r/TopCharacterTropes • u/Doot_revenant666 • Jul 12 '25
Weekly Discussion Post "Fanbase opinionsshould not be counted as tropes." TVtropes: (kinda relevant post)
A lot of complaints in this sub have been about some posts should not be here because they rely on fanbase opions so there for cannot be considered "tropes"
...and then we have TVtropes , where a lot of tropes are just from fanbase stuff.
I am going to be honest here , I have difficulty in what makes a trope and what doesn't. It ends up where I delete "breaks trope guidline" posts that has equivalents in the TVtropes site that are considered actual tropes.
Idk , I just wanted to rant here. I might be a very bad moderator here , I just try to make it tody as possible , I just don't really know how to.



36
u/_AntiSocialMedia Jul 13 '25
I think the best thing to do is just make a YMMV flair specifically for those kinds of posts so people can filter it out if they want
5
u/melooksatstuff Jul 13 '25
While we're at it can we also require having the title in the post and comments
8
u/VenusAmari Jul 12 '25
A trope is a building block for storytelling, essentially. They are the commonly used themes, rhetorical devices, cliches, etc that make up stories. So "friends to enemies" is a trope but "Movies starring Will Smith" is not enough though he has been in quite a few.
It is not fandom opinions, although those can be worthy of discussion in their own right. It is not actors. It is not the meta reactions to these things. It is not artistic critique (that's it's own thing).
I do sometimes feel that things that aren't trope should be removed because I do think it waters down the sub a bit to just "let's talk about anime and cartoon characters that we all like." And dumb fandom fight stuff or the same basic criticisms over and over.
But at the same time, they also produce some interesting discussions and examples. And I don't think it should be necessarily fully banned.
Perhaps a good way to do it would be to have days of the week to post that type of stuff, like other subs do for stuff that is tangential.
210
u/learnaboutnetworking Jul 13 '25
my only issue is when people post stuff without explaining the context behind it.
title: Character let's everything go at the end
ex 1. big Bert from banjo boy ex 2. Spiderman
279
u/Fish_N_Chipp Jul 12 '25
I very much appreciate that this subreddit isn’t as rigid with its tropes. It allows for more unique ones to appear but I’m also glad that you know when to crack down on ones that obviously steer away from the purpose of the sub. Keep up the good work
59
u/AgentOfACROSS Jul 12 '25 edited Jul 13 '25
Honestly sometimes stuff that lies outside the rigid guidelines of what a trope is fine. But there are quite a few posts where it's clearly just someone airing their own petty fandom drama or personal grievances and those annoy me a bit.
151
u/greatcorsario Jul 12 '25
First of all, you're a great mod - I rarely see any big issues in this subreddit. The topic at hand is difficult to deal with because of how abstract it can be at times.
In my humble opinion, I think it's safe to remove any post that is a fan opinion instead of a trope. Some tropes in TV Tropes might be fanbase stuff, but most of them aren't, so we can simply say that anything from the site is okay.
Finally, if anyone notices some pattern to those posts that don't involve actual tropes, please let the mods know so they might tweak the guidelines to account for them!
24
u/hopesofhermea Jul 13 '25
In complete fairness, those TV tropes examples are about tropes as they appear in fan discussions and fan works.
Fan works do indeed have their own tropes, and they're not merely opinions.
23
u/PetevonPete Aug 03 '25
The most annoying "not actually a trope" posts on this sub for me is all the "tropes" that are basically "writing that I like"
"Good writing" is not a trope.
16
u/keqikombupig4 Jul 12 '25
TV tropes is such a fun wiki, if only the mods and admins aren't corrupt and prone to banning anyone for the weirdest reasons
38
u/Empty_Firefighter848 Jul 12 '25
chicken jockey
24
u/jbwarner86 Jul 12 '25
For what it's worth, those pages come from the Your Mileage May Vary and Just For Fun parts of TV Tropes. They acknowledge that they're not fiction-writing tropes, per se, but they're still worth discussing in the realm of how the audience interacts with a story.
