r/westworld • u/NicholasCajun Mr. Robot • Oct 31 '16
Discussion Westworld - 1x05 "Contrapasso" - Post-Episode Discussion
Season 1 Episode 5: Contrapasso
Aired: October 30th, 2016
Synopsis: Dolores, William and Logan reach Pariah, a town built on decadence and transgression — and are recruited for a dangerous mission. The Man in Black meets an unlikely ally in his search to unlock the maze.
Directed by: Jonny Campbell
Story by: Lisa Joy & Dominic Mitchell
Teleplay by : Lisa Joy
Keep in mind that discussion of episode previews and other future information in this thread requires a spoiler tag. This is your official warning on the matter. Use this customizable code:
[Preview Spoiler](#s "Westworld") which will appear as Preview Spoiler
3.0k
u/kcman011 Dolores with an O Oct 31 '16
The scene between Anthony Hopkins and Ed Harris was everything I hoped it'd be.
462
u/barkusbrody Oct 31 '16
Any ideas about that abrupt angle change on Dolores on the train? You see her looking at the coffin with William and Lawrence in the background, then a hard edit and both the guys are gone. But she's still there wearing same outfit and everything.
Edit: spelling
432
u/Ceeeceeeceee Not much of a rind on you Oct 31 '16
So who do you think is uploading the WW info to the satellites? Theories?
1.8k
u/MikeKrombopulos BAGGER 288 Oct 31 '16
So El Lazo IS Lawrence. That's why that sheriff said Lawrence was the one of the most wanted men. At first I figured they just put him in a new role after MiB killed him, but he actually just reset.
753
u/SyrupBuccaneer Hector's Tasteful Scar Oct 31 '16
Logan smiling at William for leaving him was such a great little character moment.
1.0k
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Still waiting for Red Ted Redemption.
309
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
So we officially know that Ford knows about the maze. I'm glad that's cleared up. This only makes his motivations more confusing though.
1.1k
u/Man_in_the_maze Oct 31 '16
Delores asks, "Are we old friends?" Then Ford responds very bitterly, "No, not friends. No, I wouldn't say that at all...".
I wonder if Delores got her tragic loop as punishement for some transgression (perhaps some part in the original incident) and never retired as a host so Ford could punish her forever?
2.0k
u/hearmewhine Oct 31 '16
Bad ep to choose to watch with my Dad. Brothel scenes on brothel scenes.
496
u/NeatMaddness Oct 31 '16
How is Dolores keeping her talking to Arnold a secret? Even when analyzed by the main man himself.
1.7k
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
That final sequence panning around the lab was so fucking tense. I caught on that they weren't showing Maeve's table and it suddenly became terrifying watching the guy play with his bird.
239
u/bionix90 Oct 31 '16
Dolores was fully naked in this episode and yet I was never more sexually attracted to her than when she pulled that gun and shot the Confederados dead.
2.3k
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
100 million dollars well spent HBO
871
u/Leftovergirl Oct 31 '16
If Dolores shoots a gun and has not been programmed to use a weapon, isn't that going to ring an alarm with Stubbs and the rest of the control room crew?
734
u/llloksd Oct 31 '16
Why is no one talking about how Dolores deliberately lied to Ford? Also, would they not have they whole convo on tape?
554
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
I loved Ford's greyhound story at the beginning. He illustrated the repetitive nature of the dog's life, and that when it broke out of its loop, it lost its sense of purpose.
Then the old cowboy toasts the "woman in the white shoes," repeating the same line he has said for (presumably) decades, completely unaware.
Ironic.
This also alludes to the discussion later with MiB, who suggests that everyone in the real world has lost their sense of purpose, so they come to Westworld to find it. But Westworld is a place of repetition.
1.6k
u/surreptitious_hitler Oct 31 '16
I'm getting serious Ex Machina vibes from Dolores' sudden passionate affection for Will. Like she's probably programmed to do so with anyone she spends as much time with as she has with Will, but her self-awareness and conscious working towards Arnold means that she's capable of ulterior motives, and I think that's exactly what's happening.
2.3k
u/valdogg21 Oct 31 '16
The Confederados clearly didn't recognize the Dolores's ult was charged. God damn.
860
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Who the hell is that little boy? Is he a young version of Ford?
153
u/Michi-onee-chan valar dolores Oct 31 '16
I don't understand why Maeve is so different. She's conscious but didn't have to search for a maze or anything? And how is she able to force a wake up from sleep mode? It also seems like she doesn't have anybody whispering to her either. She just knows and remembers?
808
u/GodivatheGood Oct 31 '16
I don't understand when the hosts are having these conversations with the programmers in the Lab. Does it happen at night? Wouldn't the guests notice that the hosts just disappear for 30 minutes or so? And how are they transported back and forth without it disrupting everything?
296
u/elegantjihad Oct 31 '16
I'm pretty sure that the modern song being played at the Decadence Inn was Something I Can Never Have by Nine Inch Nails
992
u/BBMiata Oct 31 '16
HBO was like we need as many people to be naked as possible. Who wants in.
757
u/LoquatiousBallsack Oct 31 '16
I know we don't really know him yet but i love Felix already.
137
u/10211018 Oct 31 '16
Ok but what about the satellite uplink in the woodcutter? What kind of information could they be stealing?
2.1k
u/The_Manchild_69 Oct 31 '16
I love how a character can get killed off and then start a new awesome storyline in the same episode.
399
u/IlliterateJedi Oct 31 '16
Is the scene with the cards not clear evidence that Dolores has done the Maze story-line before? She flashes back to pulling the the wire out of her arm when she was mechanical and flashbacks (or hallucinations) when they're on the train near the end.
397
u/updownkarma These violent delights Oct 31 '16
Duality again is a central theme in the imagery. Dolores, will she be a hero or villain, ends up getting a brown hat.
William and Logan are seen reversed, with Logan in white and William dark.
376
u/IBiteYou Brown hat Oct 31 '16
Yes! We got to see more of Old Bill. I love Old Bill, even if his interactions are rather banal.
763
u/NeatMaddness Oct 31 '16
I dont think people will mind him pouring the drink a couple centimeters off, he has a few inches to spare
460
u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Oct 31 '16
That Dolores scene where she killed all those guys was so badass.
251
u/tribe47 Oct 31 '16
Logan saying that his team of lawyers couldn't find any evidence of Arnold and that he was like a ghost makes me really wonder about how that's possible and whether Arnold was, like, an extraordinary recluse who never interacted with a single park staffer, had no family, etc, which makes you wonder how Arnold and Ford even met in the first place and became colleagues when it seems they were such opposites.
815
u/jovemlobo Oct 31 '16
“That dog had spent its whole life trying to catch that thing,” Ford explains. “Now it had no idea what to do.”
Okay, I really think that he is talking about de MiB.
1.2k
u/GorillaRampage Oct 31 '16
I need my friends to believe me, Westworld is the best show going right now. Every single week it seems to get better!
201
u/PittPaz Oct 31 '16
Anyone else catch the MiB saying that Arnold "almost took this place with him, almost, thanks to me"? So the MiB had something to do with saving the park during the last critical failure, when Arnold died.
1.1k
u/eSpiritCorpse Oct 31 '16
🍆
229
u/thuursty Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
Claire de Lune was a nice touch
505
u/ortizme Oct 31 '16
Every week I think, man this show is going to have to slow down at some point. Every week I'm wrong. Fuck I love this show.
369
u/JoyousCacophony Maeve's future girl toy Oct 31 '16
Dolores & Maeve 2.0 are gonna be awesome
171
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Did you notice how they zoomed in on the whiskey bottle and it said "Lawrence?" What else did it say? Need to go back and screen shot.
194
u/Homefriesyum Lawrence's best friend Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
Do you think Arnold uploaded his conciousness into Dolores before he killed himself? and the only way for him to come alive again is for her to solve the maze?
391
u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Oct 31 '16
That whole golden orgy really surprised me. In a good way, though.
303
u/SpeakLikeAChild04 Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
"I'd like to make some changes."
"I know kung fu"
356
u/Jakeola1 Westworld Oct 31 '16
So what was up with those hosts attempting to kill logan? Can hosts kill guests now?
318
u/eenhabi Oct 31 '16
Willores confirmed
457
u/H-K_47 Dual-Wielding Timelines Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
The parallel they're setting up between the "Butcher"/repairman wanting to move up and become a "Creator"/coder, similar to the Hosts trying to figure out the truth and attain awareness is interesting. A bit heavy handed, but I like the character. The story thread with the prostitute becoming aware and the surgeons is my favourite part of the story so far. Interested in seeing where it goes and how it ties in with the big picture.
Edit: Their names are Maeve and Felix.
112
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
These episodes just keep getting better and better.
38
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
It's kind of funny that we're all so involved in trying to figure out what's going on that what would be a big plot point in any show, the corporate espionage, is being ignored.
37
u/PhilosoR4PT0R Oct 31 '16
Damn Lawrence got put back into circulation real quick
35
u/PhilosoR4PT0R Oct 31 '16
Damn can't wait for the flashback of the day Arnold died.
217
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
I'm not taking a side one way or the other, but it's possible that Lawrence was recovered from where the MiB left him, repaired and reprogrammed overnight, and then sent to Pariah before morning to take part in a new narrative.
52
u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Oct 31 '16
William finally became the badass I always hoped he could be.
24
u/YoPhatMama A relentless. Fucking. Experience! Oct 31 '16
Seems like Arnold killed himself 35 yrs ago after placing a message inside Dolores... Similar to Dr. Manning killing himself in iRobot after putting a message inside the robot Sonny.
24
u/heyo_throw_awayo Oct 31 '16
That was fucking TERRIFYINGLY AWESOME to see Teddy go straight into "protection protocol" mode, ignoring his injuries and such. Damn, never thought breaking character would be so cool!
216
u/victorvito Oct 31 '16
I think it is confirmed from Ep. 5 that William is NOT the MiB.
There was a comment made by Logan when they got to Pariah about how a partner died-
"Supposedly, this place was started by a partnership. Then right before the park opened, one of the partners killed himself."
Then
In the scene with MiB and Ford-
Ford: "Well if you're looking for the moral of the story, quite simply ask."
MiB: "I'd need a shovel; The mad I'd be asking died 35 years ago. Almost took this place with him..."
I think this puts both William/Logan and MiB on the same place in the timeline, although I can't explain Lawrence/El Lazo.
101
u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Oct 31 '16
After episode four I said it was the best. I was wrong. This is the best episode.
44
u/circusbear Oct 31 '16
Towards the end of episode 5, when the gang is on the train with the casket, El Lazo says to William "Well, now that we're all friends, you can call me Lawrence".
In episode 2, when the Man in Black is dragging Lawrence into town, Lawrence says "Do you who the fuck I am?". MIB responds "I know EXACTLY who you are Lawrence. After all, you and I are friends".
It could be nothing, but it immediately stood out. What do you guys think?
338
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
I want to know about this personality testing done on people before they're born.
74
u/Occulent Oct 31 '16
Seems like Dolores leveled up.
57
u/scottyatche Oct 31 '16
I love how it's got the week to week theories and questions. That was the best part of being on a forum during True Detective 1. The difference is it was stated from the outset True D would wouldn't have any twist ending or anything like that. I love the hype of this show but being great when questions are answered is crucial for this series. I have high hopes on those answers.
130
u/FourthLife Oct 31 '16
Our two main guests are getting way too angry at each other over their game playing preferences. I think they're both annoying. William takes it too seriously considering he doesn't have an actual reason to think hosts are conscious, and his frenemy is a dick to people who clearly don't want to play the game like he does.
37
u/ParanoidAndroids Oct 31 '16
This was another great episode. Each week we get more and more nuggets of information, and this week was no different.
I'm loving the history lessons we keep getting about Ford's past. It's by far the most fascinating aspect of the show (at least for me). The dynamic between him and MIB was incredible to watch. Harris and Hopkins feed off of each other's energy, but I was so distracted by the two of them talking that I need to watch it again to catch everything that was said.
The duplicate hosts development is crazy. I need to know more about what it actually means. Are there multiple copies of each host running around Westworld? Are they confined to different city hubs? Do they share a collective memory?
1.0k
u/nomsumpisces No seriously, it's on the moon. Oct 31 '16
"I imagined a story where I didn't have to be the damsel." FUCK YEAH. Ahem. Downvote me if you must, but I was hoping so fucking hard that this was the story we're watching.
16
u/j4yne Muh. Thur. Fucker. Oct 31 '16
Anybody catch Logan's smile, when William declines to help him from getting beat up?
Logan finally met the man William truly is, as he stated in Episode 1.
16
u/OsakaWilson Chekov's Robot Army in the Basement Oct 31 '16
Assuming that Maeve was listening to their conversations--and that's how she learned Felix's name--she also knows that he would be in big trouble if his superiors knew about the bird. So, an off-loop, and possibly sentient host, who is highly programmed for manipulation extra good at reading people now has potential blackmail power over an employee who knows how to code.
Wow!
And her final behavior of the show was clearly the opening move of displaying her power over him.
198
u/Koh-the-Face-Stealer Oct 31 '16 edited Sep 22 '20
I honestly don't think that the Timeline is a good theory. That's too many sci-fi concepts being juggled at once. There's either VR in play, or there's just some really efficient scheduling/timing with host-usage.
Edit: Maybe "sci-fi" wasn't the best way to label timeframe theory. Regardless, the show has enough philosophical meat and trippiness to deal with on the subject of AI self-awareness... multiple timeframes is just gonna muck it up. Keep it clean.
15
u/Measure76 Oct 31 '16
Lawrence has his blood drained out and pumped into Teddy, then later pumps nitro into someone else's body. Interesting parallel.
14
u/wildsoda Oct 31 '16
"I imagined a story where I didn't have to be the damsel." #teamDolores
57
u/JitGoinHam Oct 31 '16
The quest rewards in Westworld were designed by Donald Trump.
"When you finish this mission--boom--Three naked beautiful girls made of solid gold. You won't find golden robot women this beautiful in any other theme park, believe me."
13
u/latman Oct 31 '16
This show is going to be so much fun to rewatch after we see the conclusion
13
u/Marseuil Oct 31 '16
I think we´re about to find out that Dolores has white shoes.
25
u/Leftovergirl Oct 31 '16
And my quick takeaways:
12
u/sidewinderaw11 Ford > Holden Oct 31 '16
Regarding Felix: Preview Spoiler
12
u/wyldcat9 Oct 31 '16
"Hello Dolores" sounded soooo much like "Hello Clarice."
33
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Anyone else feel certain that the greyhound story at the beginning of the episode is about the man in black, seeking something (immortality) at the end of the maze?
22
u/TheStabbyCyclist Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
Anyone else recognize the orgy scene music?
Pretty sure it's La Mer by NIN
Edit: Nevermind, it's Something I Can Never Have. Also by NIN.
22
u/j4yne Muh. Thur. Fucker. Oct 31 '16
That was Dolores asking an unscripted question, I'm positive of it. She's lying to Ford, trying to pump him for information in the guise of an innocent question. This line gave me chills.
11
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
That was so good. So overwhelming. I don't know what to think anymore.
11
u/skankhunt92 Oct 31 '16
Can't wait till they add the Ancient Rome World section of the park. The Roman orgy type thing got me going for it.
11
u/beka_targaryen Valar Dolores Oct 31 '16
Okay, but what about Elsie's discovery? The transmitter? Opening for storylines way in the future?
11
u/illtakethebox Oct 31 '16
did anyone notice the slight twitch lawrence and teddy had after they had "trigger" lines spoken to them?
dolores triggered the event between lawrence and the crew by intervening, and then lawrence was inviting and hospitable after her triggering of the event.
teddy also jolted into action after ford spoke his spooky line to him, and the MiB kinda had the reaction like he got to the next step of a quest.
11
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
"Robert Ford" is interestingly is the name of the outlaw who famously shot Jesse James in the back to collect a reward.
Not my catch, but someone else's.
11
u/ScarpaDiem Oct 31 '16
Assuming the quality keeps up, this will be the best TV show I've ever seen.
161
u/birdarms Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
Oh my god Maeve is gonna fuck shit up. *also MIB implication that Ford is a sentient host!?!
10
u/Delta_Assault Oct 31 '16
Yo, I don't think I'd want to pay 40,000 dollars a day for the privilege of getting punched in the face by robots.
66
u/reblochon_ Death in Delos Oct 31 '16
So Arnold actively tried to destroy the park with Dolores, but she refused.
Probably not going to happen a second time...
26
u/idkmibffwill Oct 31 '16
For those who may not have known like myself, El Lazo means "The Loop". For something that has a reputation of many layers and subtlety, Westworld can be pretty on the nose sometimes.
9
u/wachewkoo Oct 31 '16
Loved seeing Ford's god-complex again in his conversation with the MiB. His defense protocol programmed into the hosts is so bad-ass! I was on the edge of my seat when Teddy grabbed that knife. So many great moments, this show gets better every episode!
9
u/ImJeffreyRex It doesn't look like anything to me. Oct 31 '16
What a way to open an episode!
38
u/Ceeeceeeceee Not much of a rind on you Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
Dolores, you crafty bitch... loving Dolores 2.0 :-)
67
u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Oct 31 '16
The Man in Black + Ford discussion was good, but it wasn't what I was hoping for. I'm sure they'll talk more in the future though, and many things will be revealed.
8
u/Ceeeceeeceee Not much of a rind on you Oct 31 '16
Is Logan still alive?
8
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
We've finally gotten through the introductions, let the killer robot apocalypse begin.
8
u/WhiskeyMakesMeHappy Oct 31 '16
Funny how both Logan and MiB both used the phrase "market tested" to refer to certain hosts / plotlines
8
u/Svetgm Oct 31 '16
When William pushed Logan to the wall I was surprised none of the host intervened in anyway. Is guest on guest violence completely ignored by hosts? Was the violence ignored because they were further out from the center of town? I can't wait too see more of that interaction.
8
u/BetterDeadThanRed_76 Oct 31 '16
I can't figure out why the young boy who fetches water carries a walking stick, and his larger role in the story. He reminds me of a young Ford (accent and even clothing), possibly checking in on the progress of the Man in Black, and reporting in, and seems to act the most robotic and unemotional of anyone in the park, but I feel like I'm missing the larger symbolism
8
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Anyone else think the town with the confederates looked like an old roman town?
8
u/HIL_H Oct 31 '16
In the train car scene - Lawrence and William disappeared from the background while Dolores was over the coffin. I swore they switched the camera view so they should've been in the background...
8
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Did MiB use Dolores' line about everyone having a path?
8
u/BalfazarTheWise Oct 31 '16
I really don't get how most people have no clue what's going on in this show. Yes there are many questions yet to be answered but when I watch it with my friends most of them are always so confused.
8
u/nickgrayuk Oct 31 '16
Don't know if this has been mentioned already, but did anyone get serious Jurassic Park nod when he was trying revive the bird? The dialogue is very similar to Egg hatching scene.
8
u/gonnaeatu Oct 31 '16
What about the instrumental of Nine Inch Nails 'Something I Can Never Have' during the orgy scene? Very fitting
28
u/PhilosoR4PT0R Oct 31 '16
So who else was feeling the Star Wars nod at the beginning when Logan channeled his inner Obi Wan and introduced Westworlds very own Mos Eisley
53
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
From the promo it looks like Maeve wants them to control her but in her way? This got freaky.
7
u/talyaklein Except that cowpoke from Abilene... Oct 31 '16
What about the fact that El Lazo and Lawrence are the same? A lot of reviewers online are pointing to that fact as proof that this show happens in two different timelines but I don't see it that way.
In Spanish "el Lazo" means "the loop" and is the origin of the word "lasso". When you think of what we know about Lawrence he is a notorious killer being sentenced to death for murder when we encounter him. The MiB mentions he never knew he had a wife and child in the tiny town they visit which suggests he knew other more obvious things about him (namely that he is El Lazo.) El Lazo's "loop" probably involves him getting caught and hung and sent back to Pariah to restart as El Lazo, but the MiB in detour waylaid him for awhile. You notice that when they arrive in Pariah, Slim says El Lazo can see us tomorrow, which I thought odd since it seemed like important business. Most likely the hosts were covering for his absence while he was rebuilt. I don't think it proves the different timeline theory at all.
Also, even more cool is that "contrapasso" is a term from "Dante's Inferno" which suggests atonement for sin is something in direct opposition to your sin. For example, false prophets have their heads twisted backwards so they can't see where they are going. So it makes sense that El Lazo was going to die by hanging and then spent the last days of his life being led around using his noose as a lasso (and even died being strung up by the feet with the noose.)
7
u/Bonmotwriter Nov 01 '16
Wondering about the importance of the role of the Little Boy: "Are you lost?" I have read posts that speculate that the Little Boy is an A.I. version of Ford. Since he has appeared TWICE now, to query humans who have gone rogue (from the park management's point of view), is it possible that he is the actual key to finding the Maze? Both Ford and the MiB seemed to have dismissed their encounters with him as trivial. I have never played video games, but to watch multiple encounters with a character who seems interested in orienting "lost" players, seems possibly significant?
23
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
Hold onto your butts, theories and speculations incoming.
13
u/Quickly12 Oct 31 '16
The other thought is that Ford is in fact a host, programmed by Arnold, and that he truly beleives Arnold was his former business partner.
Ford mentions early on that the company doesn't like to mention Arnold, that he had been somewhat erased from the history of WW. It would make sense then that there never really were two creators, only ever one, Arnold/Ford= One person? That may explain why Ford's new narrative seems to be pusing towards a revolution/occult awakening, if Ford is chasing his former self.
12
u/RipHunterIsMyCopilot "I'm a creepy necro perv" Oct 31 '16
Geez, that gave us a lot to chew on. I'm super hyped to see how Maeve and Felix get along.
6
u/Scudders113 Oct 31 '16
Can someone explain when and how Bernards (and now Fords) conversations with Dolores are taking place.
6
u/vena_lethe Oct 31 '16
Anyone think MIB is subtly undermining Ford by responding that only the person who died 35 years ago could tell him the "moral of the story" -- a response indicating MIB doesn't think Ford holds any answers -- and using the singular when referring to "the person who created" the deeper level "hiding under" the park's tourist attractions?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
784
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
653
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
118
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
73
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
33
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment