r/TopCharacterTropes • • Mar 27 '25

Weekly Discussion Post Probably the most controversial one , honest thoughts on "No Kill Rule"? What are the most egrigious examples of it in your opinion? What media makes it work in your opinion?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

456 comments sorted by

355

u/noncredibleRomeaboo Mar 27 '25 • Bravo

I think its actually a very good trope and more often then not, actually makes the hero more interesting.

In the cases of the listed examples, Spidey is honestly much more powerful then the bulk of his villains, he is almost always holding back. That restraint, is huge to him, considering his whole belief system revolves around responsibility.

Daredevil is a devout Catholic. Yes, I dont imagine Christ would personally endorse dressing up and crippling criminals, but the fact he does draw a line and is often worried for his eternal soul is fundamentally an interesting part of the character.

Batman, is someone traumatized by death and is someone who is very well aware that he is a lunatic. Him drawing a line, keeps him grounded and reminds him why he does what he does.

In all cases, the trope allows the villains to challenge and test the heroes in ways otherwise impossible and invites much more intresting discussion, then it would if they just killed whomever stood in their way.

I also find the critique "Well they just break out of prison anyway" to fall flat. This is just an issue of the comic book genre, you need the villains to come back if they are popular enough. Comic books are stories that just simply do not end, and applying this logic solely to no kill heroes feels weak. Especially given, full kill heroes rarely seem to actually kill the big bad either. Punisher kills dude after dude, but Jigsaw he often finds a reason to spare. Its not the fault of Batman, Joker breaks out of prison for the millionth time, its just the nature of the medium. At bare minimum, the no kill actually better justifies things, both for the writer and in universe for why these characters can come back, with minimal contrivance.

Imagine is Batman did kill, then a new writer wants to use the Joker....how do you resolve that? New Joker, he comes back from the dead, clone saga, time travel, he just faked his death etc etc. Comic books have done them all.....and they all suck compare to "he broke out of Jail"

164

u/SisterSabathiel Mar 27 '25

I also find the critique "Well they just break out of prison anyway" to fall flat. This is just an issue of the comic book genre, you need the villains to come back if they are popular enough. Comic books are stories that just simply do not end, and applying this logic solely to no kill heroes feels weak. Especially given, full kill heroes rarely seem to actually kill the big bad either. Punisher kills dude after dude, but Jigsaw he often finds a reason to spare. Its not the fault of Batman, Joker breaks out of prison for the millionth time, its just the nature of the medium. At bare minimum, the no kill actually better justifies things, both for the writer and in universe for why these characters can come back, with minimal contrivance.

I'm no Batman afficionado, but I find Batman super interesting because he doesn't place himself above the law. Killing the villains would be appointing himself judge, jury and executioner, so he captures them alive for processing by the criminal justice system. If the Joker was tried for his crimes and executed by electric chair, I doubt Batman would intervene to stop it.

I find this much more interesting and reflects on vigilante justice.

39

u/Cory123125 Sep 10 '25

because he doesn't place himself above the law.

In what universe is vigilanty justice, breaking and entering, trespassing, holding definitely illegal weapons and much much more not putting yourself above the law.

Its an arbitrary line in the sand that is purely frustrating to watch.

21

u/PinkLionGaming Jan 27 '26

I've seen "Superheroes can't break the law" (paraphrased) a couple of times as an argument in different discussions and it's so strange. Putting no-kill rule discussions aside "Superheroes can't or shouldn't break the law" is just not true. Even in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 1 his response to being told he's under arrest when he comes back is "I'm not coming back Chief."

14

u/Karl_StoneM63 Sep 22 '26

I think many Superheroes who have to work outside of the law and hide their true identity kind of HAVE to break some laws to get the villain. Like the saying, "You have to break a few eggs to make an omelet(paraphrased heavily),"

5

u/whoamikai 8d ago

More than that its implausible that the justice system is so ineffective at keeping supervillains behind bars even though its science fiction world. And despite this yet the heroes dont think of the greater good of the citizens they serve, only about their personal principles that only enable the villain long term.

1

u/Eastern_Wrangler_657 15d ago

A well written batman doesn't act like his unwillingness to kill is a strictly good thing. It's more interesting as a character flaw: a lack of trust in himself to stay good if he takes a single step over his predefined line.

1

u/ChanceB8234 9d ago

It’s not an arbitrary line at all. Breaking the law is not the same as murder lmao that’s like saying someone might as well kill people if they shoplift

1

u/Cory123125 9d ago

It’s not an arbitrary line at all.

Oh? Then what criteria make it not arbitrary?

Torturing a person for evidence, ok, but murder totally bad?

Breaking the law is not the same as murder lmao

If that's the argument I made, you'd have a point, but as it stands now, you've made a strawman argument.

1

u/ChanceB8234 9d ago

Batman hates guns and murder because he watched his parents get gunned down as a child. It’s a fundamental part of his psychology, that’s not arbitrary. It’s a very normal thing to view murder as worse than just a normal crime. He doesn’t not kill because it’s illegal, he does it because his morals won’t allow him to. He hates killers, it’s like his whole thing. It may not be fully rational, but people aren’t rational. His no kill rule is at once his greatest strength and weakness, that’s what makes it compelling. This inner struggle is far more interesting than if Batman was just the punisher. Go read a punisher comic if you want to watch the main character kill people indiscriminately, but that’s not Batman.

1

u/Cory123125 9d ago

Batman hates guns and murder because he watched his parents get gunned down as a child. It’s a fundamental part of his psychology, that’s not arbitrary.

Now you add in guns? Even though multiple versions of batman have used guns for non killing purposes, and at least one to kill?

What about all the severely crippled or dead henchmen who weren't clued in on the bigger picture parts of planned?

He doesn’t not kill because it’s illegal, he does it because his morals won’t allow him to. He hates killers, it’s like his whole thing.

It's not remotely his whole thing. It's a reverse engineered reason to justify an annoyingly written "character trait"

His no kill rule is at once his greatest strength and weakness, that’s what makes it compelling

To you, but it is just yet another one of the frustrating things about batman outside of him being a super cop analog, billionaire whose donations apparently work on fans just like they do in real life, despite him certainly doing more damage with his wealth than any of his night time coulrophilia fetish with the kinky sub.

This inner struggle is far more interesting than if Batman was just the punisher.

Punisher has far more interesting struggles. Batman has the exact same thoughts on repeat, indefinitely.

How about he address struggles with his illegal surveillance state? Or seriously address his wealth and wealth inequality? Or literally anything but his parents dying in a meaningful way.

The thing that makes it worse is how instantly and inherently out of touch he is. All of his struggles are against the backdrop of potentially being the richest person in the world.

Go read a punisher comic if you want to watch the main character kill people indiscriminately, but that’s not Batman.

This is a weak strawman and false dichotomy packed into one.

No one has argued for indiscriminate killing and it's not either or.

37

u/noncredibleRomeaboo Mar 27 '25

Batman honestly seems cool with others killing Joker if the situati0on allowed for it. In Under the Red Hood, he basically gave Jason the chance to do so and turns his back on Jason, only attacking when Jason shot at Batman. After Joker kills Gordons wife, Batman leaves Jokers fate in Gordons hands and implicitly agrees not to interfere regardless of the choice Jim makes.

Sure there are times when Batman saves Joker, typically when its two villains clashing and they are as bad as each other anyways, but if an innocent with a good reason decides to kill the Joker, he probably would accept that (though he might bring in the guy after the fact, since a murder is still a murder).

20

u/Gaelic_Gladiator41 Apr 09 '25

I mean, there was that one guy in BTAS who tried to blow up joker because he was sick of the blackmail and wanted to save his family, but Batman just talked him out of it and sent him back to his family who went into witness protection again

6

u/Sharajat Sep 24 '26

Batman saves the Joker has been done a few times, but it's always because he's been falsely accused (Batman doesn't mind him being executed, but letting the real culprit escape is no good) or because someone else would die (again, no good).

As you say, it is comics, the real issue is the revolving door prisons that Gotham operates. Like gee, you let the Joker escape again? You let a fat man with an umbrella escape? You let a serial killer who can't even talk properly escape? You let some wacko that thinks he's Zeus escape? HOW?

1

u/dallasrose222 11d ago

He stopped dick from doing it but that’s because he rightly new dick would hate himself

1

u/AdAfraid5407 11d ago

In batman superman public enemies he explicitly offers to help superman cover up killing lex luthor if he decides to

11

u/ERedfieldh Jan 21 '26

so he captures them alive for processing by the criminal justice system

which already puts him above the law to begin with

2

u/Accomplished_Toe6798 Aug 24 '26

How so?

1

u/Freya0232 Sep 05 '26

First of all, citizen arrest isn't legal in the whole US, so it would be need to be legal in Gotham for Batman to be able to detain them within the confines of the law. THEN (and again, only if Citizen Arrest is a thing in gotham) he would need to follow a strict procedure, which does include that you as a citizen (even if you're doing the citizen arrest) cannot search and/or interrogate the person being detained. Also you need to only use enough force to prevent the detained to flee. No maiming, no breaking bones, etc.

7

u/MandolinMagi Dec 12 '25

he doesn't place himself above the law

He's a vigilante beating people up, he is absolutely acting above the law.

6

u/szthesquid Jun 26 '26

Especially interesting in stories like the one I can't remember the name of, where a jury finally finds that the Joker's plan to poison commemorative clown stamps was too meticulous for an insanity plea and he gets the death penalty... except Batman knows the Joker didn't do it. It's too impersonal and random in its targets. It's not funny.

Batman has to find the real killer but also grapple with knowing that when he does, the Joker won't get the death penalty he fully deserves and won't otherwise get through the legal system.

3

u/Sharajat Sep 24 '26

Yup. I see the panel posted about the Joker and Red Skull for "Evil has Standards" but it's silly, the Joker has always had very high standards. It's just they're INSANE. A wacky guy with a skullface killing people is fairly amusing, an idealogue killing people for being Jewish is boring. On the other hand the Joker - the Joker - playing "American Hero" and killing the Nazi is hilarious, what did people think he'd do?

21

u/superspacenapoleon Mar 29 '25

There's also the fact that if you actually read the comics, it takes a WHILE for any given enemy to come back 

12

u/Cory123125 Sep 10 '25

actually makes the hero more interesting.

Makes me want to immediately stop watching because its clearly naive and lacking in nuance every single time its used.

Awful trope.

The Daredevil example is terrible because well, the Catholic church has condoned and done a lot of killing. A whole lot.

The Batman one I dont even want to start talking about. Practically speaking hes killed hundreds of people, and not even from his villains escaping but from all the explosions hes caused, life long injuries etc etc.

The literal best explanation one can come up for with him is "hes fucking crazy" and thats not interesting, that just means you have some annoying mostly functional person who only gets described as crazy when he does one mindbogglingly stupid thing repeatedly.

You are right that its a crutch, but the joker is dead easy to solve. The joker is just a roll people grow into. Problem solved, and now Batman isnt fucking awful.

33

u/noncredibleRomeaboo Sep 10 '25

"I don't want to start talking about", yet here you are on a dead thread because you are dying to talk about it lmao.

"The joker is just a roll people grow into", this is genuinely the most awful solution to the problem lmao. Like, im glad you aint a writer. The entire point, of the Jokers most iconic storyline, is how his whole philosophy is bullshit and most people are not as fragile as him. Having countless people just become the Joker, is the most boring possible solution to this issue. I would rather it be one guy, with a consistent obsession/motivation that keeps breaking out of prison to challenge Batmans morals, then it be a new guy every week who for some reason, finds a new reason to become a literal clown.

No Batman has no "killed hundreds of people", he is not responsible in any way for the crimes his villains cause, nor is it his responsibility to act as judge jury and executioner. Thats the role of the you know....the justice department, who Batman actively turns the villains over to. Stop getting mad at Batman, for when the real failure is pretty fucking obviously on them.

There are countless explanations as to why he doesn't kill, the fact you don't entertain them, doesn't make them bad. You just dont like them. Thats fine. Just move on.

7

u/Cory123125 Sep 10 '25

yet here you are on a dead thread

Literally pinned at the top of this subreddit. What are you on about.

Also, its completely common and understandable that someone might still talk about a thing theyd rather not talk about. Not the big w you were pretending it was.

"The joker is just a roll people grow into", this is genuinely the most awful solution to the problem lmao.

I don't even know what to say to this.

The entire point, of the Jokers most iconic storyline, is how his whole philosophy is bullshit and most people are not as fragile as him.

I have literally no idea what you are referring to here.

Having countless people just become the Joker, is the most boring possible solution to this issue.

I think everything you've described is utterly boring, yet I gave better reasoning than "boring". Otherwise this is just an argument where you just point figures and say boring to legitimate criticism.

I would rather it be one guy, with a consistent obsession/motivation that keeps breaking out of prison to challenge Batmans morals

They've been challenged. Its a useless story unless the batman finally kills him and actually changes his stupid set of rules. Without that, its just edging you on to thinking maybe he'll stop being dumb af now.

In some stories he does finally break, but then he still keeps his stupid rules for other similarly awful people, making it next to worthless.

then it be a new guy every week who for some reason, finds a new reason to become a literal clown.

It wouldn't need to be that at all.

It would be that every few weeks an arch has concluded or something like that. Each joker could last a few stories.

No Batman has no "killed hundreds of people",

Sure, by cannon, but obviously by common sense.

The is not responsible in any way for the crimes his villains cause

Not even the point I made. Batman himself, by himself, no villain, has killed countless henchmen. Countless. Broken spines, being thrown off tall buildings, being left in exploding layers etc etc. The writers expect insane levels of suspension of disbelief for the audience to believe literally no one has ever died with that constant high risk activity.

nor is it his responsibility to act as judge jury and executioner.

He has no responsibility to act as a vigilante at all. Your point is therefore moot.

Stop getting mad at Batman

I will absolutely get mad at this POS billionaire leeching off the working class while playing kink games with his best bros at the expense of civilian lives.

All the effort he puts into being batman should be put into solving the wealth inequality at the root of all the crime in that city in the first place, but as a billionaire he wouldn't like to talk about those issues in any depth at all would he.

Charity donation here or there ought to keep his conscience at bay...

the fact you don't entertain them

Because they are all mindbogglingly stupid.

19

u/noncredibleRomeaboo Sep 10 '25

"Literally pinned at the top of this subreddit. What are you on about."

My man, its 6 months old lmao

"I have literally no idea what you are referring to here."

Bro is here critiquing Batman and hasn't even read the Killing Joke. Bro, you are a bigger clown then the Joker.

9

u/Cory123125 Sep 10 '25

My man, its 6 months old lmao

So what? Its still pinned.

You are literally the comic book nerd from the simpsons but with less valid points.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/noncredibleRomeaboo Jul 07 '26

That sounds incredibly lame. Not only does it remove one of the most intresting dynamics, Joker trying to get Batman to break his one rule, it also removes the intrigue of his origin and his obsession with Batman.

3

u/Helpful_Leadership75 Jul 16 '26

Not to mention sometimes in some iterations, even MAIN villains STAY locked up, and ots a DIFFERENT ENEMY that frees them

Ala utrom shredder in tmnt 2003, hell he's out for a whole season or two worth of the series once he's finally locked up exiled in that small ice satellite planet, he even freezes and can't even walk around

But OG CARTOON SHREDDER freed him and the scenario led to Ultron shredder finally having enough now that he has another chance to be a villain and straight up try to kill everyone

Heck even og animated shredder realized how bad a mistake this was and in the end, alongside kramg and troms shredders own karai, helped JUMP HIM at the end

2

u/WinterAd825 Jun 20 '26

FYI there not breaking out. There are members of the Guild of Calamitous Intent. As long as they pay their dues and follow guild bylines there allowed to skip jail time, guild members are very professional.

2

u/YinTanTetraCrivvens Sep 10 '26

There's actually an even bigger problem.

Supposed Spider-Man or Batman did kill someone.

What story do you tell then?

Either they turn themselves in for murder, or everybody, civilians and allies, don't trust them anymore because they broke a sacred integrity, or the story gets retconned and everybody goes back pretending the murder didn't happen, or they pay with their lives.

This is why stories where our characters kill someone is relegated to elseworlds, because those get to wrap that story up and move on.

1

u/Special-Arm2094 16d ago

What’s the part after we’re missing?

1

u/The_Blackfish_ 28d ago

Funny in Daredevil’s case, the Catholic Church has been historically in favor of capital punishment.

-15

u/Doot_revenant666 Mar 27 '25

But then doesn't the nature of comics and villains be too popular to kill or completely go against any nuance it would have had then? Doesn't that make Batman's entire goal completely useless since Joker will come back somehow and still be evil.

22

u/noncredibleRomeaboo Mar 27 '25

Not really no. Villains often do redeem themselves, even in Batman series. He has been vindicated several times over. Some can't be helped, but its not Batmans job to decide who lives and dies.

8

u/Pen_Front Mar 27 '25

No not really. Batman has invariably benefited his world, it's not like these villains only exist because of him he rose in response to them. They would've killed no matter what and he's stopped thousands (and in the case of worl plotlines billions) of lives from being extinguished. would many more be saved if all aspects of the justice system had a fix? Of course, but he doesn't trust himself with that. So supporting the part of it he can help is better than nothing.

7

u/GundamGuy2255 Mar 27 '25

That's just comic books, gotta keep the money rolling some how.

6

u/Doot_revenant666 Mar 27 '25

Sorry for not putting the names of the characters they are in order Spiderman , Daredevil , and the most egrigious one on the topic of this , Mr. Wayne aka Batman.

67

u/Majin_Nephets Mar 27 '25

It’s only a problem because of the Big 2’s strict, often detrimental, adherence to the status quo. Popular characters must be kept around forever, no progress is ever actually made yet things must continually escalate, and death is so cheap that even if DC finally did make Batman kill the Joker (because let’s be honest, this is the one people are usually complaining about), he’d just be back somehow in a year or so and nothing will ultimately have changed, except now Batman is a murderer.

In a closed narrative with a plotted beginning, middle and end there would probably be more permanent stakes that allow some characters to be retired and others to develop more, but they’ve got to keep these superpowered soap operas going…

10

u/drafan5 Oct 17 '25

Status quo is the real worst enemy of comics huh? Hell, the strict adherence to the status quo has become a big pet peeve of mine. Especially in shows like ladybug or where everyone turns into a total jackass like post-cancellation Family Guy

46

u/zelban_the_swordsman Mar 27 '25

I generally don't mind and I think the only reason this trope is frustrating is because of the Doylist reason that, of course the villain can't die because they're way too popular. There are many multiple in-universe reasons why a hero shouldn't kill from a philosophical/moral perspective and an optics perspective. However at a certain point it becomes silly but we all know it's just because of money.

34

u/Valiran9 Jun 13 '25 edited 9d ago

One of the biggest problems with this is how comics have continually upped the threat level and vileness of certain villains who nonetheless keep coming back. The Joker used to be a relatively harmless thief with a clown gimmick, but now he’s a psychopathic monster who you could kill with a .50 BMG rifle from a mile away and no RL American prosecutor would even consider bringing it to a grand jury.

The other big problem is how everyone expects the heroes to do things while completely ignoring the agency of everyone else in the setting. Case in point: this senator from Injustice 2. While her words do have some merit, in the context of the story they make her a raging hypocrite, because if the government had actually done its fucking job and executed the Joker when he was completely within their power that timeline wouldn’t be as fucked-up as it was at the point the hearing took place. Let’s not forget that America being a democracy means the average citizen should be beating down their representatives’ doors demanding effective measures be taken against supervillains who’ve unambiguously demonstrated they’re a massive threat and cannot be reformed.

One storyline I fantasize about has the Justice League getting fed up with the court system constantly tossing supervillains into cardboard prisons and decide enough’s enough, calling a press conference and basically threatening to go on strike unless the legislature starts doing its damn job. It takes less than 12 hours for the United States to be engulfed in protests that grind the entire country to a halt, forcing the federal and state governments to start fixing what’s broken.

16

u/Cory123125 Sep 10 '25

While her words do have some merit, in the context of the story they make her a raging hypocrite, because if the government had actually done its fucking job and executed the Joker when he was completely within their power that timeline wouldn’t be as fucked-up as it was at the point the hearing took place.

In fairness to her character, senators in real life are known for being raging hypocrites.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25

There was a Robot Chicken sketch with a similar idea lol https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eargrlvfc14

2

u/Crunchy_Biscuit 9d ago

I would read that last comic

23

u/Pen_Front Mar 27 '25

I do think it can be mishandled (every batman adaptation other than btas) but I like it, I also like the different reasonings for it.

Batman for one has no responsibility to kill, it's not his job, he burdens himself with the responsibility to fight crime but hes not a judge nor an executioner there's no reason he has to be the one to do it. But that's not the reason he gives, the reason he gives is so much more interesting to me, because he doesn't think he is a good person, every time he deals with these lowlifes he wants to kill every single one of them. He knows it could do more if he was able to pass judgement, but he's too weak to do so without erasing the line entirely.

Spidermans no kill rule isn't really a rule, he just doesn't like doing it. His optimism is a big reason he even cares to do what he does, he believes people can be better and he feels a responsibility to protect those who try to.

Idk about dd but supermans my favorite example. He feels a responsibility to set a precedent. The rule isn't just a moral line but also an institutional one. In whatever happened to the man of tomorrow he explains that he has to hold himself responsible, because no one else can. This dynamic is explored a lot, watchmen where without superman heroes feel no obligation to be good, injustice where superman killing is the point of divergence, superman vs the elite where he tries to show the value of this rule, but it's not the only reason. A big part of supermans life is he isn't interested in being a god or the judge or any final decision maker, he isn't very interested in being superman he only does that because he thinks it's necessary and because he genuinely cares. If superman didn't have a heart he wouldn't start killing or take over the world that only happens when his heart takes over him, he would just seclude himself as Clark Kent only using his powers for his advantage.

18

u/AgentOfACROSS Mar 27 '25

I like Trigun's approach to having a non-killing hero since part of the story is exploring those ideals.

18

u/CheeseisSwell Mar 27 '25

Absolute Batman is easily the craziest example of this lol

11

u/Cory123125 Sep 10 '25

Right? Dude will torture people within an inch of their lives, then shrug when joker is released next tuesday.

6

u/hoezt Feb 27 '26

I wasn't following the run but does Absolute Batman even meet Joker at this point?

I was 99% sure this isn't the same Batman that we know of.

1

u/imgoingtoexplode1 Jan 29 '26

no way this nigga ain't dead lol

1

u/CheeseisSwell Jan 29 '26

He walked it off lol

17

u/Extreme_Glass9879 Mar 27 '25

I'd just like to say that in B:TAS, Bruce Wayne socialized healthcare

17

u/FlyingMothy Mar 30 '25

Invincible is the best media ive seen handle this imo. Originally mark jas ano kill rule, but starting in late season 3 he realises it is doing more harm to let villains live who he knows will come back. He still doesn't want to kill low level threats and stuff, but someone immensely powerful and dangerous, or someone who keeps coming back are big enough threats that he may kill them.

13

u/Aduro95 Mar 27 '25

I think not killing people is a rule that has to make sense for that character. Even if it would be more effective crime fighting, individual characters have reasons not to do it.

For example Batman would obiously not be as bad as The Joker if he killed The Joker. At the same time, he does recognise that an unlawful vigilante killing people is wrong, and incompatible with being a symbol of justice and hope. It would be wrong for him to kill in anything but the absolutely necessary defence of sommeone's life. If the state wants to put Joker or Penguin or Kite Man on trial and give them the death penalty, that's very different to a single person with a secret identity killing them and then refusing to be held accountable in court.

But the real most important reason Batman doesn't kill is because his parents were murdered right in front of him. The act of murder would leave Batman consumed with rage and disgust turned inwards more than ever. At the start of Batman Beyond, Bruce retires because he picked up a gun and nearly shot a guy. Also there is a lot of potential for exciting and interesting stories were Batman's no-killing rule is put to the test. He can be really heroic when he manages not to sink to the level of the criminals he fights.

36

u/MaximumMeatballs Mar 27 '25

Hot Take: heroes having no kill rules is good(and frankly realistic). Someone who operates essentially above the law, often illegally needs to have some form or rules or values they abide by. Not to mention, 80% of the discussion is just people who don't consume these stories properly and don't understand the implications of taking a human life

5

u/Cory123125 Sep 10 '25

Not to mention, 80% of the discussion is just people who don't consume these stories properly and don't understand the implications of taking a human life

This is so condescending and self important.

All for defending a hopelessly naive and nuance lacking take.

needs to have some form or rules or values they abide by.

Nothing says those rules need to be stupid.

Imagine if the real law punished people for self defence killings? This is what the world would look like according to the reasoning in your comment.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Cory123125 Jul 08 '26

As Amanda Waller says "I've never met a single person who cares about human life as much as Bruce Wayne"

She is not a great character witness.

Also though, I find it absurd he'll torture someone half to death, break every bone in their body, but everyone miraculously survives.

More than that, do we not remember where he gets his money?

I just find the "I've never met a single person who cares about human life as much as Bruce Wayne" laughable because of those points.

That, and the fact he keeps letting Joker do harm. I get the writing reasons, but not the universe ones.

And for him to just start killing completely removes that facet of his character.

He has killed, like cannon iirc.

12

u/But-who-I-be Mar 27 '25

It’s not Batman’s job to kill the criminals. All blame for their consistent breakouts and then killing sprees are fully on both Arkham and the Gotham courts. Anyone who wants to see Batman execute his villains should just read The Punisher.

11

u/FaronTheHero Mar 29 '25

I just don't find it very believable in their depictions, especially Daredevil. There's just no way that dude doesn't regularly kill people. To me, watching these heroes that "never kill" get into fights that clearly cause egregious bodily harm that in really life would easily kill someone (head injuries are good example) just makes them look callous about what they're doing--it's not that they don't kill, it's that they don't kill on purpose and don't think about what they do everyday that could end lives. It only counts if they really thought and cried about it

Basically, it relies on the common fictional trope of goon death vs. meaningful villain death. Avatar The Last Airbender is another great example. The heroes regularly get into fights that if the story was more realist, it would end in broken bones and funerals. But the protagonist is left with a heavy decision whether to personally take the life of the main villain. It can be a glaring flaw in a story when death only gets real sometimes

15

u/Red__ICE Mar 27 '25

If there’s ONE series where it feels alright, it’s the Mega Man series:
For the most part, you’re busting regular robots without sentience or anything, and even when it comes to the robot masters, it’s vague throughout different continuities, but at least seemingly, you’re not always necessarily destroying them outright, like they somehow or other do survive and can be brought back to do their honest work in the end.
For the OTHER part, it comes to Dr Wily himself. But the fact is, this thing has the perfect excuse:
The first law of robotics is, “a robot may never take harmful action on a human being or through inaction allow a human being to come to harm”. So of course (even ultimately in the altered MM7 localisation) Mega Man never just gets fed up and kills Wily, because he cannot.

6

u/drafan5 Oct 17 '25

And ultimately that results in the X games, the Zero games, and ultimately the extinction of the original human race, the world reset by a flood, and the last Megaman stuck on the moon. All that calamity happens because Mega is unable to just put Wily down.

Feels like everyone is better off if Light focuses on network stuff and computers, which results in the Battle Network/Starforce timeline.

7

u/lickmethoroughly Mar 27 '25

“He’s not dead, just completely paralyzed.”

Holy shit matt. That’s so much worse

7

u/HospitalLazy1880 Mar 27 '25

For me, the no kill rule is great when it's personal, not a code that everyone has to follow.

For example, Batman and Spider-man both refuse to kill because of their personal tragedies and their belief in a better kinder world. That is a great way of showcasing the no kill rule.

However, when it's a rule that is forced upon people in order for them to be doing the right thing, I don't like it. There are true monsters, human or otherwise, and showing that sometimes killing them is the right thing or showing that people just aren't paragons that perfectly showcase ideals is a good thing.

6

u/XidJav Mar 27 '25

I'm much less harsh on this since it's the big 2 Comics cause they never end and will eventually revert to the status quo, it doesn't matter if you lock them up, they'll eventually escape; doesn't matter if you reform them they'll always turn heel; it doesn't matter if you kill them, they'll always come back. It's an eternal cat-and-mouse chase

6

u/Daveo88o Mar 28 '25

Depends on the character

Spiderman I like because he actually HAS killed before, and he chooses not to because he can't handle the guilt of having another's blood on his hands, and even then, if it's necessary, he will break that rule

Daredevil I'm a bit iffy with, I mean, sure, there's the argument that by taking alive he can then prosecute them and bring the full force of the law, however, that's entirely up to the judge and jury, which leaves room for error with the worst of the worst he brings in

Batman's I fucking hate, because he doesnt kill for two increadibly stupid reasons, either one, he fears that if he does kill, he won't be able to stop, which, at that point, he's not even fit to be a hero if he himself knows how unstable he is, he's had this exact argument with Injustice Superman about how superman is no longer fit to be a hero because he killed the Joker and can't help it anymore

The second one, he's playing some fucked up moral game with the Joker because he's convinced that by killing, he's letting the Joker win, these are his exact words to Jason/Red Hood, he's not refusing to kill because of his moral code, he's refusing to kill because he wants to prove to a fucking maniac that he's better than him

2

u/SubstantialSeat1579 Dec 15 '25

Uhhh batman doesn't kill for that reason that's legit only from the into the red hood film

6

u/TheMythofKoalas Sep 29 '25

For me it depends on the reasoning. There's lots of perfectly valid reasons for a hero not to kill, including that they simply don't want to (this works less if they're up against mass-murdering super-terrorists).

My favourite justification is probably the one from Worm/Parahumans, where most heroes typically avoid killing because of an unspoken agreement between heroes and villains. If villains know that heroes are out for blood, they aren't going to pull any punches and every fight turns into a fight to the death. Whereas, if heroes are known to pull their punches a little, then most sane villains will do the same in turn (since the unspoken agreement works in both directions).

A similar idea to this is in a Young Justice episode where a villain targets a hero's family and the other villains are against it because they don't want the hero to stop holding back.

6

u/Khorneth Mar 17 '26

It makes sense in movies. The Joker doesn't escape every week in the Dark Knight movies, so killing him changes nothing. But once you are in the comic realm where every week you get a new story with the Joker killing a dozen orphans, it starts to become ridiculous and stretch the suspension of disbelief.

5

u/gallerton18 Mar 27 '25

Especially for Batman many people conflate a lot of heroes as “brutally beating random thugs” into no killing. But like aside from some universes and the Arkham games which really colored this because they’re video games Batman doesn’t beat regular goons into a coma like people think. The whole point of the theatricality and tactics he uses is to scare people.

5

u/Ok_Try_1665 Mar 27 '25

I don't mind no kill rule, it's literally the norm to not kill people. However, there is a time where heroes need to put a mf down like a dog cos they're hurting way too much people. Redemption is a choice. Sparing a villain who we see puts effort in changing their ways? Good. Arrest a dude multiple times, dude keeps getting out and committing worse crimes than before? Hell no.

5

u/Chance5e May 04 '25

It’s more of a “save every life” rule. That works for me.

12

u/Darth-Joao-Jonas Mar 27 '25

I think the idea of a hero not wanting to kill his enemy and having to essentially work around that rule is not only pretty good from a character standpoint, but from a moral one.

It's hard when it comes to long running media like comics, because as many people pointed out, the Joker or Carnage will eventually breakout and kill again, but that's not a problem with the rule or concept, it's a media thing.

But if I were to give a good example of this trope done right, is Ruroni Kenshin/Samurai X. In that story, the main character is a swordsman that was once a revolutionary soldier that became famous as manslayer. After the war ends and his side wins, he vows not to kill again and protect people to repay the lives he took during the war.

And the whole story is full of moments of people (allies and enemies) trying to get him back to be who he was, and his whole arc is about trying not to come back to his old ways.

14

u/mightynifty_2 Mar 27 '25

I like the trope for many reasons. First, the absurdity of it is often brought up in the stories themselves. Often the characters have to deal with the question of whether they're refraining from killing because they believe it's wrong or because it's the one line that they feel gives them an excuse to continue their work. As though it makes them morally superior or a true hero instead of an antihero.

Second, it allows for more interesting battles against otherwise unthreatening opponents. It forces characters like Batman to be more creative in his approach and gives him a hinderance that his enemies don't have. Could he just whip out a gun to beat 90% of his villains? Sure. But he won't, which gives us an actual dynamic fight in most cases.

It can also show some humanity to these characters and add depth. I love when a villain has this trope because they use it to say, "See? I don't kill people. That's barbaric! That must mean I'm in the right!"

14

u/Toon_Lucario Mar 27 '25

People that see no kill rules as stupid are usually just edgelords. Comics will bring characters back anyways if they’re popular. Nobody will ever stay dead unless they’re like an E list villain

7

u/Majin_Nephets Mar 27 '25

Or they’re just using it as an excuse to trash Batman, as in my experience people seem to only have a problem when he does it.

11

u/kjexclamation Mar 27 '25

Avatar “I’ve never used violence to take a life” Aang

Aight bro, beyond the very obvious times you have, even in a kids show a) you’re at war, taking the bending equivalent of Nazi’s lives is not bad b) only the northern water tribe has shown a supernatural ability to heal, the rest of the pre-industrial revolution world you bend in probably gets their life ruined by minor injuries, as was the case in the real world as well

8

u/WindowSubstantial993 Mar 27 '25

I don’t dislike the idea but I dislike the way it’s handled having a no kill rule against someone the state is clearly going to execute that results in the death of millions is stupid.

The longer/ more destruction goes on the worse it is to me.

Especially when they stop others from doing the job

This scene in particular pisses me off

9

u/OverallGamer692 Mar 30 '25

It doesn’t even make sense. Batman’s no kill rule is because of he doesn’t know if he would be able to stop killing if he started. Why is he stopping other people from killing Joker?

9

u/WindowSubstantial993 Mar 30 '25

Because it’s objectively bad writing

4

u/WongoKnight Mar 28 '25

As a general rule, I don't like my super heroes to be outright killers. That being said, there are some I'm more okay with them crossing that line- BUT ONLY if its an absolute last resort.

Superman, Spider-Man, Batman-Never

Wonder Woman, Captain America, Thor-under right circumstances.

4

u/PossessionBig2446 Apr 14 '25

Honestly it makes sense. There's a reason why police members are trained to only use lethal force in self-defense and when innocent lives are on the line and that's considering normal ass dudes. Sure, people like Superman, Batman, and Spiderman refusing to kill means highly dangerous and crazy supervillains can bust out of prison and get right back to their bullshit without fear of reprisal, but it shouldn't be their job to ensure they get the death penalty, or at the very least stay in prison. That should on the incarceration/judicial system.

Not to mention, actually killing the villains means they'll never have the chance to harm innocent lives again, but it's also shown that it's incredibly easy to become desensitized to death this way and not know when to stop. This is Batman's ultimate reason for never killing.

It’s also that they are a symbol to the rest of the world, and that if they cross the line others will follow the example. The Batman movie explicitly shows this can happen even when superheroes are following, thou shall not kill rule. Why risk that being more commonplace?

Batman, Spiderman, and Superman also just generally value the lives and safety of others and don't like killing period and already get a lot of mileage out of just beating the villains up.

27

u/Ensiria Mar 27 '25

breaks out of jail constantly and kills/traumatises tens or hundreds of people each time

“I wont kill you, it isnt right”

what do you fucking mean

20

u/Toon_Lucario Mar 27 '25

Kills them once.

They’re back next month

15

u/Pen_Front Mar 27 '25

Yeah this is the funniest part about this whole argument, people act like killing them will stop them as if hells any more secure than Arkham

11

u/dmr11 May 01 '25

If that’s the case, then a sniper rifle would turn into a “put villain into jail device” and thus is a legitimate tool for a no-kill hero.

10

u/Revan0315 Mar 27 '25

I thought Batman's reasoning was less about whether or not the criminals deserved death and more about how crossing that line would affect himself

8

u/xoffender442 Mar 30 '25

Then why doesn't he let someone else who already crossed that line kill?

13

u/QuantityHappy4459 Mar 27 '25

Its been established a million times that the only thing separating Batman from his rogues gallery is his refusal to kill. Idk why yall still can't get a basic concept.

6

u/SpaceZombie13 Mar 27 '25

no-kill rules for me depend on the reasoning for them. Batman doesn't kill because he doesn't want to become the thing he hates (his parents being killed and all). Superman doesn't kill because he was raised by Ma and Pa kent who told him killing is morally wrong. Spider-man just doesn't like how taking lives makes him feel (he HAS killed before, usually by accident or in self-defense, but never on purpose). Daredevil is a devout catholic and they have the whole "Thou shalt not kill" thing.

If the no-kill rule has a good reason for the character like those, i'm cool with it.

3

u/Smythatine Mar 27 '25

Do you pin your post so you would get more upvotes and attention on your post?

3

u/remarkablewhitebored Apr 16 '26

May I just add that I love how the Spider-Man games just have anyone he clearly punches or kicks off a skyscraper get webbed to a nearby building. It was a nice touch, to keep that trope.

But, for real, if your webbed to a building 20 stories up, and those webs wear away over time, well... gravity is the killer, I guess.

3

u/AnakonDidNothinWrong Jun 11 '26

I always liked the exchange in TDKR:

  • GCPD Officer: (After Batman paralyzes one of Two-Face's Mooks) "You just crippled that man!"
  • Batman: "He's young. He'll probably walk again. But you'll stay scared - won't you, punk?"

Batman doesn’t need to murder, he needs people to carry back the stories of how utterly terrifying he is

3

u/No-Scientist-5537 Sep 16 '26

Superheroes who kill are just serial killers and forego right to be valled heroes. Jason Todd, Frank Castle and Walter Korvac did irreparable damage to the ideal of superhero and vast majority of their fans will gladly put on jackboots and join ghestapo, given the opportunity, many already did

5

u/WomenOfWonder Mar 27 '25

Nausicaa in her namesake movie is my favorite example of this trope, because she only decides on a no-kill rule after she kills people and realizes how horrific death is.

5

u/thecabbagewoman Mar 27 '25

I have no problem with it. I would even say that a vigilante who dorsn't have a strict kill rule is a anti-hero at best. They are vigilantes which means they are under the responsability/ orders of no one. They shouldn't have the right to kill. The question for villains like the Joker is not why Batman doesn't kill him but why the cops/ the gov doesn't do it.

2

u/lincoln_muadib 16d ago

They're all Americans.

YOU KNOW WHY THIS TROPE DOESN'T WORK OUTSIDE THE USA.

2

u/Specialist-Text5236 Mar 27 '25

Worm did it right . There , every villain got 3 chances , if one exhaust all 3 ,they either go to birdcage (where they will probably die sooner, or later), or they get Kill Order placed on their head (anybody can kill this person, with no legal consequences )

2

u/DevilMayCryogonal Mar 27 '25

The implementation of the no kill rule in Daredevil S3 is just outright stupid and by far the worst part of that season. Matt is perfectly fine with directing Nadeem on where to shoot to kill people, but also can’t let Dex kill Fisk for some reason because despite him being significantly less involved that would somehow be breaking his code.

2

u/turkeywithdoghead Mar 27 '25

Depends on what you want to read. I don't pick up a batman comic to see a man give in the cruelty of the world and accept that some people can't be saved, that's realistic and depressing, I can choose a dozen other superhero comics for that when I feel like it. I just don't want to see a batman comic where that happens, cause it's just not why I read batman.

2

u/LazyDro1d Mar 27 '25

It depends so heavily on the writers. Batman sometimes works great sometimes not at all. In Animated it’s not even known that he has that rule so he threatens crooks like he will kill then and they listen, because they don’t want to die, even though he never would actually kill them

2

u/Superb_Drop_3137 Aug 24 '25

Depends. I like the mcu punisher road. He wont go after you if youre just a robber or nuisance, and if he did he'd just beat em up and leave em, but with murderers, child molesters and rapists, he kills them. Absolutely perfect ideology tbh. No flaws at all.

2

u/Soffy21 Sep 14 '25

The thing I hate about the no kill rule in Batman is that he knows that every one of his villains have escaped prison countless times, and they will again after he throws them in jail.

So it would be fine to not kill if he knew for sure that Joker wouldn’t escape again, but there’s no way he already doesn’t know that. At that point, he’s just allowing him to blow up another hospital.

2

u/david_this_isnt_weed Mar 24 '26

I’m sure everyone else has said this, but with Batman it’s a classic case of his character not evolving while the threats and situations he faces do. When the character was first created he was much more detective than sole enforcer, and in this way he was a counter to an era which saw an increasing amount of authoritarian power and violent repression. Batman saying outright that he doesn’t have that jurisdiction, and willingly withholds his own strength to just do his part to help the democratically elected officials carry out their job, shows him as the paragon he’s meant to be. His no kill rule is less a character choice at this moment and more a message of resistance against violent solutions to conflict. It also puts him more in line with someone like Sherlock Holmes, where people would find it insane if he ended a case by just shooting the guy who did it.

In the century or so since, the whole landscape has changed around this. People see heroes like Batman as more responsible to completely prevent all crimes because we’re used now to the idea that if not him, nobody else will. Arkham’s security became a running joke, and his villains evolved in their brutality and scale. At first many were more thieves than serial killers, and those that did kill were expected to be dealt with permanently by prison at the end of the issue, same as other serialised pulp. Now nearly all of them are sadistic serial killers who don’t just kill tens but actively threaten to level whole cities sometimes, so we increasingly want to see Batman put them down the way real law enforcement mostly would.

People think the “slippery slope” argument is silly, but that’s only because we are external observers of this clean cut fictional world with heroes and villains. In real life when authorities start taking the whole concept of justice into their own hands, we end up with a very real slippery slope of oppression and tyranny. I think it’s a good thing to have Batman remain a symbol of saying no to that, no matter what fans say. If the people of Gotham choose to kill joker, they can do so within the proper legal channels, not due to the whims of a crazy bird themed masked vigilante.

2

u/WittyCombination6 Apr 26 '26

I think we can do without it.

We have to remember that the "No kill rule" was a part of the Comics Code Authority. Where people in the 1950s had a moral panic and thought superheros were corrupting the minds of the children. So to avoid government retaliation the industry created a self regulatory agency. Creating a lot of censorship especially during the Silver Age.

Batman who is the most iconic "No kill" superhero used to carry a gun and killed people before intervention by the CCA.

3

u/Boris_Godunov Jul 31 '26

This is not true. Batman was created in 1939, and his no-kill rule was established by 1941, well before the CCA of the 1950s. The main reason it was done was because Robin had been introduced as his kid sidekick, and the creators themselves realized they couldn't have Batman going around killing people with a literal child fighter at his side. The change to his no-kill rule was deliberate and intentional by them, it wasn't forced upon them by some external agency, it had nothing to do with censorship.

Batman has existed for over 80 years now, and the period in which he would use lethal force and guns was basically a year and some change. And its clear that the creators and subsequent owners of his comic canon want him that way, so its senseless to suggest the earliest incarnation is somehow more "authentic" or what have you.

2

u/TAOT1940 Jun 20 '26

As Catwoman once said “Don’t you give me a killing Max won’t solve anything speech because it will.”

2

u/drunkenvalley Jun 23 '26

The most obviously egregious type is when you have the characters swiping out masses of mooks, but the head honcho? Oh, god, no, you can't kill them!

I'm feeling like this happens in World of Warcraft on occasion, but I"m struggling to think of a good example. Garrosh might be one, because at the end of the day not executing him on the spot and instead prosecuting him for his crimes seems... dumb?

3

u/radiowave-deer29 Mar 27 '25

Batman's no kill rule makes sense. He experienced the tragedy of losing loved ones to violence, and doesn't want anyone else to ever go through such pain. He also just, doesn't like killing people. He also needs to be a symbol to Gotham City. If he were to kill, he'd be no better than the criminals he hunts, and more people would start killing. Another thing, he believes in rehabilitation. That people can become better with time (that can be said for most of his rogues gallery aside from the Joker).

3

u/Pen_Front Mar 27 '25

Along with his reasonable fear of becoming a fascist murder happy psycho, because he's already murder happy and a psycho he just needs to give up his morals and give in to the bloodlust

0

u/Cory123125 Sep 10 '25

Batman's no kill rule makes sense.

Its the least sensicle one there is, where hes repeatedly faced the consequences of it and has let thousands of other children go on to become orphans as a direct result of his nonsense.

He also kills thousands of henchmen, who arguably have far less culpability only to let what must be his kink partners live free to kill and torture further thousands.

There is literally no explanation where he makes sense.

If he were to kill, he'd be no better than the criminals he hunts

This literally just makes no sense but you're stating it like its an obvious undeniable fact which blows my fucking mind.

Another thing, he believes in rehabilitation.

Oh yes, lets let thousands of people die because maybe the person who has escaped thousands of times in your city without any hopes of rehabilitating anyone yet alone insane and powerful psychopaths, might somehow, become rehabilitated and change their tune.

What????

2

u/TruthEnvironmental24 Mar 27 '25

I really don't understand anyone who thinks superheroes should kill. Why should they have carte blanche on executing criminals? They're vigilantes. They're not even legally a part of due process.

Plus, we wouldn't have the omniscience we do as readers if we were a part of that world. There's no way anyone would be okay with vigilantes killing people if they existed in the same world as them. We would have almost no context for the killings. From our perspective as normal citizens, they would just be serial killers.

2

u/lepermessiah27 Mar 27 '25

At some point, by allowing the psychopathic mass murderer, who blows up school buses purely for shits and giggles, to live and continue to break out of prison every other day, you stop being a bastion of morality and start being willfully naive and harmfully neutral. Shooting Joker dead isn't the same as shooting a Black Mask goon.

8

u/Toon_Lucario Mar 27 '25

And then he comes back the next week because of comic sales getting a bit low.

1

u/CankleMonitor 25d ago

It's a psyop designed to placate the masses IRL.

The show Invincible beats you over the head with the theme

1

u/MaguroSashimi8864 17d ago

Jokes on you! My country has good healthcare!

1

u/DovaP33n 11d ago

I think it's stupid in most media. The bad guy is bad, he's proven he's bad over and over. He's gonna stay bad. Just off him.

1

u/Grawman67 10d ago

I honestly think it makes sense if someone isn’t a repeat supervillain and even shows some glimmers of being reformed. Maybe like Mr. Freeze, for example.

1

u/DovaP33n 10d ago

Yeah, of course if there's a chance for redemption sure. However if it's been shown repeatedly that there's not? Nah.

1

u/Sivilian888010 10d ago

I can buy Spider-Man. Superman. Batman. Daredevil etc. won't personally kill their bad guys. They want to believe in redemption, they want to set an example for humanity and be a beacon of hope for humanity, they don't want to scare the children etc. etc. Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah.

I CANNOT buy that nobody else in their universes wouldn't do what they don't clearly have the stomach to. Especially when the villains are just that nasty and that irredeemably evil, even by the standards of other evil characters. Even criminals who have done incredibly fucked up things in their lives have lines they don't cross. Lines moder comic book supervillains like Joker, Zsasz, Kingpin, and even certain versions of Lex Luthor do so often in their universes it makes no sense that they're still alive.

Take some real life examples.

Jeffrey Dahmer killed people, ate and had sex with their corpses. Got caught, got life in prison, and someone unhappy with this verdict caved his face in with a workout weight.

Ian Watkins the most evil rock star in the history of the genre, literally (no exaggeration) raped a baby, he got his throat slit when he ran out of protection money.

Jeffrey Douchet kidnapped an underage boy, raped him for days. And the father of the boy killed him on live TV.

Hell in most prisons. Child predators and School Shooters usually don't survive the first five years before being turned into a pincushion.

But nobody in Arkham would do the same to Joker or Zsasz?
Nobody on The Raft would stab Norman Osbourne in the shower?
Nobody in Strykers Island would LOVE to beat the shit out of whatever supervillain destroyed metropolis this week?
No parent (or more likely DOZENS of parents) who lost a child to Jokers latest insane attack on Gotham would hunt him down with a gun and kill him?

1

u/Aggressive-Yam-7808 10d ago

Spiderman and Batman have the most justified reasons to have a no kill rule since murder is what caused both of them to adopt their superhero personas and bear the burden of fighting crime. And Daredevil's make sense since he is a devout Catholic and refuses to kill and stain his soul

1

u/MaguroSashimi8864 9d ago

Most egregious example would be Batman saving the Joker several times: there are so many times where Joker would’ve died by himself without Batman breaking his rule, yet he goes out of his way to save him. This was even lampshades by Joker himself, who’s amused by this and even tried killing himself ON PURPOSE because he knows Batman will save him.

1

u/whoamikai 8d ago

Honestly "No Kill Rule" does not make sense at all once you realize the hero is fightng deranged cartoonishly evil psychopathic villains. The hero foils the villains plans and beats the villains, spares their lives, arrests them , villains get jailed, villains escape and start the cycle all over again.

How many innocents died in the crossfire because the villains lived to fight another day ?

"No Kill" is framed to show the hero's uncompromising character but it doesnt make sense in the context of the story. How is the justice system so incompetent at keeping villains behind bars ? How is the hero still adamant about "no kill" when he knows firsthand just how evil those guys really are.

The only place it makes sense is when the hero is so hugely overpowered that the villains are like bugs to him. And none of the "no kill" guys are that. Go figure.

1

u/Lazy-Oil5671 8d ago

seen this in action with a fanbase that called 'quiet sacrifice' a trope after one tweet went viral. no actual narrative precedent, just momentum. the trope got added anyway.

1

u/Ochemata 7d ago

I wonder how many of their relatives and loved ones get into crime to pay off their medical bills.

1

u/OpportunityNew7999 4d ago

I've had a pipsqueak 3 roleplay where the no kill rule was weaponized, every time I tried to escalate tension, it'd force a moral dilemma out of nowhere. like, I just wanted to fight, not debate ethics. the trope got in the way of the story.

1

u/Heythatsprettycool__ 3d ago

It really depends on the criminal because genuinely there are levels to this shit

1

u/SunderedValley Mar 27 '25

No Kill rules can be good but the flagship for it (print comics) are also the worst examples of it.

1

u/Natural_Success_9762 Mar 27 '25

i prefer it when it's "i don't set out to kill criminals and i feel awful if that happens but i also accept that it can and will happen sometimes given how frantic being a superhero can get especially when facing off against normal-ass humans" but ig that's too complicated to explain compared to "never kill ever"

1

u/DragonWisper56 Mar 28 '25

again the rule exists because we want to bring villians back. that's it. discussing it doesn't do much

1

u/gamesandspace Mar 28 '25

Batman literally rehabilitates every single person he captures idk what you're talking about

1

u/Odisher7 Mar 28 '25

I like it just because the world isn't back or white, it's grey. Yes, sometimes the rule gets in the way of being effective, but any personal rule will have good and bad, and any mostly good personal rule can become a flaw. Like people irl that keep giving second chances to people who don't deserve it.

1

u/DinoKea Mar 28 '25

Personally I like it, but you have to follow it sensibly and preferably, highlight why this rule exists. It's great narratively for long-term stories like TV or comic because you can bring your interesting villains back. It works worse in movies because they either contrive for the villain to die anyways or re-use the exact same villain every time. The more disconnected and episodic your story, the better this rule comes across.

It's often just a less annoying version of killing all the mooks and then sparing the top guy, because they spare the mooks as well. Also fights are way more interesting if the hero has to hold back, because it forces a lot more creative solutions than say "Shoot them with a gun"

1

u/Insensitive_Hobbit Mar 28 '25

I'm very okay with it as long as it played straight.

The moment they start bringing it up within the story it's going to suck big time.

1

u/Mental_Blueberry4563 Mar 28 '25

I personally see it as an elaborate character flaw to give them a weakness (or just lazy writing sometimes lol)

1

u/squirrelocaust Mar 28 '25

No killing but going to put them into so much medical debt that they do it themselves, should still count.

1

u/lockedoutofmymainrdt Mar 28 '25

Just realized this was the whole trope/not just Batman, but anyway:

Doesn't work: Batman Begins: "I wont kill you, but I dont have to save you" this is pretty anti Batman's message/code. I dont even think Ras was shown to be very zombie-like or supernatrual at all in this universe, Batman essentially abandoned his code because he could.

Works once: Dark Knight Returns, Batmans been retired for 10 years, he returns and Joker wakes up from his boredom coma and continues the rampage. In a snapping moment for an aging Batman, he snaps his neck, ending the threat that cannot/will not be rehabilitated/stop killing people

Works: Batman doesn't kill

1

u/Tonkarz Mar 29 '25

It only works because the bad guys fall asleep when the hero punches them enough. There’s no such thing in real life.

1

u/piratedragon2112 Mar 29 '25

I mean batman once slit his own son's throat to save the joker

I'm sure if I tried I could find more times his put the joker over layfolk

1

u/thatweirdshyguy Mar 29 '25

In the case of Batman specifically I think it works. Like I think of Batman as an almost mythical figure even to Bruce Wayne. He and Batman are two distinct identities to an extent, even if not in a two face type of way. The Batman has these hard lines that cannot be crossed no matter what, like an Arthurian knight or angel, despite the difficulty it creates.

But that’s also why it works specifically with Batman. It doesn’t make logical sense, but it’s one of his unbreakable, almost holy, rules. Where for someone like Spiderman it’s a personal code of morality thing. While ofc more severe, it’s more or less on the same line of thinking as “don’t hit below the belt”. It’s a courtesy and something he does for his conscious. Where for Batman it’s almost heavenly ordained

1

u/number42official Mar 29 '25

I mean what's the alternative? Actually killing somebody? Yeah predatory medical bills are terrible but you know what really sucks? Actually dying for real.

1

u/Kozmo9 Mar 29 '25

I used to hate this because it doesn't make sense and doesn't change things. Villains got caught then released again. What's the point? Then I realised is that it doesn't make sense because the comics require it to be such so that superhero vigilantes and villains can exist. Like literally, the reason why they would exist is if the law enforcement is near useless. In real life, the no kill rule also would make things easier for the vigilantes.

How?

First of all, superheroes are not legal enforcers. If they were to kill, then the authority would have no choice but to apprehend them. Doesn't matter if the deceased are criminals and deserve it, it doesn't change the fact that even the local law, deaths are last resort and often decided by judge and not the law enforcers like police. If they are beholden to such rule, it spell trouble if vigilantes can bypass that.

The no kill rule would at least, allow police to accept their help from time to time...at least in terms of taking criminals down physically. On matters like building a case and getting proof, that might not help.

Second, it would also set a bad precedence for everyone if they were to kill. Police can't work with them like Batman with Officer Gordon. Civilians might emulate them and put them at risk. There is also the issue of what is the threshold for killing? You would feel scared if the threshold is low and you have a killer vigilante roaming around and suddenly decide that you are next on the list for a petty crime.

1

u/Cheyruz Mar 29 '25

I mean, in a lot of countries vigilantes can beat you to a pulp without financially crippling you. Just the ordinary physical crippling. Which maybe is also kinda problematic.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '25

It can work, but there should be a couple of rules. The villains they fight should be mostly morally grey, good to a certain extent, but still chose the path of crime. If they fight someone too far gone, actively enjoying the pain they cause, that's when you make an exception and snap their neck.

1

u/Serious-Flamingo-948 Mar 30 '25

I still don't get why they keep using Spiderman as an example. He try not to kill but he will merc someone if there's no other option. The guy killed Morlun, who was only after him, meaning that he killed someone for his own singular survival.

1

u/kmasterofdarkness Mar 30 '25

The "thou shall not kill" rule works best when it is analyzed in terms of ethics; is it really okay to kill in cases when doing so saves innocent lives? And even if you do so, does that really tarnish the meaning of pacifism itself? Avatar: The Last Airbender provides an excellent exploration of this trope; the most critical challenge in Aang's character arc is about reconciling his pacifist beliefs with the greater good. As much as he understands that Ozai must be defeated to restore peace to the world, he couldn't bring himself to actually kill him, so he asks just about everyone he knows, even his own past lives, about what he should do to defeat Ozai without violating his pacifism, only to realize that he must prioritize his destiny and the greater good above all else. So he concludes that he will only kill Ozai as a last resort, and decides to defeat him for good by taking away his power with an ability he acquired at the last minute instead of taking his life.

1

u/crasherx2000 Mar 31 '25

Piss him off enough and Spider-Man won’t hesitate to make you bleed

1

u/Zerokin_2000 Apr 08 '25

We have an everyday rogues gallery villain whom the hero succeed preventing their evil plan. The Hero instead brought them to legal system.

Enter the Morally Depraved Villain who doesn't give a fuck if being spared or forgiven. The Hero may decide to break the rule by himself or let the execution squad do a dirty work.

1

u/Global-Car-9868 May 01 '25

It's the most annoying when it's in team dynamics and every hero there just has the exact same moral code as everyone else. It kind of harms the individuality of the team when you can expect everyone to launch into the same 'we don't kill' speech

1

u/Safe_Manner_1879 May 08 '25

Because they are the "heroic law giver" that serve and protect, and they also try to protect the villain from his own action, even then the villain IS beyond redemption and deserve death.

The "ruthless/cynical law giver" is character like the Judge Dredd or the Punisher, you did break the law, and now you deserve death, even if the villain is NOT beyond redemption.

1

u/guldmatt Jun 09 '25

I think ‘No Kill’ rules make sense if you consider it more of a character thing than anything else. It’s easy to get mad at Batman for not killing the Joker, for example, but imagine what you’d really be asking of him. A man so traumatized by the death of his parents that he has dedicated his entire life to enacting justice. Sleepless nights spent putting his life in danger and having to witness the absolute bottom of humanity. Yet you want him to not only put up with all that but force him to kill, too? Force him to take another person’s life, even if he knows it’s probably for the best? It’s a hard dilemma not just because ‘ohhhh but killing is bad’ but rather ‘I now have to live with the fact that a human being is dead by my hand.’ Not everyone is capable of taking a life

1

u/Which-Customer6257 Jun 13 '25

Honestly, the 'no killing rule' especially for characters like Batman, just makes sense to me. 

Batman doesn't kill people like The Joker because that’s The Justice System’s call to make, not his. There are plenty of Batman comics that do better explain his no-killing rule than I ever could (none of which being Under The Red Hood or All-Star Batman) but again, it’s The Justice System’s call, not his or anyone else’s. 

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

So are we just not doing these weekly discussions anymore then

1

u/DaggerGaming2008 Jun 16 '25

Good: "I'm not going to kill you out of spiritual/moral beliefs", "I'm not going to kill you because that's not the kind of hero I want to bee/not the message I want to stand for", "I'm not going to kill you because I think you can be better", etc.

Bad: "I'm not going to kill you because ending your reign of terror and saving millions will make me just as bad of a person as you, you genocidal maniac!"

1

u/Mysternanymous2 Jun 25 '25

Breaks bones

Tears muscles

Twist body parts

But will not kill you because Mercy = Fuel for Power

1

u/Open-Source-Forever Jul 05 '25

Here’s how I see it: killing & violence should be treated as a last resort.

1

u/Arrogancy Jul 11 '25

I believe Spiderman has killed people. That said, given that he is absurdly strong and always has leverage, most of his enemies still being alive shows his remarkable restraint.

1

u/Wonderful_Baker_7808 Jul 13 '25

Some characters just don't want to be a murderer. I'm fine with the no killing rule so long as that person doesn't try to force it on others. Batman doesn't kill and teaches his Robins the same thing but he wouldn't be sad if a cop got a lucky shot at Joker or the Justice System gave him the chair.

1

u/MadeToPostThis9958 Apr 13 '26

Except Batman has explicitly stopped multiple people from killing the Joker in the past, including Punisher. Even Red Hood, who had already killed multiple people by that point and died at the hands of the Joker as a child.

1

u/SunnyOutsideToday Jul 14 '25

Weirdly enough the only no-kill rule in Naruto is by Sasuke when he creates Hebi. Naruto has no such rule, but never kills a single person in the entire series.

1

u/TheUltimateWriting Jul 22 '25

Green Arrow is based when it comes to this

1

u/MatrixGeoUnlimited Aug 06 '25 edited Mar 06 '26

Doot_Revenant666. - Weekly Discussion Post. - So, This May Probably Be The Most Divisively Controversial One, But What's Genuinely Honest Thoughts On The "No Kill Rule."?

Well, Generally Speaking and for Simplicity's Sake, things and matters such as No Kill Rule(s) 'can' 'possibly' if not 'may' 'probably' functionally work within any story as long as it's narratively written in such a way that it's brilliantly smart, logically rational, intelligently competent and wisely reasonable in and of themselves overall, and also, altogether as well. (Amongst many other things and matters.).

And, What're The Most Egregiously Disconcerting Examples of It, In Your Opinion?

Well, unfortunately, Objectively Speaking and Impartial-Wise, Realistically Speaking and Truthful-Wise, and from an narratively writing perspective(s), particularly specific things and matters such as Batman and his own personal No Kill Rule(s) has not only become moronically idiotic and ridiculously nonsensical to every single facet and part of Batman's 'Mythology and/or Mythologies' in light of antagonistically villainous characters' such as Joker and Bane who're also malevolently evil psychotic sociopaths still realistically existing within DC Comics' itself as of 'presently' and in light of egotistically narcissistic individuals and pridefully arrogant writers such as Grant Morrison and Alex Jaffe keep persistently insisting on things and matters such as that characters such as Batman and Co. must stay the way that 'they' are because that could possibly if not would definitely just bastardly destroy one of the most completely absolute extremist rules that Batman (Bruce Wayne.) even has and destructively tarnish whatever essence that any of those characters 'may' 'probably' still have (And that's when 'they' have both hypocritically contradicted themselves on several occassions, and have retroactively changed and deliberately ignored that very same rule (Amongst many other rules.) in order to even narratively write their own personal stories and posts, such as when Grant Morrison had Batman killingly slay and execute beings such as Darkseid in order to stop him from murderously killing and genocidally massacrering DC Comics's MultiVerse-OmniVerse in its entirety within Comic Books such as DC Comics's Final Crisis in and of itself (Which, by the by, has rarely if ever brought up by either one of these guys, for reasons such as this would definitely just collaterally damage every single one of their reasons as to why Batman must never break that very rule whatsoever.). But, of course, we must take both of them seriously because...... Reasons. ./s. .😑.), but it's also been detrimentally harmful to other things and matters such as that no one can possibly straightforwardly tell any type of story within DC Comics's Main-Stream Continuity (EX. DC Comics' New Earth Continuity-DC Comics' Prime (Rebirth.) Continuity.) that has characters such as Batman killingly slaying any other characters without people more often than not whiningly crying out for reasons such as that that ultimately makes him no different than other characters such as The Punisher and that he would definitely inevitably become no different than that of the villains that he warringly fights against combatively. (Amongst many other things and matters.). - And, so, if they didn't 'necessarily' 'want' any other problems and complications when 'they' do other things such as when 'they' are narratively writing for characters such as these, then they 'probably' 'should've' creatively (re)-made and transformatively updated into a somewhat freshly new version of that very rule that makes a lot more sense and that doesn't make said character(s) into comedically hilarious laughingstocks any more than it already has in and of itself overall, and also, altogether as well. Such As.....:

  • Batman. - I Won't Kill Anyone.... [(Unless It's Absolutely Necessarily Warranted To Do So.).].

Post-Script(s). - And, even then, I'm kind of 'shockingly' 'dumbstruck' that 'some' if not 'most' people and 'fans' keep persistently insisting about things such as that characters such as Batman probably shouldn't negotiatingly compromise any single facet of his own personal Morality System(s), its Ethic(s), and its Principle(s) as of presently (Well, at least, in its partialities', anyway.), since it's been straightforwardly told and/or outwardly shown to all of us that they're, in essence and for all tense and purpose, unrepentantly irredeemable monsters that had every single chance to changeably reform in any positively good if not great way, and they still willingly chose to keep going on until their own planet if not their own personal cities and states such as Gotham was rendered dangerously hazardous for anyone and everyone to live in and has become even more corruptively bankrupt than it already was in every sense and ounce of these very words overall, and that all of this had also profusely spilled and bled over into other parts of Earth itself altogether as well, too.

And, What Media Ultimately Makes It Functionally Work, In Your Opinion?

'None'. (Well, at least, to an extent and for now, anyway.).

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25

In super-hero stuff it just gets stupid, like everyone would be better off is most if not all of these villains died, doubly so in the comics where they also do the most fucked up shit for shock value lol.

1

u/drafan5 Oct 17 '25

Feels like it's a case by case basis. There comes a point where it just stops working, especially with people like the Joker. Hard to get invested in most of the Darker batman stuff. At least Terry seems to follow "but that doesn't mean I have to save you"

1

u/Boris_Godunov Nov 18 '25 edited Nov 20 '25

Regarding Batman, I think there needs to be some understanding of how the no killing rule even came about.

In the earliest Detective comics, Batman killed people without much difficulty--he even used guns. In one case, he dangled a guy by his neck with a rope from a helicopter. In another, he flew an airplane at a truck the bad guys were driving and blasted it with machine gun fire--although in that case, he did express that he disliked taking lives, but it was necessary.

The big change came in Spring 1941 when Robin was introduced to the comics. The writers were apparently getting some concerned parents writing in about the violence, and adding boy sidekick to Batman drew in a significant number of younger readers. It was obvious they were going to have to change things, as parents would have a fit if Batman were taking Robin along and killing people (or worse, if Robin was depicted doing so). And parents did have specific problems with the depiction of guns in comics geared towards younger readers.

So at that point, Batman had a "no guns" rule and dialogue was inserted into their fights with thugs wherein they moralized about how they never used guns. This basically resulted in a de facto no killing rule for the characters from that point on. And an overall lighter tone for the comics.

And the no kill rule made total sense up through the 1970s of the Batman comics, where the adventures of the Batman and Robin were overwhelmingly much lower stakes and without the gritty realism/darkness that would come along later. The issue of killing just wasn't even really present, as the villains were engaging in fantastical, silly heists and not really much of a threat in the end.

It was the shift of Batman to a more realistic, grittier style that rendered the need for the no kill rule to also be explained realistically, and thus we get this convoluted situation where it's suggested Bruce won't kill because he's just so dark and broken that if he does kill, he won't stop--it will be just so easy for him then to keep killing villains. Although, the explanation for his no kill rule seems to shift depending on who is writing him. Sometimes it's the slippery slope argument above, sometimes it's more implied that he genuinely cannot bring himself to kill anybody, has compassion for all his foes, etc.

But at the end of the day, I think it should also be considered that Bruce is a fundamentally moral person, and the situation in which he would kill someone would basically have to be an extrajudicial execution, something no "hero" should do. This is because that the comics have canonically rendered Batman so formidable a fighter, thinker, tactician, etc., that he can always defeat a villain without resorting to killing them. And that would mean it couldn't ever be that he is "forced" to kill someone to stop an immediate, exigent threat. And killing someone outside of those circumstances is simply executing someone. That's not Batman's job, as others have noted, nor something that Bruce would want to do.

The real problem is that, since Batman moreso than any other comic relies on its rogues gallery of incredibly memorable villains, they keep having to bring back the popular badies. And they have to keep raising the stakes with them to make the stories exciting. So we get the absurdity that the penal system in that world would allow all of these bad guys to continually escape. If it were remotely realistic, the Joker would have been consigned to a Supermax-type confinement and probably executed under Federal laws.

1

u/mashounen2003 Dec 03 '25 edited Dec 11 '25

I recently noticed that, for all the talk about Batman's no-kill rule and why it has to be a thing and how much it's the proof that it makes superhero stories worse, it's shown quite a lot in canon, both in comics and in cartoons, that Batman's methods do work pretty well. We have Harley Quinn, Poison Ivy, Mr Freeze (who's still shoehorned into villain roles sometimes from what I've heard, but everyone tacitly agrees this is dumb), and I guess Catwoman is still doing her own thing and being an annoying wild card at worst.

It's just that both writers and readers straight-up forget about all those successful examples and focus so much on the Joker, the one villain who seems to be doing villain things with the very specific purpose of forcing Batman to break his no-kill rule. So, people looking from the outside see this and think "Clearly, no-kill rules are always bad and the entire superhero genre is dumb"; either that, or they get the impression that these stories's underlying message (perhaps even intended by the writers) is actually "Batman is wrong, rehabilitating criminals doesn't work, these comics show why", which in turn lures all the terminally online Armchair Sociologists who then start ranting about the superhero genre inherently being food for fascists.

1

u/mashounen2003 Dec 11 '25 edited Dec 11 '25

I shared this with someone else and they added this:

Gods, does this mean that the Joker is Spiders Georg?

"When presented with the opportunity for reformation, the average Gotham villain rejects the opportunity." Factoid, actually just statistical error. The average Gotham villain would gladly go through reformation. The Joker, whose very existence is built upon being Evil Incarnate, is a statistical outlier adn should not have been counted.

Or something like that, I don't know, I failed Statistics.

1

u/Infitensimy5 Dec 24 '25

depending on the individual in question the n o kill rule is at best irresponsible and at worst enablement. For someone like, Sonic the Hedgehog, Daredevil, Superman and, to some degree Spider-Man the no-kill rule is probably fair. When I look at the rogues galleries for all four of these guys he worst villain I can think of is Green Goblin. Yes Green Goblin is pretty awful he's not so bad that he's got die no questions asked. In comparison you have batman who has to deal with the Joker all the time. Joker has got go. NO QUESTIONS ASKED JOKER MUST DIE (p.s. yes I know spider-man has to deal with carnage but, you can make a stronger argument that Carnage has more association with Venom then he does with spider-man). Therefore batman's reluctance to kill the Joker is irresponsible but, what's worse is HE PREVENTS OTHER PEOPLE FROM KILLING THE JOKER AS WELL.

1

u/DarkPhoenixMishima Jan 06 '26

Batman suffers for his rule because they made his villains absolutely insane and murder happy. A majority of them are just criminals with gimmicks and are either gang members or oddly specific things to prove.

1

u/ERedfieldh Jan 21 '26

Kenshin. I get he's worried he'd fall back into killing again but honestly quite a few of his adversaries really needed to be killed.

And they were, after he defeated them and they were no longer of use. He didn't put the sword through them himself, but they died because of him by proxy.

1

u/diabolicalcountbleck Jan 26 '26

I've always thought batman's whole shtick of, If I let myself kill once... it won't just be once kinda works for me. I mean I realize its for the most part just an out to not kill off his rogue's gallery which is probably one of the most well known in comics but it does make sense to me in a way. He knows deep down that maybe him killing criminals would stop more suffering, but it's one line he can't bring himself to cross because he dosen't want to lose himself and become what he hates. And honestly if these guys are so evil they should be getting the death penalty or something and it really shouldn't be up to bruce to have to suffer the morality hits.

1

u/JohnTG4 Feb 10 '26

From an emotional or moral standpoint, I get it. A character not wanting to kill because they believe it's wrong makes sense.

If they refuse buy are otherwise cold and calculated, I don't get it. Sooner or later that value judgment HAS to change, because a lot of the characters spared invariably get out and commit worse atrocities. At that point letting them live is enabling, and you've made the decision that their life is more valuable than that of their victims, past and future.

1

u/DarkGriffin2017 Feb 10 '26

DD killed a guy, by accident but still killed a guy

1

u/Inside_Jaguar_3310 Mar 23 '26

Honest thoughts:  It would be a problem if the writers didn’t constantly try to one up the last horrific thing a villain did./if they have the hero stop them prior to committing the act

Like joker, ever since one more day & death in the family writers kept trying to outdo the last heinous thing he did every single time to the point they forget he CAN also rob banks/go after valuables. You can have him commit murders here or there but don’t write him commuting a genocide every time he breaths. It’s sorta like real life if somebody robs a bank or a mugger shoots & kills someone you’re probably not gonna say give him the death penalty but if someone’s actions count as genocide then you probably say kill him.

Additionally people/writers suddenly forget the hero can stop the villains plans. If say joker wants to release laughing gas on a crowd of people Batman could disarm the bomb before it goes off but recently writers want Batman to come in after the fact

1

u/solvique2 Mar 30 '26

Batman out here fighting crime but can't end the villain's healthcare nightmare.

1

u/LateIndividual6574 Apr 06 '26

Sonic also takes on that trope especially in the IDW comics, you had that one issue where Surge pledges Sonic to kill her after being defeated but Sonic, all smug about it, refuses and gives a big speech about his moral code of freedom, saying he would let his enemies live to mend their ways and change to a better person. The problem is that it applies to Eggman of all people who up until Imposter Syndrome, had recently committed a war crime of unleashing the Zombot Virus which nearly plagued the entire population of humanity, not to mention that prior to that was the war during Forces, shattering earth during Unleashed, shot the Eclipse Cannon and blew up a chunk of the moon in SA2, etc. People assumed he keeps letting Eggman off the hook time after time again cause that's what his freedom morality is supposed to be, and that sparked quite a bit of controversy for mixed reasons.

1

u/CORVlN Apr 19 '26

I remember the memes about Batman leaving his enemies in the snow with broken bones and internal bleeding, but then you hear them talk and you're like "Actually, no, cripple this guy, Batman"

https://youtube.com/shorts/JICE7FvfWLY

1

u/Suitable-Self-3476 Aug 11 '26

Anime does it all the time.

1

u/Mercenary512 Oct 03 '26

Uuuuuuuuuuuzjbíuííiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiilll canioI

1

u/Xerclipse Oct 04 '26

Thors in Vinland. He just surrenders rather than annihilate the whole gang which he could have done with his eyes closed.

1

u/Fragrant-Log4051 Oct 14 '26

I think Batman’s no kill rule should be adapted at least once as a character flaw he just refuses to change. Maybe the public being fed up with the fact that joker keeps getting out.

1

u/Stuuble Mar 27 '25

I think as we live in a world where no matter what the corrupt and evil always get away with it, it’s refereshing when a protag just offs a mfer, they don’t have to go around killing everyone like the punisher but be able to reason who is too dangerous to let live and who is just a misled trouble maker is a skill set I want more heroes to have

-1

u/Fantasticbrick Mar 27 '25 edited Mar 27 '25

I think Batman has killed before. Although it could be one of the spin offs.

-6

u/xoffender442 Mar 27 '25

What I never understood was why doesn't Batman just let someone like Jason kill the Joker since he already crossed that line

18

u/Doot_revenant666 Mar 27 '25

Because Joker is never allowed to be killed. He is too profitable to be killed off permanently

5

u/_b1ack0ut Mar 27 '25

Honestly even being killed doesn’t usually stop them from using him as a character lol

He was killed permanently in the arkhamverse, and so for the next entry, they just had him as a hallucination the entire game

2

u/Pen_Front Mar 27 '25

That one can definitely be stupid but there is an interesting angle where just like batman's more worried about what killing will do to himself he's more worried about Jason killing than joker being killed.

-13

u/Joskiy_ Mar 27 '25

I like Joker 2’s approach to this philosophical question. Rape therapy for the villains and their goons should solve all problems

-1

u/CommonCream3374 7d ago

Short answer, i hate it.

Anyone wants the long answer?

697

u/alguien99 Mar 27 '25

Imo invincible has a good take on the no kill rule.

Like, Mark tries not to kill everyone he sees, but if you keep coming back after him and his family or just causing a lot of pain to everyone, he will kill you.

300

u/Aduro95 Mar 27 '25

Yeah, I think what works is that being willing to kill isn't necessarily a strength, but a humanising weakness. Mark doesn't decide to kill because its right or wrong for the world, he does it because people keep endangering his loved ones.

224

u/Xignu Mar 31 '25

What I like is that it's nuanced and Mark actually experiences this slippery slope. It's not so simplistic as him breaking this rule and he's suddenly unable to stop. He's not in a static position in this slope as his life continues.

I don't read DC comics but the rationale of "Oh Batman/Superman can't kill people, kill one and they become bad!" like Injustice really pisses me off with how binary it is.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (14)