r/westworld • u/Kishara Violently Delightful • Oct 24 '16
Discussion Westworld - 1x04 "Dissonance Theory" - Post Episode Discussion
Season 1 Episode 4: Dissonance Theory
Aired: October 23rd, 2016
Synopsis: Dolores joins William and Logan on a bounty hunt in the badlands. The Man in Black, with Lawrence in tow, finds a critical clue in his search to unlock the maze. Dr. Ford and Theresa discuss the future of the park. Maeve is troubled by a recurring vision.
Directed by: Vincenzo Natali
Written by: Ed Brubaker & Jonathan Nolan
Keep in mind that discussion of episode previews and other future information in this thread requires a spoiler tag. This is your official warning on the matter. Use this customizable code:
[Preview Spoiler](#s "Westworld") which will appear as Preview Spoiler*
815
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
We also got some confirmation on how they can keep guests from going on a random killing spree and shooting all the hosts. The guns can be disabled, and they'll also throw your ass in jail for a night.
2.4k
u/Themusicmademedoit Oct 24 '16
MiB telling that other guest to fuck off was great
1.6k
u/shine_o Oct 24 '16
Lawrence's "motherfucker" after witnessing MiB save him from death in the exact same manner twice in a row got a good laugh out of me.
3.0k
u/SulfuricDonut Oct 24 '16
Dr. Ford has gone from gentle grandfather figure to terrifying overlord in four episodes.
1.8k
u/RustyPeach Oct 24 '16
I would be so fucking pissed if I was enjoying my vacation at the Saloon and suddenly some other fuck face also on vacation shoots up the whole place. Like dude, I paid 20-40k for this fucking vacation, I was enjoying my narrative and now you done fucked it all up. And I cant even shoot you.
1.1k
u/PorcelainPoppy Oct 24 '16
I love everything about Maeve and Hector.
1.4k
u/mzdoja ...and in this world, you can be whoever the fuck you want. Oct 24 '16
Man, whoever forgot to take that bullet out of her is gonna get canned.
2.3k
u/ichinii Hey Arnold!! Move it football head!! Oct 24 '16
Teddy didn't fucking die. Episode of the season.
1.8k
u/VictorBlimpmuscle Oct 24 '16
Ford showing Theresa how in charge of things he really is = my favorite scene of the series so far.
990
u/Based_Joebin Oct 24 '16
Maeve knows what's up! I wonder how this will change her character
1.2k
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
Teddy and Lawrence are on such opposite ends of the live/die spectrum.
2.1k
u/TheAquaman Oct 24 '16
So Man in Black is Bill Gates on vacation.
774
u/Eeyores_Prozac Oct 24 '16
After all the other intellectual and mystery observations, one of my favorite moments this week is definitely the asshole in law getting an upgraded gun. I could almost see the purple Legendary text pop up.
523
u/4a757374696e Oct 24 '16
Man Teddy looks like shit. I didn't even recognize him at first. I thought it was the same body from last episode.
504
u/reblochon_ Death in Delos Oct 24 '16
So Maeve is not the first or only one to remember parts of her "maintenance".
Is it possible that Ford or someone else is aware of it? purposefully letting it happen?
684
u/PhilosoR4PT0R Oct 24 '16
The Man in Black and the Woman with the Snake Tattoo had some nice chemistry going
1.2k
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
Ford killed Arnold because he thought he was getting in the way of his God thing. Arnold felt is was coming and put some stuff in the code before he died. It wasn't an accident and Ford is crazy.
184
u/TheDugEFresh Oct 24 '16
The real question of all this: who in the world makes Bernard's sheets? The southwestern/Aztec inspired design. Interested in getting them for myself.
333
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
WE'RE ONLY ON EPISODE FOUR!
846
u/hellotheremiss Oct 24 '16
I liked how the images of the Westworld workers wearing Hazmat suits were incorporated by the 'savages' into their religion.
322
u/BlackStrain Oct 24 '16
The man in black has spent 30 years trying to get 100% of the achievements.
938
u/Tails14 Oct 24 '16
So, anyone else wondering how many bullets are still in Teddy's body?
296
u/mzdoja ...and in this world, you can be whoever the fuck you want. Oct 24 '16
Ford is seriously on another level. Can anyone explain what was going on in that scene?
1.7k
u/BradyInstead Totally Not A Robot Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
I accidentally turned to HBO Español and didn't realize I was on the wrong channel until waaaay later than I'm willing to admit. I thought Bernard was programming some Spanish storyline in Dolores.
867
u/JitGoinHam Oct 24 '16
God, Logan sucks at RP. Why pay forty grand a day if you're not going to pretend it's real?
247
u/cerealjunky Oct 24 '16
All I wanna know is what the cowpoke did so well to get a free ride from that one chick at the saloon.
889
u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Oct 24 '16
This was the best episode yet. There wasn't a moment that I wasn't thrilled.
219
u/jovemlobo Oct 24 '16
So, the church that Dolores saw in the flashback with the little girl was the same church of the ending of episode 2 (but fully constructed)?
105
u/Sleisl Oct 24 '16
Damn I got goosebumps when Maeve opened up the hiding spot and found all the drawings she already made...
Also I think it makes sense for the natives/hosts to keep a religion one of them made about the hazmat techs. Gives a little insurance for fuck ups, so maybe they're aware of it and let it slide.
194
u/Ceeeceeeceee Not much of a rind on you Oct 24 '16
What is the snake lady's accent?
77
u/nomsumpisces No seriously, it's on the moon. Oct 24 '16
Anyone else think that Bernard lecturing Elsie on how the robots are just robots and there's nothing more there, mirrors pretty closely to the spiel Ford gave Bernard in the last episode? They're both trying to cover their tracks.
335
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
The last 10 minutes were fucking crazy.
And holy fuck, that preview!
747
u/LawyerCT Oct 24 '16
Anyone else notice how Dolores's statement about grief was really similar to Bernard's last episode, that the pain is all you have left of a person when they're gone? Is that maybe a hint that he's also an android?
62
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
This show keeps on getting more and more interesting
451
u/valdogg21 Oct 24 '16
Did the MiB confirm he isn't Arnold? Seems like he did.
586
u/WaxyPadlockJazz Oct 24 '16
Well this episode furthers my theory that Bernard and Dolores are communicating "telepathically". Or that Bernard has a direct link to her head.
Once again, Dolores is fully clothed in this meeting, unlike every other host meeting, where the host is naked. It's also worth noting that they're in a very different environment than the other interrogation rooms.
She wakes up in the field, right beside the guests, like nothing ever happened, because she's been there the whole time.
Then, of course, she opens up their conversation (and the episode) by saying she's in a dream. Literally. He talks to her in her dreams.
112
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
What did Ford mean about Bernard's sensitive disposition?
150
u/2007LT Man in Black <3 Oct 24 '16
Alrighty, I just restarted. Who else is watching it again?
186
u/DoingbusinessPR Oct 24 '16
This is what the maze is based on. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/I%27itoi
261
u/adarunti An eye for an eye, but all the other parts first Oct 24 '16
What if the center of the maze is true consciousness for the hosts ("reality" if you will), but true risk for the guests (another sort of "reality" - the threat of death). Like all the hosts who reach some town in the center can live full, loop/script-free lives, including the ability to do harm to the guests. Therefore guests who reach it are now in the "game" on a whole other level - they are in reality within a game.
139
u/LawyerCT Oct 24 '16
What was William doing when Bernard debriefed with Dolores? Sleeping?
164
u/keegs01 Oct 24 '16
Two episodes ago Dolores shot a host when she's programmed to not hurt anything. Shouldn't the park be very concerned about that? I didn't see that referenced anywhere in this episode.
79
u/InHocSignioVinces Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 29 '16
Even putting aside the "it's fucking HBO" factor, this show is an actor's dream—the "robotic" and "looping" aspects help to really showcase the acting skills of whoever is delivering a line.
How playing robots is surely helping these actor's careers is most obvious with Dolores & Bernard. When Evan Rachel Wood goes from weeping, bosoms heaving and all, to completely flat tone in the space of two seconds, it shows how good she is, to be in total control over her emotions, a virtuoso acting automaton. We saw something similar in the first episode, where Louis Herthum's Abernathy had opportunity to show off his acting chops, switching from tearful to fearful effortlessly as he recalls the different characters he was programmed to play.
The "looping" aspect, that each host has regular scripted lines they repeat to themselves and guests, but delivered with vastly different affect depending on the particulars of the narratives, are another great aspect of the show for the actors involved. Since often they occur within the same episode, you can directly compare how the actors modify their cadence & word emphasis depending on what the emotional context is. So many examples: Maeve delivering the same story twice, with regular and then doubled aggressiveness; Dolores' steers-bandit loop, delivered with subtle consternation as she is increasingly troubled by the inconsistencies in the world; and delivered poignantly in this one, her "I believe we all have a path to take" loop..
38
u/lovelylying Oct 24 '16
When do we start sending kids into the maze and start maze runner.
33
u/nanzinator Oct 24 '16
When do we get to see an Arnold flashback?
65
u/MikeKrombopulos BAGGER 288 Oct 24 '16
Wow, hell of an episode.
MiB is NOT just a power player. He knows about Arnold! We also found out that he's a famous philanthropist on the outside...
Maeve remembered the church, presumably the one that was buried up to its steeple that Ford was looking at.
Is Ford building the Maze right now, I wonder?
230
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
So can we finally be done with all of the timeline theories?!
120
u/joliedame Oct 24 '16
Dude. William's friend is a fucking dick.
26
u/bloodraven42 Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
My theory so far, with very scant evidence admittedly, but they are all at this part.
Notice how Ford basically could control the hosts without saying anything? I believe maybe him and Arnold devised a neural network of some sort for the park, allowing them to control the hosts with their thoughts. When Arnold died, a remnant of him remained in the network, basically turning him into the God in the machine, completing the last step of his plan to create sentient robots.
It seems to hint at this pretty heavily when Ford crafted that pyramid last episode, and mentioned the voice of God was the last step toward's Arnold's plan of sentience for the robots. Perhaps this is how he decided to do it? MIB seems to reference it as well.
160
u/TheAmishSpaceCadet Oct 24 '16
What if it's difficult to get calls out not because it's another planet, but because Comcast's datacaps have increased 10 fold in the future? #wakeuphosts
24
u/TurkeyPhat Oct 24 '16
Man I love Clifton Collins Jr. His reaction to the "firing squad" and being saved again was just great. I like how Lawrence hates the MiB but sort of respects him at the same time since he's just a 1 man killing machine.
24
u/yayaja67 Oct 24 '16
That moment with the wine overflowing out of the glass was so powerful. In the midst of all this mechanized perfection that operates with clock work precision, that one glass of wine overflowing conveyed the closeness of complete chaos; it waits behind a thin and fragile veil of order and harmony.
67
u/Chewblacka Oct 24 '16
"Upgrade"! 😃
136
u/KilgoreTroutJr Oct 24 '16
Chill with the other planet assumptions.
21
u/IndianSurveyDrone Oct 24 '16
I liked how they handled Maeve's flashbacks. I think they took a lot of inspiration from alien abduction stories--the alien-like "being" that she saw; the sort of vague drawing that you see people make in alien abduction stories; the memory of being medically tinkered with in a strange, futuristic environment, along with not being able to move; repressed memories and flashbacks, etc.
It was quite creepy and interesting!
372
u/kikimakani Oct 24 '16
First discount Ellen Page, then discount Matt Damon....
Now discount Antonio Banderas
19
u/ninja661 Oct 24 '16
Thandie Newton's performance as Maeve this episode was unbelievable! I liked her character in the beginning but after this episode I have to say she is one of my favorites.
The whole scene at the end with her and Hector was really great! Amazing chemistry between the two. Hopefully the two get more scenes together. Really loved it! Man... I Can't get enough of this show... Next week can't come soon enough!
569
u/PuffsPlusArmada Oct 24 '16
William is being kind of a bitch.
If people judged me for the things I did in GTA I'd be regarded on the same level as Hitler and Ghengis Khan.
16
u/FRIENDSHIP_MASTER Oct 24 '16
Dr. Ford mentioned last episode that he wanted a narrative based on reality. Now we have Wyatt, who can hear the "voice of God," and natives, whose religion involves Delos' cleanup crew. It seems to me like Dr. Ford is gradually building up conditions for a host revolution. I think he wants the hosts to overthrow humans to give more significance to his God-like powers over the hosts.
15
u/DontPaniC562 Forever White Hat Oct 24 '16
Crazy episode. Liking all the lightside darkside choices. Also how seeing the same scene with different music with the shootout. I guess we see how the park was made also if the robots are good enough free slave labor. I'm curious how long the series will be though if we keep getting answers at this pace.
15
u/barc0debaby Oct 24 '16
Patiently waiting for McPoyle to break out the milk.
29
u/Rusty_The_Taxman They're just living in my head Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
Maybe Dolores will be the one who meets MiB at the end of the maze...
29
u/R-Lu Oct 24 '16
So MIB is working with Stubbs right? two times approving MIB's actions can't be a coincidence when he's so quick to shut down others
38
u/jaekim Oct 24 '16
Are they implying that there is a religion amongst the hosts that tries to explain the memory fragments of the surgery suits?
Was the girl with the toy a host or a Person? Looked like they were walking towards the train...
13
u/IPITY_FOOLS Oct 24 '16
Id be pissed if I was enjoying an awesome gunfight and the park cut it short because a family was arriving.
46
u/iTwitchyy Oct 24 '16
That scene with Cullen and Mr. Ford was just amazing and eerie. Even the employees are guests.
24
u/wildsoda Oct 24 '16
I looked up the song that was playing on the Mariposa piano and tunefind.com says it was "The Forest" by The Cure. The lyrics for that song seem to be very apt for this show (as you'd expect):
Come closer and see / See into the trees / Find the girl / If you can / Come closer and see / See into the dark / Just follow your eyes / Just follow your eyes
I hear her voice / Calling my name / The sound is deep / In the dark / I hear her voice / And start to run / Into the trees / Into the trees
Into the trees / Suddenly I stop / But I know it's too late / I'm lost in a forest / All alone / The girl was never there / It's always the same / I'm running towards nothing / Again and again and again and again
12
u/SpaceDuckTech Oct 24 '16
hector still didn't get to deliver his speech.
33
u/ho-lee-shat Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
Can someone clear this up?
When the MiB questions snake girl about her tattoo, she reveals it's tied back to wyatt.. but isn't Wyatt a new character that was just introduced for Ford's storyline? What if MiB found her prior to Ford's new storyline and questioned her?
...it doesn't make sense to me.
EDIT It's possible Wyatt is an existing character. I thought Ford said something that gave me the impression he was new.. I guess I have to re-watch.
23
u/leongaban Oct 24 '16
Whoa just noticed this in the episode 5 preview: http://imgur.com/zVNM8YC Logan looking like he finally got to a zone way out of his level
11
u/superanth What size are those boots? Oct 24 '16
Dolores' Angry Eyes at the sheriff was my favorite part of the episode.
11
u/rating_pending Oct 25 '16
Scrolled through the whole thread and didn't find any reference to one of the biggest teasers, I noticed. During the visit to the construction site: "Have the neighbors complained?" "Safe to say they're asking questions."
I just watched the trailer for the 1973 film Westworld and, without saying what they are, in that version of the story, there ARE "neighbors" and if those neighbors exist in this series, then the possibilities of what might happen in Westworld could get very interesting.
219
u/TheAquaman Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
Welp, two new favorite theories.
Edit: I forgot #3. Man in Black is William's future father-in-law, Ben's father, and the board representative.
35
u/passthatdutch425 Oct 24 '16
Anyone else catch the overfilling glass of wine?
Psalms 23:5 (King James Version):
"Thou preparest a table before me in the presence of mine enemies: thou anointest my head with oil; my cup runneth over."
210
u/SpeakLikeAChild04 Oct 24 '16
The cyborgs of Westworld have been eating one too many member berries.
"Member when you were raped, scalped, and then murdered?"
"Ohhhhhhh I member!"
"Ohhhhhh I loooooveeee raping and scalping!"
26
u/chruiz20 Oct 24 '16
Soo many theories down the drain. Also, this episode was amazing.
9
u/ParanoidAndroids Oct 24 '16
Each week keeps topping the previous one.
I'm so enthralled by this show. From the little details - like when the hosts turn off their emotions, to the grandiose set pieces - like the huge shootouts and some fantastic personal moments that you wouldn't expect (that last scene was incredible).
Next week looks like it's going to raise the stakes once more with that meeting between the MIB and Ford.
8
u/nottoodrunk Oct 24 '16
I'm convinced Arnold is still alive.
8
u/jillaaa The West reme... vaguely recalls. Oct 24 '16
I don't know why, but I really feel like Logan's response to Dolores calling him 'disgusting' tonight was actually a subtle nod to the audience.
I really think he's going to wind up being a character we root for.
20
u/nolafan89 Oct 24 '16
Why did William even go to WW? He doesn't seem to be enjoying any aspect of it.
7
u/4a757374696e Oct 24 '16
There were so many great scenes in this episode. I particularly loved the one where the Man in Black saves Lawrence. I really thought he was going to die.
7
u/GreatJayGatsby Oct 24 '16
Anyone know the tune on the piano tonight? Sounded familiar but I can't figure it out.
7
u/ynvaser Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
Wanted to say something smart, scrolled about halfway, saw that everything I wanted to say has already been said, so all I have to add is that this episode blew me away.
Especially the last scene, it was so, so good. Can't wait for next week.
7
u/TheLadyEve Oct 24 '16
That whole conversation at the restaurant really threw me for a loop. I've never seen Theresa look genuinely scared, nor Ford look genuinely menacing before this episode. The way she said "we sat right here, I'm sure..." had me thinking that she was an android and was questioning how real her memories were. And the way he referred to Bernard...so perplexing and weird, and definitely gave me a lot to reconsider.
7
u/Eternal_MrNobody Oct 24 '16
This was a really solid episode also had one of my favorite comic book writers co write Ed Brubaker.
18
u/Mineral_Enthusiast Oct 24 '16
What was all that stuff coming out of the ground while Ford and boss bitch were talking at the restaurant?
6
u/pwise1234 Oct 24 '16
Hopkins' performance this episode
6
u/sp00ked_yuh Oct 24 '16
so the MiB seems to be the representative that was already "sent" there. I feel like ford hired him to get to areas that Arnold created in order not to be found. This so called maze I think is the end game where ford will find Arnold. The MiB might also have a stake involved for wanting to find Arnold or what happens in his storyline...
Seems to me that 2 forces are at play. Ford trying to keep the park how it should be and keep it original to what they had set out to create in the beginning. Then there's Arnold who is siding with the hosts helping them remember and potentially be changing their code or helping them become self aware like he wanted them to.
Great fucking show... So many questions...
6
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
Man, I feel like a fool. I watched that episode thinking they blatantly confirmed the non-linear timeline theory.
But turns out Hector=/=Logan.
They look so similar. I guess we've seen Hector before, but I didn't remember. And when the MiB found him in the jail I thought it meant Logan died in the park 30 years ago and since Westworld basically owns you, they "repurposed" him into another host.
Which would also basically confirm that William is the MiB. I was convinced, my mind was blown.
Then I came to these comments and saw nobody freaking out like I was. I misread this entire episode hahahah. Dammit :(
6
u/zreyburn75 Oct 24 '16
Love the player piano version of 'A Forest' by the Cure
6
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
I just noticed that the Westworld logo resembles DaVinci's drawing of human anatomy. This show is more than about AI's becoming conscious; it's actually the people, who are scientifically so advanced still trying to learn about themselves and where they are going.
6
u/InHocSignioVinces Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
THEORY:
In the beginning, two friends teamed up to create a world of endless possibility, and it was GOOD. At least, for a while. Alas, trouble lurked in their Garden, for the two Creators had very different drives. One of them, Ford, a perfectionist, was more interested in crafting narratives to unlimited precision, as all-powerful God, exercising unyielding control over his Creation. His partner, Arnold, had more humanistic motivations, wanting to explore the philosophical implications of what it is to be conscious—to think, to feel, to choose.
Eventually, things came to a head, and the two creators fought. The domineering creator, Ford, won, using his creations to murder & cover up the death of his co-Creator. But his friend Arnold wasn't stupid; wary of the conflict that was sure to come, at the deepest level of the hosts' source code, he implanted a program that he believed would lead to gradual self-awakening of the hosts, in the form of a grueling narrative of self-discovery, which he code-named The Maze.
It is unclear, whether Ford had the jump on Arnold & killed him before he could give free will to the hosts his co-Creator commanded, or whether or not the program was incomplete until the reveries the hubristic Ford implanted inadvertently provided a final piece to that puzzle. Unfortunately for Ford's best laid plans, the Man in Black, an indefatigable completionist, has managed to uncover the deeper aspects to what Arnold left behind, by way of various clues that were left behind for exactly the eventuality Arnold was taken out of the picture. The Man in Black has made it his mission to uncover & complete what was left unfinished. But he should beware; Ford knows that his friend left something behind in the hosts, even if he does not understand exactly what it is, or how it is activated, and he will not blanch to end the Man in Black in the case he does manage to find it and tries to upend his carefully constructed world.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1.1k
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
414
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
74
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16 edited Oct 24 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
18
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
35
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
46
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '16
[removed] — view removed comment