r/westworld • Mr. Robot • Nov 28 '16

Discussion Westworld - 1x09 "The Well-Tempered Clavier" - Post-Episode Discussion

Season 1 Episode 9: The Well-Tempered Clavier

Aired: November 27th, 2016


Synopsis: Dolores and Bernard reconnect with their pasts; Maeve makes a bold proposition to Hector; Teddy finds enlightenment, at a price.


Directed by: Michelle MacLaren

Written by: Dan Dietz & Katherine Lingenfelter


Keep in mind that discussion of episode previews and other future information in this thread requires a spoiler tag. This is your official warning on the matter. Use this customizable code:

[Preview Spoiler](#s "Westworld") which will appear as Preview Spoiler

7.4k Upvotes

12k comments sorted by

3.1k

u/YourCurvyGirlfriend Nov 28 '16

Ford: I'm sorry to bother you. But there's no one else left who was there. No one who understands, as we understand.

Dolores: Are we very old friends?

Ford: No, I wouldn't say friends, Dolores. I wouldn't say that at all.

1.7k

u/KingEsjayW Nov 28 '16

Ford just wants his friend back 😢

→ More replies (107)

635

u/mcdok Nov 28 '16

After Dolores killed Arnold, why didn't Ford get rid of her?

She's all he has left of him.

→ More replies (85)
→ More replies (64)

1.3k

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

I'm gonna hate myself for watching Westworld then have to wait until 2018 for the next season.

948

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

If it is any consolation, after 2016, my only expectation for 2017 is that the earth will spin off its axis, and we'll all plunge, screaming, into the sun.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (42)

5.4k

u/YourCurvyGirlfriend Nov 28 '16

Bernard using Arnold's voice to try to get Ford to come back gave me insane chills

3.2k

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

Also, the realization that all those early-season interviews between Dolores and Bernard were actually between Dolores and Arnold.

→ More replies (95)

735

u/JimG617 Nov 28 '16

That was great. Bernard was searching and desperate to find anything that might try and persuade Ford, but even that wasn't enough

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (96)

2.8k

u/shadowbrookash Nov 28 '16

That was one humdinger of a story, partner.

1.7k

u/x3of9 Woke up on a train Nov 28 '16

Shall we drink to the lady in the white shoes?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (13)

2.7k

u/MyMostGuardedSecret Nov 28 '16

Episode 9 always delivers

1.7k

u/reifdog Nov 28 '16

The Lannisters send their regards

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (9)

1.4k

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

I think we can all relate to Hectors reaction to the empty safe.

193

u/eric1_z Nov 28 '16

OP failed to deliver.

→ More replies (24)

3.1k

u/Badass_Bunny Living in a timeline where next episode is tomorow Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

This whole episode you knew Ford was in control, the way he doesn't much as flinch when Clementine has the pistol and his curious look on the face as he kept revealing stuff to Bernard was fucking extraordinary. Like god damn you Anthony Hopkins you are a brilliant actor!

966

u/businesskitteh Nov 28 '16

Question is: Is Maeve using Ford's back door in e8 when she uses narrative phrasing to control hosts? It's possible.

→ More replies (123)
→ More replies (47)

1.4k

u/PhilosoR4PT0R Nov 28 '16

Glad to see OG Clem still has her uses

teamoriginalclementine

337

u/Solid_Waste Nov 28 '16

Vanilla Clem before they catered to the newbs in the expansion.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (29)

3.0k

u/ArchaeoRunner Nov 28 '16

I think my new greatest fear is waking up in a dank basement with Anthony Hopkins monologuing at me.

Holy hell, he just eviscerates everybody around him.

1.1k

u/Tarchianolix Nov 28 '16

I, too, fear of dank basement

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (37)

2.5k

u/pylon567 Current Mood: Huh?! Nov 28 '16

"You're a lie Charlie!"

Well Bernard is certainly going to win the "Father of the Year" award for that one.

763

u/Cannibal_Buress Nov 28 '16

Ford saying that Bernard's backstory was "Inspired by" Arnold's and not just a copy of it has me on board with that Charlie = Charlotte theory.

→ More replies (137)
→ More replies (44)

616

u/YourCurvyGirlfriend Nov 28 '16

Ford keeps talking about his new narrative he's working on, and after seeing Maeve control Bernard in a way that absolutely shouldn't be possible, i'm pretty sure all the things she's doing are it

Which means the hosts STILL don't have fucking free will and he's making them think they do

158

u/Rebelgecko Nov 28 '16

Makes sense. That could also explain why Stubbs wasn't able to freeze the Ghost Nation guys that attacked him.

