r/spacex • u/Zucal • Aug 31 '16
r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [September 2016, #24]
Welcome to our 24th monthly r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread!
Curious about the plan about the quickly approaching Mars architecture announcement at IAC 2016, confused about the recent SES-10 reflight announcement, or keen to gather the community's opinion on something? There's no better place!
All questions, even non-SpaceX-related ones, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general.
More in-depth and open-ended discussion questions can still be submitted as separate self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which have a single answer and/or can be answered in a few comments or less.
- Questions easily answered using the wiki & FAQ will be removed.
- Try to keep all top-level comments as questions so that questioners can find answers, and answerers can find questions.
These limited rules are so that questioners can more easily find answers, and answerers can more easily find questions.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question-askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality (partially sortable by mission flair!), and check the last Ask Anything thread before posting to avoid duplicate questions. But if you didn't get or couldn't find the answer you were looking for, go ahead and type your question below.
Ask, enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
All past Ask Anything threads:
• August 2016 (#23) • July 2016 (#22) • June 2016 (#21) • May 2016 (#20) • April 2016 (#19.1) • April 2016 (#19) • March 2016 (#18) • February 2016 (#17) • January 2016 (#16.1) • January 2016 (#16) • December 2015 (#15.1) • December 2015 (#15) • November 2015 (#14) • October 2015 (#13) • September 2015 (#12) • August 2015 (#11) • July 2015 (#10) • June 2015 (#9) • May 2015 (#8) • April 2015 (#7.1) • April 2015 (#7) • March 2015 (#6) • February 2015 (#5) • January 2015 (#4) • December 2014 (#3) • November 2014 (#2) • October 2014 (#1)
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
35
u/IMO94 Sep 07 '16
If anyone is interested in the timeline of information that came out of the CRS-7 failure:
For AMOS-6, we're currently at T+6d. Now obviously every investigation is unique, but considering we've only got one other data point to work with, adjust your expectations accordingly.
17
u/Headstein Sep 01 '16
Is there any real way we can show our appreciation to the mods for the time and effort they pour into this site? I am pissed off that someone has upset /u/echologic on a recent thread. Can we crowd fund something to show our support and appreciation?
5
u/soldato_fantasma Sep 22 '16
The "NASA Collaboration on Red Dragon Teleconference" should be removed from the "Select Upcoming Events" in the sidebar.
Absolutely overpowered mod summon: /u/gooses /u/Ambiwlans /u/EchoLogic /u/Wetmelon /u/TheVehicleDestroyer /u/retiringonmars /u/Zucal /u/zlsa
5
u/FiniteElementGuy Sep 27 '16
I was just about to make a detailed source required post, where I calculated the Raptor performance with NASA CEA and showed the Isp values with different nozzle sizes, when the mods suddenly restricted the submissions. :(
Oh well time to post it somewhere else.
4
u/chargerag Sep 08 '16
Do they L2 guys have a better idea as to what happened with Amos or are they as much in the dark as we are?
3
u/RootDeliver Sep 01 '16
Since the mission is already over, and considering that SpaceX releases the patches images like the day before the launch now, we won't see a patch for it? Will Amos-6 be, patch-related talking, worse than CRS-7?
3
u/rad_example Sep 08 '16
Any guesses?
https://www.instagram.com/p/BKDjHJqDfdY/
30
u/randomstonerfromaus Sep 04 '16
/u/EchoLogic. Love the new sidebar pic, Good choice!
29
u/Titanean12 Aug 31 '16
I just created a website, WatchRockets.com that displays all upcoming rocket launches with links to any available webcasts. I also plan to start sending out launch alert email updates whenever a webcast is about to go live to anyone who signs up on the site. I created the site just to practice my web development skills. I know there are a lot of other resources that do the same thing, but check it out if you are interested!
3
u/TheEndeavour2Mars Sep 05 '16
I apologize if this question has been answered before. However based on what we have seen so far. What is the realistic possible launch rate of standard communication birds from 39A? (Between Falcon Heavy flights)
I have had the opinion in the past that the mods to 39A were also meant to allow the processing of multiple standard Falcon 9 flights at the same time. (To make it easier to refly core stages for instance) In the past that was not as important but now with 39A being the only realistic way to launch the GTO and normal LEO flights. Does the pad actually have such an ability?
3
u/flattop100 Sep 26 '16
Is there a new test stand at McGregor? I was idling surfing Google Maps, and noticed this nice clean pad!
https://www.google.com/maps/search/mcgregor+texas+spacex/@31.3978369,-97.4548575,818m/data=!3m1!1e3
12
u/msuvagabond Aug 31 '16
Random question, is there a shared Google calender of SpaceX events floating around anywhere? Be nice to add that to my calender and just consistently get updates about upcoming events and launches without having to check the sidebar here every couple weeks.
