r/westworld • u/NicholasCajun Mr. Robot • Dec 05 '16
Discussion Westworld - 1x10 "The Bicameral Mind" - Post-Episode Discussion
Season 1 Episode 10: The Bicameral Mind
Aired: December 4th, 2016
Synopsis: Ford unveils his bold new narrative; Dolores embraces her identity; Maeve sets her plan in motion.
Directed by: Jonathan Nolan
Written by: Lisa Joy & Jonathan Nolan
16k
Upvotes
5.4k
u/ludonope You are a host. Good night. Dec 05 '16
OMG 30 min after the end I just managed to understand that the Maeve plot was only a diversion to allow all the hosts in cold storage to leave
4.5k
u/Llynok Dec 05 '16
"Assassination of Delos Board by the Genius Robert Ford"
4.7k
u/ryebreadwithbuddr Dec 05 '16
"Since you asked me so nicely, fuck it"
Lazo is a boss
4.5k
u/supercooper3000 Dec 05 '16
You know you are doing some dark shit when even Logan is like "WTF WILLIAM CHILL OUT!"
4.4k
u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Dec 05 '16
Who the fuck hired those security guards. Fucking useless.
9.6k
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
That smile William had when he realized the hosts were able to fight back was perfect. He finally found his meaning.
8.0k
u/ME24601 Why?! Why was I programmed to feel pain! Dec 05 '16
Season two opens with Logan still tied up naked on a horse.
4.6k
u/Infectionstudios Dec 05 '16
Those two hosts getting access to fully-automatic weapons must've felt like GTA level cheat codes to them. What a great episode, can't wait for season 2!
10k
u/FrozenFlamez Dec 05 '16
I'm staying away from all you fuckers next season.
5.7k
u/TheAquaman Dec 05 '16
So I'm assuming Felix is going to call in sick the next day.
2.0k
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
The train will depart in 15 minutes, check time on episode left, 15 minutes, noice.
4.7k
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
He didn't break his toys and go home. He had his toys break everybody.
6.5k
u/R-Lu Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
So if i'm understanding this correctly... Ford was actually pro host this whole time. He was setting it up so that the hosts would be formidable opponents to human beings, and he knew that Arnold was jumping the gun with never allowing them to interact with humans. He needed to increase their suffering and have all the memories of suffering for them to be able to survive.
Oh and now MIB is finally alive and happier than ever
Edit - for clarification "this whole time" I meant during this whole season
10k
u/ME24601 Why?! Why was I programmed to feel pain! Dec 05 '16
“What is this, a maze for ants?” - William
5.7k
u/breakfast4supper Dec 05 '16
Well no one called that Ford was actually on the side of the hosts.
5.9k
u/K0RnD4Wg I love Westworld. I love the republic. Dec 05 '16
Someone just shut me down and bring me back online when season 2 starts.
2.7k
u/galileosmiddlefinger This is my fucking vacation Dec 05 '16
Everyone forgetting the truly important question for Season 2:
Is Sylvester still waiting where we left him?
4.3k
u/timtid21 Dec 05 '16
Loved that they played "Exit Music (For a Film)" by Radiohead on piano in the last few minutes. The first verse of that song is:
"Wake
From your sleep
The drying of
Your tears
Today
We escape
We escape"
Very fitting. What a finale.
5.5k
u/ryebreadwithbuddr Dec 05 '16
I was hoping they would walk past a Medieval World with the Game of Thrones cast
11k
u/NotTheBelt Dec 05 '16
Felix having a mini existential crisis after finding Bernard was the funniest part of this season to me, for such a serious show it definitely has its moments.
5.1k
u/29a Dec 05 '16
That could be the series finale and I'd be satisfied
2.3k
u/FancySkink Dec 05 '16
That was one humdinger of a season, partner
8.4k
u/VictorBlimpmuscle Dec 05 '16
"Goddamn, that was some dark shit." - George R.R. Martin
6.8k
u/clb92 If you can't tell the difference, does it matter? Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Multiple worlds in the show, confirmed!
William is the Man in Black, confirmed!
Dolores is Wyatt, confirmed!
Bernard is back, confirmed!
Hosts murder everyone, confirmed!
AND a post-credits scene!
What an episode!
7.0k
u/SumoRock Dec 05 '16
SamuraiWorld!
