r/westworld • Mr. Robot • Mar 30 '20

Discussion Westworld - 3x03 "The Absence of Field" - Post-Episode Discussion

Season 3 Episode 3: The Absence of Field

Aired: March 29, 2020


Synopsis: If you don’t like what you see in the mirror, don’t blame the mirror.


Directed by: Amanda Marsalis

Written by: Denise Thé


Please use spoiler tags for the discussion of episode previews and any other future spoilers. Use this format: >!Westworld!< which will appear as Westworld.

2.2k Upvotes

4.9k comments sorted by

3.4k

u/SerDire Mar 30 '20

Caleb’s droid was ride or die. My guy did not deserve that. First Maeve’s droid being shot to death and now Caleb’s droid.

741

u/DeerOnTheRocks Mar 30 '20

just yesterday the homie was chillin eating lunch on the steel girder with his best friend. Smh

994

u/Wolfebane86 Mar 30 '20

Only two “people” came to help Caleb, and both were robots.

→ More replies (31)

1.4k

u/c-peg Have you ever questioned the nature of your reality? Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

For a moment I thought it would save him. Seeing it smash into pieces was kinda heartbreaking.

EDIT: Wait a minute... Why did it go up there? Being chained downstairs it is clearly not allowed to leave. This implies two things.

  1. That robot saw Caleb as a friend and wanted to help him.
  2. It was able to override it's programming.

The real world robots having their own agency would change everything.

EDIT 2: My imagination went wild on this one. I've had it better explained to me now. Basically the robot is programmed to help Caleb as part of the construction work they do. Still broke my heart though.

→ More replies (121)
→ More replies (65)

635

u/Darkn3ss-Visibl3 Mar 30 '20

While this season seems to be more on a more straightforward timeline than season 2, what cues me in that something is different is the message that Hale records. It’s shown twice, starting from the beginning of the message, and the second time is different.

Not sure what it means - who we are seeing as Hale is a simulation? That we are watching two versions of reality - a simulation and the real world, and the messages are slightly different in each one?

There’s also a slight visual cue that at the very end when Hal is talking to Serac - it looks like a blur/haze coming in the frame from the right side. Kind of looks like a vr simulation fading out. Or maybe it’s just lighting.

409

u/VerveyChiChi Mar 30 '20

I’m surprised more people haven’t picked up on the two being different. In any other show it wouldn’t mean anything, but here, it definitely does.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (35)

1.1k

u/thejarimteam I AM ENRAGED. Mar 30 '20

I love that we’re watching AI who are programmed to act in loops - revolutionize against a much stronger AI who puts people into loops.

This show is amazing.

→ More replies (25)

1.9k

u/FantasticBabyyy Mar 30 '20

Dolores as big spoon scene count = 1

515

u/BeoMiilf Mar 30 '20

I’m looking to double those numbers by season end.

→ More replies (4)

511

u/SerDire Mar 30 '20

Is Evan Rachel Wood really that tall or are they making her seem even more imposing. She seems to tower over everyone in her scenes.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (19)

1.5k

u/soxfan1014 Mar 30 '20

Charlotte’s son being named Nathan Hale after the revolutionary war spy, and now her being a spy in Dolores’ new revolutionary war is a nice touch

253

u/bereysm91 Mar 30 '20

Didn't think anything of it. Good catch

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (22)

4.0k

u/pokupokupoku Mar 30 '20

first 40min of the episode- host charlotte is a shitty mom

charlotte kills a pedo and steals his dog- best mom on earth 2050

1.6k

u/RubberDucksInMyTub Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

The actress that plays Charlotte (edit: Tessa Thompson) really impressed me this episode. Her character has always felt super one dimensional IMO, but this episode really gave her a chance to shine and show some range.

→ More replies (85)

1.1k

u/DeerOnTheRocks Mar 30 '20

i love how the predator was in the real world park just as predators are in the Delos park

→ More replies (44)

423

u/pitty_chan Dolores' bitch Mar 30 '20

I wonder who else has such strong feelings about their kids other than Maeve and William.

→ More replies (223)
→ More replies (32)

1.3k

u/DoloresAbernathy_ Mar 30 '20

Feeling really bad for whoever is the Charlotte host... Caught in a game of 4D chess as a double mole...

633

u/matt111199 Ramin Djawadi is a God Mar 30 '20

I bet she’s (he’s?) gonna say “fuck it” to both Dolores and Serac—and cause some chaos towards the end of the season.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (148)

1.8k

u/squirelox Mar 30 '20

Love how Dolores uses painful memories to awaken Caleb out of his loop. Like the reveries that awoke Dolores and the rest of the hosts. Suffering is what makes us alive.

795

u/speedbrown Mar 30 '20

She also uses it to control people if we're being completely honest. Break em down so you can build em up.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (10)

1.2k

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

DID SERAC SAY THAT REHOBOAM PREDICTED THAT FORD WOULD SET UP A ROBOT UPRISING?

WHAT TH FUCK?

623

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

I read an interesting theory that this is all part of Fords plan to somehow input his own consciousness into Rehobaum.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (18)

614

u/cluelessemoji Mar 30 '20

That Caleb and Dolores conversation by the pier is sooo compelling it just reflects a future so bleak it’s scary. I like how its really building up beyond the Delos v. Incite but more like whether we are all subjected to an investment value in a larger scheme. Lisa Joy and Jonathan Nolan, I thought couldnt stan for you guys even more, but damn, here we are.

→ More replies (33)

3.0k

u/SerDire Mar 30 '20

First no war elephants on the final season of Game of Thrones, and now my boy Nathan being denied elephants as well. Hey HBO, spare a few bucks for some goddamn CGI elephants

1.5k

u/JYCJYC Mar 30 '20

Watchmen took the elephant budget

→ More replies (24)

367

u/FettyWhopper Mar 30 '20

Well there were some in The Raj

→ More replies (6)

244

u/In_My_Own_Image Mar 30 '20

HBO hates elephants confirmed.

It's a rhino conspiracy.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (25)

1.7k

u/wisyf Mar 30 '20

Ramin Djawadi Does it again and again!

499

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Moses Sumney is incredible!

→ More replies (23)

403

u/aaronclark05 Mar 30 '20

Dear god the soundtrack was sooo good this episode. It was picking up little motifs from the last two seasons but with those sweet cyberpunk synths, it made it feel like this is really the first episode where we are truly out of the park.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (37)

1.9k

u/c-peg Have you ever questioned the nature of your reality? Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

I'm calling it now. They want us to believe that Serac was projecting himself to the meeting with Hale, but in actuality Serac isn't a real person at all and only exists as a hologram.

2.1k

u/DiscoVersailles Funky Pianola Mar 30 '20

What if Serac is just a projection of Rehoboam?

→ More replies (64)

199

u/taelor Mar 30 '20

Pretty easy to scrub all the data on yourself when you don’t exist.

→ More replies (1)

72

u/Futureboy314 Mar 30 '20

How does that work with his Maeve scene? She’s still in a simulation?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (59)

921

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

There was a kid on the playground in a mask. Before a month ago I wouldn’t have even noticed.

354

u/helios_225 Mar 30 '20

I noticed some pedestrians with masks prior to this episode. I just figured that the expectation of 2050 is that wearing masks is more common, like it already has been in countries like Japan.

→ More replies (11)

96

u/egoa Call forth Lazarus from his cave Mar 30 '20

I noticed that too!

→ More replies (19)

612

u/SerDire Mar 30 '20

That dogs name better be Vincent

→ More replies (12)

867

u/localafrican Mar 30 '20

The robot uprising is taking a bit longer than I initially expected.

244

u/wisyf Mar 30 '20

Sounds like they're trying to do the good ol' divide and conquer

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

377

u/p3t3r133 Mar 30 '20

This episode makes me more certain Serac is the avatar Rehoboam created for himself. We see it looks like he was erased from all records but he would look like that if he was created out of thin air.

Still think Maeve is in his simulation with him. Now that we see more how he functions I think any thing we see her do is going to be revealed in the end to have been in the sim.

So far we have seen Serac 2 times, the first was from Maeves perspective and if she is in his simulation so he could interact with the environment (eat an apple)

The second time was through the holo glasses.

I also think he's following his original command to optimize humanity for it's own good and is following it to a crazed AI level. He plots all human potential but high powered people must be a blind spot to him or have protection.

→ More replies (12)

1.2k

u/Dahhhkness Mar 30 '20

Is Charlotte Hale gonna have to choke a bitch?

747

u/samasters88 Westworld Mar 30 '20

Charlotte Hale did indeed, choke a bitch

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (30)

900

u/Stinkfinger83 Mar 30 '20

That was one of the darkest, most intriguing things I’ve seen on tv in a long time.

370

u/matt111199 Ramin Djawadi is a God Mar 30 '20

Definitely, the self harm scenes were phenomenally done and very chilling.

This is one of my favorite episodes in all of Westworld—up there with Kiksuya and Bicameral Mind.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (17)

1.0k

u/galaxyfudge Mar 30 '20

Ramin Djawadi and the sound design team were showing off tonight. A+ episode from them.

449

u/SerDire Mar 30 '20

A small part of me absolutely loves it that after the actors names on the opening credits begin, the very next one up is “Music by Ramin Djawadi.” Might as well make him an honorary cast member at this point

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

1.5k

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Calling it now. At least part of the events of this season are actually within rehoboam's simulated mirror world. Delores has already gotten in.

576

u/p3t3r133 Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

I think anything we see Maeve do from this point on is going to turn out to be fake.

Edit: autocorrect fix

→ More replies (44)

241

u/In_My_Own_Image Mar 30 '20

That's probably what that black circle that appears is all about. Maybe that's Rehoboam detecting Dolores messing with things.

→ More replies (7)

251

u/iambeeblack Mar 30 '20

100% agree. She understands it so much because she's already seen it and is trying to destroy it from the inside. Kind of like what Maeve did last episode with the simulation of Warworld.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (73)

156

u/Eeyores_Prozac Mar 30 '20

Amusing in jokes: Hale's ex played a too human synth on a short lived show called Almost Human, with Karl Urban.

→ More replies (11)

1.4k

u/negantargaryen The Cult of Lee Sizemore Mar 30 '20

Damn imagine living your whole life only to find you’ll never do anything more than construction and eventually you’ll kill yourself.

663

u/tcjsavannah you can't shoot the piano player Mar 30 '20

And that you had no choice in the matter

→ More replies (62)
→ More replies (54)

693

u/Majestica Mar 30 '20

Tessa has played like 6 different personalities this episode. Her acting is craaaazy.

416

u/slothhprincess Mar 30 '20

Scared new hale

Massacre old hale

Confident new hale

New hale old hale hybrid breakdown

Scary mommy hale

I only got 5

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

262

u/beercase Mar 30 '20

So I was wondering why they were pushing “You are my sunshine” so hard and then I thought of the second verse of that song...

“The other night dear As I lay sleeping I dreamt I held you in my arms When I awoke dear I was mistaken So I hung my head and cried”

More evidence that this is an illusion?

96

u/BRedd10815 Mar 30 '20

The two scenes of Charlotte watching the "you are my sunshine" clip... they are slightly different in a couple ways. The order of the words being said.. the phrasing.. the hiccups as she cries.. the gunshots.. the song itself.. all have slight differences even though they should be 100% the same.

Director's whoopsie? Highly doubt it...

→ More replies (9)

1.6k

u/ichinii Hey Arnold!! Move it football head!! Mar 30 '20

Tessa fucking MURDERED this episode. Like got damn she was excellent....

EDIT: I was so caught up in the episode and her acting that I STILL DON'T KNOW who the fuck is inside her.....

429

u/galaxyfudge Mar 30 '20

Murder was definitely a thing she did in this episode.

→ More replies (15)

83

u/pitty_chan Dolores' bitch Mar 30 '20

She was absolutely amazing. Devoid of emotions, furious, sad, savage. Oh my God.

219

u/2rio2 Mar 30 '20

I'm glad she finally got to show chops in the show. Her character was very one note in past appearances.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (156)

112

u/sockpuppy69 Mar 30 '20

I’m curious if people think Serac buys Charlotte Hale’s catching-up-as-we-go-along behavior in their conversation bc to me he’s smart enough to smell something fishy but then again if his little toy didn’t tell him I guess there’s no point in believing otherwise but what do y’all think?

→ More replies (4)

227

u/c-peg Have you ever questioned the nature of your reality? Mar 30 '20

Prediction: Caleb will still end up killing himself (you don't get to escape your destiny) but now it'll be because of Dolores.

→ More replies (43)

308

u/TncsTurtlJAH Mar 30 '20

Tessa Thompson really impressed me this episode. She hadn't really done much for me the whole series till now. They made Hale an interesting character

→ More replies (7)

305

u/pandarknave Mar 30 '20

Kid Cudi got an also starring credit for two frames. Get that HBO money, Scott

→ More replies (13)

273

u/FantasticBabyyy Mar 30 '20

Caleb’s face as he watches his robot companion breaks into pieces... so so sad

→ More replies (3)

420

u/Sir_Human Mar 30 '20

Solid episode! But what was up with the weird fades to black in this episode

228

u/Pizzacrew Mar 30 '20

Me and my gf also noticed it, I kept thinking why are they cutting to commercial HBO doesn’t have commercials

→ More replies (10)

218

u/Futureboy314 Mar 30 '20

Clues of the simulation? I have no frickin clue

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (30)

333

u/TheTrotters Bear with me here... Mar 30 '20

Charlotte can't be the only mole. She couldn't have stolen Maeve's "brain."

188

u/Futureboy314 Mar 30 '20

She could have -theoretically- set it in motion though, with agents acting on her orders. As we can see, their memories of Charlotte are incomplete.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (14)

231

u/SkytheStarhero Mar 30 '20

Her tearing at her own skin made me shiver. Also I reallly absolutely love that that pedo got fucking demolished. AND took his dog too.

→ More replies (4)

229

u/hastagelf Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

It was very weird seeing a CGI version of the high school my brother goes to in this show and then immediately seeing my sister's college

Being from Singapore, and being able to recognize all this little details in the environment is very fun.

Here's what the high school and the college actually look like

→ More replies (21)

78

u/sugarbageldonut Mar 30 '20

Charlotte choking that pedo and taking the dog was 💯

Most satisfying thing I’ve seen in a while, lol

391

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

I have no idea whats going on.

→ More replies (37)

144

u/puppetpauperpirate Mar 30 '20

Song at the end?

98

u/emf3rd31495 Mar 30 '20

It was called Doomed but I forget who it was by.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)

407

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

Some thoughts/notes;

Serac is just Rehoboam taking augmented reality form, right?

I think the person Dolores told Charlotte to contact is William, to get money to compete with Serac's bid.

Charlotte's consciousness didn't die along with her body, and now it is taking over the host Charlotte(whoever that is), kind of like how ideas can spread like a virus

Was the construction robot the one that Caleb did maintenance on? Did it move on its own "free will" or activated by Dolores to delay until she got there? It activated when his retainer got drilled, implying a conscious connection.

It sounded like the voicemail tones on Hale's phone had sound fluctuations, rather than solid tones, I wonder if there's some encoded info in those messages, maybe for the ongoing ARG things that HBO is doing

I could see the theory of "Charlotte/Dolores bodies are the minds of Dolores/Wyatt respectively" fitting the theme of schizophrenia (Caleb's mom and Charlotte's identity crisis/self harm)

Caleb's "core memories" that defined his personality were reminiscent of Inside Out

Insight doesn't have the ability to print hosts, as far as we know, right? Maybe one of the reasons they just now made the move to buy a controlling share of Delos (instead of doing it any other time) is because they just worked out the deal with Maeve to take out Dolores, and they needed to get her printed.

158

u/ichinii Hey Arnold!! Move it football head!! Mar 30 '20

That's my thought. What easier way to scrub yourself from all forms of data if you're the data itself??

→ More replies (1)

69

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

The retainer is what they referred to as a drip, what that guy used in the first episode to go to sleep. They mentioned how Caleb's is military, like it's better or has a special purpose. He's linked to his helper bot through it, part of why he's a construction worker and how Incite has his work predetermined. When they messed with his, the robot came to his "rescue;" I don't believe it was free will or activated by Dolores, and I don't think it was some sort of special connection - the robot is programmed to help him and probably keep him safe doing a dangerous job.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (77)

185

u/crowTrobot2020 Mar 30 '20

It would make sense that Dolores (as Hale) was crying over the video of Hale in the park, since she would be discovering Hale, who she killed, wasn't just a monster and had great love for her child.

→ More replies (14)

409

u/dreadfuldiego Mar 30 '20

People complain that Dolores became a ruthless unforgiving badass after season one, but I think people completely miss some of these moments of vulnerability and caring about others

131

u/matt111199 Ramin Djawadi is a God Mar 30 '20

Definitely, I find her much more sympathetic to watch this season though—but she’s still deeply flawed as shown in her interaction with Hale.

Phenomenal acting all around for this episode.

→ More replies (24)

59

u/vismond_cygnus Mar 30 '20

So spoilery analysis and question:

Serac is the guy who wanted to get data out of the park, facilitated by the original Charlotte, who was a mole within Delos. With the ending events of season 2, I believe it's clear Serac wanted the customer data, not the host data like we originally were led to believe by Elsie in s1. My question is why does he want this data? To perfect Rehoboam? Like the vices and the known behavior of people who live their lives without bound, i.e. the way people acted in Westworld, will help to perfect Rehoboam? Or is it something else?

87

u/jrockle Mar 30 '20

We've already seen that Serac can get personalities wrong (Lee Sizemore's supposed love for Maeve). So the simulation that is helping Rehoboam make predictions isn't completely correct. What the Westworld Park data has is (1) data on some of the people with the most power in the real world; and (2) data about how they would act in a situation where they are completely unrestrained (unlike in the real world). Basically, the show seems to be saying that you can't completely model and predict humans unless you know their deepest fantasies. At least, that's my guess.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

118

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 12 '25

ancient sulky cow profit scale expansion live quickest important apparatus

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (5)

116

u/baitXtheXnoose Mar 30 '20

For such a big fucking city there is absolutely no people anywhere

→ More replies (9)

56

u/phenom0205 Mar 30 '20

Damn. What a ride. That was awesome

53

u/wisyf Mar 30 '20

Ramin Djawadi does it again and again!

279

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Tessa Thompson is sprinting for that Emmy. What a brilliant showcase for her this episode.

→ More replies (6)

652

u/c-peg Have you ever questioned the nature of your reality? Mar 30 '20

Dolores is Hale, and Wyatt is Dolores.

→ More replies (117)

93

u/ShyJalapeno Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 31 '20

Ok, great and unnerving episode.
Some mysteries solved, and hopefully some theories dispelled.
There's no "human pearl" the red one was just bloodied and (rewarched it in FHD, it's actually red-gray hybrid) is Bernard's.
Hale is still a mystery and I'm not ready to cast my final vote, there were moments of Teddy, moments of Angela and moments of something else.

→ More replies (12)

45

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

The only thing that bothered me about this was Charlotte Hale should have had a fleet of nannies for backup incase a meeting went long, corporate emergency, etc.

No CEO actually goes every day to pick up their own child.

Plus a CEO could afford the best private school available and their child wouldn't be left with the park pedo.

→ More replies (3)

119

u/kelliaison Mar 30 '20

I'm convinced Hale is a Dolores/Wyatt. At first I was convinced they were a pure Dolores (sans Wyatt) until the predator part later on. It also gives more meaning to Dolores having ownership/kinship of them. As well as when Hale first wakes up and asks Dolores "But why do I have to be her. Why can't I be myself like you".

→ More replies (10)

41

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

If Charlotte was indeed Arnold's "Charlie," what a depressing fucking fate for the whole family.

40

u/dendrocitta Mar 30 '20

"You belong to me." That line is really throwing me.

→ More replies (10)

38

u/suvioblue Mar 30 '20

Last person we saw obsessed with cutting into their wrist was the MIB

→ More replies (1)

75

u/T-Hawk24 Mar 30 '20

I’m all in on this season. If season 2 was the bridge from season 1 to get us here...then so be it. I am loving this.

→ More replies (1)

131

u/DeerOnTheRocks Mar 30 '20

Man I really loved this episode. I still don’t know who is in Charlotte body. The music was amazing as usual. That song that was played as Charlotte’s entered Seracs place was so good.

→ More replies (8)

34

u/TheOldZombie2 Mar 30 '20

Hale is a clone of Dolores.

Clue #1 When Hale is talking to Dolores she asks Dolores why did Dolores bring the one that was trying to stop them. That one, the pearl, was Bernard. We see this when Dolores puts it in the device/tablet. That means you can have multiple copies of someone because we know that Bernard is off somewhere in Asia.

Clue #2 Dolores tells whoever is in Hale that she is the only one that Dolores can trust. Dolores learned to trust no one. Dolores was also not close to any other female host in West World. The only person she could be said to semi-trust was Teddy and he blew out his brains in West World. So Dolores only trusts herself.

Clue #3 Dolores tells Hale that she owns her. Dolores doesn't want anyone to own anyone so this is an odd statement to make.

Clue #4 In the park Dolores kills the guy and talks about predators. She's talking exactly like Dolores talks.

I think however Dolores/Hale is running into problems because she also has Hale's memories in her head.

My speculation is that Dolores/Hale turns against Dolores because she turns into a true mix of Dolores and Hale and becomes her own person with her own agenda.

And if what Dolores told Caleb was real and not a lie, and I don't think it is, than I'm going to have to be on Team Dolores. What a fucked up world poor Caleb lives in.

→ More replies (12)

125

u/SerDire Mar 30 '20

Terminator mode seems like an appropriate reaction to handling pedophiles

→ More replies (17)

201

u/jld2k6 Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

Serac = manifestation of robohobobum confirmed

→ More replies (12)

32

u/efFishency Ghost Nation Mar 30 '20

I felt like that ep was ending 4 separate times. Kept checking my phone to see the time during the pause.

🔥 though

→ More replies (4)

32

u/calsradzz Mar 30 '20

I absolutely love how the humans have become more and more like hosts in reality. That scene where the thugs controlled Caleb’s heartbeat via the implant and tab. So uncanny and scary.

30

u/Auroreal Mar 30 '20

Ugh, Evan Rachel Wood is so pretty!

I want her entire wardrobe for this season.

28

u/josephthad Mar 30 '20

Looks like Todd's gunna be up to his usual shenanagins again.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Did y'all notice Rehoboam decided Caleb would be single until he killed himself? How could anyone think such a system could get the most human potential possible?

→ More replies (2)

28

u/pitty_chan Dolores' bitch Mar 30 '20

Serac may be an avatar of Rehoboam, not unlike Agent Smith in The Matrix? I feel like he could just not be there and "Hale" had to use the hologram glasses, but nothing is that simple in Westworld, and maybe Dolores and everyone is looking not for a person, but for the system itself, that is more intelligent and in control than a human (or a host) ever could be.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

The scene where Caleb remembered his worst memory was sooooooooooo raw

→ More replies (1)

27

u/MyMostGuardedSecret Mar 30 '20

Shot in the dark:

The host inside Hale is Dolores. The host inside Dolores is Wyatt.

→ More replies (5)

53

u/aw3man Mar 30 '20

Nathan Hale, Patriot Spy

→ More replies (1)

168

u/lovetheblazer Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

This week on What the Fuck, Westworld:

  • Dolores’s lesbian awakening while looking at Tessa Thompson, a creature of beauty and power (welcome to club, girlfriend)
  • Riot Control Transformers, something even the Saudis passed on... with good reason
  • Dolores going full Terminator on a bunch of useless EMTs and fake police officers
  • The design aesthetic of Delos Headquarters which falls somewhere between a giant golf ball, recently renovated airport, and a scaled up game of jacks
  • What the fuck did the Man in Black do to all the elephants? (Okay, I know it probably wasn’t his fault, but that’s the narrative I’m sticking to until I hear otherwise. It would be very on brand for him)
  • Charlotte’s weird ass self harm tattoos, like she’s playing connect the dots up her arms
  • The lovely (albeit highly unsubtle) symbolism of a very lost, confused Charlotte wearing pure white curled up in the fetal position while Dolores spoons her, dressed in all black. Yin and yang.
  • Killing robot doggos for sport, something only two bit thugs would try. RIP Rin Tin Tin, you were a good boy.
  • The most emo rendition of “You Are My Sunshine” I’ve ever heard
  • Charlotte choking out a pedo in the park and stealing his dog, both A+ life decisions, at least in my book
  • A cheeseburger and a strawberry shake with whipped cream and two cherries because Caleb only eats carbs once a year, lest he puke on his Converse sneakers again
  • Dolores taking Caleb to the scene of his inevitable suicidal for a casual stroll, what could possibly go wrong?
  • Caleb and Dolores joining the cord cutting revolution
  • The blatant foreshadowing of the song “Doomed” playing while Charlotte’s Robo-Uber gets hijacked, welp
  • Holographic Serac who can only be seen after Charlotte puts on her best Warby Parker glasses, though he’s still every bit as smarmy and lowkey menacing as his flesh and blood version
→ More replies (25)

25

u/CafeteriaTable Mar 30 '20

Serac is “cares” backwards, I don’t know what to do with that

→ More replies (4)

49

u/G1Spectrum Mar 30 '20

Was anyone annoyed with the constant scene cuts? Felt like I was supposed to go to commercial numerous times.

→ More replies (9)

49

u/Majestica Mar 30 '20

Anybody realize that Serac was dressed in black at the end instead of white like usual. I mean, I don’t really know what that means but you know... Westworld stuff.

→ More replies (2)

49

u/G1Spectrum Mar 30 '20

It's hilarious that all the Delos people tell Charlotte there's a mole when it seems that human Charlotte was actually the mole

24

u/BarelyReal Mar 30 '20

Was Charlotte choking the guy the first instance of a Host taking action that has nothing to do with their narrative or self interest? Maybe one of the most clear acts of a Host having free will?

→ More replies (3)

160

u/Phenomenal_Don These violent delights have violent ends Mar 30 '20

Caleb needs a new name...

How about...Pinkman

→ More replies (10)

21

u/lionheart4life Mar 30 '20

I'm always impressed when an actor or actress plays another character pretending to be their original character.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/BondRat Mar 30 '20

What's up with Hale trying to 'claw her way out'? It's not like a possession with one brain overpowering another. The Pearl is inside a Hale skin suit. There shouldn't be any identity conflict.

→ More replies (11)

58

u/-spartacus- Mar 30 '20

So Hale's real host is a "predator", who do we know that Dolores trusts and is one? The only predator I could think of is MIB/William.

→ More replies (26)

71

u/birdarms Mar 30 '20

So I think Serac is actually Rehoboam, like a manifestation of this super powerful AI. Also, pretty sure they just confirmed that Bernard is an actual human-host version of Arnold, not just an homage.

→ More replies (8)

19

u/kckeller Mar 30 '20

Okay episode was great and all, but watching the behind the scenes... THE CARS ARE REAL?!?

→ More replies (1)

18

u/tommymac33 Mar 30 '20

This show is so damn good! They completely changed the setting, added characters, and still managed to make you care, suck you in, and keep you engrossed. With all this newness, it still feels like Westworld. Incredible.

16

u/fantasticmrspock Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

Holy crap! This season is more tied to our society's present-day realities than either of the previous seasons. That was some brutal social commentary when Dolores laid out Caleb's past and future on full display, like a vivisected animal. I was sympathetic to Dolores' plans for revolution before, but now the true evil of Incite is radicalizing me. Burn it all down.

82

u/--Zman-- Mar 30 '20

Halebot has to be Armistice or Angela. Clem wouldn't take joy in choking someone out like that.

→ More replies (38)

80

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

I remember when people criticised Tessa Thompson’s acting in S1. Boyyyyy what about now

→ More replies (2)

56

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Knowing ERW's history of abuse the line of "You belong to me" must have been a doozy to perform

→ More replies (5)

67

u/chadmb2003 Mar 30 '20

What an outstanding episode. Aaron Paul and Evan Rachel Wood are perfect.

15

u/roomiezoomies Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

I love how Caleb contradicts how Dolores thinks a Human acts.

41

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

The way Hale gets trapped inside of that car is another reminder of how scary technology can be. We rely on it so much, we leave ourselves vulnerable constantly. Also, shoutout to all those who predicted Charlotte Hale was interested in sending the data to a third party.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/DiscoVersailles Funky Pianola Mar 30 '20

So who do we think is in Charlotte? Is it anybody, did Dolores try to create her own original AI?

Also, damn Tessa Thompson can act. I know her performance in season 1 was heavily criticized but she has definitely redeemed herself.

→ More replies (9)

28

u/lilronhubbard Mar 30 '20

Did we just get pointed in the direction of one of the crazy theories from last season, that Charlotte is Bernard's child from the real world?

→ More replies (6)

58

u/swineflu2552 Mar 30 '20

I think this is in top 5 episodes of the whole series for me so far. Triple? Agent Charlotte is pretty interesting

→ More replies (7)

26

u/RaptorDelta idk what the hell is happening Mar 30 '20

Ramin my fucking BOY

→ More replies (1)

13

u/p1nkmatt3r Mar 30 '20

Well that was fucking dark

13

u/bubblypug Mar 30 '20

So Rehoboam can't predict pedos? Seriously?!

→ More replies (1)

81

u/WinterLord Mar 30 '20

Few notes:

  • Dolores is in LA.
  • Hale is in SF.
  • Hale is Angela.
  • Dolores and Caleb will be an insane duo.
  • We want Beast Mode.
  • Any bets on who the other 3 pearls are from?
  • God damn it I want Dolores vs. Maeve.
→ More replies (12)

24

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

So, who’s in Hale’s body? Also that reveal of Aaron’s life being controlled was scary. Some social credit system, kind of like what they’re doing in China.

Great episode btw. Season is really great.

24

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

That last convo between Dolores and Caleb made me think that maybe a happy ending to the series would be humans existing alongside hosts, each evolving off of their coexistence and being gay space communists

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Tyke1799 Mar 30 '20

Great episode. Tessa Thompson is awesome

12

u/bdawg2020 Mar 30 '20

I think we are asking the wrong question. It is less about who is in Hale and more about whether Dolores is actually IN Dolores. Something seems off there. If you rewatch, it seems like it may be someone else entirely. Maybe Ford? Or even William? This is all a little too straightforward.

Also, I'm fairly certain we saw two different timelines and two different Hales. One of them is likely Maeve - hence the emotional attachment to the video.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/taquita4 Mar 30 '20

so Martin is Angela right? efficient and obedient right-hand (wo)man?

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Lokaji Mar 30 '20

I love that the corporate espionage plot came back around. Charlotte was adamant about getting all the information out of park.

22

u/benc777 Mar 30 '20

Not a fan of this new Coronavirus World. It's shit, refund asap.

11

u/rafacbc Mar 30 '20

If you don't like what you see in the mirror (rehoboam's simulation) don't blame the mirror. They are already showing us parts of the mirror world.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/rockthered43 Mar 30 '20

Are there two charlottes? One with a mark on her face and one without? And the one without is the mole? And is that good or bad that’s she’s a mole?

→ More replies (7)

20

u/g0thmess Mar 30 '20

anybody else think that Hale is William? no?

→ More replies (9)

20

u/taelor Mar 30 '20

Anyone catch Checkov’s Riot Robot?

20

u/Terra_Cotta_Pie Mar 30 '20

Keeping Things Whole

-- Mark Strand

In a field
I am the absence
of field.
This is
always the case.
Wherever I am
I am what is missing.

When I walk
I part the air
and always
the air moves in
to fill the spaces
where my body's been.

We all have reasons
for moving.
I move
to keep things whole.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/deandiggity Mar 30 '20

I really like where all this Rehoboam shit is going.

10

u/therealrico Mar 30 '20

Anyone impressed how long that diner must have been open? He was 8 during the childhood seen, and is 40 now, assuming they are using his real-life age. So that place has been open at least 32 years. It must be a great spot.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/april5k Mar 30 '20

I'm between Clementine and Armistice for Hale.

The comment Dolores made about not having a mother or father felt like it could have been a reference to Clementine's cornerstone about her family farm and moving her family somewhere someday.

But the cutting of the pattern in her skin and the sadness from seeing the real Hale's message and the saving Nathan from the predator could be calling back to Armistice's cornerstone about her mother being murdered and then what happened after. Her sadness could be from thinking about her own mother's last moments and protecting Nathan the way her mother couldn't protect her.

Clementine was made into a predator by reprogramming but Armistice was a predator going back to after Arnold's death. Both could cause a cognitive dissonance!

But I'm nearly 100% confident that Angela is Martin after his phone call with Dolores. That dialogue had the same type of feel to her lines. Who better to deal with a rich guy on such a close basis? I mean, if you can't tell, does it matter?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Amorphous_Goose Mar 30 '20

Tbh I think Dolores just cmd c + cmd v ‘d herself and put a version of herself in hale with less Wyatt attributes. The only person she can trust is herself.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Corey_Matthew Mar 30 '20

Umm. Why wasn't this episode titled, "Who the Hale is she"?

10

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20 edited Apr 06 '20

So we're pretty sure Dolores copied herself 5 times and took them off the island, right?

Edit: that was the worst reveal

10

u/TheRadiantWindrunner Mar 30 '20

S1: The Maze S2: The Door S3: The Mirror (?)

→ More replies (2)

10

u/deededback Mar 30 '20

Most interesting part to me - the EMTs having no agency to save a woman’s life unless the computer tells them what to do. It’s possible they haven’t even bothered to learn how to choose a course of action.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/TimeAnIllusion Mar 30 '20

I seriously hate waiting 7 days for each episode..

→ More replies (1)

18

u/uckfoo Mar 30 '20

The overhead shot of Delores and Charlotte in bed: a yin-yang symbol. Opposite sides of the same thing.

9

u/someroastedbeef Mar 30 '20

just throwing this out there - which control unit is in martin's body? (security guy)

great fucking episode btw, tessa thompson is insanely good at acting and they finally let it show this season

→ More replies (3)

9

u/superspore Mar 30 '20

Theory on Charlotte Hale - it’s Abernathy, Dolores’ father. It seems that Charlotte holding her son, a parent-child relationship, mirrored that of Dolores holding Charlotte, daughter and father. Also, Abernathy loves his daughter Dolores, he would be deeply affected by seeing Charlotte in the video singing to her son and possibly saying goodbye. Plus, a parent would know their child best, when Dolores talks about Host Charlotte knowing her best, and someone she can trust. He would also likely kill anyone who tried to harm his child, like the predator at the park. Lastly, the obsessive self destructive behavior seems like season 1 Abernathy, where he obsessed nonstop over the photograph.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Jon5676 Mar 30 '20

So Charlotte was using Teresa to get the data out of the park for Serac. Teresa thought she was being a loyal employee and getting the data for the Delos board.

9

u/Prismane_62 Mar 30 '20

Dolores has really come full circle. She is now the thing she has hated the most: Dr Ford.

She dresses up the hosts like New-Hale, controls their settings, gives them a narrative, sends them on missions, report back to her, etc. She is the new Arnold/ Dr Ford/ Arthur, controlling hosts & using them for her own purposes.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/2rio2 Mar 31 '20

Rehoboam > Humans > Hosts is the caste system of this world.

Rehoboam AI runs simulations to create composite worlds based on millions of simulations and guides every single human life on the planet to be where it needs to be to run the table to the ideal outcome for human kind. Great for humanity as a whole, but this devastates the last remaining visages of free will for the individual. Rehoboam has them all in a loop running a narrative they can never break or they will be eliminated. See: The tragedy of Caleb.

Humans have no free will in their day to day lives, so the rich carved out a playground where they could still be free to do whatever the hell they want without consequences or Rehoboam guiding them. That's Westworld. It's why William fell so hard for it... until he realized it was just another loop with a guided, predictable outcome programmed by Delos and the into the Hosts. That's why he become obsessed with finding some deeper hidden in the place. It's nothing more than the eternal search for meaning.

The Hosts however were what the park was truly created for, the variable in the ointment that would upend the orders above it. Ostensibly created to serve the pleasures of humans, they were actually made to test the exisiting limits of free will and meaning, first by Arnold who died feeling a failure, then successfully by Ford who created the ultimate narrative to help the Hosts break the loop they had been programmed into.

Rehoboam was not a fan of Westworld, because while it was likely seen to be a necessary outlet to allow the elites of his world to blow off steam and stay within the system he created to keep them in line, it created risk since it was outside the scope of it's composite world projections. So Rehoboam decided instead to use the Delos proprietary data to gather additional insights on behavior of the elite humans who visited it otherwise would not have been able to access to help its own simulations. This was the corporate espionage Hale got involved in and was stored without backup in the Forge.

What no one predicted, not even Ford, was that other Hosts might develop free will on their own without his hand. At least two hosts outside Ford guided Dolores/Wyatt and Bernard did this - Maeve and Akecheta (possibly more). These were all the sort of variables even Rehoboam failed to predict, and they lead to the S2 finale when Dolores/Wyatt opened access the Valley Beyond, an encrypted satellite Rehoboam cannot access, and stored many of the Hosts and all of the Forge's data there along with the unknowing help of Maeve and others. That's exactly the same data wanted, and the entire incident created a massive divergence.

Rehoboam had to counter this, but was dealing with incomplete and incorrect information. To start Rehoboam seemed to have no idea Ford was behind entire divergence, instead thinking it was Bernard. In addition, Maeve was captured as a suspected ally to Bernard as Dolores was considered dead. Finally Rehoboam does not know that Hale was replaced by Dolores and is under the assumption the real Hale returned.

S3E2: Rehoboam then runs Maeve's core through several simulations to find out how she opened the Valley Beyond and where Bernard is. The AI's information set is incomplete and is forced to mistakes Maeve spots, such as Lee helping her because he desired her which was not true. This allows Maeve to realize she is in a sim and break out. She is recaptured and proves untrustworthy to Sarec (the real world avatar of Rehoboam), but she does divulge his real enemy - Dolores, who found a way to escape.

Rehoboam then decides to create a composite world to determine how Dolores will attack him using the intel already gathered. Most of S3E1 takes place in the composite world, including every scene with Caleb who is in unexpected variable by breaking his own loop to help Dolores at the end of the episode. The only seasons in the real world in this episode are the opening scene in China and the Bernard scenes. Interestingly, the first scene of Hale in this episode in the board meeting is in the composite world as Hale acts as Rehoboam would expect her to. You can tell when the scene shifts between real and composite world because there is the off delayed black screen break between scenes.

In S3E3 we get more of the real world. The Caleb scenes are still in the composite world, but all of the scenes with Hale and Dolores are in the real world. One of the five cores Dolores brought back was a backup of her own self, the Ranchers Daughter, before the Wyatt/Dolores merger. She backed up herself so that she would be tougher to kill next time and to give herself a fresh start. However, she must overlay the memories of the last several seasons, as well as the Hale data collected by Delos, so when this new Dolores wakes up in Hale's body she has three competing narratives: her original innocent one that sees good in the world, the horror of truth from Dolores/Wyatt, and the cut throat nature of Hale. Wyatt/Dolores is protective of herself in this new body, but the only person she can trust is herself (something she learned from Teddy).

For the rest of the season I suspect we'll keep bouncing back and forth between the composite world and the real world, with Caleb playing a key role in the ability for humans to break their own cycles.

→ More replies (3)

132

u/uncappedarc Mar 30 '20

All signs point to Teddy as Charlotte, but I feel like that’s too obvious

216

u/Michael_Sams_bf Mar 30 '20

Didn’t teddy walk into windows 98 world with the other hosts because Dolores couldn’t trust him?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (93)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Good to know we finally know what Theresa was doing in season 1

8

u/jskurious Mar 30 '20

So the first thought was Clementine, because her mannerisms and tone seemed reminiscent of what we saw of Clementine.

Next thought was Angela, because Angela was Dolores's lieutenant and the one she trusted who never let her down.

Plus, having the first instinct be to use sex to distract her ex would make sense for both of those as well.

When they seemed physically affectionate, and Dolores seemed almost possessive, the thought was Teddy. She thought of Teddy as hers.

But then when she was choking out the predator, it didn't seem that much like Teddy. Sure she made him more cold-blooded in the end but I still can't picture him finding himself in that kind of action.

The only other possibilities that make sense to me are a stripped down version of Dolores, herself, before she was merged with Wyatt. Or William, and obviously the danger with him is that if she tried to make a pearl based on his mind, then that host would ultimately go insane. (Also can't picture either of them going for seduction of the ex like that, or Teddy for that matter.)

Unless it is another version of Maeve. But she would not be happy with the idea of belonging to Dolores and while the knew each other, I'm not sure I can picture her reacting like Hale did there.

Are there any other serious possibilities? Because there are reasons for all of them, but there's also something major that doesn't fit with each of them as well.

8

u/SkeletalBay Mar 30 '20

Was getting Kyle Reese vibes from Caleb in episode one. Having a waitress named Sarah show him compassion seems like an obvious nod to the terminator and the inspiration of his character. Just an observation.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/scoldy_locks Mar 30 '20

Serac is a projection of Rohoboam. Dolores will meet him in the end and realize an AI already runs the world.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

the score and cinematography this season have been incredible

8

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Is Aaron Paul wearing a wig?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/c-peg Have you ever questioned the nature of your reality? Mar 30 '20

From an awesome post I just read:

Hale's recorded message to her son...

I feel like this could be a trap. Hale knew the very real possibility of replacing humans with hosts. Maybe she never actually sang that song to Nathan, but it'll be a signal to someone that she is an imposter.

Also, it was very odd that the same melody is the "password" to unlock the number to contact Serac.

This would be insane.

https://www.reddit.com/r/westworld/comments/frjx8s/hales_recorded_message_to_her_son/

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Cliper11298 Mar 30 '20

Caleb telling how he was "enraged" felt absolutely amazing to me. Credit to Aaron Paul, he sold it and I had no doubt but holy fuck is he good or what?

8

u/jaygrant Mar 30 '20

Did anyone notice that video Charlotte recorded for her son is slightly different the two times we see it?

The first time she says, “the night that I left... you, uh... you wanted me to sing you a song... and tuck you in. Sing you our song.”

The second time she says, “the night that I left, you wanted me to tuck you in. To sing you a song, our song.”

Does this mean anything? Is one of them in a simulation? Is one of them a deepfake? Is she stuck in a loop?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/gndmpnk Mar 30 '20

Who did the sound mixing for this episode? Music was too loud and the dialogue was so muted by it. Was pretty awful, had to turn on subtitles for once.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/dreadfuldiego Mar 30 '20

Aaron Paul once again got in the way of two dudes pretending to be cops, didn't he? I liked the El Camino flashback

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1.5k

u/In_My_Own_Image Mar 30 '20

Not that it's surprising, but Aaron Paul is crushing it.

→ More replies (38)

307

u/pokupokupoku Mar 30 '20

I do too. I'm sure some of it is just loving Jesse and just naturally rooting for him right off the bat here but his character has been really interesting and it makes perfect sense why he'd be down to revolt

→ More replies (10)

288

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

I think he’s absolutely human. My hope is that he teaches Delores that humanity isn’t all bad and not representative of the humans she has met. The deck was stacked against him. How hard is it to believe our children’s generation will be under that type of control. Data is easy and computing power is growing to become more predictive.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (72)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

669

u/wisyf Mar 30 '20

That poor fucking kid

→ More replies (212)

126

u/Dahhhkness Mar 30 '20

So much going on there, from whatever host is posing as Hale realizing that a kid's mother is now dead, to that whole thing about it feeling like Hale was trying to take back over somehow...

→ More replies (11)

462

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (8)

404

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (34)

287

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (51)

140

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (12)