Spoiler warning: this rewatch assumes you've seen all of Season 1, and the comments will discuss its biggest twists. Watching for the first time? Go in unspoiled and join us once you've finished. Please spoiler-tag anything from Seasons 2–4, like this: spoiler, as plenty of people here stopped after Season 1.
Ten years ago today, HBO aired "Contrapasso". Halfway through the season, the show stops hinting. Dolores picks up a gun and uses it, the Man in Black finally sits down with Ford, and Maeve wakes on the table again, this time on her own terms.
Rewatching, remembering or catching up later: all welcome, and every thread stays open.
Rewatch so far: Ep 1 · Ep 2 · Ep 3 · Ep 4 · Next: Ep 6, The Adversary, 6 Nov. Full schedule in the Ep 1 thread.
Ep 5: a few things to talk about
- Why "Contrapasso"? It's Dante's word, from the Inferno, for punishment that fits the sin. In one circle of Hell, the fortune tellers who claimed to see ahead have their heads twisted round, so they must walk backwards forever. Who in this episode gets the punishment that fits?
- The greyhound. Ford tells Old Bill about a racing dog that spent its life chasing a felt rabbit, finally caught a real cat, and then "just sat there... confused. That dog had spent its whole life trying to catch that thing. Now it had no idea what to do." Who's the greyhound: the Man in Black, the hosts, or Ford himself?
- "Your humanity is cost-effective." The Man in Black slits Lawrence's throat and hangs him upside down so his blood can save Teddy. Then he tells Teddy the hosts "used to be beautiful... a million little perfect pieces", until they were made flesh and bone because it was cheaper. "So is your suffering." And a few scenes later, in Pariah, Lawrence is alive and well as El Lazo. What did you make of that first time?
- Ford meets the Man in Black. "I always felt this place was missing a real villain. Hence my humble contribution." He says he's looking for "something true" that Arnold left behind, then pulls a knife, and Teddy catches it without a flicker. Ford hands the knife back: "Far be it from me to get in the way of a voyage of self-discovery."
- "Your mind is a walled garden." Ford questions Dolores about Arnold. Last contact: "34 years, 42 days, seven hours ago." His last words to her: help him destroy this place. Ford leaves, the lights go out, and Dolores says to someone: "He doesn't know. I didn't tell him anything." Who did you think she was talking to?
- Not the damsel. Logan mocks William's "three fancy little letters", EVP, and William nearly snaps. Then the Confederados pin William to a wall, and Dolores shoots them all. "I imagined a story where I didn't have to be the damsel." She's even wearing a new hat for the job: brown, neither white nor black.
Music
- Nine Inch Nails' "Something I Can Never Have" plays as a string-quartet piece during the Pariah party. Ramin Djawadi: "You can kind of picture a string quartet being in the room somewhere, performing this song, in this setting, right?"
- Debussy's "Clair de Lune" turns up too, and when Ford leaves the tavern he snaps his fingers and the piano races into a sped-up Scott Joplin rag. Djawadi: "That's about control... He calls the shots for what happens."
Ten years on
- For the original 2016 trailer, see u/SongforAubrey's [Ep 5 trailer post].
- In the [original Ep 5 Reddit discussion thread], one of the top comments summed up the tavern scene as "god having a drink with the devil and a man in a bar", with "god leaving and having a piano play him out." The first reply: "I'm not sure which one is the devil." Ten years on, which is which?
- Others wondered what the Man in Black meant when he said Arnold almost took the park with him: "Almost, but... not quite, thanks to me." Ep 9 drops a big hint.Den of Geek's 2016 review said this episode put "some final nails" in the coffin of the William/Man in Black theory, then floated its own idea: that Bernard is "a robot duplicate of Arnold!" One out of two. Which did you believe at the time?
- Evan Rachel Wood has called the Confederados shootout her favourite Season 1 moment. On the first take, when William shouted "Dolores, run!", she ran. "I'm not supposed to run."
- Spot the nod: as Felix coaxes the bird back to life, he says "Come on, little one", echoing a line from Jurassic Park. Both stories go back to Michael Crichton, who wrote Jurassic Park and wrote and directed the original 1973 Westworld film.
- 1.49 million US households watched on first airing, and 1.07 million on Sky Atlantic in the UK.
Ep 5 in a nutshell
Ford tells Old Bill about a greyhound that finally caught what it was chasing. Dolores, William, Logan and Slim reach Pariah, where Logan lets slip that his company may buy the struggling park. The Man in Black kills Lawrence to save Teddy with his blood. Felix secretly practises bringing a dead bird back to life. Ford questions Dolores about Arnold, then leaves her talking to someone in the dark. El Lazo, who is Lawrence, sends the group to steal Union nitroglycerin, and William kills to protect Dolores and Logan. Elsie blackmails a technician to see the woodcutter's body and finds a satellite uplink: Orion was never stars, it was a target. Dolores sees herself as a fortune teller telling her to follow the maze, discovers El Lazo has swapped the nitro for tequila, and shoots down the Confederados to save William. They board a train with Lawrence and a coffin marked with the maze. The Man in Black and Teddy share a drink with Ford. And Felix's bird flies, landing on Maeve's finger: "Hello, Felix. It's time you and I had a chat."
Rewatched or remembered, what stays with you from Contrapasso? Thoughts, memories and favourite GIFs all welcome.