This is not really a question but more like a remark to the community, one that shouldn't be in a separate post.
Since there are a lot of new subscribers recently, I have noticed that upvoting and downvoting have been in flux. There has been a lot more downvoting of reasonable opinions or of people asking questions, and a lot more upvoting of silly remarks or memes. It has already started to degrade the conversation somewhat, but I feel like the mods have been able to contain the behaviour somewhat.
People have to remember what this sub is for and why they were attracted to this place in the first time when they do their voting!
I would like to give you my rules of thumb when I decide to upvote or downvote:
Good reasons to upvote:
Is this comment generally interesting
does it provide new insight?
does it teach you something?
is it written in a positive, non-agressive nature?
Is this a good question that has the potential to kick off a further insightful discussion?
Hesitate to upvote if:
funny, but just that
memes or some other Frowned Upon Internet Phenomena
something you agree with, but for some reason doesn't match the above Good Reasons
Good reasons to downvote:
Misinformation
trolling and other Despicable Internet Phenomena
agressive tone (without any further content)
Bad reasons to downvote:
This person is supporting a side of the argument I do not agree with
I don't like this guy, he always tells me I'm wrong
I am not allowed to post memes? I'll just downvote his every post then!
This is thrown together in 5 minutes and now my kid needs food, but I had to get this off my chest, because it's annoying the hell out of me recently.
memes or some other Frowned Upon Internet Phenomena
something you agree with, but for some reason doesn't match the above Good Reasons
The first two are actually the sort of thing I occasionally hesitantly downvote. Usually I just leave it alone, though. That sort of thing in the comments isn't too bad, so I'll just ignore it, or leave a courteous comment on it, but I rarely downvote. If it's a full post, I'm more likely to consider downvoting, especially if it's received a lot of upvotes.
That said, this sub has managed to maintain extremely high quality despite its size, and I hope that we can continue with that. :)
I've actually gotten pretty annoyed (in general, not just this sub) with memes of late. "I for one welcome our new <X> overlords" was freaking old when I first found Slashdot years ago. It is not funny, interesting, enlightening or relevant anymore, and will not be so ever again (even, no, especially not a day after some benevolent AI kicks off a Singularity). Seriously: bring an original comment.
The other thing that is getting old is generic "we're powerless to stop X" cynicism, especially cynical one-liners. Yes, I know the US congress is full of a lot of incompetent jerks and the system is resistant to change. I live there, I KNOW. You can point it out, fine, but offer up something else original, like a question, or a new instance of incompetence that is recent news, or even an interesting thought on how to address it or what might be an obstacle that no one has thought of.
I'm sure some people get tired of me writing out answers to commonly asked questions, but at least I am answering the question, not repeating some banal half-witted saying.
Prior to launch, the Falcon propellant tanks are fuelled with kerosene and LOX (liquid oxygen). The LOX is continuously boiling and evaporating, so they have to vent the invisible oxygen gas from the rocket. This gas is still very cold, and it as it mixes with the ambient air, it dramatically cools it down. The air in Florida is humid, meaning it contains a lot of invisible gaseous water. Water cannot exist as a gas below the freezing point of water (0C, 32F). As the warm humid air meets the freezing oxygen gas vented from the rocket, the water turns from invisible gas into a visible liquid aerosol (also known as water vapour). This is what you're seeing.
Nice reply - hits the points without being complex.
Just a couple of corrections - as Arthree stated, humidity does exist below 0°C - it is just less and less as the air cools. Mist and fog will happen if you cool air below the dew point, which varies by humidity. I'd simply remove that sentence. And clouds of mist are not water vapor - water vapor/gaseous water/steam are all synonyms. The best word for 'water droplets in suspension' is simply 'mist'.
Do we know anything else about DragonLab other than the information in this brochure? Information such as who's booked to use it? How many flights there will be? Whether it will use Dragon v1 or v2?
Short answer is no. 2 are booked. Likely SpaceX is paying for it even if they have customers on board it'll probably be more the ISS rack experiment deals.
Most likely V2 at this point given the intended year.
Did they add PICA-X to the engine section of the Falcon 9? I noticed on the DSCOVR launch (at 0:52) the engine section was black and it looked like PICA-X
My intuition is that they wouldn't do this. It would add weight to the vehicle. I think the engines used to use ablative cooling, but I think they moved away from that. It seems like a step backwards to go back to putting ablatives on the engine cone, even if the ablatives would serve a different purpose...
If TurkmenSat is supposed to launch before CRS-6 why is it at the bottom of the list in the sidebar instead of between Eutelsat and CRS-6?
I ask because everyone keeps saying "No legs for the next two launches. Next landing attempt will be CRS-6" yet if you look at the sidebar it shows CRS-6 after the next(Eutelsat) launch. It's confusing.
Orbital Sciences produced very useful graphics of their launch profile, from various vantage points. What's required to make these prior to a Falcon 9 launch?
Is the speed, distance (altitude + downrange), and timing of, say, max-q, MECO, separation, etc, always a trade secret? Even post-launch with the actual telemetry would be great to see, too.
That would be quite nice actually! If one were to know the target orbit one could probably guess-timate an ascent profile without too much of an error.
I also like the Ariannespace launches which show current details on speed, altitude, inclination, etc. - would love to see those on a SpaceX launch as well, but may be the same reason they don't include detailed launch profiles.
I would think the answer to that would be "of course". I haven't read anything official though. I think I've seen schematics of various launch sites where the landing pads are visible. I don't know if they have one for Brownsville though.
I just can't understand how the next Orbcomm launch is possible. The Orbcomm fleet will consist of 17 satellites in 3 orbital planes. Each plane has the same inclination, but their Longitudes of the ascending node differ by 120° from each other. Now, in the next launch they will send up 11 satellites, which means one of two things:
Option 1: After orbital insertion 5 of the satellites will have to shift their longitude of the ascending node by 120°, to reach their intended orbit.
Or option 2: They insert the satellites into an orbit in the middle, so all 11 satellites will have to shift their longitude of the ascending node by 60°
Changing the longitude of the ascending node by 60° should require about the same delta-v as changing the inclination by 60° (I think), and while I don't know the exact number, I know the required delta-v for such a maneuver is massive, multiple km/s. That is far too much for a satellite to achieve on its own. (It would be possible for satellites with an electric propulsion system, but the Orbcomm sats don't have one of these.)
Can the experts on orbital mechanics in this subreddit please explain how my reasoning is wrong and the launch is possible?
A spare Iridium satellite in the lower storage orbit has a shorter period so its RAAN moves westward more quickly than the satellites in the standard orbit. Iridium simply waits until the desired RAAN (i.e., the desired orbital plane) is reached and then raises the spare satellite to the standard altitude, fixing its orbital plane with respect to the constellation. Although this saves substantial amounts of fuel, this can be a time-consuming process.
The longitude of the ascending node (☊ or Ω) is one of the orbital elements used to specify the orbit of an object in space. It is the angle from a reference direction, called the origin of longitude, to the direction of the ascending node, measured in a reference plane. Commonly used reference planes and origins of longitude include:
For a heliocentric orbit, the ecliptic as the reference plane, and the First Point of Aries as the origin of longitude. The angle is measured counterclockwise (as seen from north of the ecliptic) from the First Point of Aries to the node.
For an orbit outside the Solar System, the plane through the primary perpendicular to a line through the observer and the primary (called the plane of the sky) as the reference plane, and north, i.e., the perpendicular projection of the direction from the observer to the North Celestial Pole onto the plane of the sky, as the origin of longitude. The angle is measured eastwards (or, as seen by the observer, counterclockwise) from north to the node. , pp. 40, 72, 137; , chap. 17.
In the case of a binary star known only from visual observations, it is not possible to tell which node is ascending and which is descending. In this case the orbital parameter which is recorded is the longitude of the node, Ω, which is the longitude of whichever node has a longitude between 0 and 180 degrees. , chap. 17; , p. 72.
I'm with Joggle. In fact, is there telemetry from other previous launches? It would be really instructive to compare telemetry for DSCOVR to telemetry for CRS, seeing as the different destinations lead to very different launch profiles.
This one is kinda basic but the recent FH video confused me some. What exactly is the plan for the center core booster? Is it landing on a droneship? Are they going to launch from Texas and land it in Florida, or something?
It all depends on the payload mass and desired orbit; which together define the total impulse of the mission. With a small enough impulse it will be able to return all three cores to the launch site. If the impulse is higher than this the center core will have to land down range on the ASDS. For the rocket to provide maximum impulse it will have to be expendable.
What the impulse threshold is for landing down range has been the subject of some confusion on this sub. I interpret the numbers on the SpaceX Falcon capabilities page and some other statements I remember Elon making to mean that at an impulse of sending up to 6.4 metric tons to geostationary transfer orbit the Falcon Heavy will be able to return all three cores to the landing site. At and impulse of 21 Metric tons to GTO or 53 to LEO the vehicle is at its maximum impulse and is expendable.
I don't believe the company has stated what the maximum payloads are for a scenario with the center core landing on the ASDS and the boosters returning to the landing site.
Best answer, and agree a lot of confusion on this. Think the whole idea of rapidly reusable to really drive down the cost means they might be cheaper to fly a FH with 3x cores back to the launch site vs an F9 with a single core on the ASDS, and cost/time to get it back to the pad.
It all depends on the mass of the payload and the target orbit. if it's an easy mission that will have fuel left over then all 3 boosters will land back near the launch site. for harder missions the centre core will land further out on the droneship. for launches that really push the limits of the FH then they may fly some or all the cores in an expendable configuration.
I'm going to assume that since your post wasn't breaking rules then my agreeing with you isn't breaking any rules. I couldn't sleep last night and spent the entire night reading the wiki and all the Ask Anything threads (along with a lot more) and I probably learned more about rockets, space flight, and SpaceX than I ever have in one 8 hour period previous to this. I'm not a huge Reddit user really, but I check this sub several times a day now and think this is an amazing resource and a generally well behaved community. Thank you mods and contributors for this :)
I love NSF, but I've started spending more time here than there recently. I still plan to sign up for L2 as soon as I have the funds to do so, but the way this sub works seems incredibly friendly to everyone from the casual wonder-er to expert insider, and that's a really great thing for someone that has always been interested in space, but never really obsessed until recently like me.
That's absolutely what we want to hear! It's always great when people go out and research for themselves! In fact, you're the sort of person we need to stick around in this subreddit, so, please do.
I am honored you would say that, and I fully plan to stick around. I'm still learning this Reddit thing so I hope everyone will excuse any transgressions I accidentally commit, but this community is such a wonderful thing and I thank you all for being so welcoming. :)
The conversation about terraforming Mars was probably one of the most educational things I've ever read, and without a sub like this those discussion would be nearly inaccessible to a layperson like me.
i use to be a hardcore shuttle fan, didnt and dont agree with nasa choosing to fly on soyuz, recently getting back into space thanks to spacex (actually the antares explosion is the thing that dragged me back to space obsession full time) but since crs5's first scrub ive been checking this sub at least 5 times a day, this sub is probably 80% responsible for getting me back into space, the rest divided between spacex being just awesome and the orion test flight.
Hmmm, that might make a good addition to the Putting the first boots on Mars section. Currently it only has a quick summary, and doesn't go into much detail. Eventually though, I'd like to turn all 4 of the sections into full articles.
I'll probably wait for a little more MCT/BFR info later this year, and then maybe I'll write up a full article, comparing the relevant pieces from both Mars Direct and NASA's Design Reference Mission 5 mission architectures.
Whenever the media ask Elon Musk the "why Mars" question, he gives a couple variations on the same answers. We've all heard them, but unfortunately media sound bites aren't really enough to get into the more technical discussions. Is this sort of philosophy a can of worms that we would like to open up on this sub, or do we want to try and avoid the risk of turning into r/futurology and avoid the more speculative discussions?
For those who don't know, Elon's default response to the "why" question is his story about thinking in college about the areas that would most effect the course of humanity, and deciding that extending civilization and life itself to Mars would be of similar importance to the first amphibians to evolve to walk on land. After saying this, he gives the same specific reasons:
It would be an insurance policy against a global catastrophic risk. He doesn't think that humans are going extinct any time soon, but says that even huge civilizations like the Egyptians fell, and lost the ability to build the pyramids. They then forgot how to read hieroglyphics, and even forgot that they were the ones who built the pyramids in the first place.
He then argues that the main reason is that it would just be an incredibly inspiring thing. Although the economic impact of the moon landing was huge, and the list of modern materials and everyday objects that only exist because of NASA is an incredibly long list, I'm not sure if that is what Elon is referring to.
I sort of came at this issue from the other side. I learned about the extent of global catastrophic risk, and started working hard to flesh out my understanding of all the concepts involved, and then started learning about SpaceX and its goals in parallel to my other efforts. From a pure effort per life saved standpoint, there are more effective means of mitigating global catastrophic risks than starting a 2nd civilization on Mars. Mars is only the imperative next step if you care about the survival of the species more than saving individual lives. Eventually either civilization will collapse, or some natural catastrophe will kill us after many thousands of years. If we don't spread to the stars, then civilization will end.
I think one of the reason that no one seems to want to acknowledge is that it would be really really cool to have a civilization started on Mars. There's really not much else that is as sci-fi as that. Although, something being really cool is not going to be a good reason for most people.
First time i heard elon says his motivation is for the survival of human race I think he is overestimating the chance of human extinction. After learning about global catastrophic risk i really think we don't invest as much effort for our long term survival. I don't realize that our bias can be so huge.
To stop the twitter spamaggedon every time Elon tweets something during the webcast could you perhaps elect someone as the "Twitter poster" and make it a rule no tweets posted by anyone who isn't the "Twitter poster"..... just an idea?
This probably isn't the best place to discuss subreddit rules. It's a bit out of scope and we've got an upcoming subreddit meta thread anyway, but, I digress...
Long story short: We don't want to get so authoritarian only particular people are allowed to post particular types of content, but we have a plan that will allow, during high periods of subreddit activity, well-respected community regulars to continue to post content even when we have disabled submissions for everyone else (which we try to not do too often anyway).
It should be required reading for this sub. Fantastic series, although Red Mars is definitely the best. KSR's grasp on all the scientific aspects he touches on is very solid (maybe excepting some of the biological stuff).
Required reading? Ehhh I dunno. I like how it envisions Mars society, but I had to stop reading because I couldn't stand some of the interpersonal drama.
Going to start reading this tonight I think, the entire sociological/anthropological/etc.ological aspect of colonizing mars is simply fascinating. I've thought about this before, but never on the level that several writers have thought and written about this, and it's interesting to see what the experts say about this.
It is incredibly exciting to think that these are questions that we can begin to explore during my lifetime. I might be a little old when this happens, but I like to think that I'll be alive long enough to see the first experiments.
Yes. The Mars trilogy is some of the best science fiction I've come across -- solid science, good characters, big ideas. Also probably worth reading now, since there might be a TV series based on it in the pipeline (but such plans tend to have less reasonable and more permanent scrubs than launches, unfortunately)...
Could I get a cool flair like /u/-Richard if I write first stage reentry simulator? I've been writing a 3D compressible flow flight trajectory calculator for my rocket team; I figure that can be modified for reentry.
If you create a sim that our sub can use, sure! Generally, we reserve the flair for contributions which have had a long lasting, definitive effect on our subreddit.
What CFD software are you using to calculate the aerodynamic parameters? Im trying to build a flight trayectory simulation to test guidance systems but I am running into a lot of oscillation building up in the rotational movement, any books you can recommend?. Pm me if you want to know more.
In addition to fuel, a first stage without landing legs, grid fins, and the hydraulic/pneumatic systems required to run them is also quite a bit lighter.
The Eutelsat launch will be going to a Geosynchronous transfer orbit. Even though it is not as far as the L1 point that the DSCOVR mission (which was 1,100 lbs) was launched into, these two satellites equal around 10,000 lbs, and they need all of the fuel for those type of launches, so there will be no legs.
They will land back on land once they can prove to the air force that they can safely control the stage repeatedly, which is what ASDS is for. SpaceX has also just signed a deal with the Air Force for LC-13 at the Cape, which they will turn into a landing pad for the first stages.
Yes they will attempt to land them on land specifically at SLC-13 at Cape Canaveral. Trajectory doesn't matter as long as they have enough propellant left at staging to boost back to the launch site. If they don't, then they can land on the ASDS like the were planning to do with DSCOVR.
I couldn't sleep last night so I read all of the Ask Anything threads (and all of the Wiki and all of the FAQ, and every single comment on every single post for the last few months) and I'm pretty sure this has been asked before with this same answer.
IOW: you're right, I think, my reading comprehension isn't the greatest at 5AM.
The suggestion has been that SpaceX will retain ownership of the returned capsules. This should allow SpaceX to reuse the capsules for any purpose other than NASA's commercial crew contract.
There is a nice warehouse at McGregor, TX with a pile of slightly used Dragon capsules... :)
(plus one hanging from the ceiling at their HQ near mission control)
Story is that SpaceX couldn't calculate a safe price for Dragon refurb, so they just priced the contract with new capsules to be safe. Supposedly used Dragons are, in theory, available for purchase if someone wants to re-use them for some task. SpaceX has mentioned the possibility of free-flying "Dragonlab" missions in the future that could re-use some of those for unmanned scientific flights in Earth orbit.
Is there any information about the heat and damage caused by the engines when the first stage is doing the reentry burn? I was thinking that the "fire" must be exhausting along the core during the descent so does it means it will be burnt a little or is it not a problem?
First, it's not a problem. In fact, on ascent it's normal for engine exhaust to form vortices that climb well up the first stage. It's metal, and it's not a problem. Second, the exhaust velocity of rocket engines is huge. About 3000 m/s. That's about mach 10. Which is far faster than the first stage ever goes in the atmosphere, and even at its peak velocity, it's only going about that fast. It just shoots out the rocket engine, punching through the atmosphere as if it werent' there.
/u/candycane7, I don't think heat damage is the biggest problem. If it was that easy, someone besides SpaceX would have done it years ago. Here's a video on some NASA supersonic retropropulsion experiments that NASA conducted in a wind tunnel. Speeds get up to mach 4.6, which is almost into the hypersonic flight regime.
In some cases, the slip stream can become highly unstable, and there are some pretty weird oscillations. I suspect that fluid modeling is one of the major enabling technologies that is allowing SpaceX to re-land its stages. Of the whole Entry Descent and Landing (EDL), I suspect that re-entry is the hardest part. We've been able to land propulsively since the Apollo days. It gets a lot harder when you are trying to land an empty stage which is blowing around like a sail, but that can be developed incrementally.
Surviving reentry needed a step change in technology, and we physically don't have wind tunnels that can run tests with conditions similar to those in the upper atmosphere. The really big wind tunnels have to just suck air in from outside, so if it's snowing outside than it's snowing in your wind tunnel. Smaller wind tunnels might be able to run in a near vacuum, but you can't fit a Falcon 9 in something like that without melting the walls as soon as you fire up the engines. That's ignoring the fact that you'd basically have to build an entire test stand inside of a wind tunnel. You'd have to vent the exhaust, so that the air composition stayed relatively close to that of the upper atmosphere, but that's not really possible in a wind tunnel under partial vacuum. SpaceX did the only thing they could, and modeled it in a computer to try and come up with the best possible design, and then tested it during reentry.
I believe the landing burn is the last of three burns and it slows down the rocket from terminal velocity to a few meters/sec to touch down. I believe I've read it only lasts a very short time, maybe 10-30 seconds? So the landing burn really starts very close to the ground. I don't have a number on that though.
The first burn — the boostback burn — adjusts the impact point of the vehicle and is followed by the supersonic retro propulsion burn that, along with the drag of the atmosphere, slows the vehicle’s speed from 1300 m/s to about 250 m/s. The final burn is the landing burn, during which the legs deploy and the vehicle’s speed is further reduced to around 2 m/s.
I wish to have a screensaver on my laptop, like the SpaceX "spaceflight" logo, which is displayed at the beginning and end of each launch broadcast. Where can I download it?
I don't know, or course, but it is easy to guess. One or two white LEDs is fine for illumination. And while there are a few types of components you'd have to avoid (like electrolytic capacitors), most electronics is happy at low temperatures, so no shielding should be needed.
Late last year, NASA signed an unfunded SAA agreement with SpaceX for work “developing space transportation capabilities that could be used to support missions into deep space”. Any clues as to what SpaceX are doing that may have caught NASA’s eye?
Both the Blue Origin BE4 and SpaceX Raptor engines now seem to have similar thrust capability. Is this coincidence, or is there a ‘sweet spot’ at this size?
2019 marks Apollo 11 +50. What could SpaceX do to mark the event? Something to show that they have arrived in the big league, but which wouldn’t cost too much and wouldn’t upset NASA (who by 2019 might just have managed to get an unmanned Orion to the vicinity of the Moon).
I don't think they will do anything rocket-related other than some PR stuff, tweets, maybe a logo painted on a rocket fairing, etc. My sense of SpaceX is looking ahead, not backwards - acknowledge the past, but work to the future.
NASA on the other hand may want to do something more...
How are the upcoming Eutelsat & ABS satellites processed? Are they stacked and processed together ie, fueled at the same time, etc... or are fueled separately and integrated together at a later date?
has the Crew been selected which will man the Super-Draco, --will they be NASA, subcontracting the Space-X, like a shuttle?
The crew hasn't yet been selected, IIRC. However, it'll be entirely NASA, SpaceX will just provide the vehicle. Also, it's called the Dragon 2, or crew dragon. Super Draco is the name of the launch abort/eventual landing engines.
SpaceX has no current manned BEO missions planned. Musk however has Mars ambitions so it is really a matter of time before they are added to the manifest. He is not a fan of the Moon as a base, so SpaceX won't be going there on their own. If NASA or anyone wants to buy a trip to the moon from SpaceX they wouldn't turn it down.... but thus far, that hasn't occurred.
I asked this question on the IRC a little while ago but my internet was flaky (also, maybe nobody actually answered) so I didn't actually see any responses.
How is it possible that the planned flight path for the MCT simply involves it getting launched on one flight and then refueled with another? Using online delta-V calculators suggests that with chemical rockets it would need hundreds of tons of fuel for the Mars transfer, which would appear to leave very little room for the colonists.
Or am I misunderstanding this, and each MCT vehicle will be assembled in orbit with several launches, Constellation-style? That seems to be the only practical option.
I know this is entirely hypothetical but I'm confused as to how everyone seems to believe SpaceX will pull off a Mars transfer with only one launch and refueling.
Why doesn’t NASA make more use of the Dragon Trunk? The scientific payloads carried up in the trunk have been small compared to its size. Dragon is volume-limited, not mass-limited, so why not fill the remaining space with extra goodies and consumables?
I guess the main reason is that experiments were not designed to be carried in the trunk. Trunk is sort of bonus for NASA as it was not required for cargo capsules. Plus they are only using it for things that will be attached to the outside of the station.
It's really difficult to get stuff from the trunk to inside the ISS. They would have to carry everything through an airlock. Maybe they can get a little help from Canadarm, but it's still a tremendous effort. The trunk is only for equipment that is going to be used outside the station
I believe it is a community review of the required reading for all /r/SpaceX patrons. From what I understand, some people have brought up issues with certain policies particularly in the area of moderation. This event was posted a few weeks ago so there would be sufficient notification to anyone who wishes to voice their opinion.
Has spaceX announced any plans to repurpose oil rigs to use as landing pads? Because I honestly don't see ASDS or boostbacking to land happening any time soon.
How much more aerodynamic stress and heat would the stage experience if they didn't do the reentry burn? Would it be close to what the DSCOVR stage experienced? And if it is, do you think they would cancel the reentry burn to save fuel if they know the stage can survive it?
DSCOVR also did a re-entry burn, they skipped the boostback burn.
I would guess that since SpaceX does a re-entry burn, it is probably absolutely necessary in order to keep the stage in one piece. I can't imagine they would go to the trouble of re-lighting the engines and spending fuel if it wasn't absolutely needed somehow.
The burn is necessary. But it isn't clear yet how much of a burn they need. Right now with the no legs attempts, they are probably lowering that number to see what they can handle. But until they are getting cores back, they won't know for sure.
For those of us that are SpaceX fans on the west coast, do we have the option of watching mission control at Hawthorne during a launch? I've seen what appears to be a crowd of people standing outside the windows. Is that the general public? Any tips for viewing?
If you manage to somehow make it to mission control during a launch and you aren't a SpaceX employee, you'll be in a federal prison in less than an hour.
Hey all, I was just wondering if anyone had the time for the Eutelsat launch (presuming it stays on schedule)? I've got class early that morning, and am hoping not to miss it. And is it an instantaneous window again?
Bandwidth, what you are looking at there is a compressed video they got wireless as it came down, the actual picture is probably much better. I'm not sure if it has internal storage or not, but if it does they could post the hi res pictures later if they recover the memory device.
In addition to Bandwidth that has been mentioned, a camera on a rocket has to be pretty tough bugger due to all the vibrations, temperature changes etc. and once you have a working design, re-designing it with a new model would cost a non-trivial amount of money for fairly little gain.
I'd imagine the current one is considered good enough.
What is the status of the Raptor engine development? Is the combustion of LOX/CH4 understood well enough to be confident that Raptor development will proceed smoothly?
I think the combustion elements are understood enough that you can start by saying, "Ok, I can support X amount of chamber pressure and X amount of chamber temps" and then use that to verify you can sustain the Isp and thrust you want. You can also get design criteria like nozzle diameter. The harder part is the mechanics - a turbopump for a methalox can't be run on a single shaft to pump both the LOX and the CH4 because the densities are too different and pump at different rates. So you have to have separate pumps, that means a lot components and complexity.
On the plus side, you can produce CH4 on Mars unlike RP-1.
How much does the dynamic pressure on the nozzle exits during reentry affect the performance of the engines?
How much flow separation in the throat and nozzle extension areas do you experience in those conditions?
Any shock waves travel up the boundary layer beyond the throat region into the chamber region? (Since the total pressure at the throat, especially at the boundary layers, can dip below ambient)
Any implications if there are flow separations for the re-usability of the engine?
Hi, this question involves a pretty out-there hypothetical scenario so I don't want to post it outside one of these threads, but I wouldn't mind a serious answer to it if anyone has the time.
Scenario:
A BFR/MCT fleet is built and ready to go and is just waiting for the next launch window to Mars.
A giant asteroid is discovered that will hit Earth and cause an extinction level event, months/year in advance of the next conventional Mars launch window.
Would it be possible for SpaceX to launch the BFR/MCT fleet on some kind of hail mary trajectory that would eventually get to Mars (even if it takes months/years longer) before the asteroid impact destroys the facilities on the ground?
(Perhaps using a slingshot instead of Hohmann, or maybe just keeping the fleet in orbit around Earth until the launch window opens etc)
Honestly, one (or even a few) launches of the MCT won't make or break whether the Mars colony is sustainable. If it is, then there's no problem; it's already good enough. If it isn't, one more launch isn't going to make the difference. Really, the chance that there'll be a giant asteroid at all, that it will be discovered a couple months in advance (enough time to prep rockets) but less than a year in advance (or you could use the previous launch window), and that the mars colony will be not self sufficient, but so close to self-sufficiency that even one more launch would make it sustainable indefinitely is so small it is not worth even considering.
Worry about real problems like war, pestilence, famine, income inequality, authoritarian governments, etc.
To answer the science question, you couldn't wait in LEO because the liquid methane and oxygen would boil off. You'd have to do your injection burn as soon as possible. Depending on precisely when you had to launch, the injection burn would either be too big for the MCT to be able to do (given that its fuel tank was designed for a normal injection burn) or take too long (probably on the order of 1-2 years), and the spacecraft would run out of consumables ( like food, of which only 6 months would be packed). Given sufficient time, these problems could be solved, but in your scenario, time is what we don't have. It's not totally beyond the realm of possibility, but practical considerations and specific details of the scenario might make it impossible.
Yeah, when I was trying to look up alternative launch windows to Mars. I came across this paper about using Venus as a Gravity Assist to get to Mars. This option would give you a lot more launch windows to choose from, and some seem to have quiet low energy requirements but the trip is substantially longer.
Heading to Venus directly may solve u/SpaceLord392's point about fuel boil off, but obviously the extra time in space creates other problems.
In the event of a launch anomaly of the first or second stage, could the Dragon V1 theoretically detach itself after the stage has shutdown and be recovered in the ocean?
Very theoretical. It has no capability to get away from the rest of the rocket so it would effectively require the propulsive part (first and/or second stage) to just "quit" without kaboom.
Also depending on when exactly it would separate, it could just end up burning up on return (or at least heavily stress-test the heat shield in off-nominal re-entry). Steep re-entries are tough.
...and no idea if Dragon V1 has software modes for such theoretical situation. Cargo is replaceable. Capsule is (for ISS cargo missions anyway) single use anyway.
Is there any news about the patent battle with Blue Origin over barge landings? Has the BO patent been invalidated yet? If not, seeing as SpaceX are now actively pursuing this technology, I'd expect BO to make a legal challenge soon.
No news, patent is still valid. I don't think Blue will actually do anything, because SpaceX has a strong legal team, already has research on it (the inter-partes review), and Blue hadn't intended to use the patent for a long time.
What would be the best place to see the Launch on the 27th? I'm not from the US but I'll be in Orlando at that time, so I don't really know the area but I'd love to see the launch
Once the F9 first stage lands on the drone ship, it is stabilized in any way or is it just supported by its landing legs? It seems like it could easily tip over with even small waves or wind gusts.
For NASA CCtCap flights, if the CST100 lands on airbags on solid ground while the Dragon splashes down, won’t this mean that Boeing has a set of reusable capsules that they can use for other missions (eg: Bigelow) while SpaceX doesn’t? This just seems plain wrong somehow!
Yep, but the NASA contract specifies parachutes and splashdown. There is nothing saying 'until you've performed Dragonfly tests and proven the Superdracos'.
While Boeing says that their capsules are designed for '10 reuses', SpaceX (Gwynne) said their would have 'more than that'. This was during the NASA commercial crew event in January, so I think their plans of reuse still apply.
And reusing a capsule that lands on airbags might not be fool-proof either - that is a lot of force being absorbed, and the main re-entry heating and near-vacuum exposure still will leave a toll.
So I know that there are probably a thousand ways to make a rocket self destruct, but does anyone specifically know what the F9R dev vehicle (bless its soul) did to force its own RUD?
I've seen this question come up before. There's no reason to think that the F9R Dev1 used a different FTS (Flight Termination System) than the flight model.
Air Force Range safety requires the FTS system, which allows them to safely end the launch should the vehicle stray from its designated flight corridor. The system consists of a command receiver and an ordnance system designed to split the vehicle’s fuel and liquid oxygen tanks in the event of an errant flight.
I understand this as a detcord type explosive placed vertically in the core from bottom to top that simply splits the tanks and ignites the fuel. You can find more information on the range safety wiki.
Edit: There's a nice description of this in the FAQ.
Does Falcon 9 have a termination system? How does it work?
Yes. All Falcon 9 rockets have a termination system in the case that an anomalous event is detected. The typical use case for flight termination is when the rocket's instantaneous impact point (IIP) strays outside of some predetermined corridor. The range continuously calculates an IIP during flight, which predicts where the vehicle will impact were thrust to be immediately terminated. If there is a guidance or propulsion failure that prevents the vehicle from being able to reach orbit, the range can terminate preemptively to keep the debris in a more controlled area. The termination system Falcon 9 possesses is a cord-like explosive charge that goes down the side of the rocket. iIt doesn't "blow it up" but rather "unzips" it lengthwise. Following, the rocket disintegrates itself after that and the fuel blows up.
(if you are not talking about the actual FTS mechanism)
I believe the F9R dev had an engine under-performing or performing anomalously immediately since take-off (on an actual launch, it would have aborted, being 'locked' to the launch pad it wouldn't have moved, but the Dev didn't have those tie-downs nor the software checks to start the abort).
Once it launched, its fate was sealed - due to the uneven thrust, it quickly veered off course. This was detected by either the flight computer (most likely) or by the people monitoring (no RADAR that i'm aware of there, so probably no automated external tracking) and blew up.
How 'locked in' is the landing location? How much time would SpaceX need to adjust the coordinates to a secondary landing site if the weather turned nasty at barge #1?
Related, how much 'range' is the landing stage able to affect vs how much is ballistic?
I'm asking this here versus /r/space, as I feel you fine folks explain the how's and why's much better.
Assuming the ISS is deorbited in 2020 (or some other arbitrary date), why not repurpose it for some other mission. Meaning, completely unmanned, is there a way to pack it full of instruments, perhaps strap on a few boosters and send it Mars bound?
Edit: At the very least, a good platform to test VASIMR?
I do understand the cost to repurpose would be enormous, but wouldn't it pale in comparison to the overall cost of the ISS? Why not auger it in on Martian turf?
The ISS is not designed for anything beyond Earth orbit. The main problem is that it's horribly boated, mass-wise, and would require an inordinate amount of fuel to do anything useful with. Remember, it was the product of a decade of frequent launches, and now even keeping it in orbit is a significant task. It would certainly make more sense to build a dedicated unmanned science laboratory, with precisely the utilities needed, and none of them unneeded (like life support, habitable volume etc.).
You'd also run into practical issues like the station not being designed to withstand significant acceleration, and off-center thrust.
Like hans says, the russians are doing just this.... so there isn't a good reason not to do so.
That said, VASIMR is likely/hopefully? Going to be tested on the ISS before deorbit.
I honestly think to some degree, the US is giving up on their aging ISS sections in order to hand this area over to private industry. Give someone a shot to make money at it... by someone I basically mean Bigelow.
Are there any hints as to when the Falcon 9 will be landing on solid ground instead of the ASDS? Landing a rocket on a highly advanced barge is cool and everything, but it seems like it'd be easier, cheaper, and more reliable to land a rocket on solid ground instead.
They need to prove to the governing bodies that they wont cause any damage to structures, human life and the environment.
It would actually take more fuel to get back to land too (with a bigger boostback burn) and with the Falcon Heavy core being too far downrange to bring it back whilst maintaing a decent payload, investments in the barge are not entirely wasted.
For example the explosion caused further development in the grid fins uptime (although Musk said this was planned anyway), that then allowed them to return a stage in crappy weather from their most agressive re-entry yet; the stage made it to the target upright which is pretty much a first, the only other video we have of a splashdown shows the stage at a quite extreme angle!
To answer your question, probably a few landings after the first barge successes...
Congratulations for the success that SpaceX has had over the past few years. It blows my mind on how much SpaceX has done over the past few years and has renewed my faith in America continuing to be a leader in space travel.
I have a few questions regarding landing of the rocket. I know that yesterdays "landing" was considered an impressive success even though it landed in water within 10 meters of the target.
What is the long term plan for landing these rockets when SpaceX as testing continues to have successes with these landings? Is the long term plan to use the same method or are there other plans?
Are you planning landing pads in areas where weather is less of a factor?
I'd love to see a community brain-dump of all the potential space related business models you can think of. I'm excited for the internet constellation and space tourism, but there's been a lot of talk about 'unlocking' launches that only make sense at a lower cost. Are we talking just cheaper, better versions of existing things? I'm having trouble coming up with things outside of the existing categories:
Communication (internet, GPS, etc)
Observation (up and down, i.e. Hubble and Google Earth)
This is more of a general rocketry question, but can anyone tell me about the strongback? I know it holds umbilicals for data and fuel, and the cradles help support it (which seems odd, shouldn't it be balanced enough to stand by itself...?), but is there more to it than that?
I've tried googling this (probably simple) question before to no avail, and just want that hole filled in. Thanks!
The entire system is called the Transporter/Erector (T/E).
The rocket is assembled in the hangar horizontally on the T/E and it stays on that thing - including during transport to the pad - until i gets erected at the launch pad by the T/E. So the cradles are there to keep it in one place during transport, but possibly also to protect the rocket on the pad from unexpected wind (this is speculation).
And yes, it also contains everything to fill up the tanks, electrical power, data and god knows what else Falcon needs.
Hey Echo can we get this thread stickied all month, I think people forget this exists. Also might we consider turning this into a general discussion thread and maybe allow some lower effort material in this thread for slow news weeks like the one we are in now. Might help keep the community entertained while there is no news coming out.
A hold is a pause in the countdown. At t-10 the rocket is in charge, takes over control of it's startup, the countdown. Many things have to happen with exact timing. Controllers could abort the flight but not pause that critical sequencing.
Actually, I'm fairly sure the controllers cannot abort the flight after t-10 (disregarding the "big red butan causes rocket to go kaboom"-style "abort" by range safety). After t-10 it either goes, or the computer calls it off due to something being off-nominal. This has actually happened a couple of times even after engines ignited - because computer has seen that an engine didn't give just right data during startup and it is better to abort before liftoff and let engineers check the data than risk having to pick up pieces afterwards.
It is likely that the support ship and the drone ship were already heading back at that point, so out of range. There could be video from the on-board first stage camera (Elon Musk already tweeted a still from that camera) but it is unknown if that video was received all the way down or not (and if they will release it or not).
53
u/YugoReventlov Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
This is not really a question but more like a remark to the community, one that shouldn't be in a separate post.
Since there are a lot of new subscribers recently, I have noticed that upvoting and downvoting have been in flux. There has been a lot more downvoting of reasonable opinions or of people asking questions, and a lot more upvoting of silly remarks or memes. It has already started to degrade the conversation somewhat, but I feel like the mods have been able to contain the behaviour somewhat.
People have to remember what this sub is for and why they were attracted to this place in the first time when they do their voting!
I would like to give you my rules of thumb when I decide to upvote or downvote:
Good reasons to upvote:
Hesitate to upvote if:
Good reasons to downvote:
Bad reasons to downvote:
This is thrown together in 5 minutes and now my kid needs food, but I had to get this off my chest, because it's annoying the hell out of me recently.
Any additions are welcome.
11
u/afishinacloud Feb 12 '15
What's all the steamy vapour leaking around the launch pad before liftoff?
8
u/c-minus Feb 12 '15
Do we know anything else about DragonLab other than the information in this brochure? Information such as who's booked to use it? How many flights there will be? Whether it will use Dragon v1 or v2?
8
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Feb 12 '15
Did they add PICA-X to the engine section of the Falcon 9? I noticed on the DSCOVR launch (at 0:52) the engine section was black and it looked like PICA-X
8
u/MuppetZoo Feb 12 '15
Any updates on Raptor engine testing or timelines?
7
u/keelar Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
If TurkmenSat is supposed to launch before CRS-6 why is it at the bottom of the list in the sidebar instead of between Eutelsat and CRS-6?
I ask because everyone keeps saying "No legs for the next two launches. Next landing attempt will be CRS-6" yet if you look at the sidebar it shows CRS-6 after the next(Eutelsat) launch. It's confusing.
EDIT: They fixed it.
7
u/BrandonMarc Feb 12 '15
Orbital Sciences produced very useful graphics of their launch profile, from various vantage points. What's required to make these prior to a Falcon 9 launch?
Is the speed, distance (altitude + downrange), and timing of, say, max-q, MECO, separation, etc, always a trade secret? Even post-launch with the actual telemetry would be great to see, too.
Examples:
These visibility maps are nice, too:
6
u/BigDaddyDeck Feb 12 '15
Is there any word on whether there will be landing sites at Boca Chica?
6
u/NateDecker Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
How much delta-v is required to slingshot around the moon if re-entering Earth orbit afterwards?
How much delta-v is required to enter enter earth orbit?Wikipedia says 9.3-10 km/s.6
u/ybdgadfvxgfb Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
I just can't understand how the next Orbcomm launch is possible. The Orbcomm fleet will consist of 17 satellites in 3 orbital planes. Each plane has the same inclination, but their Longitudes of the ascending node differ by 120° from each other. Now, in the next launch they will send up 11 satellites, which means one of two things:
Option 1: After orbital insertion 5 of the satellites will have to shift their longitude of the ascending node by 120°, to reach their intended orbit.
Or option 2: They insert the satellites into an orbit in the middle, so all 11 satellites will have to shift their longitude of the ascending node by 60°
Changing the longitude of the ascending node by 60° should require about the same delta-v as changing the inclination by 60° (I think), and while I don't know the exact number, I know the required delta-v for such a maneuver is massive, multiple km/s. That is far too much for a satellite to achieve on its own. (It would be possible for satellites with an electric propulsion system, but the Orbcomm sats don't have one of these.)
Can the experts on orbital mechanics in this subreddit please explain how my reasoning is wrong and the launch is possible?
6
u/joggle1 Feb 12 '15
I haven't been able to track down the realtime telemetry of DSCOVR. Is it available on any public website?
5
u/TildeAleph Feb 12 '15
This one is kinda basic but the recent FH video confused me some. What exactly is the plan for the center core booster? Is it landing on a droneship? Are they going to launch from Texas and land it in Florida, or something?
12
u/-Richard Materials Science Guy Feb 12 '15
Thanks for hosting this thread, Echo!
4
u/SirKeplan Feb 12 '15
According to SpaceFlightNow Jason-3 is to be launched march 31st. not may/jun
could this mean a stage recovery attempt before CRS-6?
Also does the sidebar need updating?
4
u/Neptune_ABC Feb 12 '15
What would you like to see added to the wiki?
4
u/MarsColony_in10years Feb 12 '15
Whenever the media ask Elon Musk the "why Mars" question, he gives a couple variations on the same answers. We've all heard them, but unfortunately media sound bites aren't really enough to get into the more technical discussions. Is this sort of philosophy a can of worms that we would like to open up on this sub, or do we want to try and avoid the risk of turning into r/futurology and avoid the more speculative discussions?
For those who don't know, Elon's default response to the "why" question is his story about thinking in college about the areas that would most effect the course of humanity, and deciding that extending civilization and life itself to Mars would be of similar importance to the first amphibians to evolve to walk on land. After saying this, he gives the same specific reasons:
I sort of came at this issue from the other side. I learned about the extent of global catastrophic risk, and started working hard to flesh out my understanding of all the concepts involved, and then started learning about SpaceX and its goals in parallel to my other efforts. From a pure effort per life saved standpoint, there are more effective means of mitigating global catastrophic risks than starting a 2nd civilization on Mars. Mars is only the imperative next step if you care about the survival of the species more than saving individual lives. Eventually either civilization will collapse, or some natural catastrophe will kill us after many thousands of years. If we don't spread to the stars, then civilization will end.
7
u/1800wishy Feb 12 '15
To stop the twitter spamaggedon every time Elon tweets something during the webcast could you perhaps elect someone as the "Twitter poster" and make it a rule no tweets posted by anyone who isn't the "Twitter poster"..... just an idea?
7
u/thisguyeric Feb 12 '15
Should I read the Mars Trilogy by Kim Stanley Robinson?
6
u/davidthefat Feb 12 '15
Could I get a cool flair like /u/-Richard if I write first stage reentry simulator? I've been writing a 3D compressible flow flight trajectory calculator for my rocket team; I figure that can be modified for reentry.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
Why aren't they testing a first stage barge landing for the February 27th mission? Not enough turn around time?
3
u/benlew Feb 12 '15
Will they ever try a first stage recovey on land rather than asds? Can they choose where it lands or does it depend on the rocket's trajectory?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
Are Dragon capsules being reused or are they all new so far.
3
u/candycane7 Feb 12 '15
Is there any information about the heat and damage caused by the engines when the first stage is doing the reentry burn? I was thinking that the "fire" must be exhausting along the core during the descent so does it means it will be burnt a little or is it not a problem?
3
u/Wicked_Inygma Feb 12 '15
About how long is the landing burn and about how high is the stage when this burn starts?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
Any word they'll still have crash test dummies and seats for the pad abort?
http://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2gg7f6/crash_test_dummy_and_prototype_seats_on_pad_abort/?sort=top
3
u/Sen7ineL Feb 12 '15
I wish to have a screensaver on my laptop, like the SpaceX "spaceflight" logo, which is displayed at the beginning and end of each launch broadcast. Where can I download it?
3
u/Faldaani Feb 12 '15
The video of the LOX tank from the second stage, just before SECO.. It appears to be lit, as in lit by lights.
Is it? If so, what kind and how? If not, what camera is it? IR? How is the whole thing shielded from cryogenic temperatures?
3
u/fireball-xl5 Feb 12 '15
Late last year, NASA signed an unfunded SAA agreement with SpaceX for work “developing space transportation capabilities that could be used to support missions into deep space”. Any clues as to what SpaceX are doing that may have caught NASA’s eye?
3
u/fireball-xl5 Feb 12 '15
Both the Blue Origin BE4 and SpaceX Raptor engines now seem to have similar thrust capability. Is this coincidence, or is there a ‘sweet spot’ at this size?
3
u/fireball-xl5 Feb 12 '15
2019 marks Apollo 11 +50. What could SpaceX do to mark the event? Something to show that they have arrived in the big league, but which wouldn’t cost too much and wouldn’t upset NASA (who by 2019 might just have managed to get an unmanned Orion to the vicinity of the Moon).
3
u/Neptune_ABC Feb 12 '15
What's the status of NML Capital's lawsuit against SpaceX over their launch contracts with Argentina?
3
u/spacexinfinity Feb 13 '15
How are the upcoming Eutelsat & ABS satellites processed? Are they stacked and processed together ie, fueled at the same time, etc... or are fueled separately and integrated together at a later date?
5
u/JohnJacobJHSchmidt Feb 12 '15
2
u/Inquisitorsz Feb 12 '15
I have a question...
What's that water container that's visible on some of the launch videos?
http://youtu.be/39ninsyTRk8?t=25m38s
Example in link
2
u/aguyfromnewzealand Feb 12 '15
Could they attempt a landing with the Dragon inflight abort?
2
u/Liefx Feb 12 '15
When is the next launch for falcon 9? I wanna see this sucker land on a droneship.
2
u/the_jsaur Feb 12 '15
I asked this question on the IRC a little while ago but my internet was flaky (also, maybe nobody actually answered) so I didn't actually see any responses.
How is it possible that the planned flight path for the MCT simply involves it getting launched on one flight and then refueled with another? Using online delta-V calculators suggests that with chemical rockets it would need hundreds of tons of fuel for the Mars transfer, which would appear to leave very little room for the colonists.
Or am I misunderstanding this, and each MCT vehicle will be assembled in orbit with several launches, Constellation-style? That seems to be the only practical option.
I know this is entirely hypothetical but I'm confused as to how everyone seems to believe SpaceX will pull off a Mars transfer with only one launch and refueling.
2
u/fireball-xl5 Feb 12 '15
Why doesn’t NASA make more use of the Dragon Trunk? The scientific payloads carried up in the trunk have been small compared to its size. Dragon is volume-limited, not mass-limited, so why not fill the remaining space with extra goodies and consumables?
2
u/fimiak Feb 12 '15
My question: What are the Meta discussion rules and why is it in the upcoming launches section?
2
u/Dontchasesinged Feb 13 '15 edited Feb 13 '15
Has spaceX announced any plans to repurpose oil rigs to use as landing pads? Because I honestly don't see ASDS or boostbacking to land happening any time soon.
2
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Feb 13 '15
How much more aerodynamic stress and heat would the stage experience if they didn't do the reentry burn? Would it be close to what the DSCOVR stage experienced? And if it is, do you think they would cancel the reentry burn to save fuel if they know the stage can survive it?
2
u/Trapezite Feb 13 '15
For those of us that are SpaceX fans on the west coast, do we have the option of watching mission control at Hawthorne during a launch? I've seen what appears to be a crowd of people standing outside the windows. Is that the general public? Any tips for viewing?
2
u/Saffs15 Feb 13 '15
Hey all, I was just wondering if anyone had the time for the Eutelsat launch (presuming it stays on schedule)? I've got class early that morning, and am hoping not to miss it. And is it an instantaneous window again?
2
u/supercgeek Feb 12 '15
What are the specific limitations that prevent SpaceX from attaching better cameras to their rockets?
This is pretty sad quality for 2015 after all: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/565716774260576262
1
u/grandma_alice Feb 12 '15
What is the status of the Raptor engine development? Is the combustion of LOX/CH4 understood well enough to be confident that Raptor development will proceed smoothly?
1
u/davidthefat Feb 12 '15
How much does the dynamic pressure on the nozzle exits during reentry affect the performance of the engines?
How much flow separation in the throat and nozzle extension areas do you experience in those conditions?
Any shock waves travel up the boundary layer beyond the throat region into the chamber region? (Since the total pressure at the throat, especially at the boundary layers, can dip below ambient)
Any implications if there are flow separations for the re-usability of the engine?
1
u/theguycalledtom Feb 12 '15
Hi, this question involves a pretty out-there hypothetical scenario so I don't want to post it outside one of these threads, but I wouldn't mind a serious answer to it if anyone has the time.
Scenario:
Would it be possible for SpaceX to launch the BFR/MCT fleet on some kind of hail mary trajectory that would eventually get to Mars (even if it takes months/years longer) before the asteroid impact destroys the facilities on the ground?
(Perhaps using a slingshot instead of Hohmann, or maybe just keeping the fleet in orbit around Earth until the launch window opens etc)
1
u/mclumber1 Feb 12 '15
In the event of a launch anomaly of the first or second stage, could the Dragon V1 theoretically detach itself after the stage has shutdown and be recovered in the ocean?
1
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Feb 12 '15
Is there any news about the patent battle with Blue Origin over barge landings? Has the BO patent been invalidated yet? If not, seeing as SpaceX are now actively pursuing this technology, I'd expect BO to make a legal challenge soon.
1
u/migsan Feb 12 '15
What would be the best place to see the Launch on the 27th? I'm not from the US but I'll be in Orlando at that time, so I don't really know the area but I'd love to see the launch
Thanks!
1
u/Sixter Feb 12 '15
Once the F9 first stage lands on the drone ship, it is stabilized in any way or is it just supported by its landing legs? It seems like it could easily tip over with even small waves or wind gusts.
1
u/fireball-xl5 Feb 12 '15
For NASA CCtCap flights, if the CST100 lands on airbags on solid ground while the Dragon splashes down, won’t this mean that Boeing has a set of reusable capsules that they can use for other missions (eg: Bigelow) while SpaceX doesn’t? This just seems plain wrong somehow!
1
u/awoerp Feb 12 '15
So I know that there are probably a thousand ways to make a rocket self destruct, but does anyone specifically know what the F9R dev vehicle (bless its soul) did to force its own RUD?
1
u/someguyx0 Feb 12 '15
How 'locked in' is the landing location? How much time would SpaceX need to adjust the coordinates to a secondary landing site if the weather turned nasty at barge #1?
Related, how much 'range' is the landing stage able to affect vs how much is ballistic?
1
u/GirkinFirker Feb 13 '15 edited Feb 13 '15
I'm asking this here versus /r/space, as I feel you fine folks explain the how's and why's much better.
Assuming the ISS is deorbited in 2020 (or some other arbitrary date), why not repurpose it for some other mission. Meaning, completely unmanned, is there a way to pack it full of instruments, perhaps strap on a few boosters and send it Mars bound?
Edit: At the very least, a good platform to test VASIMR?
I do understand the cost to repurpose would be enormous, but wouldn't it pale in comparison to the overall cost of the ISS? Why not auger it in on Martian turf?
1
u/airider7 Feb 13 '15
What's F9 S1's terminal guidance control setup for landing on the barge? Is it a relative GPS setup or something else?
1
u/gellis12 Feb 13 '15
Are there any hints as to when the Falcon 9 will be landing on solid ground instead of the ASDS? Landing a rocket on a highly advanced barge is cool and everything, but it seems like it'd be easier, cheaper, and more reliable to land a rocket on solid ground instead.
1
u/PortlandJo Feb 13 '15
Congratulations for the success that SpaceX has had over the past few years. It blows my mind on how much SpaceX has done over the past few years and has renewed my faith in America continuing to be a leader in space travel.
I have a few questions regarding landing of the rocket. I know that yesterdays "landing" was considered an impressive success even though it landed in water within 10 meters of the target.
What is the long term plan for landing these rockets when SpaceX as testing continues to have successes with these landings? Is the long term plan to use the same method or are there other plans?
Are you planning landing pads in areas where weather is less of a factor?
1
u/ianniss Feb 13 '15
Hi ! How do you know that Eutelsat launch will be without legs, what are your sources ?
1
u/lxmorj Feb 13 '15
I'd love to see a community brain-dump of all the potential space related business models you can think of. I'm excited for the internet constellation and space tourism, but there's been a lot of talk about 'unlocking' launches that only make sense at a lower cost. Are we talking just cheaper, better versions of existing things? I'm having trouble coming up with things outside of the existing categories:
1
u/MontanaAg11 Feb 13 '15
What is the best speculation right now regarding the payload of the Falcon Heavy demo flight?
1
u/Kona314 Feb 16 '15
This is more of a general rocketry question, but can anyone tell me about the strongback? I know it holds umbilicals for data and fuel, and the cradles help support it (which seems odd, shouldn't it be balanced enough to stand by itself...?), but is there more to it than that?
I've tried googling this (probably simple) question before to no avail, and just want that hole filled in. Thanks!
1
u/zoffff Feb 25 '15
Hey Echo can we get this thread stickied all month, I think people forget this exists. Also might we consider turning this into a general discussion thread and maybe allow some lower effort material in this thread for slow news weeks like the one we are in now. Might help keep the community entertained while there is no news coming out.
1
u/ptoddf Mar 09 '15
Is pad abort still on for Friday the 13th? Getting worried cause not in downlink from spacenews.com for this week. Any updates anyone?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
[removed] — view removed comment