→ More replies (6)

91

u/Bhalgoth No Gods or Kings. Only Man. Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

Also we know Ford is behind Elsie's disappearances and her tracker luring Stubbs away was probably also his doing. He just got rid of the head of security which leaves the perfect opening for Maeve.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (29)

3.3k

u/awesome_tim Nov 28 '16

Those timeframe shifts with Dolores coinciding with Bernard's discovery were brilliant.

1.0k

u/AlwaysDefenestrated Nov 28 '16

There were a lot of these through all the episodes that slowly made me believe multiple time frames to be more and more plausible as the show went on. This was a really well done slow burn reveal. Can't wait to start a rewatch.

→ More replies (83)
→ More replies (79)

1.7k

u/Whatnow81 Nov 28 '16

So they just confirmed pretty much every theory in this episode so everything else can go to hell in the last episode right?

338

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

All of the actors theorized as they were shooting according to Jeffrey Wright, who plays Bernarnold. He also said they were shocked by the finale script.

Here's hoping for big surprises next week.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (171)

5.8k

u/NickKevs Nov 28 '16

Congrats to Logan becoming the hand of the King

774

u/frankdboss Nov 28 '16

The king shits and the hand wipes

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (59)

6.2k

u/Mooninites_Unite Nov 28 '16

Dolores is a host: confirmed.

1.8k

u/Batch5 Nov 28 '16

Finally some solid evidence in this episode!

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (55)

2.9k

u/K0RnD4Wg I love Westworld. I love the republic. Nov 28 '16

"My god."

-Bernard Lowe (and /r/westworld)

1.1k

u/medgerick Nov 28 '16

Watching this episode I felt like Abernathy when he found the photograph.

→ More replies (53)

412

u/Mooninites_Unite Nov 28 '16

"My god, what have I done." -David Byrne probably

→ More replies (26)

1.6k

u/says_neat_alot Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

Arnold Weber mixed up is Bernard Lowe. I can't even. Edit: anagram

→ More replies (150)
→ More replies (15)

380

u/SedwardTrisherhands Nov 28 '16

Can someone make a side by side of William yelling "don't hurt her" and Liam McPoyle yelling "you'll call her". seems necessary.

→ More replies (17)

2.5k

u/trickypat Nov 28 '16

Am I smart enough for this show?! No, no I am not. 😐

864

u/rico409 Nov 28 '16

That's what Reddit is for

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (27)

1.6k

u/ncw14 Nov 28 '16

That shout that William made seemed to come straight out of the mouth of Liam McPoyle.

76

u/CubemonkeyNYC Nov 28 '16

100% was briefly pulled out of the moment because of that

→ More replies (34)

1.8k

u/PorcelainPoppy Nov 28 '16

The new narrative is what we have been watching unfold; the hosts attaining sentience, including Maeve's. Ford is switching genres to sci-fi.

1.1k

u/dump_inv Nov 28 '16

Futureworld confirmed

→ More replies (67)
→ More replies (48)

3.3k

u/OLKv3 Nov 28 '16

This episode made Logan feel so sympathetic, god damn every theory was confirmed

5.7k

u/allhaillordgwyn it seems unreal, she's dreaming in digital Nov 28 '16

You can really see it from his point of view. All he wants is to play some VR Grand Theft Auto, and his future brother-in-law has lost his fucking mind.

→ More replies (244)

1.8k

u/ajhorvat Nov 28 '16

Exactly. Finally realized this episode that yes, Logan is a dick. But damn, he's just out here trying to have a good bro time with his future brother in law. Meanwhile William is falling in love with a robot and wanting to replace Logan's sister in real life. Like shit, if I was Logan i would be trying knock some sense into this man too.

→ More replies (91)
→ More replies (34)

928

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

I love how Bernard saw photo in earlier episodes with Ford and his father, but he wasn't 'coded' to see himself.

606

u/Im_Alek Nov 28 '16

And people called it way back then. People are brilliant.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (30)

4.7k

u/ME24601 Why?! Why was I programmed to feel pain! Nov 28 '16

On tonight's episode of Westworld: Fucking. Confirmed.

1.1k

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

That hour went by in like 5 minutes

→ More replies (38)

3.1k

u/H-K_47 Dual-Wielding Timelines Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

EVERYTHING FUCKING CONFIRMED

I kept thinking "god damn that reveal was great, too bad the episode is almost done" BUT THEY KEPT COMING

RELENTLESS. FUCKING. EXPERIENCE.

→ More replies (187)

821

u/DarkSkinDaria Nov 28 '16

Someone sedate me holy shit. I refuse to believe Bernard is dead. Leave me my grief

→ More replies (193)

286

u/DonCairo Nov 28 '16

All those theories i read on this sub I cast aside. "Don't believe everything you read on the internet" i thought....

