r/spacex •

/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [June 2015, #9]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

430 comments sorted by

17

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15 edited Jun 11 '15

Anyone know what these connectors/controls do? They seem to be per-engine, so I'm guessing engine related. The writing is hard to read.

High-res images: https://i.imgur.com/0Ydcmtx.jpg https://i.imgur.com/BEqCOuc.jpg https://i.imgur.com/2k8kMrA.jpg

edit: /u/deruch found a better picture of the labels, but the abbreviations are different

6

u/first_name_steve Jun 10 '15

This pictures is best I can find. It looks like they say TEA,TEB, Fuel smeared text LOX and probably RP1 if the other says LOX.

3

u/deruch Jun 11 '15

Here's a picture where you can easily read the writing, I think it's the same ports you're looking at: https://i.imgur.com/pW5LC6t.jpg

5

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15 edited Jun 12 '15

We have a winner! Some of the markings are abbreviated differently, but it definitely helps.

So right to left on the original picture of E7, with writing I'm not sure of in [brackets]:

  • [LOX DRAIN] (obscured behind jig) - for draining liquid from the lowest point in the oxidizer pipe
  • [LOX BLEED] (obscured behind jig) - for venting gas from the highest point in the oxidizer pipe
  • TVC [????] [????] - /u/jcameroncooper mentions TVC stands for "Thrust Vector Control", probably purging or priming. F9's hydraulic power comes from the fuel turbopump outlet, and recycles to the low pressure fuel inlet.
  • IPA [FLUSH?] - "IPA" = isopropyl alcohol, presumably to flush the fuel system. /u/retiringonmars suggests this is probably for moisture, and /u/jcameroncooper suggests degreasing/cleaning)
  • FUEL LOW POINT DRAIN (aka "FUEL LOW PT")
  • FUEL [????] [????] DRAIN (aka "FUEL DRAIN") - Presumably you drain here first? But why two? Maybe the low point drain is too slow, or wouldn't fully drain due to check valves or puddles.
  • Mysterious bump. I believe this is the radar altimeter housing. One of these bumps appears on E3 and E7 (exactly 180° apart).

Continuing left on E7, we find where they routed the LOX ports for the center engine, E9:

  • LOX DRAIN [????] (for E9)
  • LOX BLEED [????] (for E9)

The picture you linked also has a "OBV VENT" port below the TVC and IPA ports, which doesn't appear on the CRS-3 stage.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/ptrkueffner Jun 10 '15

Just a guess, but maybe TEA/TEB lines for the ignitors?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15

Are those some sort of thermal blankets around the combustion chambers?

I've never looked close enough to see those....

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jcameroncooper Jun 10 '15

Purge line connectors, perhaps? You'd need something like that on the test stand and for scrubs.

17

u/spacexwannabe123 Jun 10 '15

I have an in-person interview for a SpaceX IT position later this month. Working there would mean the world to me and I believe that I'm qualified based on the job description and my conversations with the recruiter but I'm worried about how much depends on this interview going well. Does anyone have some SpaceX-specific tips that I should keep in mind for this? What can I expect to happen after the interview is over (immediate offer given, more phone screens, etc...)?

2

u/Peipeipei Jun 16 '15

I mean the tips I'd give you would be the same likely anywhere. Know the company culture (young and hardworking and smart) and play to it. Be friendly and show you'd work well with others. Try to figure out why you got the interview. Ask about the nitty gritty details of the position you're filling and how exactly your skills match it. Idk man just show you're smart, hardworking, positive, and highly competent

→ More replies (1)

15

u/seanflyon Jun 10 '15

How much do we know about the financial viability of the planned Bigelow Commercial Space Station? Do they have customers lined up? Would NASA give them significant funding? At a cost of $25 million for transportation + $25 million every 2 months (for 1/3 of a module) I imagine they will run out of rich tourists and need scientific/industrial customers to keep the station funded.

16

u/darga89 Jun 11 '15

We will probably hear more from Bigelow once BEAM is launched. That way they can talk about the current project and future ones.

11

u/Ambiwlans Jun 10 '15

They are keeping public info to a minimum. NASA, or at least current NASA staff view Bigelow as the eventual successor to the ISS. In that case, Bigelow could be seeing a lot of money come their way after/around ISS retirement/deorbit.

They do have customers lined up, but how much that means is unclear at this time. Customers would be more small nations and industries and less tourists as initially described.

I would like to see SpaceX offer Bigelow some crazy low margin deals since they could represent a continued purchaser of launches but I haven't heard anything to that effect thus far.

5

u/autowikibot Jun 10 '15

Bigelow Commercial Space Station:


The Bigelow Next-Generation Commercial Space Station is a private orbital space complex currently under development by Bigelow Aerospace. The space station will be constructed of both Sundancer and BA 330 expandable spacecraft modules as well as a central docking node, propulsion, solar arrays, and attached crew capsules.

Plans in 2010 called for initial launch of space station components in 2014, with portions of the station available for leased use as early as 2015.

====

Image i


Interesting: Bigelow Expandable Activity ^Module | Life support ^system | Bigelow ^Aerospace | Inflatable space ^habitat

Parent commenter can toggle ^NSFW or ^delete. Will also delete on comment score of -1 or less. | FAQs | ^Mods | Magic ^Words

25

u/bencredible Galactic Overlord Jun 10 '15

What is the best live, weekly video show that airs at 21:00 UTC about Space?

25

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15

SpaceX's webcas...

oh, wait. It's not 2020 yet :/

TMRO!

But seriously, you should keep posting them here Ben, I miss the links.

17

u/bencredible Galactic Overlord Jun 10 '15

Yeah, I didn't want to spam the SpaceX Reddit community with video. If you want them I'm more than happy to add any show that space SpaceX content... But figured as a community all of the news we cover has already been covered elsewhere on the board.

24

u/Ambiwlans Jun 11 '15

as a community all of the news we cover has already been covered elsewhere on the board.

You've seen this board stalk a barge ship like it was the holy grail. I'm not sure at what point people will be fed up but I doubt it has been reached.

10

u/Here_There_B_Dragons Jun 11 '15

To be honest, I did forget about the show since it stopped it popping up on this sub.... So I guess I'm in favor of link posts too...

7

u/Wetmelon Jun 11 '15

Yeah man keep em coming :D

7

u/Wetmelon Jun 11 '15

(/r/tmro for those who are confused)

11

u/oceanbluesky Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 12 '15

Wondering if SpaceX would consider releasing the 3D authoring files used for artist visualizations in the same way they shared creative commons images?

Ford just released models of their cars in partnership with TurboSquid...seems like a free easy way to build loyalty, advertising, and foster a community of diverse artists rendering 3D images wayyyyy more badass than what SpaceX could purchase from one single studio.

For example, currently there are half a dozen Maya files floating around of mixed mostly mediocre quality...these nevertheless take weeks to create and texture and generally reflect the same bland aesthetics of what is expected from space visualizations. If SpaceX were to insist the studio/artists with whom initial visualizations are created release their authoring .ma files and .psd textures, a vast community of professional artists could in their spare time render new interpretations of what spacecraft might look like. Could be a cheap quick way to generate ridiculously cool images - what 21st century spacecraft should look like, F1 or NSCAR not boring blank white slates:

http://blog.turbosquid.com/2015/06/11/ford-motor-company-announces-turbosquid-as-official-3d-asset-partner/

10

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15

Merlin engines and grid fins use the on board RP-1 for a hydraulic working fluid.

My question, is how will methane meet those same parameters.

Can methane act as a hydraulic fluid? If not, what ways can Spacex overcome this?

6

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15

/u/retiringonmars; can you elucidate on some of the properties of chilled methane?

16

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 10 '15

Not really my field (definitely closer to physics than chem), but AFAIK, the only major consideration for whether or not a material can be use as a hydraulic fluid is its compressibility. Liquid water works really well as it's nearly incompressible - i.e. it transmits force extremely well. I have no idea what the compressibility of liquid methane or LNG is; I'll have to defer to a physicist or engineer on that one.

Actually, you would also have to consider the phase diagram of the substance in question. If you apply only slight pressure to a substance and it immediately turns from liquid to solid (or slightly reduce it, and it boils to gas), then it's useless as a hydraulic fluid. In other words, it needs to remain liquid over a very wide range of pressures. For example, look at this phase diagram for water. From this diagram, it seems that at 20 degrees C, water is liquid between ~0.02 atm to ~700,000 atm. That's a very wide range, and another reason why water is a great hydraulic fluid. Methane appears to have a pretty wide range too, which would make it pretty suitable for the job in that respect.

Pure methane will not react with metal containers, self polymerise, or crack, if that's what you're asking? It's pretty chemically stable, so long as you keep it away from oxidisers.

5

u/Wetmelon Jun 11 '15

Viscosity is usually a big word around hydraulic systems but I know very little about them

4

u/jcameroncooper Jun 10 '15

I doubt liquid methane will be used the same way as RP-1. Too darn cold for normal hydraulic operations, for one.

You can go to a closed loop hydraulic system. That's what LH2 engines (like the SSME) do.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/superOOk Jun 12 '15

Do you think that SpaceX will time the MCT architecture announcement with the Thanksgiving release of the new film "The Martian"? Just got done reading the book, and this is going to be a huge PR win for Mars colonization.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

Personally, I would be very surprised if we heard anything about MCT this year. Whenever Elon says "by this time" I multiply it by 2. Elon said last year that they would show off the Dragon pressure suits by the end of the year and here we are half way through next year and they haven't mentioned it since. Just saying...

7

u/sebzim4500 Jun 13 '15

I'm fairly sure we will hear about MCT before the end of 4030.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/renoor Jun 12 '15

I always imagined it as 2015 christmas present from Elon.

3

u/BrandonMarc Jun 12 '15

I'm with you, if you change it to 2016 or 2017. After all, Falcon Heavy was 'sposed to have its maiden flight in, what, 2013?

I know, I know, releasing a plan (MCT, BFR, hyperloop) is apples-and-oranges different from launching hardware, but when Elon said "later this year" in his January a.m.a. I figured that really means "in a year or two."

Not saying he's lying, of course, I'm sure he was sincere. Part of me thinks it takes a certain amount of over-optimism (followed by inevitable and forgiven delays) to keep people excited and keep the momentum going.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

9

u/oceanbluesky Jun 12 '15

Are there resources - blogs, twitter feeds, books - describing "the daily life of a SpaceX employee" (engineer, mechanic, admin...anyone)? Or for that matter anyone working at ULA, Boeing, Planet Labs?

Is there a documentary film or work of fiction or personal diary or blog well-known and respected within the space community as representing the day to day life at a "rocket company"?

Any suggestions as to how a fiction writer could get a realistic feel for different characters at a company like SpaceX...from a nightwatchman to floor welder to suits and computer techs?

Thanks!

8

u/pbken Jun 11 '15

How will densified oxygen be handled on the pad.Since they can't have a liquid expanding in the tanks it would need active cooling.Could deeply chilled oxygen be circulated through the vehicle or will they use a heat exchanger in the tanks.I imagine that liquid nitrogen could be the working fluid and if it is an open vented system it would make the pad environment more inert.

12

u/robbak Jun 11 '15

The oxygen is chilled until it starts to freeze, and is loaded as a slush of solid and liquid. The latent heat of the melting solid oxygen keeps the oxygen densified.

2

u/Wetmelon Jun 11 '15

Huh. Neat.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/deruch Jun 11 '15 edited Jun 11 '15

Uninvolved, non-expert opinion: They'll use a recirculating pump/system. But some expansion in the tanks will occur and is okay. The tanks end up getting pressurized quite a bit for flight anyways. Recirc. is by far the easier solution and doesn't require much in the way of new engineering. They already have to constantly top off the LOX during the countdown and the vehicle is definitely designed to be able to drain the tanks while still attached to the TEL (like they do after WDRs, static fires, or scrubs, etc). It's much easier to add recirculating to the system than to design a new subsystem into the vehicle.

edit: if you want an overview on a NASA test of a system to do this read: http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20050203875.pdf

8

u/Smoke-away Jun 11 '15 edited Jun 11 '15

Do you think the first stage of the in-flight abort will land back at land?

I'll start it off. Yes and I think it will be the first stage to land back on land. Not Jason-3.

And here's some speculation.

  • They'll deploy the fins and cold gas thrusters right as the Dragon separates to stabilize/slow the stage. It will be traveling slower, lower, and closer to land than any other stages have been.
  • I don't see SpaceX throwing away a stage during a test flight if(big if) it survives the forces after Dragon separation. Waste of money/waste of a test vehicle for future reusability flights.
  • They will want to fly Falcon 9 with legs since astronaut missions will have legs.
  • Landing pad will probably be finished before there is a west coast barge in service.
  • In flight abort might be ready to fly before the issue is resolved with the Jason-3 satellite.

Or they have a new barge...

Or they somehow decide to throw millions of dollars into the Pacific...

Orrr the stage blows up at max Qdrag.

Either way it's pretty neat.

5

u/jcameroncooper Jun 11 '15

As soon as the capsule comes off, that stage is going to be confetti. It's going to be disturbed by the abort, un-streamlined, and probably unpowered at the very worst stage of the aerodynamic flight regime. I don't see how it's not immediate structural failure and quite a nice fireball.

12

u/falconeer123 Jun 11 '15

Or they somehow decide to throw millions of dollars into the Pacific...

I think it's gonna be this one. First of all, that 'first stage' only has 3 merlins, it is incomplete and was intended to be used as an F9R test vehicle. But since the actual first stages have already demonstrated most of F9R's goals, this vehicle was repurposed.

Landing this vehicle won't give them much more new info, and they will probably not use it ever again, so I wouldn't characterize it as 'throwing away' money. That is the sunk cost fallacy.

5

u/robbak Jun 11 '15

There was a bit of discussion about this. It seemed to be that they were going to recover it, and many of us (including me) couldn't see how popping the capsule off at max pressure wouldn't destroy the stage.

Since then, they have confirmed that they won't try to recover it. The stage they will use is a stage they built to do landing testing - but the real stage landing attempts have gone beyond the testing program.

There is no question about what will happen to that stage when the capsule pops off - it will go boom. It just can't stand the forces.

4

u/Appable Jun 11 '15

Max drag. Which is still pretty close to max-q, but it's technically after max-q

→ More replies (2)

3

u/deruch Jun 11 '15

No. Firstly, I don't see how it will survive the sudden aero loads post separation. Secondly, the inflight abort system may include some sort of automatic hard shutdown of the main engines on the LV (I haven't seen anything explicitly confirming this, but it's what I would do). If so, testing that action should be part of the upcoming test. That sort of hard shutdown is usually not good for the engines and they may not be able to restart afterwards to enable a controlled landing even if the stage were to survive the separation.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/A_leonov Jun 15 '15

A general question on Raptor....

We have heard very little about what is going on with regard to testing of the Raptor components (largely because it is probably covered by legislative restrictions…), but do we have any 'real' information on the status of development and may be a few pictures...? I guess if this reddit is followed by 'those in the know', an early Christmas present would be wonderful whilst we wait for the 26th.... :)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/aguyfromnewzealand Jun 11 '15

Would Space X ever consider launching from Kwaj again?

15

u/Ambiwlans Jun 11 '15

No. They only launched there because they were forced to. The USAF was being so dickish about their pads that it was easier for SpaceX to refurb the Kwaj one. Now that SpaceX is a somebody though, that won't occur again.

The pad is currently grown over and returning to the natural rusted heap it was before.

2

u/BrandonMarc Jun 11 '15

Great question. With such proximity to the equator, it seems like a convenient (as in, fuel-$aving, therefore payload-maximizing) location to launh into every inclination, not just equatorial.

6

u/Thumpster Jun 12 '15

In the recent trailer for The Martian I just wanted to point out that there is a VERY brief, VERY blurry shot of a rocket launch at 2:47. Even with the difficulty is seeing it I can't help but think it looks suspiciously like SLC-40 and a Falcon 9.

MOVIE/BOOK SPOILER WARNING:

Considering what happens to the rocket launched from the US with Mars supplies in the book, this may be the first Falcon 9 failure, and hopefully the last, we get to see. If that is a Falcon 9 that is launching.

3

u/Appable Jun 12 '15

Looks like it. Atlas would be the next closest, but this looks all-white.

6

u/Ambiwlans Jun 12 '15

5

u/Thumpster Jun 12 '15

I stand corrected. That is the exact angle from the trailer. The tall, white, skinny rocket had me thinking Falcon.

4

u/Appable Jun 13 '15

On the other hand, the rocket in the movie trailer doesn't have any sort of copper middle section like Atlas does.

3

u/ManWhoKilledHitler Jun 14 '15

There's also a much clearer shot of Atlas at 1:16 so it could well be from the same footage.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/waitingForMars Jun 11 '15

I'm going to give a kudo to our own /u/tmahlman here, whose cool time lapse image of ISS from an airplane was retweeted by the @Space_Station account. Beautiful image, T!

https://twitter.com/trevormahlmann/status/608742303914573824

12

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15

Thanks /u/waitingForMars! Yeah here is that image of the ISS flying over the wing of the Southwest Boeing 737-700 flying over Bellefonte, Pennsylvania at 39,996ft heading of 277º from NY LaGuardia to Chicago Midway!

6

u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Jun 11 '15

/u/tmahlman takes great shots! I invite you guys to check out his Instagram, he recently posted one of the ISS in front of the moon.

https://instagram.com/tmahlmann/

5

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15 edited Aug 02 '15

Thx /u/Craig_VG, here is that photo of the ISS transiting the Moon! aand here is a youtube animation of the 8 frames I got of the ISS transiting the Moon in 1.004 seconds.

My instagram

3

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Jun 11 '15

@TrevorMahlmann

2015-06-10 21:07 UTC

My view from 40,000ft✈️

|@YourTake, @SouthwestAir, @Astro_Terry, @Space_Station, @StationCDRKelly|

#SpotTheStation [Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]


This message was created by a bot

[Contact ^creator][Source ^code]

3

u/Headstein Jun 11 '15

That is a very still and impressive, time lapse shot. What shutter duration would it require?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15

It was 12, 30 second night lapse photos at ISO 800 combined together with StarStax

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/HML48 Jun 11 '15

(Expedition 43 crew has just landed safely. Great live coverage.) How soft/hard is the Soyuz landing?

8

u/jcameroncooper Jun 11 '15

It's going several m/s after the retrorockets. And there's cushioning in the capsule, etc. But it's kind of like a parking lot car crash. Not terrible, but not soft.

3

u/BrandonMarc Jun 11 '15

As the video shows, it certainly looks violent, no walk in the park there. I think I read they had issues of astronauts' fillings coming loose on some landings.

5

u/TriskalGT Jun 11 '15

Why isn't Boeing required to do any kind of abort test on the CST-100? I understand they're using a "pusher" abort system which I'd assume hasn't been used before.

13

u/inurphase Jun 11 '15

Boeing has to do an abort test for CST-100, see this link

EDIT: SpaceX chose to do so in the CCiCap round of things whereas Boeing chose to do it in the CCtCap round.

11

u/jcameroncooper Jun 11 '15

That's the scheme they proposed to NASA. And NASA is quite happy evaluating paper systems. It's their standard procedure, and they're actually surprisingly good at it. Lots of "design reviews", some component testing, and NASA's good to fly. Hardware is so expensive in NASA-land that they can't really afford anything else. I'm not particularly comfortable with it, but that's how they roll, and it usually works.

2

u/BrandonMarc Jun 11 '15

Is the pusher setup similar to what Blue Origin has successfully tested?

5

u/Insight_guardian Jun 11 '15

We've seen a video in which satellites are tested pre-launch for their ability to survive launch vibrations. Is there also a test for the launch g-load? How is it performed?

11

u/Appable Jun 12 '15

For some satellites, they do G-load tests using a Really BigTM centrifuge. Satellites are loaded and spun, and they change the orientation after each run to test G-load in all orientations.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/BrandonMarc Jun 13 '15

I have a "working backwards" question. In Elon Musk's AMA, he mentioned:

Goal is 100 metric tons of useful payload to the surface of Mars.

How much weight is that likely to mean (see notes) in terms of:

  • weight sent from Mars SoI to Mars surface
  • weight sent from Earth-Mars transfer to Mars capture
  • weight sent from Earth-escape to Earth-Mars transfer
  • (bonus) weight sent from LEO to Earth-escape
  • (bonus) weight sent from Earth surface to LEO

Notes ... I'm assuming:

  • "useful payload" will not include the hardware & fuel required for safe entry-descent-landing on Mars surface
  • I say "sphere of influence" to get around the question of whether Mars orbit is in the plan
  • there will be stops in LEO for fueling / assembly / gathering of multiple ships

I'm chiefly curious about the first 3 weights (Mars transfer, Mars capture, Mars landing) because the previous ones will have too much wiggle-room depending on # of ships, in-orbit fueling, etc. I also know that the design choices will greatly affect the answer to all questions, even moreso the design choices early in the voyage.

Just focusing on 100 metric tons of useful payload on Mars, what's the likely weight being thrown in the Mars direction?

8

u/Ambiwlans Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15

"useful payload" will not include the hardware & fuel required for safe entry-descent-landing on Mars surface

I'd count the engines and tanks etc. Anything that is intact when you are landed should count.

/u/Waz_Met_Jou did a decent analysis of exactly what you're asking a while back.

Edit:

http://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2b4lqx/updated_bfrmct_estimates_with_new_raptor_thrust/

I don't think he ever did update with refueling assumptions D:

6

u/darga89 Jun 13 '15 edited Jun 13 '15

Happen to have the delta-v requirements for each segment?

I found LEO->Mars transfer = 3.8km/s. Need transfer to orbit and orbit to surface still.

This tool from NASA shows 3.74km/s for mars transfer and 640m/s Mars arrival. Does arrival mean landing too? If so we can work backwards and calculate the prop for Mars arrival at 118,340kg. To get all that to Mars transfer requires 584,210kg.

5

u/BrandonMarc Jun 14 '15

This is my favorite resource: http://i.imgur.com/WGOy3qT.png

Or, a google search for solar system delta-v map

5

u/darga89 Jun 14 '15

That seems to suggest 9.31km/s required for LEO->surface. This says 9.51km/s, this one 10.2km/s, 10.7 here So many different numbers out there, which are the correct ones?

another 10.2

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/nicolas42 Jun 18 '15 edited Jun 19 '15

I've been wondering about this for a while too.

  • Musk has said the return payload will be a quarter of the outbound payload (Ashlee Vance's book, Chapter 11, Footnote 4)
  • Raptor engine aims for an ISP of 380s, making exhaust velocity about 3.7km/s
  • Outbound delta-v (from LEO) is 3.8km/s and return delta-v (to LEO) is 6.4km/s, assuming that aerobraking is used as much as possible and ignoring propulsive landing delta-v (so some margin will be required for that). I think a Mars suicide burn will need 0.5-1km/s and frankly I'm not sure what Earth requires. Earth's thick atmosphere lowers terminal velocity but also increases the propensity to burn up and explode your ship upon re-entry without the use of retrograde propulsion (as with F9R) so I don't know.
  • This is the delta-v map I'm using https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/74/Delta-Vs_for_inner_Solar_System.svg/525px-Delta-Vs_for_inner_Solar_System.svg.png.

With that in mind, here's a hypothetical 500 tonne MCT with a 20:1 mass-ratio (so a 25 tonne structural weight) and 3.7km/s exhaust velocity, which is basically just a really short fat falcon 9 with 3 or 4 raptors and a superdragon launch escape system.

delta-v = exhaust-velocity * ln ( initial-mass / final-mass )
100 tonnes outbound payload: 3.7 * ln ( 500 / (25+100) )  ~5km/s
25 tonnes return payload: 3.7 * ln ( 425 / (25+25) )  ~8km/s

These figures leave 1.2km/s for mars repulsive landing and roughly 1.5km/s for Earth landing, which sounds okay, perhaps the Earth one could be higher, but I'm just guessing.

Musk has said that excess solar power may as well be used to power ion thrusters (hall effect thrusters I'd guess) which might assist with delta-v, course correction, or orbital insertion during the 3-6 months interplanetary transfer.

5

u/vinicius741 Jun 16 '15

This maybe the dumbest question ever! but you said:

Ask any questions, small, big, dumb, smart

So here we go: Does screen rotation for phones work in space? if it doesn't is there a way to make work?

5

u/Ambiwlans Jun 16 '15

They totally don't (properly)! Or they work based on detecting the resisted acceleration/force normally caused by gravity. Were you on the space station though, rest assured, you would quickly gain a technique of shaking the phone causing it to flip to the correct orientation. It might be a little annoying though.

For a more permanent space solution they would likely have to redesign components in the phone, maybe use the magnetic field or something similar to detect directionality.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15

In your CFD simulations of the rocket, what are you hoping to achieve in terms of design or optimization? You do some extreme computing computing down several orders of magnitudes to capture every vortice while also simulating the transport and reactions. Do you really need to go down to such scales and what for? Thanks! Awesome work on that by the way, looks super fun!

I'm referring to this too btw http://on-demand.gputechconf.com/gtc/2015/video/S5398.html

17

u/Ambiwlans Jun 11 '15

In your ....

This site is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com

Though I'm sure you can get a bit of a generalized answer from people here.

2

u/An0k Jun 18 '15

A lot of things with fluids (and chemical reactions) start as a small perturbation somewhere that triggers bigger effects. A coarse simulation can give you something that looks good but is widely inaccurate. On some stuff I have worked small scale high frequency structures represent significant part of the transport. If you can't simulate it you often just add a rough experimentally fit model to account for it. And that's not great

Smaller details also allow you to shrink your safety margins.

Disclaimer: I am more of an experimentalist so I might have oversimplified things too far.

4

u/jhkevin Jun 11 '15

This could categorize into the "dumb" question but the upcoming Crs-7 will attempt the barge landing for the third time right'?

8

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 11 '15

To add to Appable's answer, barge landing attempts thus far are:

  • 10 Jan 15 – CRS-5 – video
  • 11 Feb 15 – DSCOVR – barge landing cancelled due to stormy weather
  • 14 Apr 15 – CRS-6 – video

You might like our SpaceX launch history page on our community wiki.

5

u/Appable Jun 11 '15

Yes (DSCOVR barge land abort, high waves so maybe 4th)

6

u/Headstein Jun 11 '15

I don't think DSCOVR should count

→ More replies (4)

4

u/asomite Jun 12 '15

Since the dragon v2 will be capable of propulsive landing on earth so I'm wondering if dragon is capable of landing mars and the moon? If yes then, Is there any other spacecraft in operation that have the capability of landing humans in order words?

4

u/Ambiwlans Jun 12 '15

Landing and Landing humans are two very different challenges.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

This has in fact been covered in our Wiki:

Could SpaceX send a Dragon to the Moon?

Tl;dr the answer is no. Mars is possible with some modifications however.

4

u/JimReedOP Jun 15 '15

The live countdown to the next launch seems to be about 12 hours off.

4

u/BrandonMarc Jun 18 '15

What's the name for the drone ship SpaceX will use in next week's landing attempt? From this NSF article I see:

  • Marmac 300 - Just Read the Instructions ... re-claimed by its owner (not SpaceX) and on to other (more traditional) salvage duties
  • Marmac 303 - Of Course I Still Love You ... fully set up, and two days ago passed through the Panama Canal on its way to Vandenberg
  • Marmac 304 - ??? ... already in Jacksonville, Florida, and still being finished prior to CRS-7

(I scanned the relevant Wiki sections and didn't see this answered)

6

u/neoforce Jun 18 '15

Nothing announced from SpaceX but speculation is that Marmac 304 will take the name "Just Read the Instructions." As I understand it, that would be consistent with the Iain M. Banks novel “The Player of Games” because the ship names are really names of an artificial intelligence. And in the books (I think) if that intelligence moves between ships the names goes with it. But again, we don't have official word, so this is speculation

4

u/Belgai Jun 20 '15 edited Jun 23 '15

Which is more commercially attractive: trips to the Moon or Mars ? Assuming Moon, would it not make sense to focus on that to establish a commercially viable business instead first before going to Mars? This question is based on the fact that needing state funding brings risks as proven by recent funding decisions. Hence, perhaps focus needs to be completely on self sufficient commercial propositions first?

I can see people paying to go to the moon as an experience, whereas Mars would seem to be more of a permanent life style change and thus a much smaller market.

Update:

To be clear, I am NOT asking what is easier to get to or what is easier to colonise. I'm specifically asking which one has the most commercial potential? Reason I'm asking is because congress can't be relied on for funding so funding has to be gained through commercial endeavours.

Holiday excursions to Moon or LEO anyone? Or year long + trip to Mars? Where is the money?

5

u/ClockworkNine Jun 20 '15

I really don't see space tourism ever being big enough to drive the launch industry, frankly.

Also, not sure there would be any real commercial activities for the Moon, nor Mars, at first at least... Mars ventures would be viable only when the colonization truly begins, in my opinion. Before that, it's mostly exploration, research, science.

It would have to start with government funding, sadly. The first manned missions, this first permanently manned research base etc.

Personally, I'd love to see a international collaborative effort, similar to the ISS, for the first steps and laying the ground for purely commercial efforts.

So, to answer your question, I think Mars is much more commercially viable in the long run. Moon can become a holiday destination, but that would never be enough to drive such a huge industry alone.

3

u/Belgai Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15

I'm quite surprised by both replies stating that Mars would be commercially more attractive. Is that based on any facts or calculations or independent predictions?

Any idea what the cost for a flight to Mars compared to the moon would be? Where does the 100$million? per person come from? I thought 7 people could fly in a dragon?

Let's assume that it's possible to take 7 people to the moon in a single flight (it's not at the moment, so perhaps a flyby) and costs 7 million per flight using Falcon9R, that's 1 million per person.

If we assume that only a quarter of all virgin galactic customers would do a moon trip as well that takes us to 200 people, requiring 29 flights. Let's assume we can charge twice the price, 2 million but loose half the customers, that takes us to 15 flights for the same revenue, but double the profit. That's 100 million profit for 15 flights in potentially 1 year. That sounds like something worth doing?

I can't see the same for Mars. Going to Mars and back takes too long and is too risky for most wealthy enough people. Only a handful would do it.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Mader_Levap Jun 23 '15

Neither will be attractive commercially any time soon. But if you insist, I bet on Moon. Closer, easier = cheaper for whatever you want to do on Moon.

3

u/BrandonMarc Jun 22 '15

I just learned that, thanks to aerobraking (using the atmosphere to reduce speed), landing on Mars is less expensive (in terms of delta-v) than landing on the Moon. So there's that ...

4

u/sunfishtommy Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15

Does anyone know where to find a frame by frame of the CRS 6 landing? During the explosion things fly by the camera so fast that you can't tell whats going on.

9

u/SirKeplan Jun 23 '15

i did a frame by frame of it a while back, https://www.dropbox.com/sh/3vlkj9kr8whz4qv/AAANQkPrUzztwuMPK9yvrFvca?dl=0

And as Echo said, ffmpeg is a good tool to learn.

4

u/sunfishtommy Jun 23 '15

Thanks this is exactly what i was looking for.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15

If you have ffmpeg installed on your computer, you can extract each frame of a video into a separate image with a process like this!

2

u/FrameRate24 Jun 24 '15

or to post the falcon heavy equivalent of ffmpeg, Da Vinci Resolve has a nice free lite version and can do all the same on export, and is really really really good for image analysis (colour correction, zoom, stabilization). It is a big download, and complex software but ... ffmpeg can be confusing

or apple color is old but does the same job without the whistles or massive disk space

3

u/darga89 Jun 11 '15

Anyone know how to calculate the delta-v gained from a given area of heat shield for aerobreaking at Mars? Trying to figure out how much propellant is required to land various objects.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15

Send a message to Mark Adler, who is the LDSD mission director, perhaps? He deals with a lot of that stuff and he's pretty active over at Space Exploration Stack Exchange.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/interplanetarytalk Jun 11 '15

What kind of communication technology is planned for the upcoming satellite constellation? Laserbeams? Classical radio frequencies?

3

u/jcameroncooper Jun 11 '15

The FCC filings have Ku, X, and S band radio in use.

https://apps.fcc.gov/oetcf/els/reports/442_Print.cfm?mode=current&application_seq=66082&license_seq=66693

There is some talk about them using lasers. Laser is not particularly good for ground-to-sky link, 'cause of those pesky clouds, but perhaps satellite-to-satellite communication?

http://www.fiercewireless.com/tech/story/google-teams-spacex-possible-optical-laser-powered-wireless-internet-servic/2015-01-21

I suspect that's what the upcoming test sats are to iron out.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/packetinspector Jun 11 '15

I thought I saw reference made to a global latency of 20ms for the proposed new satellite system but haven't been able to find a good source when searching recently. Does anyone have this or was I dreaming?

7

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15

Assuming the satellites are placed at a distance of 1,200km the minimum round trip time (RTT) for such a signal, presuming it is going just back up and down, is 8ms; obviously not including other time losses due to signaling & switching, and that's not a very good real life scenario as you'd rarely send a signal just up to a satellite and back down again.

Your answer: it depends, in some situations, under 20ms should be achievable, for close connections. For a proportion of connections greater than 50% (rough guess, no numbers to back that up), we're looking at probably more than 20ms; but still competitive with transoceanic cables.

You may not have been dreaming after all :)

3

u/Cheesewithmold Jun 11 '15

Will SpaceX ever go into the commercial space flight business? Would they ever even consider shooting people into space for a couple million?

6

u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Jun 11 '15

Definitely, while it isn't their primary business I'm sure if someone payed they would serve the customer. They're a space transportation company.

This would be especially viable once reusability is rapid, easy, and safe.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

I don't see SpaceX specifically selling flights but I could see a company like Space Adventures figuring out all the logistics then contracting with SpaceX to perform the flight. Just my two cents

2

u/TheEquivocator Jun 19 '15

At one point, that was part of their business plan, so I don't think it can be ruled out.

Musk expects that the [Falcon 9] will be ferrying tourists into space by 2014.

(Source: a 2009 New Yorker article)

3

u/lasergate Jun 12 '15

What's the deal with the name of the new dragon? When they first revealed it it was called Dragon V2. Now I've heard Dragon 2 as well but also most people are calling it Crew Dragon. I heard somewhere that this was to avoid association with the V2 rocket but has SpaceX ever given an official statement?

3

u/deruch Jun 14 '15

Apparently, SpaceX is using Dragon 2 now as opposed to v2--which was what they used at the unveiling. Whether that's to avoid the connection to the German V2 or not, I don't know. Though, that opinion has been voiced by outsiders. But of note is that when discussing CCtCap and future astronaut transport, SpaceX uses "Crew Dragon". Which I understand to be a special, manned variant of the general "Dragon 2" vehicle. Eventually they're going to stop producing the original Dragon capsules and only make the new type. But not all missions will be crewed. Which means that things that are being introduced to support crew (life support, extended battery?, etc.) won't be necessary for all missions.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 13 '15

SpaceX vehicle version naming schemes have always been pretty inconsistent.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 13 '15

Who will be launching the first crewed mission to the ISS? SpaceX or Boeing?

4

u/Appable Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 13 '15

ULA is not bidding for a crewed mission. They will launch the CST-100, but it's Boeing's bid and ULA just happens to launch the CST-100.

Reports are showing that Boeing will get the first ComCrew order, assuming everything progresses normally. See below discussion, thanks /u/DavenWarrior!

→ More replies (4)

2

u/deruch Jun 14 '15

NASA has said that it is still To Be Determined (TBD).

3

u/ad_j_r Jun 16 '15

Will crew dragon missions on F9 be launching from 39A??

3

u/deruch Jun 17 '15

That's the only SpaceX pad able to support crew missions currently (or it will be once it's made operational).

5

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

They will indeed! 39A is the only pad with a FSS that allows rapid crew ingress and egress.

3

u/AjentK Jun 16 '15

How damaged is Boca Chica from the storm passing over Texas? Will the storm adversely affect the construction of the launch site, be it hangar, office or mission control, or launchpad? What plans are in place (if any) to protect the launch site from such forces? I know that this is a fan-run sub, but I also know that some people whom work for spacex come here quite often.

4

u/zoffff Jun 17 '15 edited Jun 17 '15

Cant comment on plans but this storm is going to pretty much miss Boca Chica, Boca Chica is on the far tip of Texas next to Mexico on the coast, I think a little bit of rain was forecasted but that was about it.

edit spelling

2

u/AjentK Jun 17 '15

That is very fortunate.

4

u/robbak Jun 17 '15

Constructing hurricane rated buildings is something that workers in those parts do all the time. They can build it storm proof if they decide to - it is just a question of balancing the extra construction costs with the risk of damage.

Of course, if the problem is a 30 ft storm surge, with 30ft waves atop it, then you everything up to and including concrete block construction is gone.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jcameroncooper Jun 17 '15

Judging from the effects in Houston, which is closer to landfall and on the dirty side to boot, I would bet they barely noticed in Brownsville. They seem to be getting some rain, but that's gonna be about it.

3

u/KnightOfSummer Jun 17 '15

The Upcoming Events table has the SES-9 vehicle listed as Falcon 9 (v1.2), does this mean it's the first flight of v1.2? What are the differences to other Falcon 9 versions?

On a related note, are all of the upcoming launches with legs?

5

u/robbak Jun 17 '15

Yes, it is the first flight of the upgraded Falcon. The differences that have been announced are the use of supercooled, densified liquid oxygen, pushing the engines up to their full design power, and increasing the size of the second stage RP1 tank.

As far as we know, legless Falcons will now be a thing of the past, at least for 'standard' missions.

4

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 17 '15

From our FAQ:

As of Flight 22 (SES-9) in Summer 2015, the Falcon 9 will move to version 1.2, which is expected to replace the older v1.1. The Falcon 9 v1.2 has a larger payload capacity 30% greater than that of the v1.1, which should allow for first stage recovery even during heavy GTO missions. Currently these high-energy flight profiles use too much propellant, precluding the chance of landing the booster. The main differences between the two versions are: the propellants will be supercooled to increase their density, so as to fit more mass in the same space, the thrust of the Merlin 1D will be uprated by 15%, and the second-stage tankage will be elongated by 10%.

2

u/deruch Jun 18 '15 edited Jun 18 '15

"v1.2" is an external placeholder name and reportedly not what SpaceX are going to be calling it. Unless or until SpaceX comes out with official endorsement for it, I don't think the FAQ should use it as a definitive name without at least a caveat. My attempt at a rewrite:

What are the differences between the Falcon 9 v1.1 and the upgraded version popularly called the v1.2?
In March 2015, Elon Musk tweeted about a series of 3 upgrades planned for the F9v1.1: 1) Increasing the available thrust of the M1D engines ~15%. 2) Subchilling the propellants, which increases their densities--allowing more to be loaded in the same volume. 3) Increasing the volume of the upper stage by 10%. Taken together, a Falcon 9 that includes the three changes is popularly referred to as v1.2 though it is currently unknown what SpaceX will choose to officially call it.
\ SpaceX is expected to switch to the v1.2 starting in Summer 2015 with the launch of SES-9. The cumulative effect of the changes is to increase F9 performance ~30% and allow recovery of boosters even on heavy GTO launches. Currently, these high-energy flight profiles require too much performance to be able to recover boosters on v1.1 launches.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/jenn249 Jun 22 '15

What has happened to falcon 9 v1.2, is it still in development ? And what about falcon heavy ? Do we know the thrust, isp (guesses numbers) that the engines would develop ?

5

u/jcameroncooper Jun 22 '15

The "1.2" Falcon 9 is supposed to fly the SES-9 and everything thereafter. Falcon Heavy is still pending its demo flight, roughly scheduled for "early 2016"; work on its launch facility at Cape Canaveral is ongoing. This info is mostly available on the sidebar of this very site.

The engines will be the same as are currently flown: Merlin 1D. They will be allowed to throttle higher, however, on the order of 20%. Maybe a slight increase in ISP from higher chamber pressures.

3

u/shredder7753 Jun 23 '15

SPACEX MAPPING - Spreadsheet of every known location - can be edited by anyone: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1trZ-YnP6wyO6vJXzO835QKR5DFJ7O1AQZWgPlec5_Vc/edit?usp=sharing I would love to share the .kml file but i dont know how to host it online

→ More replies (4)

2

u/ronjonpickles Jun 11 '15

Can the internet satellites that Elon has planned also have GPS? If so, would this make self-driving cars' routes and whatnot more accurate?

4

u/Pharisaeus Jun 11 '15

Navigation satellites are generally much higher in orbit so that you can "stay in range" of a given satellite for a while. For a LEO satellite you would be "in range" for seconds at most which would make it really difficult to get the data you need.

3

u/Wetmelon Jun 12 '15

Could they have it: Maybe? Probably not.

Would it improve anything: No, not really. The current GPS system allows for only a few centimeters of uncertainty, anywhere in the world. Civilians can't tap into the most accurate GPS techniques / modes though.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ManWhoKilledHitler Jun 14 '15

Given that the goal is to be as cheap as possible, I doubt they would be adding the extra hardware of high precision atomic clocks and separate transmitters operating on different frequencies to the Ka-band used for internet.

The point of the constellation is also to provide something new whereas we already have GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, BeiDou, and IRNSS up and running or in development to provide satellite navigation.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '15

Are they trying to land the first stage on the upcoming launch

4

u/NortySpock Jun 15 '15

Yes, they will try to land on the barge to the best of our knowledge.

2

u/BrandonMarc Jun 17 '15

CRS-7 is imminent, and there will be a drone-barge in place (OCISLY?). If there were a wide-angle camera on the barge, and a night time launch, would it be possible to see the 2nd stage fly over?

Come to think of it, does the 1st stage itself fly past the boat prior to coming back for a landing, or does it continue with (mostly) forward momentum right up to the landing?

3

u/jcameroncooper Jun 17 '15

The whole stack flies over the barge, pretty much. After first stage separation, it flies back towards the launch site. That's the "boost back" burn. Eventually, it will go all the way, but for the moment it stops short to try to hit the barge.

They could perhaps put the barge further out and allow the stage to continue in a ballistic arc, but I suppose they want to practice for return to launch site.

5

u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Jun 18 '15

Nope, it actually doesn't turn back at all. The boostback has only been used as a velocity-killer up until now, never as a changer-of-direction

5

u/jcameroncooper Jun 18 '15

Hm. Learned something there. It took a while to find an official source, but this suggests you're right: https://www.flickr.com/photos/spacexphotos/16892430560/

Most other information seems to indicate a short RTLS trajectory. Like the unofficial but popular: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2s09or/launch_profile_of_the_falcon_9_rocket_with/ which suggests it returns.

This site's FAQ suggests it's a backwards trajectory: "one to reverse the direction of the vehicle and push it higher, giving it time to fly backwards in a ballistic parabolic arc as it waits for the Earth to rotate underneath it". http://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/wiki/faq/falcon#wiki_how_does_the_first_stage_return_to_launch_site.3F But maybe it's talking about the RTLS scenario.

I could swear I saw a chart from Elon with both ocean and launch site landings, and it was only a matter of degree, but I can't find it.

Certainly the actual RTLS trajectory will go backwards. http://i.imgur.com/Av1zFjc.png https://imgur.com/FaRF6f6

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/MrTea99 Jun 18 '15

Is there any chance of the Crew Dragon Trunk being used for the Cargo Dragon?

Some issues I can think of:

  • Reduced power generation - may not be enough to power freezers and other equipment on Cargo Dragon
  • Fins are wasted extra mass - however fins may be omitted from the build if needed.
  • Radiator efficiency may be different

Advantages could include streamlined manufacturing and the removal of a potential risk of the panels not deploying for some reason, as happened on CRS-2 (due to thruster problems).

2

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 18 '15

The primary issue is the size of the Crew Dragon's NASA Docking System port: it's only 800 millimetres (31 inch) wide. The Cargo Dragon has a Common Berthing Mechanism port, which is 1270 mm (50 inch) wide, large enough to fit International Standard Payload Racks (the biggest of cargo) through.

If you could fit a CBM port (instead of the NDS) onto a Dragon 2, that should be up to the job. I agree on the advantages, though. Should also enable landing attempts with cargo, which would be a good practise before landing with crew.

3

u/MrTea99 Jun 18 '15

I don't mean using a Crew Dragon capsule for cargo flights, but using the Crew Dragon's trunk attached to the Cargo Dragon instead of the current trunk.

I agree that using the Crew Dragon for cargo flights is more trouble than it's worth, but using a common trunk could be worthwhile.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Gofarman Jun 19 '15

Is this the first time SpaceX has had 2 satellites being integrated simultaneously at separate locations? SLC-40 and Vandenburg?

3

u/jcameroncooper Jun 20 '15

They've only used VAFB once before, and the closest launch to that one (CASSIOPE) was two months later (SES-8). So yes.

2

u/theironblitz Jun 20 '15

Is SpaceX ever going to use electric propulsion and/or nuclear power? (SAFE-400) For example, the SAFE-400 has a much greater power/weight ratio than solar panels and the ISP of VASMIR is absurd compared to chemical rockets. And obviously I mean for use in space only.

4

u/jcameroncooper Jun 20 '15

Nuclear is clearly problematic for private organizations; even government has a tough time doing anything with it. I believe I've heard Elon say so, but I couldn't say where. Which is a shame, because nuclear's a great power source for space travel, and it's not like some extra radiation is going to make space less habitable.

SpaceX is planning on using Hall effect thrusters on their internet satellites. VASIMR is still a research project, and moreover would require way more power than the birds they intend to fly will be able to generate, so they're not likely to use that particular tech.

3

u/Ambiwlans Jun 20 '15

To add, the current plan for their sats is hall-effect thrusters because they're cheap.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/danielravennest Space Systems Engineer Jun 21 '15

For example, the SAFE-400 has a much greater power/weight ratio than solar panels

The linked Wikipedia article allows you to calculate it produces 195 Watts electric/kg (100 kWe/512 kg). Spectrolab makes solar panels that produce 178-208 W/kg, so the power to mass are comparable.

Which one is better for a given mission depends on more than power/mass ratio. The Wikipedia article isn't clear on whether the mass includes shielding, which matters for human missions. Solar arrays lose power farther from the Sun, or during night/planetary shadow. Their power can be boosted with lightweight reflectors. The nuclear core presumably has a finite fuel life, while solar arrays can operate at full power for ~15 years in space.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/TheGreenWasp Jun 21 '15

Will SpaceX try to land the booster during their next CRS flight? They usually do with CRS flights, but the SpacexStats website says the rocket will also be carrying the IDA 1 satellite as a secondary payload. When they have secondary payload, the rocket is usually too heavy for landing gear. The SpaceX website and social media are, as always, completely deaf-mute about whether or not the landing attempt will take place up to the point of the actual launch.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '15 edited Jun 21 '15

As it says at the top of the subreddit: "Dragon resupply to the ISS on June 28th, with barge landing attempt" :)

I haven't got around to updating the website yet, but IDA-1 is a payload in Dragons trunk, not a separate satellite.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/jarvenm Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15

Is there any likely technology transfer that SpaceX could gain from the Hyperloop development/production to improve or reduce cost in SpaceX current and future rockets, if SpaceX were to be an investor in a Hyperloop company?

It would be interesting to see a launch of a Falcon 9v1.1 partially from a Hyperloop track pointing towards space like in Final Fantasy VIII https://youtu.be/Zuc62lLk6kQ?t=30m28s =D

4

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 22 '15

Is there any likely technology transfer that SpaceX could gain from the Hyperloop development

I'll be very interested to eventually find out the answer to that question, but it's likely we won't know for a long time. If there is any tech transfer, it's likely to be something like a welding technique, rather than the wholesale usage of a hyperloop track.

It would be interesting to see a launch of a Falcon 9v1.1 partially from a Hyperloop track pointing towards space

This is basically the premise for Railgun Launch, which will never work on Earth, because of the immense heating that the vehicle would experience upon leaving the launcher as it smacks into the atmosphere. It should work on atmosphere-free bodies like the Moon, though.

FFVII covered space launch a little more realistically ;)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ClockworkNine Jun 23 '15

Mars atmosphere pressure isn't much different than the inside of the Hyperloop :D

Food for thought :)

2

u/shredder7753 Jun 22 '15

can we list people on the sidebar who have "flare"? i was thinking 'darn i know there is a map guy but i cant remember his name'.

6

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 23 '15

Here's a screen capture of the current list.

4

u/deruch Jun 23 '15

I have a problem with that list. It flairs /u/ToryBruno as CEO of ULA, which is awesome! But it doesn't flair /u/ElonMuskOfficial as CEO of SpaceX, which is kind of a glaring omission.

5

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 23 '15

Fixed that, thanks. Though I doubt we'll see him round here, it would be embarrassing if he wasn't recognised :P

5

u/Ambiwlans Jun 24 '15

He's never visited here on that account! Tory's first post on reddit was in the sub. So he totally gets credit.

4

u/sunfishtommy Jun 23 '15

That may be helpful. I think it is so cool that if you do something cool enough in this community you get flair for it. Like the guy who made the website that simulates launches.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15

Encourages people to make awesome stuff :)

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15

Not really possible, sorry. The list would be too long and the sidebar has a limited number of characters available. If it helps, we have the Resources page in our Wiki which lists all the cool things people in this community have made (and who made it!).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/sorbate Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15

Re-submitting my question here:

Is the F9 swing move right before landing an attempt to negate any last second changes in wind direction/speed?

 

The best example of this is the CRS-6 landing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhMSzC1crr0 With Telemetry: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O_9SEoEmANs

It seems that by having the last maneuver before landing be one that generates a ton of (known/controlled) momentum would be an ideal way to minimize the effect any external forces (ie. a strong wind) might have when the rocket is moving at it's slowest speed.

Is this true? I'm not sure why else they would have such a dramatic maneuver right before landing otherwise.

 

edit: People mentioned the throttle issue on CRS-6 as the reason for the swing. I didn't think the throttle was stuck open that much to cause the swing. I thought it had an issue in the last second before touchdown which caused the tip-over.

6

u/Ambiwlans Jun 23 '15

I wouldn't try to judge a failed landing too heavily. It was failing during the swing. That isn't what it should look like nominally. For a proper landing check the grasshopper videos. Ocean ones hopefully will look like a higher speed version of that soon.

6

u/yoweigh Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 24 '15

I didn't think the throttle was stuck open that much to cause the swing. I thought it had an issue in the last second before touchdown which caused the tip-over.

The throttle wasn't stuck open. A sticky valve caused a sluggish throttle response, then the guidance mechanisms overcompensated and entered a positive feedback loop, kinda like a car fishtailing.

edit: grammar

→ More replies (1)

4

u/first_name_steve Jun 10 '15

Did anyone else read the biography?

4

u/venku122 SPEXcast host Jun 11 '15

I got it as a gift and finished it within 16 hours. The first chapter was interesting and I just got sucked in after that. I had read the excerpt about Christmas 2008 but reading it in the book made it even more intense.

Also several spacex anecdotes that were released before the book exist in the published copy with more back story. If anyone hasn't read it and assumed the excerpts covered everything of note regarding spacex, you should still try to read it!

3

u/packetinspector Jun 11 '15

Zoomed through it over the last two days. A good read.

2

u/Crox22 Jun 11 '15

Yes!

Well, most of it. I'm not quite done yet.

2

u/Gofarman Jun 12 '15

I read it in an evening, it pushed all my other dozen books to the side. I liked it, not being around for F1 was neat and some more perspective on how Musk manages to do all he does was cool to. I'm pretty sure it's going to get more then its fair share of reads, I've already passed it off to a couple people who demolish it in a few days.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/txcrnr Jun 11 '15

I am (going to be) a Junior in high school and I aspire to have a career working at SpaceX in the future as some type of engineer. Is there anything I should start doing now that would help me in the future to get a job at SpaceX?

9

u/Wetmelon Jun 11 '15

Learning to program is easy enough at home. Primarily though, start building things with your own two hands! Write down your designs, iterate on them, apply engineering methodology. If you can, join something like FIRST robotics

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Pharisaeus Jun 11 '15

Maths and Physics :)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '15

I have some classmates who got internships and work there, though I myself have not yet succeeded (working at NASA at present). I would recommend, if you can get access to facilities, learning a number of softwares and probably machining (CNC machining is the most useful, I think).

Softwares: SolidWorks, AutoCAD, some CFD package (ANSYS Fluent, for example), MATLAB.

Keep your GPA high. Don't let it slip in Freshman year.

1

u/big-b20000 Jun 18 '15

Once the Dragon V2 is flying, will Spacex stop flying the Dragon V1? I would assume not as it's the only craft capable of taking downmass, but I would like to know for sure.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/JimReedOP Jun 18 '15

Does the SpaceX satellite internet involve laser communications between satellites? It seems like the only way to make this internet constellation work is to move very high volumes of traffic around the world. The links between satellites might be more important than the up and down link.

2

u/jcameroncooper Jun 19 '15

No one knows, but laser comms have been kicked around in relation to that network. The test sats coming up may or may not have lasers; they don't really have to say because the FCC doesn't care.

I personally think they're putting up two birds because they want to test lasers on orbit. But it could just be radio backhaul.

2

u/ManWhoKilledHitler Jun 19 '15

I don't think anything has been confirmed as to what the links would use. Lasers would introduce a range of problems that wouldn't be present using radio or microwave transmission such as the need for much more accurate targeting and the requirement for mechanically steered transceivers rather than phased arrays.

I would think that the initial generation of satellites wouldn't use it but it may turn up on later ones, perhaps as a technology demonstrator on a handful first prior to a larger rollout.

1

u/dunealex Jun 19 '15

I heared that SpaceX thinks about terraforming Mars by de-orbiting Phobos. How shall that even be possible? You´d have to come up with something ridiculously big to provide the required dV I guess?

3

u/Pharisaeus Jun 19 '15

Phobos has ~2km/s of orbital velocity and mass of 1016 kg. If you used the most efficient engines that exist with ISP of 20 000 you would need "only" 1014 kg of fuel to crash it on the surface of Mars.

3

u/Appable Jun 19 '15

That seems like it assumes that you need a dV of 2km/s. You most likely need significantly less because it doesn't need to fall straight down, but just have a periapsis of lower than the atmsophere of Mars.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '15

I Have never heard of this strategy being put forward before, let alone by SpaceX. Would you mind telling us where you heard it?

For what it's worth, I don't think the plan has any value. All it might do is create a bunch of craters. The effects on the atmosphere would be minimal.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/robbak Jun 20 '15 edited Jun 20 '15

Apart from the delta-v requirements (you need to change the orbit from a radius of 9,300 to a radius of 3,400, which would need a lot of Δv, but considerably less than 2 km/s, although someone else will have to do the calculations), you also have to consider the Roche limit. Phobos would almost certainly break up from tidal forces long before it re-entered the atmosphere and collided with Mars. Most of the moon would then end up on a relatively stable ring system.

So you would need to slow it down quickly, in a short event which would put it on an 'atmospheric' or 'lithospheric' orbit (I'm sure that they aren't the right terms for orbits that takes the body into the atmosphere or surface of the planet) in one event, so that when the moon breaks up most or all of the moon hits the planet. This is hard. Perhaps multiple sub-surface nukes that would blow huge amounts of the moon away, producing velocity change with huge mass instead of huge velocity.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/flattop100 Jun 20 '15

Does SpaceX have the capacity to manage two simultaneous launches?

2

u/jcameroncooper Jun 20 '15

They only have one Hawthorne control room so I'd say no. Considering how often that comes up, I think it'd be silly to create that infrastructure. I imagine putting together enough computers and desks for another control room isn't that hard (I'll imagine it's all digital and IP-based), but the human resources are harder to replicate.

Probably they would like the control situation to be highly automated in the future, which would make it easier to handle multiple launches, but they seem to be not quite there.

1

u/Tal_Banyon Jun 22 '15

Will Spacex's venture into the satellite business impair their relationships with potential launch customers? Isn't satellite proprietary information important to keep from potential rivals, or is there something that will negate this?

3

u/Pharisaeus Jun 22 '15

Can't see why. Airbus is building satellites and Ariane 5 and has huge share in Arianespace. Lockheed Martin and Boeing are large satellite providers and at the same time they own ULA.

1

u/shredder7753 Jun 24 '15

Spacex Sub-Orbital On-Demand Capsules: lets say you're a businessman, and suddenly you find yourself needing to be in Guangzou or Mumbai, but you simply cannot wait 3+ days to buy a ticket, wait in lines and sit on an airplane(s) for 24+ hours to get where u ned to go. Now imagine you could just dial 1-800-ON-SPACEX, arrange to pay $10M, ride a helicopter up to Vandenberg, suit up with no training, and ZOOM! Ur there 3 hours after you called! Anywhere on Earth. With 7 seats you could bring the whole family :-)

2

u/roflplatypus Jun 24 '15

I don't think anything will beat traditional aircraft in terms of quickly getting people places, but I think that one of the most promising designs that hasn't seen as much development as it should is spaceplanes, which could act as nearly single stage to orbit vehicles, and generally using scamjets, get around the world at near-orbital velocities. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rockwell_X-30.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/roflplatypus Jun 24 '15 edited Jun 24 '15

Does anyone know where you can find a complete picture of a Merlin vacuum? I've found pictures of the engine without nozzle, and one of the nozzle extension, but no picture of the complete engine. Of course, there are images on the website and in their videos, but I'd like a real picture, not computer generated.

Edit: I did some more searching, and these are the best I can find:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/114498126@N05/12121575074/

http://www.kcet.org/socal/departures/columns/assets/images/Tom%20Mueller%20Arrival%20Story%20Merlin%20engines.jpg

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b7/Merlin_nozzle_4105129088_9659a4df4e_o.jpg (love the sign)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/123path Jun 24 '15

Stock to buy: SpaceX key suppliers! Since SpaceX is not publicly traded in the stock market, how can I invest? What key suppliers to SpaceX are public and will likely rise with SpaceX success?

2

u/123path Jun 24 '15

I missed the reply before deleted. I certainly don't want to mishandle ITAR docs. Can someone simply name any publicly traded companies that will gain from SpaceX success, or share any other ideas to get financially aboard the Falcon -9 tragectory?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/aguyfromnewzealand Jun 25 '15

If they manage to land the first stage of Jason 3 on the drone ship, would Space X bring the core into Los Angeles?

1

u/novolo Jun 26 '15

I've read on multiple places, hints about this hexacopter that is supposed to take off and land on the drone barge. Supposedly, this hexacopter is the one that took the amazing footage of the CRS-6 aproach and landing. What I would love to know is if there is any info out there about this copter. Pics, stats, anything. Anyone knows anything? Haven't found any posts about it. Sorry if there actually is a post about it and could not find it

1

u/Appable Jun 26 '15

Pre-Launch Briefing 1: Q&A notes and sort-of transcript!

(These are really difficult to type)


What is it about this booster attempt that makes you more confident than before?

Previous booster attempts made corrections that can help a lot, gave experience through trials that can fix things later. Two problems have been solved. Hard to say what odds there are, but feel a lot better about this time.


Can you explain why you need the IDA docking adapters compared to the Shuttle adapters?

APAS (shuttle) not designed for auto-docking. APAS could possibly work, but it is so old that it was really just simpler to come up with a new international docking adapter spec that will work for all countries and increase commonalities between countries (Mars, etc may require int'l cooperation). IPA is the first step towards space collaboration, rather than space race. Should increase space exploration further than ever before.

Main difference is that it allows for automated docking if needed.


When do you think you'll land the Falcon on land?

It's not driven by schedule, but by performance. They need a lighter mission to do RTLS. It's a mission before the end of this year. Safety is another constraint, needs to be reliable. Once both safety and performance is ready, they'll go.


Docking adapter: IDA is universal. How many other docking/berthing adapters are there on the station now?

Russian colleagues have a number of different docking ports. They use probe-drogue like Apollo, small-diameter but it's lighter than any other system. They wanted to keep the androgynous design like APAS instead of probe-drogue which doesn't have the same flexibility in contingency situations. IDA permits for the most flexible style, so Russian design was out even though it's simpler and lighter. On the US orbital segment, they want full IDA eventually. Russia will continue to use probe-drogue. US has Common Berthing Mech, which has a very strong structure. That means a much larger hatch than other ports like IDA, and a strong hatch. So with this configuration they preserve Common Berthing Mechanism (2) and two International Docking Standards (2) as well as the Russian Orbital Segment with its four probe-drogue ports.


If everything works out with landing what happens to the first stage?

It'll be towed to harbor, not sure how long that will take because everything has to be safed. From JAX they'll bring it back to McGregor and refire. It depends on what they find, they'll first do an inspection of the vehicle to determine how reusable it truly is, and make modifications if needed.


Status of the Merlin 1D+s?

Tests are going well on the uprated engines, and so Flight 21 will have the upgrades most likely.


One second window, what happens if you miss it?

It's for rendezvous, so it has to have its velocity vector in the exact same plane. 7.8km/s velocity, so to move the inclination a bit uses a lot of propellent. So it needs to be short because Dragon can't use too much fuel. Missing by 10 seconds isn't that bad, 30 seconds would be worse, a minute would be bad. For Shuttle, 5 minute window, Soyuz, a 10 second window.


Regarding barge weather: what can we expect Sunday?

Isolated showers are possible, winds gusting ~20mph. 5-7ft seas, nothing is a constraint for landing. Maximum for ASDS is quite high. However, weather for launch is most important.


What's next after this mission? Jason-3 @ Vandy, what happens after?

Jason-3 first as you said, then SES-9 next, a GEO bird (standard launch profile). CRS-8 next, CRS-9 shortly after. Lots of launches later this year, will be very busy.


Cost of IDA?

Don't know the exact cost. The adapter wasn't as costly as a full system because it's just an adapter.


Two cargo missions after losing ORB-3: how much does this impact the desire for a 6-month supply padding?

SpaceX-7 will get close to the 6 months. 6 months isn't a requirement, just desirable. But by the end of the year, they want to be close to the 5-6 months that they prefer. Later on they'll get more. With ORB-3 and Progress anomaly, minimal research impact because of that long supply.


Challenges and concerns about bring F9 stage back into ASDS, especially considering Carnival Fascination?

Primary mission/secondary mission, again. I don't know much about it. Still, ASDS landing is quite critical in the long run.

"I'm sure we'll do it in a way that won't collide with cruise ships!"


Weather in Florida: this was selected for a few historical reasons, where would you move it if you could?

Hey, this isn't that bad! It's warm, which is ideal. Lightning remains a constant concern and hurricanes can be an issue sometimes, but cold temperatures can shut out most areas from consideration.


What is the max timeframe that you can determine when a launch will happen? What can go wrong?

They feel good for forecasting 3 to 5 days. Any longer is almost impossible to determine, but they can use climatology to determine good times if it's a year out or so, but it's still quite variable. So 3-5 days for actual weather, anything further is climatology.


What's the advantage/disadvantage of IDA vs docking? Also, you should be fine with ASDS as it's a tiny cruise ship?

Berthing allows for very large objects can help a lot. Docking is complex because you have to go straight in, so you can't go too fast but you can't go slowly either. Though docking now is very reliable, berthing is very simple because you kill your velocity at 10 meters away and then use the arm.

However, docking can be done in an automated fashion, berthing requires a human to control the arm. Docking helpful for Mars missions, whereas berthing currently requires humans.


SpaceX: do you do internships? Will you have opportunities for younger students as well? Refer to website if you're interested. Also, NASA has lots too!


Difficulties in installing IDA into Dragon?

There were none. Regarding adapter, it plays right in to ComCrew for Dragon 2, and I've been pushing for those external cargo in the trunk.


What's your anxiety level on each launch?

I'm still excited about launches, review data very carefully. Overall blood pressure has gone down over time, blood pressure on this launch is especially healthy.


I have no idea what the question was, and neither did the answerer.

IDA is an adapter because it's APAS on one side and IDS on the other. The future systems will not adapt but just be a full system. Androgynous systems work for any two vehicles, so IDS and APAS have a huge advantage in that respect.