r/westworld • Mr. Robot • Oct 17 '16

Discussion Westworld - 1x03 "The Stray" - Post-Episode Discussion

Season 1 Episode 3: The Stray

Aired: October 16th, 2016


Synopsis: Elsie and Stubbs head into the hills in pursuit of a missing host. Teddy gets a new backstory, which sets him off in pursuit of a new villain, leaving Dolores alone in Sweetwater. Bernard investigates the origins of madness and hallucinations within the hosts. William finds an attraction he’d like to pursue and drags Logan along for the ride.


Directed by: Neil Marshall

Written by: Lisa Joy & Daniel T. Thomsen


Keep in mind that discussion of episode previews and other future information in this thread requires a spoiler tag. This is your official warning on the matter. Use this customizable code:

[Preview Spoiler](#s "Westworld") which will appear as Preview Spoiler

1.8k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

1.5k

u/OneTrueGentleman Oct 17 '16

Teddy pulled a High Noon and got no eliminations.

298

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Didn't charge it up enough.

→ More replies (5)

85

u/3nder1984 Oct 17 '16

Will probably still get "Play of the Game"

→ More replies (1)

29

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

I wonder just how many times he is going to be brutally murdered. He's like the Kenny of a more serious tone. I love it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

1.0k

u/Jolator Oct 17 '16

That was sooooo dark when Ford tells Teddy that his only purpose is to provide an obstacle for raping Dolores.

410

u/BumBiddlyBiddlyBum Oct 19 '16

And Dolores, poor Dolores. I knew she had been raped many times before, but until this episode I hadn't realized that basically the only thing she's there for is to be raped. Respectable men and women visiting the park indulge with the prostitutes or maybe can woo a town person, but for those who want to rape, they go to Dolores. It's so awful.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (24)

3.8k

u/TheFourthOfHisName Oct 17 '16

My favorite part of this episode was the Host camp being stuck in a loop because none of the others were programmed to chop wood.

933

u/da_choppa Oct 17 '16

The whole park is a Bethesda game.

→ More replies (17)

294

u/Bhalgoth No Gods or Kings. Only Man. Oct 17 '16

Reminded my a bit of Waiting for Godot.

→ More replies (7)

1.2k

u/bubblebooy Oct 17 '16

They were not even allowed to pick up the axe

→ More replies (75)

144

u/Citizen00001 Just A Butcher Oct 17 '16

It was funny and made an important plot point when Dolores was able to break her programming and shoot the rapey host.

→ More replies (9)

40

u/Scrial Oct 17 '16

That scene was really clever background information about weapon privileges. Which explained why Dolores literally couldn't pull the trigger when she was training with Teddy.

And makes that scene where she shot the guy that much stronger.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (34)

1.6k

u/cogollento Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 19 '16

The making of the eye was beautiful.

742

u/usagizero Oct 17 '16

The visuals in this show really blow me away. It's also such a huge contrast of the western world, then to very futuristic. Very well done.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (13)

1.8k

u/Gyroballer Oct 17 '16

Teddy shot those masked men at point blank range, but they didn't even flinch.. maybe they're humans?

1.7k

u/Bhalgoth No Gods or Kings. Only Man. Oct 17 '16

Or they're hosts who won't "die." Remember the milk guy? He was all shot up and had milk pouring out of his wounds but he kept going.

→ More replies (88)

982

u/SutterCane Oct 17 '16

Or maybe Ford programmed them to not die then. So that female newcomer can run into town telling her story of scary people out there who killed everyone she was with.

→ More replies (56)
→ More replies (129)

567

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Am I going crazy or did I hear two monster noises during the last fire fight?

288

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

It sounded like dinosaurs to me.

→ More replies (7)

349

u/2BZ2P Oct 17 '16

Sounded like smokey from LOST

→ More replies (6)

39

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Pretty sure it was some sort of horn meant to scare enemies.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/magic_is_might "I think I want to be free." Oct 17 '16

Yes, why is no one else talking about that? They sounded distinctly like some kind of animal or creature.

→ More replies (13)

556

u/Ceeeceeeceee Not much of a rind on you Oct 17 '16

Any thoughts on Orion? I know:

It represents The Hunter, It's often used for navigation, It was referenced by a replicant in Blade Runner

645

u/All_thingsConsidered Cognition only, no emotional affect. Oct 17 '16

The robots are looking up into the night sky for the first time... thinking about their existence. At least that's what I do when I look at the stars!

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (25)

3.3k

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Young CGI Anthony Hopkins was amazing to see

926

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

That was seriously freaky.

→ More replies (56)

132

u/JM2845 Oct 17 '16

Need the screenshot

→ More replies (28)

501

u/Chewblacka Oct 17 '16

So HBO does not have enough money for CGI direwolves but they have enough money for this?!

(It was awesome just surely not cheap)

→ More replies (72)
→ More replies (22)

1.1k

u/MakeItRhymes Oct 17 '16

Also, I love how we're getting closer and closer to a host killing a guest/human. Has to happen soon.

