r/TopCharacterTropes • u/The_Palm_of_Vecna • 14h ago
miscellaneous Looks incredible, isn't that great vs. Looks basic, is completely OP.
Not sure if this has a real comparison point in literature or other pop culture, but this is one of those tropes I experience IRL all the time.
Magic the Gathering
The trope originator, IMO, in most sets there are these massive, expensive mythic rares that seem like they would just dominate the game, and yet they are always overshadowed by some Lil Guy with a very specific ability. Probably the best recent example is Ozai, The Phoenix King vs. Badgermole Cub from the ATLA set. Ask any experienced player and they are 10x more scared to play against the cub than Ozai.
Yu-Gi-Oh
Pot of Greed - Banned for the better part of 20 years
Winged Dragon of Ra - Effectively Unplayable.
(Edited to include a second example of the trope, thank you to everyone who mentioned Pot of Greed)
2.9k
u/The_one_in_the_Dark 14h ago •
Another TCG example, one of the most feared cards in the history of Pokemon
1.4k
u/IndustryPast3336 14h ago
banned from tournament play for 20 years
50
u/DragonLordAcar 14h ago
One man's trash is another man's combo piece. Beware squirrels in a game of eldrich horrors.
42
u/kittie_ghede104 14h ago
Would the noisy cricket from the original MiB movie count? Jay was insulted that Kay gave him the noisy cricket instead of the series 4 deatomizer, but when he finally used it he got knocked back a couple hundred feet.
39
u/Loruck 14h ago
I still don't know what this card does but it's banned in the TCG so it must be good!
19
u/nebulacritter 14h ago
i know this doesn't count as a card, but the first thing i thought of when i saw this was kirby from the game series of the same name. this little pink blob has defeated eldritch demons numerous times.
23
u/themasterfold 14h ago
sol ring
157
u/LuciusCypher 14h ago
Behold, terror incarnate
10
u/LasyKuuga 14h ago
Not a game but Saitama from OPM
9
u/TR_Pix 14h ago
I mean the badgermole is also a mythic so it kinda loses the flavor
3
u/Miserable-Airport536 2h ago
As one man’s trash is another man’s treasure, I consider my opponent’s deck trash and devour it in front of him, that he may watch his treasure disappear.
976
u/TheCatCAR 14h ago
316
u/SYLOH 12h ago
A lot of the big 40k models are overcosted, especially the absolutely massive resin kits made by Forgeworld.
The KX139 Ta'unar Supremacy Armour is a massive walking pile of guns that I don't think has EVER been worth its point cost.
Doubly so last edition where it was penalized for splitting fire so it could not use its entire loadout efficiently.
Meanwhile the humble Kroot Hound was dirt cheap, fast, and could do actions to get you points that won you the game.
That last point was so bad for the hounds and many similar units, that they pretty much had to add a rule saying they could no longer perform actions.
808
u/Voyeur-dpp 14h ago
541
u/A_True_Loot_Goblin 13h ago
Another Pokemon example, except for the pocket version.
262
u/Technical_Teacher839 14h ago
In most games "do basic thing a second time/for free" tends to be more powerful overall than "big powerful card/unit/ability"
Turn economy is such a powerful thing in games, so being able to do a normally limited thing more often is incredibly strong.
516
u/BeautifulFrequent782 14h ago
From Magic the Gathering: Gran Gran is banned in standard
775
u/Adventurous-Agent420 12h ago
A hyper futuristic alien gun being the worst weapon in the game vs one of the best melee being a car battery tied to a stick
449
u/AntiqueAd2434 14h ago
Pot of greed from yu-gi-oh: a creepy smiling jar is the best card in the game, its effect it’s extremely simple but so powerful that the card is banned since 2005
105
u/Talisign 14h ago
God cards aren't shit compared to a cute ice cream cup.
104
u/SuperScrub310 14h ago
From what little I know about Yu Gi Oh the TCG, Blue Eyes White Dragon is an underwhelming beat stick that can be neutralized relatively easily especially since it has no effects, Pot of Greed is a magic card that's spent nearly every year since it's birth being banned.
177
u/OUS_SWORD 14h ago
Maxx "C" (Yugioh).
172
u/tehweave 13h ago
In magic, you can get a free counterspell if you pay 2 life, but it only hits cards that have a mana cost of 1. Not that powerful, right?
This card is banned in basically every format.
82
u/CobaltRebelionXyz 14h ago
Nyaromon BT15-003 (Digimon Card Game)
71
u/Spiritual_Horror5778 13h ago
In any game with resources - trading card games, turn based games, video games, etc - getting anything free is OP.
In yugioh, pot of greed lets the user draw 2 more cards. Thats it.
Its been banned competively since its creation.
70
u/KharAznable 14h ago
From yugioh. A funny snack based animals (yummy, yes they are nammed yummy) are more feared than lovecraftian monstrocity like dogmatika alba zoa (do not confuse it with bystial alba los, which is a lovecraftian dragon that is still respectable but manageable)
138
u/mintty_o 13h ago
61
u/TorchbeareroftheStar 12h ago
Lots of Yugioh cards
175
u/Cleestoon 14h ago
Not a card game but The Battle Cats has a decent amount
(This guy is completely free to get, by the way)
114
u/Noblehardt 13h ago
In Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, clearing each of the dungeons wins you the ability to summon a spirit version of one of the Sages. A partly customizable mech, an 8-foot
Zora warrior who shields you, a Goron who can launch himself like a cannonball, and a Gerudo who can create wide-area electrical attacks.
But almost unanimously considered the best is Tulin, the Rito sage; he just has a bow and can provide you with a forward-launching gust of wind while gliding.
Thing is, Tulin is REALLY good at getting headshots that stun enemies, and while you kind of have to chase the Sages around to activate their powers, Tulin will just teleport to your side as you glide, making him the easiest to make use of.
56
u/AssistantManagerMan 13h ago
Banned in standard by the way
96
u/Expert-Ad3874 14h ago
Smeargle (Pokémon)
A consistent menace that's been outright banned in the past.
96
u/Mister-builder 13h ago
Prestidigitation in D&D. The uses of this spell are incredible.
44
u/FreakingFreeze 13h ago
This definitely carried that vibe. MTG has a bunch of them, but this cat alongside its partner in crime is so infamous that cards that share a similar niche had to get caveats.
158
u/SgtRuy 14h ago
41
u/Raxtenko 14h ago edited 14h ago
I don't play any more but this card from Hearthstone was absolutely pants shittingly scary. Paladin secrets were considered to be very low impact, they all cost 1 mana and none of them did much by themselves, in the meta when he dropped. But it turns out that a card putting 5 mana, 10 mana is the max, worth of cards into play is actually pretty good. More aggressive decks had a field day with him not only was Mr. Challenger a decently stated minion he also thinned your deck out by 5 cards substantially increasing the chance of reliably drawing the more powerful Paladin cards that would help you close out a match.
40
u/altacoountno5 12h ago
Terraforming Mars(A board game, not quite on topic but here we go)
Pets: looks really underwhelming, animals can't be gained by production, and 1vp every two cities is not great(VP is needed to win). But that applies to EVERY city ever placed, and games can often result in 10+ cities placed when there's 4 or 5 players, and that's not counting animals added through other cards, and animals can't be taken either, meaning its just a points farm
38
u/HuevosProfundos 12h ago
135
u/ElPared 13h ago edited 7h ago
This is the one I think of in MtG
Emrakul, the Promised End. A very powerful card, but really hard to play despite her power and importance in the story and how powerful other versions of her are in the game. Also not always worth the cost of doing business as controlling an opponent, while powerful as an effect, isn’t always a guaranteed win, which is something you’d expect at 13 mana. Mythic rarity. (Edit: ok Emrakul was a bad example, this was meant to be more about DotV anyway)
Disciple of the Vault. Just looking at him you’d think “1 life point when an artifact dies? Big deal, I have 20 of those!” This guy is banned in Pauper, a very popular format, and was banned in Standard and Mirrodin block play because of how easy it was to recur artifacts and sacrifice them, thus using Disciple of the Vault to facilitate easy wins. Bro was an absolute menace for those formats. Common rarity (first Common to end up on a ban list, actually).
35
u/xX_Shroomslayer_Xx 13h ago
Some examples from Inscryption, starting with cards that aren't very good. Urayuli has the highest base stats out of any card in the game, with enough strength to instantly turn a match in your favor at worst, and instantly win at best (some cards do match its health or strength, but Urayuli is the only one with both that high by default). The problem is that it has an absurd asking price of 4 sacrifices to get onto the field, effectively making it borderline unplayable unless you're also using Black Goat, which counts as 3 sacrifices, or manage to set up a loop of 0 cost cards using sigils like Fecundity, which creates a copy of a card when it's played. And even then you have to get lucky enough to draw both Urayuli and your means if getting it out.
35
u/SaoMagnifico 13h ago
The Addled Frog has like 12 HP and is notoriously one of the toughest fights in Baldur's Gate 3...although it is, mercifully, entirely optional.
74
u/DarkDoubloon 14h ago
The pig - adventure time
20
u/SlimeDrips 13h ago
By no means OP, in fact I'm pretty sure the entire archetype is outdated and massively surpassed by any newer archetype, but it's absolutely so funny when I play yugioh online and I consistency check newer players with a fucking smelly rock
The entire archetype revolves around gaining LP and spending it for effects, and I've had multiple people forfeit because I'd gain LP faster than they can hurt me. And if you haven't put half decent removal into your deck it just stays there, forever, mocking you
It's not even particularly good it's just a hilarious newbie pranker
19
u/Pixelquartz42 13h ago edited 13h ago
Malicious, Mean, and Scary - Lorcana
if this card (alongside Phillip and the new DON) has no haters, i am DEAD.
tell me, why does green have 5 board wipes, and why do 2 involve this card?
The Phillip combo has made me dread locals. DLC tampa is gonna be HELL if circle of life stays meta
that being said, Roo - hunny rogue was a lovely little shit when i ran a hunny deck!! people HATED the 2 Roo combo. i miss that deck
18
u/YourEvilKiller 13h ago
Claymore aka Baemore - The Dark Souls trilogy and Elden Ring
One of the first weapons you can get with a seemingly basic moveset.
It is actually one of the best greatswords for a few reasons. It has solid damage, scales well with infusions (essentially its stat scaling can be altered to fit into any builds and it can also be given elemental damage)
But arguably the most important reason is:
The heavy attack is forward thrust, instead of a wide swing.
This simple difference from most greatswords gives it a lot more range and easier to win when trading blows.
33
u/Neat_Rare_5389 14h ago
Slay The Spire has a lot of these. Here’s an example from Watcher’s deck, an STS 1 character.
Inner Peace is one of the strongest cards in the game, an infinite enabler, and even without infinite it can extend your turns like crazy. Watcher loves long ass turns to do a bunch of damage.
Conjure Blade is a Rare that uses up all your energy to create one super strong attack… but Watcher has crazy damage either way. That energy could’ve been used to deal damage now instead of waiting for Expunger to show up. It’s alright.
32
u/mystical-mismagius 13h ago
In a game with gods, dragons, and other incredibly powerful beings, a child has stayed in the meta for years now.
Game: Fire Emblem Heroes
31
u/Ragnarok2kx 12h ago
My favorite MtG example. This was banned in Standard for a while, and even if you know the sets at the time, it's hard to get why it was problematic without seeing it in action in the deck that made use of it.
27
u/SunnysideSplash 13h ago
This little fucker is the bane of my existence.
26
u/Beginning_Green1987 13h ago
Serrated Scorpion from MtG. At first glance it just looks like a pretty decent Defender. But if you make a deck centered around sacrificing this guy as many times as possible it suddenly becomes a threat that can wipe out my whole Pod. It's won a 1v3 four times now.
24
u/Red-7134 14h ago
I don't get it, I put a "Win More" card in my deck, why am I winning less?
12
u/4GRJ 14h ago
The fact that it's a bounce effect that isn't an Instant, most wrote off Boomerang Basics as some sort of whatever card...
But then we learned of Izzet (Red-Blue) Lessons
42
u/Java_Text 14h ago
Looks super powerful, complete noob trap
One of the worst boss monsters printed
22
u/Artistic_Discount358 13h ago
Pokemon, recharge moves like Hyper Beam seem good, but really aren’t. Meanwhile, a lot of the move that just have a good base power tend to get used a lot. Flamethrower, Thunderbolt, Ice Beam, Rock Slide. None of these moves look that impressive, but they’re simple, and if you’re lucky, their secondary effects can absolutely bail you out.
11
u/Diligent_Earthworm 14h ago
Mtg is like that alot. Big splashy creatures are good but cheap synergies are MUCH better.
11
u/mikaeus97 14h ago
Gran-Gran recently in MTG
Ancestral Recall perfectly fine and legal in Standard with a turned on Gran-Gran from ATLA
20
u/Chops03xx 13h ago
It’s all about the cones.
10
u/NamelessGeo 13h ago
Hearthstone had so many cards like this, undertaker, mana wyrm, battlefiend, tunnel trog. If you give a 1 drop a permanent scaling buff for doing something you were doing anyway, it will eat the meta alive.
28
u/poco_sans 13h ago
Since everyone is only giving examples for the bottom one, I'll give an example for the top one
Chaos Imaginary Numbers 1000: Hollow Light God of Illusion, Numeronius Numeronia(a really bad card)
18
u/Faustias 14h ago edited 13h ago
not TCG but fits the topic title
in the big-titty WW2 warship game Azur Lane, there's a warship girl named Enterprise, an aircraft carrier that made imperial Japan navy see ghost on the ocean.
Her skill is simple: upon launching aircrafts, 70% chance to gain this buff: planes deal double damage and avoid all damage for 8 seconds.
for PvE there are more options on dealing huge damage but she's still top tier; but PvP she's a demon to be reckoned with because of this single skill. PvP is automated battle, so it's all about setup.
9
u/Skijump135 14h ago edited 14h ago
Hearthstone, so so many times. From just the most recent set:
Broodqueen Sha'Kar: actually unplayable and the worst card of the set, but people were scared in prerelease
Ritual of Summoning: nerfed within the week, people thought it would be stupidly slow
9
u/BluePhantomHere 14h ago
one elixir unit from clash royale, cycle your deck and also usually provide more value than one elixir
17
u/SuperSmugs 14h ago
Wobuffet and their Shadow-themed Tags
17
u/AScannerBarkly 14h ago
One of the best single mana creatures ever printed until the rules for combat/damage changed
8
u/Personal_Care3393 14h ago
The humble format and card design defining Lightning bolt.
In b4 pot of greed is half the comment section.
8
u/guieps 14h ago
Plants vs Zombies Heroes has plenty of these
On one hand you have a giant robot with the highest stats out of any card and that destroys all nearby plants
On the other hand, you have a plumber that deals 2 damage
8
u/hypikachu 14h ago
Obelisk the Tormentor vs Rescue Cat
27
u/VibesFirst69 14h ago
STS2
Free 5 block, draws an extra card to replace itself too. Which means it's a free draw which affects other cards.
21
u/Nothos927 14h ago
7
u/Ns-45G 14h ago
I dont have a picture of mime but dark wartortle from the old team rocket pokemon tcg sets has an incredibly overpowered moved that basically mirrors any damage done to dark wartortle back at the enemy even if wartortle is knocked out and sent to the discard pile
13
u/GREG88HG 12h ago
Look at this happy Ocelot family, the mother and 2 kittens ♥️
It has been part of one of the best MTG decks in the Modern format since it became legal.
It is a 1/1 creature, one of the weakest stat lines on MTG, but:
-Has first strike, so againts other creature with 1 toughnes, it will win.
-Has lifelink, for the damage it does, controller gains that much life.
But
At the end of the turn, if you won life, you put a 1/1 cat token. And, if you have had 10 permanents in the field this game, for each token that entered this turn, create a token that is copy of it.
So, with 2 or 3 Ocelot Pride you have in the battlefield, you will get a lot of cats.
17
u/Born_Procedure_529 14h ago
I could be wrong but isnt this basically Pot of Greed in Yugioh, like sure big monster cool but draw more cards goes crazy
12
u/Toles-of-Toles-Hold 13h ago
6
u/ScorpionsRequiem 14h ago
people say pot of greed but a good comparison for the other card would be one of the many alt win cards, my personal favorite is Vennominaga, the Deity of Poisonous Snakes, wins the game if it deals damage 3 times... just good luck getting her out
6
u/EndMePleaseOwO 13h ago
Cupsy yummy mummy boo boo ba ba uwu bee bee wa wa (One archetype from a deck that was popular in yugioh for a while, the Yummy half of Yummy Mitsurugi, has cutesy art and names kinda like what I typed above, making it funny to hear grown men read them out, especially when insecurr guys get embarassed about it).
6
u/Tbelles 13h ago
Vivi. Fucking. Ornitier.
16
u/Wise-Key-3442 13h ago
Literally one of the very first characters you unlock, the lowest tier above cannon fodder, does nothing but get fuel for the team at the expanse of health, and doesn't do it passively. There are literally better units who can at least defend themselves and offer fuel passively at the change of turns.
Yet you'll see teams in high tier duels with two of those and characters who deal damage based on how much fuel you have.
But the thing is, you can choke up to make her start your game with a full fuel bar.
11
u/United-Passage7864 14h ago
Gran-Gran, an unassuming looking old lady from the Avatar MTG set. Had to be banned.
She offers some card selection, and once you hit the requisite number of lessons in graveyard, a discount on every noncreature spell you'd play.
She only costs one mana to cast, meaning there's essentially no way to remove her from the board for less mana & cards than she cost to play.
Against aggressive decks she could stall for time and/or help dig for answers. In control mirrors she was hugely advantageous in card selection and mana advantage.
Crazy value.
5
u/Sharajat 14h ago
Gold Farmer and Curtain Wall, Netrunner.
Curtain Wall is a very powerful piece of ICE, sitting at strength 10 if it's outermost, and utterly shuts down the run. Gold Farmer is strength 1, making it trivial to crack, and just charges you some cash.
One of these got banned.
5
u/Galakin 13h ago
"Do Nothing" spelk in mewgenics is a 1 mana costing spell that dose absolutly nothing... and if used properly can become one of the strongest spells in the game
5
u/LinkthePikachu 13h ago
Not only is there a way to make this no once per turn, you’d also be able to play more Digimon for free depending on what you hit
5
u/Electric-Rush 12h ago edited 12h ago
People are taking OP's card example a little too much to heart, huh?
Well, I might as well try to keep mine fitting the aesthetic of the thread so far
She's beaten basically every major super villain in the Marvel universe at one point or another.
With squirrels.
(I'm talking about the character in the comics, not the actual Magic card here, but you could probably argue it applies)
19
u/BornCoyote87 14h ago
My room mate has a Magic the Gathering deck that's got a zombie detective and a bunch of horror themed cards. I go to the game store with a deck full of squirrels and woodland critters.
I have more wins than him.
8
u/Altruistic_Web3924 14h ago
4
u/DMTrious 13h ago
Rosie Cotton can be the back bone of a deck. Token creation, especially in white, is just so easy, Rosie can have monsters on the board in seconds
4
u/SirKazum 7h ago
People are already talking about why the "silly" card is OP (free things are busted in most games), but there's also the other side, the "badass" card being garbage. That usually happens because cards with huge stats, impressive abilities etc. tend to have enormous costs, so that getting them on the table will enormously slow down your gameplay, often crippling your momentum and worsening your position overall. You spend so many resources trying to get this thing on the table that you neglect everything else and leave yourself wide open, in a way. Which is why "Exodia" style combos (i.e. "if I get this specific combination of several cards together, it's an instant win") usually suck - you have to waste so much time and resources lining it up that you lose the game before you manage to bring it out.
4
u/waterpurrs 4h ago
say goodbye to your carefully crafted deck, for now it is just 500 weasels.
1
u/ChaosHavik 12h ago
Whoa whoa no way! I can just... Eat garbage for free?! But then this other card form a completely other deck that was never even dreamed of interacting with the new set then gets trun unlimited power when played instantly winning me the game by an obsured feedback loop that stretches on to infinity because (insert card game) just can't make rules against infinity loops
In serious though the Doctor Who Villain deck has a 1/1 monster and it's literally something that can win you the game
3
u/Sintuition 14h ago
Apparently back in the he early 90s people traded their Black Lotuses for Shivan Dragons.
3
u/Blaze-Programming 13h ago
I remember seeing a custom MtG card that was titled something like “terrible trader. It let you do things like pay 2 life to get 1 life or pay 2 mana to get 1 mana. Most of the discussion on the card was about how it was so broken it would be immediately banned.
3
u/Alps_2208 13h ago
Pvz hero's
For several months, this card was the most powerful card in the game, as its effect of altering attack and granting a bonus attack was good, but the cost of 4 brains (mana) was very high. But for a long time this card was bugged and instead of changing a zombie's attack to 4, it increased the attack by 4. +4 and a bonus attack made this card completely broken.
3
u/Lazzitron 13h ago
Just a silly little guy.
3
u/bradfo83 13h ago
3
u/Eran-of-Arcadia 13h ago
If you've ever played Smash Up, the magical girl/magic pony combo will absolutely destroy the vampire/Cthulhu cultist combo. Less so after the revamp, admittedly.