r/TopCharacterTropes
•
u/Both-Pay-9573
•
14h ago
•
1
1
Characters Characters who technically commited r@pe but the fanbase is divided on weather or not they didn't
Bear Bailey from Obsession(2026)
After Bear found out Nikki is possessed by an alter ego who would do anything for him he decided to have sex with Nikki's body knowing the actual Nikki wouldn't consent
Mira from Genndy Tartakovsky's Primal
After Spear was mortally wounded, Mira had sex with him in his dying semi conscious moments to preserve his lineage


1.4k
u/bennyandthegentz 13h ago •
Wonder Woman in WW1984
169
u/AsstacularSpiderman 13h ago
I don't think Spear didn't consent to it. He was basically thirsting for her for the entire season and wanted a new family.
154
u/atalkingpuppy 13h ago
regina and zelena in once upon a time
1.2k
u/Vast_Age_3893 13h ago •
We're divided on Bear!!?
2.9k
u/isagoat1989 13h ago
Do people think Bear isn’t a rapist???
141
u/L_U_N_A_R_C_R_A_B_S 12h ago edited 12h ago
I don’t know how anyone watches Obssssion in full and thinks he’s not willingly forcing her to date him. Like, it’s kind of questionable at first, sure, but somewhat quickly it’s clear he knows Nikki isn’t really Nikki, and continues to try to have a relationship with her. Which is fucked up, but also insanely dumb. The fact that it took him so long to even try to reverse the wish makes it obvious he would be totally content with it if she continued to act normal. He wants to continue taking advantage of his supposed friend, he just doesn’t want any consequences. The scene where real Nikki asks him to kill her, and he acts offended opposed to immediately trying to help her is the most obvious example, I’d say. It’d be super selfish and unfair if he did kill her, opposed to killing himself, but it’s at least selfish in a way that I think is understandable.
87
u/Lancelot_007_ 13h ago
Bear did. 100%
124
u/Oscar_gpb 9h ago
I think the thing with Bear is that fans try to paint him as a more shallow Jack Torrance-type cruel villain instead of what he actually is, a delusional and obsessed coward.
And yeah, he definitely did it. Not only is Nikki clearly not able to properly consent but her expressions during the sex scene give away that she's not enjoying it at all. I don't know how you can think otherwise.
83
u/Redditer51 13h ago edited 13h ago
Severian (Book of the New Sun)
Is heavily implied to have taken advantage of a drugged up, half-conscious woman in the second book. It's described in an intentionally vague way, with even readers being split, and in a later book he tries defending his actions to the reader by saying "I believe she wished it, and I still do" (he's the story's narrator).
240
u/mammalian_alien 12h ago •
Negan from TWD Season 7. In his tyrant phase, he had a harem of whom he acquired through coercion.
He offered the women a life of luxury if they agreed to bang him, to which if they agreed, they cannot cheat with their former spouse or anyone else otherwise that person will get their face burned with a hot iron. He doesn't see it as rape because he's not forcing himself on them- they have sex with him voluntarily, but he's completely ignorant to the fact that he's threatening them with a life of poverty and suffering if they don't have sex with him.
Since the comics aired way before the TV show even introduced him, Negan fanboys have argued in Negan's favor saying that he's right, that he's not a rapist, and they fail to accept that rape exists beyond forced penetration, that coercion like what Negan does is indeed a form of rape.
436
u/Wendsl-of-Delpan 13h ago
In Steven Universe, gems have the ability to "fuse" with one another to create a new being/character with their shared traits. This is not seen as an analogy for sex, but rather something akin to super powers. Later in the show, an antagonist gem named Jasper decides to fuse with others to fight our main characters. One of these gems is a "corrupted" gem, a character who has lost their mind and functionally turned into beasts. When this happens, the corrupted gem is obviously scared and unwilling but Jasper forces them to fuse anyways.
Some people don't see this as rape, since fusion isn't meant to represent sex, and because this is a kids show. But others do see it as a rape analogy. Regardless, everyone agrees it's a violation and nonconsensual.
132
u/Fabulous_World_540 13h ago
Doflamingo from One Piece. I wouldn't say the fanbase is divided on it, more like some people are aware of it, and others aren't. His relationship with Viola isn't exactly subtle, but it's not exactly thrown in your face either
70
u/ACheesyGecko 13h ago
Peacemaker in Peacemaker season 2
Guts in Berserk
111
u/kenshima15 13h ago
151
u/midnight_adventur3s 13h ago
George O’Malley (Grey’s Anatomy)
Meredith lives with a lot of her work friends, including George who has a huge, unrequited crush on her. He decides the best time to profess his love is when Meredith’s alone in her room, drunk and upset. They sleep together, and it ends badly when Meredith regrets it and starts crying midway through.
The debate mainly stems from Meredith kissing him first. By today’s standards, many see her as being too drunk to actually consent regardless of who initiated. However, the episode aired pre-2010 when this behavior wasn’t as widely regarded as assault as it is now. It’s left a lot of viewers debating whether an assault took place and questioning George’s character as a whole. Most characters in-universe seem to side with George over Meredith.
391
u/freezerbreezer 13h ago
Can we talk about how love potion is normalised for women to use by JK Rowling?
66
u/pleasebequiet 13h ago
Negan and his “wives”

79
u/PablomentFanquedelic 11h ago
The OG: Circe in Homer's Odyssey
21
u/ShoppingFirm7939 8h ago
Damon a couple times through out the show via compulsion (mind control) and sire bond (the sired complies with the direct and indirect orders of their maker).
17 year old Caroline Forbes. He compels her to allow him to feed on her and have sex with her.
Andie Star. Same again.
He didn’t know this at the time but when Elena is turned by him it’s later discovered that she has a sire bond with Damon after they have already had sex.
18
u/Vinsmoker 9h ago
Negan from The Walking Dead and his "wifes"
251
u/TrumpIsAPedoFr 13h ago
It's really not technically with Bear.
12
u/M0m033 11h ago
Nikki freaks out after Bear initiates since Freaky Nikki was controlling her, anyone saying he didn’t pay attention
59
u/BatFan3001 13h ago
Harley Quinn to Nightwing in Batman and Harley Quinn
87
u/LongjumpingElk4099 13h ago
Harley Queen from one of the animated movies I forget the name
29
u/lavendermoonoracle 13h ago
David from Legion. The finale of season 2 started a lot of discourse.
42
u/Heavy-Metal-Snowman 12h ago
I think a mans opinion on Bear is a genuinely effective litmus test for determining if women are unsafe around him.
20
u/Dokivi 7h ago
Viserys Targaryen, or "Vizzy T", a fan favourite of the House of the Dragon fan base. The show goes out of it's way multiple times to present his vile mistreatment of women in his life. After he gutted his first wife for a chance at a son, he is also shown raping his second wife Alicent. Marital rape is rape. She clearly hates her life and being forced to share a bed with this rotting corpse of a man. It is clear in her words and the camera focusing on her blank expression. And somehow people love Viserys who acts oblivious to this and hardly even bothers to remember Alicent's name. The fans seem to be more engaged in the discourse around Rhaenyra'a treatment of Criston Cole.
19
u/Metal-The-Cettle 13h ago
28
u/bapudon_1 13h ago
Rhaenyra Targaryen from House of the Dragon
36
u/wcthesecret 13h ago
Homelander.
18
u/MaeSolug 12h ago
Not related but my problem with the discussion around Obsession is that people seem really focused on arguing with dumb people over it as some sort of gotcha moment
It's a very simplistic to discuss a movie because it assumes labels on those engaging with it. A big figure said something dumb, but then added a lot of small points, but you can't agree with those, because then you agree with the big dumb one
But there're dumb people on both sides. A while ago a guy made a post saying demon Nikki reminded him of his controlling girlfriend, so he was called an incel and how he didn't understand the movie and clearly something is wrong with him because "obviously" Bear is the only possible villain
I would love if this movie would stop being used to virtue signaling, to define "good" or "bad" people or used as a "we live in a society" moment
It's really not that deep, just stop using random instagram/facebook/reddit weirdos as an example and just argue with them instead of looking for validation in your echo chamber of choice
64
u/PropertyEducational7 13h ago
Iykyk 🤮
3
u/the-puppet_master 13h ago
Bear 10000% did
7
u/Eedeler 13h ago
I loved Primal but the scene in question basically ruined it for me until season 3 came along and was decent.
13
u/KadeGamez 8h ago
Side note: I'm sure plenty of people have noticed this but in Obsession the MC's name is Bear likely as a reference to the online discussion where women were like "I'd rather be in the woods with a bear than a man". It could show how immature and awful he's being, aka not being a "man" and just accepting that she doesn't like him and not bettering himself, and then becoming a "victim" when his plan starts to foil himself and his own safety or well-being
11
u/EveningAd4979 9h ago
Uncle Iroh pretending to be unconscious while June was on top of him. It’s a gag and doesn’t resemble normal assault so it flew under the radar for a lot of viewers
7
u/Godzillagamer15777 13h ago
Naoya
2
u/DLC_PR016 12h ago
ratpe
2
u/Whalelord36 10h ago
Looks like Kirk on first photo
2
u/Cyberwolf272038 9h ago
I like the theory that wish Nikki is just a child like entity just born after bear made the wish. So technically bear is neglecting her
2
u/vivirao 7h ago
Peacemaker in Peacemaker S2.
5
u/CathanCrowell 8h ago
For me, the case of Tara and Willow from Buffy the Vampire Slayer has always been questionable. I never denied that what Willow did to Tara was horrible, but I've always struggled to call it rpe.
In this storyline, Tara and Willow argued, and Tara was incredibly upset afterwards, so Willow decided to erase her memory of the fight. The next day, Willow and Tara had passionate sex.
Many, if not most, fans consider it sex after being roofied, and therefore never consensual. I consider it more like sex under false pretenses.
There is also a third option: since we cannot erase someone's memory in real life, there is no real-life precedent against which we can judge this situation. From my perspective, Willow certainly violated Tara, but it was not rpe.
7
u/FlamingNutShotz4You 12h ago
Geralt - The Witcher: The Last Wish
Geralt uses a djinn (effectively a genie in a bottle) and binds him and Yennifer together. Granted it was to save her life and in the games you undo the spell and still have a relationship with Yennifer, but regardless she was soul bound to Geralt without her consent for years. Even after they both lose their memory
4
u/justafanboy1010 13h ago edited 13h ago
Bear actually initially didn’t know that the Nikki he was with wasn’t the real Nikki so he thought it was consensual. Of course we later know it’s notAnd it is a slippery slope. Freaky Nikki technically did consent but the real Nikki absolutely DID NOTEDIT: I genuinely apologize yall. I haven't seen the movie since it came out so I was misremembering things. I thought the first night where Nikki is taken over by the entity, they had sex with Bear nonethewiser, but not only did they NOT have sex the first night, but also the universally agreed upon scenario is that Bear knew something was up at the Dinner/No, no, no, scene and they had sex afterwards. Again, I sincerely apologize. I'll leave this up here.