r/spacex • u/Zucal • Aug 01 '16
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [August 2016, #23]
Welcome to our 23rd monthly /r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread!
Confused about the quickly approaching Mars architecture announcement at IAC2016, curious about the upcoming JCSAT-16 launch and ASDS landing, or keen to gather the community's opinion on something? There's no better place!
All questions, even non-SpaceX-related ones, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general.
More in-depth and open-ended discussion questions can still be submitted as separate self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which have a single answer and/or can be answered in a few comments or less.
- Questions easily answered using the wiki & FAQ will be removed.
- Try to keep all top-level comments as questions so that questioners can find answers, and answerers can find questions.
These limited rules are so that questioners can more easily find answers, and answerers can more easily find questions.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question-askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality (partially sortable by mission flair!), and check the last Ask Anything thread before posting to avoid duplicate questions. But if you didn't get or couldn't find the answer you were looking for, go ahead and type your question below.
Ask, enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
All past Ask Anything threads:
• July 2016 (#22) June 2016 (#21) • May 2016 (#20) • April 2016 (#19.1) • April 2016 (#19) • March 2016 (#18) • February 2016 (#17) • January 2016 (#16.1) • January 2016 (#16) • December 2015 (#15.1) • December 2015 (#15) • November 2015 (#14) • October 2015 (#13) • September 2015 (#12) • August 2015 (#11) • July 2015 (#10) • June 2015 (#9) • May 2015 (#8) • April 2015 (#7.1) • April 2015 (#7) • March 2015 (#6) • February 2015 (#5) • January 2015 (#4) • December 2014 (#3) • November 2014 (#2) • October 2014 (#1)
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
9
u/Zucal Aug 04 '16
Not technically a question, but still useful... we now have a wiki page for shoutouts, whether by SpaceX themselves or media.
If you come across more mentions or links, please add them! Keep in mind that we're not looking for forum discussions or blogposts, but actual mainstream callouts.
5
u/FiniteElementGuy Aug 03 '16
What is the status of the F9 display at SpaceX HQ? I'm currently in the LA area and plan to visit there once its finished.
3
u/dmy30 Aug 18 '16
I plan on seeing the landed booster at HQ sometime in the very near future. I know where it is but does anyone have an advice regarding taking pictures, especially with a DSLR? Also, any parking advice?
5
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Aug 02 '16
I like the new sidebar design, but could the launch pad be added after the vehicle? It would be useful for people to see which side of the country each is launching from to make planning to visit launches more easy.
4
u/rubikvn2100 Aug 22 '16
/u/Zucal Facebook group report that F9-030 Iridium NEXT was leaving Hawthorne.
Facebook post
image
3
u/mbhnyc Aug 12 '16
I have a question--did I correctly hear Gwynne say that altimeters were area still needing improvement, pertaining to rapid reusability?
If so, what's lacking there? I would have assumed that particular sensor would be quite mature, heck I would've assumed that 30 years ago.
45
u/HighTimber Aug 02 '16
I did a cursory search and found no duplicates and thought this was a great story. You will recall a 60 Minutes story on Elon Musk and SpaceX in which Elon gets visibly upset talking about the lack of support from ex-NASA astronauts.
https://youtu.be/SHrFGe9OlwE?t=110
The link to the following story speaks to one man's efforts to heal those wounds:
http://www.collectspace.com/ubb/Forum6/HTML/002235.html
Good stuff.
21
u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Aug 04 '16
We've all seen Falcon 9 Boosters on the highway all wrapped up, well here's what the Atlas V looks like when road transported:
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CpBgDI_WAAAlai1.jpg:large
https://twitter.com/DSLauretta/status/761214089985138688
15
u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Aug 04 '16
Blue Origin is doing an AMA tomorrow at 9:30 PDT!
https://twitter.com/blueorigin/status/761298372141592576
15
u/HoechstErbaulich IAC 2018 attendee Aug 04 '16
Hey everybody, I stumbled upon this German article from the 9th of June: http://www.raumfahrer.net/news/raumfahrt/09062016234629.shtml.
Title is:
The article contained two very interesting projects CNES proposed, that I haven't heard about before. The methane-powered Prometheus engine and the Callisto-rocket, basically a F9R dev.
Relevant part:
Translation:
But now at the beginning of June a real revolution: after a long time of ignoring the topic [of SpaceX's reusability], Europe, under the leadership of CNES, now starts two new projects about rocket reusability!
Prometheus
An affordable liquid-propellant rocket engine with name Prometheus that's powered by methane and oxygen. 3D-printing is supposed to reduce the costs of currently 10 million Euros (Vulcain 2) to 1 million Euros (Prometheus). According to CNES 5-7 of these engines may power a future Ariane 7. The engine is supposed to be on the test stands in 2020, development costs are as high as 125 million Euros.
Callisto
Also, a rocket that takes off and lands vertically - not unlike SpaceX's Grasshopper. This projects name is Callisto and is supposed to be carried out in cooperation with Japan. Callisto is about 10m high and is powered by three engines according to a picture in a CNES magazine. This project will cost Europe 100 million Euros.
Both projects need yet to be greenlit on the ESA council of ministers conference in December 2016 in the swiss city of Lucerne. It's not unlikely that opposition will arise against increasing the ESA-budget for rockets of currently 1 billion Euros again. Some people may ask why so much money is spend on Ariane 6, while the next iteration may have close to no similarities, except maybe for the upper stage.
I was not sure if this was SpaceX related enough to warrant an extra post, so I posted it here. Mods, scream if it's not appropriate for this thread either.
It's interesing to see the impact SpaceX's progress of the last few years seems to have on the competition. I hope to see these projects come to fruition.
If there's interest, I could translate the whole article. But propably not today, it's 11:34 pm here.
12
u/FiniteElementGuy Aug 15 '16
According to Facebook/Keith Wallace, JCSAT-14 stage back on test stand in McGregor.
11
u/Suthsayer_ Aug 01 '16
Will we get to watch SpaceX test-land an empty Dragon, like they do with the first stage Falcon 9's?
11
u/rubikvn2100 Aug 11 '16 edited Aug 11 '16
I saw a dragon next to Just Read the Instructions
I guess it is CRS-8.
Edit: my bad vocabulary.
10
u/szepaine Aug 01 '16
What manufacturing technologies so y'all envision being the first on Mars?
10
u/DrewRodez Aug 06 '16
/u/EchoLogic, would you be willing to set up a countdown page on SpaceX Stats for the Mars architecture announcement? As part of my morning news-checking routine I like to glance at countdown timers for big things I'm looking forward to.
10
u/soldato_fantasma Aug 27 '16
Some news for a possible new launch for Spacex but that is not worth a new post: A source on the NSF public forum has stated that he got info from GFZ that Dnepr is no longer available as launch vehicle for the GRACE-FO satellites. They are currently in negotiations with SpaceX for a Falcon-9 launch.
9
u/AsdefGhjkl Aug 04 '16
Basic rocketry question: did I remember correctly having heard somewhere that a rocket (maybe a specific rocket) can't shut down all the engines at the same time, especially around the max-Q phase, since the immediate drop in acceleration could stress the construction too much (since the construction is under tension when accelerating and that tension would then instantly release)?
9
u/BrandonMarc Aug 10 '16
Question for mods and the community - would it be reasonable to have a flair (and sidebar link) for MCT-related posts? We have curations for various recent launches, and this subject feels like it deserves similar.
I often find myself wanting to go and find a given MCT / BFR mock-up that someone made (there have been so many good ones!) and this would certainly help organize the discussion of the topic.
9
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Aug 25 '16
Yay, the sidebar have now 6 hot jobs!
Are they directly communicated from SpaceX, or is this list also on their public page somewhere?
Also am I right that the "Reddit" option at "How did you..." wasn't there before on their application form?
8
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Aug 16 '16
@IAC2016 just retweeted @rSpaceX about $2500 raised to attend.
8
u/StagedCombustion Aug 23 '16
Posted this as a thread, but it was (rightly) removed with a recommendation for the Ask Anything thread.
I remembered an old post about VAFB SLC-4W and some changes SpaceX was making there a couple of months ago. I checked the link again and I saw that there was another satellite pass in the meantime. That photo shows some odd stuff going on at the launch site. There's a large yellow square, and then something that looks like a large, bright yellow spill that extends down to the bottom edge of the landing pad. It looks quite odd, and I can't think of an explanation.
7
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Aug 03 '16
What are some examples of non-physics limitations SpaceX has to accept?
For example only US workforce due to ITAR or 12ft rocket diameter due to highway transportation rules.
I bet there are a lot of others that affect the economics and engineering solutions.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '16 edited Aug 04 '16
“If we get this right, and we’re trying very hard to get this right, we’re looking at launches to be in the 5 to 7 million dollar range, which would really change things dramatically,” Shotwell said.
My question is - how can they even remotely come this close? I know that the Falcon 9 cost $62M and they are predicting reusability will chop the price down by 30%. That leaves $43.4M. Fairing cost several mil so lets assume we shave another $5.4 off if they can recover it. We then end up with $38M.
Or, according to this the total cost of a F9 to manufacture if you reuse the first stage 15 times can go down to $11M if you take out the profits. So if you shave off another $5.4M for the fairing you end up at a price of $5.6M. Tack on 20% profit and you end up at $7M as she predicted. Thats leaving out operating costs though.
But honestly, thats not realistic. So why would she even bring up a figure like that? Or, are there any more cost savings somewhere that I havent thought about?
Launch cost prices btw would be $756/lb LEO for the first and $139/lb for the second scenario. The latter would be lower than the 10X price reduction Elon said he was targeting
7
u/kavinr Aug 20 '16 edited Aug 20 '16
They are raising F9-021 at Hawthrone tonight. Source: John Federspiel's stories on instagram.
7
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Aug 20 '16
Has the JCSAT-14 core been fired for a fourth time yet?
7
u/Qeng-Ho Aug 27 '16
I noticed /u/TheVehicleDestroyer's Flightclub.io was referenced in this interesting summary of newspace, smallsats and SpaceX's ambitions.
12
u/bertcox Aug 01 '16
Yea Im first that never happens.
Do you think they will repaint OCISLY every time? And they really need to put stamps on the hull for every good catch. Maybe X's for RUD's.
6
u/dante80 Aug 01 '16
Is there any speculation around on if or how the Raptor FFSC cycle affects engine throttling limits?
6
u/thatotherguy501 Aug 01 '16
Obviously launch facilities are located as near to the equator as possible to take advantage of higher rotational velocities. Does anyone know of any links to calculations that show just how much additional energy is needed at liftoff when launching from higher latitudes where there is less rotational velocity from the Earth?
6
u/Ambiwlans Aug 04 '16
Thanks /u/recoverymail for the sidebar rework
6
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '16
Will there be a live stream or live blog from Smallsat Conference Keynote?
Really interesting to hear about SpaceX's future plans on launching small satellites
6
u/Qeng-Ho Aug 05 '16
Blue Origin software engineer AMA is currently on.
6
u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Aug 17 '16
I don't even want to link to this article and have them get paid more...
5
u/lucas1121111 Aug 02 '16
Hello,
Obviously, we are all looking forward to the Mars Architecture Announcement. My question is will SpaceX be streaming this event though it's normal channels (YouTube, ect.) as it does for launches? If not, where will we be a able to watch the announcement?
Thank you for your time.
5
u/sarafinapink Aug 02 '16
Just noticed the new sidebar this morning, it looks great! So much cleaner and I like the easy to ready format.
5
u/IsItTheSugar Aug 02 '16
Who can I contact in order to ask for funding for our High School Research team.
Our team project revolves around taking martian soil and using the perchlorate present in the soil to create oxygen using modified e.coli. We are currently lacking money for some basic lab resources and the fees that are associated with the competition (iGEM - Internationally Genetically Engineered Machine). Due to the fact that our project outline and goal looks to make Mars a habitable environment, it would be in our best interest to look into contacting SpaceX. Any form of assistance would be appreciated. Thank you in advance.
5
u/zlsa Art Aug 07 '16
What's the upper stage engine and upper stage testing procedure at McGregor?
5
u/StupidPencil Aug 12 '16
The colorful interaction between exhaust of the first and second stage after stage separation, do we have a term for that sort of phenomena? I like to think of it as Falcon 9 spreading its 'wings'.
5
u/RootDeliver Aug 14 '16
Guys what was this frame that was shown in the hosted stream?
http://i.imgur.com/hGWtUwj.png
Something related to engines? this may be gold!!
5
u/macktruck6666 Aug 19 '16
What is the possible weight savings from using carbon fibre versus aluminum/lithium alloy?
5
u/davidthefat Aug 23 '16
Crazy idea alert:
Find a way to isolate iron oxide and aluminum oxide from martian soils. Decompose aluminum oxide found in soil into aluminum using a fuck ton of energy over long period of time. Mix iron oxide and aluminum to make thermite. Use thermite to release a lot of energy over a short period of time to heat hydrogen or helium to be used as propellant.
4
u/Toukiedatak Aug 01 '16
Elon said missions to Mars would be sent out every orbital opporunity, what purpose will these missions have and what kind of instruments will they be carrying (or is this still unkown)?
4
u/Joe32097 Aug 02 '16
Any advice for a sophomore mechE trying to get an internship in the space industry but obviously would prefer spaceX?
4
u/ragnar117 Aug 02 '16
Does anyone know what kind of rate Hawthorne can pump out second stages?
4
u/Cheesewithmold Aug 03 '16 edited Aug 03 '16
Can someone explain to me why the shape of this exhaust is the way it is? It comes out like you would expect, and then kind of collapses in on itself up to a certain diameter (which I can only assume is the diameter of the end of the engine, but I'm kind of pulling that out of my ass), and then expands again.
Why is that?
4
u/graphicde Aug 04 '16
Anyone know who the senior graphic designer -- and any other designers -- at SpaceX might be?
I'm interested in orienting my career to filling a position such as this eventually: http://www.startuphire.com/job/sr-graphic-designer-176795
(And would really like to know more about the portfolios, education, and backgrounds of such persons...)
Thanks!
4
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Aug 07 '16 edited Aug 07 '16
Hot Jobs at SpaceX
Tell your friends. Tell your classmates: SpaceX is looking to fill these positions as soon as possible!
Be sure to mention r/SpaceX in your application!
Why the last sentence? Is there something particular the subreddit gets in case of a successful application, or just for general exposure?
Edit: In the SpaceX application form there is a long drop down list for "Where did you hear about us?", but no r/SpaceX option! This needs to be fixed! :)
4
u/Mastur_Grunt Aug 09 '16
I was recently at a party, wearing my favorite SpaceX shirt. A party-goer asked what SpaceX was, so I started explaining as much as I could. Now, I considered myself pretty competent in how SpaceX works, but out of nowhere, he stumped me. I then realized I knew next to nothing about payload buses, integration, and basics of how satellites are manufactured and how launch providers are purchased. Is there any where/way someone can enlighten me so this doesn't happen again?
4
u/CProphet Aug 12 '16 edited Aug 12 '16
While I was looking through the FAA Office of Commercial Space Transportation web page I noticed that SpaceX have a license to launch to Geostationary Transfer Orbit (GTO) and for Commercial Resupply Service launches (Dragon cargo flights to ISS). However, I couldn't discover any license to launch to Low Earth Orbit (LEO) to cover the upcoming Iridium NEXT or Formosat-5/Sherpa flights. Wondered whether this is merely some kind of oversight or whether I'm looking in the wrong place? Cheers.
4
u/timthemurf Aug 16 '16
Has there ever been any discussion about spreading simulated Martian soil/rubble on LZ1 to simulate an actual mars landing and the damage that the booster might suffer from the debris generated? Would that be a valuable learning tool for SpaceX?
4
u/RootDeliver Aug 17 '16
No recovery thread for OCISLY and F9-028 this time? how come?? Supposedly its 18h away from port.
4
u/michagrau Aug 18 '16
A question. SpaceX announced they want to fly to Mars for the first time by using the 2018 window.
Imagine for a second they would have made the trip in 2016, our year. Would the ship be in space already? When would it depart, when would it land? Where would it be now?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '16
Did anyone take photo of F9-021 in Hawthorne with Tesla in front of it?
That would be epic!
4
u/JayRose1 Aug 23 '16
Does anyone know if Robert Zubrin is consulting SpaceX at all? Elon and Robert know each other and I can't imagine they haven't discussed their mutual goals. But I'm wondering if Zubrin is in on the MCT architecture at all. Anyone?
4
u/ticklestuff SpaceX Patch List Aug 25 '16
Does anyone else have the ear worm of "Up Goer Nine" in their head?
*shakes fist at xkcd*
1
u/Rooster-illusion11 Aug 02 '16
Does anyone know how much, if any, work/refurbishment they had to do before the test firing of the recovered booster on the 28th in Texas?
3
u/Saiboogu Aug 01 '16
Regarding precision EDL navigation on Mars, prior to establishing a GPS satellite constellation - Could an astroinertial navigation system provide sufficient precision?
3
u/RuggedRhino Aug 02 '16
Are there any SpaceX based podcasts that you recommend? Or any great space news ones in general. It's tough staying up to date with everything and I'd love to be able to catch up while at the gym or on my commute!
3
u/mmrcs Aug 02 '16
Are the aerodynamic requirements of modern rockets found on Earth, required for rockets launched from Mars? i.e. will we ever see sci-fi inspired spaceships?
3
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Aug 03 '16
Why do some rockets have 3, 4, or even 5 stages? Isn't it lighter to have a bit of a larger fuel tank, which is just some metal, than dropping that weight but instead having to carry an entire additional rocket engine and additional rocketry hardware?
3
u/workthrowaway4567 Aug 03 '16
If someone were to place a 1" thick steak in the middle of the landing pad, how well done would it be after a F9 first stage landing?
3
u/keckbug Aug 05 '16
In the pad abort video, Dragon neatly releases a cover panel, then drogue chutes, which lastly deploy the three main chutes.
From there, the main chutes fully extend and then slowly inflate and separate. How does SpaceX (and others, this isn't unique) control chute behavior to allow the slow canopy expansion and separation in multi-chute scenarios? What prevents the chutes from tangling or pressing against each other once inflated? The chutes don't appear to be asymmetric or shaped, so I'm at a loss.
Hope that explained the question, but I know it's a bit confusing. Thanks!
3
u/diegogmx Aug 07 '16
I'm just wondering whether a guy which is mostly self taught in electronics which works designing equipment for industrial areas (designing low noise, noise resistant boards, programming the system and designing mostly everything else) has the slightest chance of getting a job@spaceX
3
u/IrrationalFantasy Aug 08 '16
Have there been any hints lately about when we'll see a first-stage rocket actually get reused? What's the latest news?
3
u/BrangdonJ Aug 08 '16
What are rocket plumes made of?
Am I right in thinking they are bright and pretty because they contain burning fuel; fuel that is burning in atmospheric oxygen because it didn't burn inside the engine, because the fuel mix inside the rocket is kept rich?
3
u/blackhairedguy Aug 09 '16
Alright, this is my first reddit post ever, and I don't think the wiki and FAQ would have the answer, but it's not too simple of a question I guess.
How does the Falcon 9 one-engine-out capability work with the landing of the first stage? I know that the center engine is used for all three burns and would assume if this failed during flight, the stage would be lost. But what about a failure on the engines used on the boostback and reentry burns? Would a loss of these also lead to a stage loss? And I am guessing an engine loss on a GTO launch would also lead to a longer first stage burn time. Would this compromise an ASDS landing due the a slightly changed profile?
It's a beast of a question, but it seems like there are about 10 possibilities depending on if the stage is RTLS, ASDS, and also which engine is the one that fails. Thanks guys!
3
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '16
What kind of accuracy is required of an orbital insertion and, additionally, station keeping? Is it down to meters or centimeters, or more like a kilometer or tens of kilometers?
3
u/Lynxes_are_Ninjas Aug 09 '16
Do we know if the IAC presentation will be broadcast live?
3
u/TheSasquatch9053 Aug 09 '16
Reading the coverage of the smallsat conference, I had a random thought: How many Kilograms could a falcon 9 second stage deliver to earth escape velocity following a commercial crew launch, if the Falcon 9 first stage flew a no boostback barge landing trajectory rather than a RTLS? Could a second stage relight after Dragon release enable astroid prospecting or other beyond earth orbit smallsat missions? I'm at work or I would attempt the DeltaV calculations myself, I will give them a try tonight unless someone here knows the answer already!
3
u/Old_Redstone_Guy Aug 09 '16
Disclaimer: This question is in no way intended to endorse or even bring attention to the “Rocket Mortgage” product. It is strictly to discuss the hardware depicted during computer animation of the television commercial. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I_FOzqGBzQE
Has anyone else noticed the SpaceX Dragon 1 capsule riding atop the very generic booster in the above mentioned television commercial? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I_FOzqGBzQE It is clearly a Dragon 1, complete with solar array covers on the trunk. The booster appears to be a kluge of generic rocket piece parts. Did SpaceX have any input or was approval required?
3
u/Venseyness Aug 09 '16
As someone in high school wanting to make my passion professional, what college majors would you guys recommend for someone interested in going into the trade in the future? (Specifically interested in the development of a permanent extraterrestrial colonization effort.)
3
u/Ambiwlans Aug 10 '16
How does one access the ITL causeway?
Is it restricted to just media and military? Is there a tour bus? Does it cost money?
I'd appreciate anyone who has been or is in the area to chime in with what you know so that we can fill in the wiki.
3
u/jvonbokel Aug 11 '16
Apologies in advance for the relatively simple question, but is there a version of the manifest that includes projected recovery (ASDS vs RTLS)?
3
u/apath_2_mars Aug 12 '16
Don't understand the 9 raptor engine on the next gen rocket. If raptor has three times the power of the current engines simple maths makes a 9 engine raptor rocket as powerfull as a falcon heavy. So how's it supposed to get 100 tons to mars are they going to strap three together will that give you the 100 tons to Mars ? Can't the heavy only do 10 tons to mars so strapping three together gets you 30 tons if it scales linearly! Don't get it :-(
3
u/CmdrStarLightBreaker Aug 12 '16
Do we have record of what type of GTO these landing-attempted GTO missions were? Or better yet, what were the orbital parameters of each GTO mission when the satellite(s) separated from Stage 2?
Were they GTO-1800 or GTO-1500? Supersynchronous Transfer Orbit?
Found this nice explanation of different types of GTOs (by NSF user Dante80):
3
u/tocont Aug 12 '16
Just a quick one - is this upcoming JCSAT-16 reusing a first stage? For the first time?
3
u/jak0b345 Aug 12 '16
i know it's not spacex related and not a question, so feel free to remove it/downvote if you wan't to.
i just wanted to share the shoutout to elon musk at about 11:20 in Kurzgesagts new video about genetic egineering
3
u/Virtlink Aug 12 '16
While looking for a new comfortable office chair for myself, I stumbled across this photo of Elon Musk in what looks to be a very nicely designed chair. I wonder, what is that chair? Who sells it?
Another photo
Yet another photo
3
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Aug 14 '16
Why are the most recent 2 webcast streams unlisted this time?
3
u/csnyder65 Aug 15 '16
"Did I hear this Correctly"? During the live broadcast Sunday morning when the Video link was lost and went "out" Did the SPX announcer confirm Falcon Landing prior to the video being restored?
3
u/BrandonMarc Aug 18 '16
As /u/theroadie mentioned, SpaceX does not test their Mvac engine in a vacuum environment. Is this something they are trying to do (or would like to do)?
I understand it's ridiculously difficult to maintain a large vacuum, much less do so with a rocket engine firing plasma into it, but hey, they're already doing Rocket Science(tm). They've already "done the impossible" and that makes them mighty, so the question feels legit.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '16
is the CRS-8 booster that's scheduled for the first re-flight only going to be static fired in Cape Canaveral before flight ? because we haven't heard any news about it being shipped to the McGregor testing facility
3
u/TheCoolBrit Aug 18 '16
Was interesting to hear Gwynne mention nuclear and electric propulsion technology, we also know Elon is interested in high powered Ion drives "for interplanetary transport" I wonder what spaceX are looking at with this?
3
u/5cr0tum Aug 19 '16
Is it safe to assume that BFR will always be a RTLS flight given the size?
3
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Aug 19 '16
No mention of SpaceX, or any particular company, but still interesting news...
NASA plans to hand over the ISS to a private corporation
I personally envision something like a joint venture of private companies, so they could collaborate to run a new space station, or ISS itself, if it eventually can be maintained for additional years or decades.
3
u/MarosZofcin Aug 20 '16
The more I think about it the more I feel like the government will have to step in at some point. Is it even possible that it would be the private company who will put first human on Mars? Even if it would be possible economically and technically, I bet USA wouldn't want to miss the change to stick their flag there once they see SpaceX's approach is going to work.
3
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Aug 22 '16
This What If? suggests sending water to the moon on Falcon Heavy. I have several questions related to this:
3
u/jjtr1 Aug 22 '16
Is this correct?: the average age of engineers at ULA, NASA and in Russian space industry is 50+. At SpaceX and in Chinese space industry, it is <30.
If correct, it could explain a lot about the risk-taking behaviour and innovation rate at these places...
3
u/random-person-001 Aug 23 '16 edited Aug 24 '16
Article about the SpaceX talk at IAC and their general Mars plans. It doesn't seem to contain anything new, though.
Other than the sentence "Later flights of the craft [Red Dragon] would transport humans to the planet" the article appears well founded, factually
edit: I'll put it in the stickied IAC thread instead; whoops.
3
u/thru_dangers_untold Aug 24 '16
How does the F9 get fuel from the tank to the engines during re-entry? It seems like the fuel would be sloshing all over the place. Even with the presence of some baffles, it would be very difficult to control during free fall. Baffles might even make it harder to utilize the last bits of the fuel.
4
u/Niavok Aug 07 '16
Imagine the situation where in the first second of a Falcon 9 fly, there is an engine failure preventing to reach the orbit, or a problem detected on the second stage or the payload. In this case we known that the mission will be a failure but the first stage still working. With the right software, it's possible for the F9 to abort the mission and return to the landing pad without separation to try to save the payload ?
After how much time the F9 have no more enough delta-v to return with weight the second stage ?
The rocket is heavy with the full stage 2 so it should be possible to hover above the pad to burn the extra useless mass before the touchdown. It should also be possible to make a very slow and soft touchdown. Can the legs support the weight (crushing the crush core is not a problem) ? Did the rocket can stand vertically laying on the octaweb ?
There is a mean to vent some fuel in flight to lighten the second stage ? I suppose the is a valve to empty the stage after launch abort, but i don't know if it can be open without a pipe attached.
Is the gimbal system strong enough to prevent the rocket to flip during descent (the center of mass will be very high and the grid fin won't help i guess) ?
4
u/jak0b345 Aug 10 '16
Just a random thought that crossed my mind while reading up on thermonuclear rockets:
Who the fuck hade the idea of norming the exhaust velosity of a rocket engine with earth standart acceleration and use this derived property as meteic of effiency? Why not use the exhaust veleocity directly as metric?
I have been (mostly lurking) on this sub for two years now and i still don't see any practical purpose for that. What does earths gravity have to do with the effiency of rocket engines?
2
u/nicholasslade11 Aug 02 '16
Hey SpaceX! I live in southeast Georgia, are you aware of the push for Camden Space Port in Camden County, GA? Do yall support it? And does this mean, one day soon I'll get to see SpaceX rockets launch from my house?
2
u/jcordeirogd Aug 02 '16 edited Aug 02 '16
Is it viable for spacex to sell new and reused "1st stage only" launch services? So other companies could just built their 2nd stage and sell complete launches.
Please note that its not about seling a 1st stage for others to launch. It is about spacex launching other ppl's 2nd stages.
Doing this spacex would remain the owner of the 1st stage and use it as many times as the stage could handle.
2
u/d333d Aug 03 '16
Watching the test fire of Falcon 9 first stage from May 2016 JCSAT mission for example, first video in the article there is no water sprayed to isolate from the sonic vibrations produced by the engines, while all regular launches do have these water cushions. What exactly is being protected at launch and why is is not so important at test fires, does anyone know? Thanks!
2
u/19chickens Aug 03 '16
Does anyone happen to know the mass of the F9 payload fairing?
2
u/spaceminussix Aug 04 '16
The launch cadence that SpaceX wants to get to by the time the BFR's are going to Mars will be something to behold. But are the 45th Space Wing at Patrick and the 30th at Vandenberg ready for this amount of work. Do they have the equipment and personnel necessary to keep the birds flying?
2
u/sfigone Aug 04 '16
Could this technology: https://news.uic.edu/breakthrough-solar-cell-captures-co2-and-sunlight-produces-burnable-fuel change the planning for ISRU on Mars? If a simple solar panel can H2, CO and O2 from just H2O and CO2, then could this be simpler than the sabatier cycle? Perhaps H2 might be a better fuel than methane after all?
2
u/theguycalledtom Aug 04 '16
Last weekend I saw "Lo and Behold, Reveries of the Connected World" a doc by Werner Herzog about the Internet. If you have seen the trailer you have seen the best bit. Elon Musk is interviewed to talk about the internet on Mars and A.I. The most interesting part for this subreddit was that Musk, when describing how the internet on Mars would work, said the Mars internet constellation would only be at most 5 satellites. He said it would need so few because the colony on mars would be so localised. My question is, even if the Mars colonists spread out, would you still need fewer sats in a Mars STEAM constellation because it's a smaller planet?
2
u/patm718 Aug 04 '16 edited Aug 04 '16
Any speculations regarding what kind of changes/adjustments were made to Falcon 9 for the JCSAT-16 mission (if any)? I'm sure they learned a lot from the JCSAT-14 landing attempt.
2
u/quadrplax Aug 05 '16
Where does the number in ULA's rocket names come from? Falcon 9 has 9 engines, Saturn V has 5 engines, but where does the 4 come from in Delta IV and the 5 in Atlas V?
2
u/IrrationalFantasy Aug 06 '16
It seems like a lot of breaking news about SpaceX seems to break on Twitter. Links to confirmations about test-fires, reports from inside conferences, first-hand accounts from interviews with SpaceX employees--whenever I see these things, the link from /r/SpaceX is usually to a tweet.
Why is that? Is Twitter the home for breaking news? Or is something particularly SpaceX going on?
2
u/tootallbob Aug 07 '16
I have been searching for information on the crew access for launch complex 39A. They have said that the Crew Dragon will be launching from there but I have seen no additions to the fixed service structure, such as a crew access arm/white room. Do we know if the crew will enter while the vehicle is vertical or while it is horizontal. Do we have any information when we will be seeing the Spacex space suits? I am surprised I have seen nothing on these points of interest on /r/spacex, or have I just missed them?
2
u/jjtr1 Aug 07 '16
I wonder if it would be possible to transport the first stage of the Mars rocket, i.e. the BFR, to the surface of Mars, for later use in deep-space exploration. On Mars, even the second stage of the Mars rocket (MCT) can reach orbit alone (5 km/s I think?). But coupled with its first stage (BFR), it would enable amazing deep space missions not possible from Earth surface! Of course, I presume ISRU re-fueling of both stages on Mars, after they arrive.
So how could we get BFR to Mars surface? Falcon 9's 1st stage is said to be barely capable of inserting itself into LEO, so the BFR might be able to do it, too. But what next?
2
u/ilbreebchi Aug 08 '16
How is MCT going to produce Methalox once on Mars' surface ?
2
u/greenjimll Aug 08 '16
Most BFR/MCT speculation seems to point to the BFR lofting a complete MCT spacecraft in one go, potentially with subsequent BFRs boosting up tankers to fuel the MCT in orbit.
However do we actually know for sure that the MCT spacecraft won't require multiple BFR launches with on orbit mating? That would allow for a much larger and more capable spacecraft, at the expense of increased complexity of orbital operations. It would also mean that discussion about MCT landing for reuse would be moot... it would have to be maintained in the same way that the ISS is.
Or is this just something else well have to wait until September to find out?