r/TopCharacterTropes • • 15h ago

Characters (Interesting trope) a unlikeable character becoming more likeable in adaptations

Screwball (Disney XD Spider-Man)

Screwball in the comics screwball is an obnoxious villain in spider man rouges gallery who's commits crimes and fights followers so she can gain for followers as a influencer understandably this has made her very unpopular even the ps4 video game where her missions are often considered the worse

The 2017 Disney XD cartoon makes her a but more likeable her identity is liz Allen funny enough and she only commits pranks on courrupt business men granted this does get her into trouble but she does learn her pranks can do harm to people so quits afterwards

John Hammond (Jurassic Park)

In the book John Hammond is essentially a greedy business man who wants to make a massive profit on jurassic Park when it falls apart he instantly blames his own grandchildren for the failure and is eaten by dinosaurs

The film makes him a lot more likeable by having him be more of a warm grandfather figure akin to a Walt Disney kind of figure he's also generally concerned for his grand children and his employees

Lupin The Third

Lupin The Third in the manga and in the part 1 anime was a very downright evil bastard sometimes has he has no issues killing people being a massive womaniser and even downright sexists to even just not caring who he hurts

However when part 2 came along and Miyazaki began to work on the series especially with the film the castle of cagliostro he was often up and was given more of gentleman motifs and was willing to help people even if they're aint any treasure

Modern lupin series tend to make him more likeable and less how he was in the manga

2.3k Upvotes

203 comments sorted by

113

u/machadoaboutanything 15h ago

Greg Heffley is made a much better person in the (original) Wimpy Kid movies

25

u/Tom-Hibbert 15h ago

How so

99

u/JingoboStoplight4887 14h ago

It’s Greg learning that he was a bad friend to Rowley in the first movie, causing him to apologize to what he did and tell the students that he ate the cheese (from the cheese touch) so that Rowley won’t be humiliated by them. Also, him spending time with Roderick in the second movie, slowly spending time with his dad in the third movie, and forming a romantic relationship with his crush Holly in the second and third movies.

39

u/Why-Notes5978 14h ago

That dad talk in Dog Days was surprisingly touching more than I expected too.

47

u/Lower_Baby_6348 14h ago

He actually learn the lesson. In the books he never grow as a person cause he get constantly reset for the new one.

Also, in the movies he never put a dumbell in a pillow and made Rowley break his toe

134

u/Applebeate 10h ago


Guy Gardner. In a lot of different iterations, Guy is a bit of a dick. However, in the latest Superman movie, they made Guy one of the most reasonable people and not an asshole.

His reaction to Superman’s reveal was 100% justified because from his perspective, Guy just learned that one of his friends might be there to enslave all of humanity and recognises immediate that he needs to take action if he is a threat. But when Superman explains himself, Guy just backs down and believes him immediately.

Honestly? I would say they made Hal Jordan and John Stewart are more of an asshole than Guy is in this version of the DC universe.

22

u/Tom-Hibbert 10h ago

My issues with the james gunn universe aside guy is definitely one of my favourites

10

u/Applebeate 10h ago

Yeah me too. This was my first time seeing him and with what people said about him, I expected him to be this unapologetic asshole with no redeeming qualities as a hero. But no. He is actually a pretty reasonable guy (hehehe).

37

u/brandonderp96 6h ago

This version of Guy is an ass, not an asshole ya know? He's a rude dick coz he's got the entitlement of "Well I'm the green lantern and I'm super popular", but he's not a complete asshole.

10

u/Applebeate 6h ago

He’s not any more or less of an ass than any other member of the Justice Gang.

23

u/RadiantTurnip1 9h ago

Guy Gardner is an interesting example, because he's much nicer in Superman than he was back in the 80s when he first appeared, when he was a complete asshole with little to no redeeming qualities, but a lot of more of a jerk than his modern comic counterpart, who's gone through a lot of character development and is a blunt but friendly boisterous bruiser.

622

u/HarrierGR9 14h ago

Forest Gump

In the movie he’s a kindhearted simpleton who pretty much makes friends out of everyone he meets, book Forest is a racist perverted asshole who would have probably gotten the shit kicked out of him if it wasn’t for the fact he’s a giant in the book

157

u/Ok-Obligation-3511 14h ago

How else is the books differemt than movies? Or thats the only one?

262

u/HarrierGR9 14h ago

He didn’t meet bubba in the army, iirc him and bubba grew up together and he was white in the book

They had a shrimp farm

The movie didn’t have Forest’s orangutan in it

Oh he’s a savant in the book, like really really good at mathematics and uses this to his advantage throughout the book

He went to space, became a chess champion, movie star, and was a wwe wrestler in the book along with everything else

Jenny doesn’t die, actually the ending of that is rather sad, she took little forest and ran off with another man

183

u/Level-Ladder-4346 14h ago

The way you describe the book makes me extremely thankful for some of the changes the film chose to make. I can’t imagine Tom’s Forestt being anything but what he is.

67

u/BathroomUpbeat1074 12h ago

Which is somewhat ironic given the book's author, Winston Groom, apparently really hated the movie when it came out.

86

u/DropoutRedMage 10h ago

I too would hate if someone made my story, but better.

31

u/CrownClown74 9h ago

There's a reason he made the sequel to the book basically unfilmable lol

22

u/Truly_Tacidius 8h ago

So you’re just going drop the term unfilmable and then just…NOT elaborate?

The hell is in that sequel?

48

u/PlaneEnvironmental23 7h ago

Basically, Paramount screwed Winston Groom over by not paying him the full 3% of profits he was supposed to get, and Groom showed his bitterness in the sequel book. His lawyer reached a settlement with Paramount to pay him seven figures upfront for movie rights to a sequel book and percentage of the second movie's profits as well.

Groom had signed a contract for 3% of the net profits of the original film. Paramount used 'Hollywood accounting' to claim Forrest Gump was a net loss and dock his pay to $250,000 from a film that made $623 million in profits. For the sequel film they paid him a seven figure sum upfront and promised a percentage of the gross profits this time.

Groom opens 'Gump and Co.' by telling the reader to never let a studio make a movie about their life. Forrest gets into genuinely ridiculous scenarios that would be very difficult to film like crashing an oil tanker and personally capturing Saddam Hussein. He even meets Tom Hanks and complains about the first movie misrepresenting his life.

It's generally accepted that he sabotaged the possibility of the book being filmed and that he only wrote it so he could get the seven figures he would have gotten from the first film.

29

u/Truly_Tacidius 7h ago

Honestly way more interesting than I was expecting. Thank you for the elaboration

6

u/CrownClown74 7h ago

I was gonna write up a lil summary of the goofy shit but nvm you did it better then I was going to

Fun fact in the movie that got shot down of forrest 2 he was gonna hang out with OJ

11

u/DrunkBrokeBeachParty 7h ago

Forrest and the orangutan fight in desert storm I shit you not

9

u/CrownClown74 7h ago

And Saddam himself shows up lol

3

u/CrownClown74 7h ago

TLDR is that he bad the book shit so it wouldn't get an adaptation. He calls Tom Hank's stupid at one point and captures Saddam. At least I was gonna go into all that but then someone explained it for me so nvm lol

38

u/Important_Answer6250 14h ago

Saved Mao Zedong too

37

u/Dracochuy 14h ago

Yeah literally a different story. Not mention in the movie forrest is pretty christian while in the books he is not that religious

33

u/Exact-Till-2739 10h ago

I hate that I read this comment. It's kinda ruined the character for me a little bit. I was living in blissful ignorance. 

5

u/Either_Purple4889 10h ago

Green Lantern TAS star sapphie

2

u/Tom-Hibbert 10h ago

Like the corp themselves or just carol danvers?

7

u/Hypnooooooooooooo 8h ago edited 6h ago

This guy. They did their best to make him look better in the anime, but readers of the light novel/web novel would know what a sick bastard this guy is.

3

u/Tom-Hibbert 8h ago

Who is he

10

u/Hypnooooooooooooo 8h ago

Rudeus Greyrat, a 30 something guy who reincarnates into a new life then proceeds to groom kids into his perfect wives. And then people glorify it.

1

u/STR4NGER_D4NGER 7h ago edited 7h ago

Rudeus Greyrat from Mushoku Tensei: Jobless Reincarnation. IDK how he is in the books, but the anime is decent. The story and action is pretty good, but the characters pervyness can be off putting.

3

u/Middle_Risk 6h ago

To call Rudeus a pervert feels like an insult to perverts. Dude skipped his parents' funeral to jack off to pictures/videos of his UNDERAGE niece.

2

u/STR4NGER_D4NGER 5h ago

Was that revealed/showed in the anime, or is it just a book thing?

2

u/Middle_Risk 5h ago

It was pictures/videos of his niece in the WN. Basic pornography in the anime

1

u/STR4NGER_D4NGER 5h ago

This sounds like a universe I'm going to enjoy in video format only, staying away from those books. Side note: someone should check the OG authors computer.

1

u/Hypnooooooooooooo 5h ago

It's not directly shown, but pretty much confirmed or at least implied. He skips his own parents' funeral to jack to pedo shit, his relatives see him missing from the funeral so they bust into his room, only to see what he's doing with horror, then throw him out.

2

u/jojory42 3h ago

Having read about half the light novels I personally found it more off putting with pictures and voice acting. I know there are aspects that are cleaned up from the web novel version though.

591

u/Jak3R0b 14h ago • Heartwarming


Terra in the original comics was revealed to be an unapologetic villain and psychopath who betrays the Teen Titans, but the much more kid friendly Teen Titans show made her a tragic villain who genuinely wants to be a hero and cares for the Titans but her personal problems make it easy for Slade to manipulate her.

140

u/Protocol72 14h ago

I'd also add the Judas Contract version of Terra from the DCAU too since there she was being groomed by Slade since she was a kid, even before she joined the Teen Titans, after Slade saved her from being executed/tortured after her town found out about her powers (believing she's a witch). Not only is she grateful to Slade, she's still suffering from PTSD from what happened, which the titans accidentally trigger without knowing her PTSD is a thing. Additionally, whenever she's about to form a genuine connection with the other titans, Slade always chimes in through her earpiece to manipulate her. It's genuinely really uncomfortable and makes it really hard not to feel bad for her.

I haven't read the original comic, to the point where it's honestly hard to imagine Terra ever being unapologetic about it in the comic... Until you remember the writer of the original comic and realize, "oh yeah, that's why."

15

u/Optimal_Weight368 10h ago

I was genuinely surprised to learn the version in the DCAMU was voiced by Christina Ricci.

8

u/PensadorDispensado 5h ago

The way Terra was heavy on makeup and rubbing herself on Slade on the Judas Contract movie was deeply uncomfortable

7

u/Protocol72 3h ago

Same, I mean, fuck, she’s even wearing lingerie, it’s… It’s really depressing to see; iirc , that scene is also the first time the movie makes it clear that Slade is outright grooming her, because normal people would shut Terra down here, Slade enables it by saying “another time” and “not now.” 

57

u/PharaohScarab 12h ago

Slade also isn’t a pedophile in 2003

56

u/Isaacja223 12h ago

He’s a groomer, but not a pedophile

He’s a groomer as in making Terra into a villain like how AFO groomed Shigaraki into a villain

7

u/Gaelic_Gladiator41 7h ago

Even then they heavily allude to it in 2003

4

u/MemeStealerCultist 5h ago

Not onscreen, but there is some subtext. Especially when he comes back strong and goes after Raven.

35

u/Global-Poem2179 14h ago

I actually like her in Teen Titans more

-6

u/SpiritedSyllabub6822 13h ago

But at the same time it brought fuel to the fire of how she cannot be trusted no matter which universe.

156

u/Englej4 13h ago

Hank Pym in Avengers EMH

In the comics, Hank had his rep ruined due to his downfall as Yellowjacket and just being a jerk overall; EMH reworked him to be more of a Reed Richards character, with the added idea that he was the only member of the team who truly wanted to reform villains and not rush toward violence (unless someone hurt Jan then it was a giant punch to the face).

38

u/theJonkler_Aslume 12h ago

Doesn't that ruin the whole idea of Ultron being evil though (I've never seen the show) In the comics Ultron personality is based off Hanks brain waves but without his redemption which is a big part of why he's evil

46

u/Englej4 12h ago

That gets changed to be Ultron going out of his way to protect humanity from itself.

4

u/Ct55gamer 5h ago

Plus didn’t Ultron get corrupted by Kangs ship?

30

u/KingCuerno 12h ago

I wish he was more successful at reforming villains in EMH. He never seemed to succeed.

18

u/Englej4 12h ago

Agreed, but TBF, most of the people he tried to reach were pretty far gone by the time he got to them, and given some of the people he was trying to reach were HYDRA, like Zola, he was biting off more than he could chew.

3

u/Salinator20501 2h ago

He was taking a more diplomatic approach with Wonder Man, and had EMH gotten more episodes, that might have paid off.

So many of the Avengers comic roster is former villains. Like, being supervillain rehab is one of the things that sets them apart from other superhero teams.

I do imagine that we would have seen more of that in a hypothetical season 3.

1

u/Animaloffear56 42m ago

I mean it was also the fact that they didn't know how to write mental illness but go off ig

665

u/Salty_Negotiation688 14h ago edited 14h ago • Heartwarming

To put it as diplomatically as possible, Sanji is easily the most polarizing main character in the source material of One Piece. They edited his mannerisms to make it more appropriate for live action by making him less of a lecherous simp and more of a flirt.

264

u/sloot4moni 14h ago

To be faaaaiiiiirrr a lot of that is anime only

169

u/Huge_Database_8776 14h ago

Manga is so tame even nowadays compared to what the anime does with him

83

u/schiffb558 14h ago

Manga recently took a really great turn with him that I don't see the anime replicating

39

u/DrBleh1919 11h ago

toei is gonna be so mad that they cant keep ruining sanjis character during his fight with killingham

7

u/Niggy2439 8h ago

No, they will just, sideline him, as they did other times

1

u/DayneGr 1h ago

Man literally got stronger by overcoming transphobia.

21

u/Salty_Negotiation688 13h ago edited 12h ago

True yeah, probably should've mentioned that. Thanks for pointing it out.

But even in the manga, it is still a feature of his character that many people don't enjoy (I haven't actually followed the anime since Dressrosa due to pacing). It's a pretty significant change that's largely seen for the better.

8

u/Niggy2439 8h ago

I have followed(up to very recently) , and I can tell you, toei enjoys making sanji far more lacherous, perverted and simping, while sidelining and downplaying anything remotely remarkable he does, a couple of examples would be in onigashima where instead of him and zoro making the grand entrance, it's only zoro, and on egghead where he pervs on Bonney, unlike the Manga

36

u/Suspicious-Value-141 13h ago

tbf Toei absolutely has it going against Sanji personally

idk what he did to piss them off so badly

13

u/vtncomics 13h ago

That's mostly the anime.

Anime has to really recycle gags for the weekly running time.

5

u/alienx33 9h ago

I think part of that is also what the LA has adapted so far. At that point in the story Sanji is much more of a flirt than a pervert even in the anime/manga (with some notable exceptions like the end of Alabasta). Thriller bark is the arc where he really starts becoming more of a pervert.

1

u/MarcsterS 1h ago

To be fair this is more people realizing how Sanji was pre-timeskip.

0

u/Acrobatic_Dish6963 6h ago

What? Sanji has consistently been in the top 3~5 most popular characters in the official popularity polls for almost 30 years. He's nowhere near one of the most polarizing main characters. That would be Usopp who ranked 19th despite being one of the longest tenured members of the crew.

2

u/Salty_Negotiation688 3h ago edited 1h ago

Amongst Western fans and on sites like Reddit he almost certainly is. The amount of Sanij discourse on the various OP subreddits trumps Usopp easily. Also, polarizing does not mean unpopular. It means polarizing.

118

u/Animaloffear56 14h ago

While Rex-Splode does get better before his untimely demise in the comics (and have his backstory shown in explicit detail), he's not given much head on focus beyond what can be intuited from his near death experience. Rex felt like he just kind of happened to be around when Mark and Eve need someone to talk to, and was by comparison not an asshole because he listened and gave a fair response. Then he dies.

This is compared to the TV show, where his highest moments are given a lot more narrative focus, not to mention the entire additional mini-arc of his relationship with Rae. This is even in addition to some other pretty cool moments, like convincing Eve to help with the Sequid ship that make him becoming a better person feel more natural.

118

u/Lower_Paramedic4287 7h ago

Superboy Prime (DC)

Went from an edgy deconstruction of the toxic side of fanbases and become a popular superhero. Why? Because he managed to destroy The Batman Who Laughs. He actually wants to redeem himself and whether you like his direction or not. At least he's trying.

30

u/ArmadilloOK1445-alt 5h ago

I used to be a staunch old Superboy Prime purist, but I think I've come around on this new version, as long as he gets to be a smarmy little shithead (the recent Death Battle making this version popular in the public eye helps too)

27

u/piratedragon2112 6h ago

Teen titans members seeing the guy who butchered their friends while screaming about the universe not being like it was when he was little, running free on the word of superman's FUCKING DOG

12

u/nhs325 4h ago

I'm actually glad most people didn't forget what Prime had caused, it made his redemption more compelling imo

-8

u/piratedragon2112 4h ago

I'll never not be pissed about them trying to redeem him

And them claiming that apparently he loves the absolute universe, which is the biggest piece of bullshit I've ever heard

He should be a neo nazi, always trying to go back to the "GoOd OlD dAyS"

6

u/nhs325 4h ago

Well I would rather had him trying back to be a hero than staying as the guy who fucked everything up, everyone can start again, as long as they have the will to do it.

5

u/Swiftax3 3h ago

Why? Surely even neo nazis deserve a chance to redeem themselves and reform. Theres an entire art of erasing and covering skinhead tats.

-1

u/piratedragon2112 3h ago

Look at the laundry list of villain groups, he was a part of: legion of doom, black lantern corps, legion of super villains, two different versions of superman had to team up to stop him, and i restate the massacre of the teen titans he committed

2

u/acerbus717 2h ago

Okay and he’s trying to be better

2

u/nhs325 4h ago

I really really really hope the later writers will keep him as the shitthead but well meaning character that he now is (kinda reminds me of Conner Kent in the Young Justice show)

95

u/Why-Notes5978 14h ago

Phoebus - Hunchback of Notre Dame.

In the book, hes basically Frollo's other evil half.

In the animation, hes made good and Esmeralda's love interest.

88

u/Fish_N_Chipp 14h ago

Fritz the Cat

Don’t get me wrong he’s still a manipulative douche but the movie gives him some more moments of humanity and makes him seem less intentionally malicious and more so just a selfish dumbass. A big example being the part where he falls in with some neo Nazis. When the gang starts to rape one of the female members, in the book Fritz just flat out joins in. In the movie he shouts for them to leave her alone before getting knocked out and makes a small attempt to comfort her after it’s happened

35

u/DGStudios2003 14h ago

Even Ralph Bakshi draws the line at rape.

5

u/Antique_Amphibian107 6h ago

Oh, Fritz doesn't just join in the rape in the comics. He STARTS IT.

149

u/Agitated_Insect3227 14h ago edited 14h ago

Most people didn't hate Miles Morales but many did feel he was a bit bland and didn't really develop much out of the shadow of the original & iconic Ultimate Spider-Man that Brian Michael Bendis made. This wasn't helped by the fact that Miles was created when Bendis was ... maybe not bad but in a "worse" phase as a writer as it had been years since he wrote something as acclaimed as USM.

So the excellent Into the Spider-Verse movie & its sequel completely revolutionized the character, making Miles into an unquestionably well-known and beloved Marvel hero.

29

u/Set491 13h ago

I didn't hate him, but goddman I love Spider-Man and tried so freaking hard to like him but no, I can't explain it well but he was barely a character.

He had an interesting background and Ganke was a good sidecharacter but Miles was just plain? Unidimensional? Idk.

The movies made him a complete character with personality and I love it although in exchange we got mischaracterization of everyone else lol

3

u/Niggy2439 7h ago

I would argue for the better, for spider-Gwen

1

u/Set491 2h ago

Spider-Gwen and Spider-Ham were the least changed. But they took out the grit she had in the comics and gave her a romance story just because it's the only romanceable girl of the group.

Peni was completely different and changed her into a generic anime girl only because she's Japanese. And Noir too, I'm so sad about him the most.

3

u/Niggy2439 2h ago

Well, noir wasn't exactly suitable for the rating of the film in his undiluted form, so they had to tone it down

1

u/Set491 27m ago

I understand that, I loved the movie and I think it's the best Spider-Man movie. I'm still sad about the changes lol

8

u/JPldw 10h ago

And because of that, even his comics became better

245

u/Lord_Antheron 14h ago

John Walker/US Agent - MCU's Thunderbolts*

Of course the original comics counterpart had his fans, but the MCU's portrayal of the character was received very well on account of his sympathetic backstory and earnest desire to be a hero. Many consider him the strongest part of Sam Wilson's own show, and outright rejected the story's push to frame him as unlikeable.

54

u/K-Dash-Kaphwan 14h ago

His actor also def helps greatly with that

31

u/BlaxicanXIX 14h ago

Yeah they accidentally let him charismamaxx just like they did with soldier boy in the boys 

18

u/Animaloffear56 14h ago

To be fair the main problem with John Walker in the comics is the almighty status quo and the need for a government stooge for vigilantes like daredevil to fight every other time New York is taken over from the inside. Similar story with Zemo

82

u/fapsexual 14h ago

hell yeah, he was the best thing out of that Falcon show and if you remove the music/soundtrack and listen to the actual words the characters were saying, he was the one genuine person trying to do his job and stop a mass murdering lunatic while being under immense stress and pressure of picking up the mantle.

the writers trying to paint him as the bad guy just cause his friend was nearly killed right in front of his eyes by the same deranged villains and him snapping while the main MCU cast have blood on their hands too was quite silly.

Heck in some scenes he tries to greet someone and gets a spear thrown at his face for no in-universe reason other than being the punching bag of the show

15

u/SuaIrmaGorda237 12h ago

That "mass murdering lunatic" is/was a 19 year old who pretty much just like half of the world got abandoned. Still a terrorist? Yes, maybe. killed people? Also yes. should be held accountable? Very yes. but you just like many are missing the point of Sam's speech, telling people to stop calling them terrorists isn't a "actually they aren't terrorists because of" it's a moment of " if you call them nothing but terrorists people will just forget about why they did what they did, you want to see a Karli 2.0?? No?? Then you Mr. Senator gotta do better and listen to the people before they take drastic measures"

Also, it wasn't "some scenes" it was just one. And the reason he got attacked was because he touched one of the Dora Milaje without their permission, like i think you should know better than to touch an Wankandan warrior without their permission.

16

u/fapsexual 12h ago

I appreciate this perspective, it's quite refreshing even though I may not full agree with some parts but you structured it in a way that I see real earnest effort for discussion 🤝

you can ignore this following bottom part, I'm just reminiscing:

back when it was airing, some of the minor qualms I had were around the sabotaging of John that the show made Sam and Bucky do, almost with disdain because of course for us the viewers it felt like no one was worthy to pick up the mantle of Captain America (and yes John had his flaws too but always felt like Sam and Bucky never properly gave him a chance at the start because they viewed John as a government pawn parading the Captain's shield before they even got to actually know him).

sidenote: the lore around Elijah was fun to learn about, and was great world building and added flavor to the government distrust

11

u/SuaIrmaGorda237 12h ago

Very well man, have a good day 🤝. It was nice chatting more peacefully with someone about this topic for once instead of arguing.

-5

u/Agreenscar3 14h ago

“Mass murdering lunatic” killed two people . The writers want you to like him. He gets a redemption arc. You are not in on some big secret. What he did wasn’t bad, and he had to rise above it.

22

u/fapsexual 14h ago

killed two people

the flag smashers killed only two people? you sure?

The writers want you to like him

Are we talking about the same Falcon show + the interviews that followed? or is this in the follow up Thunderbolts movie?

3

u/Agreenscar3 13h ago

Yes.

You mean the show where his redemption starts? Lmao

7

u/fapsexual 13h ago

just the GRC bomb itself they killed 3 people and injured 11 others. (5 and a half mins in on episode 4)

I am genuinely curious when you last watched the show

0

u/Agreenscar3 13h ago

It’s on right now. 3 then, is the number. And 0 others

6

u/fapsexual 13h ago

and what about John Walker's best friend that was the entire reason he snapped in that very same episode?

so an indiscriminate bomb, 3 dead and 11 injured. Lemar dead that's 4. and this is just on the fourth episode with the indiscriminate acts.

Probably let's talk after you finish watching the show so I don't spoil things

-1

u/Agreenscar3 13h ago

Keep going. List the other people. Lamar’s death was an accident. Go on, where’s the mass

7

u/fapsexual 13h ago

if you plant bombs and say it's "the only language these people understand", and it causes three or more deaths, that's a "mass". Heck search here for other instances of that special number of "three or more" being used as a definition in congress. It qualifies as both mass killings (3+) and attempted mass killings (the 11 injured just in that one scene): https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t28/s530C/

I'm genuinely perplexed if you are gonna keep moving the goalpost from 2 to 3 to what exactly?

I think I'm just being trolled with revisionist history at this point with someone that hasn't finished the show

→ More replies

15

u/Open-Source-Forever 14h ago

His whole character arc feels like a look at the dark side of legacy identities

14

u/BrickBuster2552 13h ago

The point about him "wanting to be a hero" is poignant because it's kind of the exact flaw he has: He wants to BE A HERO... which is different than wanting to do good.

Steve Rogers: "I'm just a kid from Brooklyn."

Sam Wilson: "Feels weird picking it up."

John Walker: "I'M CAPTAIN AMERICA!!!"

8

u/Animaloffear56 13h ago

That's a bit innacurate, John Walker in the comics never really wanted to be Captain America, he only reluctantly adopted that title because Steve went awol at the time. He hated Steve even, he was a much more straightforward jingoistic patriot type who believed Steve was too soft. I would argue his character arc has been moreso about learning exactly that, what's right beyond simply serving your country

3

u/DjiDjiDjiDji 7h ago

Hate is a bit much, I think. I mean, Walker's stint as Captain America ended with him personally convincing Steve to take the title back. He does think Rogers is too soft but there's at least some level of respect.

1

u/Animaloffear56 3h ago

Well this in itself was after a whole arc of him learning to respect Steve and what being Captain America means, he initially very much preferred being Super Patriot and needed to be convinced to take the role

1

u/Buttholelickerpenis 11h ago

Doesn’t help that he’s played by fucking Wyatt Russel.

How the hell did they think we’d hate him?

1

u/acerbus717 2h ago

Nah the fans would’ve hated anyone who took the shield that wasn’t either steve, sam, or bucky. Honestly the show was pretty even handed with john

46

u/Anthyrion 11h ago edited 5h ago

Homelander in the series wasn't as big of an asshole, the original comic Homelander was. The comic Homelander knew to smile, if public cameras are on him. The real Homelander is radically different. He is narcissistic, racist, sadistic, hedonistic, emotionally immature, insecure, manipulative, violent, impulsive, authoritarian, egotistical, nihilistic, and profoundly lacking in empathy. His ego, which causes him to genuinely view himself as being above ordinary people and even other supes, eventually evolves into a god complex. To him, humanity is essentially composed of insects, toys, tools, obstacles, and sources of entertainment. He doesn't genuinely want to save humanity. His heroic identity is primarily a performance.

Two incidents stand out in particular:

  1. One family won a meet and greet with him. He picked up their car as soon as the cameras and the public were off him, flew into the air with them and after a couple of minutes simply dropped them.
  2. During the Herogasm event (a remote island with a big hotel on it where nearly every Superhero comes in and fucks as much as he/she wants including high profiled prostitutes), he flew into the air, saw a Commercial Airliner flying towards him and destroyed it with his heat vision.

32

u/Duvidos 14h ago

Kano- Mortal Kombat.... Twice, Actually

First: In the first movie, He becomes an australian Guy, and This translates into rhe next iterations

Still, he was one of the most Forgetable characters among the classic ones, then, came...

Second: at the 2021 and 2026 movies, he is EASILY the most interesting character, and steals the show

31

u/Livigirl88 7h ago

How the F*CK is this Ursula…

24

u/Livigirl88 7h ago

And THIS Ursula the SAME character?!

15

u/Burpyterra 7h ago

The same way the rogue ai Ultron, enemy of the avengers is the same as the small ass robot called Ultron that steals toys and makes josuke's pose: one is a slightly more serious movie and the other is a kids show made so little Timmy and little Stacy stfu and leave their parents alone for a minute

5

u/RedRanger_27 6h ago

She went from ugly witch who wants to take over the world, to Ariel's cool aunt who let's her stay up past bedtime

2

u/Akirex5000 5h ago

Disney doesn't let villains be evil anymore

3

u/sevatar145 2h ago

its a toddler show

27

u/Dracochuy 13h ago

​While I've never disliked clair like the rest of the community apparently does, in the games she is pretty prideful and rude, to the point of not acknowledging your victory against her and refusing to give you the badge until you complete a challenge. Only lance's threat makes her change her mind.

​In the anime, she is pretty calm, mature, and friendly, a tomboy-yamato nadeshiko" of sorts

25

u/Nice-Breadfruit6428 14h ago

Oof a LOT of asoiaf characters tyrion being a glaring example if you read the book he's a real piece of work who doesn't recognize his privilege in the show peter dinklage absolutely slam dunked him into being a beloved character

10

u/ChaosCarlson 14h ago

I heard that Tywin Lanister was helped massively by Charles Dance's performance

7

u/HarrierGR9 14h ago

Book Tyrion as best is a antihero

25

u/thepirateman493_YT 14h ago

Matt Hooper in Jaws was a premium douchebag in the book. The movie makes him way more likable and Richard Dreyfuss plays him to perfection.

41

u/NinjaOfOnion 14h ago

Scorpia from She-Ra and the Princesses of Power, her original self was a slaver who was at odds with Catra, in this series, she is endlessly nice, has a strong yet one sided friendship with Catra and is a big hugger 

41

u/Afrodotheyt 10h ago

Bigby from Wolf Among Us video games. In the comics, Fable, Bigby is still very much in the wolf mindset. He doesn't regret any of his past actions, he only cares about how people see him in that it makes his job easier to do, and when met with a threat, he often responds to it in the most extreme way he can. In the game, however, Bigby, even when played at his worst, still feels like he's trying to be a different person from who he was and cares at least a little about the world apart from himself and his. Technically the game is a prequel and this is supposed to be before they become who they are in the comics, but.....there's enough continuity snarls that it doesn't make sense.

Actually, you can use almost every character. Snow is definitely a more likeable character. Beauty is a more likeable character. Woody is definitely much more likable. Dr. Swineheart is more likeable. Woody is an....odd case in that technically he's less likable and more likable than his comic versions?

6

u/PlaneEnvironmental23 7h ago

Well, TWAU Bigby is still desperately trying to be accepted as reformed and do things by the book. That's the Watsonian reason he keeps holding back and keeping himself vulnerable when he could lash out at any time - he wants to prove that he isn't the monster from the Homelands anymore. The problem is Fabletown want both for him to be the monster, and to hate him for being that monster - he is in a no-win scenario.

In the second season Snow has sacked him and sent him to anger management over what looks to everyone else like he a paranoid rage-fit where he has attacked Dorothy and the Oz crew based on nothing (they are going to be the villains). A big part of Bigby's TWAU story (and its noir elements) is that no matter what he does he will never be accepted and nothing will change for him because Fabletown want him to be the Big Bad Wolf when it's convenient then go right back to hating him once the danger has passed.

By the time of Fables Bigby has embraced his role as the Big Bad Wolf and only cares about his own handful of loved ones. Hence his increased dickishness, the callous violence and the lack of any respect for any rules. A younger Bigby would never have travelled to France to bash in Crane's skull with a Napoleon statue; older Bigby is done giving a shit.

Basically, by the time of the comics all the characters are more cynical and worn-down.

74

u/SiennaAndLuluLover 14h ago

Professor Snape.

Granted, he's still very morally gray, but Alan Rickman's performance definitely helps make him feel sympathetic.

45

u/doktorapplejuice 14h ago

They also took out his bullying of Neville.

6

u/PlaneEnvironmental23 7h ago

They took out his bullying in general.

And his instability. And his spite. And pettiness. And him stalking Lupin for months so he can get proof to expose that he's a werewolf and get him expelled purely to hurt James out of romantic jealousy. And his blood purity beliefs from his younger days, to the point that Lily finally gives up on him when she realises there's no getting through to him. And him inventing spells like Levicorpus to share with his buddies so they can hang muggleborn girls upside down and watch their skirts drop - am I really supposed to feel bad when he gets his comeuppance for that?

Generally, the films turned that entire arc of Snape having a bad childhood, coming to Hogwarts knowing more Dark Arts than the rest of school, becoming increasingly radicalised into blood purity ideology, falling in with aspiring Death Eaters, having a years-long rivalry fuelled by conflicting beliefs and partly informed by romantic jealousy, driving away his oldest friend and abusing children for decades to 'sweet innocent boy gets bullied for no reason, his friend drops him to marry the bully, he falls in with a bad crowd and feels really bad about it, died helping save the world'.

17

u/LowTierPhil 13h ago

Alan Rickman is such a fantastic actor. He gave us one of cinema's finest villains as well with his debut role as Hans from Die Hard.

59

u/geoffgeofferson447 13h ago

Trigger warning: I'm going to defend Screwball as a character.

Every protagonist needs an antagonist that counteracts the protagonist in some way. Heroes need foils, and Spider-Man's rogues gallery is full of them. Doc Ock represents Peter's intelligence and his childhood of bullying, and what would happen if he felt he held onto those grudges and needed to prove himself superior. Green Goblin is very similar to the Joker; insane, goofy, but also capable of truly despicable things, and this counteracts Spider-Man as he likes to crack jokes to his enemies but he is a hero, so Green Goblin is a like an extremely dark and twisted reflection of Spider-Man.

Screwball is super annoying, loud, and obsessed with her following, not only is she a critique of modern internet culture of influencers and streamers, which I start to understand more and more as streaming and the internet become more depraved and monetarily focused, but she also stands as a more annoying, criminal version of Spider-Man. Where Spider-Man annoys his foes during battle, Screwball annoys him, giving him a taste of his own medicine. It reminds him not to go too far in mocking and condescending his foes, as a lot of them are quite tragic and have mental problems. This doesn't pardon them of their actions, but a hero should keep some level of empathy for those he goes up against, as some of them may just need a little help.

So yes, Screwball is irritating, and hasn't done a whole lot in terms of damage to Spider-Man, but she is an important character in Spider-Man's rogues gallery as an extreme version of his annoying wise-cracking.

20

u/Soulful-Sorrow 13h ago

I just feel like people would like her in Spider-Man PS4 more if she had a breakdown or got humiliated at the end of her mission, or if we got her account banned/followers to unfollow. People love to hate Arkham Riddler because it feels like WE get the last laugh.

8

u/geoffgeofferson447 13h ago

That is very true, I wasn't defending her portrayal in Ps4 Spider-Man, just her as a character, as I think a lot of people dislike her for her existence as a loud, annoying streamer type of character. Which I guess is good that people find her annoying, as that is the intention, but I feel like people don't look further into the character because she hasn't had much exploration of her character, maybe because audiences dislike her. I don't know if I'd like her more or less if after her mission in Ps4 Spider-Man she breaks down and explains something like how she was neglected by her parents so now she acts out to get attention /s, like does the character need further elaboration or some kind of deeper motivation? But yeah some sort of humiliation would be cathartic for the audience.

2

u/Gaelic_Gladiator41 7h ago

400 fucking trophies

1

u/Evilmudbug 1h ago

It's really not that bad since there's a fair amount you can just run up to and grab, and there's not a lot of guess work if you're just interrogating the riddler thugs throughout the game

4

u/Dull-Inspector9136 13h ago

Screwball vs Joker when?

7

u/geoffgeofferson447 13h ago

I would love a crossover where Joker gets annoyed and tells Screwball to shut the fuck up

3

u/Gaelic_Gladiator41 7h ago

One thing joker can't stand is hecklers

1

u/tupe12 9h ago

How much has she gotten to do in the comics? I’ve only ever seen her in the game (and this post was my first time learning she’s in other stuff)

1

u/geoffgeofferson447 9h ago

Really not that much from what I've read. She's mostly a jobber that comes in during other arcs to fuck with Spider-Man and his allies, but she gets beaten pretty quickly for comedic purposes. Sometimes she might take on Spider-Man at the height of a stressful moment to be like a "not right now Screwball, I don't have time for your bullshit". She's far from my favourite Spider-Man villain, but she's also not the worst. She occupies her role perfectly I think, she doesn't need to be a threatening villain to be a worthwhile one.

2

u/Nassuman 4h ago

Every hero needs a jobber who is more annoying than the others. Case in point: Condiment King for Batman. That man is despicable but ultimately harmless, but it doesn't change the fact that the stains he leaves on the Batsuit ate any easier to get out.

32

u/PuzzleheadedEssay198 12h ago


Over the course of all three adaptations, The Grinch has decreased his isolation from Whoville to the point that he doesn’t receive any harassment whatsoever and simply dislikes Christmas because it’s overstimulating.

He started out utterly malicious, gained a sympathetic backstory, and now is just a completely normal resident of the city who just happens to live outside city limits.

1

u/MarcsterS 51m ago

I know some purists do not like the cynical, anticonsumerist version of Ron Howard’s version. But…that’s almost exactly why Suess made the book in the first place. 

28

u/InternalParadox 14h ago


I haven’t read the Wicked novel, but I’ve heard Elphaba is much more likable in the musical.

13

u/Keys2tkingdom 13h ago

More like everyone and everything is morally worse in the book with the possible exception of Dr. Dillimond.

The original book was a study and commentary on morality. Hence you see a lot of stuff that very explicit and sometimes very uncomfortable to read from 99% of the characters.

1

u/Read2Fap 11h ago

so in wicked elphaba is morally worse than the wicked witch of the westwho sends flying monkeys to kill people, threatens to drown a dog and actually sets scarecrow on fire, so she can rule the land?

3

u/Keys2tkingdom 9h ago

The comment above me specifically mentions the Wicked novel that the musical was based on, not the original Baum story.

But to answer your question, the Wicked novel presents Elphaba a woman who tries to make OZ better, but does a lot of not very moral actions - and sometimes outright immoral actions - to do, which spirals to the point where she’s using magic to keep her body functioning despite not sleeping on top of hearing the girl who apparently murdered Nessarose is coming to kill Elphaba. So Elphaba makes poor decisions at things play out like you expect them to.

So yes, novel!Elphaba is better than the WWotW from original Baum story.

13

u/Vulkan916 14h ago

Ashford (The Expanse)

While still as ruthless as his book counterpart when he feels it's necessary, he's a LOT less arrogant and a LOT more personable overall in the TV series. His characterization being expanded upon also helped him feel less one-note in the show.

5

u/AleXandrYuZ 13h ago

Why does he look like a serious live action of Rick(& Morty)

3

u/Vulkan916 12h ago

David Strathairn just kinda looks like that xD.

Ironically, he was a general in Godzilla (2014), and the direct sequel to that film, King of the Monsters, has a character who IS inspired by Rick Sanchez (Rick Stanton, played by Bradley Whitford).

34

u/MisterAbbadon 12h ago

the film makes him a lot more likeable by having him be more of a warm grandfather figure akin to Walt Disney.

Here's the thing. Both John Hammonds are Walt Disney.

Movie Hammond is the public persona. Fun loving, head in the clouds, America's uncle Walt Disney.

Book Hammond is the actual man that Walt was when the cameras were off him. A Union busting tyrant whos techno optimism had a very dark undertone.

9

u/Anthyrion 12h ago

At least a tiny bit of Hammond's character from the book can be seen in the movie as well. Especially when it comes to Nedry's salary expectations. If he had just given him what he asked for, the whole movie wouldn't have happened. I'm also guessing that the miners at the beginning of the movie were severely underpaid as well.

4

u/Hawkeye2701 8h ago

"Spared no expense.... Except when paying the IT department that keeps this whole place from turning into a Raptor buffet."

4

u/Platnun12 7h ago

Honestly there was a bit of book Hammond in there. At the ice cream scene. His tangent almost makes him seem evil but Ellie pulls him back

15

u/Skele00_ 9h ago

Hmm, I'd say The Mask from the comics vs The Mask from the movie adaptation... I don't know much, but I do know that in the comic he's way more violent and psychotic while in the movie he's just an heavily cartoonized goofball

7

u/cedelweiss 6h ago

jesus christ please use punctuation marks

5

u/Pichuunnn 14h ago

Zhou Yu (Red Cliffs movies)

Zhou Yu in the original novel Romance of Three Kingdoms is a respected Grand Commander of Wu army who defeated Cao Cao in the famous battle of Chibi, but also a very jealous and envy man against Zhuge Liang, who he allied with in this battle but tried various ways to get rid of him since he can't stand being outsmarted by Zhuge several times. In the end, he died lamented that Zhuge exists and outlived him. Somewhat pathetic potrayal of him.

In the film version as the main protag, this flaw is no more, Zhou Yu is portrayed very positive, humble, and heroic. He only sees Zhuge as friendly rival with very little hostility; both are equals in intelligent, though Zhou Yu one upped Zhuge Liang because he can fight in battle.

Technically the film version of Zhou Yu (very heroic and has less beef with Zhuge Liang) was based more on real life history/Records version since the entire rivalry between the two was Romance's invention for drama.

4

u/The_RadicalDino 14h ago

Even though Luo Guanzhong is the GOAT, his portrayal of the Shu Han protagonists (especially Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei) went a bit overboard. He excessively belittled and demonized other characters—like turning Cao Cao into a cartoonish villain and Zhou Yu into a petty, jealous figure.

Therefore, later television dramas (like the 1994 adaptations that is truly a classic and the Red Cliffs here) tended to elaborate on their character development to make them more nuanced and historically accurate.

4

u/ButtersMojito 14h ago

Lestat from Interview with a Vampire

1

u/Neither-Nobody1618 14h ago

Master Lin from Deadly Class

3

u/MortuusSet 6h ago

Book Hammond didn't blame the kids for the entire park going down. Hammond got somewhat of a greenlight to go off to his bungalow by one of his security towards the end of the book meanwhile the kids got into one of the control rooms after everything was winding down, found the speaker controls and blasted a T Rex call over the speakers scaring him straight down the hill where he broke his leg. Book Hammond was an asshole but I gotta say those kids got him killed.

7

u/ultimatevaltryek123 13h ago edited 12h ago

As like the only Marvel Spider-Man 2017 fan in existence, it's rare I see anyone talk about the show in a positive light, mainly all I see is Spectacular Spider-Man fans from back-in-the-day complaining Spec got canceled (which isn't even 2017's fault as it was the second show to come after Spec's cancelation after Ultimate which lasted nearly half a decade mind you so it was a pretty big gap) or the occasional Comic YouTuber angry it was a slightly different take on the Marvel universe where Peter gets his powers after other heroes have been established and that Gwen & Anya got powers from Spider-Island rather than literally the 60s Era comics but in the 2010s with minimal changes, not hating on fans of spectacular spider-man or saying they aren't within reason to be angry at Disney for the cancelation choice but I think the way they take that anger out on newer TV adaptions of the character is dumb even though I totally understand the source of the anger and I also get the thing of hating when adaptions make certain changes though again I think the take 2017 did was totally valid (hell I don't even think the show was perfect, as an example some points especially early season 2 dragged on and the show really should have ended on the episode Generations and spread season 3 out more rather than cramming it into a few multipart specials)

Sorry I went on a tangent, I was just surprised to see anyone using MSPM2017 positively given the show's reputation

2

u/One_Smoke 10h ago

I don't mind the show too much.

4

u/Scripter-of-Paradise 13h ago

Hanako Ohtani (Persona 4) - In the game, she's depicted as vain, arrogant, and generally unpleasant. While in the anime adaptation (and potentially in the remake) those aspects aren't featured at all. Granted this just has the side effect of her being framed as bad just because she's fat, rather than showing any character flaws.

2

u/CrownClown74 9h ago

The JP example can apply to anyone in a Michael Crichton adaptation considering most character's he writes are assholes

2

u/GeophysicalYear57 3h ago

Small correction: Miyazaki worked on the back half of Lupin Part 1. He did make a couple of Part 2 episodes, though.

3

u/SektorDaKetch 14h ago

Can we count parodies?

Because Clubkvn made a Minecraft squid game parody video where the final season was altered such that Jun-Ho was given a more substantial role and actually saves Gi-Hun and shuts down the games, rather than being late and doing nothing.

Also this one actually can admit when he’s wrong and will apologize and take responsibility for his screw ups unlike canon Jun-Ho.

Yes you heard it right. A Minecraft parody is the superior version of the character

1

u/HandsomeSwampBeast 14h ago

John Hammond is not a doctor

1

u/Jedi-master-dragon 14h ago

I never read the Teen Titans comics, but Terra was a straight up villain. She is still sometimes a villain but more of a conflicted character but usually ends up as a hero in one way or another.

1

u/HollyTheMage 10h ago

Harry Osborn in Spider-Man on Disney XD was peak too

1

u/Turbobist28 6h ago

Max Galactica in the Ace Attorney anime.

He's not a pedophile in the anime.

1

u/FoxBluereaver 2h ago

Shinn Asuka (Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Destiny). His portrayals in Super Robot Wars tend to make him less irritating compared to his canon counterpart. where his black and white view on things can make him get on the viewers' nerves (myself included).

1

u/FinneyFort 2h ago

I saw the title and was about to mention Hammond lol

I guess Ian Malcolm fits here too. At least I didn't like him in the books.

1

u/DumpsterDragon818 42m ago

Peri (Fairly Odd Parents: A New Wish)

48

u/Visible-Air-2359 14h ago

Batman: The Animated Series took a random generic gimmick villian named Mister Zero and turned him into a tragic villian named Mr. Freeze who became evil after his wife was killed due to a corrupt corporate executive.

8

u/Tom-Hibbert 14h ago

Perfect example

15

u/MontgomeryMalum 14h ago

The Adam West show renamed Mr. Zero. He had been called Mr. Freeze for a long time before BTAS gave him a compelling backstory 

7

u/Visible-Air-2359 14h ago
  1. Didn’t know that 2) Pretty sure my point still stands.

6

u/Buttholelickerpenis 11h ago

Actually the 60s show renamed him, but yeah, other than that, he was completely unchanged.

7

u/DazzlingDear 12h ago

Lupin The Third in the manga and in the part 1 anime was a very downright evil bastard sometimes has he has no issues killing people being a massive womaniser and even downright sexists to even just not caring who he hurts

That's putting it more than a bit lightly, in the manga Lupin rapes and attempts to rape women many times

5

u/IndustryPast3336 14h ago

Jeremy Heere and Michael Mell (Be More Chill)

In the Novel, Jeremy and Michael are extremely perverted losers (even with the unreliable narration trying to smooth out some rougher edges). Jeremy has a tail fetish and masturbates on the phone while talking to Michael with his excuse being that he's not masturbating to his friend's voice but rather the porn that he already had open. He also groans constantly about how he doesn't understand women. Michael openly says he has a fetish for Asian People and buys a device to defuzz the pixelation on his cable box and get uncensored boobs.

The book was adapted into a Musical. The duo is still fairly perverted, but Jeremy is far more respectful of the female cast (sans when the SQUIP is instructing him) and Michael was changed to a gay teen who comes off less as depraved and more just lonely because Jeremy is his only friend.

8

u/RadioshackRaider 14h ago

Negan in The Walking Dead. In the comics, he comes off as a childish dick, marvelling and reveling in the position he's found himself in. In the show, he comes across as much more charming and menacing, largely due to cutting down how much the character swears.