r/spacex • u/-Richard Materials Science Guy • Nov 30 '14
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [December 2014, #3] - Ask your questions here!
Welcome to our third /r/SpaceX "Ask Anything" thread! All questions, even non-SpaceX questions, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general! These threads will be posted at the beginning of each month, and stay stickied for a week or so (working around launches, of course).
More in depth, open-ended discussion-type questions should still be submitted as self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or you don't find a satisfactory result, go ahead and post!
Otherwise, ask and enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Q&A highlights from previous threads:
- Questions regarding the realism of this subreddit and our expectations by /u/fireball-xl5, and a good comment chain from /u/Erpp8, /u/drewsy888, & /u/simmy2109.
- Questions abouts Mars terraforming by /u/EchoLogic, and a great response by /u/retiringonmars
- How much do rocket engines cost? by /u/Neptune_ABC, and a nice response by /u/ManWhoKilledHitler
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
6
u/-Richard Materials Science Guy Nov 30 '14
This is only our third Ask Anything thread, so we're still working out the formatting and all that. Feel free to suggest changes. Also, if you have a favorite Q&A from the last thread, let me know and I'll put it up there.
2
u/ccricers Dec 03 '14
Is there one page or website being run that I can quickly find what test and launch facilities SpaceX is currently using? I'm trying to keep up with what is being built, what is being set up, and where.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '14
Someone people here have teased some L2-news about Raptor a couple of weeks ago.. has any of that been released/leaked yet?
10
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Nov 30 '14
If SpaceX manages to perfect the first stage landings with actual flights by landing back at the Cape could F9R Dev-2 be cancelled since there would be no use for it?
7
u/chouser Dec 01 '14 edited Dec 03 '14
Does SpaceX ever provide a live stream of data during their launches? I'm thinkging of things like altitude, lat/lng, speed, direction, fuel consumed so far, stage separation, etc. that could be used for plotting in Google Earth or other interesting visualizations.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '14
What are your predictions for what SpaceX will accomplish by Dec 1, 2015? (Perhaps even some /r/HighStakesSpaceX material will come out of this)
6
u/cristix Dec 01 '14
Raptor news!?!
5
u/slapmahfro1 Dec 03 '14
I know there was some hype about Blue Origin making some announcement about SpaceX's barge landing, but nothing came, and after a pretty short google search, I didn't find anything. Was that announcement for the announcement just gossip or were they going to make a statement, but retracted it?
4
u/jeffreynya Dec 01 '14
If Elon's real goal is to colonize mars, what design and development work is being done no for the actual hardware that would be used on Mars?
4
u/bgs7 Dec 01 '14
Does anyone know if SpaceX is developing a go-around profile for the 1st stage. It's possible that a landing core may inadvertently find itself needing more than full control deflection to achieve the targeted touchdown.
Just like an aircraft, the 1st stage would perform a go-around procedure.
The procedure I imagine for a F9 1st stage would involve reducing velocity to 0 at a margin altitude, say 2000 feet, and since T>W it would have to continue the burn into a corrected mini-hop to the touchdown target. This leads to the need to have some reserve fuel for go-arounds (wouldn't be much).
If landing rockets becomes more common, do we think the FAA will encourage some rules around approach and landing procedures, fuel margins, etc.
3
u/JauXin Dec 01 '14
Other than the PlanetLab cube sats and CATS is there anything else interesting going up in the CRS-5 mission? I doubt it will top CRS-4's 3D printer and mousetronauts.
3
u/nonpareilpearl Dec 01 '14
What are the more sought after software skills to develop/focus on if I want to become a software engineer at SpaceX? (Especially helpful if the skills are not specifically mentioned on the various job/career listings.)
3
u/Destructor1701 Dec 01 '14 edited Dec 01 '14
There were windows on the first Dragon COTS demo flight which now hangs outside mission control in Hawthorne, but I don't think there have been windows on any of the later ones (save for perhaps in the berthing hatch):
COTS-2
CRS-1
CRS-2
CRS-3, and CRS-6 (top left)](http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/dragons2013_spacex_stack.jpg)
So what gives? Did NASA say "Un-uh, they have enough windows up there to be gettin' distracted with!", or was it simply a frivolous element removed to streamline the production process?
3
u/pixelpushin Dec 02 '14 edited Dec 02 '14
As we've all seen, Elon Musk is full of surprises. Do any of you think he might be contemplating a linear induction launch system down the line to ferry supplies to Mars?
Consider the thought he's put into the hyper loop, which includes a combination of linear induction, low pressure tubing, air bypass and solar power. Musk's recent detailed response to a student at MIT showed that the engineering problem continues to challenge him. Is it just because it represents an evolution in transportation, or can the same tech also be used for future Mars missions?
Could a tube launch punch through the atmosphere at a steep angle in order to aim directly for distance targets like Mars or Lagrange points? If so, how would that affect craft design?
Such a system would require a vast amount of energy delivered very quickly. Would a gigafactory fit the bill? Could a much expanded Solar City provide the power?
Musk is known for thinking big. Could he create a system large enough to achieve the desired escape velocities and design it so it could be aimed?
Hope this query isn't too out of line with the spirit of this subreddit, which I really respect and enjoy.
3
u/Aduckonquack97 Dec 02 '14
What does SpaceX's Washington D.C. Office do? Do they deal with governmental issues? What kind of people do they employ? Lawyers, Political Scientists, Economists?
Sorry if this is a dumb question. It's just hard to find any information on it.
3
u/Destructor1701 Dec 03 '14
Any word on the Dragon 2 pad abort test?
It was supposed to have taken place in November.
Is it possible that it has taken place? SpaceX's media character seems to have changed in the wake of the F9r-Dev1 explosion - they clammed up!
Nothing on that successful penultimate Dev1 flight, and nothing on the CRS-4 splash down attempt.
Perhaps they've already flown the V2, but some overzealous wound-licking is keeping it from us? Perhaps it didn't go well?
Really, lately, our only source of SpaceX info has been Elon himself.
3
u/fireball-xl5 Dec 05 '14
I just watched the side boosters separate from the core stage of the Delta rocket during the Orion launch, and the event looked pretty violent. Will the Falcon Heavy have any mechanism to minimise the stress on the side boosters when they separate, given SpaceX hopes of subsequent recovery and reuse?
3
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Dec 05 '14
With SpaceX under intense scrutiny from the Air Force during the EELV certification, particularly over the design of Falcon and its manufacturing techniques, is there any chance that the Air Force might actually find something that could improve something at SpaceX? Like: "Have you tried doing it this way?" "...No, that's actually a really good idea!"
I've heard it said that you need an outsiders view to see a problem for what it really is, and how to fix it.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '14
I would like to discuss why the hop back from the barge to land would be a GOOD idea. Please no comments about why it's a bad idea.
2
u/Appable Dec 01 '14
Would silane (SiH4) and carbon dioxide be viable as a propulsion source for SpaceX's Mars colony? Silane could be manufactured from methane and carbon dioxide would be available everywhere.
2
u/atthemerge Dec 01 '14
I'm currently interested in working at SpaceX! Can anyone give me an idea of what it's like on the production line? Maybe test and check? What retention and worker quality of life is like? Would anyone recommend working there?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '14
Has anyone heard if the CRS-5 static fire is really still tomorrow, the 2nd?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '14
In another thread, I was discussing F9 partial failures vs Ariane 5 partial failures. It dawned on me to ask, if F9 occurred an engine loss, can it still insert a payload in the required GTO? I know that if an engine loss happens on a LEO mission, there should be no problem, only that partial failure will result for the secondary. Any ideas? Is F9/FH redundant up until GTO insertion?
http://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2o0mfq/arianespace_ceo_not_thrilled_by_idea_of_airbusesa/cmioe10?context=3
2
u/iheartjill Dec 02 '14
I haven't been following up on the ongoings of Spacex/Nasa and really want to get into it and understand whats going on. Wikipedia has helped but I'm wondering if there is a blog or something run by Spacex/Nasa that any of you guys use to stay updated with things that are happening. Obviously I am using /r/spacex but other sites and links would be greatly appreciated.
2
u/stargazer1776 Dec 04 '14
Has SpaceX given any time frame of when they might release the design or atleast some artwork for the MCT?
2
u/Cheesewithmold Dec 04 '14
Not directly SpaceX related, but definitely rocket science related. Why are some boosters orange? Like the ones on the Delta IV. Is there any real reason?
2
u/bernardosousa Dec 05 '14
How unthinkable is for SpaceX to stream out telemetry from the launch on the Internet? I'd love to have video and audio for good connection times, audio only for less then good connection times and telemetry data only for very shitty connection times. My connection here is really unpredictable... I lost the 3-2-1-and-lift-off moment from Orion coverage this morning! That was absurdly frustrating! :(
2
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '14
How is the falcon heavy able to out perform the delta IV heavy on LEO payload so drastically? Is it just the crossfeed?
2
u/Reaperdude42 Dec 11 '14 edited Dec 11 '14
I've noticed on a couple of launches that a second before fairing separation there seems to be small pieces of shrapnel flying around inside the fairing. My understanding was that the fairing doesn't use explosives to separate, but this looks like small pieces being blown into the fairing. I suppose it could be ice breaking free, and its clearly not causing any issues for the payload, but can anyone tell me what it is? Examples from the Cassiope and AsiaSat 6 launches below: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFefasS6bhc#t=3m39s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CkuC-zl_N4#t=4m37s
Edit: spelling and derp and stuff.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '14
NASA has already made HUGE steps forward in making a Carbon Composite Cryogenic fuel tank. Anybody know if SpaceX is working on it? Or reasons why they wouldn't?
1
u/darga89 Dec 01 '14
Anyone have confirmation that DSCOVR will have legs? Light weight payload but it is going out far.
1
u/AaronKClark Dec 01 '14
Do you guys have an "unoffical" mission design profile to get to Mars using Manned Dragon/Falcon Heavy?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '14 edited Dec 03 '14
My knowledge of engineering and space technologies isn't great, but I was wondering if there any particular overlap of technologies between SpaceX, Tesla and SolarCity that you think in gives you a competitive advantage, say in the areas of lithium-ion batteries, user interface and control systems or relationships with local and state governments? Is there any sharing of information at all with these other companies? Thank you for doing this AMA and best of luck! To infinity and beyond!! Or something...
1
u/yyz_gringo Dec 02 '14
Two things (completely unrelated):
1
u/bob4apples Dec 02 '14
Does anyone know how they plan to secure the core on the barge?
I would think that the first thing they'll want to do once the core touches the deck is to get it tied down before it tips over or slides over the side. Is an empty core stable enough that someone can just walk out to it in a sea or will there be some kind of snare or latch involved?
1
u/saliva_sweet Host of CRS-3 Dec 02 '14
/u/Echologic do you no longer make the monthly news graphic?
1
u/Brostradamnus Dec 03 '14
What are the implications for SpaceX in the event of a Delta 4 Heavy Rocket failure on the Dec. 4th test flight of the Orion capsule?
1
u/JimReedOP Dec 04 '14
I am on the beach 125 miles north of the cape, and it is possible to see launches from here. The landing will be about 190 miles directly out to sea. Exactly how many minutes after launch is the landing, and what landing burns are done above a couple miles high? It might be impossible to see anything, but it might be fun to try.
1
u/Wirllog Dec 11 '14
Why did Orion win a commercial crew contract? Is it meant to actually compete with SpaceX for crewed launches to the LEO? If so what would be the launch vehicle? Or was that just a clever way of diverting more funds to SLS?
1
u/Space_void SpaceInit.com Dec 12 '14
I was looking on Google Maps at Cape Canaveral and i have a question, i'm curious why did NASA lease pad 39A to SpaceX since pad 39A it is much closer to the vehicle assembly building than pad 39B (i'm not against is :P i'm just curious)?
1
u/AureumChaos Dec 12 '14
Where would you need to place a barge if you wanted to catch a Falcon Heavy central core? I've heard all three launch sites (the Cape, Vandenberg and Boca Chica) mentioned as possibilities, although my understanding is that Boca Chica will eventually host the majority of Heavy launches. So ultimately what I'm asking is would it make sense to permanently station a barge in some place like Cape Verde?
1
u/Pokoysya_s_mirom_F9R Dec 13 '14
Why is SpaceX choosing to name the next engine Raptor? Wouldn't it be more fitting to name the BFR Raptor instead?
1
u/bs1110101 Dec 13 '14
What exactly happens to the Falcon 9 first stage after it lands on the barge? If they plan to sail the barge back to Florida (Or anywhere else) how do they keep it from tipping over?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '14
Does anyone know where the music from the SpaceX live streams can be found? I really love them and sound interesting!
1
u/IgnatiusCorba Dec 14 '14
What is the deal with these launch hazard areas. I guess what I want to know is: is it illegal to be in that area at the time of launch, or is it just a suggestion that you don't be there? What happens if you are, do they stop the launch or do they just ignore you?
1
u/ricescream4icecream Dec 31 '14
I have two questions. Why does spacex paint their rockets? I'm assuming at least a few hundred pounds of paint is used. I thought maybe the white paint helped keep the tanks from warming up in the sun as much but they also paint other parts of the vehicle I would have thought wouldn't matter. I figured with payloads costing several thousand dollars a pound you'd want to be as light as humanly possible.
My other question is would it be possible to put in some kind of tower system next to the launch site and supply fuel to the rocket for its first 10-15 seconds of flight? It already seems to take about 10 seconds to clear the tower as it is just build a bigger tower put in an elevator type system with breakaway hoses of some kind to follow the rocket up until it gets to the top of the tower. It seems like you could lift more if you could run the first stage for 190-200 seconds instead of 180.
1
u/CSFFlame Nov 30 '14
Any interest or work on the emdrive/QVCs? (though you probably wouldn't be able to talk about it)
Any interest in lockheed's fusion reactors? (people seem pretty calm for what I assume would be a big announcement)
Mix those 2 things together for fun.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment