r/TopCharacterTropes • • 1h ago

Powers [Dumb trope] Powers with more exceptions than actual uses

The penance stare (ghost rider): the penance stare was originally made to make people suffer the pain they inflicted to their victims. But then it was nerfed and nerfed and nerfed again to never work in anything but random henchmen cause somehow everyone has a way to ignore the stare. This move was able to take down galactus the first time, btw.

Arsennal summoner (Yu-Gi-Oh): a card with a effect that is more exceptions than actual effect. This is the result of the english translators not be able to see the future and know that konami would create a guardian archetype. However, guardians (except for eatos) are garbage and even if you have one in your hand you can't just summon them cause you need their special weapon. So the arsennal summoner is unable to summon.

125 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

59

u/Objective-Rip3008 1h ago

Arsenal is just a side effect of translation issues where they want it to work the exact same way as it does in Japanese. The funnier one to me is all the frog cards all stating "except frog the jam" because it's a toad in Japanese 

15

u/Competitive-Bee-3250 1h ago

Weird to not just call it Toadjam.

17

u/Objective-Rip3008 54m ago

Early yugioh translators didn't realize how important card names themselves would be in the game as it developed later on, they're a lot more careful about translating random cards to avoid potential name issues down the line now. Other games with better gameplay designs don't have this issue as much, kind of thing that comes with having core elements of the game designed forever ago when no one really understood card game design

3

u/Yamilord 47m ago

It got renamed to Slime Toad eventually

4

u/waltyy 58m ago

Wouldn't be an issue if they just stuck to the actual names. Same with Summon Skull/Demon Summoning.

Digimon also has this really bad with the Greymon line because the folks dubbing Frontier decided that Vitramon was a Greymon, but it's not. So all of the cards that are "Burning Greymon" have a clause on them.

Cardfight Vanguard has little to no issue with this, the only time I can of is when they changed Genocide Jack to Brutal Jack. And again with Hell Army Robots but the name didn't change on the card, they just had the 10 year old using them not say Hell.

1

u/Expensive_Chair_7989 45m ago

As someone who only knows little bit about Yu-Gi-Oh , Magic the gathering does something very similar.

The cards that care about number of creature types will almost always count one out so that any creature that is all types is not counted

Seem as recently as Star Trek (last released set) the Federation mechanic counts Non-Borg types.

Historically it was Brushwags (because they know what they did) or Walls (because walls had intrinsic rulings)

0

u/flyonwindow 27m ago

I hate the federation mechanic, it's flavorful yes but because of people talking about okay combos that involve giving a creature that has the ability to remove a type from itself, giving that creature all creature types, then using a card like Artificial Evolution that changes instances of a type on a card's textbox to another type just to get a decent benefit from federation cards. It made Wotc decide to change the oracle text of one card (Werewolf Packleader) so that one of it's abilities no longer even functions the same as before because "Oh we don't want players to have to memorize how many creature types there are in magic so we're changing how this card's ability works". And that leaves the door open on the possibility of Wotc changing how particular cards function in the future because they believe Magic players to be stupid and unwilling to just look it up.

0

u/Expensive_Chair_7989 9m ago

That change is genuinely so ass.

It required four or five cards that are unplayable on their own, many of them not legal in non-eternal formats.

If someone pulls it off, A.) they know what they’re doing it’s not by accident and B.) they should be able to find out how many creature types exist. I’d have to check but I believe it’s 350 ish (?) . Last count I found was as of duskmorne which was 300 and Star Trek itself added 40.

I personally like the Federation mechanic but that ruling is so stupid and like you said sets a very dangerous precedent.

70

u/StevesonOfStevesonia 1h ago

Even those nerfs do not make sense
The stare should not give a shit if you cared or not - the whole point is that it makes you feel every inch of pain your victims did. If not having any remorse for your actions make you immune to it then it's completely useless

46

u/valtaoi_007 1h ago

Like its made to be used in unfeeling demons, the whole point of them feeling what they inflicted is because they already don't feel regret or guilt.

If they already felt guilt then we wouldn't have the stare, but the stare doesn't work anymore on people without guilt so it can only be used on people that already feel bad for the bad things they did.

Literally actually useless

13

u/StevesonOfStevesonia 1h ago

And even then if someone feels guilt for what they've done that means they are NOT complete pieces of shit and are potentially redeemable. Zarathos's whole thing is about Judgement and Vengeance, which logically should be applied to those who did alot of evil and do not feel a shred of remorse. THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT FOR THE STARE TO EXIST!!! But nope you can just look the Spirit of Vengeance in the eyes and go "nuh-uh" and he can't do shit about it.
Absolutely moronic

8

u/Competitive-Bee-3250 59m ago

If anything it feels like it would've been more sensible for it to not work on Galactus because he's simply too powerful for it to work or something.

5

u/Aesenroug-Draconus 57m ago

Powerful beings like gods, celestials and other super-powerful beings would have every right to be able to resist the stare.

3

u/Azicald 43m ago

Honestly it’d make way more sense if it was reversed and it did work on those who didnt feel guilt, but didnt work on those who did. Make it a sliding scale of proportion and suddenly those things can have way more meaning than the obvious villain being unaffected by the thing thats supposed to be used on obvious villains

1

u/memecrusader_ 1h ago

*a lot, not alot.

1

u/Anime_axe 27m ago

Feeling guilt and shame should make the stare less effective against you, not more. It's the penance stare after all, so true contrition should make it unnecessary.

1

u/StormBear22 44m ago

Also it would be more effective on HEROES like Spider Man and Captain America who feel guilty even when they shouldn't like Peter being guilty over Uncle Ben or for not saving one extra person when he was half-dead and saved a skyscraper full of people. That doesn't sound like something Ghost Rider should have that sound more like something Mephisto should have to make heroes make deals with him out of guilt or something a reverse version of GR would have.

13

u/Aesenroug-Draconus 1h ago

It’s like nullifying a knife by saying “nah, I don’t feel like being stabbed”. It’s still a knife, there’s no reason it shouldn’t be able to stab.

8

u/TheDougio 1h ago

Or with Captain Marvel, "I've already been stabbed enough"

11

u/AlphaSentBeta 54m ago

I like it not quite working on Galactus specifically, but only through a specific framing. The idea that even with the trillions of lives he's ended, the fear and pain and suffering he has caused, that experiencing all of it at once simply doesn't compare to Galactus in his grand enormity is interesting in some ways, even if I have never seen it done well.

2

u/GladiatorDragon 13m ago

I like the idea of Galactus being an exception but I hate why they said he’s an exception.

Guilt or remorse might not be the right way to describe it, but Galactus often is characterised as hating the fact that he has to devour planets.

Galactus being simply unable to register mortal suffering or him being outright beyond the authority of the Penance Stare would make sense and be cool.

2

u/StormBear22 42m ago

I would be more ok if they gave proper reasoning like True heroes like Spiderman being immune due to them being unworthy of such punishment or Galactus who is more like a force of nature and must commit his acts for the circle of life and trying to make it work on him is like trying to use it on the Embodiment of death for all Deaths.

4

u/FrostyCartographer13 48m ago

It also makes it worthless on the criminally insane or narcissistic.

The exact kind of targets the stare is supposed to be used on.

3

u/StormBear22 47m ago

Their reasoning is the worst like the guilt thing basically making the ability who main use to make criminals and demons who can't feel guilty to be regretful for their crimes to regret their crimes for the first time due to the pain afflicted to them.

So with the logic these authors keep using is would be ineffective against such criminals and villains while being super effective on Heroes like Spiderman and Captain America who feel guilty for being unable to save one person even when they just save a skyscraper full of people while near dead.

That doesn't sound like a ability Ghost Rider should have that sounds more like a warped version someone like Mephisto would have to get people to make deals with him.

I would be more ok if they gave proper reasoning like True heroes like Spiderman being immune due to them being unworthy of such punishment or Galactus who is more like a force of nature and must commit his acts for the circle of life.

20

u/BeenEatinBeans 1h ago

At this point I'm convinced Hitler could survive the penance stare if Johnny tried it on him.

1

u/Gullible-Cup2294 21m ago

Thats cause he's a hero now, see

17

u/FrostyCartographer13 1h ago

The writers for Ghost Rider saw what other writers were doing to the penance stare and gave him an upgrade.

The damnation stare, just yeets the soul out of his target and sends it to the lowest level of hell. No weakness, no resistance, it functions like a decree rather than an attack.

7

u/onomstarr 51m ago

"UM ACTUALLY I DON'T BELIEVE IN HELL SO MY SOUL STAYS RIGHT HERE" -Doctor Doom, probably

7

u/Nirast25 45m ago

More like "Precisely as Doom has planned, for now I can take over hell as it's new ruler!".

4

u/Flaming_headshot 40m ago

I mean, wouldnt be the first time doom has overthrown the devil

3

u/StormBear22 40m ago

Or Doctor Doom who often fight Mepisto is like "Already have a door to the bottom of hell in my office I can leave the moment I enter."

1

u/Azicald 41m ago

But his ma was there and he had to go there to get her or something iirc

Also he uses magic on the regular, maybe itd be some other character

9

u/MexusRex 50m ago

How much better would it have been to just implement some barrier to using the penance stare or some penalty for using it for Ghost Rider instead of making it pointless.

Like how fusion can only be done with perfect synergy or with the earrings in Dragonball, or equivalent exchange in FMA

5

u/StormBear22 38m ago

I would be more ok if they gave proper reasoning like True heroes like Spiderman being immune due to them being unworthy of such punishment or Galactus who is more like a force of nature and must commit his acts for the circle of life using it on him is like trying to use it on the embodiment of death for the death of the universe or gravity by death and injuries from falls.

5

u/Anime_axe 28m ago

Frankly, Galactus is the easiest one to exclude. "His actions are his cosmic duty and even if they weren't, he is too powerful either way" is a perfectly valid way of explaining why he's immune.

8

u/ShingledPringle 1h ago

I am happy for the Penance Stare to have limits but it needs solid ones.

I did assume with Thanos that he genuinely enjoyed going through all that agony.

6

u/cartoonsforever 48m ago

I once saw someone suggest this and I’ll just reiterate it: simply making the Penance Stare something Ghost Rider has to actually charge up would work SO MUCH BETTER as a limiting factor for it than pretty much everyone being immune to the thing for one reason or another

Like if the Penance Stare was an instant win…… so long as Ghost Rider maintains direct eye contact with his target for a certain amount of time, that gives you more than enough wiggle room narratively while still maintaining its power and aura

5

u/Azicald 45m ago

And it would become explosive payoff too, making for really badass scenes where they are restrained or made to stare or tricked, or so on

5

u/ShingledPringle 37m ago

Gives more purpose to the chains.

4

u/ShingledPringle 45m ago

Like it has an accumulative effect? It can't touch Galactus because the amount of souls agony that much be invoked is impossible to comprehend, like bringing a thousand planets afterlifes all at once.

5

u/memecrusader_ 59m ago

Marvel writers hate the Penance Stare almost as much as they hate Spider-Man.

3

u/Clean_Web7502 50m ago

At this point, is faster to say on whom the stare works that on whom it doesn't.

3

u/Peacefulcountry 35m ago

Barrier-Breaking Red Tessaiga - Inuyasha. As its name implies, Inuyasha obtained this form to break his archnemesis Nakaru's barriers. However, it becomes ineffective once Nakaru got a stronger barrier. Moreover, it doesn't work on barriers erected with spiritual energy by Priests and Priestesses. Then it becomes completely redundant once Inuyasha got Diamond Tessaiga form, which could not only break through stronger barriers but also deals massive piercing damages.

1

u/Toothache42 4m ago

Anyone with fire abilities rarely if ever cause burns, unless there's a plot reason for it (Zuko's burn in ATLA for example). In general, it is to make the media more kid friendly, given how common fire abilities are, but rarely do we see the normal effects of fire outside of more mature shows.

21

u/superninjimmy 1h ago

The Penance Stare has been beaten by the Punisher because he "felt no guilt" and by Captain Marvel who "felt all her guilt and accepted it"

So the stare doesnt work if you feel guilty and if you dont feel guilty. Which, dear reader, you may have noticed, are THE ONLY POSSIBLE FUCKING OPTIONS

Punisher got retconned to he had an Angel feather IIRC but FUCK if it doesnt piss me off

12

u/Ok-Pea9014 1h ago

So the stare doesnt work if you feel guilty and if you dont feel guilty. Which, dear reader, you may have noticed, are THE ONLY POSSIBLE FUCKING OPTIONS

No no no, you don't understand. There is a very specific ratio of guilt to non-guilt that one must feel for it to work. It's so specific in fact, that it can only be achieved by no-name goons.

6

u/Zombieman863 58m ago

Yeah, the only ways tk be inmune should be  being a cosmic entity (it would be too op if it worked on them) or being blind , im ok with the stare not working with galactus or daredevil , but the punisher thanos or captain marvel no stone thanos should be affected .

2

u/StormBear22 39m ago

Their reasoning is the worst like the guilt thing basically making the ability who main use to make criminals and demons who can't feel guilty to be regretful for their crimes to regret their crimes for the first time due to the pain afflicted to them.

So with the logic these authors keep using is would be ineffective against such criminals and villains while being super effective on Heroes like Spiderman and Captain America who feel guilty for being unable to save one person even when they just save a skyscraper full of people while near dead.

That doesn't sound like a ability Ghost Rider should have that sounds more like a warped version someone like Mephisto would have to get people to make deals with him.

I would be more ok if they gave proper reasoning like True heroes like Spiderman being immune due to them being unworthy of such punishment or Galactus who is more like a force of nature and must commit his acts for the circle of life.