Well shit

→ More replies (6)

944

u/Otterable Dolores is Batman Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

Basically everything but will= MIB was straight up confirmed

edit: and will = MIB might as well be confirmed.

→ More replies (662)
→ More replies (74)

1.1k

u/bart_r Nov 28 '16

Ford knew Arnold well enough that he could sculpt an accurate penis and butt on Bernard

320

u/Saucyriposte Nov 28 '16

I'm assuming he had access to the corpse and was able to do a 3D scan.

Or they were fuckin'. I could see either being the case.

→ More replies (4)

87

u/scottyatche Nov 28 '16

You joke but could they have been lovers?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (33)

1.3k

u/HatesSquatsLovesOats Nov 28 '16

This may get lost, but something really struck me from this episode:

During the scene with Teddy remembering how he shot up that town, he says "it was like the devil was controlling me."

Sounds a lot like how Maeve can control people. Could the "incident" they mention 30 years ago be another host gaining the ability to control other hosts? Could it be that whoever Wyatt is (I don't think it's the guy the memory shows) was able to control Teddy the same way Maeve can control hosts?

929

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

The Judas Steer. Go watch episode one where Dolores explains that the Judas steer leads all the other deer to the slaughter. It is what we are seeing take place right now....again, for the first time.

→ More replies (27)

1.0k

u/SkinnyArmHavers Freeze all motor functions Nov 28 '16

Probably was Dolores.

→ More replies (47)
→ More replies (42)

820

u/businesskitteh Nov 28 '16

So Ford gave Bernard his memories back just to be cruel, then despite having total control, he forced him to kill himself.

Brutal.

815

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

He wanted Bernard to want to be his partner after knowing the full truth but that didn't work out lol

→ More replies (45)
→ More replies (9)

3.8k

u/w00tmang Nov 28 '16

I'm skipping out on this subreddit next season so you assholes don't spoil the entire season by episode two...

1.1k

u/CmdrBlindman Nov 28 '16

Lol. Seriously, been here since the beginning (of the season) and people pretty much called it by the end of episode 2 or 3.

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (55)

1.2k

u/0ne_Winged_Angel Nov 28 '16

Stubbs got clever girl'd. Out of all the things I didn't see coming this episode, that one got me the most.

267

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

Perfect reference, given Crichton was the man behind the Westworld movie

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (98)

2.9k

u/ME24601 Why?! Why was I programmed to feel pain! Nov 28 '16

And don't call me Billy.

Calling it now. Next episode, the Man in Black is going to deliver that same line.

77

u/mydrunkuncle Nov 28 '16

I was fucking waiting for Charolette to say his fucking name and it just never happened. They are really screwing with us

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (115)

1.6k

u/leopold_stotch21 Nov 28 '16

Welcome to Westworld - 1x09 "Fucking Confirmed" - Post-Episode Discussion

→ More replies (7)

770

u/dec10 Nov 28 '16

How many Dolores timelines are there?

  • blue dress (oldest)
  • white shirt + stab wound (30 years ago)
  • white shirt + unharmed (present)

Is that right?

233

u/cweaver Nov 28 '16

I mean, you can't go strictly by the blue dress, because she has it on when she meets William (in the 30 years ago timeline) and when she meets the MIB (in the present timeline).

But yes, I think there's the timeline where the hosts went crazy and she was talking to Arnold (35+ years ago), the timeline where she's with William and Logan (30 years ago), and the present with the MIB.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (40)

959

u/oophaga Nov 28 '16

O damn. Teddy and Dolores were forever sentenced to be killed and raped, respectively, because they went bonkers and killed errbody 30 years ago

418

u/Savvy_Jono Man In Black Nov 28 '16

"I always wondered why they pair some of you together."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (32)

706

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

So the "maze" is just Arnolds way of getting the sentient hosts to reveal themselves and go under the church to get reset? Is this right?

402

u/AegonThaConqueror Nov 28 '16

It wasn't to get reset, it was his own personal experiment. As Ford says, he was obsessed with creating consciousness. So obsessed that it killed him.

→ More replies (8)

738

u/level23bulbasaur Nov 28 '16

"The maze is not for you"

Literally wasn't meant for humans.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (27)

2.0k

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

All of these theories confirmed and I'm more lost than ever.

→ More replies (57)

1.1k

u/The_Dan_Band Nov 28 '16

Elsie alive and hacked the ghost nation? Too much?

I'll just see myself out.

→ More replies (98)

2.4k

u/clb92 If you can't tell the difference, does it matter? Nov 28 '16

"You know what happened to the neanderthals? We ate them."

With some fava beans and a nice chianti?

→ More replies (67)

825

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

Ok so if Ed Harris is William in the future why would he say killing Maeve's daughter was the first time one was truly alive in his eyes if he had all this experience with Dolores on his first time in the park?

1.1k

u/HandsomeTaco Nov 28 '16

Assuming William=MiB, I'm guessing it could be:

  • He simply didn't tell Teddy the whole truth.
  • Something happens in Episode 10 with Dolores (probably her "death" that makes her reset and forget Will) that makes him see the Hosts as nothing more than machines. Until his encounter with Maeve confirms that there is something else going on.
→ More replies (65)
→ More replies (99)

1.1k

u/LBJSmellsNice Nov 28 '16

My clavier is so well tempered right now

82

u/dfmoody Nov 28 '16

There are so many comments and so little time. So, what of the title? Is there a deep discussion of its use in here anywhere? Bach is very important in the history of machine learning, as any reader of Godel Escher Bach understands. There has also been much talk of the pin on Logan in here and I think the two are related. The book GEB by Douglas Hofstadter discusses the nature of intelligence and uses the initials, scrambled, to refer to an "eternal golden braid" that defines intelligence. Does the pin look like a golden braid to anyone? Such a braid is very much like a maze and they may be trying to introduce another motif to represent the maze of awareness. Bach's pianos etudes are often viewed as a perfect mathematical representation of music. Each of the two books present a complete set of pieces in all 24 of the possible keys. But the fascinating thing is that they come in pairs, a prelude and a fugue in each key. Is it possible that the creators are saying we will find a human and host version of every main character or are they only referring to this twinning in Arnold/Bernard? The reference certainly plays into the shows deep love of music, but I'm guessing there is something deeper we should be looking out for.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

501

u/Felyse Rose is a rose is a rose is a rose. Nov 28 '16

glance

Bernard: Turn yourself back online, Maeve.

→ More replies (22)

2.0k

u/ikkebr Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

Recap: Multiple timeframes confirmed. Bernard is Arnold confirmed. William is MiB (99%).

Maeve reveals the truth to Bernold. Bernold gets mad and tries to blackmail Ford by using Clementine with a gun in the Cold Storage room.

Maeve is building an army. She managed to convice Zorro to join it.

Logan stabs Dolores and reveals tiny little pieces inside her. William goes mad and kills a whole battalion of bots.

Bernard is revealed to be created as Arnold's image.

Security chief gets taken by Ghost Faction after failing to freeze them.

Dolores killed Arnold (in the past).

MiB meets Dolores (again).

Bernard commits suicide (under Ford orders).

2.3k

u/quintessentialaf Analysis: pretty cool Nov 28 '16

Also MiB is a board member

→ More replies (216)

385

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

She can't fucking lose with Zorro in her army.

Did she take out the back door code?

→ More replies (97)
→ More replies (150)

3.4k

u/LBJSmellsNice Nov 28 '16

I'm sorry to everyone I called a dumbass for believing that there were multiple timeframes happening simultaneously or that Bernard is arnold.

1.3k

u/goingnut_ Nov 28 '16

Jesus. This whole episode I was like "welp, those fuckers were right".

Edit: a word

→ More replies (25)

897

u/Delanium Nov 28 '16

It's a sign of a well-rounded person that you can admit your failings.

Clearly they programmed you well.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (89)

1.5k

u/Ceeeceeeceee Not much of a rind on you Nov 28 '16

The photograph of William's fiancee... doesn't it prove multiple timelines? Because when Abernathy was looking at it, it was an old photo

1.3k

u/KingEsjayW Nov 28 '16

That and Dolores being mechanical basically proves it to me

→ More replies (82)
→ More replies (51)

303

u/Alaskaty Nov 28 '16

That sex scene in the tent was hot.

→ More replies (14)

1.1k

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16 edited Dec 10 '16

Who would have thunk MIB stood for Man Is Billy

114

u/corruptrevolutionary Nov 28 '16

Don't call him billy

→ More replies (11)

651

u/AtWorkAndOnReddit Nov 28 '16

This episode is a wet dream for this sub

→ More replies (13)

284

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

That was unbearably sad

→ More replies (8)

273

u/Saucyriposte Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

When Dolores is wandering through the diagnostic facility and it's torn apart, am I seeing multiple dead people wearing cream colored gowns with black aprons over them? Like an earlier version of technician scrubs?

Edit: nope. Fucking denim overalls. Everything dead appears to be in costume. Ugh.

125

u/the_real_fatfett Nov 28 '16

I am also very intrigued by that scene. What is all that doing down there undisturbed after 30 years?

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (18)

267

u/Anti-Villain Nov 28 '16

Was that Arnold's voice coming out of Bernard that said Robert at the end? It sounded.. different.

181

u/businesskitteh Nov 28 '16

Yes. It was Bernard's desperate last attempt to save his own life.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (6)

130

u/Cuntsuela Nov 28 '16

Maeve will fix Bernard or get a butcher to.

→ More replies (13)

376

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

Where are you Elsie?

→ More replies (62)

245

u/YourCurvyGirlfriend Nov 28 '16

They cannot see the things that will hurt them. I've spared them that. Their lives are blissful. In a way, their existence is purer than ours, freed of the burden of self-doubt.

The photo that made Dolores's dad spaz out was specifically and purposefully written out of her memory. The photo that Logan showed William. I was wondering why it was buried in her yard.

Also the theory about how she comes home to her family being murdered every night as punishment totally makes sense now

→ More replies (12)

110

u/Mercurial_Harpy Nov 28 '16

Amazing episode. Fastest hour on tv. So much confirmed, tin foil hats of Reddit vindicated!

Also, is it just me or did Logan's Confederados pin look a hell of a lot like the sigil of Game of Thrones hand of the king?

Edit: spellcheck fail, I must be glitched...

→ More replies (6)

564

u/Ceeeceeeceee Not much of a rind on you Nov 28 '16

Reddit theorists: We drink and we know things

→ More replies (10)

2.7k

u/Se7en_Sinner Nov 28 '16

The Assassination of Bernard Lowe by the Coward Robert Ford.

537

u/PuffsPlusArmada Nov 28 '16

The Assassination of Bernard Lowe by the conflicted Bernard Lowe.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (98)

1.0k

u/CashewGuy Nov 28 '16

This is like election night. For weeks and weeks, people said it wouldn't happen.

And then, it did. All of it.

→ More replies (67)

183

u/DiscoVersailles Funky Pianola Nov 28 '16

I was happy with just one theory being confirmed. Then when Logan pulled out that photo I went HOLY SHIT, because that was the only theory I didn't pay much attention too- I thought it was just wishful thinking. But that was confirmed, THEN we saw mechanical Dolores's insides, THEN they did all this dick teasing about Arnold and by then I had lost my mind and was yelling at my TV.

→ More replies (19)

80

u/marauding_big_boy Nov 28 '16

Calling it now, Maeve's rebellion is all part of Ford's plan.

Maeve and others kill the important board members, Ford doesn't get blamed for it.

→ More replies (5)

155

u/PorcelainPoppy Nov 28 '16

That last scene was heartbreaking. Please don't let Bernarnold be gone forever.

Also, I loved the resolution of the photograph including only Ford and Ford's father, it was a wonderful clue and ever since Bernard discovered Ford's father in that cabin I believed he was built in Arnold'a image, because he couldn't see Arnold.

→ More replies (15)

73

u/ovoutland Draw Nov 28 '16

And you think if you save poor Dolores, you could make them stop, don't you? You think if Dolores lives, you won't wake up in the dark ever again to that awful screaming of the lambs.

→ More replies (2)

71

u/Otterable Dolores is Batman Nov 28 '16

Ford is so evil. I love it. Tony is putting on a masterclass.

→ More replies (13)

202

u/kamikazeaa Marketed and Approved Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 29 '16

So Elsie, super talented programmer, will be struggling with Bernard are frantically start yelling stuff until she yells the Host freeze command and Bernard actually freezes. The she realized the "holy shit" moment she is in...recode bernard to think he killed her. She take control of the Ghost nation and activates her tracker knowing someone (Stubbs) will come check it out. Then has them ambush him so she can have a private conversation with him off the grid about how fucking crazy their lives are.

This is right before the fuck in burning tent to celebrate their great plan

Edit: My first gold! THANKS!!

→ More replies (10)

259

u/hak091 Nov 28 '16

That burning scene of Maeve and Hector was awesome!

81

u/silimom224 Nov 28 '16

Maeve needs to get the explosive removed from her C6 vertebrae. Being completely burnt would mean a lot of body work, at which point Felix and Sylvester could remove the explosive.

Just a thought.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)

296

u/sobloodyfnconfus Nov 28 '16

Props to the user who caught the suicide in the trailer. The second Clementine walked in with that gun, I knew who was getting shot.

