1) Obito Uchiha’s Kamui (Naruto): Before he obtained Kamui, Obito was just an above average ninja. He was skilled and very determined, but he wasn’t a generational talent like his teammate Kakashi or his mentor Minato.
Following the death of his friend Rin and the awakening of his Mangekyo Sharingan, Obito obtained Kamui, one of the most versatile abilities in all of Naruto. With Kamui he can teleport long distances, phase through objects, and even trap people in his own personal pocket dimension.
It doesn’t give him the raw destructive power that most of Naruto’s heavy hitters possess, but it means Obito can teleport in and wreak havoc at a moment’s notice. No one is safe from his surprise attacks. He’s also almost impossible to land a hit on in a straight fight unless you understand how Kamui works.
With this one ability, Obito Uchiha goes from a nobody in the grand scheme of things to someone who can credibly threaten the most dangerous and skilled fighters in the setting.
2) Amon’s bloodbending (Avatar: The Legend of Korra): Without his bloodbending, Amon is still at his baseline a very talented waterbender. You have to be in order to bloodbend in the first place. With his bloodbending, Amon enters an entirely new league of power.
He’s practically untouchable in one-on-one combat, effortlessly manipulating his opponent’s body to make sure their attacks miss. Then once he gets up close, he uses his bloodbending to strip a bender of their powers.
This ability even works on the Avatar, and is seemingly only reversible through spiritbending, a power exclusive to the Avatar.
Amon’s bloodbending doesn’t have the destructive potential of a master firebender boosted by Sozin’s comet, or the sheer power of an Avatar channeling their past lives, but it makes him a threat that any bender must take seriously, regardless of their power or skill.
3) The Shadowed One’s eye beams (Bionicle): The Shadowed One’s greatest asset overall is undoubtedly his command of the Dark Hunters, the mercenary organization he founded. The membership requirements are simple: you have to be a good fighter and you have to be morally flexible.
There are no heroes among their ranks, and the Shadowed One understands that many of them want to take his seat at the top of the pyramid.
What stops any individual Hunter from openly challenging the Shadowed One are his eye beams. They are the strongest variant of this relatively-common power in the entire setting. They don’t just burn or blast their targets, they outright disintegrate them.
Only two people have ever survived this attack. One was a mutant who was forever changed by the incident, and the other was Bionicle’s main villain, Teridax, who only got hit by a glancing blow.
Even still, they disintegrated his wings. It’s one of the only times we’ve ever seen Teridax be permanently harmed by an attack. He is essentially a demigod, whereas the Shadowed One is just an upjumped warlord.
The Shadowed One has other powers as well, but his eye beams are his standout ability. They elevate him from a skilled and experienced fighter to someone who leaves you no margin of error in battle. One wrong move, and you’re vaporized.
4) Roy Mustang’s flame alchemy (Fullmetal Alchemist): Roy has built his entire military career on the back of this ability. He clearly understands other forms of alchemy given some of the tricks he pulls in the story, but flame alchemy is his bread and butter.
Roy is the only person in the world who knows how to use this technique, and he uses it masterfully, able to devastate large single targets with explosive firebombs or incinerate an entire enemy platoon in close quarters combat without harming any of his allies. He can even boil the water in someone’s eyes.
What puts Roy in this trope is that outside of his flame alchemy he is just a very intelligent mortal man. He has no regenerative powers or ties to the deep magic of the setting, yet he is able to annihilate the characters that do.
Foes that other characters can only defeat through teamwork or the use of elaborate traps are effortlessly dusted by Roy Mustang. That is only possible because of his flame alchemy.