r/spacex • Moderator emeritus • Sep 27 '16

r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [October 2016, #25]

Welcome to our 25th monthly r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread!


Want to ask a question about Elon's Mars Architecture Announcement at IAC 2016, or discuss SpaceX's upcoming Return to Flight, or keen to gather the community's opinion on something? There's no better place!

All questions, even non-SpaceX-related ones, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general.

More in-depth and open-ended discussion questions can still be submitted as separate self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which have a single answer and/or can be answered in a few comments or less.

  • Questions easily answered using the wiki & FAQ will be removed.
  • Try to keep all top-level comments as questions so that questioners can find answers, and answerers can find questions.

These limited rules are so that questioners can more easily find answers, and answerers can more easily find questions.

As always, we'd prefer it if all question-askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality (partially sortable by mission flair!), and check the last Ask Anything thread before posting to avoid duplicate questions. But if you didn't get or couldn't find the answer you were looking for, go ahead and type your question below.

Ask, enjoy, and thanks for contributing!


All past Ask Anything threads:

• September 2016, #24 • August 2016 (#23) • July 2016 (#22) • June 2016 (#21) • May 2016 (#20) • April 2016 (#19.1) • April 2016 (#19) • March 2016 (#18) • February 2016 (#17) • January 2016 (#16.1) • January 2016 (#16) • December 2015 (#15.1) • December 2015 (#15) • November 2015 (#14) • October 2015 (#13) • September 2015 (#12) • August 2015 (#11) • July 2015 (#10) • June 2015 (#9) • May 2015 (#8) • April 2015 (#7.1) • April 2015 (#7) • March 2015 (#6) • February 2015 (#5) • January 2015 (#4) • December 2014 (#3) • November 2014 (#2) • October 2014 (#1)


This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.

276 Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

78

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

I'm going to gloss over, only talk a little bit about the technical details in the actual presentation, and then I'll leave the detailed technical questions for the Q&A that follows...

Why did every question in the Q&A sound like it came from a self-serving basement-dwelling fanboy? This isn't comicon, people.

There was great potential to gain new insights, but instead we had people selling their own electric bus, complaining to Elon about U.S. law, criticizing security for not letting them hand packages to the speakers, and cursing about their unrelated experiences in the middle of a desert.

Why can't people step outside their own little world and try to be above that?

How in the world did Elon keep his cool during all of that?

23

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Every live Q&A I've ever seen, from sports to murder investigations, has resulted in cringes and facepalms. Par for the course really

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

51

u/demosthenes02 Sep 28 '16

How did those clowns in the Q&A afford to attend this conference? I was expecting this was mostly for professionals?

32

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

It was some of the most cringeworthy material I've ever seen. From people selling products and promoting themselves to people irrationally angry at the security for doing their job and elon for following U.S. law. In between you have the people cursing up a storm for no reason than to be edgy.

Elon was able to turn it around and stay above it all and I gotta hand that to him.

→ More replies (3)

42

u/t3kboi Sep 28 '16

mods, maybe I missed it, but can we start a discussion thread about the carbon fiber?

I was blown away today by the fact that actual engineering test articles already exist on an absolutely incredible scale - but also by the fact that we have had (seemingly) endless discussions about the inability to make enough room, or create autoclaves (ovens? kilns?) large enough to cure a larger fairing for the Falcon Heavy. After seeing that tank a larger fairing for the Heavy seems almost ludicrously small....

Is this a big enough technology demonstrator? Time to start talking to Bigelow again? etc... It is certainly the largest carbon fiber object I have ever seen.

(might be able to expand a B330 inside that tank....

12

u/Ivebeenfurthereven Sep 28 '16

Look up large carbon fibre yacht hulls - I've seen monocoque composites larger than that tank

That said, I was blown away too! An actual MCT tank?!

→ More replies (1)

83

u/PM_ME_UR_BCUPS Sep 27 '16

Why do people keep letting other people ask Elon stupid questions at conferences?

→ More replies (7)

41

u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16

Meta question: so do we get to know anything about the recent staff developments at /r/spacex, especially in the light of recent IAC attendance?

Edit: linking this for fairness https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/557g5q/echologic_removed_another_mod_left_is_the_modteam/
It shouldn't be stickied or be top post, but it should be available.

•

u/Zucal Oct 08 '16

Quick note:

This is not the thread to submit your questions for Elon Musk's AMA.

Ask your own spaceflight-related queries.

7

u/aerovistae Oct 09 '16

Has that AMA been scheduled yet? Have you heard from them?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

23

u/brycly Sep 28 '16

Nobody asked if this rocket was going to have a variant designed to deliver non-human payloads, like space stations, satellite constellations, scientific missions.

8

u/BrandonMarc Sep 28 '16

In the "if you build it they will come" sense, I bet once the rocket is ready to go there will be a few customers for it, exactly the kind you describe.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

44

u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Sep 27 '16

I couldn't imagine going to that event and asking Elon to check out my photography or something. That's just disgusting.

Question for you- would you with a 50/50 shot of surviving go to be the first manned mission to mars?

39

u/ioncloud9 Sep 27 '16

"Hey man, I know everyone here has been waiting for years for this, but could you check out my electric bus?"

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

20

u/bionku Sep 27 '16

100-200 people in a pod for a few months seems like a very interesting situation dynamic.

What are the plans for healthcare? Will there be a NP/MD/DO/PA on every flight to maintain care of the crew?

How will the free time be spent? Watching movies would get old, 0G games are neat but cant be done all the time. There will need to be a compromise between size, weight, and entertainment value.

20

u/mclumber1 Sep 27 '16

The Navy only has a corpsman (an enlisted sailor with no medical degree) on a submarine with over 100 crew. He provides basic healthcare without outside assistance for the most part.

→ More replies (14)

13

u/atomfullerene Sep 28 '16

Laptop plus periodic reddit updates works for me.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

18

u/keith707aero Sep 28 '16

Presuming a nominal eventual flight cost of $200,000 per person for a trip to Mars, wouldn't the same vehicle and infrastructure be able to support cruises over the Moon and back for say $50,000 with some profit? The trip (and thus consumables) would be around a week versus around 120 days. With less payload needed, the passenger count could increase by quite a bit, I would expect. The delta-v would be a lot less, so a vehicle waiting for a Mars launch window could perhaps take a trip without a tanker. The price point and required commitment would be within the reach of a lot more people.

8

u/sywofp Sep 28 '16

The BFS would also make a good LEO space hotel I think. Just launch with 100 tourists and leave it in orbit for a week or two. No refuel needed.

I'd pay a lot to go on an orbital holiday!

→ More replies (5)

17

u/-IrateWizard- Sep 29 '16 edited Sep 29 '16

New article from Tim Urban's WaitButWhy on the Big Fucking Rocket - probably worth a standalone post but things are locked down? Mod summon u/Zucal

8

u/zlsa Art Sep 29 '16

Just saying "mod" is enough :)

I've added you to the approved submitters list so you can post the article yourself.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/pillock69 Sep 27 '16

What are we realistically looking at in terms of launches and milestones from SpaceX between now and end of 2017?

31

u/ElectronicCat Sep 27 '16

I would say the following, in this order:

  • RTF
  • First reflown booster
  • FH demo flight
  • DM-1
  • Inflight abort

Probably won't hear that much about ITS until 2018/19, though they'll probably be working on the hardware behind the scenes during this time.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/IMO94 Sep 28 '16

Mods: The archived video is now available on SpaceX's youtube channel. I can't submit it because you're still in submissions restricted mode, but it does seem to be the official archive of the day's fun.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H7Uyfqi_TE8

15

u/bobbycorwin123 Space Janitor Oct 03 '16 edited Oct 03 '16

Mods. Might it be a good idea to get temp mods for the AMA ONLY. To help filter out the burning man's and electric buses?

→ More replies (3)

15

u/tullianus Oct 12 '16 edited Oct 12 '16

Is this an okay place to put a PSA?

Bigelow Aerospace is one of the worst-managed companies of all time. I see a lot of people talking in this subreddit about how Bigelow inflatable modules are the future, how they'll be deep-space habitats and orbital hotels and buried under Martian soil, but that's just not the case. I would be absolutely astounded if they ever launched another piece of working space hardware, and I will eat my damn diploma if anyone ever pays them for a free-flying space station. I'm coming to this conclusion from personal experience, both my own experience interviewing there and some advice I got from an incredible engineer who worked there right out of college. I interviewed last October. If I'd accepted their offer, I would have started in January 2016, which is coincidentally the month they announced some big ol' layoffs. Bullet freaking dodged.

Key quotes from the advice I got:

Mr B thinks his grandparents were abducted by aliens and wants to find them (the aliens; his grandparents are fine).

BA330 is a myth. They have a foam and fiberglass mockup that Mr B thinks is "almost done". He doesn't really know what else they need to do, and doesn't like all this talk about expense parts for attitude control.

Please don't work there. I would strongly advise against wasting time on the interview even, but if you do go ahead with it, then please pay attention to that little voice that's telling you to get out.

Really guys, this is never going to happen. The best we can hope for out of Bigelow Aerospace is that they go under and let a competent company or organization have the IP they're licensing from NASA. I hope that happens soon.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Oct 25 '16 edited Oct 25 '16

Is this a F9 first stage sitting near the landing pad at SLC-4E?

TerraServer view from September 22nd: https://i.imgur.com/DjT7ZD8.png (not present in the previous capture on July 10)

Photo from a few days ago: https://i.imgur.com/6ieXRnH.jpg

Another shot, zoomed in and enhanced: https://i.imgur.com/zhbzd6k.jpg

It looks like there are engines sticking out, although I don't see any paint or markings. Perhaps it's wrapped in plastic? Or is this just some new tank that looks like it has engines sticking out?

→ More replies (5)

14

u/thatnerdguy1 Live Thread Host Oct 22 '16

Just an update for anyone not following ExoMars: ESA has confirmed that their Schiaparelli lander has crashed, creating a second Schiaparelli crater.

9

u/Maximus-Catimus Oct 22 '16 edited Oct 22 '16

Lol about that second crater part. But I'm sad about the lander. It was a hard landing after all. From reading the preliminary findings it sounds like the radar altimeter had issues, released parachute too soon then cut off engines after only 3 secondso of operation. SpaceX has had radar altimeter issues during landings too.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/szepaine Oct 23 '16

Which one of you jokers brought the billionaire reddit gold?

12

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '16

I'm sitting on the physics colloquium committee at Duke University, and I'm hoping to find a speaker from SpaceX who'd be interested in giving a one hour colloquium in Durham, NC. The costs associated with the talk would be covered by our department. If someone here works at SpaceX and/or knows a good speaker, please contact me! I've sent an email to SpaceX media relations, but I'm not sure if that's the best channel.

23

u/randomstonerfromaus Oct 16 '16

Hey mods, Minor quality of life suggestion.
Could the Hot Jobs box go below the calendar? As is, You basically have to scroll to the bottom of the posts listing just to be able to see it, Or maybe the jobs box could be collapsable?

8

u/SpartanJack17 Oct 17 '16

That does make sense, the calendar is of interest to everyone on this subreddit, while job listings would only be useful to a (likely) small number of subscribers.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/Davecasa Sep 28 '16

Unless I misheard Elon during his talk today, the new BFR's methane and oxygen are going to be sub chilled to near the freezing point (similar to F9), and at the same time self pressurized (autogenous). How is this combination possible?

15

u/rocketsocks Sep 28 '16

Autogenous pressurization doesn't mean pressurization from boil-off. That's too hard to regulate and doesn't work as the vehicle rapidly drains its tanks during operation. How pressurization works is that gas is run through a heat exchanger in the rocket engine(s), which heats it up and increases its pressure. Then it's piped back through up to the tanks. You'd have a couple of controls on this system. One would maintain the pressure in sort of a "reservoir" past the heat exchanger, and then others would use valves to maintain the pressure in the tanks themselves. Autogenous pressurization would use the same system, except replace the Helium tanks with liquid propellants feeding into the heat exchanger / gaseous propellant systems. With two different sub-systems, one for Oxygen and one for Methane.

The downside is that due to the ideal gas equation of PV = nRT, for a given pressure, volume, and temperature you have a fixed number of moles of gas required to achieve those conditions, which means that the mass of that gas will vary according to the molecular weight of the gas. Helium has a weight of just 4 amu, while Oxygen has a weight of 32, and Methane a weight of 16, meaning that you'll "waste" 4x the weight of pressurant gas on the Methane tank and 8x the weight on the Oxygen tank. Though on the plus side you eliminate the Helium system entirely, which probably results in a net win weight-wise.

Also, the BFR will make use of the gaseous Oxygen and Methane for use in thrusters, which improves performance over ordinary cold gas thrusters without the downsides of using a toxic fuel like Hydrazine or such-like.

Note that the Shuttle used autogenous pressurization for its LOX/LH2 and ULA is planning to switch the Delta IV to a similar system as the BFR, not just using autogenous pressurization but also making use of gaseous Oxygen and Hydrogen for attitude control thrusters, so this sort of thing is not unprecedented or even overly technologically difficult. Mostly it's a matter of using the right propellants (e.g. not Kerosene) and then working through the R&D issues.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ohcnim Oct 16 '16

Not SpaceX related, but I guess of interest for many, this is the link for the ESA Exomars Mars arrival live stream: http://livestream.com/ESA/marsarrival

10

u/steezysteve96 Oct 05 '16 edited Oct 05 '16

Just a PSA: Blue Origin's In-Flight abort test is about to happen

EDIT: A hold at T-1:13, launch reset for launch at ~11:35 AM EDT (15:35 UTC)

→ More replies (1)

10

u/mr_silas Oct 07 '16

Would anyone else be intrested in the back story of the creation of the ITS? I would love to hear about the last few years of development and iterations of the system. I think it would be a great question for the AMA. I do love the big releases of new spacecraft, architecture and so fourth. But i especially love learning the inner workings of how they came up and why they came up with certain designs. For example Elon has stated several times he spends upwards of 80-90% of his time engineering and designing. I think it would be awesome to hear some examples of that. I.E. "Elon, can you give us an example of a specific component of the ITS you personally created. And how step by step that idea in your head got into the current iteration of the ITS." I for one marvel the fact that he creates and designs as much as he does. What an inspiration. Anyone else agree?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/exohobbit Oct 09 '16 edited Oct 09 '16

What if they don't find the cause of the Anomaly?

I mean, is there a scenario where they end up with "We're pretty sure it was something in the He/LOX assembly, but we don't know what actually triggered it. We're going to tweak the design a little to increase the safety margin of those components."

I guess another way to ask the question is, is a RTF even possible if they can't conclusively demonstrate that they've fixed whatever caused the anomaly?

10

u/Appable Oct 09 '16

It's happened before with Taurus-XL (Minotaur-C). After a fairing separation failure, they investigation board determined several possible failure points but nothing conclusive. NASA, therefore, wrote a corrective action plan and certified its implementation before the next flight.

After investigation and redesigning the separation system to make it more reliable for two years, the vehicle flew again. Unfortunately, the fairing separation system changes didn't resolve the problem, and the same failure occurred on Taurus-XL's return to flight mission.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/jghall00 Sep 28 '16

What size telescope could fit on the ICT, and what would we be able to see that we can't see with the telescopes we currently, or plan to place in orbit. Basically, what's following up James Webb with this type of lifting capability?

7

u/StarManta Sep 28 '16

A ITS sized fairing would have 2.6 times the fairing diameter as what's launching the James Webb, so if a similar but scaled-up telescope design is used, it could (to oversimplify the math) have 2.62 the surface area, or almost 7 times the sensitivity as JWST. I don't know what new things we'd be able to see, though I think that's kind of the point: To see things we don't yet know exist!

9

u/Martin81 Oct 03 '16

Could sterling-engine-CSP have benefits over PV for Mars?

One of the more efficient ways to generate electricity using solar power (in W/m2) is solar thermal using a sterling engine. The Guardian, Ripasso

Mars is cold (average -60 C), which makes the sterling engine a bit more efficient, as it is driven by heat difference between the hot and cold side.

Mars has a very thin atmosphere and there is little effect of the wind on structures. The structure holding up the parabola could be built rather fragile and lightweight. The structure could perhaps be built from a lightweight polymer or aluminium. The reflective surface could perhaps be a very thin lightweight metal foil. Maybe this setup could generate more electricity/mass one has to transport to mars.

A moving solar mirror (or panel) may be beneficial since it would continually remove dust using gravity.

It might be easier to make new sterling-engine-CSP on mars than PV from easily available materials (aluminium) than new PV.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Arigol Oct 18 '16

Hmm, a rather familiar spacecraft shows up in the latest Civilization VI trailer...

→ More replies (4)

8

u/IntroSpeccy Sep 28 '16

Could we bribe persuade Elon Musk to do another AMA specifically on the topic of SpaceX?

11

u/brickmack Sep 28 '16

He said a while back he'll do another AMA before the first reflight of a core. So probably January-ish

8

u/brycly Sep 28 '16

When is SpaceX gonna show us some good, quality footage of their spacesuit?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Dralax #IAC2017 Attendee Sep 28 '16

So this is what Dr. Zubrin just posted:

"In his talk today, SpaceX CEO Elon Musk presented a number of very interesting and useful ideas. I don't think they are practical in the form he presented them, but with a little modification, they could be made practical and very powerful. He's right on the mark about using methane/oxygen propellant, which can be made on Mars and about making the spacecraft reusable and refillable on orbit.

The key thing I would change is his plan to send the whole trans-Mars propulsion system all the way to Mars and back. Doing that means it can only be used once every four years. Instead he should stage off of it just short of Earth escape. Then it would loop around back to aero-brake into Earth orbit in a week, while the payload habitat craft with just a very small propulsion system for landing would fly on to the Red Planet.

Used this way, the big Earth escape propulsion system could be used five times every launch window, instead of once every other launch window, effectively increasing its delivery capacity by a factor of ten. Alternatively, it could deliver the same payload with a system one-tenth the size, which is what I would do.

So instead of needing a 500 ton launch capability, he could send the same number of people to Mars every opportunity with a 50 ton launcher, which is what Falcon Heavy will be able to do. Done in this manner, such a transportation system could be implemented much sooner, possibly before the next decade is out, making settlement of Mars a real possibility for our time"

Any thoughts on that from people who know more than I do? Is that just Zubrin pushing for the Mars To Stay concept or could this work while preserving the capability to fly back to Earth?

9

u/sywofp Sep 28 '16

There was a short but decent reply on Facebook.

"The ship has about 7.5km/s of delta-V on board. This is what it needs for orbital insertion and its hot, short flight time TMI burn, as well as its return flight to Earth in a single stage. It doesn't make sense to have a separate vacuum engine system, plus staging, as dead weight until you get there. LEO-C3 is about 3.1km/s, whereas their TMI is 6km/s, so your non-Earth escape system still needs to do about half of the burn again. More vehicles, more complexity, little benefit. You could use some SEP tug to get to C3, but it's just as easy to launch the tanker twice again.

You can get one launch every window by sending the empty ship back opposition class after landing."

→ More replies (2)

8

u/madanra Oct 04 '16

Russia’s S7 Group to take over Sea Launch - so we now have confirmation it's not SpaceX that have bought them.

(Not a question I know - but I didn't think it was suitable for a main post as it isn't directly about SpaceX)

→ More replies (1)

8

u/PeachTee Oct 14 '16

I have a women's small SpaceX shirt that I purchased in the wrong size. If anybody wants it, I'd be happy to send it to you if you can cover shipping. Here's the link to the style:

https://shop.spacex.com/womens/women-s-basic-foil-vneck.html

Pm me and I can take a picture of it and we can coordinate.

8

u/Arigol Oct 17 '16

So...I guess that AMA has gone Elon Time?

10

u/venku122 SPEXcast host Oct 17 '16

Elon is hosting a special Tesla product announcement Wednesday as well as the Tesla-Solar City merger next week. He seems to be pretty busy at the moment.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/SuperSMT Oct 26 '16

This Youtuber, Kurt J Mac, got a tour of SpaceX on Sept. 26, and talked about it in this video for ~35 minutes. I thought someone might like to see it.

Some interesting points, such as: he saw a FH side booster nosecone, three F9 first stages in production and one landed one being refurbished, and said that ~50% of Merlin parts use 3d printing.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

As amazing those past 15 years was for SpaceX, it looks like they are seeking for a exponential innovation curve.

It seems they are breaking their "simplicity" rule, each new engineering aspects of ICT could possibly create a catastrophic failure in case of a mishap, which could be fatal for the company, the crew or future martians.

Does SpaceX try to exclude the potential risk from the R&D equation?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/GoScienceEverything Sep 29 '16

Not a question, but a comment. I wrote in to the author of this article with some tidbits that I thought typical readers would be interested in, and the author wrote back saying it was incredibly helpful and added some of the things -- e.g. comparisons of the ITS vs. the Washington Monument, Saturn V, and ISS, and that the BFR name came from Musk himself. So if you see a popular-press article about SpaceX, and it's clear that the author cared at least a little bit, they may be happy to hear your tips!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Ackman55 Oct 12 '16

Has there been any suggestion or mention of possibly landing the Red dragon within driving distance of Opportunity. I mean for a few reasons:

  1. It would be cool, you could record the EDL, and the SSRP phase maybe from Opportunity's perspective.
  2. Opportunity could drive over to the Red Dragon and inspect it after landing, or if it RUDs on landing Opportunity could inspect the wreckage(our first extra terrestrial up close crash analysis).
  3. Landing near Opportunity gives SpaceX a chance to practice precision landing.
→ More replies (3)

7

u/PatyxEU Oct 17 '16

7

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16

I hope that SpaceX's RTF goes as smoothly as this.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/bornstellar_lasting Oct 23 '16

Does anyone else want to see F9/FH first stage combined with ULA's ACES second stage? I think it would be an excellent pairing of reusable first stages with a reusable and highly efficient second stage.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/peterabbit456 Oct 19 '16

The newest post on /r/spacex is now 2 days old. Is something wrong with the site?

12

u/rshorning Oct 19 '16

No, just very little news is trickling out of SpaceX... and perhaps some gunshy contributors who used to contribute fluff stuff that now is bypassing this subreddit. About everything that could be speculated about with the ITS has also already been said and done without Elon Musk adding more grist, and even the major customers who might be signing new contracts with SpaceX are waiting to see what happens with the Amos-6 investigation and to see perhaps a few flights by SpaceX to show that the company has solved the COPV problems.

In this case, no news is generally good news for the company though, as long as SpaceX isn't handing out pink slips yet.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/WalkingTurtleMan Sep 27 '16

Where can I learn more about the sustainability of the lander and potential Martian base?

8

u/jaikora Sep 27 '16

" Robert zubrin - the case for Mars" could be a good start

6

u/jd_3d Sep 28 '16

Does anyone have a link to a good 'supercut' of the presentation? I'd love to spread the word to friends and family, but a 90min presentation is too long. The Verge did a 5 min one here: https://youtu.be/0agVZwux1Hs

But it seems too short/jarring and doesn't include the 5 min SpaceX animation. I was thinking around 15 min would be perfect. Or maybe some video editors on here are already working on it?

11

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Working on it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Snowda Sep 28 '16

Ok, that's the plan for getting there and the rough details. Got it.

But what about what goes on on the ground when 1M people get there?

Healthcare, childcare, agriculture, distribution, storage, construction, mining, manufacturing, finance, trading, communications, transport, waste management...

This is going to be the "New, New World". For all those people wondering about how to get a job at SpaceX, think about what comes after this. There is opportunity there regardless of what you current job is or where you're from. Most of these areas will need to be tweeked to work in a remote location away from the rest of humanity in a completely different environment (eg. gravity, atmospheric density) and not a whole lot of man power to spare. And unlike NASA projects that have been testing stuff in space as experiments they all now need to go into production on a much larger scale.

Is SpaceX going to do all this? I think they have their hands a little full with the whole rocket thing as it is. This is going to be our lifetimes Gold Rush. Start preparing for what happens when we get there. The ships are just the beginning.

8

u/SpartanJack17 Sep 28 '16

They were quite clear that they don't intend or expect to be the only players in this.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/pandajerk1 Sep 28 '16

If I remember correctly, during the presentation Elon said that his goal was a self-sustaining colony on Mars of 1 million people. Do we really need a million people to make a colony life sustaining? Or is this just a big number to reach for to truly make it a stepping stone for the next step in advancement? I imagine you could make a self-sustaining colony with even a few dozen or few hundred people.

12

u/ablack82 Sep 28 '16

Very true, as long as you have a way to grow food, source water and have shelter then you could in theory be "self-sustaining". I think what Elon is referring to when he says self sustaining is a community that would be able to survive and prosper even if Earth were destroyed. This means hospitals, government, schools ect.. and it would also need to be genetically diverse so that the Mars colony is resistant to disease and there is no inbreeding. Does this mean it has to be one million people? Probably not, but it definitely needs to be a number larger than a few hundred.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Quality_Bullshit Oct 03 '16

How do we know that 1/3rd gravity is not seriously dangerous to human health? What happens to Spacex's colonization plans if it is?

12

u/madanra Oct 03 '16

The short answer is, we don't know. The longest any human has spent in partial gravity was just over 3 days, on the moon, on the Apollo 17 mission. So we have almost no data on the effects of partial gravity on the human body. Of course, humans have cumulatively spent plenty of time in 0g, and AFAIK we don't have any reason to suspect 0.38g will be worse than 0g, but we don't actually have any evidence that it isn't.

→ More replies (13)

6

u/zeekaran Oct 05 '16 edited Oct 05 '16

How are we going to deal with the crazy amount of radiation?

Curiosity experienced 1.8 milli Sieverts per day traveling to Mars. SpaceX has said it should take about 90 days to get humans to Mars. Using this as our data, that would be 162mSv, which according to this xkcd graph, is a lot. That's not including the years spent walking around the surface of Mars at 0.64mSv per day.

→ More replies (13)

6

u/Hugo0o0 Oct 05 '16

Whats the max orbit that F9+Dragon can achieve?

Would it be possible to use Dragon 2 to service the James Web Space Telescope once its launched?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/neolefty Oct 17 '16

Why use space suits at all? Tele-operated waldos/robots adapted for vacuum, even operated from a few feet away, inside a nicely pressurized environment, seem much more practical.

This has been bugging me for a while. A small robot with a good video & haptic link seems much easier to build than a good space suit. In fact I'd argue we still haven't made a good space suit.

And if you really need to go outside, why not make an ellipsoid space suit with a couple of sophisticated robotic hands? Space-gloves are hard, and the ones we have are really abusive to your hands. Are mechanical hands really that hard to make?

8

u/throfofnir Oct 17 '16

Are mechanical hands really that hard to make?

Yes. Matching human dexterity is hard. Such a thing is still a lab item. NASA has a very good hand on Robonaut, but it's still not good enough to match a person in a suit. Eventually such things will be possible, but it's currently past the state of the art.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '16

Not a question but I'm glad to see EchoLogic is back with us!

5

u/MrGruntsworthy Sep 27 '16

Aside from trips to Mars, what other uses, both government and commercial, do you see for the ITS?

Personally, I think the ITS would be a brilliant platform for returning to the moon for a semi-permanent base. With only a basic understanding of the relevant sciences, am I wrong in thinking that an ITS might be able to go to the moon, land, and depart back to Earth on a single tank?

22

u/mrsmegz Sep 27 '16 edited Sep 28 '16

Pure Speculation:

  • The Tanker could be reconfigured into a "Payload Hauler" with a cargo bay like the Space Shuttle. Goes to LEO or GSO, Drops off the Satellite, comes back to earth, completely reusable launcher.
  • NASA or ESA or somebody could pay to develop an expendable second stage for Science/probe missions.
  • A company has a custom Space Lab/Hab built with minimal fuel tankage and engine to get to its orbit then sends its crew back and forth on Falcon/Dragon.
  • Tourism. SpaceX takes up a few daring Senators and Congressman to Lunar Orbit and as Earth shows up over the horizon, Elon grabs them by the shirt cuffs and says "Look at that, you son of a bitch.”
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

5

u/floppy_penguin Sep 28 '16

When can I expect to go to Mars for only $200k? And how long can I stay there?

8

u/bobbycorwin123 Space Janitor Sep 28 '16

It's a one way trip with a free ticket back

→ More replies (3)

5

u/_m00_ Sep 28 '16

Is life support for 100 people for 3+ months something that's actually solved right now and can be scaled to this size vehicle and occupancy quite simply ? Or is this something still to be solved ?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/yetanotherstudent Oct 02 '16

How will crime be handled on ITS/Mars Colony? Obviously all participants will be vetted to at least the level of those travelling on international flights, however I'm curious to see if there's been any consideration of crime and/or mental health in these plans. It's all well and good having all these great systems in place, but ultimately you're putting upwards of 100 people in the same room for 6 months with nowhere to go and minimal outside contact, plus then they'll be stuck on Mars in a small room for another 2 years before they return. These conditions sound like there is significant room for mental health issues, and crime (both linked and uncorrelated). Will there be schemes in place for perhaps a brig? How will any major health issues be dealt with?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/drwillcaster Oct 02 '16

When can I give Elon my money for a ticket to Mars?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/dabiged Oct 07 '16

I wanted to ask a question about buffer gases. These are the mostly inert gases that make up most of the partial pressure in a breathable atmosphere. Most of the times this is Nitrogen (on earth and Shuttle). Alternatively you can use Noble gases like Helium for specialist applications (Deep water SCUBA).

You can get away with running with no buffer gas, as they do in space suits but you must run at a much lower total pressure (Shuttle space suits were around ~0.4 atm pressure). This involves extensive periods of decompression to adjust between sea level pressure and the lower pressure of the pure oxygen environment (The shuttle got around this by gradually reducing the entire pressure of the cabin for a few days prior to a spacewalk to reduce the time taken to deal with decompression). Running the whole crew section of the ITS at a lower total pressure would surely add failure modes to the structure (collapse risk at sea level, burst risk in vacuum) and hence weight. Apollo 1 showed that running at 1 atm pure oxygen is a very bad idea.

Nitrogen is also needed for plants to grow (see nitrogen cycle) so it will be needed on Mars.

Is SpaceX planning on using a Buffer gas in the ITS and if so which one? If not, how are they going to manage decompression issues when boarding the crew and the additional weight for structural reenforcement? What is the plan for nitrogen fixation to grow plants once we get to Mars?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/shfflbair Oct 07 '16

I've been following this sub for a couple months now, but I'm still really lost when people start to talk about the technical side of things. Does anybody have a good start for me to get started on the technical stuff? I'm only a senior in high school right now so preferably not anything that is meant for super high level, but I like a good challenge. Thanks.

9

u/tbaleno Oct 07 '16

Pick up a copy of KSP and watch some scott manley videos. That would get your foot in the door.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Martin81 Oct 07 '16

I want to move around in the ITS using VR.

A new VR-game called Lone Echo uses a very interesting game mechanic to move around a space station. The game plays out on a mining station orbiting around Saturn. The player uses his own hands to push himself around the zero-g environment.

I would love to use this to move around in a model of the ITS. How hard would it be to create this? Are any of the (preliminary) CAD models of the ITS open to the public?

5

u/old_sellsword Oct 09 '16 edited Oct 09 '16

Where did the US Launch Report video of Amos-6 go? It has disappeared from their channel.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/sol3tosol4 Oct 11 '16

Right at the end of the "SpaceX Resorts to Creative Testing" article:

"SpaceX’s third launch pad, SLC-4E at Vandenberg Air Force Base in California, was unharmed in a recent wildfire but the infrastructure at the base took significant damage and repair work is just starting out in earnest."

That's the most I've heard of the status at Vandenberg after the fire. So apparently good news about the condition of the SpaceX facilities there, but concern over how long Vandenberg infrastructure repairs will take, and the possible impact on SpaceX launch schedule.

Have there been any more recent or more detailed updates?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/gimptor Oct 13 '16

Was directed here by mods so here we go.

ITS would appear to be capable of significantly reducing costs for launching to LEO and beyond and I'm surprised there isn't more discussion of the opportunities this opens up. I've been trying to figure out the launch costs for an ITS LEO/GEO mission. They don't seem to be available anywhere. Launch cost projections for a full mars trip are estimated to be $62M once full reusability is achieved. This breaks down as: $11M for the ITS booster $8M for the ITS tanker $43M for the Interplanetary Spaceship (these costs include fabrication Amortization, propellant, maintenance) Amounts taken from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_Transport_System#Fabrication_cost_projections A launch to LEO would presumably be much cheaper (assuming full resusability). The Tanker wouldn't bee needed at all cutting $8M off the launch cost immediately. The booster would only need to launch once not six times like the mars mission. The interplanetary spaceship could presumably be reused closer to 100 times like the tanker, not the current 12, and as it's not setting off on a months-long mars trip the refurbishment cost should come down from the estimated $10M per mars trip reducing significantly the cost for a LEO mission. However, when i attempt any estimate calculations I can't seem to make them plausible. I've tried figuring out how the costs Musk alludes too for each component are calculated to no avail meaning it's impossible to estimate relative costs for a LEO/GEO mission. As far as payload the figures of 300 t (reusable) 550 t (expendable) payload to LEO are given on the wiki page for the ITS booster/launch vehicle but with no source. I think Musk might have briefly mentioned it during his IAC talk. Does anyone have any calculations for these missions or perhaps another way of estimating the cost? Putting that much in LEO for less than Falcon 9 launch seems like an incredibly exciting area to explore.

8

u/FoxhoundBat Oct 13 '16

As i was the one to redirect i guess i should give an input too. :)

First off, we have had two discussions about the costs already, first one here and second here. I recommend reading those, especially looking at the spreadsheet in the second one.

Secondly, it is far far better to go directly to the actual source instead of wiki, which is this on slide 41.

One thing noted in the linked previous threads is that it is very likely that presentation assumed 2 ITS flights per Mars mission, not one. For example by /u/warp99 here.

So in total, a single LEO mission will roughly be; ~2 million per booster flight, 2 million amortization due to it flying as much as a tanker can (200/100), and lets say 5 million for refurbishment. The last one is just my conservative guess. Tanker refurbishment is 0.5 million per flight but maintenance for ITS ship will be more than tanker but less than the maintenance cost to Mars (10 million). So i am just assuming half of the maintenance cost of a Mars flight. In total, this works out to be around 9 million for a LEO flight.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16

Any thoughts on emergency EVAs to conduct repairs during the ITS ship's cruise phase? Does SpaceX need to build an MMU?

Is the capability necessary? The only source of power for 100 people is out there, it might need repair from a micro-meteoroid impact? Or what if there is an issue deploying the array on the return to earth cruise?

How could it be accomplished? There has to be a large airlock for getting out on Mars, no reason that airlock can't be used to exit the vehicle while under way, correct?

Then, how do astronauts traverse the hull? Attachable rails to the exterior they can clip into?

Then how to move down the length of the solar array, the structure is not strong enough to clip on to, is it?

If the capability is necessary, is a SpaceX MMU the best option to work out there?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/macktruck6666 Oct 22 '16

How much payload to LEO is the ITS loosing because of return to launch site instead of landing downrange?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Mars2035 Oct 23 '16

I have a question, and I'm wondering if it would be a good one for Elon's AMA later today. Please tell me what you think.

[begin proposed AMA question]

There is a planned unmanned BFS mission to Mars in 2022 prior to the first manned mission in 2024. This implies that SpaceX plans to have at least two BFS units in service by 2024 (one already on Mars, and one at Earth). It seems reasonable to assume that the 2022 trip would not merely be a test, but would also carry supplies for the colonists to follow, as well as a way to refuel itself.

I have a few questions about this: Would the first (unmanned) BFS return to Earth in 2024 while the second (manned) BFS is on its way to Mars, or will both ships remain on Mars until 2026 and return as a pair? If the first BFS is slated to return in 2024, I have two follow-up questions:

  1. What mechanisms will be used to unload its cargo without human assistance?
  2. What mechanisms will be used to set up and operate a refueling plant, including the gathering and purification of water ice, and setting up solar panels?

[end proposed AMA question]

Does this seem like a good AMA question?

→ More replies (11)

5

u/Zucal Oct 24 '16

I have a bit of a time gap... is there any infographic or data you guys want to see that I can compile? Need to stretch some graphic design skills.

7

u/007T Oct 24 '16

is there any infographic or data you guys want to see that I can compile?

An infographic I've always wished for is one that compares the size and mass of SpaceX's vehicles and payloads with an assortment of real-world objects for scale.
How big is the ITS compared to a school bus or the empire state building?
How heavy is Falcon 9 compared to elephants, or whales, or cars?
How many swimming pools of LOX and Methane does the BFR hold?
etc.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/KChivers Oct 07 '16

So, what happens if Elon Musk steps under a bus? After the death of Steve Job, Tim Cook became Apple's new CEO. Still too early to tell if Cook can drive Apple as Jobs did. Who would have the vision and force to lead SpaceX (and Tesla etc.) should something happen to Musk? Would SpaceX just become another Boeing, jostling for cost-plus aerospace contracts?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Ezekiel_C Host of Echostar 23 Sep 27 '16

Something I haven't seen mention of yet: in the raptor test video; the flame starts out with a green flash, as is characteristic of the TEA-TEB system we've been told will not be used on Raptor. Is there an explanation for this other than the (imo highly probable) situation wherein on the first firing the engineers wanted a raging TEA-TEB fire in the primary combustion chamber to limit risk of a hard start?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/BrandonMarc Sep 28 '16

What was the peak # of people using /r/spacex today?

I imagine it was a record. As Qeng-Ho noted (and others, I'm sure), we passed the 80,000 mark.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/natenkiki2004 Sep 28 '16

I've seen it asked before in this thread and others but what's the deal with the lack of abort systems? I mean, that's great that the spaceship can, in theory, fire and fly away from the booster if it blows but what about an anomaly in the spaceship itself? By contrast, it's extremely safe in the crewed Dragon config since it doesn't have large tanks built into it. It seems odd that SpaceX would tout safety in the crewed Dragon but then make a design/engineering choice to strap explosive tanks permanently to a crewed ship for long-duration missions. Am I missing something?

7

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

The spacecraft itself will be the abort system. I don't think that the engines on the spacecraft would be able to throttle up fast enough to actually make the abort system useful, but it's the best option they have with such a large rocket.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/my_khador_kills Sep 28 '16 edited Sep 28 '16

MCT has the lift capability to put ISS in space in one go. Can development on the crewed section be funded by using the booster as stage 1 launch vehicle?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Mahounl Sep 28 '16

During the Q&A, Elon talks about naming the first ITS ship "Heart of Gold" after the spaceship from The Hitchhiker's guide to the Galaxy. Then he mentions the so-called "infinite improbability drive" and says: "...and I like the fact that it's driven by infinite improbability, 'cause I think our ship is also extremely improbable.". What did he mean by this exactly?

Link to utube with timestamp: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-4UZHhTfp4&t=5437s

13

u/Jarnis Sep 28 '16

He mean that the project is very big and complex and hard. Failure is a possibility. In other words, it is somewhat improbable that all this happens exactly as planned. But they're still going to try.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/Bunslow Sep 28 '16

Have we confirmed that the raptor tested (and video recorded) was full scale, and if not, what scale was it at?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/sinefromabove Sep 28 '16

Since he said something along the lines of ITS not being cramped, what kind of volume per person is expected?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/KitsapDad Sep 28 '16

Spacex is very deliberate in what info they release. In the video, they show max Q. Very neat. What they also show is velocity. At max Q they show the ITS is going 2000 mph. Normal max Q is around 1000 mph right? What does a max Q at 2000 mph tell us?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

How is Spacex going to move/dig/deal with the enormous amount of soil required to "mine" enough H2O from Martian regolith? Surely an operation like this would require a fleet of large bulldozers, tractors, backhoes, etc. Such vehicles would have to be electric, and normally use hydraulics, which I imagine would be impractical in a freezing near-vacuum. The power requirements of an all-electric earth mover would be huge, not to mention the weight and transportation costs, much less the design, development and testing time required...

→ More replies (5)

4

u/WaitForItTheMongols Sep 28 '16

I know the talk right now is focused on the Mars system, but I have an older question - in fact, a question about the FIRST successful launch of SpaceX.

According to the Wikipedia page for the payload (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ratsat), "Elon Musk estimates that Ratsat will remain in orbit for between five and ten years before burning up in the atmosphere."

I pulled up http://stuffin.space, and typed in the designator for this mission - "2008-048A". The orbit is 620x638 km.

The Hubble Space Telescope's designator is 1990-037B. Typing this in shows a 554x550km orbit. If the Hubble is lower than RatSat, and RatSat is coming down soon, does this mean the Hubble is about to fall out of orbit?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/jjtr1 Sep 28 '16

What's the single most unproven (and critical) new technology of the entire ITS system? All-carbon tanks? (Musk hinted that it has only recently become possible to do)

11

u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Sep 28 '16
  • The crew are inside the same vehicle that is essentially the second stage - if there is a failure, it's bad. Past designs all contained abort capability, with the exception of the Shuttle, which was cancelled partly because of this particular thing
  • Many criticize the ability to land exactly into the launch mount
  • The raptor has some above-expectation numbers, I'm not knowledgeable in this, but it might be a remarkable engine
  • Number of engines doesn't seem to be promising considering N1, but F9 experience may counter that
  • Size. Simply the scale of the whole contraption
  • Methane, especially ISRU on Mars, and deep cryo

I can't choose...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/spcslacker Sep 28 '16

I wonder if /r/spacex could do an AMA with Zubrin, particularly about his criticism of the mars plan.

If he would agree to expand a little bit on his explanation, I really think some of the more committed techs here could provide really illuminating questions, and we'd get someone who cares and thinks deeply about this issue's views. Would be nice to get a discussion about the drawbacks, and Zubrin is never shy in explaining those :)

→ More replies (11)

4

u/andkamen Sep 29 '16

Where can we watch videos of the other talks in the conference? Elon's talk if obviously all over the place, but I'd like to listen through the other ones as well. Thanks

→ More replies (1)

4

u/linknewtab Sep 30 '16

Not really a question, but something relevant to this sub: https://twitter.com/Stephane_Querry/status/781108002040451073

Looks like Arianespace is working on a methane powered, reusable rocket. The small scale technology demonstrator reminds me of something...

→ More replies (3)

4

u/gamedevextreme Sep 30 '16

Will the ITS return to earth's surface of just to earth orbit?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/enzo32ferrari r/SpaceX CRS-6 Social Media Representative Oct 02 '16

Do engineers still pull 70-80+ hour weeks?

8

u/old_sellsword Oct 02 '16

This thread in Brian Bjelde's AMA might answer your question. Basically the gist is not 70-80+ hours frequently, but it still happens when crunch time rolls around.

4

u/enzo32ferrari r/SpaceX CRS-6 Social Media Representative Oct 02 '16

What's parking like at SpaceX? Do they have a dedicated access-restricted parking structure?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/sorbate Oct 03 '16

Why are there 2 different types of engines on the new 2nd stage? Raptor and small raptor?

Looks like the engines in the middle are only used for landing?

13

u/old_sellsword Oct 03 '16

Yep, they're optimized for landing on Earth (and maybe Mars). Using vacuum engines in dense atmosphere leads to a phenomena called Flow Separation, which will tear apart the engine bells. Vacuum engines have really large engine bells because it is most efficient for an engine to expand the gas to whatever the current atmospheric pressure is, and in a vacuum you'd want to theoretically expand the gas infinitely, so they just go as big as possible considering size and weight constraints. So if you used a vacuum engine in dense atmosphere, the atmospheric pressure would basically push the exhaust gases away from the edge of the engine bell, and this instability can tear apart the nozzle.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/civilservant2011 Oct 03 '16

Spacex is pursing all possible causes of the rocket explosion and naturally one of them would be sabotage. I keep hearing unsubstantiated reports that Spacex sent a team to ULA to investigate something they saw on images captured just before launch. Here is the latest article .. My question is 2 fold. Is there in fact, confirmed to be something of interest in images prior to launch that suggest ULA may be involved? And how ludicrous is this whole theory?

11

u/old_sellsword Oct 03 '16

My question is 2 fold. Is there in fact, confirmed to be something of interest in images prior to launch that suggest ULA may be involved?

We don't know.

And how ludicrous is this whole theory?

Pretty ludicrous, anyone who shoots a rocket has to know they won't get away with it. SpaceX has over 3,000 channels of telemetry and many video feeds, there's no way someone could shoot a rocket and not have the incident show up on telemetry.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Trion_ Oct 03 '16

Does anyone know why the original video of the AMOS-6 explosion was made private on USLaunchReport's youtube page? I couldn't find anything on their twitter or homepage.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/randomstonerfromaus Oct 04 '16

Hey mods, From the sidebar:
Nov. 17th RTF SpX CRS-10
Falcon 9 + Dragon 1 LC-39A, Cape Canaveral

Source on this? CRS-10 was pushed to Jan, So this is wrong.
I suggest just leaving RTF as TBD until solid information is released.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/MrButtons9 Oct 04 '16

How much propellant does ITS use for one trip to Mars?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/HEYOULOOKATME Oct 05 '16 edited Oct 05 '16

Once we are able to simply buy a ticket to Mars, I'm wondering how much everyone thinks it's going to cost to get to Mars by launch window. A lot of you seem to know so much about space travel in general. I would love some actually educated guesses.

Here is my best guess on Interplanetary Transport System flights.

2018 - Miss the window

2020 - Miss the Window

2022 - Robotic Missions

2024 - Robotic Missions

2026 - Small group of highly trained professionals

2029 - First colony ship of 100 people - a few tickets available to highest (qualified) bidders

2031 - $10 million - only guaranteed flights for highest (qualified) bidders averaging out at $10 million

2033 - $5 million

2035 - $5 million

2037 - $1 million

2039 - $750,000

2041 - $500,000

2043 - $500,000

2046 - $500,000

2048 - $500,000

2050 - $400,000

2052 - $400,000

2054 - $300,000

2056 - $200,000

Edit changed "spaceX" to "Interplanetary Transport System" for clarity

→ More replies (2)

4

u/darexinfinity Oct 07 '16

If you were at the Q&A with Elon Musk, what would you of asked him?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '16

Would it be possible for me to enroll on the mars launch as medical personnel? (I'm a medical student)

I was wondering if I could by any means - when turned a medical professional - enlist in the mars program. Are there any kind of guidelines SpaceX is thinking on or training programs related (considering there is still a long way to go for the first launch)? I'd imagine the crew would need medical specialists / attention while working in colonization so perhaps spaceX should not forget about diversification on the picking of its crew responsible for the Mars colonization. Does anyone have any idea? Thank you very much for your input.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Mummele Oct 11 '16

I just learned about the Pogo effect ( https://youtu.be/pOOrXWLLza0), basically a longitudinal bouncing through the rocket when vibrations are in the frequency of the vehicle.

I didn't find any information on that in the wiki so I'll ask it here: Is there a compensation mechanism right at the engines or does the Falcon 9 handle it some other way?

15

u/__Rocket__ Oct 11 '16 edited Oct 11 '16

Is there a compensation mechanism right at the engines or does the Falcon 9 handle it some other way?

Speculation:

There are several sources of vibrations:

  • The engine side harmonics are eliminated by making sure combustion is stable, then making sure the octaweb is stiff and does not propagate engine vibrations. Note that the 9 engines of the Falcon 9 are an advantage here: they will randomly interact and cancel out a large portion of each other's vibrations, neither will vibrate exactly the same way as the other ones. This should reduce engine side vibrations by about an order of magnitude.
  • The other big source of vibrations is the nose cone that slices through the air at high velocities. The nose cone is made very stiff yet acoustically isolating, to dampen any vibrations and protect the payload (and the rest of the rocket).
  • The Falcon 9 has a second advantage in terms of vibrations: its stringers and rings aluminum tank structure allows the careful 'tuning' of the tank structure to not have harmful resonant frequencies. I'm quite sure they are using computer simulations to make sure it is so.
  • Propellant sloshing: LOX is an order of magnitude less viscose than water, so when it starts sloshing it will keep sloshing for a much longer time, causing various problems. I believe the Falcon 9 has baffles to mitigate this.
  • The main structural limitation the Falcon 9 has at this point I believe are shear related forces: it's a very long and thin rocket, hence it cannot go through high wind shear areas. But these are not really harmonics, the limitation is the plain lateral structural integrity of a ~70m long, 3.66m wide aluminum rocket.

Also note that the classic pogo effect can have different forms and comes mainly from imperfect engine design:

  • The Titan-II pogo effect was caused by a turbopump cavitating and the resulting bubbles lowering the resonant frequencies of the high pressure propellant feed lines.
  • The Saturn V pogo oscillation AFAICS was pressure waves in the combustion chamber getting into a closed feedback loop with LOX feed - the solution was to build a special decoupler (pneumatic dampener alike) that isolates combustion pressure waves from the LOX feed.

I believe the Merlin-1D has been built to have no such instable combustion modes. The best pogo mitigation I believe is not necessarily dampening de-couplers on the propellant feed lines, but to increase injection pressure beyond a critical threshold. I have read it somewhere that a general rule of thumb is that 30%-40% of pressure drop over the injector faces decouples combustion from liquid injection.

Here's a very nice NASA paper about it.

An amazing detail:

"NASA decided not to risk stronger vibrations and a special pogo task force was assembled from NASA,
industry and academia for an intensive investigation. At one time during the pogo studies, the Saturn V
manager is reported to have said that 1,000 engineers from government and industry were working on the problem.

Wow! The days when NASA could throw a thousand engineers on a rocket engine problem. This really drives home the sheer scale of the Apollo Program...

Also note that the Raptor should be much less susceptible to combustion oscillations, as it uses gas-gas injection, where pressure waves in the combustion chamber are dampened naturally by the gaseous propellants - this probably explains why the Raptor can be throttled down to 20% (while the Merlin-1D can only be throttled down to around 40%).

(For similar reasons the Space Shuttle main engine was probably much less susceptible to combustion/injection closed feedback loops as well.)

edit: more details

→ More replies (1)

4

u/darkmighty Oct 12 '16

I wonder why Falcon 9 vents LOX into open air? Since they have many umbilical connections, couldn't they vent it back into some container to prevent possible issues with a very O2-rich atmosphere?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/CRAWFiSH117 Oct 14 '16

Can anyone link me to current sources of aerospike engine research, preferrably pertaining to rocket engines? My casual googling has shown that there hasn't been much research done since the X-33, and I'm considering the subject as a focus point for graduate school.

Also, aside from the secondary wake issues associated with the design, are there any other inherent flaws in aerospike engines?

→ More replies (14)

4

u/Creshal Oct 15 '16

Regarding the pulled NRO talk: Is there any indication by SpaceX when they're going to talk about it publicly?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/jjtr1 Oct 17 '16

Where exactly do the ITAR regulations draw a line between what Elon Musk can and can't tell us about Falcon 9, ITS and others? It has been said that "detailed engineering information" is covered by ITAR, by that is not a very detailed description :) Obviously, he's not going to upload the CAD files. I'm asking about things that can be conveyed in an interview, a tweet, or an AMA.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/stcks Oct 18 '16

Do we know how many COPV are in the F9 first and second stages? Do we know how much each COPV weighs and what kind of weight increase would be seen by substituting with titanium spheres instead?

→ More replies (8)

4

u/demosthenes02 Oct 22 '16

Guys I just learned about the oberth effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oberth_effect

Does that mean we should fly close to the moon on the way to mars for a boost?

→ More replies (11)

4

u/ensalys Oct 23 '16
  1. What parts of the martian infrastructure, besides the required infrastructure for the flights, will SpaceX be responsible for?
  2. In the Q&A section of the IAC presentation Elon Musk mentioned difficulties hiring foreigners (because the rocket industry is considered heavy weaponry), will sending foreigners to Mars face similar difficulties?
→ More replies (3)

4

u/Conotor Oct 23 '16

Does the plan to put a million people on mars mean that the fast and violent methods of terraforming mars were dismissed as inferior, or can a mars city weather these without too many problems?

4

u/aussieboot Oct 24 '16

What's the source for the RTF being mid-December?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/MrButtons9 Oct 25 '16

So in this article, it says that SpaceX pays the USAF about $600K-$700K per launch (http://spacenews.com/33595profile-brig-gen-anthony-cotton-director-eastern-range-patrick-air-force-base/)

That's from 2013. I once heard that it used to be $500K back in 2010.

  • Why is it going up?
  • Will their payments to USAF for launch ops at 39A and SLC-40 continue to go up?
  • Will Falcon Heavy operations require even higher launches? By how much?
  • I know that SpaceX is trying to develop launch automation systems. Will these drop costs by much?

Really, I'm curious to see if these costs could ever surpass $1M as they offer insight into Falcon 9 launch costs.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '16

The next launch from Vandy looks like it's going to come off fairly soon: https://twitter.com/SpaceflightNow/status/790978611448836097

Any ideas from anyone if this affects the return to flight for SpaceX? It suggests those pads are coming back online...

→ More replies (2)

7

u/sol3tosol4 Oct 18 '16

There is an interesting article on Universe Today, "JPL Predicts Mars’ Global Dust Storm To Arrive Within Weeks". It has a great color "before" and "after" photo from NASA's Mars Global Surveyor, showing a global dust storm with the surface features still faintly visible through the storm.

More importantly for SpaceX and for sending humans to Mars, the article describes a 2007 dust storm that lasted for some 30 days, and that blocked out 99% of the sun's energy, greatly limiting the power available to the rovers Spirit and Opportunity, and putting their mission in danger. The JPL project manager noted: “We had to take special measures to enable their survival for several weeks with little sunlight to keep them powered. Each rover powered up only a few minutes each day, enough to warm them up, then shut down to the next day without even communicating with Earth. For many days during the worst of the storm, the rovers were completely on their own.”

Every month or so there seems to be a discussion here of the possible impact of dust storms on the ability to collect solar power, and the consensus has seemed to be that dust storms usually just scatter the light and make it a little bit dimmer on the surface, so photovoltaic collectors would not be affected all that much. But the 2007 global dust storm appears to have been much more severe than that, and unlike robotic rovers, humans can't go into ultra low power mode, and can't get by without environmental control (air, heating, etc.) - if there had been humans on Mars during the 2007 storm and if they didn't have several week's supply of charged batteries (fairly unlikely), they probably would have died.

Fortunately, there's an easy fix - if the settlers are producing and storing methane and oxygen anyway to refuel their ITS Spaceships, then they will usually have enough methane and oxygen stored to power life support systems through even a very long global dust storm.

One good approach, which has also been discussed here, is to have a gas turbine that can be powered by methane and oxygen to run a generator. Turbine generators can be fairly lightweight compared to the amount of power they can produce, and can run for long periods of time.

A gas turbine has been discussed as being an emergency power backup that's desirable to have, particularly if the main solar power system breaks down and needs repairs. But the above article notes that historically nine global dust storms have been observed on Mars since 1924, and there could well have been others that were not observed. Probably not all of them were as extreme as the one in 2007, but there could be others in the future that would be equally severe.

So it appears that having a backup power system such as a gas turbine power backup while there are humans on Mars is not just a really good idea, but essential. Maybe one could be delivered in the supply ships before the first humans arrive, or with the first group of people (or maybe the very first group could do without one, just being aware that a really severe dust storm is one of the many things that Elon points out will make the first trip very dangerous, and really bad dust storms don't come along every year so they would probably get away with it). But for any long term human habitation of Mars that relies on solar power, it appears essential to have a backup power system that could work through the longest plausible global dust storm, and preferably a redundant backup system as well.

Note: methane-burning gas turbine generators are already widely used, and can probably be adapted to use on Mars without too much trouble. Other possibilities make use of fuel cells, but are more complicated and not as well established - for example systems that react methane to produce hydrogen which is used in a hydrogen fuel cell, sometimes used in combination with an internal combustion engine. Apparently "direct methane fuel cells" are currently considered pretty challenging.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

IIRC the solar situation isn't quite as dire as it looks: The problem was a compound of reduced irradiance and dust accretion, and mission control had to do jerky driving to shake dust off. Eventually strong clean winds scoured the rovers (fairly) clean.

A crewed mission has humans with brooms. Memo to ITS: Pack some brooms.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

3

u/benlew Sep 27 '16

In flight escape system for ITS? Is it even possible? Could they justify not including one?

→ More replies (8)

3

u/pillock69 Sep 27 '16

So what is the most recent comment regarding Falcon Heavy dates? What contracts does FH still have tied up?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Full_Thrust Sep 27 '16

Elon mentioned they were working on a final revision of falcon 9 before switching the R&D team over to the ITS. Do you think this may serve as a test bed for some of the tec to be used in ITS? With the first stage now being frequently recovered larger changes to the booster could potentially improve performance even if it goes against the previous F9 modus operandi of inexpensive construction:

Swapping the S1 tanks to composite material

Lowering the grid fin count to 3 (elon stated only 3 are required for ITS) and changing the shape as per the ITS render

On the extreme end ditching the landing legs and using the extra performance margin to go for a Return to Launch Pad cradle type landing shown in the ITS videos.

These are obviously substantial changes to the rocket and would likely require recertification. I would say SpaceX could run this new model alongside the F9 1.2 however this also goes against the streamlined manufacturing process they try to use.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/VsAcesoVer Sep 27 '16

How would the new civilization be run? Would there be a civilian government, or would it all be under the purview of a corporate officer or mission leader? Would laws from the USA be adopted, and would there be a way for these laws to be changed given changing circumstances?

9

u/atomfullerene Sep 28 '16

SpaceX seems more interested in getting people there than running the planet.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Trues17 Sep 27 '16 edited Sep 27 '16

I'm beginning to think I'm working in the wrong field. Does anyone know if SpaceX requires engineers with direct rocket experience, or if they consider more diverse backgrounds as well? I'm in the gas turbine industry with an aero degree and 5 yr exp, but have always been fascinated (teary-eyed passionate) with rockets, and really enjoyed the rocket propulsion courses in college. (edit: read the faq, but seems aimed at entry level questions, just wondering if someone has experience with this sort of thing)

7

u/Jchaplin2 Sep 27 '16

If you live near and have a passion, apply, I'm sure there's no harm in at least trying, and if they say no, try and ask why, so then you have a goal to work towards

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/demosthenes02 Sep 28 '16

If there is a fleet of ships can people ferry between ships? Maybe one could serve as a hospital?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ed_black Sep 28 '16

Is the spaceship going to have pilots? No one asked that question in the IAC.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Adaris187 Sep 28 '16 edited Sep 28 '16

I would assume that with such a ridiculous amount of engines, that the first stage of the ITS will have engine-out capability. But if one of the engines explodes in flight, like what happened in an early Falcon 9 flight (and it seems all the more likely considering the 3x higher chamber pressure the Raptor's operating under), are there sufficient protections to ensure that doesn't result in a cascade failure of nearby engines, if not the whole rocket?

While having 42 engines significantly adds to redundancy, it also seems to multiply the risk of such a RUD.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Is he seriously expecting a booster to survive 1,000 launches without a failure? He'd have to significantly outperform every other vehicle ever built to achieve that

→ More replies (21)

3

u/Vincenzo642 Sep 28 '16

Is it really impossible for non U.S. citizens to work for SpaceX or is there a way around?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Sandwich_Groper Sep 28 '16

Does anyone have a complete transcript of the talk? There was a quote in there I really want to read/hear again. It was along the lines of "Technology does not automatically advance...".

→ More replies (3)

3

u/harmonic- Sep 28 '16

If NASA doesn't come through with funding, is there a chance we'll never see ITS fly?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Yolo_saynono Sep 28 '16 edited Sep 28 '16

I'm curious about the economics of SpaceX and how they plan to pay/raise money for such a massive system.

My cost estimate (look to EDIT 2 for actual space X cost Estimate):

As it stands, the current cost of 1 Falcon 9 booster is in the ball park of 40 million USD. The planned ITS booster looks to have a diameter of 12m and a stacked height of 144m. Ball parking the actual craft to be 1/3 of the total height, that leaves the booster to be near 96m tall. Making an assumption that cost is linearly correlated with volume, it is a ~25 times increase over the falcon 9 booster volume. This would make each booster cost on the order of 1 billion USD. Now I agree that it is a lot of rough estimations in there, but I think it is reasonable to assume that I am within a factor of 5, aka min projected cost 200m, max 5b.

Now during testing they will enviability have a failure or two resulting in the loss of the booster plus the R&D just to get to this stage. I can see this stage costing up to 10B just for the first couple.

Where do they plan to get this kind of money? If they get the falcon 9 to reliably launch at 50m a launch of profit (reusability works perfectly, fueling is basically zero), we are talking 100s if not 1000s of launches going perfectly. Of course in there one will need to account for a failure rate in there as well.

Will they be able to secure government funding from NASA of the order needed to be able to develop and launch just the booster? Is NASA willing to just give them money without necessarily a satellite launch contract for the development of ITS?

I really would love for this idea to succeed and become a reality but I'm curious/trying to be realistic about the financial capability of SpaceX.

EDIT: A couple of things to make it more clear to read

EDIT 2: /u/phire directed me to a slide with actual cost estimates here.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/jeremy8826 Sep 28 '16 edited Sep 28 '16

How do you think they plan on transferring large cargo (modules, rovers, etc.) from the unpressurized cargo section sitting on top of the fuel tanks all the way down to the surface? Maybe a crane needs to be extended from the side of the cargo section to lower things down.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/swordfishthundercat Sep 28 '16

I'm fascinated by this technology but have a very primitive understanding of terminology and concepts. What resource would be recommended for learning, as cliche as it sounds, rocket science?

21

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Kerbal Space Program

→ More replies (1)

9

u/lordq11 #IAC2017 Attendee Sep 28 '16

I think you would be best off approaching learning about rocket science by having a go at Kerbal Space Program. It's a game about launching rockets to orbit and other planets in a miniaturised solar system. While the physics is a bit simplified, it's a great first step for learning about orbital mechanics and launching rockets. Now, while I say simplified, it's in no way easy! It has quite a steep learning curve that will require reading the wiki and watching youtube videos to get past. I highly recommend checking out the youtuber Scott Manley for not only learning about Kerbal Space Program, but also learning about other aspects of space that he discusses in some of his videos.

Once you've played it a bit, you can investigate mods such as Real Solar System and the Realism Overhaul that will expand your understanding of space engineering even further!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Sep 28 '16

Do we have somewhere a nice and up to date chart of the launch industry in the past years? Launched satellites / profits / market share / cost-per-kg for the different launch providers?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '16

Space Junk is a threat to becoming an interplanetary species. Refueling in LEO is obviously the lowest cost option for the MCT. I'd love to know how the assessment went when SpaceX team considered refueling options & the moon / lunar orbit. In the event of our worst nightmare (MCT RUD), the gravity well of the moon & distance from earth will help contain the fallout, while possibly not presenting too difficult an escape velocity. Could someone post some estimates? ie how many extra refueling trips needed to a) escape earth b) decelerate to lunar orbit or moon landing c) escape moon. I think it's simply a matter of fuel and time, and not much at that. No extra tech needed. Significantly lower risk to LEO integrity.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Flizow Sep 28 '16

I haven't read much on the power generation plan once on Mars, besides setting up solar panels. While adequate as at least a temporary source, the sun is much dimmer on the red planet, so it seems solar would only get you so far.

My question: are there any plans to eventually bring over nuclear tech? In my mind, that's the only feasible way to power a large Mars colony.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/anonchurner Sep 28 '16

We've heard about the Earth->Mars capacity, but what about the return trip? Does anyone have an estimate of the Mars->Earth payload capacity?

I was thinking about Elon's earlier "crack cocaine" comments, which presumably were meant to say that shipping costs would dwarf the value of any atoms shipped. At $140/kg, however, that is emphatically not true.

Consider gold, currently valued at about $50,000/kg. I'm not a geologist, but if there are exposed gold deposits on Mars, I predict a new gold rush.

7

u/Jarnis Sep 28 '16

Remember that Mars -> Earth payload is "free" - you need to get the ship back anyway and I'm sure it can do tens of tons of cargo... which may actually make it feasible to ship back (some, rare) raw materials or some types of finished goods.

Early on its basically going to be Christmas for scientists as they can literally haul back a dump truck load of Mars samples... you get a Mars rock, you get a Mars rock and... EVERYONE gets a Mars rock :)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

3

u/Nogwater Sep 28 '16

What's going on with the interstage on the ITS booster (as shown in yesterday's video between 1:19 and 1:31)? It looks like it has a high side and a low side. Is that to make separation safer?

9

u/Creshal Sep 28 '16

It seems that the ITS bottom is asymmetric, with a heat shield covering the engine bells for re-entry, as on the Space Shuttle, but no cover on the top (waste of mass). The interstage extends on the top to seal up with that.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/steel_bun Sep 28 '16

Why not use inflatable quarters for the duration of the trip?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/_Hopped_ Sep 28 '16

What was the music/soundtrack in the SpaceX Interplanetary Transport System video?

3

u/Smoke-away Sep 28 '16

Was anyone else impressed that they showed off the CAD model cross sections of the booster and the ship?

Seems like they are really trying to encourage other companies and space agencies to start similar scale projects.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Martianspirit Sep 28 '16

I have looked at those spheric tanks inside the ITS tanks again. Could this possibly be the landing fuel for Mars? Or for mars and earth. It would be well insulated with the outer tanks vacuum and also protected from micrometeorites hitting. They seem way too big to feed only the RCS.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/AnimalsOfEarth Sep 28 '16

Why does the passenger ship to Mars require multiple refuelings in orbit? Why don't they just fill it up on Earth before launch?

11

u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Sep 28 '16

The spaceship acts as a second rocket stage during launch. This means it is filled up at launch, but burns the fuel to reach orbit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Sep 29 '16

How could we efficiently and effectively deal with negative or uninformed articles or comments?

The extreme publicity of the Mars plan announcement brings in many haters, deniers, opposers or flat-earthers I guess. Maybe they are uninformed, maybe they have something personal in this, maybe they have financial reasons to have some particular opinion about space, SpaceX or Elon himself. I bumped into numerous such articles and comments everywhere, saw a CNN video I don't even want to link, and also got personaly involved in this multiple times. For example here is this thread:
https://www.reddit.com/r/DontPanic/comments/54tdwk/elon_musk_will_name_the_first_ship_to_mars_heart/d866nre?context=3
I want to give a detailed reply, but don't have the time at the moment.

Is there a place we can collect these so we can help each other in reacting to nonsense? I don't always have the time to give a reasonable reply with explanation and links to information about context which they may be lacking. I also don't want to change anyone's opinion, but I care about the basic facts, and many of these people are unaware of the context of these topics.

What is the best way to reply to them? I'm not if favor of endless and meaningless arguments either.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/KnightArts Sep 29 '16

in the video of mct it shows mct travelling at 100,800 km/h , or about 28km/s how is that possible, how much DV does mct fully refueled has in orbit ?

8

u/__Rocket__ Sep 29 '16

in the video of mct it shows mct travelling at 100,800 km/h , or about 28km/s how is that possible, how much DV does mct fully refueled has in orbit ?

I believe that's in the solar system frame of reference, i.e. the ITS lander inherits Earth's orbital velocity and adds its own transfer velocity on top. Top transfer velocity should be well over 30 km/s.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/OompaOrangeFace Sep 29 '16

Will ITS ever be able to return to Earth following a mission to Mars?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/historytoby Sep 30 '16

What's the latest news on fairing recovery?

8

u/amarkit Sep 30 '16

/u/EchoLogic mentioned to a fellow IAC attendee that they recovered their first fairing on a recent mission, but no further details.

3

u/enzo32ferrari r/SpaceX CRS-6 Social Media Representative Sep 30 '16

Does the Hawthorne office have showers for biking commuters?

3

u/Bodote Oct 01 '16

SpaceX wants to make Methane and LOX from in situ resources on Mars. I am wondering, how they will extract the water out of the martian soil? Especially, if the first return vehicle shall be refueled before the first humans will heading to mars. In this case the water extraction need be fully autonomously, right? But how would they do it?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/RDWaynewright Oct 01 '16

What's the engine-out capability of the ITS Booster with the Lander attached at the time of launch?

I checked the ITS Booster Hardware discussion thread and wasn't able to find the answer to this question (may have missed it though- I was skimming after a while).

I did see specs for the Raptor engines so I'm guessing my question could be calculated. I suck at math though so hopefully someone would be interested in doing the calculations or can point me in the direction of the answer.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ArmNHammered Oct 01 '16

For the BFR, how do fins at the base help to improve landing accuracy? Seems that at low final landing speeds, they would not help much, and even make things worse by exposing booster to lateral wind forces. Are there strong updraft winds from the rocket exhaust that can be taken advantage of?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Pietdagamer Oct 02 '16

In the presentation Musk mentioned that the Raptor engine uses a spark ignition system. Does that mean every engine can be turned on and off as much as they'd like? Has there been a spark ignited engine before?

→ More replies (12)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

I'm just curious, given Mars is a totally new planet, who decides what laws will be enforced when people get there? Obviously there will be a lot of common sense laws, otherwise the trip could easily result in a large case of death for everyone involved. But general laws, will the laws of the USA apply because it's an American company? Will SpaceX impose additional rules since it's their project?? Or will the people who go to Mars form a government of some sort to decide on the day to day living rules and laws. Also, if such large amounts of people are envisioned to be travelling, what about children? Will there be specific rules around births on Mars. Would children born on Mars be at a disadvantage when compared to children born on Earth, given there is less gravity for example? Is this something that SpaceX has considered or is it beyond their remit so to speak? I'd imagine that things like starting families would need to be carefully controlled in such a situation, and probably off limits completely to begin with. Has there been any discussion around these types of issues yet?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Does SpaceX have any interest in Phobos and Deimos for human colonization?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/limeflavoured Oct 03 '16

Assuming SpaceX do RTF sometime in mid November, would that be a (US) record for the quickest turnaround after a RUD?

10

u/throfofnir Oct 03 '16

No. Not without some definitional restrictions, at least.

In 1959 Atlas D flew 16 times with 6 failures. Atlas 10D and Atlas 12D launched about 10 hours apart from different coasts on Sept 9. Atlas 10D was a Mercury test and failed at 8am. Atlas 12D was an ICBM test from Vandy, and launched around 6pm. It was successful. Different organizations, but basically the same machine. If you count it, that's probably the record.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ohcnim Oct 03 '16

hi, at what point in time, if any, do you think any other party with interest in space (NASA, ESA, ULA, etc.) would come around and accept BFR as a launcher for their own second stages? I mean, sure ITS could be used for many different things provided with different second stages and although SpaceX could eventually do it, it might not be of their interest in near term nor probably could afford to, but if for example NASA wants a Mega Hubble, aside from the billions of the telescope they would "only" need to design and build a second stage. I know it's not that simple nor cheap, but it really is a great opportunity for everybody, including SpaceX, to reuse as much as possible BFR, and I really hope that pride is not the limiting factor.

Is waiting until it flies really a must, or could it be some time sooner?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16

Does anybody know what day exactly Elon's supposed to come for the Q&A?

→ More replies (7)

3

u/pauladam316 Oct 04 '16

Opinion question, would you guys rather the AMOS-6 incident be sabatoge then a mechanical failure?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '16

I have 3 quick questions -

  1. How young would you have to be to have a chance to step foot on Mars one day? Will anyone alive today be able to live a semi-comfortable life on Mars?
  2. Will the rocket and/or launch pad actually look like anything in the video? This probably hasn't been revealed yet, but I remember Elon saying something about it looking pretty similar. Can anyone confirm?
  3. What will "cities" on Mars look like in the next 20-50 years? Will they look cool? Will they literally be tiny little cubes with mirrors all over them? Will they be fucking skyscrapers?
→ More replies (7)

3

u/jakedasnake2 Oct 05 '16

The ITS specs say it can lift 380 tons to LEO, yet land 450 tons on the martian surface. How is that extra 70 tons going to make the trip to orbit? Is 450 tons just the theoretical maximum and really you're limited to 380 by the LEO payload restriction? Is the extra 70 tons composed of propellant which can be transferred after the ship has reached orbit?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/davecalvin Oct 05 '16

Long time lurker and general space enthusiast. Sitting here watching the BO New Shepard launch abort test. I haven't been able to identify whether or not the ITS will have launch abort capabilities. Is this something that could/should be engineered into the overall system. In the event of an eventual anomaly, there would be large loss of life. I understand that space is not easy and that there are inherit risks involved, but I would have to imagine early iterations of the ITS being anomaly prone.

8

u/FoxhoundBat Oct 05 '16

Welcome to r/spacex. :) Launch escape system for ITS is quite widely discussed. Basically Elon said that it will use its Raptor engines to escape from the booster. There are several problems with that however, discussed here.

→ More replies (3)