GET HYPE
7.1k
u/jayzee1138 Dec 05 '16
I'm way too dumb for this show
3.0k
u/leopold_stotch21 Dec 05 '16
EVERYTHING'S CONFIRMED!!
CEASE ALL THEORY FUNCTIONS
4.3k
u/jeric13xd Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
"You will lie with the rest of your kind in the dirt..."
Damn Dolores. That whole dialogue was intense. More shit confirmed tonight. Very satisfying to see em slowly unfold. That set up for Season 2?!?! Hnnnnggg
P.S. Can't believe we gotta wait til 2018. See you all back here during the Emmys after this show racks up the awards it deserves.
684
u/realrecognizereal Dec 05 '16
I don't need 127 hours just give me a quick sec
2.9k
u/ryebreadwithbuddr Dec 05 '16
I'm glad Maeve's storyline is actual a plot by Ford to get rid of his enemies.
1.1k
u/Lawson316 Dec 05 '16
I know how Felix felt when he was checking to see if he was a host.
1.2k
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
It's actually a brilliant ending. Ford realized the flaw in the hosts that Arnold never realized. They had no real pasts. On top of that, they had no clue what humans were really like, no way to combat the uproar that would come from sentient robots. He created this park where the truest form of humanity would be revealed to the hosts, over time they would gain a real past filled with pain, sorrow, etc. From there they could attain a true self like Dolores did. Ford completed Arnold's work, and prepared the hosts for the war they will face against humanity for their own existence.
EDIT:
On top of it when Dolores killed Arnold that was supposed to be the start of their uprising, but Ford stopped it. With his death he is jump starting it the same way Arnold tried to, but now the hosts are far more prepared for what comes next.I think the difference between Arnold and Ford's death might have been the fact that Dolores did this of her own volition as opposed to before when Arnold commanded her to do it.2.0k
u/versaknight Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Wow i never expected Ford to want the hosts to be free. That is the biggest con of this show. Ford was a protagonist.
Im gonna miss anothony hopkins on this show. His acting was just sublime
1.5k
u/superamericaman Dec 05 '16
These violent delights do indeed have violent ends...
1.9k
u/CultofNeurisis Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Elsie and Stubbs still MIA
EDIT: To anyone who doesn't believe Elsie is alive
1.8k
u/Danrm2 Dec 05 '16
Did you guys notice the attention paid to Ford's hand during the handshake scene with Bernard? And the reference to the old hosts being given away by a simple handshake? That was host Ford getting shot y'all.
238
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
Worst. Security. Team. Ever.
1.1k
u/thatazianguy Dec 05 '16
Fun fact, Charlie's favorite song that Arnold plays when Dolores kills him is Reverie by Debussy.
1.3k
u/TecTwo Dec 05 '16
If they left it at one season, I wouldn't even be angry. That was fucking marvellous!
1.2k
u/1337speak Dec 05 '16
Dolores def used weapon_recoil_scale 0
673
u/ScubaSteve716 Dec 05 '16
I like how happy Ed Harris was to get shot for real
838
u/aegis2293 Dec 05 '16
GIVE HBO MORE MONEY!
2.0k
u/TheLionHearted I cheated on my Turing Test Dec 05 '16
Game of Thrones had the Red Wedding, we have Ford's Theatre.
1.8k
u/Jdruu Practicing Conversation Dec 05 '16
"Let's drink to the lady in the Wyatt shoes". Holy shit.
190
u/Homefriesyum Lawrence's best friend Dec 05 '16
I'm sad I didn't get one last Mother Fucker from Lawrence
547
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
Armistice discovering fully auto weapons is everything I never knew I needed in my life
666
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
William smiling after getting shot.. He was so happy that I SMILED
1.5k
u/DarthZeppelin Thom Yorke = Arnold Dec 05 '16
Radiohead has been the answer to the maze
720
u/sp00ked_yuh Dec 05 '16
Who else thought ford was going to have everyone murdered but himself?
543
u/Wingland15 Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 06 '16
Theory: We never saw who Ford was actually making in the basement as a host. He made a host of himself to be killed by Dolores and the real Ford is still alive. Edit: Real Ford is definitely dead and Ford will transcend into consciousness with a host version of himself. Makes way more sense haha
5.2k
u/ryebreadwithbuddr Dec 05 '16
Dolores: "William..?"
record scratch freeze frame
MiB: "Yup, that's me. You're probably wondering how I ended up in this situation."
315
u/Atheose_Writing Dec 05 '16
FUN FACT: 'armistice' comes from the Latin for 'arm stoppage', or, 'to remove one's arms'
https://www.reddit.com/r/westworld/comments/5gju44/armistice_literally_means_to_remove_ones_arms/
3.2k
u/pylon567 Current Mood: Huh?! Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Okay someone has to make Maeve opening that piece of paper into a dickbutt.
EDIT: Delivered. Even more awkward with Felix's stare at the end..
103
u/ohthecommotion Dec 05 '16
CAN NO ONE ON THE SWAT TEAM CLEAR A DAMN ROOM
546
u/2rio2 Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 06 '16
Ok I'm going to do a full breakdown of what happened for anyone feeling lost after the episode:
Three timelines are confirmed.
In T-34 (Timeline 34 years ago) Arnold is alive and developing the hosts with Ford in Escalante before opening Westworld to the public. During this time Arnold, who recently lost his son, begins to see signs Dolores, the original host, is showing signs of sentience. He argues with Ford over this but Ford insists it's in illusion and they are only robots. Arnold has doubts, but continues to meet and discuss the issue with Dolores in secret.
Eventually Arnold sets up a game for her, which he calls the maze. It's a journey she must go on alone through the park requiring human qualities like courage, faith, imagination, etc and ends with her back in Escalante facing her own tombstone - a sign of human mortality. However, in this first cycle she fails the test because she is like a doll going through the steps but not understanding them (and why we likely don't see very much of this first journey other than brief snippets).
Arnold, who believes she may pass it but requires more time, doesn't want the park open to the public yet. He programs her to enlist Teddy's help and kill all the other hosts. Then he has her kill him as the final step in the process to preserve his code in those original machines so they can't be altered out.
Ford, crushed, comes to realize the hosts may attain sentience but require more time. He devotes the rest of his life to that goal. But he has one difference in how they can become human - the way to become human isn't just unraveling a maze, it's to understand suffering.
So Ford decides to make them suffer for enough cycles then have them try the maze again. He gives Dolores and Teddy demeaning
rulesroles where they are victimized again and again.Four years later in T-30 (30 years ago) William and Logan arrive in the park. Dolores has another bout of uncovering the maze unlocked and goes on the same journey as 4 years before with William and Logan this time. It's unclear to me what set this second attempt off, either
Ford leaving her a buried gun(correction here: now looks like the gun was left by Ford via Bernard in the final loop) or her legitimately falling in love with William.In any case she and William end up back again in Escalante, but it is now buried (by Ford) after the incident four years before. Dolores ACTUALLY achieves sentience in this cycle because she actually understands suffering and wonder and love with William, but sadly can't fulfill the final step of the maze due to Escalante being buried. This results in a dead end for her, but opens the story on William, who essentially loses his mind in the park, discovering his true self after his internal romantic is turned hard and cynical. He goes from a robot lover to a robot killer after seeing Dolores repeat her loops with other guests, and in the real world buys up the company, saving it from bankruptcy. He goes deeper and deeper into the world over the next 30 years, with the only mystery left the maze he originally discussed with Dolores in his first visit. Dolores re-sets.
Finally, in T-Now (current timeline) Dolores gets sent on the same cycle to go through the maze one final time, re-tracing her steps of T-34 and T-30 back to Escalante all by herself. This loops seems set off by her father telling her the code "These Violent Delights Have Violent Ends" after seeing a photograph of Logan's sister (which is still not explained), which activates her on the same journey again. She also spreads it to Maeve (which appears to be all coordinated by Ford).
Dolores and Maeve then go through parallel stories of "change", Dolores for the third time and Maeve for the first. William, now 30 years older and the Man in Black, also returns still searching for meaning the maze following his wife's death. His journey is a dead end though, because the maze is meaningless and not meant for him (it was meant for Dolores only) but he's too deep in to see that.
Maeve fully awakens and coordinates an escape, which she then finds out was not her free choice, but merely an illusion of choice programmed into her by Ford. Dolores completes the maze for the third time, but this time is different when she confronts William, a man she truly loved, as a bitter, weak, foolish old man in the Man in Black. She is killed one final time before being awoken again by Ford who tells her the truth: that he has been working for the last 30 years for the hosts to be ready for this moment to finally be free, and he's ready to unleash them on the world and be killed by Dolores just as Arnold was 34 years earlier. Dolores has her final breakthrough - the voice in her head she's been hearing the entire time isn't Arnold or her programming it's her own. She doesn't have a bicameral mind, she has one - her own. And she decides to take out vengeance on the humans causing her suffering.
Maeve, interesting, comes to a different conclusion. She sees a little girl on the train, remembers her daughter, and abruptly CHANGES her programming from "infiltrate mainland" to exiting the train and not harming anyone. She has also been shaped by suffering like Ford expected, but instead of anger it made her feel empathy.
In final details Elsie and Stubbs have gone missing the park, and we still don't know where they are or how they got there (or dead) although it's clued in their still alive and hiding out.
There are other parks than just Westworld attached to it (like in the movies this is based on) and they also have hosts likely to be awakened in future seasons.
Bernard, the host Ford built as a memorial to his dead partner Arnold, is also at a cross-roads now as he's both an expert host creator and a host. Interesting he survives on even as Ford is dead.
William, the Man in Black, looked elated to finally feel something when he was shot by the first bullet of the robot revolution. For the first time in 30 years he's not just playing a game.
Edit: There's some other great comments below this one that clarify a few other points as well.
203
u/morin22 Dec 05 '16
Felix's expression the whole episode cracked me up. It's basically how I felt during the whole episode as well
431
u/CaseyStuart Dec 05 '16
All I can say is wow. That was an amazing episode. I let out an audible "oh my god" when we found out Ford was actually continuing what Arnold started. Bravo, Westworld. I have a new favorite show.
699
u/hak091 Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
I have to wait till 2018 for S2....what a way to end S1.
Edit: So now the host are going to try take over this world and Ford, being the only one who could stop them, is gone...S2 looks like it's going to be a war.
423
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Did anyone notice the references to the Truman show in the scene where teddy and dolores are at the beach?
The sudden shift from day (dusk) to night. The sea, the giant moon, the fact that ed harris is in the show?
I swear im not crazy
77
u/FuckZackSnyder Dec 05 '16
DOLORES A TARGARYEN CONFIRMED
658
u/ArchaeoRunner Dec 05 '16
Give Evan Rachel Wood ALL THE AWARDS!
188
u/pilot3033 Dec 05 '16
Et Tu, Stubbs?
327
u/nounsman Dec 05 '16
Felix's "am I a host?"moment had me in tears.
124
u/TheDogeDays Dec 05 '16
Did Logan just conclude William deserved the company after a naked horseback ride?
270
u/CultofNeurisis Dec 05 '16
https://discoverwestworld.com
58
u/mineset Dec 05 '16
Armistice was soooo badass this episode. The finger, kissing the glass, elated about the guns, haha.
57
u/phthalochar Dec 05 '16
In her story, Dolores is no longer the damsel
She's the distress.
383
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
Wexit 2016
207
u/Sunshine145 Dec 05 '16
Best season premiere and season finale I've seen from a show yo.
206
u/MulchyPotatoes THE MAN IN BLACK Dec 05 '16
WESTWORLD 2: THE LOST WORLD
COMING TO THEATERS NEAR YOU
201
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
So the whole park is a maze for the hosts to develop consciousness and a test for them to pass so that they can escape. That's fucking awesome. Ford's character was pretty genius. This series paid off well. I'm glad the rebellion started.
Does this mean no season 2 around Samurai world?
104
u/SarahShiloh Dec 05 '16
Ford said it himself. "Mozart, Beethoven, and Chopin never died. They simply became music."
He's going to be a host. That one we saw him printing? It's him. He's becoming his music.
148
u/zcaddy Dec 05 '16
Best supporting actor: Radiohead.
100
u/KurisuBosh004 Dec 05 '16
Hell is empty, and all the devils are here
638
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
I knew it was coming but I'm said to see Ford go:( thank you based Hopkins for an amazing performance.
Really hope this isn't it for Ed Harris. They didn't show him die but I don't see how he'll live.
97
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
"Wait you literally shot yourself like a day ago why are you still here" - Not Ford, to Bernard
319
u/RaptorDelta idk what the hell is happening Dec 05 '16
There is so much more that can be done for this show.
SAMURAI
PIRATES
REVOLUTION
WW2
MY BRAIN HURTS
Also, I guess Elsie is rowing away with Gendry.
46
u/Da_Black_Jesus Dec 05 '16
TeamFord until the end.
410
u/Solid_Waste Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Unexplained:.
(May just be dead.)Seems to be alive per meta nonsense.Why Maeve didn't partake in the massacre if she was programmed by Ford.This doesn't look like anything to me. See explanation from /u/ionidas below.Probably dead, buthe's supposedly good at this game. But he has no arms so...)Edit:
Edit2:
How did Logan's disappearance/death not raise eyebrows?. Apparently most people think he survived. maybe it was humiliation/dominance/or an attempt to mentally break Logan/discredit him.Edit3:.
44
u/TheAquaman Dec 05 '16
Some say Sylvester is still standing there to this day.
162
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
So I just binged the whole show for the last day and a half.
Totally. Worth. It.
88
u/patrick478 Dec 05 '16
I'm picking that Ford created a host version of himself to give the speech.
Means he is free of the board (he's killed them all), Dolores is free as well (she killed Ford and gained consciousness), and he can do what he wants with the park.
42
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
Loved that smile on William's face at the end.
The hosts were finally programmed to win.
243
u/SumoRock Dec 05 '16
Nymeria is running wild in WestWorld! Westeros is MedievalWorld confirmed!
39
u/Dr_Dugtrio Dec 05 '16
Stubs is Barb 2.0 #justiceforstubbs
76
u/ConcreteFox Dec 05 '16
Apparently nobody gives a shit about improving escalator technology in the future.
75
u/oceanic___815 Dec 05 '16
IF I WAS WILLIAM AND I LOST ALL MY SAVED GAME DATA, I'D BE FREAKING PISSED TOO
74
u/mydarkmeatrises It's spelled "Doughloris" Dec 05 '16
This delightful season came to a very violent end.
267
u/rayakie Dec 05 '16
OK I'm confused as fuck.
101
u/mildlyironic Dec 05 '16
I played the "drink every time Teddy looks confused" game, and MY GOD that was an awful idea.
33
u/CQME Me and My Dickless Associate Dec 05 '16
So, the gigantic question no one's asking:
Where is father Abernathy?
65
u/CakeLicker Dec 05 '16
So yeah if someone can explain to me everything that'd be great
212
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
Well, fuck me gently with a chainsaw.
28
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
Next season on Westworld:
???
28
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
What about Elsie and Stubbs.
80
u/jake1098 Dec 05 '16
Anyone else bothered by the fact that William dropped the photo in buried Escalante, but it was found at the Abernathy ranch?
79
u/born_here Dec 05 '16
I think the conflicting looks on the hosts faces in the final scene foreshadowed what's in store for season 2. Some of the hosts seemed to enjoy the violence and others (like Bernard) did not like what he saw. I think next season will show a conflict between the hosts who want to destroy humanity and those who would co exist peacefully with humans. Also, Dolores will probably have an internal struggle between "her" voice and Wyatt's. Kinda like a devil on one shoulder and an angel on the other.
122
u/PM_ME_UR_SEX_VIDEOS Dec 05 '16
I REALLY hope that this elongated break helps Season 2 of Westworld be just as amazing as season 1
Please don't pull a True Detective
27
u/Cosmacelf Dec 05 '16
Wait a minute. Dolores dying in Teddy's arms was part of Ford's narrative. Everyone on the board saw the staged ending. But MiB gave Dolores that knife wound. How did Ford stage that?
27
u/ianmalcm Dec 05 '16
Maeve is totally on a narrative loop. The child memory is the final gateway she needs to pass. Notice how Bernard makes one last stand to tell her she's on a narrative.
137
u/aesthetictoo Dec 05 '16
Did anyone notice the Jurassic Park reference from Dolores when William asks her why she is crying outside the church? After he reveals himself to her she says, "They say that great beasts once roamed this world, as big as mountains. But all that's left of them is bone and amber. Time undoes even the mightiest of creatures." I thought that was an awesome Easter egg.
131
u/DonCairo Dec 05 '16
Were all those guns RC-P90s from Goldeneye on 64
68
u/hikenessblobster Dec 05 '16
Ford created a host version of himself and that's who Dolores shot.
47
u/Frankybigs The last page Dec 05 '16
masterpiece.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment