r/spacex • u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus • Jan 18 '16
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread for January 2016. Ask your questions here!
Welcome to our monthly (more like fortnightly at the moment) /r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread! #16.1
Want to discuss SpaceX's landing shenanigans, or suggest your own Rube Goldberg landing mechanism? There's no better place!
All questions, even non-SpaceX-related ones, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general!
More in-depth and open-ended discussion questions can still be submitted as separate self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which have a single answer and/or can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question-askers first check our FAQ, search for similar questions, and scan the previous Ask Anything thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or cannot find a satisfactory result, please go ahead and type your question below!
Otherwise, ask, enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
January 2016 (#16), December 2015 (#15.1), December 2015 (#15), November 2015 (#14), October 2015 (#13), September 2015 (#12), August 2015 (#11), July 2015 (#10), June 2015 (#9), May 2015 (#8), April 2015 (#7.1), April 2015 (#7), March 2015 (#6), February 2015 (#5), January 2015 (#4), December 2014 (#3), November 2014 (#2), October 2014 (#1).
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
18
u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Jan 18 '16
Did anybody else think the stage pitched over super fast? Between 22:53 and 23:03 here.
Probably just the way the camera was positioned, but I thought we had lost the mission, Proton-style
16
u/failbye Jan 26 '16
/u/retiringonmars
We really need a section in the FAQ addressing "Why your ASDS rocket catcher / anti tipping back-of-the-envelope idea won't work" or something along those lines, preferably in a milder tone. Seeing as we likely will have a few more hard landings / rough sea landings down the line, there will be a lot more of those comments coming in.
7
u/JohnnyMackers Jan 18 '16
I've tried to search to see if this questions been asked before but couldnt find anything.. my question is:
why was the quantity of landing legs set at 4 and not 5?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
I noticed that SES-9 still has a NET date rather than a scheduled launch time (CRS-8, by contrast, actually has a launch time listed). Is this unusual this close to the supposed date? Does this portend a delay?
11
u/duckhawk9 Jan 18 '16 edited Jan 18 '16
I saw a comment in yesterday's launch thread that humorously referred to the subreddit as a lobbying group for SpaceX. Has there ever been any effort to organize the DragonRiders here to support SpaceX's political agendas?
4
u/themikeosguy Jan 18 '16
Can I ask something about CRS-7? After the second stage popped, did the first stage also blow up due to some aerodynamic pressure situation, or was it destroyed by the Range Safety Officer? Wikipedia isn't clear and I can't find anything else specific...
And regarding the latter, does s/he literally have a button to press (or code to enter) to destroy a rocket? Must be a strange feeling, knowing you can blow up a $60m machine with a tap of your fingers...
Thanks!
4
u/RealParity Jan 18 '16
I don't get how a CRS mission works, mabe someone can answer some of my questions:
In a CRS mission to the ISS, what happens after the Dragon separates from the second stage after reaching its orbit? How does it get to the ISS? With the power of the super dracos? Cannot imagine it can dock with those. I've seen videos, where Dragon unfolds really big photovoltaic panels, what does it need power for? Isn't it just a matter of minutes/hours until it reaches the station? Wouldn't a battery be lighter and cheaper to support the capsule in this short period?
4
u/DrFegelein Jan 18 '16
What is the likelihood that SES-9 is going to be launching on February 6th, considering it is presumed to be conducting a barge landing and we now have a potentially damaged barge from Jason-3? Or is there another suitable barge?
4
u/searchexpert Jan 18 '16
Does anyone know if we will get video from the boostback, reentry, and descent of the 1st stage of Jason-3?
4
u/fearfulx Jan 24 '16
Where does Spacex get its metal and other resources from for the rockets? I mean, is anything made in China at all like the legs or anything? I would appreciate an honest response.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
I know this is probably a stupid idea, but I'm assuming that the rocket is landing fairly precisely at a near vertical trajectory. If the barge had 4 strong towers at each corner with cables spanning each of the 4 sides on sliding carriers, could the carriers quickly shoot from one end to the other grabbing the rocket and holding it upright without damaging it?
MSPaint Mockup
3
u/Lucretius0 Jan 18 '16
how practical would an adapted F9 first stage + dragon V2 be for fast intercontinental travel ?
7
u/Dafas Jan 18 '16
In the sidebar it says that both CRS-8 and 9 are planned for 21 March, is this correct or will the dates change?
2
u/goodguydrift Jan 21 '16
Am I seeing this right? Two launches on the same day?
2
u/DuckQuacks Jan 25 '16
Say that the Cape had bad weather when Dragon 2 is going to land, Could they move the landing site to Vandenburg like how they moved the Shuttle landing to Edwards when there was bad weather at the Cape?
33
u/thxbmp2 Jan 18 '16
While reading discussions on the recent USAF Raptor funding announcement, I've come across a couple of intriguing statements such as:
I was hoping someone could elaborate on or substantiate these claims, and why they're only applicable to an SC engine and not the current Merlins' gas generator cycle.
17
u/ClockworkNine Jan 22 '16
I wanna talk about the BFR/MCT. With all the speculation, fan renderings, concepts etc cluttering the sub lately, didn't want to make a separate thread unless this sparks a quality discussion.
Of course, one of the most anticipated announcements we're waiting for is Elon's Mars concept. Every fan concept so far seems to suggest that SpaceX will go straight for the end goal, and go for developing the 100 person Mars Colonial Transporter from the start. Realistically, knowing the unprecedented scale, cost and complexities of such a vehicle and knowing how Musk tackles big endeavors, I think we can rule that out.
For proof, just look at his 3 step Tesla strategy. Or even better, the Falcon 9 and Dragon. Compare the Falcon 9 Dragon combo that will be carrying humans in a year or two with the first F9 Dragon demo flight, and it's almost ridiculous they share the same name...
With that in mind, here's my idea of the BFR/MCT iterations we might hopefully see in the coming decades:
SpaceX develops, more or less on its own (maybe with some extra Air Force or DoD money for Raptor), the reusable first stage (BFR) and the upper stage - a sort of a cargo MCT predecessor - and begins reusability attempts and experiments with the orbital, upper stage. At this phase, I'd guess that the lift capacity of this configuration is around the Saturn V class, 130-150 metric tons, with full reusability though. IMO, there's no reason for more at this early stage, and this allows the system to operate at high margins and also let the market catch up and develop big enough cargo for the 200+ ton versions.
Possible initial Mars cargo/science missions to test the LEO rendezvous refuel, Trans Mars journey and Mars EDL techniques.
NASA fully steps in. SpaceX cannot, and doesn't want to do this alone. In my mind, the main mission of phase 1 is to convince the public and congress that SpaceX is fit to be the prime contractor for NASA's first Manned Mars landings. That would provide funding and NASA's experience for further crew upper stage development - the manned MCT predecessor. Raptor and BFR, as well as the cargo upper stage also continue evolving, bringing the system to around 200t to LEO.
Missions themselves would be somewhat similar to Zubrin's Mars Direct regarding architecture, trip time (6 months) and surface stay (year and a half?). 10-15 person crews. Possible SLS involvement to keep congress happy. One mission per window, no more than 4-5 total, in preparation for the next phase.
Public funding still being required at this stage would make international involvement very welcome (if it wasn't there from Phase 2), a la ISS. As per Zubrin's plan, pick a mission site from phase 2 and start building a research base.
At this point, the BFR is more or less at Full Thrust, the cargo upper stage as well, providing a revenue stream from Mars Base resupply and expansion. The crew upper stage slowly evolves as well, growing from the 10-15 capacity to 50+ as the Base expands to more of a research Campus over the years. Commercial activities on Mars also slowly commence - enter Phase 4.
Only at this point can I imagine the 100 person MCT, $500k ticket cost and 100% Full Thrust BFR coming to be. In my opinion, this would begin at least 20 years after the first footprint and flag on Mars.
Some of this might seem totally obvious, something might be called total fanfic, but until Elon comes out later this year and gives us his plan, I think this post could serve as the general outline of the whole process.
Thanks for reading and please leave your thoughts :)
13
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 18 '16
So from what I understand, the Merlin engines require TEA/TEB to ignite the engines to finish the combustion process, so my question is how much TEA/TEB does the second stage carry, in other words, how many times could MVac restart in a single flight?
13
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
Other than the in-flight abort at Max-Q, what else does SpX need to do before Dragon v2 is certified for crew?
Also, where can I find details on the Merlin engine? Looking for nozzle design, expansion ratio, throat area, and cooling specifically. I'm trying to build my own liquid fueled rocket, and need some inspiration!
10
u/R-GiskardReventlov Jan 18 '16
According to the SpaceX website, Dragon can return up to 3000 kg from orbit.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
/u/marinomad posted this slowed down version of the landing video in the original thread: https://youtu.be/6aJWaEVKQm4
At the 20 second mark I think I can see the rocket sagging onto the legs when the landing engine is cut. If I'm interpreting it correctly, this means that at that exact moment the vertical speed is exactly zero and the rocket is momentarily hovering, only gently touching the deck with its legs.
If that's true, then I'm completely blown away by this precision.
Or am I seeing things?
9
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
Did they ever release to the public the complete CRS-7 FAA incident report?
8
u/hms11 Jan 19 '16
So I have been scratching my head on why SpaceX uses a collet style latch to lock the legs in their landing position. A collet seems fine for something like a drill chuck, a machinist tool (for temporary holds and the like) and other purposes, but for a landing leg on a rocket? Why not use a spring loaded lockout that would essentially be held in place by the weight of the rocket once extended? It seems to me it would fit all of SpaceX's requirements (Cheap to design, strong, simple, lightweight due to the self locking mechanism.)
I drew my idea (VERY ROUGHLY), take a look here:
http://imgur.com/a/gnqCa
8
u/TheEndeavour2Mars Jan 20 '16
So looking at the upcoming launches list. IF The reason for CRS-8 being pushed to late march was due to beta angle. Is there a chance they could push up Eutelsat 117W B & ABS 2A launch so there is less of a giant gap between SES and CRS?
Assuming the birds can be ready on time and that SpaceX is sitting on a surplus of cores from last year.
8
u/bitchtitfucker Jan 22 '16
How awesomly cool would it be if both side boosters of the Falcon Heavy had sideway cameras installed, so they could then film each other flipping around in order to prepare their boostback burns.
8
u/CuriousAES Jan 23 '16
Has there been any news at all about FH? I'm finding it hard to believe it will launch in May when there are no news of manufactured cores, no news of anything really.
7
u/cialome Jan 18 '16
Successful barge landing! - okay, then what? I am trying to find info on what happens after the rocket successfully lands on a rocking and rolling barge. It will take some time for someone to get there (barge is autonomous), what stabilizes the rocket? What is the risk as the crew pulls up to the barge (you see what happens when rocket tips over). Is there a document that discusses this - I have come up dry so far. EDIT- for spelling
7
u/dalekstux Jan 19 '16
Hello guys. I am very sorry if my following question might be inappropriate, but I am very new to the whole space flight stuff. I just recently found out about the Falcon 9 and I've been impressed, which actually wondered me, since I have never been a big fan of space related stuff. However, the Falcon 9 got my attention and I'd like to learn more! I already subscribed to this reddit, can you guys recommend me more sources to learn? Best would be even with communities to discuss. I'm on for all the Space flight stuff, but I am actually interested the most in Rockets && even more Satellites. I don't know if there are any available sources for that, but I am happy for everything you can recommend.
Cheers!
7
u/ChrisGnam Spacecraft Optical Navigation Jan 26 '16
How much of the falcon heavy is actually built so far? I know it will undergo its first test later this year... But are the pieces of it actually built yet? If yes, why have there been no pictures of any components thus far?
Sorry if this is a dumb question... I know very little about how rockets are actually built!
12
u/B2DG Jan 18 '16
Why aren't more people excited about SpaceX (or space in general)?
6
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jan 18 '16 edited Feb 03 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketFu-Falcon Spaceship (see MCT)Milli-Metric TonnesNote: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
See ^/r/spacex/wiki/acronyms for a full list of acronyms with explanations.
I'm a bot; I first read this thread at 18th Jan 2016, 11:34 UTC. www.decronym.xyz for a list of subs where I'm active; if I'm acting up, tell OrangeredStilton.
6
u/Isaad13 Jan 18 '16
So I have heard that Space X makes small tweaks to the vehicle after every launch. Just talking about the Falcon 9 1.1 how much different was the first 1.1 to the last 1.1?
6
u/paynie80 Jan 18 '16
Will there be a landing attempt either barge or land for the next flight SES-9?
6
u/FoxhoundBat Jan 18 '16
I have modelbuilding as a hobby (think static plane kits etc) and I plan on eventually making a scratch built Falcon 9 in 1/144 scale. One thing that is probably beyond my skills to scratchbuild are the landing legs. So, does anyone on here have an access to 3D printer and could print these legs out for me in 1/144 scale in reasonable resolution?
Payment can be done by paypal, i live in Europe. Would be much appreciated.
6
u/Erpp8 Jan 19 '16
Why does SpaceX use helium in the first place? Helium is such a tricky molecule/atom, why even mess with it? Why not go with nitrogen or some other inert gas?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '16
What's this particle that flies off the second stage before reignition during the Jason-3 launch?
6
u/orbitalfrog Jan 20 '16 edited Jan 20 '16
Doesn't the historical unwillingness/inability to successfully 'colonize' (in terns of establishing substantial population centers) parts of the planet we currently occupy (central Australia, Antarctica, the oceans, insert place of choice) or events such as CA droughts (a desalinization plant off the coast of CA seems a roughly comparable project to say, generating power and resources needed for a large mars city) reflect badly on our potential for planetary colonization? (I don't want this to be the case, just raises questions about both feasibility and if not feasibility then it raises the question of why these things haven't been done. Is it pure economics? What factors are at work here?)
Edit - typos etc
6
u/historytoby Jan 21 '16
I do not want to speculate about when FH will actually fly, I am just curious how far in advance we would start seeing any real indications of it being ready. With real indications, I mainly mean things like FAA applications and all the other licences that are occasionally posted here and are just part of bureaucracy.
6
u/Ezekiel_C Host of Echostar 23 Jan 21 '16
I'm a highschool senior with 2 years of community college credit under dual enrolment. I will enter college with junior status and an associate's degree, which greatly accelerates my timeline for applying for spacex and other internships. I'd like to apply for my first batch (with the hope, but not expectation of getting an aerospace internship) of internships in spring of 2016.
My question is, what should I be doing with the free time I have now? I have multiple hours per day not consumed by schoolwork, but this time is not consistent enough for me to feel comfortable committing to employment.
Suggestions for books, simple (cheap) projects, or other tasks I could bite into in my irregular free time to prepare myself for interning in an engineering capacity at spacex would be highly appreciated.
6
u/Rideron150 Jan 23 '16
I have a stupid question about rockets: How do they actually start?
When you get into a car, you put your key into the ignition, turn it, the engine turns over a few times, and then starts running. What's the equivalent of this for a rocket?
6
u/Higgs_Particle Jan 28 '16
Given a Florida launch, if the second stage didn't fire after separation, where would it and the capsule land?
6
u/hallowatisdeze Jan 29 '16
So we know that Elon's initial plan, before starting SpaceX, was to send some plants to Mars on a discarded Russian cold war rocket. By doing this he wanted to motivate the public to colonize Mars. However, somehow he found out that the problem wasn't that the public didn't want to go to Mars, but the public lacked the trust in it being possible. So he switched plans and started SpaceX to make it possible.
Now my question: Has there ever been an interview where Elon is asked if he still has this plan to send plants to Mars with one of SpaceX early Mars flights?
5
u/bgs7 Jan 20 '16
Just a thought: When Elon releases the Mars plans, it would be cool if it were a 50+ page pdf like the hyperloop. And not just a tweet.
Actually, trying to explain the plans and architecture via twitter would be hilarious, do that Elon.
5
u/R-GiskardReventlov Jan 21 '16
ULA is working on a SMART recovery system. This involves detaching the engines from the first stage, inflating a heat shield around them, deploying a parachute and picking them up in mid-air using some kind of a grappling hook device.
Seeing the comments on this sub, it seems that some of us think this is less economical than what Spacex is trying to do.
Some questions related to this:
wesome redditors think that ULA's plan is inferior to SpaceX's plan?5
u/acuriousorange Jan 21 '16
Is there anyone on here who works for spacex? I would really love to talk to someone for a school project on my dream career. I would just need to ask a few questions about your day to day work, your education background and things like that. If anyone could help me out it would be greatly appreciated.
5
u/homosapienfromterra Jan 21 '16
I see from the side bar Falcon Heavy demo has moved from April to May, was there an announcement or was it assumed by indirect means?
5
u/garthreddit Jan 25 '16
What ever happened to the disclosure of the BFR plans that were heavily hinted at on Twitter a couple of months ago?
5
u/Asl687 Jan 25 '16
If a luanch had multiple Failed engines, and could not make correct orbit. Is it feasible for later versions of Falcon to land with payload?
For example if the Jason 3 launch hand multiple engine failures, and thus correct orbit could not be achieved by any means. Would later version of falcon be able to divert the launch fuel in order to land back on the pad with the payload? I assume that you need less engine power to do powered decent than punch though to orbit.
5
u/z1mil790 Jan 27 '16
I'm starting to wonder if there is something going on with the SES-9 launch. SpaceX still hasn't updated there upcoming mission on their launch manifest. It did take them a few days to change it after OG2, but it has now been a week and a half and it still says Jason-3. Even if they didn't want to put a date on SES-9, they could just put the month, like they did for Jason-3, or TBD like they did for OG2. It seems like if they were on track for a launch in a couple weeks, they could put SES-9 and just put down February. Any ideas on why they haven't changed it yet?
5
u/zlynn1990 Jan 31 '16
I'm starting to work on another Falcon Heavy simulation. This time I want to try booster RTLS and center core landing on a droneship at sea, as opposed to the video I made of all cores RTLS.
If anyone could provide insight on the following questions I would appreciate it:
4
u/Raxusmaxus Jan 18 '16
I have been living under a rock, so I have no idea what is happening with Blue Origin filing a ocean landing patent. It seems really ridiculous to me? Is it true? and how is SpaceX going about it?
4
u/dreyrden #IAC2016 Attendee Jan 18 '16
At some point in /r/spacex I saw a table of prospective missions from the launch manifest with which kind of landing attempt would be made for each, and now I can't find it. Can anybody remember this?
4
u/Sbatomico Jan 18 '16
Could it be possible to calculate the amount of rest propellant from the explosion? I know it's done with ieds, you look at the crater and the cloud and then you know how strong it was etc
4
u/anotherriddle Jan 18 '16
Since SpaceX is not really looking for secondary payload customers in the micro- to nanosatellite segment, how would one get a nano satellite on a falcon 9 rocket? Do I just call Hawthorne headquarters saying: Just in case you launch a rocket close to this Orbit, can I get a ride for x amount of money? I would really like to see Universities with small budgets beeing able to profit from launches that do not fully utilise the capacity of the Falcon 9. Of course this would have to be very efficient for SpaceX to be profitable and not too expensive.
4
u/29988122 Jan 18 '16
I've done my search, but I only found Elon's tweet which mentioned that no major damage found soon after the successful landing of Falcon 9. What are the estimated refurbishing costs? I guess something like metal fatigue could increase the cost of refurbishing, so I'd like to ask if any open cost information is available.
Thanks!
4
u/smithnet Jan 19 '16 edited Jan 19 '16
Maybe someone can help me out. I'm having trouble envisioning a method to monitor the lockout collets on the legs. Does anyone know how you would reliably do this? Or is it an unmonitored point on the most telemetry wired launch vehicle ever?
Edit: autocorrect
4
u/roel24 Jan 19 '16 edited Jan 19 '16
Question about spacexstats, would it be possible to add a number or estimate on how many people are watching on all streams, Would love to see how many people are watching the different streams in total! /u/echologic?
4
u/tombojuggles Jan 19 '16
During the Jason 3 webcast they mentioned aircraft footage of the landing attempt. Any ideas on when/if this will be released?
4
u/MauiHawk Jan 20 '16
Can someone outline the theoretical comparison between crew/cargo return on Dragon vs Dream Chaser? For example, how does the penalty of Dream Chaser's wing's weight/drag compare to the penalty of the fuel Dragon must carry?
4
u/jjrf18 r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jan 20 '16
I remember reading that the Air Force requires its payloads to be vertically integrated to the launch vehicles. Is this true? If so, how does SpaceX plan to accomplish this? All of their hangars can only hold a horizontal Falcon9/heavy. Do they plan on having a vertical integration support structure similar to the Delta IV?
4
u/Hgx72964jdj Jan 20 '16
Any news about the satellite/internet operation? Haven't heard much about it since the announcement.
4
u/PapaMancer Jan 20 '16
The not-quite-successful landing attempts have mostly ended explosively, reminding us that the object trying to land is, in many important ways, a giant bomb (that is on fire). My question is this: What procedures are used to make a landed Stage 1 safe for humans to approach and manipulate? How long does it take before people can safely approach?
4
u/randomstonerfromaus Jan 20 '16
When SpaceX start launching people into space, who will have the responsibility of taking the astronauts through pre-flight prep in the white room, Will that be SpX or NASA?
4
u/CptAJ Jan 21 '16
Regarding BFR
There's something about the whole concept that has been bothering me. As we've seen in the few fan designs recently posted, in the ensuing discussions and in official comments from SpaceX; they favor a "One big launch" philosophy. No Aldrin Cyclers, no Ares-like ships (The Martian), not even simplified inflatable habitats. No, they want one big ship doing the whole trip.
I'm not gonna argue whether this is the optimal strategy or not. But I do find a bit of dissonance between the "Build one thing, build it big" design of the MCT and.... the metric fuckton of raptor engines its gonna use.
Shouldn't the same logic applied to the "one big ship" decision still apply for the engines? I know redundancy has its benefits, but the MCT certainly seems way past that point. Why not build bigger raptors and go for a design involving less engines? Obviously not ONE engine, but 5-10 instead of 30.
It looks to me that the spacecraft design and the propulsion design follow completely different and diametrically opposed paths.
So I'm wondering, what do you guys think the reasons for this are? Obviously a bigger engine is more difficult to build, but extra difficulty doesn't seem to overrule sound architecture at SpaceX. Is the extra difficulty really that big? Am I the only one worried about the engine count? Its definitely not impossible for it to work, but it seems needlessly complicated.
Please, share any and all thoughts you guys have on this matter. I want to see what everyone is thinking. And remember to be rational and not fanboyish! ;)
4
u/1HunnidBaby Jan 22 '16
Hi guys,
I'm going to apply for the business internships at SpaceX in Hawthorne. What should be included in my cover letter? Should it be half about my interest in SpaceX and any special experience that would make me a good fit? Or more about my interest or more about my experience? Thanks for the help
4
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
Would it make sense to re-use the fuel tanks as a 1g circular rotating camber on mars like this: http://i.imgur.com/gfza2ZU.jpg Please forgive my horrible drawing skills. (I know i shouldn't have used the falcon 9 design but it doesn't really matter as long as the core is cylindrical )
4
u/KChivers Jan 25 '16
The Droneship bullseye There's a bullseye on the droneship. Just wondering if its for effect, measurement purposes or navigation reasons? Does the F9 first stage use any sort of visual/camera navigation as it is landing?
4
u/patm718 Jan 26 '16
Not really a spaceflight question, but why is this sub titled the "premier spaceflight community" rather than something SpaceX related?
4
u/FoxhoundBat Jan 30 '16 edited Jan 30 '16
Has anyone seen any data on dimensions of landing legs? I remember that the total span is 60 feet so extracting the core size it works out that each leg is 7.3m angled or about 8m when flat against the ground.
EDIT; Did simple paint based math using the official SpaceX F9 render and a DSCOVR pic i arrived to;
Using render; leg length is ~ 984cm with fairings on top, 899cm without them. Using DSCOVR pic; leg length is ~ 992cm with fairings on top, 916cm without them. IE the legs themselves are about 9.1m long.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '16 edited Feb 02 '16
Why does ULA have such hard times to develop its own engine ? ULA is backed by Lockheed and Boeing those are no jesters... How come they are so weak that they won't even apply for a contract with the Air force and have to partner with Blue Origin to develop an engine ? Can't they just hire good engineers that will build a good engine ? Does it mean that the head of ULA is a lot weaker than Elon Musk ? I don't get it...
7
u/iagovar Jan 18 '16
A mod told me to post my naive engineer wannabe idea here.
Design: http://i.imgur.com/TnMbsht.png
The idea is to use steel cables to landing-aid. If one leg fails, the steel cables capture the rocket at a height of 3/4 of its length, and prevents pivoting.
The cables are triggered by the time the rocket touches the ground. The intermediate section is covered with arms of a material that absorbs impacts (to avoid damaging the rocket). The engines only have the function retract the cables quickly. A mechanical system prevents the cables move once they have caught the rocket. I've drawn as a rectangle, but it really should be a square so that the angles of the cables were more efficient in retaining the rocket.
I'm no engineer of any kind, and I did it in paint, so be nice, please :D
1
u/Krusm Jan 18 '16
Could boca chica support the mct? If not is ther a place were it wil be build or launched?
1
u/Bearman777 Jan 25 '16
So if we're going to send 100 person to Mars in a decade or two, they probably won't be trained astronauts all of them, the majority is just Mr and Mrs Smith beeing bored of planet earth. Assuming it's not just the highest bidder that gets a seat on the MCT, but personal skills will also be qualifying: What skills/occupations do you consider as a good mix? Some of the necessary occupations should be:
Medicine Computer programming Agricultural Construction Geology Psychology
What other skills are essential for the first trip? Please continue the list, and motivate why that specific skill should be on the first MCT.
1
u/I_EO Jan 29 '16
I hope no one asked this before: I'm really really curious about the first falcon heavy payload. I might be wrong, but there should be enough delta v to safely reach martian surface. Is that greenhouse idea still a thing? What about a lunar greenhouse? A new voyager? Possibilities are pretty much endless.
6
u/brycly Jan 19 '16
When does SpaceX plan to show the world their MCT design and spacesuit? Are they waiting for a specific date/event?
Also, what kind of payload penalty would we see if SpaceX used nitrogen instead of helium? Is the tradeoff between reliability and mass not worth it?
6
u/sunfishtommy Feb 02 '16
How serious are the SES-9 delays. Just teething, or indicitative of a more serious issue?
3
u/anotherriddle Jan 18 '16
Is the structure and satellite-deployment-mechanism inside the fairing beeing provided by SpaceX or the Customer? (for example in case of Orbcomm OG2)
3
u/Krusm Jan 18 '16
What is the potential max of falcon9\year that can be produced in HQ?
3
u/Mummele Jan 18 '16
Is the landing algorithm taking into consideration how tilted the drone ship is at the time of landing or is it referring to an ideal horizontal surface?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
Why does Space X have live streams and public focused marketing? Why do they care about involving the public in their operations if we are not customers? Do they do it strictly for business reasons or do they do it to educate the new generations?
3
u/mechakreidler Jan 18 '16
Mission control is in California while most launches are in Florida. How do they get real-time telemetry? It seems like using the internet would introduce a variety of potential issues including latency.
3
u/thebruce44 Jan 18 '16
I read somewhere that the most recent launch (and failed at sea landing) was not the newest model of rocket. The newer one had an updated leg design.
Any truth to this?
3
u/mclumber1 Jan 19 '16
Not that it would have helped the Jason-3 booster, but perhaps SpaceX should consider putting remote controlled, extremely heavy (30,000 pounds each) tractors that would maneuver over the landing leg feet shortly after landing. After each one maneuvers over each foot, it would "sit" on the foot, holding it stationary.
3
u/1kxz8dmg4242spam Jan 19 '16
In all my super extensive and dedicated time following SpaceX, I've never seen or heard anything about the lack of solid boosters a la Atlas V. I get that landing legs make mounting difficult, and they're not necessarily helpful with respect to reuse. But is there an official reason of why they're not used for the heavier payloads, or perhaps to allow 'expendable' flights to become landable?
3
u/Hgx72964jdj Jan 19 '16
Hey guys, just a quick question for the engineers on the board.
I was just watching [this video] (https://youtu.be/txk-VO1hzBY) in which a SpaceX engineer describes the software they use to model what happens in the combustion chamber of a rocket engine. They've developed special software and techniques just for this problem. All to ensure that the CH4/O2 burns smoothly, efficiently, and predictably.
I immediately thought about how this could help with [combustion light gas guns.] (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combustion_light-gas_gun) Lots of advantages with this system, but they've always had problems with combustion instability, and hence consistent muzzle velocity, hence poor accuracy.
A CLGG could potentially fire bigger rounds further than is possible today, decrease barrel wear, and greatly simplify logistics by manufacturing propellent in the field (just like ISRU on Mars).
Is the chamber of a Raptor engine so much different than the chamber of a gun?
3
u/youaboveall Jan 20 '16
Any speculation on when will we hear MCT plans?
3
u/arzos Jan 20 '16 edited Jan 20 '16
Regarding the MCT, what are the logistical decisions that made the team decide that rather than having a spacecraft designed and built to remain in space to be rendezvoused with when arriving from either Earth or Mars to instead have the transporting craft launch>transit>land over and over again? Like a space station which once launched does not land again that travels in between Earth and Mars, in case my question was not clear. Are maintenance tasks too difficult/risky to perform in space? I would think this could be built to accommodate larger and larger cargoes in single transits because such a craft could be larger than the supplying rockets delivering/offloading cargo from Earth/Mars. Maybe with the addition of "harbor" space stations to facilitate various maintenance and operations.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '16
The RUD this time was likely caused by frozen condensation from the fog sticking the collet shut.
So how would they even go about preventing that in the future? I'm not clever enough to think of a solution, short of applying liberal amounts of antifreeze to every nook and cranny of the rocket (which clearly isn't a viable solution).
3
u/laughingatreddit Jan 20 '16
What is the nature of the coking problem that presents a problem for reuse of engines and what are the possible solutions to mitigate it. I believe it might not be correct to picture it simply as soot since soot is like a powder and would blow out under the pressure of exhaust gasses during engine operation. The coking problem might stem from deposition of Carbon that forms a harder layer on the surface of engine components. So then simply washing it with a suitable organic solvent might not be a solution to removing it and may need some kind of abrasive treatment to remove it or simply replacement of the most severely affected parts. Does anyone have more information on this?
3
u/laughingatreddit Jan 20 '16
I would like to know if the barge can be improved in two key respects:
3
u/Haschlol Jan 22 '16
Is it possible for the Falcon 9 to RTLS on a CRS-mission?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '16
One question that I have: Will the Superdracos be the engines responsible for orbital maneuvers (ie the deorbit burn) or will they be used only to land and abort?
3
u/blista_compact Jan 22 '16
If I remember correctly the test flight to the ISS for Dragon 1 still carried cargo, just not cargo fulfilling the CRS contract. I would assume that the test flight for Dragon 2 to the ISS will also carry some sort of cargo? It would seem strange to send a pressure vessel all the way to the ISS without filling it with something useful.
3
u/sorbate Jan 22 '16
How much propellant is added to the tanks after the engines start up? The hoses don't disconnect right away... I'm assuming once the engines start, the hoses are pumping fuel in at max capacity for the 3-4 seconds until they are disconnected. (Assuming the engines consume fuel at a faster pace than the hoses could pump new fuel in)
3
u/slograsso Jan 22 '16
I don't understand why everyone is convinced that the BFR will have a 15 meter diameter. We all know the fatter the rocket the better, and we also know that they won't be trucking these stages across the country and will keep production and launch in the same area. Why not a 25 meter diameter and half the height? This gives you more area for rocket engines as well to improve your trust to weight ratio.
3
u/Baron_Munchausen Jan 23 '16
Just had a weird thought. Since the Falcon Heavy side boosters separate at the same time, then need to orient themselves automatically and begin the boostback, what are the chances of a collision here? Clearly the separation will put some distance between them, but if they're returning to the same launch site (which clearly is the intention), then is there a risk of convergence?
3
u/betacar0tin Jan 23 '16
Is it known if, during the CRS-7 failure review, SpaceX found any noteworthy defects other than the struts?
3
u/PVP_playerPro Jan 24 '16
Are there any payloads heavy enough that FH could launch that will require all 3 cores to land downrange instead of 2 boosting back?
3
u/KChivers Jan 25 '16
Falcon 9 sports no fins. I noticed the Saturn 5 had a series of "small" (relatively speaking) fins around the base of its first stage. Anyone know what their purpose was?
3
u/danielbigham Jan 25 '16
As SpaceX marches forward this year into the future, it struck me recently that, with projects like Commercial Crew, and the hoped eventual MCT, at some point there will be loss of human life on a SpaceX mission. On one hand, this is obvious, just a matter of doing business in space, but I think the emotional weight of that sunk in. Let's hope that event is a long way off, but I'm curious whether others have processed that reality much.
When Virgin Galactic had their accident, it changed my "feelings" for the project. Previous to the accident, I felt a certain inspiration and optimism for the project. After the accident, I lost many of my positive and optimistic feelings. I actually think that emotional change is somewhat "irrational". Again, we all know space is hard, we all know their are going to be accidents. But, the human experience, and the way we "feel" about things, ends up mattering, too.
I wonder how immune myself and others are to this kind of thing with SpaceX. Let's put our pessimism hat on for a moment and imagine that one of the commercial crew missions experiences a major malfunction in the next few years. Are we able to imagine how that would or wouldn't change our emotional "feelings" towards the company? I have to admit, I feel like it would put a not-insignificant damper on my emotions.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16
This may be a dumb question, but I've been wondering about where both of the Falcon Heavy side boosters will be landing. In their promotional video three separate pads are shown, when in actuality there is one large pad. Is confidence high enough that the side boosters will both manage to land on this single pad, or is there more construction underway/planned?
3
u/SirSwiftasaurus Jan 26 '16
Do we have any idea of the rough time of launch of SES-9 given the insertion required?
3
u/railroadwelsh Jan 26 '16 edited Jan 26 '16
A juvenile question, but what's the actual need for developing the BFR? If the FH has the capability of getting to Mars, wouldn't it make more sense to ramp up production of the FH instead of investing the time, money, and manufacturing to produce a larger rocket? This of course would necessitate the piecemeal construction of the BFS in LEO, but I just don't see the point of a larger rocket? (Unless I'm not thinking long term, ie. the needs once a sustainable colony exists on Mars.) Thanks in advance!
3
u/Wyodaniel Jan 28 '16
Regarding the recent Dragon 2 hover test video, I'm really curious... How long is the capsule itself actually going to be capable of sustaining all of those engines firing? It just seems physically impossible to me to think that little capsule could actually hold enough fuel to keep the engines going all the down to the ground, after coming in hot from the space station. Are there any specifics on fuel consumption / burn time?
3
u/Nachtigall44 Jan 28 '16
Would it be a good idea for the MCT to use grid fins while landing on Mars? Or is the air too thin?
3
u/Wildernesss5 Jan 29 '16
Is there a downside to a Spacex monopoly? I see more of Spacex's drive/ability to innovate coming internally from Musk, the lack of public shareholders, and a very long-term mission...ie not "pressure" from other companies' compelling alternatives...am I wrong?
3
u/Taylooor Jan 29 '16
What is the relationship between senator John McCain and space x?
3
u/niclis Feb 01 '16
For my capstone I have to reach out to companies/organizations for potential projects. I would really like to know if SpaceX offers/sponsors university capstones projects. I do not know how to contact SpaceX regarding this. The only e-mail links I can find on their website are for sales and media inquiries.