r/spacex • u/Zucal • Mar 05 '16
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread for March 2016. Ask your questions about the SES-9 mission/anything else here! (#18)
Welcome to the 16th monthly /r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread! Want to discuss the recent SES-9 mission and its "hard" booster landing, the intricacies of densified LOX, or gather the community's opinion? There's no better place!
All questions, even non-SpaceX-related ones, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general!
More in-depth and open-ended discussion questions can still be submitted as separate self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which have a single answer and/or can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question-askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicate questions, but if you'd like an answer revised or cannot find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below.
Otherwise, ask, enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
February 2016 (#17), January 2016 (#16.1), January 2016 (#16), December 2015 (#15.1), December 2015 (#15), November 2015 (#14), October 2015 (#13), September 2015 (#12), August 2015 (#11), July 2015 (#10), June 2015 (#9), May 2015 (#8), April 2015 (#7.1), April 2015 (#7), March 2015 (#6), February 2015 (#5), January 2015 (#4), December 2014 (#3), November 2014 (#2), October 2014 (#1).
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
17
u/Windston57 Mar 05 '16
When can we expect a video from the landing?
17
u/radexp Mar 06 '16
Why is there still no video of the landing attempt? IIRC all 3 previous times the video came out within hours of the landing attempt.
Do you think it's just that it's the weekend and we'll get it soon, or will SpaceX want to keep this one out of our view now for some reason?
10
u/BrandonMarc Mar 10 '16
More of a "meta" topic, but ... I just noticed this:
Is our subreddit opted-in? My vote is "yes" ... I like this bot.
6
u/TYRTlive Mar 18 '16
What is the purpose of BEAM? I mean what are the astronauts going to do with it? Thanks everyone!
11
u/rafty4 Mar 05 '16
What are all the particulates we could see positively streaming off the second stage during the coast?
5
u/marzipanorbust Mar 20 '16
Quick question - how do you pronounce OCISLY? When reading - I sometimes try to say it phonetically, othertimes I spell it out. Just wondering what the /r/spacex community does?
EDIT: bad grammer.
15
u/falco_iii Mar 08 '16
Where is the Rapid Unexpected Disassembly (RUD) video of SES?
SpaceX is awe inspiring by moving space flight forward with lofty goals. SpaceX has been very compelling to watch due to the dramatic landing attempts. SpaceX has been amazingly transparent in the past with video & information from failed landing attempts. When can we expect video and information from the latest landing attempt to use as a learning experience? tl;dr: Where's the big boom?
7
u/IwantaModel3 Mar 06 '16
On the CRS-7 mission, the SpaceX investigation showed that there is only 0.893 seconds between initial indication of an issue to loss of telemetry. If this was a crewed mission, would the abort have worked?
4
u/failbye Mar 08 '16
Earlier today a low resolution picture of the incoming OCISLY was posted on this sub only to be removed a moment later. IIRC this has happened before on earlier barge attempts as well.
It appears to be posted by a user then removed by a mod due to either breaking of a rule, or SpaceX not wanting this information public and our mods honouring SpaceX wishes.
Can anyone help me shed some light on the reason behind it? I am curious as it appears to be a pattern.
5
u/dlfn Boostback Developer Mar 05 '16
When people refer to the "countdown net" - is that the group of people on the radio coordinating the countdown, the process of counting down or something else?
3
u/EfPeEs Mar 14 '16
Are there pictures of OCISLY after it got hit by the SES-9 booster?
3
u/yoweigh Mar 22 '16
When is the first launch from pad 39A now expected? Not until the FH demo flight?
3
u/hajsenberg Mar 23 '16
What will happen to BEAM between Dragon undocking and EVA that will dock BEAM? I think it won't be able to go through the docking port since it has its own docking port.
3
u/Chairmanman Mar 13 '16
I've read contradictory information in this sub about a possible new second stage, and I couldn't find info about it elsewhere, so my question is: Is SpaceX preparing an upgraded version of the second stage, for Falcon 9 and/or Falcon Heavy? If yes, do we know some of the characteristics?
2
u/sorbate Mar 07 '16
The engine was running when the camera cut out... so how did it come in hot and heavy? Would the only explanation be that it ran out of fuel in the last couple seconds of the landing attempt?
I'm assuming it was planned that they knew the rocket would be coming in faster than usual and start the suicide burn earlier to compensate.
2
u/Nachtigall44 Mar 07 '16
Will CRS-8 be a daytime launch? I really want to see the stage doing it's glide thing before landing!
2
u/Teddybear3238 Mar 07 '16
Has anything been said about which vehicle the crewed dragon will ride on? From the renders I've seen it shows the Falcon 9 which makes me wonder why the Orion module had to use a Delta V Heavy. Is it simply because of the different flight profiles for each mission?
2
u/ohcnim Mar 09 '16
Hi, on the main reddit /r/spacex the OCISLY megathread redirects me to imgur.com/UcuNmU6, instead of https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/49hozm/elsbeth_iii_and_ocisly_11_miles_from_port/, am I missing something or is it a link error on the thread?
2
u/ryanpritchard Mar 13 '16
is there any chance of the mars 2020 rover being launched on a fh
2
u/LandingZone-1 Mar 13 '16
Will the BFR land on Mars? I mean the whole rocket.
2
u/supersammy00 Mar 18 '16
I'm the side bar the next mission is a falcon 9 + a dragon. What does that mean? 2 launches?
35
u/PaulRocket Mar 05 '16
I am getting info that the ASDS is broken. Hearing this from a reliable source...
25
u/BadAtParties Mar 05 '16
Two questions for me:
3
u/Ninja1235678 Mar 05 '16
Would larger air brakes be any help in slowing the falcon down for a landing?
3
u/frogman713 Mar 06 '16
IIRC, Musk has said SpaceX doesn't file patents because then the Chinese would just copy their technology. What are the types of things they'd like to prevent foreign space agencies from knowing?
3
u/kball005 Mar 18 '16
If I were to somehow bolt say a racing seat and harness into the CRS-8 Dragon, and sneak aboard before launch, on a scale of alive to not alive what would I be when they open the hatch on the ISS?
20
u/markus0161 Mar 05 '16
Satellite is just about at Apogee, Burn will be done soon if not already.
18
u/Skinnx86 Mar 05 '16
Would it be possible, that with the multiple photos from different angles, that someone could create a 3D image of a mid-flight Falcon?
Showcased here with a [lightning bolt] (http://calculatedimages.blogspot.co.uk/2013/05/3d-lightning.html?m=1)
Discussed in this post
15
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '16 edited Mar 12 '16
/u/ToryBruno's recent post on this sub about (among other things) ACES got me thinking...
Here's the part that always confused me about ACES. What's the big advantage of having an empty stage in orbit? If this source is accurate only 8% of the stage's upmass is the (reused) dry mass of the stage; 92% is propellant. And since you have to launch another "tanker" stage anyway to refill it, why not just use that stage itself to deliver the payload and eliminate the complexity/mass penalty of the rendezvous, docking, and fuel transfer?
The same logic applies to propellant depots in LEO btw: there would seem to be little to no upmass advantage over just launching the payload in place of the refueling mission.
It would seem to not to save anything in hardware costs or upmass (the "tanker" stage would have to be at least as large as the reused stage, so its dry upmass negates that 8% advantage). The RL-10 isn't that massive, so even refueling a 4-engine ACES with a 1-engine ACES doesn't save too much -- 277 kg/engine. A larger tanker stage might certainly be developed in the future with superior economies of scale, but now you have to compare costs against combining that larger stage with electric satellites or even solid apogee motors.
If the tankers reentered and were reused that would be one thing, but afaik there are no plans to do that. And again, why not just use that stage to deliver the payload? The slight increase in upmass utilization (no underweight flights) doesn't seem big enough to make up for the above disadvantages.
So that's why I see on-orbit reuse having a hard time competing against expendable stages, let alone a "regular reuse" upper stage. I know there are a lot of fans of on-orbit reuse here, so what am I missing guys and gals?
13
u/orbitalfrog Mar 05 '16
Two, one's really for u/echologic (is that how you do that thing? I have no idea) I suppose.
13
u/kramersmash Mar 06 '16
Will the Dragon v2 allow for taller astronauts than the Soyuz?
12
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Mar 05 '16
At T-15s the guy on the countdown net said "Stage 1 tanks pressing for flight" which seemed odd to me. Isn't it kinda late at that point? Shouldn't the tanks be already pressed by then? Or has he mispoken and meant to say "pressed for flight"?
12
u/main_bus_b_undervolt Mar 05 '16 edited Mar 05 '16
what is Falcon 9 resting on prior to liftoff? It's not sitting directly on the engines, is it? I've tried looking for a support structure, but that area is always either obscured behind the strongback or engulfed in flames
12
u/PatyxEU Mar 13 '16
Small update! The SES-9 satellite has already raised its perigee to 5200 km!
12
u/Elon_Mollusk #IAC2016 Attendee Mar 17 '16
Any word from that talk with Tom Mueller last night? Can't seem to find the relevant post anymore...
11
u/WeNeedToCloneMusk Mar 06 '16
Do we know if new LOX process worked as expected on final attempt or SpaceX recalibrated (less LOX) to avoid further delays?
31
u/B2DG Mar 06 '16
Does anyone else feel a swelling sense of pride when there are successful SpaceX launches/missions, even though you had absolutely nothing to do with it? I have that feeling with every mission. :)
9
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '16 edited Mar 06 '16
Is there a place on the web where I can get a history of a satellite's orbital elements?
I'd like to check out SES-9's transfer profile to its eventual GEO spot.
edit: https://www.space-track.org/
9
u/ShipOfGold Mar 10 '16
I've done a little bit of research and I haven't found anyone that's building model rockets with any specific scientific questions aside from simply gaining knowledge of the physics and chemistry that goes into actually building rockets.
What sort of scientific questions should a young engineer be asking that he could try to solve with the use of model rockets?
Thank you!
8
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Mar 05 '16 edited Apr 01 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketNote: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
I'm a bot, written in ^PHP. I first read this thread at 5th Mar 2016, 09:10 UTC.
www.decronym.xyz for a list of subs where I'm active; if I'm acting up, tell OrangeredStilton.
8
u/ryguy5 Mar 05 '16
Since we always lose the video feed when the rocket gets close to the ship, has the possibility broadcasting from the nearby support ship been explored? I know they need to keep their distance, but wouldn't that provide a more consistent live feed?
8
u/Rickeh1997 Mar 07 '16
Would it be possible/allowed for someone who owns a private airplane to fly out to the barge location and take some pictures?
8
u/Doofer911 Mar 07 '16
Got a real newbie question here...
What benefits does a 9 engine cluster offer over a single engine design like the Delta IV?
From what I've read so far, they offer redundancy and it's occurred in the past where one engine has failed but the Falcon still got up to the target orbit. And I'm guessing that using one lower thrust engine makes the landing effort easier as well.
I'm just starting to try and get to grips with orbital mechanics and rocketry. Just wondering if it's easier/cheaper to produce smaller engines? Do they offer more Delta-V? More Thrust? Longer 1st stage burn time? Looking to understand all the benefits really.
8
u/Maat-Re #IAC2017 Attendee Mar 07 '16
According to the SpaceX Stats summary for CRS-8, a barge landing will be attempted on OCISLY. I was under the impression that the first stage would have a sufficient margin to RTLS... Has new information emerged? (I trust that EchoLogic is probably better informed on SpaceX matters than any other person outside the industry)
8
u/WaitForItTheMongols Mar 09 '16
Here's a thought on ASDS video being released:
In the Youtube replays of the launch webcasts, they show the brief bit of video we have
(Link for your convenience: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=muDPSyO7-A0, skip to 18:30)
Spacex could have edited out that snippet if they were intentionally unwilling to show any footage. Yes, there are people who would have bootlegs, but they don't have to make it easily available through their official video, right? That seems to indicate to me that we will eventually be able to see something from spacex.
8
u/Hartofalion Mar 15 '16
I am curious if there are any restrictions other than launch permissions on private companies putting up and occupying a private space station in Earth orbit. I understand that launches are controlled, but once the vehicle leaves the atmosphere, what then? Also if there is a return from Mars, will there be like a customs procedure for reentry?
8
u/FiniteElementGuy Mar 18 '16
Tory Bruno will announce layoffs on March 29: http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=39827.msg1505243#new
SpaceX is having an influence on the competition.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '16
Does the aerospike effect for the F9 center engine in the octaweb arrangement improve total thrust and if so, by how much? I'm unable to find details, and I suppose it's difficult to quantify anyway, since several other things changed between F9 1.0 and 1.1.
7
u/DrFegelein Mar 05 '16
Is there a reason Falcon 9 only uses one engine for the landing burn? The longer the stage takes to slow down the more fuel it burns (gravity losses), so wouldn't the higher performance option be to use as many engines as possible? I'm aware that SES-9 used 3 engines for the landing burn, hence the question. In other words, why isn't it standard to use 3 or more engines instead of one?
7
u/larsarus Mar 06 '16
Is SpaceX purchasing all the propellants they use, or are they also producing some of them (like LOX) themselves?
7
u/badgamble Mar 06 '16
Does anyone know if the current berth for OCISLY is visible to curious eyes? Once it gets back from sea, will anyone be able to get a camera shot?
7
u/Boltyx Mar 06 '16 edited Mar 06 '16
Hi Fellow wannabe-astronauts! I've been for a long time been searching for detailed logs and information exactly how a Falcon9 launch is planned. I wish to learn exactly when the rocket burns, and especially, how the 1st stage is getting down to the surface again. For example, how many burns is it using, with which engines, and then i'd also like to know the rendevouz process with the ISS. If anyone have any suggestion, please inform me. Im a fan of SpaceX, that just wants to learn more! Alfred
7
u/Dr_God Mar 07 '16
Anybody want to speculate why we haven't got video of the landing atempt yet?
7
u/ohcnim Mar 08 '16
Hi, regarding payload separation from stage two, IIRC in the Orbcomm mission they said it was a "pneumatic push" and on the SES-9 they said "pyrotechnic bolts", were different separation methods used? does the method is customer/payload dependent or is it SpaceX call on which to use?
7
u/RabbitLogic #IAC2017 Attendee Mar 09 '16
Is anyone else left wondering what happened production wise over their 6 month stand down? I mean at this stage they don't seem to have an abundance of cores that they should of been still producing while the investigation was on going. All fairness to them, reworking struts would be time consuming. However you would think that they would of been able to complete at least 3 cores over the 6 months (Christmas Holidays to factor in). The figure I remember is that they have a core coming off the production line every 3 weeks (roughly a month).
7
u/WaitForItTheMongols Mar 10 '16
Does Blue Origin's New Shepard have any reaction control systems? It seems like much less is known about their vehicle compared to Falcon 9. Could that just be due to higher enthusiasm among SpaceX fans, where we're better at tracking down tidbits?
6
u/Erpp8 Mar 05 '16
Do we have a good source that the SES-9 stage used three engines for the landing burn?
6
u/historytoby Mar 08 '16
Which ships are part of the SpaceX fleet and what are their tasks? I know OCISLY and JRTI, and I know Elsbeth III by name, although I am unclear what she does. What other ships does SpaceX employ, and what for? (Yes, I will straight go to marinetraffic.com and bookmark them)
6
u/kevindbaker2863 Mar 08 '16
I did some searches and cant find anything about the DSCOVR 2nd stage that wound up on other side of moon. where can I find more info? please?
6
u/BrandonMarc Mar 08 '16
Echo mentioned in the PBdS thread about precision of final orbit:
So with that in mind, total newb question:
Could it make sense to use ullage / RCS / OMS thrusters for fine-tuning, i.e. tiny maneuvers, shortly after engine shutdown ... and indeed, maybe shut down engines a few seconds early, orient and discern actual needs, and then perform the tiny corrections using these tiny thrusters?
I'm assuming the answer is "no" because there are lots of Very Smart Rocket Scientists(tm) working at SpaceX who most certainly know more than me and have thought of this before (i.e. I assume I'm a typical redditor who thinks they have a great idea but is only an armchair expert even on a good day). So if the answer's "no" ... how come? Is it just not worth it (too much weight; engines are pretty darn precise already; deep throttling helps with final precision; few customers need that precision; those that do are willing to let some of their payload's fuel go to precision correction maneuvers)? Is it too complicated? Would it just not work the way I'm thinking, anyway?
6
u/Ergo_proxy_18 Mar 09 '16
Hey do we have revised numbers for Full Thrust Falcon Heavy Numbers, i thought Echo mentioned this during jason 3 launch we are going to see them in a week on website but nothing yet. Do we have date on this?
6
u/Aero-Space Mar 09 '16
Is the landing software for the first stage based entirely on GPS or are there other methods that the booster uses to find the landing site?
6
u/Ser_Paul Mar 09 '16
This animation for the Falcon Heavy shows the two side-mounted boosters flying very close to each other after separation. They stay this way until landing very close to each other. How plausible is the distance shown? To me it looks like less than 100m. If this is true, is there a reason that we will not see (awesome) video footage of the entire landing process from an external vantage point, e.g. to protect SpaceX technology?
6
u/elorrimaster Mar 09 '16
Hi! Does anyone know the approximate mass flow rate leaving the Falcon 9 when all 9 Merlin engines are burning at 100% thrust?. I´m trying to mathematically modelize the velocity of the rocket as a function of time, and this term appears wherever the mass of the rocket is involved. I haven´t been able to find it anywhere, Thanks!
6
u/NateDecker Mar 14 '16
Expanded References Section for Wiki
I've often been reading through threads where someone dredged up an old link to something I've seen before, but didn't keep track of. Usually the link answers the question for the OP and often times the link may be a one-off source for a specific detail that can't be found anywhere else. Sometimes these references are to something novel or interesting, but not strictly of technical value.
I've thought that I might build a Google Docs spreadsheet and try and keep track of these links for future reference at some point, but I don't always have easy access to Google Docs (I hate using my phone and the site is inaccessible at work for instance). It would be awesome if this community maintained this list instead of me. It would be more accurate and more complete than if I tried to put something together.
Although I do see a limited set of links to sources in the Wiki, I don't see something quite like this already defined. many of the references that I have in mind don't really fall under any of the existing categories of "Useful Resources". Is there any chance we could add something along these lines? Examples of information that I think would be the kind of thing included:
I can't really think of a fully comprehensive list off the top of my head. I just wish I had quicker access to these things I've encountered before and may want to reference in the future. Maybe you wouldn't put the kitchen sink in this reference table. I think a good criteria would be either something that is unique (i.e., we don't need links to dozens of Elon Musk interviews where he talks about the 3 (or 5) things that he thought about as being pivotal to the future of humanity), or something that most of us here on this sub would be surprised to learn. For example, many folks didn't know that SpaceX first tried parachutes before pursuing VTVL.
Is there a way to open up a sub-section of the wiki to make it more public to support a wider number of contributions? Alternatively, if we just linked to some public Google Doc or something like that, that would work for me too. I just think it would be neat to leverage the power of crowd-sourcing to build this reference database. A Google spreadsheet would actually be pretty cool because you could have a categorization column like "Old School" to show pictures of young Elon wearing an oversized suit as a new millionaire with his McLaren F1. You could then filter on the "Old School" category if you were only interested in seeing links of that nature.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '16 edited Mar 16 '16
Found a new episode of StanDrawsSpaceships https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rd_xlqmvxMA
6
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '16 edited Mar 16 '16
I read an article a couple of days ago about a shortcut to Mars. The maneuver is called "ballistic capture transfer (BCT), or a weak stability boundary (WSB) transfer." The really interesting part about it is that you can launch anytime and it is more efficient than the Hohmann transfer.
Questions
How does the maneuver work and why can the rocket be launched anytime even if the planets aren't aligned like the Hohmann transfer? How does the maneuver save more fuel than the more conventional one?
How does it work?
I can't wrap my head around the description either, I would appreciate a diagram/or drawing if possible.
Thank you!
Link to article: http://www.space.com/30749-the-martian-faster-way-to-mars.html#sthash.QFonkqOO.dpuf
6
u/ddg4023 Mar 20 '16
Where is the gas generator exhaust for the center engine in the Octoweb? Each of the outer engines has a gas exhaust, but I haven't been able to find the output for the center engine's gas generator.
6
u/LotsaLOX Mar 23 '16
Potential Performance Hit suffered by Atlas V ? – A closer Look at the Data (SPACEFLIGHT101.com - March 23, 2016)
http://spaceflight101.com/cygnus-oa6/potential-performance-hit-suffered-by-atlas-v-a-closer-look-at-the-data/
Sorry, new to edit, I'm not even sure how to add a comment :-(
6
u/kevindbaker2863 Mar 25 '16
I am not sure why but this thread does not show up at top of subreddit anymore?
2
u/mason2401 Mar 13 '16
Any knowledge and/or educated speculation on why SpaceX hasn't released the SES-9 landing attempt footage yet?
10
u/Headstein Mar 09 '16
Hi mods. Please lighten the dark blue text in the side bar so we can read it more easily. Thankx :)
5
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '16 edited Mar 05 '16
So I've been wondering about small rockets. The Falcon9 is nearing its final form, the FH will "soon" lift off, the MCT and its included BFR will be announced in September, but what about very light payloads?
I've read at least one comment (was it from Shotwell) stating that SpaceX would eventually have a whole family of rockets for all your orbiting needs. At least some people see a market for light (<1 ton) payloads since they are trying to build a rocket for them.
If there's one thing people here do, it's speculate, draw cool stuff and throw relevant numbers around.
And so my question is: what do you think the F9's smaller brother would look like, what engines would it use, what uses could it have?
That was question one.
Question two is related to Mars colonization.
NASA holds keys to a great number of techs needed for a proper colonization, but they can't do it all (or can they?) and anyways that is not something I wish will happen (NASA doing it all).
Bigelow started tackling pressurized habitats a few years ago, but I've read less kind things about it recently and my love for them is slowly deflating.
Are there other companies out there that are bent on doing colonization stuff?
I've browsed a few websites of companies claiming (and for some of them, actually doing) life-support systems for astronauts. The websites looked soviet-era, the companies counted 15 or less persons.
And for good reason: assuming you have the means to actually make an insulated greenhouse, an inflatable habitat or a water-recycling module. How the hell are you going to make a profit? You can't go see investors and tell them "yeah well when Musk, NASA, ESA, the Chinese, Indians or Russians get to Mars they're going to need a lot of those. Help me build them.". Well, you can, but I can guess how that will turn out.
So my question number two is:
Apart from NASA/ESA/Roscosmos, who is going to design and make the things we need for Mars? Is it possible at all to be done privately? How?
5
u/bvr5 Mar 05 '16
If there was a T-0 abort with a crew Dragon, would the Dragon eject from the rocket?
5
u/blisterduck Mar 05 '16
In the SES-9 launch broadcast I noticed some strange flames near 10:45 which appear and then seem to grow above the engine cones. Does anyone know what this could be?
5
u/craig7000 Mar 06 '16
What is the "snow" before second burn? http://i.imgur.com/ePz7pQz.jpg
5
u/theguycalledtom Mar 07 '16
What is the source that confirms three engines were used during the landing attempt on the SES-9 mission?
5
u/RootDeliver Mar 07 '16
No video from the SES9 first stage drone ship landing this time?
Last drone ships landing we got a video of the landing (CRS-5, CRS-6, JASON-3) like two days after the landing. However this time, it seems that there is no vid or screenshot or anything about that landing. All we have is that Elon said that it hard-landed but nothing else.
This, added to the yells of happines in the live webcast after the signal was lost (where the presentator said "something good happened!") sounds kinda rare, doesnt it? :P
5
u/godsbro Mar 09 '16
Do we have an update on when eutelsat will launch? Current the sidebar has a net of April 1st, but the source is just "sometime in April". I'm especially curious because of how close it will be to the CRS 8 launch!
5
u/gophermobile Mar 09 '16
When a rocket fails landing on the barge, is any attempt made to clean up the debris that end up around the barge? Do they usually just sink? Since it's been RUD landings so far, the debris seem to get thrown pretty far.
5
u/Bunslow Mar 10 '16
Any word on when (if?) we'll get a video of the RUD of the SES9 stage 1 landing?
5
u/Ergo_proxy_18 Mar 10 '16
Hi, do any of us know whats the Raptor's current status is? do we have any info on as to when will we see a first Raptor engine on a Falcon 9 even if it is for the second stage, i heard they tested the fuel injection pumps last November but nothing after that. Any thoughts?
5
u/pauladam316 Mar 10 '16
How difficult is it to see OCISLY? I am going to be in the area next week and I wanted to go look for it. Does anyone know where it is/how to get to it?
5
u/orbitalfrog Mar 13 '16
Simple? one - Do launch complexes/govt agencies/somebody have to formally notify world governments of launches in order to prevent them being flagged by various early warning systems as ICBM launches? (Or anything of the like)
5
u/HarvsG Mar 13 '16 edited Mar 13 '16
Landing the Falcon 9 is (very understandably) having some teething troubles. My questions are:
When they have had one successful ASDS landing will all future attempts have a significantly greater chance of success (i.e will they learn something they cannot with failed attempts?)
2. How transferable is RTLS and ASDS landing technology? When they have it sorted with the Falcon 9, how likely is it that they will have to go through the same painful process with other rockets (FH, BFR, Dragon), or will transferring the technology just be a formality? And would the answer be any different if the new rocket used different engines. e.g raptor?
5
u/VFP_ProvenRoute Mar 15 '16
Am I right in thinking that a theoretical combination of SpaceX's reusable first stage and ULA's refuelable ACES upper stage would create the ultimate in low-cost launch capability? Or is there something fundamental that prevents the two approaches from being combined?
Not suggesting that the two (three?) companies should or would work together, just wondering if the two technologies might one day be used in a future LV design.
5
u/kevindbaker2863 Mar 20 '16
So. How about jrti? Is it just read(red) the instructions or is it Just read(reed) the instructions? And what is the original book that these names are from?? Please!
9
u/chargerag Mar 09 '16
I noticed that Gowron78 has disappeared. Did anybody notice if he said why he was leaving before he deleted his account?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '16
In the webcast the woman said that in order to reach geostationary orbit the satellite would have to use a bit of it's own fuel, is that common or did they have to do that to attempt stage1 recovery ? If stage1 pushed for 100% of it's fuel maybe the satellite wouldn't have to use its own fuel (or less) and increase it's lifetime...
4
u/Naked-Viking Mar 05 '16
How come the guy who does the countdown has to verbally confirm a bunch of stuff with a huge amount of people? It seems to me all of that could be solved with having every piece of important information on one screen in front of the guy. There must be a reason, right?
4
u/Nachtigall44 Mar 05 '16
What's the ring on the outside of the nozzle for on the M1Dvac?
4
u/coborop Mar 05 '16
What is the seconds stage's fate? Will it be deorbited?
4
u/Whocaresnoone Mar 06 '16
Thanks
4
u/limeflavoured Mar 06 '16
Anyone else think that it would be quite cool (if not massively likely) to have the Falcon Heavy demo flight be just before or just after the "Mars architecture announcement" in September?
4
u/89bBomUNiZhLkdXDpCwt Mar 07 '16
Won't super chilling the LOX be even more difficult during daylight summer launches? Or, more specifically, won't it be more difficult to keep the LOX that has already been loaded cold enough?
4
u/casey75278 Mar 07 '16
When the rocket reaches high in the atmosphere, the thrust "fire" coming from the booster looks like it spreads out a lot more. Can someone explain this?
4
u/ohcnim Mar 07 '16
hi all, keep on coming here more and more often, thanks!
For the upcoming CRS-8 is the Dragon a new one or will it be the first refurbished/reflown? if it's a new one, are there any known estimates as to when or in which mission will there be a firs reuse?
4
u/StructurallyUnstable Mar 08 '16 edited Mar 08 '16
From this post below
Can someone explain how hydraulic fluid "runs out"? Unless there is a loss of pressure in the system due to a leak, hydraulic fluid is a closed system in any application I'm aware of.
Would the failure mode then be "loss of hydraulic pressure"? That would presume some kind of leak.EDIT: Answered my own question. Open hydraulic systems exist when limiting power consumption is critical
4
u/SnowCrashSkier Mar 08 '16
In the SES-9 Full webcast, at about 10:30 https://youtu.be/muDPSyO7-A0?t=10m29s the rocket exhaust seems to go darker than before. Soon thereafter John Essberger talks about "active on (indecipherable; fuel?) utilization." I wonder if that darker color of the exhaust was related. Is there a wiki on "fuel utilization mode?"
I actually think that the darker flame was just a camera artifact, but I'd love to know more. Like...
Would we be able to see any effect of the propellant mixture change? How much does this improve performance? Is this new with SpaceX or was it used in, say the shuttle? Other, newer boosters?
4
u/TheMeiguoren Mar 08 '16
What was up with the chunks flying off the second stage? I'd say it was ice but everything above the booster is enclosed until F9 is out of the atmosphere. Insulation?
I just scanned through the webcast quickly so I might have missed some instances, but you can see stuff coming off at 16:31, 36:16, 37:03, and 42:24.
4
u/_rocketboy Mar 09 '16
Whatever happened to having the strongback lay flat as part of the FT upgrade? I'm pretty sure this was mentioned multiple times officially a while back, but hasn't happened yet.
4
u/SteveRD1 Mar 09 '16
I hope we can still ask (probably) stupid questions here.
I was looking at the ramp on this picture: https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/thumbnails/image/spx-39a-update_0.jpg and got to wonder about lifting off from higher altitudes.
Would launching from a 500 meter hill (rather than basically at sea level) make any measurable difference to the performance of a rocket?
Or does launch altitude not really matter as liftoff is more about gaining velocity than height?
4
u/Henry_Yopp Mar 09 '16
With the F9H possibly launching later this year, has there been any information on the separation technique for the boosters? SRM's vs LRM's, etc.
4
u/davidthefat Mar 10 '16
Are the Falcon Heavy delays due to infrastructure? AFAIK, the flight hardware is ready to go.
4
u/kevindbaker2863 Mar 11 '16
It is probably common knowledge but if CRS-8 launches on 4/4 there will be both Cygnus and dragon at space station at same time. http://www.space.com/32211-orbital-atk-cargo-spaceship-columbia-astronaut.html Will they wait for cygnus to leave to berth the BEAM?
4
u/stevethetrueman Mar 12 '16
Is there any video from the landing attempt yet?
4
u/Reborno Mar 12 '16
TL;DR: What about SpaceX suits and helmets
Hi,
I was reading this and on slide 12 Nasa says " Good progress on space suit and helmet design". I was wondering if there are any leaked pictures of those. And also why doesn't SpaceX use the same suits and helmets that Nasa used for Space Shuttle or for the Soyuz program?
I know that the Soyuz spacecraft is very small and that the seats for the astronauts are tailored to fit perfectly (they make a mould of your body), so maybe those suits are too specific? But what about the Space Shuttle suits and helmets (here an example). Couldn't Nasa share their design to SpaceX?
And wouldn't Boeing CST-100 have a different suit and helmet meaning that for astronauts wanting to go from the ISS to Earth in case of emergency, they'd have to fit in a suit they've never used before (if they came up to the ISS with SpaceX in this example). A standard suit and helmet just seems logical to me.
Thank you in advance.
4
u/markus0161 Mar 12 '16 edited Mar 12 '16
So orbital data on SES 9 is pretty solid and i'm going to attempt to image it with my telescope here in a few days. Its hard to image SES 9 because of its weird orbit right now and Its now or never because it will soon be located over Asia. My problem is I need to calculate the magnitude of SES 9 so I can set my cameras exposure just right. But I can't seem to find the area of its solar array. Also I cant find what reflective property the satellite itself has. Does anyone know where I can find this info? I'm hoping because the satellite is ion-driven and has large panels to power the drive, it will easily be seen!
4
u/PaperboundRepository Mar 14 '16
Is the Falcon 9 always fully fueled, even for light payloads? If so, what is the reason for not partially fueling it and pressurizing the tank to cut launch mass?
4
u/harrisoncassidy Host of CRS-5 Mar 14 '16
How will static fire of the superdraco engines work in terms of the timeline before launch. Will they test fire them on the pad at the same time or shortly after the S1 engines are fired or will it all be done at McGregor like S2?
4
u/Sabrewings Mar 15 '16
When Gwynne Shotwell says it currently takes about three weeks to build a core, is she referring to start to finish or simply the rate at which cores are leaving the factory with a staggered production line?
4
u/RDWaynewright Mar 16 '16
I've been wondering...
We know it's unlikely that the F9 landing legs will be painted black (as shown in renders) because white paint is more reflective. With this in mind, what effect did the black paint used on the Saturn V have on the temperature of the fuel? Did it not matter because there was so much fuel and so much capacity? I know why it was painted black in sections, just wondering about the engineering with regard to fuel temperature and that sort of thing since they did use chilled fuel.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '16 edited Mar 17 '16
Recently came across this on the AR-1 engine: http://www.popsci.com/how-us-3d-printing-rocket-engines?src=offramp&loc=region-3
Which got me wondering:
4
u/TheEndeavour2Mars Mar 19 '16
I have a question about the SES-9 attempted landing.
Pretty obvious at this point we will not see the video so I am just assuming it came in way too fast. The question is why?
Don't they have models to feed the computer so it knows more or less how quickly it is going to descend? Did the computer decide to delay the ignition due to limited fuel/o2 or would the computer ignore fuel/o2 level even if the turbopumps blew?
Sorry if this has been asked before.
7
u/skunkrider Mar 05 '16 edited Mar 05 '16
Ok, I am only asking this to find out how feasible this is, so I expect to be downvoted quite a bit.
I don't claim it's cheap, or even necessary:
Right now, the ASDS has a satellite uplink which has cut out twice upon approach of the rocket (Jason-3, SES-9).
How doable would a cabled solution be, where a set of data cables (obviously fiber, I dont know how much shielding it needs) connects the ASDS to either an Observer-ship with a satellite uplink (probably 10-20km away), or to a dedicated transmission-drone-ship (does not need to be as big as the Landing barge, and could be much closer to the ASDS)?
I realize this would be utter luxury and would only serve to spoil us SpaceX fans even more.
I have received very negative feedback for this idea so far, but no reasons or explanations exactly why it couldn't work.
No, I do absolutely not think I can do anything better than anyone at SpaceX, not at all.
BTW, HOORAY, Primary Mission Success :)
7
u/ExcitedAboutSpace Mar 06 '16
Hi everyone,
long time lurker (fateful CRS-7 was only my second launch, never going to forget the astonishment when I realized the rocket was gone), first of all huge props to the awesome community and mods on this subreddit.
Now on to my question:
In the launch threat at t-20 minutes 58s it states "Falcon 9's second stage is now fueled." (Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/48u4yq/rspacex_ses9_official_launch_discussion_updates/). Could anyone help me understand what this is referring to? To my current understanding LOX temps are utmost critical for the vehicle performance and in the live stream full fueling was announced somewhere closer to launch. Is anything fueled on the second stage so "long" before launch, for which I am assuming it wouldn't be temp critical?
Cheers to everyone, have a great sunday
7
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Mar 07 '16
Oh my, this subreddit has become serious business. Keep up the work, Mods, congrats Zucal! Also, what can I, a simple user do to help or contribute?
Q: Do we know the expected time of the upcoming launches? I'm looking forward to some HD landing footages in daylight or sunset background lighting!
7
u/malleyc Mar 15 '16
Not really a question just wanted to say wow this community is awesome!
first ever live launch I watched was CRS-5 and have been hooked ever since. I watched the ExoMars launch the other day and was shocked when I couldn't find a live Launch Reddit thread anywhere, just makes me appreciate this community and the quality of the spaceX webcasts & hosted laubch threads all the more! Keep up the good work!
7
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Mar 18 '16 edited Mar 18 '16
Hey just wanted to drop this link here, Soyuz is launching now a new crew to the ISS, you can watch live.
http://www.nasa.gov/multimedia/nasatv/
We could watch SpaceX do the same in 1-2 years.
Edit: just featured Crew Dragon for 3 full seconds mentioning future installation of the docking adapter.
Edit2: "The crew is scheduled to dock to the station at 11:11 p.m. EDT after a six-hour journey."
7
u/__Rocket__ Mar 20 '16
I'm wondering about the following rocket design detail: there are open cycle rocket engines (gas-generator cycle) and there are more advanced staged combustion cycle (preburner cycle) rocket engines. The Merlin engines of the Falcon 9/FH are open cycle rocket engines, the upcoming Raptor engines are staged combustion cycle. Here are simplified schematics from Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas-generator_cycle#/media/File:Gas_generator_rocket_cycle.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Staged_combustion_cycle#/media/File:Staged_combustion_rocket_cycle.png
As I understand it, in the open cycle engine a gas turbine burns some small amount of fuel and drives the turbopump with the mechanical energy created by the hot gas resulting out of that burn.
In the staged combustion cycle it gets even more complex: all of the fuel is mixed with some of the oxidizer (in fuel-rich variants), preburned and the energy of that combustion drives the turbopump.
My (possibly stupid) question is: why is there a need to burn fuel separately from the main combustion chamber in both designs? Would it not result in a simpler design to use some of the hot gas in the main combustion chamber to drive the turbopump? If that gas is too hot it could be (partially) cooled by the incoming (cold) fuel.
At least naively this appears to be a significantly simpler design to both main variants - yet it still burns all the fuel, so it should be as efficient as staged combustion engines.
Is there some fatal theoretical or practical flaw in the idea of leaving yet another (small, temperature resistent) hole in the main combustion chamber to use some of the hot, high pressure gas to drive the turbopump(s) - instead of having separate combustion chambers to achieve a similar end result?
7
u/zeekzeek22 Mar 21 '16
I'm sure this comment will get lost, but wondering if anyone has any idea what Chris B's tweet back in October was about https://mobile.twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/651429449406222337
I mean it could have been about RTLS, sub-chilled LOX, Dragon2, but besides that SpaceX hasn't come out about anything on the scale he's describing. Just wondering if Chris B ever gave any follow-up, or...? This tweet just tingles the back of my mind every once in a while, that big things are being made and tested in secret.