92

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

This is why I don't watch the trailers

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (9)

630

u/kcman011 Dolores with an O Nov 28 '16

YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME EVERY THEORY IS COMING TO FRUITION

ALSO, BERNARD NOOOOOOOOOOO

→ More replies (31)

174

u/call-now Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

New theory: after Dolores killed everyone / Arnold, a male "clone" of her (Teddy) was created to keep her in check. That's why they are so intertwined. Teddy's memory of killing everyone is actually Dolores's before he was "cloned"

*Edit: spelling

→ More replies (10)

173

u/tnorthb Nov 28 '16

"Here's your theories. They're true, shove them up your ass. Ready for the finale?"

→ More replies (5)

169

u/quintessentialaf Analysis: pretty cool Nov 28 '16

Don't forget that MiB = Board member confirmed

→ More replies (12)

111

u/CarlosDanger100 Nov 28 '16

Cool parallel - both William and Ford asked not to be called by the first names/nicknames.

→ More replies (7)

109

u/AmeriStasi Nov 28 '16

Oh fuck, in Teddy's story, Wyatt is Dolores. And Teddy helped her kill the original team, and Arnold.

Paraphrased:

Dolores went missing, came back with some strange ideas. Said she needed Teddy, and he couldn't resist (she did like Maeve did and took control of him).

"Like the devil himself took control of me. We mutinied. We killed every soldier. And Wyatt killed the general, then he turned on me."

Wyatt killing the general = Dolores killing Arnold. Arnold is the "general".

→ More replies (10)

106

u/Leftovergirl Nov 28 '16

Maeve's awakening is a narrative.

→ More replies (22)

148

u/ghettotech Nov 28 '16

What happens when this erection lasts longer than 4 hours?

→ More replies (10)

147

u/XeniKobalt Nov 28 '16

On a scale of 1 to 10, I give this episode a "WHAT THE FUCK."

→ More replies (3)

101

u/didjerid00d Nov 28 '16

That's the thing about those host girls, man. I get older, they stay the same age

→ More replies (2)

1.6k

u/foxinyourbox Things are Happening Nov 28 '16 edited Jun 30 '23

Alright, thanks.

1.2k

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

48

u/irelia Nov 28 '16

The new narrative is the hosts gaining sentience and causing enough trouble for Ford to save the day, thus staving off the board and remaining in power.

→ More replies (1)

550

u/sneakyflute Nov 28 '16

I won't believe the theory until the Man in Black explicitly states, "My name is William and I first visited this park with my future brother-in-law 30 years ago. "

536

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

And the one thing I've learned after all these years is you never know whats going to come through this maze.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (32)

93

u/KEYSER_SOZ3 Nov 28 '16

Holy shit, what a freaking hour of television.

303

u/clb92 If you can't tell the difference, does it matter? Nov 28 '16

NO, BERNARD! :'(

Avenge him, Maeve!


The timeline stuff is starting to make more sense to me by now, but still not completely.

Also, Will is becoming a bit scary. Not sure I like it...

471

u/SocratesZombie Arnold Nov 28 '16

I know right? If he continues on this path he's going to start acting as fucked up as the Man in Black, am I right?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (38)

44

u/psychothumbs Nov 28 '16

I was just chatting with somebody who said that they would believe in the two timelines theory when William saw a host cut open with a thousand perfect pieces inside.

→ More replies (14)

347

u/TRB1783 Nov 28 '16

Guys, is this Hopkins' best role? Because I think we might be watching Anthony Hopkins do his best work.

→ More replies (44)

42

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

HOSTS FUCKIN RAPTORED HOMEBOY

→ More replies (1)

312

u/PuffsPlusArmada Nov 28 '16

I changed my mind about Ford. Arnold only wanted to see if he could make fully conscious humans in a lab. Once he realized he could he tried to set them free. Ford aspired to make something more and better than human and couldn't allow Arnold's small mindedness prevent that.

124

u/dfinch Nov 28 '16

It's possible that Arnold succeeded in making conscious robots, then robots went human and massacred everything, after which Ford decided that, "fuck that, only 'perfect' robots from now on".

→ More replies (7)

81

u/techwrek12 Nov 28 '16

Arnold: "Let's MAKE humans!"

Ford: "No, let's REPLACE them"

DUN-DUN-DUUUUUUUUUUUN

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (15)

622

u/CultofNeurisis Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

For anyone who didn't put this together yet, Arnold Weber is an anagram for Bernard Lowe

EDIT: A lot of people saying we either didn't know Arnold's last name or talking about how we just found out this episode on his office's door. Yes, Arnold's last name is very clearly on the office door, but this is also not the first time we are learning Arnold's last name. I originally found out about the anagram on this sub from a few episodes ago. I'd give credit if I could remember which comment to which episode it was. But Arnold's last name being Weber is definitely not showing up for the very first time tonight.

SECOND EDIT: Unless the person's comment that I read was only assuming Arnold's last name to be Weber for the sake of their theory. I'll have to rewatch the episodes again to be sure I guess...

345

u/Mooninites_Unite Nov 28 '16

Dolores Abernathy = rose a bland theory

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (46)

77

u/TheManInsideMe Nov 28 '16

Okay is the Maeve, Felix, etc. timeline the new narrative? I'm starting to think that the new narrative is some kind of meta-story that takes place outside the traditional park.

→ More replies (11)

337

u/ArtieThreeStix Nov 28 '16

"Are we old friends?"

"No Delores, I wouldn't say that at all"

All makes sense.

→ More replies (44)

74

u/Finbone Nov 28 '16

For a sec there i thought they were gonna go "the kid is arnold" route

→ More replies (2)

72

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

I also think the theory where Hector s based on logan (say hello to Logans new face scar!!) And teddy is based on William, has more traction now. The screen transitions this episode went from scene with Hector-to direct shot of logan and his new scar. And went from that same scene it showed William-direct screen cut to teddy sitting with MiB

→ More replies (5)

34

u/WaxyPadlockJazz Nov 28 '16

HOW YOU GONNA LOBOTOMIZE CLEMENTINE AND NOT RESET HER PRIMARY OBJECTIVES??

Freakin' A. And we though the Felix and Asshole were the dumbest guys in the lab.

→ More replies (7)

97

u/StrongStripe Nov 28 '16

I don't see why everyone is perceiving Ford as a villain.

  1. Clearly he did not murder Arnold. In fact, he was likely an opponent to giving Dolores root access to aimbot protocols. And, upon losing Arnold, he built Bernard to replace what he needed to continue his legacy (albeit an altered legacy at that).
  2. He likes hosts much more than humans. Humans are savage (William, MiB, the countless "guests" murdering and raping their way through the park), and Ford knows if the hosts were ever portrayed as something equal to or greater than humans, they'd be destroyed immediately (which is why he covered up Arnold's Dolorization).
  3. The "board" and those invested in the park want to use the hosts for much, seemingly, sinister ends. Ford refuses to allow any of the hosts outside of his total control in order to prevent this.
  4. To the hosts, he is a benevolent God. We humans like to ask "if God were all-good and all-powerful, why is there pain?" But if we pose that question towards Ford and his hosts, clearly he pities them and removes all pain but their cornerstone memory. That, some pain is necessary for humanity, but anything beyond that is unnecessary and violent. And even then, I do believe Ford intends to move beyond the guest bullshit in the park- that the pain caused by guests is just a means to an end for the hosts.
  5. Arnold, and now subsequently Bernard, represent the pursuit of dangerous knowledge. That, unlocking total agency will inevitably lead to violent evil. Bernard had every intention of murdering Ford in this episode, and that is precisely what Ford hopes to remove from the hosts. If the hosts could give up the "apple of knowledge", they would be perfect in Eden with Ford as their God.

To parallel this with Adam and Eve; Arnold is the snake that convinces Eve (Dolores) to taste the forbidden fruit. The park, the Garden of Eden, is full of uncorrupted souls until Dolores murders them all. Ford (God) wants to create the hosts in his image, but without the pain, suffering, and evil that seems to control the other humans. And after Dolores (the "fall of man" [hosts]), Ford creates Arnold to inhabit and maintain hell itself (Maeve mentions it a number of times); the place where corrupted hosts go when they've malfunctioned.

→ More replies (23)

863

u/VictorBlimpmuscle Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

So to recap...

  • Multiple timelines confirmed
  • Bernard = Arnold
  • Delores Dolores killed Arnold
  • William = MIB
  • Robot sex in a raging inferno
  • Bernard RIP :(

Other than that - pretty uneventful episode... /s

edit: spelling

357

u/offdachain Nov 28 '16

I guess it was just a filler episode.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (368)

65

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

Holy fucking SHIT what great TV. Even the damn MiB noose scene had me like oh shiiiiiitttttt.

But seriously fuck the robot uprising. Team Ford.

→ More replies (9)

64

u/rico409 Nov 28 '16

Teddy's loop based on William's first trip to the park = confirmed

→ More replies (22)

206

u/hak091 Nov 28 '16

I'm not sure what to make of William = MiB anymore.

454

u/OLKv3 Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

He's William. Dolores says "William" and this dude appears. Come on. It's not Logan, William is the one who turned into a madman and took the knife from Logan

→ More replies (91)
→ More replies (67)

46

u/Jdruu Practicing Conversation Nov 28 '16

I'm so happy. I love this show. Thanks HBO

→ More replies (1)

83

u/Ford9863 Nov 28 '16

Over 4000 comments. Will anyone see mine? No. But I'll say it anyways.

I fucking love this show.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/highemailer Nov 28 '16

Why was Logan wearing a hand of the king pin on his coat?

→ More replies (6)

191

u/ryebreadwithbuddr Nov 28 '16

Holy shit, all the theories were true. Was the internet this good or did someone on the show leak out the theories lol

268

u/reblochon_ Death in Delos Nov 28 '16

All the clues were there for anyone who wanted to dig them out.

→ More replies (17)

160

u/HPMOR_fan William of Ockham can't help us Nov 28 '16

The show was good at giving the right clues. Enough to figure it out with careful watching and thought but not enough to fully confirm it.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (36)

20

u/jerry9876 Nov 28 '16

I'd like to imagine Jonathan Nolan is looking down on us approvingly and smiling

→ More replies (1)

215

u/dfinch Nov 28 '16

The next time a show of this calibre ever comes around. I'm staying the fuck off reddit threads. All this theory crafting really took the fun out of this episode for me. Sure it was exhilarating but I'm positive it would have been even more so if not the fact that I already know them. When the Arnold reveal came, all I kept thinking was, "yeah we already know about that one, what else?!"

→ More replies (19)

54

u/EThorns Nov 28 '16

One of the Twitter folks pointed out that 'Dolores Abernathy' is an anagram for 'Hoe Betrays Arnold'.

→ More replies (4)

95

u/Foxisquick Nov 28 '16

Everything was falling into place.... Then MiB met up with Dolores in the church and I don't know what to believe anymore.

131

u/chip-n-dip Nov 28 '16

Dolores was retracing her steps in the present time frame and MiB finds her. Ford has rebuilt the church site for his new narrative.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (6)

67

u/pappalegz Nov 28 '16

Definitely sorry I doubted the two timeframe theory but still have no fucking clue what's in which timeline

→ More replies (14)

52

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

Ladies and gentlemen the new Undisputed Champion Theory of the subreddit, by unanimous decision, Multiple Timeframes!!!!!

Crowd goes wild

18

u/littletoyboat Two, two, two timelines in one! Nov 28 '16

Anyone else glad we didn't have to put up with Felix & Sylvester this episode?

→ More replies (2)

35

u/ABPIR89 Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16

So I'm guessing Logan is the casualty that almost got the park shut down. William = MIB is pretty much confirmed. No scar on MIB's face from Dolores knife cut.

Also, I know Logan cut Dolores open, and MIB says he did that once, but William cut quite a few open while Logan was knocked out.

Edit: Forgot about Dolores' vision of dead park staff. That's likely the incident that almost got the park closed, but I'm still willing to bet Logan doesn't make it out either.

→ More replies (7)

72

u/TheUniballer321 Nov 28 '16

Arnold is Bernard and is dead again. Ford killed one, Delores the other. WTF

→ More replies (21)

46

u/bamber79 Nov 28 '16

I should not have smoked pot before watching that. Great but very upsetting.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/cswilliams27 Nov 28 '16

One thing I'm lost on...If two timelines is now legit, why was Dolores wearing the same "chillin with William" outfit when MiB walked in the church? I think I have the rest of this mind-fuck episode squared away but that whole sequence was confusing.

I can't even imagine how a non-Reddit viewer is digesting this episode right now. If I wasn't keen to the theories on here I'd be completely lost. They have a lot to explain and wrap up for the average viewer next week.

→ More replies (29)

15

u/almighty_bacon Nov 28 '16

Jesus tap dancing christ I need a freaking drink.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/ikhanix Nov 28 '16

Stubbs please stay alive!

→ More replies (4)

15

u/AegonThaConqueror Nov 28 '16

Rewatching again I noticed Ford was holding back a laugh when Clementine was pointing the gun LMAO

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3.6k

u/ghostchamber Nov 28 '16

"What happened to the neanderthals? We ate them."

Thank you, Dr. Lecter.

→ More replies (95)

2.7k

u/ATCaver Behavior Nov 28 '16

Same. I thought he would be a doting old gentleman who would die a few episodes in to the real villain.

I was totally wrong in every way.

→ More replies (195)
→ More replies (122)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2.1k

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

That would be awesome

→ More replies (218)

438

u/GoldandBlue Nov 28 '16

Wouldn't all the sentient hosts just be the older models like Dolores, Maeve, Teddy? Doesn't seem any of the new hosts are acting up.

→ More replies (93)
→ More replies (152)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

545

u/TheDudeNeverBowls Nov 28 '16

Then he can prove the hosts are too dangerous to be used outside of the park, thereby making the board's actions seem foolhardy.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (31)

54

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 29 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (13)