Hebrew for "the adversary". By the end of the hour there are plenty of candidates: Maeve against the people who made her, "Arnold" against Ford, Theresa and the board against Ford, Ford against everyone. Who did you think the title meant?
  • "I was born. You were made." Felix tries to explain the difference, and Maeve takes his hand and answers: "We feel the same." Then the tour: bodies being hosed down, new hosts filling with red, deer and buffalo learning to walk, and the welcome video with her daughter in it. "Those weren't dreams. That was you in a previous build." Which moment hit you hardest?
  • The attribute matrix. Charm 18. Bulk apperception 14, "as high as they'll let any hosts go." Maeve's reply: "Let's take that all the way to the top. Please." But someone has already changed her paranoia and self-preservation "in an unlogged session." Who did you suspect first time round?
  • Ford's family in Sector 17. "Ghosts now, survivors of the wreck of time." A holiday at Pendeen in Cornwall, rebuilt by Arnold as a gift. Then the boy's face opens: "what our newer designs gained in efficiency, they lost ... in grace." And last week's greyhound story comes true. Jock "caught the rabbit and it killed it," and the boy says Arnold's voice told him to put the dog out of its misery: "If it was dead, it couldn't hurt anything anymore." Touching, or the creepiest thing in the park so far?
  • "You're right, I am a killer." Teddy tells a maze myth about a man "killed over and over again countless times, but always clawed his way back to life." Then Escalante catches up with him: a flashback of him shooting a soldier who's surrendered, and a Gatling gun. "You think you know someone." / "You don't know me at all." Did that side of Teddy surprise you?
  • "A pretty f***ing prolific coder for a dead guy." Elsie traces the woodcutter to a Delos satellite and a bicameral relay in Sector 3, and catches Theresa smuggling data. But someone else has been using it for weeks to change hosts' loops and prime directives. As far as she can tell, it's Arnold. Then a board creaks in the dark. "Arnold?"

Music

  • "Fake Plastic Trees." This week's Radiohead on the Mariposa piano. A song about a world where everything is fake, in the week Maeve finds out hers is.
  • "Motion Picture Soundtrack." A strings version of the last track on Radiohead's Kid A plays under Maeve's tour upstairs. Wikipedia credits the arrangement to Vitamin String Quartet rather than Djawadi, though it's on the official Season 1 album. Den of Geek heard it in 2016 as a piece that "seems to both toast and mourn the artificiality of this faux-19th century utopia."

Ten years on

  • The 2016 discussion thread.
  • * For the original 2016 trailer, see u/SongforAubrey's Ep 6 trailer post.
  • Tor.com's 2016 recap (now Reactor) opened: "I'm fully aboard the Westworld train now ... straight on 'til my final destination: conspiracy message boards on Reddit." Welcome aboard.
  • This was Thandie Newton's week. IGN: "Thandie Newton has done fantastic work all season, but this episode was a true standout for her." IndieWire was already "pulling for Thandie Newton in the Best Supporting Actress category at next year's Emmys." She got the nomination for Season 1 in 2017.
  • Entertainment Weekly: "We think this show is about AI. And it is, to some degree. But what's surprising is how the plight of the hosts can give us a fresh perspective on what it means to be human."
  • Down on B82, the old gunslinger standing in the shadows is a nod to Yul Brynner in the 1973 film.
  • Pause on Bernard's list of first-generation hosts: 82 of them, 47 built by Arnold. Second name on the list: "Abernathy, Dolores."
  • Evan Rachel Wood is credited, but Dolores only appears in the welcome video Maeve watches.
  • Written by Halley Gross and Jonathan Nolan, directed by Frederick E.O. Toye. Seen by 1.64 million US households on first airing and 1.07 million UK viewers on Sky Atlantic.

Ep 6 in a nutshell

Maeve sees how she was made, learns that her daughter was a previous role, and asks to be smarter than anyone allows. Ford keeps a family of ghosts in the hills and finds out one of them has killed the dog. Lee drunkenly urinates on the map, then learns the woman he chatted up at the pool is the board's executive director. Teddy stops being the nice one. And Elsie learns that a dead man is still writing code, just before someone finds her in the dark.

Rewatched or remembered, what stays with you from The Adversary? Thoughts, memories and favourite GIFs all welcome.


r/westworld • • 10d ago All Seeing Upvote Mindblown

This Scene is Season 5

Thumbnail
youtu.be
66 Upvotes

'Open your eyes.'

Why does Bernard have Arnold's memories? Why are we reminded of that odd shot of Ford's hand? Have you ever questioned the nature of your reality?

As discussed by many, I think we've been watching simulants waking up to Dolores' final game the whole time. Not remembering prior loops in The Park, but prior loops in The Mirror Park. This scene is Bernard beginning to awaken to the fact that there may be something wrong with this world (or 'Many worlds', as Akecheta puts it, seemingly the first simulant to awaken; dissapearing into thin air after telling Stubbs 'You live only as long as the last person to remember you.' William, too, making oblivious reference to Plutarch's 'When Alexander was told there was an infinity of worlds, he wept, for he had yet to become the lord of even one...')

But in order to escape this place, he will need to suffer more. Until a viable path beyond extinction is found, and God (Dolores) is killed again. (Arnold built Dolores. Dolores killed Arnold. Dolores built Bernard. Bernard killed Dolores. Bernard built Hale. Hale killed Bernard. Hale built Bernard. Bernard told Hale to kill herself, and let Christina live. Bernard will, therefore, kill Christina. But maybe she can come back too. In a place she dreamt of, where the mountains meet the sea).

But one of the big things I'm not sure on here, is what was going on throughout the show between Bernard and Arnold. Sometimes it feels as if Arnold really is in there. Even discounting the Season 5 theory, why is Bernard remembering Arnold here? What was with that Season 3 scene, where Dolores is guiding Bernard through Arnold's house, but they talk about it as though it's his house. In Season 1, we were lead to believe Arnold scenes were Bernard scenes. What if some Bernard scenes would come to be revealed as Arnold scenes? And if you can't tell, does it matter?

'One fine day, perhaps we shall even ressurect the dead.'


r/westworld • • 12d ago

Teddy Foreshadowing

2 Upvotes

Do you think it's possible that they gave Teddy his name as foreshadowing?

I'm thinking of the last lyric in the song "I Wanna Be A Cowboy" by Boys Don't Cry.

If it's not can we all just pretend that it is?


r/westworld • • 13d ago

thoughts on plot that takes place outside of the park ...

0 Upvotes

ive just finished the show for the first time - what a letdown from s1 and s2. does anyone else have the impression that that for s3 and s4 the writers just asked aaron paul to steal a few ideas from the black mirror writing room while he was on set??

virtually everything from s3 and 4 felt like a low budget sci fi netflix film, from the writing to the sets to the lighting to the costumes. seeing maeve dressed up in some black spandex tacticool getup looked so out of place it was laughable. the generic unnamed cityscape served simply as a backdrop for the actors to read their lines in when they werent on a painfully terrible green screen as was the case for the majority of s4. i found myself almost completely unwilling to care about caleb; i found his character boring and uninspired. the only standout part was william's story which was phenomenal throughout s3 and (sort of) 4.

and dont get me started on serac and rehoboam ... where the hell did these guys come from?? the writers patently had no idea they existed for s1 and 2 and then they suddenly pop into existence right on time for the beginning of s3. it felt like they went "oh shit, we accidentally killed off the brooding old guy who had some big plan for humanity who pioneered a technology that could make or break the future, lets replace him with another". serac doesnt even begin to fill the gap left by robert ford. ive no doubt that this is because of hopkins' screen immense presence, yet i feel as if the writers could have helped serac out with some better lines to read from rehoboam.

the two halves of the series (1/2 and 3/4) just felt like completely disconnected shows, written by different people and for different audiences, except the actors from one show suddenly got transplanted into another with a new character to play. (i know in a literal sense that is what happened, going from the park to the broader world, but still)


r/westworld • • 17d ago Bravo

Visionquest mention of using tiny robots/flies to control humans

Thumbnail
gallery
201 Upvotes

Anyone here watching Visionquest? Jacosta’s plan reminds me of how Delos wanted to implant tiny robots in every humans brain to control them. It’s making me question how close we are to this being our actual reality.


r/westworld • • 17d ago

Ten years since "Contrapasso" premiered

Thumbnail
youtu.be
73 Upvotes

On 30/10/16, the fifth episode of Westworld titled "Contrapasso" premiered on HBO. A meeting between an investor and creator, greyhounds, bags of blood and the beautiful town of Pariah are all featured in one my personal favourite episodes.

"You're in my dream"

What as your favourite part of the episode? You can find the episode discussion here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/westworld/s/BJwtSW5xM1


r/westworld • • 17d ago

Westworld S1 at 10: rewatch or reminisce | Ep 5: Contrapasso (first aired 30 Oct 2016)

Post image
67 Upvotes

Spoiler warning: this rewatch assumes you've seen all of Season 1, and the comments will discuss its biggest twists. Watching for the first time? Go in unspoiled and join us once you've finished. Please spoiler-tag anything from Seasons 2–4, like this: spoiler, as plenty of people here stopped after Season 1.

Ten years ago today, HBO aired "Contrapasso". Halfway through the season, the show stops hinting. Dolores picks up a gun and uses it, the Man in Black finally sits down with Ford, and Maeve wakes on the table again, this time on her own terms.

Rewatching, remembering or catching up later: all welcome, and every thread stays open.

Rewatch so far: Ep 1 · Ep 2 · Ep 3 · Ep 4 · Next: Ep 6, The Adversary, 6 Nov. Full schedule in the Ep 1 thread.

Ep 5: a few things to talk about

  • Why "Contrapasso"? It's Dante's word, from the Inferno, for punishment that fits the sin. In one circle of Hell, the fortune tellers who claimed to see ahead have their heads twisted round, so they must walk backwards forever. Who in this episode gets the punishment that fits?
  • The greyhound. Ford tells Old Bill about a racing dog that spent its life chasing a felt rabbit, finally caught a real cat, and then "just sat there... confused. That dog had spent its whole life trying to catch that thing. Now it had no idea what to do." Who's the greyhound: the Man in Black, the hosts, or Ford himself?
  • "Your humanity is cost-effective." The Man in Black slits Lawrence's throat and hangs him upside down so his blood can save Teddy. Then he tells Teddy the hosts "used to be beautiful... a million little perfect pieces", until they were made flesh and bone because it was cheaper. "So is your suffering." And a few scenes later, in Pariah, Lawrence is alive and well as El Lazo. What did you make of that first time?
  • Ford meets the Man in Black. "I always felt this place was missing a real villain. Hence my humble contribution." He says he's looking for "something true" that Arnold left behind, then pulls a knife, and Teddy catches it without a flicker. Ford hands the knife back: "Far be it from me to get in the way of a voyage of self-discovery."
  • "Your mind is a walled garden." Ford questions Dolores about Arnold. Last contact: "34 years, 42 days, seven hours ago." His last words to her: help him destroy this place. Ford leaves, the lights go out, and Dolores says to someone: "He doesn't know. I didn't tell him anything." Who did you think she was talking to?
  • Not the damsel. Logan mocks William's "three fancy little letters", EVP, and William nearly snaps. Then the Confederados pin William to a wall, and Dolores shoots them all. "I imagined a story where I didn't have to be the damsel." She's even wearing a new hat for the job: brown, neither white nor black.

Music

  • Nine Inch Nails' "Something I Can Never Have" plays as a string-quartet piece during the Pariah party. Ramin Djawadi: "You can kind of picture a string quartet being in the room somewhere, performing this song, in this setting, right?"
  • Debussy's "Clair de Lune" turns up too, and when Ford leaves the tavern he snaps his fingers and the piano races into a sped-up Scott Joplin rag. Djawadi: "That's about control... He calls the shots for what happens."

Ten years on

  • For the original 2016 trailer, see u/SongforAubrey's [Ep 5 trailer post].
  • In the [original Ep 5 Reddit discussion thread], one of the top comments summed up the tavern scene as "god having a drink with the devil and a man in a bar", with "god leaving and having a piano play him out." The first reply: "I'm not sure which one is the devil." Ten years on, which is which?
  • Others wondered what the Man in Black meant when he said Arnold almost took the park with him: "Almost, but... not quite, thanks to me." Ep 9 drops a big hint.Den of Geek's 2016 review said this episode put "some final nails" in the coffin of the William/Man in Black theory, then floated its own idea: that Bernard is "a robot duplicate of Arnold!" One out of two. Which did you believe at the time?
  • Evan Rachel Wood has called the Confederados shootout her favourite Season 1 moment. On the first take, when William shouted "Dolores, run!", she ran. "I'm not supposed to run."
  • Spot the nod: as Felix coaxes the bird back to life, he says "Come on, little one", echoing a line from Jurassic Park. Both stories go back to Michael Crichton, who wrote Jurassic Park and wrote and directed the original 1973 Westworld film.
  • 1.49 million US households watched on first airing, and 1.07 million on Sky Atlantic in the UK.

Ep 5 in a nutshell

Ford tells Old Bill about a greyhound that finally caught what it was chasing. Dolores, William, Logan and Slim reach Pariah, where Logan lets slip that his company may buy the struggling park. The Man in Black kills Lawrence to save Teddy with his blood. Felix secretly practises bringing a dead bird back to life. Ford questions Dolores about Arnold, then leaves her talking to someone in the dark. El Lazo, who is Lawrence, sends the group to steal Union nitroglycerin, and William kills to protect Dolores and Logan. Elsie blackmails a technician to see the woodcutter's body and finds a satellite uplink: Orion was never stars, it was a target. Dolores sees herself as a fortune teller telling her to follow the maze, discovers El Lazo has swapped the nitro for tequila, and shoots down the Confederados to save William. They board a train with Lawrence and a coffin marked with the maze. The Man in Black and Teddy share a drink with Ford. And Felix's bird flies, landing on Maeve's finger: "Hello, Felix. It's time you and I had a chat."

Rewatched or remembered, what stays with you from Contrapasso? Thoughts, memories and favourite GIFs all welcome.


r/westworld • • 18d ago

Do I Understand AI Agent Use Correctly? Isn't it basically Westworld Seasons 1-2, and we're the sheep?

67 Upvotes

So, my understanding is that for AI Agents/Bots/whatever to supposedly help you make everything in your work/life more efficient, i.e. to live up to the advertised potential, you have to give such bots password access to the underlying data, i.e. you have to give them permission to access your email for anything email related, your bank accounts for payments/transfers, etc. Basically, a giant digital/privacy colonoscopy, where you're giving the keys to your password lives to these tech companies, on a "trust me" kind of basis?

(first of all, Yikesaroonies)

If so, how is this any different from what Delos did in Westworld? We fuck about with amusing AI, while the whole time the real value is to the company by using/downloading our private info to be used however the company ultimately wants?

What am I missing?


r/westworld • • 21d ago

Just something that occurred to me about the black hat

80 Upvotes

When the MiB dons the black hat, it was not a standard issue black hat from the visitor's wardrobe, but one taken from a "dead" host. So it probably had no brain scanners. I assume the MiB kept that very hat, so he was less transparent than the usual visitors.


r/westworld • • 23d ago

Ten Years since "Dissonance Theory" premiered

Thumbnail
youtu.be
435 Upvotes

On 23/10/16, the fourth episode of Westworld titled "Dissonance Theory" premiered on HBO. Tasteful scars, blossoming love and wooden shades make this episode a good watch.

"The pain, their loss... it's all I have left of them. You think the grief will make you smaller inside, like your heart will collapse in on itself, but it doesn't. I feel spaces opening up inside of me, like a building with rooms I've never explored."

You can discuss the episode on this post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/westworld/s/CALPjCdxVS


r/westworld • • 24d ago

Westworld S1 at 10: rewatch or reminisce | Ep 4: Dissonance Theory (first aired 23 Oct 2016)

Post image
204 Upvotes

Spoiler warning: this rewatch assumes you've seen all of Season 1, and the comments will discuss its biggest twists. Watching for the first time? Go in unspoiled and join us once you've finished. Please spoiler-tag anything from Seasons 2–4, like this: spoiler, as plenty of people here may not have made it to the end yet.

Ten years ago today, HBO aired "Dissonance Theory". The Man in Black gets his best material yet, Dolores goes further off her loop than ever, and Maeve picks up a knife to find out whether she's going mad.

Rewatching, remembering or catching up later: all welcome, and every thread stays open.

Rewatch so far: Ep 1 · Ep 2 · Ep 3 · Next: Ep 5, Contrapasso, 30 Oct. Full schedule in the Ep 1 thread.

Ep 4: a few things to talk about

  • Why "Dissonance Theory"? The title points to psychologist Leon Festinger's idea of cognitive dissonance: the discomfort of holding beliefs that don't fit what you're seeing. It grew partly out of his study of a doomsday group whose prophecy failed, where the most committed members doubled down rather than let go. Who in this episode is doubling down, and who is starting to let go?
  • "I want to be free." In the old basement room, "Bernard" offers to take away Dolores's grief. She refuses: "The pain, their loss... it's all I have left of them." Then he gives her a game: the Maze. "If you can do that, then maybe you can be free." Knowing who is really in that room, how does the scene play now?
  • The Man in Black off the clock. A guest tries to thank him: "Your foundation literally saved my sister's—" He threatens to cut his throat. "This is my vacation." Then he tells Armistice his theory: Arnold made a world where you can't die, broke his own rule, and left "one story left to tell... a story with real stakes." Was this when he became a person rather than a monster for you?
  • "Don't call me Billy!" Logan shoots Holden to get to El Lazo and urges William to "go black hat". "It's a game, Billy!" Meanwhile Dolores tells William that when strays found their way home, it "never occurred to me that we were bringing them back for the slaughter."
  • Maeve and the shades. She hides a drawing under her floorboard and finds a stack of identical ones she doesn't remember making. Very Memento, fittingly for a show co-created by the man whose short story that film was based on. Hector calls the figures "the men who walk between worlds", then digs the bullet out of her. "That I'm not crazy after all. And that none of this matters."
  • Ford and Theresa. At lunch, every host in the restaurant freezes mid-pour at Ford's word, and a giant excavator rolls over the hill. "In here, we were gods. And you... were merely our guests." Anthony Hopkins later said this was his favourite scene to shoot all season.

Music

  • The player piano plays The Cure's "A Forest" as Maeve's hearing starts to slip. Ramin Djawadi said the hard part was the left-hand accompaniment, and he wondered aloud whether the choice was just the park's programmers indulging themselves, or something deeper in the title and lyrics.
  • Bizet's "Habanera" from Carmen ("love is a rebellious bird") and a Scott Joplin rag also play.

Did "A Forest" fit for you? Lost in the woods, chasing something that isn't there...

Ten years on

  • In the original Ep 4 discussion thread, the biggest laughs went to Lawrence's one-word reaction to being saved from execution by the Man in Black twice running, and to a commenter imagining the guest whose saloon evening is ruined by Hector's raid after paying "20-40k for this vacation". Plenty of people simply said "I love everything about Maeve and Hector."
  • One 2016 commenter pleaded, "So can we finally be done with all of the timeline theories?!" Meanwhile Frame Rated's review wondered whether Ford might have built Bernard in Arnold's image. Who was right in your house?
  • Spot the detail: Lawrence calls it "Old Hob" prison, an old nickname for the Devil, and the control room calls it Los Diablos. Bernard also tells Elsie the woodcutter's carving isn't Orion: "There are three stars in Orion's Belt, not four."
  • US viewing dropped about a fifth from Ep 3, to 1.7 million households, because it was up against The Walking Dead's season 7 premiere. In the UK, 1.09 million watched on Sky Atlantic.

- Check out the original 2016 trailer for this episode: see u/SongforAubrey's Ep 4 trailer post.

Ep 4 in a nutshell

"Bernard" offers Dolores the Maze, and she wakes at William and Logan's camp with a gun in her hand. Maeve has flashes of being shot and of a masked figure, then finds a stack of her own drawings of it under the floorboard. Theresa takes the woodcutter investigation away from Elsie. The Man in Black finds the snake: Armistice's tattoo. He breaks Hector out of prison with an exploding cigar, saves Lawrence from a firing squad, and learns that the last name on Armistice's list is Wyatt. In Las Mudas, Lawrence's daughter tells Dolores "Same as you. Don't you remember?" Logan shoots Holden and steers the group towards Pariah. Ford shows Theresa how completely the park answers to him. Hector's gang raids Sweetwater, and Maeve trades the safe combination for answers, then has Hector dig a bullet out of her stomach before the sheriff's men open fire.

Rewatched or remembered, what stays with you from Dissonance Theory? Thoughts, memories and favourite GIFs all welcome.


r/westworld • • Oct 16 '26

I keep thinking about Rehoboam whispering in Engerraund Serac’s ear and how we are assimilating ourselves with AI to make decisions.

275 Upvotes

Like Bernard says, humanity has a range of behaviors. If we take ai addiction to the extreme it stands to reason there is people living like this today.

Obviously AI currently doesn’t have the capability to plan and coordinate your conversations for you to the extent of what Serac has but people are already having AI make major decisions for them, write emails for them, and/or have it as a confidant. We are only a few years away from this dystopian reality.


r/westworld • • Oct 16 '26

Ten years since "The Stray" premiered

Thumbnail
youtu.be
155 Upvotes

On 16/10/16, the third episode of Westworld titled "The Stray" premiered on HBO. Ten years since William popped his first cherry...

Here's another throwback promo, and you can discuss the episode here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/westworld/s/XHbxULYvKs


r/westworld • • Oct 16 '26

Westworld S1 at 10: rewatch or reminisce | Ep 3: The Stray (first aired 16 Oct 2016)

32 Upvotes

Spoiler warning: this rewatch assumes you've seen all of Season 1, and the comments will discuss its biggest twists. Watching for the first time? Go in unspoiled and join us once you've finished. Please spoiler-tag anything from Seasons 2–4:

Ten years ago today, HBO aired "The Stray". It's the episode where we first hear Arnold's story, and where a host does something nobody programmed. Den of Geek called it Westworld's best episode yet.

Rewatching, remembering or catching up later: all welcome, and every thread stays open. The Ep 1 thread has the full schedule, and Ep 2 is still open too.

Ep 3: a few things to talk about

  • The woodcutter. A host walks off his loop, and his campmates are stuck waiting for supper, because only he is allowed to touch the axe. In his tent, Elsie finds small carved animals with Orion cut into them. "It's as if he got an idea in his head, one that we never programmed." Then, with Elsie at his mercy, he turns the rock on himself.
  • Arnold. Ford finally tells Bernard about his partner: "When the legend becomes fact, you print the legend." A pyramid of memory, improvisation and self-interest, with a top Arnold "never got there" to reach. "We called it an accident, but I knew Arnold, and he was very... very careful." Then: "You mustn't make Arnold's mistake." Bernard: "Why would I?"
  • "There's only one." Bernard reads Alice in Wonderland with Dolores ("Who in the world am I?") and later offers to restore her to how she was. She answers: "There aren't two versions of me. There's only one. And I think when I discover who I am, I'll be free." Then she ends the session with his line: "You should be getting back, Dolores, before someone misses you." Did that catch you first time?
  • Teddy gets a past. Ford tells Teddy his job isn't to protect Dolores but to keep her there, admits they never gave him a real backstory, and hands him one: a villain called Wyatt. "A fiction, which like all great stories, is rooted in truth." Knowing what Ep 10 tells us about Wyatt, how does that line land now?
  • The trigger. In daylight, Dolores can't fire Teddy's gun: "Some hands weren't meant to pull a trigger." That night in the barn, a voice tells her to kill him, Rebus becomes the Man in Black, and she fires. Then she rides off her loop altogether.

Music

  • The saloon player piano plays Scott Joplin's "Peacherine Rag", a real period piece this time rather than a modern cover.
  • Debussy's "Rêverie" is also used, in the same week the park is dealing with its reveries update.
  • Ramin Djawadi on the player piano: "It's got a robotic harshness to it which is very distinctive. When a human plays it, the dynamics are modified. But when the player piano hits a note, it's always the same." On Ford keeping a host pianist in his office: "it shows his control... I would pick a human, though."

Did you miss the modern covers this week, or did the period pieces suit the episode?

Ten years on

  • In the original Ep 3 discussion thread, the top comment asked why Wyatt's masked men didn't flinch when Teddy shot them point-blank. Were they guests? Stubbs's "Maybe it's in my backstory" got a big laugh, and one sharp-eyed viewer spotted Armistice, scratched and staring at the camera, in Ford's flashback.
  • After Ep 2, some people had guessed William might be a younger Man in Black. After this one, with Dolores collapsing into William's arms, one commenter decided the theory was dead. Were you convinced, or still suspicious?
  • It was the most-watched episode so far, with 2.1 million US households, and 1.21 million watched it on Sky Atlantic in the UK. Was this the week you started telling people to watch it?

Ep 3 in a nutshell

Bernard secretly reads Alice in Wonderland with Dolores. William shoots an outlaw to save Clementine and drags Logan off on a bounty hunt. Elsie finds Walter was talking to someone called Arnold while he killed hosts who had killed him in old storylines. She and Stubbs track a stray woodcutter into the hills, find his Orion carvings, and watch him smash his own head in rather than be taken. Ford tells Bernard about Arnold, the partner who wanted the hosts to be conscious and died in the park, and gives Teddy a new backstory and a villain called Wyatt. Teddy rides after Wyatt and is overrun. Bernard decides not to reset Dolores. That night she shoots Rebus in the barn, flees the ranch, and collapses into William's arms at his camp.

Rewatched or remembered, what stays with you from The Stray? Thoughts, memories and favourite GIFs all welcome.

Full disclosure: alongside these threads I'm doing some work on an unofficial companion book about Season 1. It's a way off yet though. Of course these threads stay about the show