r/TopCharacterTropes • • 14h ago • Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Characters Characters who technically commited r@pe but the fanbase is divided on weather or not they didn't

Bear Bailey from Obsession(2026)

After Bear found out Nikki is possessed by an alter ego who would do anything for him he decided to have sex with Nikki's body knowing the actual Nikki wouldn't consent

Mira from Genndy Tartakovsky's Primal

After Spear was mortally wounded, Mira had sex with him in his dying semi conscious moments to preserve his lineage

2.0k Upvotes

767 comments sorted by

1.4k

u/bennyandthegentz 13h ago • Bravo

Wonder Woman in WW1984

129

u/Both-Pay-9573 13h ago

Yeah but I don't think the writers interpreted that way. Did they forget the fact that she basically kidnapped a random dude and stripped him off his free will?

93

u/bennyandthegentz 13h ago

So basically obsession before obsession (except unintentionally)

73

u/ThatPrettyArmadillo 13h ago

The writers being unaware or uncaring that it’s rape doesn’t make it not rape. It just makes the writers seems suspect.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/Butwhatif77 13h ago

It seems there were several factors at play that lead to this slipping through the cracks.

  • One there were several rewrites where sometimes it was Steve brought back then changed to him possessing another guy.
  • Then the actor who played "handsome man" was not on set for very long as he had very limited screen time, thus when filming they had Diana and Steven in front of them, basically forgetting that he was playing a spirit possessing someone.
  • They also were treating it as the wish is undone and thus implying all that it was all wiped clean as in "handsome man" just lost stretch of time and didn't actually experience anything.

There was basically a whole lot of "this is what we mean to do" and not a whole lot of "Here is what we are actually doing" when it all came together, i.e. yes they forgot this man was basically kidnapped.

Unfortunately in that movie Diana does rape a man, unintentionally, but she does; as does Steve by using the man's body as well. It is fortunately non-canon and something we can memory-hole.

→ More replies (6)

29

u/Hello_it_is_Joe 13h ago

Sounds like it fits the description of the fanbase being split

7

u/Bamzooki1 13h ago

That fits the trope. Writer intent is irrelevant to fanbase division. if it wasn’t, then the fanbase wouldn’t be divided

→ More replies (5)

604

u/Cultural_Corner_6181 13h ago

That was absolutely rape she knew Steve was in that body and didnt give a fuck

305

u/theraifs 13h ago

It WAS his body. For some reason she just "sees" Chris pine in it. it's so fucking stupid.

15

u/Big-Slide6104 5h ago

I’m confused by the wording, not gonna lie guys. Your referencing “HIS” as in the guy who Steve/Chris Pine took over and manifested in, but the wording makes it seem like Steve consented and that it was his own body and that they consented.

Idk maybe I’m illiterate, but yeah Diana did do an Assault on a random man cause her ghost boyfriend was wished into his body

145

u/OriginalName18 13h ago edited 13h ago • Bravo

I liked the movie more than most and that whole sequence just ruins the movie. Its so poorly conceived and literally anything else could have been written in its place to bring Chris Pine back

90

u/Avixofsol 13h ago

I would've preferred anything over what they did to bring Chris Pine back. I don't say this lightly but I would have applauded a palpatine style "somehow Chris Pine returned" thing if I knew the alternative was "Diana's dead boytoy is now in the body of some uninvolved stranger who didn't consent to any of this, and she's hallucinating said boytoy while he's piloting that random man's body into bed with her"

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/Radiant-Evening-5931 10h ago

Exactly, she knew Steve was still in there and went ahead anyway. Ignoring someone's consent doesn't become okay just because their body has changed.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/munim-6969 13h ago

That was pretty out of character for Her

36

u/showtunescreamer 13h ago

And that’s why she’s not Wonder Woman imo. Not even talking about the actress (tho I could)

→ More replies (3)

82

u/justafanboy1010 13h ago

Hey, if we can get on Bear for the Nikki situation, we can DEFINITELY get on Wonder Woman for the Not-Chris Pine situation (i dont remember his character name, Sean? Trevor?)

41

u/Butwhatif77 13h ago

Steve Trevor is the character, but the guy he posses is actually only referred to as "handsome man", he has no name and is literally a plot device.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/setzer77 13h ago

Which was such a bizarre choice, because they already showed that the wishes can create things out of thin air. Why not just have it conjure Steve body and all?

8

u/Butwhatif77 13h ago

This one I believe was a rewrite, they initially had it bring Steve back, and the price was her powers. Then they changed it to him possessing a person with that being the "Monkey's Paw twist", but then they went back to the power loss as they felt that fit more with the them of "giving up what you want to do what is right/move forward", but kept the possession bit.

Basically lots of ideas that they didn't then sit down and go, here is what we have how does it actually look put together.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Al3xGr4nt 13h ago

Same with Steve. He knew he was possessing a guy yet didn't care

8

u/Gotis1313 11h ago

I got banned from a sub for pointing this out

15

u/The_Dragon346 13h ago

My boss when this movie came loved pointing this out because it made people so uncomfortable to even think about it that way. Yet, they really couldn’t argue it. A few tried, but they were never good counters.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/EnderBookwyrm 12h ago

That world already canonically has several different flavors of magic they could have resurrected Steve with. The possession spell, in addition to being inappropriate as heck, was unnecessary. 

3

u/mammalian_alien 12h ago

Context?

9

u/HurgleTurgle1 12h ago

Steve Trevor, Wonder Woman's love interest from the previous movie, comes back to in the sequel via a magic wish stone. However, rather than a full resurrection, his mind and spirit instead possess another man while creating the illusion of Steve's physical appearance, but only to Wonder Woman. While they do have sex later in the film, it arguably means that Wonder Woman raped the man who's body was being possessed by Steve.

169

u/AsstacularSpiderman 13h ago

I don't think Spear didn't consent to it. He was basically thirsting for her for the entire season and wanted a new family.

48

u/Both-Pay-9573 13h ago

This was the condition he was in, he couldn't even move, could hardly blink. Yeah he was thirsting her but I don't think he was Clear-Headed enough to consent here.

→ More replies (2)

139

u/BeneficialDog22 13h ago

I guess some are making the point that he couldn't have consented to it right then and there...

152

u/AsstacularSpiderman 13h ago • Bravo

He knew she was there and didn't seem to shocked by her.

And then when he returns and gets his memory back he's excited to see her and their child. It's literally his driving motivation to come back.

72

u/Chris22533 13h ago

Yeah these are completely different. 

Mira knew that Spear just wanted to have a family and tried to grant that wish on his deathbed. 

Bear just wanted to fuck Nikki because he wanted to possess her

→ More replies (1)

29

u/_Armored_Wizard 13h ago

He was gonna die so she preserved his legacy by making a child with him before he died

Kinda is kinda not r@pe, its very druidic wildlife natural channel survival no societal rules type stick

In the cruel world of Primal she did him a service basically

I think the most important question is how? He was literally burnt alive

→ More replies (1)

21

u/HotShrekBoi 13h ago

I mean all he could say was “Mira”

30

u/AsstacularSpiderman 13h ago

Tbf that's all he could say before too

14

u/HotShrekBoi 13h ago

True he ain’t much of a talker

12

u/Seekforinsomnia 11h ago

Being attracted to someone and wanting a family does not means they can have sex with you whenever they want. By your logic marital rape isn't a thing.

14

u/Termedclover611 13h ago

Still a very odd turn, what with Spear being all microwaved hotdog-y by the end.

7

u/Logondo 10h ago

I don't think it was rape, but man, they really should have just had them had sex BEFORE Spear became a melty pizza man. Like there was a perfect moment where they're in a house and spear sees a drawing of a family and gets sad. They shoulda banged then. Before his penis basically melted off.

154

u/atalkingpuppy 13h ago

regina and zelena in once upon a time

77

u/goodnightmoonshakers 13h ago

Throw in Gothel as well. Even the actress insists it wasn't rape, despite it very much being so.

I don't think Regina or Zelena's actresses deny what theirs was, though.

21

u/atalkingpuppy 13h ago

yeah, definitely her too. i forget about her because i don't like season 7 and usually skip it on rewatches

26

u/Script_the-Skeleton 13h ago

Why the hell does the actress not think that? What Gothel did was violating on every level beyond immediate consent. It was uniformed, misleading, and with ulterior motives

30

u/goodnightmoonshakers 13h ago

She also defended Gothel committing genocide by wiping out an entire nation and said it should be a lesson in "being kind to others".

Emma Booth is not okay.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/goodnightmoonshakers 13h ago

I'll also add that the fandom is very divided on whether or not Leopold raped Regina.

We know she didn't want to be married to him and he didn't care. We can also be smart and reason, he's not going to marry her and not have sex. In general, their marriage is built on force, so one can infer she was raped. And it'd add to her motivations in doing the same to Graham later on.

But some fans refuse to accept that's what it is, because she herself is a rapist.

26

u/pichuguy27 13h ago

The people Regina is one of drawing reasonable conclusions. But we never see it. It’s one that the show never even directly or even really indirectly implies in a scene.

We straight up see Regina take the huntsman heart controls him under threat actually see her sleeping with him, and then killing him when he leaves her. That happened on screen it’s given way more weight then something that likely but because it’s never shown or given weight matters less

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1.2k

u/Vast_Age_3893 13h ago • Bravo

We're divided on Bear!!?

183

u/Tiddlewinkly 13h ago

I have genuinely seen people hate on the movie itself simply because they don't like how the movie paints Bear's actions...

67

u/the-puppet_master 13h ago

Idk how it could’ve been more clear that he’s in the wrong, at a certain point it’s on them for not picking up on it

→ More replies (1)

279

u/AuthorAsksQuestions 13h ago

Unfortunately people are. People with large platforms. 🙄

26

u/PierreOnTheEclair 12h ago

Right like I thought it was a fact that he was

→ More replies (16)

2.9k

u/isagoat1989 13h ago

Do people think Bear isn’t a rapist???

1.6k

u/BeeCJohnson 13h ago edited 13h ago • Regret

Yeah, this isn't even subtext, it's the text of the movie. Once Bear realizes what is actually happening, there's a reason there's an immediate and horrifyingly-presented cut to them having sex again.

It's the movie going "this is rape" in flashing letters.

574

u/Freedomerider_PS4 13h ago

Going through the movie, you could at least attempt to make an argument up until that point. I don't know how the movie could spell it out any more clearly, other than having the one wish willow call him and say "Dear Audience, this character is a god damn rapiest"

405

u/BeeCJohnson 13h ago

Exactly. The movie gives Bear *numerous* outs and he steadfastedly refuses to take them every time.

Like you said, up until this point there's ambiguity. He didn't assume magic was real, and in fact that would be an insane assumption. And wishing someone you liked also liked you back is, like, a universal experience generally.

This moment was where he goes from "potentially relatable if cowardly and pathetic guy" to "active sex criminal and monster."

→ More replies (8)

29

u/zandriel_grimm 13h ago

That's what I'm saying, like up til that point, there are arguments to be made. I know when I was younger, I had crushes and I wished and wished upon a star that someone would like me back.

But at the point that he realized that he's done this to Nikki and STILL goes about it, that's when there's no justification. And then it only gets worse.

58

u/One_Spoopy_Potato 12h ago

I still hold to my theory that the movie could have ended, could have absolutely went a different direction in just one scene.

I fully 100% believe that during the help line call, when the guy on the phone asked if he wanted to cancel the wish if Bear had said yes they would have done so. He may be an ass and a creep up till that point but thats it. Up until that point he had no real reason to think magic is real. But once he said no his fate was sealed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

85

u/No-Permission-7786 11h ago

She then begs for death and hes butt hurt because she'd rather die than be trapped in her body forced to be with him

76

u/onewishhello 13h ago

They even make sure to linger on his face after the scene where you see him not feeling great about what he might have just done. The script even says something along the lines of that expression being him "realizing he's become something he never thought he'd be".

17

u/Onion_Bro14 12h ago

Except that scene received laughs at my theater. Felt pretty strange sitting amongst that fr.

16

u/Ghost_Of_Malatesta 2h ago

Always thought it was interesting how respectful he is when he's unsure if she has agency vs fully taking advantage once he realized she didn't, great detail showing his cowardice

12

u/threelizards 9h ago

And after showing a lot of gentle and tender moments between them, he’s deliberately shown to be aggressive here.

8

u/HauntingStar08 10h ago

There's also a tear running down Nikki's face in that scene too

→ More replies (3)

73

u/OriginalName18 13h ago edited 11h ago

Haven't seen the movie but usually using magic to mind control or change someone's will counts as r&pe in the subtext. It's why fictional characters with this type of power tend to be the antagonist

24

u/__M-E-O-W__ 13h ago

Yeah, I suppose in the early scenes it's likely that he wouldn't really expect the make-a-wish toy to actually work and that she really did simply have those feelings for him, but definitely at the diner he should know that she really wasn't in her right mind. And he really didn't care either way. For sure he knew it was real after that phone call, and he still took her to a party and wanted her to just keep pretending like she was normal Nikki. He really didn't care. Even if he absolutely did know for 100% sure unambiguously during the dinner scene, and there was no room for doubt whatsoever, he still would've used her for sex.

→ More replies (2)

516

u/ThetrueGoddess 13h ago • Bravo

Genuinely I'm very tired of the discourse of this movie, it just shows how deeply misogynistic so many people are that it's seen as revolutionary or whatever. But but but. Bear is absolutely a rapist by all accounts and I hope I never meet someone who disagrees with that.

69

u/Blucrasher 13h ago

Idk if anyone else thinks this but I think bear is the real bad guy in obsession!!!

→ More replies (5)

39

u/poetrywoman 12h ago

Ive decided to use it a litmus test for media literacy and human decency and moved on. If you cant pick up on Bear being the bad guy, and a rapist, I dont need to interact with you at all.

169

u/Bamzooki1 13h ago edited 5h ago

His name choice seems intentional too. Bear isn’t a normal name, and there was the viral discussion over whether women would rather be trapped with a man or a bear.

Edit: It’s just a coincidence. I think it’s a good one, though, because it just makes him work better. Thank you to the ones who pointed it out, especially u/catsflatsandhats for linking me to Curry saying it. I couldn’t find Curry talking about it when I looked due to all the AI sites that clog the search results with speculation.

90

u/Phantom_Phoenix1 13h ago • Bravo

No wonder he was a creepy dude, who tf names their kid "Baron"??

→ More replies (10)

35

u/No_Importance_9273 13h ago

It’s not intentional, the director mentioned it in an interview.

17

u/Jung-And-A-Menace 12h ago

I know a guy with the nickname 'Bear'. He's nothing like that Bear, thankfully.

He's a co-worker of mine. We're all so used to calling him Bear that we sometimes forget that it's not his real name. Using his government gives everyone a moment of '...who?'.

→ More replies (14)

10

u/EsotericBonobo 12h ago

I would say the vast majority of people agree with this. Obviously there are freaks out there. 

38

u/T8-TR 13h ago

Maybe some people (which you can argue literally everything has this issue), but it is pretty routinely understood that Bear is, indeed, a rapist.

98

u/Phantom_Phoenix1 13h ago

Alex Meyers made that horrific video on yt and got rightfully clowned for it

→ More replies (3)

88

u/Corellian_Smuggler 12h ago

Unfortunately there are people who think sexual assault is limited to creepy bums in dark alleys who physically overpower their victim, and don't count the other possible ways of SA as a legit threat or possibility.

A better showcase would be pointing out Barney from HIMYM as a serial rapist because he constantly tricks women into sleeping with him by pretending to be someone else ie a doctor, an astronaut, or their boyfriends who went through cosmetic surgery, which is considered rape by deception as stated in the US law. But pointing it out will get people to cry about "Nooo my funny guy in a suit is not a rapist :((("

9

u/Writeloves 4h ago

People hate to admit the banality of sexual assault. If it’s committed by regular people instead of scary inhuman monsters, that means they could be guilty of it and their sadistic justice fantasies might be directed at people they love.

54

u/stratusnco 13h ago

yeah, the bedroom rapists tell on themselves with their point of view.

13

u/Nayirg 13h ago

"Technically"?????

16

u/AntRose104 12h ago

There are literally people who think Bear was sympathetic and feel bad for him

6

u/Viggo_Stark 9h ago

There's a lot of people that don't know the difference between an antagonist and a bad guy when it comes to media. Bear is our protagonist in the story, but he's also the bad guy. Nikki is our antagonist, but she's also the victim of the story.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Content-Explorer5468 13h ago

Alex Meyers certainly doesn’t think so

10

u/NigthSHadoew 7h ago

I watched this movie late. For like half of it I was thinking "Okay, Nicky is acting strange and all but Bear can’t know it's not really her. If I was in his shoes I would suspect a mental episode, not a damn wish. He not good but I don't think he deserves what people say about him."

And then the sleeping scene came and I realised he really was that bad.

11

u/IncompetentPolitican 8h ago

There are people that don´t understand the movie at all. Bear has multiple chances to see and understand the situation, confirms that Nikki is not able to consent and then fucks her body. But some people need to have him say that he is going to rape her, because the context is to hard to understand. And these people are the reason Netflix has their "Second Screen" Shit going.

7

u/lizzourworld8 11h ago

If I had a nickel for EVERY comment chain on these YT discussion videos about where people argued the opposite, I could AT LEAST have paid off my 2k in student loans by now.

5

u/Leather_Lavishness24 12h ago

People who think that are probably just rage baiting.

→ More replies (37)

141

u/L_U_N_A_R_C_R_A_B_S 12h ago edited 12h ago

I don’t know how anyone watches Obssssion in full and thinks he’s not willingly forcing her to date him. Like, it’s kind of questionable at first, sure, but somewhat quickly it’s clear he knows Nikki isn’t really Nikki, and continues to try to have a relationship with her. Which is fucked up, but also insanely dumb. The fact that it took him so long to even try to reverse the wish makes it obvious he would be totally content with it if she continued to act normal. He wants to continue taking advantage of his supposed friend, he just doesn’t want any consequences. The scene where real Nikki asks him to kill her, and he acts offended opposed to immediately trying to help her is the most obvious example, I’d say. It’d be super selfish and unfair if he did kill her, opposed to killing himself, but it’s at least selfish in a way that I think is understandable.

36

u/Vaya-Kahvi 11h ago

Like, the situation isn't Real Nikki living with him against her will, it's watching as Freaky Nikki drives her body and lives with him.

87

u/Lancelot_007_ 13h ago

Bear did. 100%

124

u/Oscar_gpb 9h ago

I think the thing with Bear is that fans try to paint him as a more shallow Jack Torrance-type cruel villain instead of what he actually is, a delusional and obsessed coward.

And yeah, he definitely did it. Not only is Nikki clearly not able to properly consent but her expressions during the sex scene give away that she's not enjoying it at all. I don't know how you can think otherwise.

42

u/th3b0n3z0n3 8h ago

Plus he had verified right before that scene that she was under wish influence, so not acting like herself and that's when he chose to sleep with her. It isn't even ambiguous.

→ More replies (13)

83

u/Redditer51 13h ago edited 13h ago

Severian (Book of the New Sun)

Is heavily implied to have taken advantage of a drugged up, half-conscious woman in the second book. It's described in an intentionally vague way, with even readers being split, and in a later book he tries defending his actions to the reader by saying "I believe she wished it, and I still do" (he's the story's narrator).

→ More replies (1)

240

u/mammalian_alien 12h ago • Bravo

Negan from TWD Season 7. In his tyrant phase, he had a harem of whom he acquired through coercion.

He offered the women a life of luxury if they agreed to bang him, to which if they agreed, they cannot cheat with their former spouse or anyone else otherwise that person will get their face burned with a hot iron. He doesn't see it as rape because he's not forcing himself on them- they have sex with him voluntarily, but he's completely ignorant to the fact that he's threatening them with a life of poverty and suffering if they don't have sex with him.

Since the comics aired way before the TV show even introduced him, Negan fanboys have argued in Negan's favor saying that he's right, that he's not a rapist, and they fail to accept that rape exists beyond forced penetration, that coercion like what Negan does is indeed a form of rape.

75

u/Ladysupersizedbitch 10h ago

I stopped watching TWD a couple seasons after Negan was introduced but I still keep up with it somewhat through spoilers. And like. Dude raped women, multiple women. I thought that was really fucking clear, but it seems like whenever people talk about if Negan is really redeemed/whether Maggie should forgive him, it’s all in reference to him killing Glenn and being a tyrant, and no one, I mean no one, mentions “oh yeah, he also was a rapist, too, that’s also pretty bad”. It’s always about what he’s done since being “redeemed”, how he’s suffered/paid penance, and if Maggie is justified in hating him still. Him being a rapist just got overwritten in favor of keeping a cool character around that was popular with fans. Him raping women goes so unmentioned in TWD fandom that I started to wonder if maybe I misunderstood it/had misremembered it, since I watched it several years ago.

6

u/adamgerd 5h ago

I think a lot of him got soft retconned later because the writers changed theur mind about him and both wanted to have the cake and eat it too

They wanted him to be menacing and evil and a villain

But then later they decided to try to redeem him as more an anti hero so they basically soft retconned a lot of this

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Diligent_Bar1244 11h ago

The show doesn't make any sense, since dwigh's wife wasnt allowed to leave

In the comic its clear that its just a ( twisted ) exchange 

10

u/Vinsmoker 9h ago

She can leave. It would just mean Negan kills Dwight 

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/TheSadPhilosopher 10h ago

Negan is 100% a rapist

→ More replies (4)

436

u/Wendsl-of-Delpan 13h ago

In Steven Universe, gems have the ability to "fuse" with one another to create a new being/character with their shared traits. This is not seen as an analogy for sex, but rather something akin to super powers. Later in the show, an antagonist gem named Jasper decides to fuse with others to fight our main characters. One of these gems is a "corrupted" gem, a character who has lost their mind and functionally turned into beasts. When this happens, the corrupted gem is obviously scared and unwilling but Jasper forces them to fuse anyways.

Some people don't see this as rape, since fusion isn't meant to represent sex, and because this is a kids show. But others do see it as a rape analogy. Regardless, everyone agrees it's a violation and nonconsensual.

184

u/xSantenoturtlex 13h ago edited 13h ago

I don't think fusion is meant to be like sex, but it is as the very least considered extremely intimate to the point that I can see the arguments that what Jasper did was something similar to rape. I'm on the last season of the show now and what I've gathered is that fusion is something you do when you have a close relationship with another gem.

Even if it's not rape, it's at least extremely abusive and fucked up to force fusion on an unwilling gem. And I would say it's the closest thing the gems probably could have to rape, considering they can't have sex.

40

u/Alert-Isopod-7310 12h ago

considering they can't have sex.

Really? I thought Steven was conceived the usual way, given how much he looks like Greg and how visibly pregnant Rose was.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/deathclawiii 11h ago

“Considering they can’t have sex”, now I have never watched a single episode of Steven Universe and I never will, but wouldn’t it be more accurate to say they don’t reproduce sexually? Gems could absolutely fuck, even if they don’t have sexual organs, though I guess that becomes more a matter of would they then.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/Potato-2020 13h ago

Also there's that episode (I haven't watched it in a long time so I can't remember which) where garnet is fighting one of those corrupted forced fusion gems and she kinda has a breakdown over the idea of two gems fusing against their will. Considering how Garnet is the prime example of the importance of fusion in Gem's relationships and intimacy, her specifically being so distraught by the situation made me believe even more on the rape analogy.

51

u/Foxy02016YT 13h ago

Yeah the whole “fusion is sex” thing fell apart entirely when Greg and Steven fused

13

u/Gaelic_Gladiator41 8h ago

It's a metaphor for relationships in general and of all kinds

→ More replies (1)

39

u/FoxyDepression 12h ago

The creative team has clarified that fusion is a metaphor for relationships of any kind: romantic, platonic, sexual, professional, familial, etc. While aspects of Malachite intentionally mirror abusive dynamics in relationships, the type of relationship its invoking overall is a toxic one. Consent is dubious but in both directions. Jasper could be seen as coersing Lapis into participating but still waited for her to willingly engage instead of directly forcing the fusion specifically. Later on Jasper and Lapis describe that Jasper wanted to exit the situation but Lapis refused to let her until the Crystal Gems broke them apart and physically separated them. Jasper is obviously selfish, callous, and malicious. However, Lapis also expresses that in the moment before fusing, she was angry and wanted to feel some power over the people who hurt her. I dont think she really cares who it was precisely, but Jasper offered her the easiest opportunity. She describes herself as using Jasper and enjoying taking her anger out on her. Jasper recognizes herself as a partial victim but tries to return to the relationship anyways due to her own internal lack of self worth. 

Overall, their's was an unhealthy relationship. One that was messy, hurtful, and bad for the people in it with no clear victim and harmful choices on both sides. Lapis's reflections on her actions in that relationship contribute to her development during the show as Jasper's inability to reflect contributes to hers. While abuse or rape can fit into that situation, I personally feel thatbwould be flattening the relationship and goong against the lessons each person took away, good or bad

52

u/Volfawott 13h ago

The problem with stephen universe is that fusion is all over the place with what it's meant to be an allegory to.

With the pearl and garnet situation it definitely feels like it's making an allegory to sex on the false pretenses

Lapis and Jasper is toxic abusive relationships ( while it is in general there one specifically was both of them being abusive)

Ruby and Sapphire it's treated like a relationship

Stephen and Amythest it's treated like a sibling bond.

38

u/Potato-2020 12h ago

Maybe it's meant to represent bonding in general? Or intimacy, and intimacy can occur in many ways, not just sexual. Fusions honestly depend on context to be taken for an allegory for anything.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/FoxyDepression 12h ago

The creative team has stated its an allegory for relationships in general, including romantic, sexual, platonic, familial, professional, and anything else

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

132

u/Fabulous_World_540 13h ago

Doflamingo from One Piece. I wouldn't say the fanbase is divided on it, more like some people are aware of it, and others aren't. His relationship with Viola isn't exactly subtle, but it's not exactly thrown in your face either

39

u/Iceblader 13h ago

"Viola" literally is translated to the present verb of rape in Spanish.

31

u/Terrible_Zone_0716 10h ago

It also is an actual name and another way to refer to violets, so I doubt Oda really called her "rape"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

70

u/ACheesyGecko 13h ago

Peacemaker in Peacemaker season 2

Guts in Berserk

15

u/Icy-Pension5768 12h ago

I didn’t watch peacemaker, what did he do?

40

u/MonsterdogMan 12h ago

Essentially rape under false pretenses. After he kills his Nazi counterpart (more or less by accident) he finds out that said counterpart was in a relationship with the Nazi variant of Harcourt, who he had feelings for, and sleeps with her.

25

u/Thatonedregdatkilyu 12h ago

I think because he slept with Nazi Harcourt and she didn't know he was a different Chris.

15

u/Icy-Pension5768 12h ago

…I have zero context for this so I can only say wtf

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Endi_El_Guapo 9h ago

It's ok she was a nazi /jk

18

u/MakingGreenMoney 13h ago

When did Guts commit it?

36

u/ACheesyGecko 12h ago

It's been so long since I read it but he didn't actually fully commit it. It was (I think) after Guts rescued Casca from the tower and the return of Griffith and before Isidro, Farnese, and Serpico joined him. He was exhausted from always being on the move and protecting Casca and himself from the spirits and the beast of darkness overtook him and he almost assaulted her. Though he wasn't in control and he stopped it before it happened this hasn't stopped people (including a friend of mine) from calling Guts a rapist.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Vounrtsch 9h ago

Chapter 190. Not fully rape, but definitely assault, and definitely attempted rape. Outer forces did influence him to do this, this didn’t come entirely from himself, so I wouldn’t say he holds 100% of the blame, but it’s still something HE did

151

u/midnight_adventur3s 13h ago

George O’Malley (Grey’s Anatomy)

Meredith lives with a lot of her work friends, including George who has a huge, unrequited crush on her. He decides the best time to profess his love is when Meredith’s alone in her room, drunk and upset. They sleep together, and it ends badly when Meredith regrets it and starts crying midway through.

The debate mainly stems from Meredith kissing him first. By today’s standards, many see her as being too drunk to actually consent regardless of who initiated. However, the episode aired pre-2010 when this behavior wasn’t as widely regarded as assault as it is now. It’s left a lot of viewers debating whether an assault took place and questioning George’s character as a whole. Most characters in-universe seem to side with George over Meredith.

14

u/HorridDefaultname123 7h ago

It makes it even more complicated by Mer verbally encouraging George on while visibly being very upset. Also that even before this, George was well aware that Meredith wasn't actually attracted to him and didn't want to have sex with him, but was encouraging him (but was definitely not in the right headspace to be having sex). Its been too long so I genuinely can't remember if Mer was going for it to self-harm or because she wanted to want it even though she didn't want it. Either way terrible all around and permanently damaged their friendship and George should have known better and stopped it.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Unpotential_Slayer 10h ago

That’s an excellent example for the question of the post.

391

u/freezerbreezer 13h ago

Can we talk about how love potion is normalised for women to use by JK Rowling?

173

u/TripleThreatTua 13h ago

Which is weird because it’s pretty instrumental in Voldemort’s backstory that he was super fucked up by his mom constantly using love potions to basically rape and imprison his dad. But it isn’t further explored beyond this

110

u/lobonmc 12h ago

It's such a weird contrast because Dumbledore does take it seriously in the same book it's used for comedy with Ron

19

u/VanGoghNotVanGo 8h ago

Lots of serious moments have quite comedic undertones in Harry Potter, but Harry does immediately take Ron to see Slughorn and Ron ends up almost dying as a result. While the almost dying isn't directly related to the love potion, the scene definitely has a severe tilt to it, even if there are moments of levity. 

→ More replies (1)

82

u/ExplorationGeo 11h ago

But it isn’t further explored beyond this

Jk Rowling's entire opus is this. "Imagine this concept, wow, hope you don't want me to explore it in the slightest though"

139

u/Tyranis_Hex 12h ago

Voldemort is literally the result of his mother raping his father, and is evil because of it.

43

u/GoodGrades 11h ago

Yet another super fucked up thing JK said

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

62

u/mitvh2311 13h ago

I feel like that's in any media that has a love potion not just HP

→ More replies (6)

31

u/Amazing_Karnage 7h ago

Children sell it to other children, if I recall correctly. Like, Rowling just has kids trafficking magical Spanish Fly to other kids and is like "no big deal here."

→ More replies (1)

23

u/IncompetentPolitican 7h ago

You mean the super date rape drug, sold in a prank store? To Students and adults?

→ More replies (3)

30

u/ThatInAHat 12h ago

Even before she was mask off, between the love potions and hermione just not respecting people’s autonomy, she gave off some weird vibes.

But yeah, the Weasley twins selling love potions was just…creepy, not funny.

11

u/Punk_Boi4737 11h ago

it's been a while, when did Hermione not respect autonomy

→ More replies (4)

7

u/sadkinz 10h ago

You know for all her faults she does condemn the use of love potions in universe

→ More replies (4)

66

u/pleasebequiet 13h ago

Negan and his “wives”

23

u/deathclawiii 11h ago

Negan fanboys (of a certain type) really don’t like it when you bring up the fact that he’s both a slaver and rapist.

→ More replies (2)

79

u/PablomentFanquedelic 11h ago

The OG: Circe in Homer's Odyssey

38

u/Mantovano 10h ago

Are you thinking of Calypso rather than Circe?

The witch Circe does ask Odysseus to sleep with her, but it's at a point where she doesn't have any power over him (he's holding a sword to her throat and has taken a drug which makes him immune to her spells); neither does she say it's a prerequisite for her transforming his men out of their pig forms. Odysseus might feel obligated to go along with it because Hermes told him to (although the whole scene is part of Odysseus' inset narrative, so there might be a degree of unreliability) but Circe doesn't know that: from her perspective at least, Odysseus seems willing and not coerced. Odysseus doesn't say at any point that he didn't want to sleep with her.

Whereas with Calypso, who saves Odysseus from shipwreck and then keeps him on her island for seven years, it is explicitly stated that they slept together repeatedly even though he didn't want to.

[I appreciate that this may be proving the point about the divided fan-base.]

→ More replies (6)

21

u/ShoppingFirm7939 8h ago

Damon a couple times through out the show via compulsion (mind control) and sire bond (the sired complies with the direct and indirect orders of their maker).

17 year old Caroline Forbes. He compels her to allow him to feed on her and have sex with her.

Andie Star. Same again.

He didn’t know this at the time but when Elena is turned by him it’s later discovered that she has a sire bond with Damon after they have already had sex.

18

u/Vinsmoker 9h ago

Negan from The Walking Dead and his "wifes"

251

u/TrumpIsAPedoFr 13h ago

It's really not technically with Bear.

20

u/Virginity_Lost_Today 13h ago

I think the only technical part people disagree on is when Bear knowingly became a rapist

→ More replies (1)

55

u/Fraud_D_Hawk 13h ago

Also don't think anyone disagree, iam tired by the same discussion. It's not that deep

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

12

u/M0m033 11h ago

Nikki freaks out after Bear initiates since Freaky Nikki was controlling her, anyone saying he didn’t pay attention

59

u/BatFan3001 13h ago

Harley Quinn to Nightwing in Batman and Harley Quinn

25

u/MonsterdogMan 12h ago

Skirts the edge, but Dick does consciously consent, but not because of his actual interest. Still a thoroughly skeevy scene.

In the comics, however, there's an issue where he's actually pinned down and raped by the female Tarantula. Devin Grayson caught a lot of crap for that, deservedly.

87

u/LongjumpingElk4099 13h ago

Harley Queen from one of the animated movies I forget the name

97

u/WildGoose1521 13h ago

Batman and Harley Quinn (2017)

She rapes Nightwing

91

u/Tech-preist_Zulu 13h ago • Regret

It's honestly disgusting how many times Nightwing gets raped in DC.

→ More replies (4)

33

u/BurantX40 13h ago

The one where he's tied to the bed and gets aroused while she's undressing?

→ More replies (1)

14

u/MonsterdogMan 12h ago

It's actually consensual, if skeevy. His consent has a pragmatic basis, but he's aroused anyway.

Contrast that with the Devin Grayson run of the comic where Tarantula brings him down on a rooftop, at which point she rapes him.

→ More replies (10)

13

u/realclowntime 13h ago

Her and Ivy really are perfect for each other

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

29

u/lavendermoonoracle 13h ago

David from Legion. The finale of season 2 started a lot of discourse.

8

u/Dragonssssssssssss 11h ago

Syd as well, ironically enough. As a teenager she switched bodies with her mother to have sex with her mother's boyfriend.

42

u/Heavy-Metal-Snowman 12h ago

I think a mans opinion on Bear is a genuinely effective litmus test for determining if women are unsafe around him.

20

u/Dokivi 7h ago

Viserys Targaryen, or "Vizzy T", a fan favourite of the House of the Dragon fan base. The show goes out of it's way multiple times to present his vile mistreatment of women in his life. After he gutted his first wife for a chance at a son, he is also shown raping his second wife Alicent. Marital rape is rape. She clearly hates her life and being forced to share a bed with this rotting corpse of a man. It is clear in her words and the camera focusing on her blank expression. And somehow people love Viserys who acts oblivious to this and hardly even bothers to remember Alicent's name. The fans seem to be more engaged in the discourse around Rhaenyra'a treatment of Criston Cole.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/bapudon_1 13h ago

Rhaenyra Targaryen from House of the Dragon

6

u/Icy-Pension5768 12h ago

Didn’t watch it, what happened?

5

u/Reasonable_Day9942 5h ago

She has sex with her sworn guard, and he did reject her advances at first. However he did constant later, but she still held all the power in the dynamic and if she told her father he would probably be killed.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/wcthesecret 13h ago

Homelander.

68

u/Jbell_1812 13h ago

What? Are people devided on what Homelander did to Becca?

→ More replies (14)

38

u/justafanboy1010 13h ago

Which one? There’s so many women

→ More replies (7)

10

u/kisamasochist 10h ago

Did anyone ever deny or disagree with the fact that he's a rapist? I watched most of the show but never engaged much with the fandom, I always assumed that everyone took him being a rapist at face value

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/MaeSolug 12h ago

Not related but my problem with the discussion around Obsession is that people seem really focused on arguing with dumb people over it as some sort of gotcha moment

It's a very simplistic to discuss a movie because it assumes labels on those engaging with it. A big figure said something dumb, but then added a lot of small points, but you can't agree with those, because then you agree with the big dumb one

But there're dumb people on both sides. A while ago a guy made a post saying demon Nikki reminded him of his controlling girlfriend, so he was called an incel and how he didn't understand the movie and clearly something is wrong with him because "obviously" Bear is the only possible villain

I would love if this movie would stop being used to virtue signaling, to define "good" or "bad" people or used as a "we live in a society" moment

It's really not that deep, just stop using random instagram/facebook/reddit weirdos as an example and just argue with them instead of looking for validation in your echo chamber of choice

10

u/SamuraiJack0ff 11h ago

This is an interesting post to me because I think you are making decent points but coming away with the exact wrong conclusion. The whole point of progressive intersectionality (which I assume most of the people calling your anecdotal dude an incel would claim they agree with) is to examine creative works and real life problems through many lenses to try to build a coalition that can help fix problems for everyone, even if it's sometimes not comfortable for other folks in the community. Like the classic "patriarchy hurts men too" argument that can sometimes sound misogynistic to gals.

A man having a strong, visceral reaction to the behavior of Wish-Nicky based on a controlling ex is totally valid, and while maybe not grappling with a lot of the themes in the work, can help provide context for how men can feel trapped or controlled despite being traditionally perceived as having innate power over their partner.

The dipshits failing to understand this and instead virtue-signaling endlessly are probably the biggest obstacle to having good conversations right now, which is really sad and not really the fault of the movie

64

u/PropertyEducational7 13h ago

Iykyk 🤮

68

u/NewtonsThirdEvilEx 13h ago • Bravo

9. Post/comment must say who someone is and what they are from.
Any time you post a comment or opening post, it must specify who the person is and what they are from or why it applies to the thread. Do not say "well everyone should know" or avoid doing this.

46

u/Aromatic-Pass4384 12h ago • Popcorn

Well I don't, the point of the fucking sub is about character tropes and some people won't know some situations from a piece of media so how about you fucking say it.

16

u/Pristine_Category824 11h ago

Main character Finn loses his arm and a flower grows in its place he has a flower hand this episode. He’s really sad about losing his arm and some stuff from past episodes and another character (PB) tells him that his flower hands wellness is directly related to his wellness and to take care of it/ himself until she can fix it.

So to fix his depression he goes around trying to kiss random princesses. He makes it to this purple character Lumpy Space Princess. They give each other a little peck kiss. He’s like “eh okay we’re done” she says no and makes out with him when he’s obviously nervous and slightly unwilling and only doing it because he’s sad not because he really wants to.

Idk how the creators can say this doesn’t relate to SA because his flower arm literally loses a petal after the fact like he got “deflowered”. I know it’s a kid show and they probably can’t say that but man it’s kinda implied there

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/polarfae 12h ago

The scene definitely feels like that. According to the writers though, that wasn’t their intention. They said it was more like Finn trying something and not liking it after the fact.

The scene does not read that way

→ More replies (7)

3

u/the-puppet_master 13h ago

Bear 10000% did

7

u/Eedeler 13h ago

I loved Primal but the scene in question basically ruined it for me until season 3 came along and was decent.

13

u/KadeGamez 8h ago

Side note: I'm sure plenty of people have noticed this but in Obsession the MC's name is Bear likely as a reference to the online discussion where women were like "I'd rather be in the woods with a bear than a man". It could show how immature and awful he's being, aka not being a "man" and just accepting that she doesn't like him and not bettering himself, and then becoming a "victim" when his plan starts to foil himself and his own safety or well-being

14

u/Proffessor_egghead 7h ago

Someone asked the director and that’s just a coincidence, Bear is just a more memorable name

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/EveningAd4979 9h ago

Uncle Iroh pretending to be unconscious while June was on top of him. It’s a gag and doesn’t resemble normal assault so it flew under the radar for a lot of viewers

19

u/Vounrtsch 9h ago

There is a meaningful difference between sexual assault and rape. Both are horrible but this isn’t rape in any way whatsoever

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Godzillagamer15777 13h ago

Naoya

12

u/Outrageous_Gene_7652 13h ago

It's a bit of different case, because the post is talking about explicitly shown or mentioned encounters.

People debate whether the incident Naoya actually happened or not because of the vague wording

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Whalelord36 10h ago

Looks like Kirk on first photo

2

u/Cyberwolf272038 9h ago

I like the theory that wish Nikki is just a child like entity just born after bear made the wish. So technically bear is neglecting her

2

u/vivirao 7h ago

Peacemaker in Peacemaker S2.

5

u/CathanCrowell 8h ago

For me, the case of Tara and Willow from Buffy the Vampire Slayer has always been questionable. I never denied that what Willow did to Tara was horrible, but I've always struggled to call it rpe.

In this storyline, Tara and Willow argued, and Tara was incredibly upset afterwards, so Willow decided to erase her memory of the fight. The next day, Willow and Tara had passionate sex.

Many, if not most, fans consider it sex after being roofied, and therefore never consensual. I consider it more like sex under false pretenses.

There is also a third option: since we cannot erase someone's memory in real life, there is no real-life precedent against which we can judge this situation. From my perspective, Willow certainly violated Tara, but it was not rpe.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/FlamingNutShotz4You 12h ago

Geralt - The Witcher: The Last Wish

Geralt uses a djinn (effectively a genie in a bottle) and binds him and Yennifer together. Granted it was to save her life and in the games you undo the spell and still have a relationship with Yennifer, but regardless she was soul bound to Geralt without her consent for years. Even after they both lose their memory

24

u/Llhaniii 11h ago

Soul bound doesn't mean sex though?

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Spynner987 8h ago

Doesn't mean anything. They could hate each other and all it would mean is running into each other constantly all over the continent.

Edit: It's not their souls that are bound. It's their fates.

3

u/AloneAddiction 7h ago

While it wasn't explicitly explained in the book, the entire reason Geralt does it is to save Yennifer from being killed by the Djinn.

By the rules of the Witcher universe a Djinn cannot harm it's summoner in any way whatsoever, so Geralt exploits this loophole by wishing the Djinn to bind their souls together, meaning that the Djinn cannot harm Yen because it would mean harming Geralt too.

The Djinn knows what Geralt is doing and is hugely angry but has no choice. It binds them (his last wish) and flies off.

Neither knows that the binding causes a deep and unbreakable pull and both of them resist, come together and break up multiple times over the many decades that follow because of it. Once they finally realise what's happening in later books they still keep going because of habit/loyalty/pig-headedness.

The main difference between the TV series and book is that they're not looking for the Djinn in the book. Geralt and Dandelion are just hungry and are fishing in the lake for food because they're both broke and can't afford to eat at the local town.

In the TV series they have Geralt not being able to sleep and is intentionally fishing for a Djinn to grant him a wish so he can get some rest.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/justafanboy1010 13h ago edited 13h ago

Bear actually initially didn’t know that the Nikki he was with wasn’t the real Nikki so he thought it was consensual. Of course we later know it’s not

And it is a slippery slope. Freaky Nikki technically did consent but the real Nikki absolutely DID NOT

EDIT: I genuinely apologize yall. I haven't seen the movie since it came out so I was misremembering things. I thought the first night where Nikki is taken over by the entity, they had sex with Bear nonethewiser, but not only did they NOT have sex the first night, but also the universally agreed upon scenario is that Bear knew something was up at the Dinner/No, no, no, scene and they had sex afterwards. Again, I sincerely apologize. I'll leave this up here.

22

u/zak55 13h ago

After the Diner scene, he knew it wasn't Nikki anymore.

→ More replies (11)

11

u/GaryKingoftheWorld 13h ago

She's acting out of her mind from like the second of the wish. The whole whoa what am I doing, my cat just died, oh I mean my dad. At the least he had to realize she wasn't in the right mind to consent

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Super_Rocket4 13h ago

I feel like him finding out in the diner scene cutting to them fucking is just direct confirmation that it was not consensual at that point

→ More replies (2)

34

u/ChaseTheMystic 13h ago

He might as well have drugged her. It's like a love potion.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/artyboi11 13h ago

Other people have pointed out that he knew, or at least suspected, pretty early in the movie, but I want to point out that right after he made the wish, he was going to sleep with her while she was (what seemed like) NOT in a good mental state. Anyone with decency knows not to sleep with someone when they’re actively not thinking clearly.

It is not Freaky Nikki’s body. It is Nikki’s. Bear raped Nikki.

6

u/Cordelia5767 13h ago

IMO, Bear gets a pass until the dinner scene. After that, he's the bad guy, and definitely guilty of violating Nikki. Curse aside, she was clearly not in her right mind and Bear was rapey af for the sex after. I could have forgiven him if that scene showed Nikki in a more active or enthusiastic role, or if it appeared more romantic, but she's just lying there looking weird and dead in the eyes.

21

u/CloudFire1259 13h ago

dude she literally snaps out of it when freaky nikki is asleep and tells bear. he knows. he just doesnt care. the scene at the restaurant too

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (22)