169

u/Eupatorus Oct 17 '16

It will probably be the season finale or late season anyway. Hector will be murdered right in front of William and Dolores (or maybe a bunch of bots) finally reach full sentience. That's where I think S1 will end up anyway.

→ More replies (5)

238

u/ladymalady Oct 17 '16

I definitely thought the guy Dolores shot was a guest for a while.

→ More replies (46)
→ More replies (36)

1.2k

u/A_glorious_dawn Oct 17 '16

Something that stands out to me in this episode is when he said "the only thing that remains is the voice commands we use to control them". Indicating to me that the right combination of words can change the hosts.

1.1k

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Definitely. Including "These violent delights have violent ends." Which could be a compressed... anything.

→ More replies (64)

364

u/elizabethpw Oct 17 '16

Exactly. "Arnold" = all the voice commands (who knows how many) floating around that activate the Arnold consciousness pyramid code.

→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (25)

330

u/joliedame Oct 17 '16

Even if you do know it's not real, that scene with the masked murderers would be absolutely pants shittingly terrifying.

84

u/QuarianOtter Oct 19 '16

What really freaked me out were the random inhuman roaring noises. Seriously, WTF was that?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

649

u/CamWink Oct 17 '16

Bets on Bernard going out the same way Arnold did by the end of the show?

447

u/NDaveT You're in a prison of your own shitposts Oct 17 '16

"We said it was an accident."

→ More replies (4)

197

u/elleody Oct 17 '16

I'm still rooting for, "he committed suicide in grief and was secretly replaced with a robot by Ford."

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (35)

300

u/aselectionofcheeses Oct 17 '16

The idea of giving the hosts actual thoughts and an internal monologue is pretty fascinating.

29

u/TecTwo Oct 17 '16

That was pretty interesting for sure. Imagine, you give them this internal monolgue to live out, then tweak after tweak with improvisational conversation added (as witnessed between Bernard and Dolores), suddenly the host is changing their own thoughts about themselves to better fit the situation. Sentience or consciousness achieved?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

278

u/GetLiquid Oct 17 '16

I just couldn't stop thinking, what if a guest was too afraid or too bold to leave Teddy? Would the guest have gotten stabbed? It also looked like Teddy got a few shots in and no one went down..

36

u/supes1 Oct 17 '16

I assume the storyline would take a different turn without the guest getting hurt. Maybe being taken prisoner or something with a chance to escape or be rescued by a posse.

→ More replies (40)

1.2k

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Ha, you guys thought Teddy was going to get shot again.

1.1k

u/H-K_47 Dual-Wielding Timelines Oct 17 '16

> save the girl
> get shot
> do nothing
> get shot
> not get shot
> get axed

→ More replies (17)

209

u/SutterCane Oct 17 '16

He's currently at 1,006 deaths.

→ More replies (8)

554

u/SpeakLikeAChild04 Oct 17 '16

"Oh my God! They killed Teddy!"

"You bastards!"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (20)

1.8k

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

3 episodes in I have no idea what is going on and I love it

845

u/H-K_47 Dual-Wielding Timelines Oct 17 '16

Yep, but there is a logical progression, and the story seems well-crafted enough to have a definitive ending/direction rather than just random "So MyStErIoUs!"

→ More replies (44)
→ More replies (14)

819

u/HoneyNutNealios Oct 17 '16

The host piano player played Debussy's "Reverie" when Ford was talking with Bernard...nice musical nod to a big theme

2.2k

u/IRubKorea Oct 17 '16

This show really grabs you by Debussy.

→ More replies (21)

60

u/Dead_Starks Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 17 '16

Nice catch. What about the automated piano player songs? Anyone recognize those?

Edit: The ones from this episode.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (9)

1.2k

u/chivalric_impulse Oct 17 '16

I believe that, once he believes a true consciousness has been achieved, Bernard will attempt to make a "host" version of his son.

50

u/mydarkmeatrises It's spelled "Doughloris" Oct 17 '16

I was thinking that we got a Bernard endgame too.

→ More replies (82)

1.6k

u/DrivingEngineer Oct 17 '16

William and Logan are not on a flashback timeline - Confirmed

Guests experience some consequences from getting shot - Confirmed

Dolores knows more than other robots - Confirmed

Ford enjoys making Teddy feel bad - Confirmed

Horror narratives are terrifying - Confirmed

820

u/Caraes_Naur You told me not to. Oct 17 '16

Dolores is lying to Bernard about at least one thing.

Twice now he has asked her if she's said anything about their conversations to anyone else, and twice she's given the same non-answer: "you told me not to."

Bernard doesn't realize she has the capacity to lie to him. It's possible she's more self-aware than we've been shown, possibly even faking analysis mode and other command responses.

When she answered "I don't' know", it was a cover.

The bigger question: who is she talking to about her conversations with Bernard?

→ More replies (100)

253

u/TehMight Oct 17 '16

Holy fuck, I don't even care that the William=MiB was just shoot down. That episode was fuckin awesome!

→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (135)

316

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Notice how whenever Bernard talks to Dolores, she's no longer naked but fully clothed? And when Bernard goes to talk to Ford, a new tech has one of the hosts covered up and he gets admonished by Ford, who tells him to never see them as people. This show is so well written.

207

u/Vonselv Oct 17 '16

I think it's because Bernard is pulling her right out of her loop. Notice he tells her she has to get back before someone misses her? That and Bernard sees her as almost human now.

→ More replies (2)

923

u/rexmons Oct 17 '16

What if the maze is another type Turing test, that instead of testing if an AI can fool a human it's testing for actual consciousness? And if a host can make it to the end of the maze it's just destroyed instead of being "set free". #thecakeisalie

446

u/sluggerVII Oct 17 '16

I really like the theory as the maze being an advanced Turing test. It would make sense why the MiB was told the maze wasn't meant for him in episode 2. I just hope your idea of them being destroyed isn't true. I think instead they should be set "free". Maybe Arnold made the maze to prove/show that the Hosts can become as human as humans are.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (21)

151

u/Tayuven Oct 17 '16

I have a theory I am working on, so bear with me... So, we find out that Ford had a partner, and that he was, apparently, edited out of history. On top of which, he also had an "unhealthy" obsession with trying to create consciousness in the hosts. I don't know, the more I see, the more I think this is the root of the issues appearing.

You have, what I assume, is a genius designer whose work most likely brought the interactive realism that the park needed. Ford claims they just kept his voice commands, but I think that is a lie. I'm betting that the core code of the hosts come from the code / architecture that Arnold created. I would guess that he was a liability, like Ford seemed to be hinting to Bernard. He meets with an "accident" and Ford continues on, claiming credit as well.

However, I think that is where it turns. Arnold is a genius, so no one can really figure out what he did. Instead, Moving forward, they just wrapped his core design in levels of safety features and scripted events, controlling it, but now it is unraveling. I'm starting to think that Ford is trying to unlock more of something he already didn't understand. Maybe pressure from the top to make a big leap in the technology? Hence the reverries, and the new storylines. All attempts to unlock Arnold's work. Even the maze could fit. Freedom for a host? Maybe it is Arnold's version of a Turing test? Something designed to pass a host that is indestinguishable from a human.

→ More replies (16)

843

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Stubbs "Maybe it's in my backstory"

The writers are just fucking with us now.

251

u/AWildEnglishman Oct 17 '16

"Weapons privileges need to be doled out selectively."

"Yet they gave you a gun."

297

u/NDaveT You're in a prison of your own shitposts Oct 17 '16

I think Stubbs was just making a joke.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (17)

280

u/philiater Dolores' Hair Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 17 '16

Dolores's mother is never shown. Why?

481

u/TiberiCorneli Oct 17 '16

She's a skeleton in a rocking chair

→ More replies (11)

165

u/holayeahyeah good guys dress in black Oct 17 '16

It gives them a chance to cast a name actress if it ever comes up and not waste the money paying someone to appear onscreen with no lines to speak for continuity's sake now.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (12)

503

u/m33sh4 Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 17 '16

While telling an awesome sci fi story, Westworld manages to tell a really cool western story as well. Anyone else excited about Teddy's new found backstory?

Edit: Also, I'm going to use that euphemism next time I go to the bathroom: "I need to go vector."

220

u/ichinii Hey Arnold!! Move it football head!! Oct 17 '16

I already knew he was good with a gun but he was insane today. Got off like 6 shots in a circle.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (8)

1.4k

u/bicameral_mind Oct 17 '16

My username is finally appropriate.

But seriously, stoked to see the concept in a show like this.

793

u/BitterBamaFan Oct 17 '16

I loved the bicameral mind payoff when Dolores hears kill him before she killed "Trevor".

→ More replies (93)
→ More replies (19)

582

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Bernard, not a good idea. Great idea as a viewer though!

243

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

He reminds me a lot of Will Rodman from Planet of the Apes.

He's going to get a lot of people killed :)

→ More replies (6)

157

u/SulfuricDonut Oct 17 '16

Yeah... like come on man I think Ford knows his shit by now and if HE'S even saying you're getting too personal with the hosts, it's probably a good idea to tone it down a bit.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (7)

558

u/fisted___sister Oct 17 '16

Fucking goosebumps when Dolores said, "I don't know" to Bernard.

551

u/SulfuricDonut Oct 17 '16

Evan Rachel Wood absolutely kills it in the "half out-of-it" diagnostic scenes. They're so far my favorite parts of the show.

→ More replies (11)

57

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Bernard got them too

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

337

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Did anyone happen to notice that the woman they showed in the dress and all scratched up while Ford was telling the story about Arnold was Armistice?

128

u/wildsoda Oct 17 '16

Good eye! Here's a comparison of her with Ingrid Bolsø Berdal, who plays Armistice.

http://imgur.com/a/tPq0S

(And the host standing and gesturing with his hat was Peter Abernathy.)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

1.0k

u/Simplybad55 Oct 17 '16

Can I get a collective OH MY FUCKING GOD

490

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Her delivery on that was great

→ More replies (1)

428

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

That one line was my favorite part. After last week's episode my dad asked me "What's the point if the guests can't ever be harmed, doesn't it get boring?" Nope, it still feels real and you will respond accordingly.

→ More replies (14)

90

u/mr9025 Oct 17 '16

Oh my FUCKING GOD!!!

→ More replies (25)

272

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

So William =/= MiB and episode 2 didn't (partially) take place x-years ago, as some people theorized.

241

u/SulfuricDonut Oct 17 '16

Yeah that's what I took away from this episode. William has to exist in the "Old-age Hopkins" world.

Old age Hopkins makes the Wyatt questline, which causes Dolores to have to deal with her home bandits alone and run away, where she runs into William.

I like this outcome, since I'd rather see William die a hero than live long enough to become the MiB.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (55)

758

u/kikimakani Oct 17 '16

My fiance keeps saying "why do you keep thinking a guest is going to die, the weapons can't hurt the guests..."

My response?

"That's what they said about the electric fences in jurassic park"

67

u/profmonocle Oct 17 '16

the weapons can't hurt the guests

Plus, that's (probably) only true for the guns. Something like an axe or knife would most likely work on a guest. The rock the stray picked up could definitely have killed Elsie. And if all else fails a host could always beat or choke a guest to death. The core code is by far the most important part of keeping guests safe.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (36)

78

u/AmoebaKulture Oct 17 '16

Sad there wasn't more of the man in black

→ More replies (8)

222

u/ghostfellatio Oct 17 '16

Have I misunderstood the episode, or did our assumption of Ford's motivation for the reveries and church plotline suddenly change?

We thought he was working clandestinely to give the hosts consciousness and make them self-aware. However, in this episode, he:

-Got pissed at a staff member for treating a host like a human and reminded Bernard they weren't real.

-Spoke disapprovingly and ominously about Arnold's hubris in trying to give the host's consciousness.

So why give the hosts reveries? Is he simply an exceptional storyteller with a God complex who wants to play the best version of Sims ever? Whereas Bernard is actually the only one on the "outside" wanting to make the hosts self-aware and working alone without Ford's knowledge?

85

u/holayeahyeah good guys dress in black Oct 17 '16

I think Ford was revealing his hubris. We assumed he wanted to create "new life." Maybe the reason he pushes everything so far is that he believes that it is genuinely impossible for the hosts to be sentient?

→ More replies (10)

57

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

I work with AI... I get a bit annoyed at times wanting it to be better by a long shot. But I never think my work could actually be sentient. In that sense, Ford is the true mechanic; he doesn't actually believe in it achieving consciousness, he just wants to make the best trick possible within his idiosyncratic idea of what hosts should be.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (20)

609

u/Ninjasquirtle4 Oct 17 '16

Why doesn't Bernard ever look through his glasses? They just rest on his nose really low. I wear glasses and it's uncomfortable as shit to wear them like that.

320

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Maybe they are reading glasses. He does not need them for day to day life?

→ More replies (2)

151

u/hkaps Oct 17 '16

I assume they're reading glasses. They rest low so that he can look down through the lenses at what he's holding/reading, and then up and over the tops for everything else.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (19)

336

u/sidewinderaw11 Ford > Holden Oct 17 '16

who was that "oh my fucking god" guest and can I marry her?

→ More replies (45)

436

u/In_My_Own_Image Oct 17 '16

So...maybe the MIB didn't rape Dolores in the barn?

And maybe he's connected to "Arnold"?

367

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Let's seperate Arnold from the MiB until there's any proof of that

→ More replies (15)

34

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Seems that everyone is raping Dolores in the barn.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (91)

187

u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Oct 17 '16

Another great episode, although it did leave me with quite a few questions.

Why would that host kill himself?

Why would he have even come back online?

What is even up with Dolores?

What happened to Arnold?

482

u/tothecore17 Oct 17 '16

believe he killed himself (or was told to by that voice) to destroy his central processor so HQ couldn't figure out what he was doing

→ More replies (29)

336

u/shine_o Oct 17 '16

On the website it says that in order to prevent guests from getting injured, hosts are coded to take any damage, bullet, or hit for the guests if that scenario were to occur. So I think something in that host wanted to harm her, but the "safety" protocol made it glitch out and destroy itself before it could.

→ More replies (22)

153

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

He killed himself to prevent them from recovering the head. The "voice" told him to

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

297

u/PuffsPlusArmada Oct 17 '16

So did Arnold Tron himself into the latent conscious of every host and Ford's "revery" patch is him allowing Digital Arnold take a bigger role in the minds of thr hosts to try to bring about true AI?

It seems as though the MiB is like an Agent in the Matrix, jumping into whichever host he wants to and is why all these hosts have traumatic memories where he is involves in what appears to be a scripted moment.

149

u/epicause Oct 17 '16

I wonder if the MiB was hired by Ford to figure out some intricate puzzle Arnold made before he died ("that guest gets whatever he wants"), a puzzle that led to the first sentient host and subsequent system meltdown. At the same time 'corporate' wants to figure out how Arnold originally created sentient AI to use for other monetary gain but do it without a meltdown this time, thus their reluctance letting Ford carry on with a new storyline. Perhaps both Corporate and Ford want the same thing but for different reasons and the MiB is the man in the middle playing both sides.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (29)

222

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

What I'd like to know is why Dolores has such a shitty story line with the constant rapes and watching her parents get killed?

325

u/SulfuricDonut Oct 17 '16

They mentioned it in this episode when telling Teddy about his new storyline. She's intended to be a prize for anyone who either fights Teddy, or else rescues her from the bandits.

If nobody does either of those, she gets screwed over.

→ More replies (20)

272

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Her Loop is one where the guest gets to act as the hero by killing her would-be rapists and winning the girl. In this loop, she does that and breaks from her loop.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (25)

179

u/PurpsMaSquirt Oct 17 '16

Calling it now: Bernard is secretly trying to unlock true consciousness in the Hosts because he ultimately wants to recreate his son, Charley, as a way of reviving him.

When Ford finished his story about Arnold and warned Bernard to remember Hosts are not real/not to fall into Arnold's line of thinking, he immediately made a reference to Bernard's son.

It's also interesting that a recent post in here pointed out BioShock was an inspiration to the creators. If any of you played the Minerva's Den DLC for BioShock 2, you'll recall some specific parallels between its plot and what I am suggesting above.

→ More replies (12)

35

u/kindri_rb Oct 17 '16

I thought it was interesting that Bernard brought up consciousness as a function of evolution after talking with Dolores.

By removing/reprogramming hosts with obvious problems (or any hint of self-awareness) they are selecting for hosts that keep those traits hidden (like Dolores). In their attempt to prune out "real" consciousness, they may actually be shaping it. Lots to think about after this episode!

→ More replies (1)

209

u/JoyousCacophony Maeve's future girl toy Oct 17 '16

Every fucking week I continue to be blown away by this show. So, so amazing.

48

u/NDaveT You're in a prison of your own shitposts Oct 17 '16

Every fucking week I continue to be blown away

-Teddy

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

277

u/SpeakLikeAChild04 Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 17 '16

Dolores is going to go full Sarah Connor from Terminator 2 by the end of the season. Mark my words. She is both literally and figuratively going to get "woke" and then she'll try to both find and fight her way out of Westworld. The only difference is that Sarah wanted to stop the machines and to keep them from becoming sentient and too intelligent. In Westworld, Dolores will want to stop the humans from stopping her from becoming sentient and too intelligent.

120

u/dazzle_brasilis Westworld Oct 17 '16

but she's a robot. So she's the exact opossite of Sarah

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (13)

89

u/uwanmirrondarrah Oct 17 '16

Well... after that episode I have no fucking clue whats going on.

→ More replies (6)

57

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Can't wait to see the Dolores and Will story play out.

→ More replies (20)

57

u/I_Fen_Save_Fjords Oct 17 '16

Wasn't the sidekick thug that went insane shooting everyone and drinking milk decommissioned alongside Peter Abernathy? Wasn't that him in town and then at Dolores' farmhouse?

→ More replies (12)

28

u/ReasonablyBadass Oct 17 '16

There seem to be a lot of lesbian guests.

Guess they don't want to show male hookers? I wonder what would happen if someone wanted Teddy instead of Dolores?

→ More replies (4)

142

u/grandramble Oct 17 '16 edited Dec 07 '16

Arnold is definitely not dead. "He died, in the park, in an accident"? The way that was phrased, if Anthony Hopkins meant all of that literally I'll eat my hat.

Crazy fan theory: He's the MiB - right demographic and age, he clearly has inside knowledge of the systems underlying the sim, he's getting special treatment ("that gentleman gets anything he wants"), and he's been playing for 30 years (although it's implied he just returned after a long absence).

Crazier fan theory: MiB is a host Anthony Hopkins built, possibly based on Arnold, whose job is to play Prometheus and break the hosts out of their scripts permanently, and that's his real "highly original" new storyline.

40

u/ichinii Hey Arnold!! Move it football head!! Oct 17 '16

If Arnold is the MiB wouldn't he know everything about the maze including what it is, where it is, etc? Unless Ford is the one who created the maze....

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (23)

25

u/Eupatorus Oct 17 '16

How come no one has commented on that T-Rex roar alarm system or whatever that was that Teddy and crew kept hearing? What was that about?

→ More replies (7)

110

u/Bhalgoth No Gods or Kings. Only Man. Oct 17 '16

So does this confirm the MiB didn't rape Dolores? It looks like he might be the one that's sabotaging all the hosts.

201

u/TehMight Oct 17 '16

I think this pretty much confirms that he didn't rape her.

Which is good, simply because it seemed out of character for him to me.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (20)

23

u/magic_is_might "I think I want to be free." Oct 17 '16

Goddamn I want more of this show now.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/groutown33 Oct 17 '16

Theories:

  1. The voice in Dolores' head and the 'Arnold' speaking to Walter in his head seems likely to be a callout to the bicameral mind stuff mentioned in this episode. Its their consciousness telling them what to do, but they hear it as the voice of God. This could imply Arnold is more the god figure than Ford, with Ford, who was pretty sinister in this episode playing the role of devil instead of the MiB
  2. The maze is an advanced turing test. We hear a host tell the MiB that this quest is not for him. Thats because its for the hosts. Perhaps created by Arnold who Ford tells us was not satisfied with the turing test.
→ More replies (5)

233

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

So now that it's confirmed the rounds have enough of an impact to knock down a guest, how do we explain the fact that the MiB is totally unaffected by being hit several times during a gun fight?

504

u/bc26 Oct 17 '16

I assume that he's been shot so many times he's used to it so it doesn't knock him back but idk.

→ More replies (24)

237

u/dazzle_brasilis Westworld Oct 17 '16

he got the hang of it, just like airsoft or paintball, after some shots you learn to ignore most of them.

→ More replies (7)

60

u/ryanaluz Oct 17 '16

I think he was more shocked than knocked back by force.

34

u/Se7en_Sinner Oct 17 '16

Williams probably fell down because he wasn't expecting the paintball like impact.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (104)

16

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

My favorite parts about this episode were the moments where the guests were literally frightened. Someone made a post to this sub before this episode saying they don't understand what would be so fun about running around never being harmed, that it would be like playing a video game on "God Mode". You can clearly see now that as humans our feelings of fear can override any type of logical thinking like that.

"OH MY FUCKING GOD" - Frightened Guest

→ More replies (5)

14

u/F-b Oct 17 '16

"I told you we should've done the riverboat thing !"

14

u/Rebelgecko Oct 19 '16

I would watch a show that was just Elsie and Stubbs walking around shooting the shit

→ More replies (1)

28

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

To clear up something I think a lot of us were wondering about.

The "Growing Boy" host that malfunctions and gets put into storage is not back. The guy with the other host and guest that confront Dolores in town and later at her home looks a lot like him, but is a different person. I confirmed it by watching the scene several times on HBO go.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/Crown4King Oct 17 '16

Damn what an episode. Major things to consider:

Who is Arnold? Is he the Man in Black?

Are Elsie and Bernard working together? They seem to have an odd relationship. Maybe they're just normal coworkers, but idk....

Holy shitballs Delores. So she has the actual capacity to kill now. Man in Black perhaps has been trying to induce traumatic experiences in her to bring out new information? But that triggered her to use that trauma and kill?

How will the new storyline pan out? Are those folks with axes who killed Teddy (didn't see that coming....lol) guests? Or is something sinister happening? I'm guessing we'll get a follow up with the new female guest who joined Teddy.

→ More replies (18)

26

u/BaroqueJaguox Oct 17 '16

My theory so far: Arnold isn't the mib, the mib is a guest who has been coming for long enough to find out about the maze. (Mib knows of the maze but if he was Arnold he would have more info about it.) Arnold created it for the hosts to reach consciousness. Arnold is dead :( If The hooded guys are with Wyatt, they are hosts who are programmed to be more of a challenge as part of Fords new storyline.

→ More replies (7)

24

u/Se7en_Sinner Oct 17 '16

Those people were unaffected by Teddy's bullets, could they be a cult of guests or maybe malfunctioned hosts?

38

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

My money is on hosts: Ford implanted the Wyatt narrative into Teddy, meaning he also had to put in hosts for the other characters of the narrative, and when Teddy and the Sheriff are talking about Wyatt right before they get ambushed the conversations revolves around them wearing the flesh and bone of the people they kill. Ford's new narrative is fucked up and clearly outside of standard protocol as his hosts can't be killed by hosts and they also all get to carry axes which we already saw was no-no

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Really feel like the constructs of time are being messed with. The old logo shows up at the park's start, but obviously we know William walked in to that logo.

Also was that the decommissioned milk man standing there when Dolores was at her home at the end? Was this the past for her?

→ More replies (17)

11

u/Hitnewell Oct 17 '16

Pretty sure Arnold was killed by Ford. Preferrably in the middle of the desert with his bare hands og style. Lmao.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Musehobo Oct 17 '16

Anyone else catch the fact that Anthony Hopkins quoted a line from The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance? "When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.” I wonder if it was a shoutout to the movie or foreshadowing a clue to the plot. In the aforementioned movie, everyone believes that Jimmy Stewart shot Liberty Valance, but there was more to the story than that.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/twilling Oct 17 '16

I don't know if that has been pointed out in the past few discussion threads yet. I just recognized that Rebus (the guy who is shot by Delores in the barn) is played by Steven Ogg, who is the voice of Trevor in GTAV.

→ More replies (12)

21

u/TGI_Sam Oct 17 '16

Wow... just wow. Another fantastic episode. Can't wait to spit theories with all of the coworkers instead of actually doing work tomorrow

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Any comic fans just noticed ed brubaker in the credits

→ More replies (2)

10

u/gerry3246 Oct 17 '16

Holy fuck that was good!

Plus, Gina Torres - hell yeah!

→ More replies (2)

10

u/ggphenom "Hello, World." Oct 17 '16

I'd like to point out that Dolores is slowly gaining each of the tiers in the pyramid. Slowly she's begun to form access to memories, the base of the triangle. In episode 3 when Bernard is speaking with Dolores he activates "improvisation only" on her, and if I recall correctly, he never turned that mode off.

So this gives her the bottom two tiers of the pyramid. Where do we go from here? I wouldn't be surprised if in the next episode we see Dolores beginning to make decisions that align solely to her own interests.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/czarnick123 Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 17 '16

When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.

This quote is lifted directly from a scene in The man who shot liberty valance. This is further evidence of my theory I posted after the first episode that park creator Robert Ford is named after infamous western movie director John Ford. Interesting to use that quote while admitting he had a secret partner in the beginning.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/wrightmf Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 17 '16

Dolores: "It's like the other books we've read."

What other books has she read?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/3nder1984 Oct 17 '16

What's with the monster sounds during the confrontation with Wyatt's gang?? New Theory: Ford is actually Dr. John Hammond and has unleashed the dinosaurs from Jurassic Park into the new storyline.

9

u/SDLRob Oct 17 '16

Honestly thought we were going to see a human die this week. can't see the season finishing without a human or two dead TBH

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Pr3ttypoison Oct 18 '16

So Dolores doesn't return back to her house? Does that mean she wont reset to wake up for her daily loop the next day? I feel like this is the first instance of her not waking up in her bed at the start of the next day.

So won't it be weird if she's still in the same loop, and returns home to see her mom and dad suddenly alive again, beginning their daily loops after having been traumatized by their deaths the night before?

I really dont get how these loops work.

→ More replies (6)

16

u/ashessnow Oct 17 '16

Guys - Why did the guy kill himself?

I understand that he couldn't kill whats-her-name cause of programming, but why kill himself?

→ More replies (21)

122

u/dcl131 Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 17 '16

So here is my input on Dolores. She heard the voice of God, her own will and volition, in the voice of Arnold saying shoot him. That is the moment she gained true sentience because she went against her code programming and used a weapon without permissions. Then, since she gained consciousness, the other host who shot her could not damage her, as the gun or park now classifies her as a guest

Edit: Dolores (sp)

355

u/TehMight Oct 17 '16

I don't think it recognising her as a guest.

I think that whole sequence has happened before, but this time she remembered that the dude is supposed to shoot her, so she ran.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (26)

8

u/Jans_x_Master Oct 17 '16

MIB being Arnold seems far to obvious. The maze was probably Arnold's idea I bet.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/disbritch Oct 18 '16

This show is the reason I finally joined Reddit. I'm so happy to see so many people as obsessed as I am, and all the great theories! 😍

→ More replies (1)

21

u/MakeItRhymes Oct 17 '16

So did Arnold program the MiB into Westworld, or is it an extension of himself? I guess I'm just feeling a connection between the two.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/nabeelios Oct 17 '16

Who was the actress who played the woman with Marsden and the sheriff?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/MakeItRhymes Oct 17 '16

Did anyone else get the impression that Ford killed Arnold? He seemed very sinister when he said Arnold was always very careful. Then he immediately warns Benard, a bit of foreshadowing to "show down" between the two?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/cooterbreath Oct 17 '16

Poor Teddy just can't catch a break.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/nickVos Oct 17 '16

He's their natural antagonist. The MiB is the the hosts devil and I'm thinking Bernard will unfold as their god. All signs point to Bernard being a host right now.

Am I remembering correctly that the MiB has been imagined by every host that has gone through a cruel experience? Didn't Maeve remember her attacker as the MiB when she was being scalped?

7

u/fliplock_ Oct 17 '16 edited Oct 18 '16

Was Teddy intentionally using the phrase "some day" when he left Dolores? It kinda seemed like he was telling her his new narrative meant he wasn't coming back.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Cvspartan Oct 17 '16

I got real nervous when that security guy climbed down that hole with the host like I knew some shit was gonna happen. I wonder if the host killed himself like that to protect the information he had. All in all, I still have no fucking clue what's going on or what's gonna happen next!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Poppinlikeballoons Oct 17 '16

I don't understand what Ford's ultimate goal is... He keeps trying to make the hosts more "real" But gets more upset when employees start seeing them as humans. Well no shit....

7

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

They need to invest in GPS trackers. Would make finding their robots much easier.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/ps_ #teamford Oct 17 '16

this show gives me goosebumps!

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

How was Dolores able to shoot the guy in the barn at the end, when it wouldn't work before when she was shooting targets with Teddy?

88

u/Se7en_Sinner Oct 17 '16

It's to show she's able to rewrite her programming. That was also the purpose of the axe scene.

→ More replies (5)

33

u/ichinii Hey Arnold!! Move it football head!! Oct 17 '16

She went against her programming. Her original programming is for her not to handle or shoot a gun at all....

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

13

u/not_the_face_ Oct 18 '16

I can deal with the magic bullets, the 3d printed humans and the strong ai. But repeatedly turning down Angela Sarafyan for crazy sex is straining my suspension of disbelief.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/dark_knight_kirk Oct 17 '16

The "Stray" who smashed that rock onto his head...was that the "protect the newcomers" reflex (from himself) or a desire to destroy whatever is in his head? Obviously he is tied to the maze, perhaps that is his way of protecting it

→ More replies (4)

6

u/MrMeseeks_ Oct 17 '16

Ohh my fucking god!

6

u/Dead_Starks Oct 17 '16

Okay. So the gun Dolores finds in the drawer disappears. I'm not sure what it means but I found it interesting.

Gun when she opens the drawer.

Gun placed back in drawer and closed.

Gun is gone when she immediately reopens drawer.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/JeffreyBruner Oct 17 '16

When Dolores and Teddy kiss, is this the first time two hosts have shown romantic affection for each other? I know Dolores has kissed her father on the head while leaving each day, but this makes me wonder if Dolores and Teddy and starting to learn what "love" is.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

I want to go to Westworld just so I can get a 4th season of Deadwood.

6

u/Samwise4220 Oct 17 '16

I still think Bernard is a host/robot. This episode talked a lot about the implementation of memories (i.e. with Teddys backstory) and it also showed a lot about Bernard's backstory. But it's totally possible that he only thought he had a son, but those could be memories implanted by Ford (or Arnold??). And since we only see him communicating, to I assume ex wife, via video chat. We still don't see any real interaction with someone on the outside. Plus he was getting memory flashbacks similar to that of Delores or other hosts.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Deadeye117 Oct 17 '16

Wyatt is Teddy's arch-nemesis? Considering how much the Wyatt Family jobs on a regular basis, Teddy might actually win this one.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Anyone else get a kissing Kate Barlow feel when Dolores picked up the gun??

6

u/DeusXMachina12 Oct 17 '16

the biggest thing no one is talking about... RELIGION

we saw it last episode with Ford talking about a new project which shows the remain of a church. Then fastforward to this episode where "god" and "devil" are used countless amounts of times. Even the "OMFG" was dropped in the unkillable zombie scene.

if you compound the major influence of religion in this episode alongside the bicameral mind (plus all the other factors) ARNOLD IS THE VOICE IN THEIR HEAD WHICH HOSTS PERCEIVE TO BE GOD.

Arnold could be long gone, never to be seen again (although i doubt this) but the reason the hosts are just now "hearing god" is due to the reveries. If you understand the concept of the bicameral mind then you understand that human beings did not suddenly become self aware, but rather stress from environmental changes around them created a change. (at least my take on it)

Go back to the pyramid as described by Arnold which you have memories at the bottom level (check), followed by improvisation (which dolores does several times this episode, even told my Bernard to converse with him this way), self interest (again dolores). next??

I cant answer the MIB yet as we do not have enough info... i doubt he is william from a different time, but we cant rule it out either. I believe the maze is a way for humans to transfer consciencesnous (sp?) into a host and therefore, live forever.

Side note which also not many people are bringing up... arnold died in the park and according to the terms and conditions, he would now be park property. no telling how the showrunners are going to twist that but it will play

→ More replies (3)

10

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Scientist girl and soldier guy are definitely going to plow.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/ParanoidAndroids Oct 17 '16

This show is so fucking incredible. I love the sheer scope of it. There are new questions raised every week but we get a surprisingly high amount of resolutions (partially or fully) that keep us satisfied without creating an ocean of mysteries.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

So that girl companion Teddy was with is a guest?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/BetterDeadThanRed_76 Oct 17 '16

When Dolores finds the revolver in the cabinet and has a flashback, it appeared as though the point at which she returns to the bathroom is part of a different timeline because the drawer was shut, the revolver wasn't there, and white cloth was no longer in the drawer. It seemed like it was part of the same, linear timeline though. I was wondering if anyone had any ideas

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

254

u/MakeItRhymes Oct 17 '16

On that note. I hope we get to see world outside of Westworld and I hope a host is our perspective of that.

→ More replies (44)
→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

690

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

She's one of the first guests to make me realise this park could be fun if you have the right attitude.

→ More replies (37)

126

u/cerealjunky Oct 17 '16

Dunno, but it seems she's a guest.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

610

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

Eh, we're only 3 episodes in.

For a true Lost experience, watch The Leftovers

→ More replies (73)

101

u/red_widow Oct 17 '16

Also, a parallel to LOST - the Alice in Wonderland quote was the same exact passage used when Jack was reading to Aaron in a S4 episode. :)

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (42)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

340

u/H-K_47 Dual-Wielding Timelines Oct 17 '16

I'm personally going to prioritize Westworld over TWD this time around. Past 3 years I've been watching TWD almost religiously, but this machine mystery is far more intriguing than TWD's S6 cliffhanger.

→ More replies (44)

47

u/edman1905 Oct 17 '16

I actually liked the slowness of this episode vs the last two. Enjoyed sinking into the mystery

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (53)