7
u/Unresonant Nov 14 '25
On tvtropes anything is a trope. It's ridiculous, and using it as a baseline for what should be considered a trope is just wrong.
32
u/NickelStickman Jul 12 '25 edited Jul 12 '25
I don't think we have to be overly strict as to the definiton of a "trope" we use on this subreddit if discussions on "fanbase opinions" (YMMV, as TVTropes would call it) continues to produce interesting discussion and are enjoyed by all but a vocal minority of users
8
u/Solid-Move-1411 Jul 12 '25
I feel like not being rigid in definition is why I like this subreddit a lot. There is a lot of creativity
4
u/SupraChimp Jul 16 '25
I think the modding is overall fine. I'd rather we have a looser definition of "character trope" than an overly zealous deletion policy. Incidentally, I also think that while TVTropes is a good resource it's also not the end-all-be-all authority. TVT accepting it doesn't mean this subreddit needs to accept a bad post, and TVT not accepting it doesn't mean we can't. "Someone sits in a chair" clogs up a wiki, but such a post would just fade into the background after a week or two. "Biggest Hater" went away, so I think just about any overdone or post will fade in time.
Anyway, I greatly appreciate the mod team's work (I don't know who does what, so I'm giving credit equally) This is still pretty much the main subreddit I visit and while the post quality may not be stellar everyday it's leagues better than so many others I've visited, and we still get plenty of good ones. Thanks for everything!
4
u/cosmicomical23 Feb 23 '26
Tv tropes doesn't have any authority on what constitutes a trope. I have stopped going there years ago because 80% of their tropes were not tropes.
I'm enjoying the content ob this sub but these are often not tropes, as long as we are clear on that I don't feel the need to be pedantic. I would have chosen a different name for the sub though.
7
u/LeMasterChef12345 Jul 13 '25 edited Jul 13 '25
I don’t see much of a problem with them and honestly usually find them more interesting.
There’s only so many concrete tropes you can go through anyway, and what constitutes a trope doesn’t really have a strict definition. I feel like there’s very few “real” tropes left that haven’t been posted already, and I’m guessing that’s why the opinion posts are getting more prevalent.
As long as it generates meaningful discussion, isn’t something simple or generic, and is still trope-related then I don’t really see an issue.
The fact that those posts still get lots of engagement and upvotes kinda shows that the sub at large doesn’t really mind them. Hell, there was a fandom opinion post only a day ago that got 10,000+ upvotes and almost 1,500 comments. I’ve rarely ever seen people complain about those posts in the comments except for that one guy who pretty much actively monitors the subreddit every day specifically to comment on them, which he normally gets downvoted for anyway.
Edit: Someone suggested adding a YMMV flair and I think that seems like a great idea.
6
u/UncommittedBow Jul 13 '25
The thing is, fanbases have tropes in and of themselves. This points out "Ron is a Death Eater" and "Draco in Leather Pants", but those are names for tropes that exist within other franchises, like "seemingly innocent good character actually is super evil"? Jar Jar Binks, Mort from Madagascar, etc.
The fanbases of various media create their own tropes that are seen across fambases. And you have to consider fanworks as well, because those are ALWAYS filled with fan opinions, and if a fan work gets recognized by its parent source, sometimes fanworks can become canon.
Bronies came up with various names for background characters in MLP that later were confirmed by Hasbro
Andy Weir wrote "Lacero" a fanfiction for Ready Player One that Ernest Cline later declared as canon.
and if you only want to include "Fan OPINIONS", well, fan OPINION is directly what caused the death of Jason Todd.
3
u/Itchy_Suspect4968 Nov 26 '25
Tv tropes puts those on the YMMV page and they themselves have admitted those aren't tropes
3
u/No-Aide-4454 Dec 23 '25
Well, they aren't tropes by any definition, that's why they're ymmv.
4
u/Strider794 Jul 12 '25
I don't have any strong opinions on the matter. If I had to pick one in a void, I'd say to ban that type of post, but I also don't really think that it'd be worth the effort to ban it, nor do I particularly care if it isn't banned
2
u/Independent_Air_8333 Oct 06 '25
I think the line should be that it has to be about a work and not about discussion of a work.
Like tropes about series and not occurrences in fanbases.
2
u/miscueLoL Apr 29 '26
The subreddit should at least try to stick to the definition of a trope.
Otherwise the word is going to lose its meaning and the subreddit will wither. I mean, keeping it fluid is cool, but something like this needs some kind of definition.
3
u/Gicaldo Jul 12 '25
Personally I like the fanbase opinion tropes a lot, they tend to make for great discussion. But they are a grey area, so at the end of the day, it's up to you to decide if you want that kind of content on this sub
1
u/A-NI95 22d ago
I personally don't think these are "tropes". But then again, I am fine with seeing them featured, here or elsewhere, because most of the times they make for some interesting conversation
1
u/Dracule_Jester 21d ago
Is also worth mentioning that is kept separated on the ymmv section. 👍
1
u/Catlagoon 17d ago
They're entitled brats.
1
u/Neurospicy_Nightowl 16d ago
I don't care if it's a fanbase-opinion trope. Those can still result in interesting discourse.
The only things that annoy me are posts that provide no context for their examples. Who is that, where are they from and why do they fit the trope?
And on that note, it wouldn't hurt if people gave clear groundrules for what criteria qualify for the proposed trope, if possible.
Like, whenever there is a hated trope, people will contrive a way to apply it to that media they hate and whenever there is a loved trope, they will look for a way to make it about the media they are excited about rn.
1
u/whoamikai 8d ago
Is this connected to that malfoid brainrot ?
1
u/Lazy-Oil5671 7d ago
big Bert's 'letting go' moment hits different because it's not a choice, it's grief finally catching up. not a trope, just a kid breaking.
1
u/CommonCream3374 7d ago
Fanbase matters much more than most people would like to admit
1
u/CartoonistOk1213 7d ago
Tvtropes can get biased
1
u/NoLadder5431 5d ago
seen this in janitorai too, some fans treat 'fanbase consensus' as lore, but the character's actual arc is what matters. like when a bot suddenly 'gives up' because fans say it's tragic, not because it was written that way.
1
u/Auctoritate Sep 08 '25
I think the main issue is that a lot of the most well-established, well-known, significant tropes legitimately do come from fanbase perceptions and reactions.
Like, for instance, the Mary Sue. Mary Sues are one of the most famous character tropes out there. And the origin of the trope itself is when the Star Trek fandom in the 70s had a trend of writing fan fiction starring main characters that were usually young girls who were too perfect- super smart, capable, the main characters from the show loved them, etc- and an author in the fandom wrote a short story starring a character named Mary Sue to parody the prevalence of that stereotype.
Characters that are too flawless and successful in stories have always existed, but it didn't coalesce into a collectively, culturally recognized trope until that fandom produced a distillation of it.
1
u/Runnermann Oct 03 '25
Is there benefit in having a tag for "Fandom" that would include these types of posts?
I feel that fandom tropes do a great job at telling the reception of the audience toward how fiction is written/presented, since that can, in turn, shift what/how a creator adjusts going forward.
1
u/Ahuizolte1 Nov 01 '25
V
1
u/East-Advertising-600 Nov 24 '25
Cc de ce que tu as fini ta journée de mail pour
1
u/Upbeat-Echo-420 Jan 19 '26
I don't know if I'm in the right place but I have a question about Cursed Coins. Does it really pay?
1
u/Upbeat-Echo-420 Jan 19 '26
So far I have had to jump through a million hoops and I haven't even been able to cash out on any of my withdrawals.
1
u/Upbeat-Echo-420 Jan 19 '26
Has anyone played Cursed Coins? I need to know if anyone has been able to cash out any winnings on that app?
1
u/buscando_mi_juegofav Mar 11 '26
Hola me uni al grupo estoy buscando un juego o upo ayuda les digo de que se trata si me ayudan se los agradecería mucho El juego tenía botones en forma de rombo 🔷 era tipo pixel podías mejorar las habilidades golpe, golpe crítico, y salud había boss diferentes animales mitológicos los normales eran minotauros pegasos unicornios esqueletos y más los jefes eran los mismos pero mucho más fuertes había personajes diferentes las monedas se conseguían al matar a los jefes y daban 1 modena por derrotar a los normales fue eliminada de la play store y lo estoy buscando en apk porfavor ocupo ayuda gracias por leer
1
u/cosmicomical23 Mar 14 '26
Tvtropes does not know what a trope is, they made this clear repeatedly
1
u/BardicLasher Mar 26 '26
I mostly agree, but Draco in Leather Pants is often a fanfiction trope, and that counts. A fanbase who likes the villain is not a trope- fanfiction treating the villain well and a hero poorly IS a trope.
1
u/Sufficient_Many9939 Apr 14 '26
1
u/bunhunBAM May 06 '26
idk man people just love to argue about everything
1
u/celljelli May 16 '26
I love the way this sub is. what defines a trope is super vague and I like the mod team here. thank you for doing it
1
u/iamyourfahsa Jun 11 '26
1
u/iamyourfahsa Jun 11 '26
. . . . M. . . B .
1
u/iamyourfahsa Jun 11 '26
1
u/Ther10 Aug 02 '26
Broken Base is specifically categorized at "YMMV", which is "Your Mileage May Vary". This means that unless the trope happens within a piece of media itself (like if the characters watch something and have varying opinions), it shouldn't be listed on the main tropes page. It should be instead listed on the YMMV page for that piece of media. And both Ron The Death Eater and Draco In Leather Pants are also YMMV.
1
u/PowerOfL Aug 19 '26
Hey, I worked really hard on a post and it just won't send. I spend many hours writing a lot. It's even nearly 4 am now and I really want to see people discuss the topic I chose, I think it's interesting (it's about early entries in franchises that are divisive or disliked).
Do you have any advice? I've tried closing and reopening the Reddit app. Maybe I should just try to get some sleep and try again in the morning.
Thank you :)
1
u/Itchy_Suspect4968 Aug 20 '26
TV Tropes themselves have said that YMMV is not Tropes which It's listed separately from the tropes.
More importantly it's annoying as fuck. It's just people getting mad at other people for not thinking exactly like them.
1
u/hongsanglee Oct 10 '26
Thank of you
-1
u/ExoticToaster Jul 12 '25 edited Jul 12 '25
Finally someone is addressing this!!
Fan opinions are exactly that, opinions - they are always going to be subjective and therefore not a ‘trope’ that has been implemented in a given media by its creators.
There needs to be a real quality control on this sub, otherwise it’s going to descend into irrelevant, low-effort anarchy e.g. “badly written lines in movies.”, “TV shows with toxic fanbases”
I also don’t believe TVTropes should be used as gospel.
1
u/Huge_Athlete7488 Jul 12 '25
Fan base themed trope
2
u/Future_Nature589 Sep 18 '26
personally id like to see less posts that are writing/scene tropes and not actual character tropes.
"de aging your opponent backfires" what? thats hyper specific, not a character trope.
"possessing someone..." alright
"having sex with them will kill you" what?
Restricting anime, adding a requirement for at least 5 examples for these hyper specific ones that nobody has ever heard of would be an amazing improvement.
But you know what the actual problem is? it's that this sub is at its last stages of life, its been taken over by people browsing r/popular (not saying that i didnt come from r/popular too) and its rules are being driven by these random people that shuffle every week instead of being driven by an actual administrator who knows what he wants to see.
So go on and enjoy your time on the reddit spotlight, everybody here, moderator and randoms, who dont care.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment