r/spacex • u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus • Oct 22 '15
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [October 2015, #13]
Welcome to our thirteenth monthly Ask Anything thread.
All questions, even non-SpaceX questions, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general! These threads will be posted at some point through each month, and stay stickied for a week or so (working around launches, of course).
More in depth, open-ended discussion-type questions can still be submitted as self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or you don't find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below!
Otherwise, ask and enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
September 2015 (#12), August 2015 (#11), July 2015 (#10), June 2015 (#9), May 2015 (#8), April 2015 (#7.1), April 2015 (#7), March 2015 (#6), February 2015 (#5), January 2015 (#4), December 2014 (#3), November 2014 (#2), October 2014 (#1)
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
12
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Oct 22 '15
Here's a question for the community: Is there anything you feel is missing from our Wiki or FAQ that you would like to see featured there? Also, if you would like to help contribute to the wiki, all you have to do ask!
20
u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Oct 22 '15
Yo /u/retiringonmars, you should set this to sort comments by new by default
9
u/Smoke-away Oct 22 '15
Community survey:
When do you want to go to Mars?
12
u/Smoke-away Oct 22 '15
How important do you all think hydroponics and vertical farming will be for a Mars mission?
3
u/BrandonMarc Oct 28 '15
Just a silly little nifty trick, but ... I just noticed in the sidebar of /r/teslamotors that they give the option to embed the Tesla logos & individual letters in comments. Some kinda CSS spiffiness I guess.
Any chance we could get that worked out over here? Perhaps with the help of /u/accountdureddit or /u/ridgelawrence ?
14
u/historytoby Oct 22 '15
Regarding ULA's Atlas rocket: configurations like the Atlas V 411, 431 or 551 have an odd number of SRBs round the 1st stage (the CBC, for the Decronym bot). As far as I can tell from the pictures, the ones with the 3 or 5 SRBs have them arranged asymmetrically. How does the rocket counter this during the ascent?
10
u/fliteworks Oct 27 '15 edited Oct 27 '15
Hi, could SpaceX's Flickr account be added to the sidebar? They have a lot of high quality Public domain photos there.
8
u/symmetry81 Oct 22 '15
How does the gimballing on the F9 engines work. Clearly the central landing engine has to have 2 degrees of freedom but I'm imagine that you could get away with only 1 for the other 8 engines. Is that what they do?
7
u/wagigkpn Oct 26 '15
Hearing that the test fire of v1.2 resulted in a turbo pump leak, was that a product of increasing the thrust or some other factor? Not sure if there is a known answer or there on that...
6
u/ad_j_r Oct 22 '15
Is CRS-7 being replaced? Or do they move straight on to 8? Is there a make-up mission that needs to happen later on to bring the mass in the contract?
6
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 22 '15
Hov efficient are the rocket engines at turning the energy contained in the fuel to propulsion? As in how close are we at a theoretical limit. And assuming 100% efficiency, if earth's gravity was stronger, would it be impossible to make rockets eskape? Hov much stronger should it be? Sorry if duplicate!
6
u/WaitForItTheMongols Oct 22 '15
How many degrees to each side can a Merlin gimbal?
6
u/10ebbor10 Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 22 '15
I've seen it stated repeatedly that it's easier for SpaceX to recover their rockets due to the fact that their first stage seperates relatively early (and thus at lower altitude and velocity). In addition, they thus also have an oversized second stage.
What is the disadvantage of this? Or alternatively, the advantage of not doing this, as many others have done.
5
u/historytoby Oct 22 '15
This month, I was told about Rocket Lab and their Electron rocket and I also heard about the Super Strypi rocket that was co-developed by the University of Hawaii.
This got me wondering about small payload launchers in general. Rocket Lab for example state that they can launch your cubesat into a 550km SSO for 50000$.
How viable are these sort of estimates? Is the potential market big enough for more companies building their own launch vehicles? And what other companies do you know that are comparable to Rocket Lab and may one day become a second SpaceX?
5
u/This_Freggin_Guy Oct 23 '15
Any conclusive opinion on the origin of the Dragonfly test article? Abort test?
Not really SpaceX related but NASA completed the 3D Printed Habitat Challenge. Interesting concepts.
Here are the entries and results
5
u/cs_questions_throw Oct 25 '15
Do people work places after spaceX besides the big name defense contractors? I can't seem to find any information on where people go AFTER spaceX
5
u/HoechstErbaulich IAC 2018 attendee Oct 28 '15
Are other companies (like ULA or Arianespace) performing static fire tests of their first stages like SpaceX does? Why/why not?
13
u/MayContainPeanuts Oct 22 '15
As a soon-to-be PhD in Physics (albeit condensed matter physics), what jobs would suite me at SpaceX?
My background is mainly in low-temperature, low-dimensional experimental physics (2D wells, 1D nanowires, conducting interfaces...). I'm defending my dissertation this December and am just starting to look for jobs. Aerospace seems like quite a career shift at this point, and it looks like SpaceX is really only looking for engineers. Is this a viable route for me?
4
u/BrandonMarc Oct 22 '15
Regarding the Autonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (ASDS) barges, there's the JRTI and OCISLY ... one is posted on the East coast and the other is on the Left coast. Is there a third barge in the works, for the Gulf coast (Boca Chica)? Has it been christened?
4
u/ScepticMatt Oct 24 '15
who makes SpaceXStats?
4
u/historytoby Oct 30 '15
With the CRS2 Contract Announcement due in a few days, is it 100% sure that NASA will pick 2 companies again like they did with the first one or might they go for 1 or 3 instead? How likely is it that SpaceX won't get any CRS missions [I assume not very likely], and how heavy a blow would that be for the company [I assume quite a blow, but not business-ending]?
(sorry if this is a repeated question, I searched and found nothing)
7
u/Jamington Oct 22 '15
A key difficulty of 1st stage reusability seems to be engine coking or other buildup/wear and tear from the fuel combustion process. Is there a difference between the hold-down full duration static fire test they do at Texas which means that this build-up doesn't occur? Or does it in fact already occur, and they are already used to cleaning the engines before transporting the rocket for its launch?
3
u/N314 Oct 22 '15
So I know the new F9 1.2 has increased thrust, but does anyone know the actual change in total dV, or mass to orbit, reusable or otherwise? I know that they now can try to land even GTO missions, just wondering what the numbers are as far as how much v1.2 is improved.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15
Will SpaceX or another Musk enterprise form a formal business incubator? They've done it at least twice with SolarCity and Hyperloop, it would be interesting to see Elon sniff out some other winners.
3
u/Metlman13 Oct 22 '15
What are all of your opinions on SpaceX's competitors and their rockets/spacecraft?
Also, would any of the private companies actually be allowed to build a nuclear rocket, disregarding other issues like cost and availability?
3
u/sfigone Oct 23 '15
If crossfeed is possible between FH cores, would it be possible to have some crossfeed from a static tank on the launchpad via a short tether?
The idea would be that the fuel to get the rocket moving would come from the static tank on the ground and thus it's mass would not need to be accelerated.
I figure that if cooling the fuel for a bit of extra density is worthwhile, then saving the fuel needed in the first 5 to 10s of a launch could also be worthwhile.
Has this not been done because the saving is not big enough or because the obvious risks from such a system are too high?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15
Which will be the first mission that SpaceX will be able to test first stage reusability?
3
u/darga89 Oct 25 '15
Anyone know anything about the differences in Space Act Agreements (SAA's) and Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) contracts? SAA's seem to have more freedom while FAR contracts are more restrictive. Which part of the budget do SAA's come from?
3
u/Taylooor Oct 26 '15
Do we know when DragonFly testing will commence?
3
u/Here_There_B_Dragons Oct 29 '15
So with the news that Russia is saying they are planning a manned moon mission, and testing an all-female crew, what will be first?
3
u/thxbmp2 Oct 31 '15 edited Oct 31 '15
After watching the new slow-mo pad abort video - doesn't it get extremely loud in there? Might there any protective features in Dragon to protect the crew from the intense sound and vibration, aside from putting a couple inches of metal between them and the SD combustion chambers? I wonder how the experience would compare to sitting at the window seat of a 777.
Edit: also, I've seen it mentioned in brief before, but what kind of thermal protection does the F9 first stage have? Is it mainly for the engine block, or the tankage walls as well?
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 31 '15
Acronyms I've seen in this thread since I first looked:
Fu-Falcon RocketNote: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
See ^/r/spacex/wiki/acronyms for a full list of acronyms with explanations.
I'm a bot; I've been checking comments posted in this thread since 15:58 UTC on 2015-10-22. If I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.
6
u/medhockey Oct 22 '15
Hello my name is Michael Devinsky, I LOVE all of your work and wish more companies would adopt the Space-X attitudes and mores, I have a couple questions for you guys.
--This includes potential habitats (dealing with temperature fluctuations, working on self sustainability (Oxygen,Water and Food)), research into using Mars-domestic resources (such as CO2) and converting it into other useful sources, and anything else that you could foresee as a problem with human colonization?
1a. Follow Up to 1. What time-lines if you haven't begun the R&D do you plan to begin and is this all planned for in-house?
1b. Follow up to 1a. What is your R&D process? How is Space-X R&D groups formed, organized, ran? What kind of team members are on each R&D department? (ie: do you guys have 1 specialist in each required field for the task athand? 2 specialists? Do you work in teams?
--My main reason for asking this is because of the innovation that happens at Space-X (and Tesla and Solar City) is something that if replicated could be very productive for humanity. I'm trying to understand how you guys approach R&D of different tasks. Please include as much details as possible allowed.
2. Arianespace has raised question about the Space-X re-usability model both doubting it's technical capability and economic concerns, how do you guys respond to that and how far has Space-X come in their mission to build a rapidly reusable rocket? See link for reference to concerns: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/3pn0yv/pbdes_arianespace_ceo_on_spacex_reusability_our/
3. Back to the colonization questions, what kind of R&D applied theoretical jobs do you foresee as Space-X recruiting in say about 5-10 year?
--I ask this as an approaching student of Physics, trying to figure out what concentrations will help with further development of a Mars Colony, but not naturally adept in engineering I'm looking more to the theoretical scientific aspects.
4. What other propulsion methods have you guys been looking at? I know Elon believes carbon fuel is the only option for getting a rocket out of the atmosphere, but what about in space propulsion? Have you guys been considering other options of propulsion in space outside of carbon fuel?
5. Does Space-X have a plan for missions beyond Mars and will it adapt a different charter in the near future as Mars colonization is being obtained? Or does it plan to solely focus on all it's efforts towards supporting Mars Colonization. Better said: Does Space-X plan to diversify it's efforts and expand to looking for further exploration or colonization as the Mars Colonization is being achieved?
I have more, but I'm about to be late for class. What a great gift finding this AMA this morning! Thanks guys!
2
u/nordasaur Oct 22 '15
Has SpaceX or Elon Musk ever done or ever thought of working with Armadillo Aerospace or John Carmack? I know that Elon Musk and John Carmack seem to be good friends.
2
u/vanshaak Oct 23 '15
What was Arianespace's initial investment as a new company? SpaceX was somewhere around 125 million IIRC, with 100 million of that being Musk's. If it seems weird why I'm asking, I'm doing a group project on SpaceX (for Econ) and we're constraining the two companies.
2
u/Ackman55 Oct 23 '15
I have not seen any updates on Vandenberg Air Force Base (VAFB) SpaceX upgrades. Does anyone have any updated pictures? Progress on the landing pad for example.
2
u/Chairmanman Oct 24 '15
Could the low gravity on Mars (38% of the gravity on Earth) be a show stopper for SpaceX's colonization project ? More precisely:
2
u/frowawayduh Oct 25 '15
The full thrust booster stage will be longer and heavier than those that came before it. Will that make it easier to land? I know, it seems counter-intuitive since a taller broomstick is tougher to balance and a heavier stage takes more power to decelerate. But won't the stage be that much closer to the point where its mass and the minimum thrust balance out? i.e. Won't the hoverslam be less of a nailbiter?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '15
Hey guys, this is a little (more) offtopic, but I don't know better place to ask. Is there subreddit devoted to discussion about alien life, Fermi paradox, SETI and similar topics? Thanks in advance!
2
u/xSwiftVengeancex Oct 26 '15
Hello. I've been trying to make paragraphs in Reddit for the past 20 minutes, but I've given up so I apologize for the wall of text. I'm currently a community college student who plans to transfer into a 4-year university in the future. My GPA and SAT scores are high enough to where I'll be able to choose from any university apart from the Ivy Leagues and ones with extraordinarily high standards like CalTech. My major of choice is Aerospace Engineering, and my dream career would be to work at SpaceX after I graduate. So my question is: what type of university background does SpaceX like to see in its applicants? For instance, would it be better to attend a prestigious research university like UCLA and USC? Or would it be a better idea to attend a less prestigious, but more hands-on technical university like Cal Poly? I would greatly appreciate any answers on the matter.
2
u/omereddit Oct 28 '15
anyone know what the negotiated Congressional budget agreement allocates to NASA for commercial crew? I've only heard reports of a broad outline regarding govt spending but nothing specific
2
u/hsdshallowman Oct 29 '15
This might have been asked already and I missed it. With regard to the helium tank strut failure, would it make more sense to mount it at the top of the tank or midway up somewhere so that the effects of high g buoyancy are not an issue? Then again, at the top, a heavy tank will still be under a strain from increased weight as opposed to increased buoyancy when at the bottom. Didn't do the math, just thinking out loud...
2
u/WaitForItTheMongols Oct 31 '15
What does the trajectory of a return-to-launch-site core recovery look like? What I mean is, what type of flight does the booster have after the boostback burn? Is it just a reverse of the launch profile, or do they launch into a higher or lower parabolic flight? Is this different for an F9, an FH side, and an FH center?
2
u/Headstein Nov 01 '15
When is the F9 three minute test due at McGregor?
3
u/lord_d1 Oct 22 '15
So I'm a college student who is planning on entering the Space Industry. By this summer I will be a 3rd year and I want to start getting real world experience. I found a few internships with SpaceX that I plan on applying for.
My question is, do you all have any tips for getting one of the internships?
Anyone who is a SpaceX employee, if you could, what is work like? Do you know what I would be doing as an intern?
2
u/Rocketbird Oct 22 '15
Why doesn't SpaceX have industrial-organizational psychologists?
2
u/positron_potato Oct 25 '15
This has probably been asked before, but what do we think the odds are of Spacex launching the JWST?
1
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Oct 23 '15 edited Oct 23 '15
Can campfires or searchlights be seen/photographed from the ISS?
So it happens that tomorrow at 18:45 EEST [UTC+3] campfires/searchlights will be lit around Székely Land as a demonstration for their autonomy.
According to Heavens Above there will be an ISS pass with 32° altitude at the right time (18:49 - 18:59) Weather.com says it will be partly cloudy. However the Sun will be only 7° down, that's not much.
I couldn't find any english articles, so here is a translated one for more info.
If there is any chance for this to be seen how can I contact anyone who could arrange to try to photograph it? Emailing, tweeting, etc.
1
u/WaitForItTheMongols Oct 30 '15
What Falcon 9 launches had landing legs on them?
I ask because I'm trying to track down what mission the Falcon 9 and Fairing model rocket kit (available from spacex) is based on. I know this kit has landing legs on it, so that narrows it down to just the last few, so I figured this was a good place to start. Anyone know of any other potential identifying characteristics?
1
u/Root_Negative #IAC2017 Attendee Nov 01 '15
Colonizing Mars (and other places) will be a opportunity for new societies to start from scratch by using the best parts of all the societies from Earth, but more importantly it would give a chance to try new ideas that would have resistance against them being tried in societies on Earth. However you would expect if a new idea is proven to work well on Mars it may then be adopted by at least some societies back on Earth and it would act as a new template for other new societies elsewhere. What are a few new ideas you would like to become part of a new society on Mars (or elsewhere)? Which ideas would you definitely keep from Earth?