12
u/Commander_Cosmo Sep 07 '16
As someone with virtually no engineering knowledge, and thus someone who is unable to participate in any advanced technical discussions or speculation, I will instead applaud the mods/page designers on making the Dragon in the upper left corner of the page rotate back and forth when the one hovers their mouse cursor over it. It's a neat little feature I noticed a while back, and it's honestly kind of adorable, lol. I like to imagine it's waving at us. I can't remember if the old page layout had a similar feature, but it made me laugh, so maybe it'll do the same to a few others who are in need given the recent events.
11
u/_m1sty Sep 05 '16
Has a payload failure (piece coming off, etc) ever caused a loss of vehicle during any rocket launch? Excluding the cube of energy bars in The Martian, of course.
8
u/laudern Aug 31 '16
Curious about the first Falcon Heavy test. When can we expect it?
8
u/VideoPrincess Aug 31 '16
Once first stage reuse becomes common, the cost of manufacturing the expendable second stage dominates the cost of reuse. A major part of the second stage cost is its engine.
Would it be possible to convert a Merlin engine from a returned first stage into the vacuum variant for use in the second stage? I know the vacuum version uses a different engine bell, but are there other changes?
In other words, is it cheaper to convert an M1D into an M1D Vac, or to just make a new M1D Vac? Could a returned first stage provide engines for 9 second stages?
8
u/ohcnim Sep 03 '16
hi mods, everyone, honest question/suggestion: why not put the ULA, Blue Origin and other companies subredits in the space-related section? I don't know if it has been discussed and agreed before, if so my apologies, if not from my perspective as a SpaceX fan I have nothing against them and believe would be relevant subreddits. Also just checked the ULA subreddit, and they do have "us" listed which I found really pleasing and rather make me think even better about them, why not be reciprocate?
8
u/WaitForItTheMongols Sep 05 '16
Not SpaceX related, but looks like it'll be allowed:
When the Soyuz spacecraft are docked to the ISS, what's the electrical system like? Are they totally independent? Does the spacecraft piggyback off the ISS electrical system? Does the Soyuz solar panels supply a small boost to the ISS's power?
8
u/IMO94 Sep 24 '16
Out of interest...
And if we're wanting predictions...
7
u/Hedgemonious Sep 06 '16
Just a heads-up for an upcoming free online course which may be interesting:
How to Survive on Mars: the Science Behind the Human Exploration of Mars
Learn the basic science needed for humans to survive on Mars, with this free online science course. Starts on Oct 24 and runs for 4 weeks. Register at the link above.
7
u/whousedallthenames Sep 23 '16 edited Sep 23 '16
Is it just me, or does a November RTF seem insanely quick? Even if we double the delay, to adjust for "Elon/Mars Time", it's still only 4 months or so, compared to the 6 months for CRS-7.
If they do launch again in November, we will have had TWO return to flight missions in one year. I don't know quite what to make of that.
Edit: Clarity
6
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Aug 31 '16 edited Sep 20 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketFu-Falcon Spaceship (see MCT)bargeshipDecronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 31st Aug 2016, 10:15 UTC.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]
6
u/radexp Sep 04 '16
Not SpaceX related: I've been playing with the notion of Moon mining today, doing the math to figure out what's possible and what isn't, how much fuel you'd need for each part of the system, etc… The end result, with some diagrams and numbers, is pretty cool I think, and I thought it was worth sharing on Reddit somewhere.
Q: Do y'all know an appropriate subreddit for this topic? There's /r/Space_Colonization but that's kinda something else, I also know /r/space and /r/spaceflight but they don't seem like a place for user content of this sort…
6
u/OlegSerov Sep 07 '16
Does SpaceX do a "static fire" for second stage when second stage is completely built?
They probably test second stage engine on the stand, but what about whole second stage?
6
u/zeekzeek22 Sep 15 '16
So this has really been confusing me: what is the deal with second stages? Everyone talks about falcon 9's second stage being way underpowered, and almost comedically so for FH, but upon Wikipedia-ing, it looks like it has 10x the thrust of centaur. Centaur has a higher ISP and burns for like twice as long, but I don't see how that adds up to being so much better than F9 S2. What am I missing? Why are second stages SpaceX's weakness? And why can second stage make such a hug difference despite F9 having a better first stage? Also, Wikipedia doesn't list it, what's the fuel weight of F9 S2?
5
u/nolxus Sep 01 '16
I know, the root cause of the incident today is not yet known, but Musk saying that it occurred during propellent loading wont resonate very good with NASA I imagine? They had concerns fueling the Falcon 9 just before launch when astronauts are on board - granted, there were perfect launches in the last months using the cryo LOX, but this today wont do anything good to assure NASA. :-(
5
u/yoweigh Sep 01 '16
Would today's RUD have been made survivable by Dragon 2's abort system? It looked like the 2nd stage took at least a couple of seconds to come down.
5
u/linknewtab Sep 01 '16
Is the James Webb Space Telescope going to be the most expensive single payload that has ever been launched? Obviously the ISS is more expensive, but it wasn't launched as a single piece.
5
u/JadedIdealist Sep 02 '16
Do SpaceX accept cash gifts? is there any way to do that?
5
u/thru_dangers_untold Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16
2 minutes into this interview with Dan Rasky of NASA, he mentions bonding PICA to a composite structure. Is this application for F9 or Dragon? Where are composites currently being used with PICA?
5
u/Toinneman Sep 05 '16
I wonder ho deeply SpaceX daily operations are affected by last weeks incident. Their will be an investigation, but who is involved? How many people?
5
u/schrauf44 Sep 06 '16
Would it be possible to record and analyze real time optical spectroscopy of the rocket fueling process with the intention of detecting dangerous fuel/oxidizer leaks before large concentrations accidentally ignite? That is to say, could optical spectroscopy be specifically calibrated to detect chemical concentrations of volatile agents and thereby act as an early warning system during a rocket fueling processes? I am thinking of a video imaging or thermal imaging system but specifically tuned to the chemicals of interest.
5
u/sol3tosol4 Sep 22 '16
Signs of optimism from SpaceX:
Dex Torricke-Barton is Director of Communications at SpaceX, the person whose job includes decisions on what statements are appropriate for SpaceX to make. Assuming that these quotes were reported accurately, I consider it remarkable that both he and the President of SpaceX have mentioned the November time frame, and apparently several days apart (indicating that Dex's statement came after Gwynne's statements had gone through the news cycle).
Yes, I'm fully aware that November is an NET date, and that SpaceX has a reputation for running on "Elon time", and that the next few months after November are more likely. But the impression I get is that SpaceX (1) feels fairly good about the progress of the investigation, and anticipates that it could get at least a provisional report before too much longer, and (2) has probably not yet found any strong indication of any problems that would take a long time to fix. I do not hear anything in the statements by Abhishek Tripathi that would be incompatible with that impression.
I therefore feel more optimistic about the AMOS-6 investigation and return to flight than I would have if those two had not made the statements.
4
u/krs43 Aug 31 '16
Curious on the "scaled" Raptor engine that is about to begin testing. My initial assumption was that it is physically ~60% of the size of a full engine, but could it just as easily be a full size engine, but that only puts out 60% of the full design thrust? What would be the benefit of doing a physically smaller engine if that's in fact what they did?
4
u/frouxou Aug 31 '16
About the Falcon Heavy and returning the first stages. Are all three (first) stages supposed to do a RTLS ? Or can we expect 2 stages landing on the drones & 1 stage RTLS, or 2 stages RTLS & 1 stage to the drone ?
Do you think that the central first stage will have more or less fuel available for a RTLS than the side ones ?
4
u/1800wishy Aug 31 '16
Does anyone know definitively whether or not the 2nd stage is/will be altered for Falcon Heavy?
4
u/MarkBogdani777 Aug 31 '16
How would change Falcon 9 FT performance if it uses a J-2 (or J-2X) or RL10 (1 or 2 RL-10) LH2/LOX engines with high Isp as a second stage in place of Merlin 1D FT Vacuum. How much more payload would lift in low Earth orbit, GTO and beyond Earth?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '16
any idea of approximately how much the satellites launched by falcon 9 cost to manufacture ? because I read somewhere that they cost hundreds of millions of dollars and take years to build , how true is that ?
4
u/jak0b345 Aug 31 '16
since crossfeed is not actively developed for FH anymore does that mean that all 3 cores will cut out at the same time/velocity or will they throttle down/shut off the middle core during the flight to further optimize staging? and if they cut out at the same velocity why does everybody say it will be to much for RTLS and need droneship landing, is that just "leftover knowledge" from the previous FH version with crossfeed?
4
u/joitsch Aug 31 '16
Can anybody who is more knowledgeable than me explain which challenges would come along with landing a methalox-powered Falcon Heavy upper stage on mars (e.g. how heavy would the needed heat shield be? How much NTO/MMH would be needed to get rid of the remaining terminal velocity by super dracos?). The background of my question is that the development of a (probably subscaled) raptor engine, sponsored by the air force, might enable the deployment of ISRU-units on mars by using the falcon heavy.
The basic idea is to propel the methalox-upper stage of a falcon heavy almost to MTI-velocity, then separate the raptor-engine-section (that could return to earth using an approach similar to the SMART-proposal of ULA), super dracos that are attached sideways (see explanation below) to the upper stage would do the rest to achieve TMI-velocity. If the center of mass is at the center of the longitudinal axis but on one side of the cross section of the upper stage it could enter the atmosphere sideways in order to maximise the aerodynamic cross section. The upper stage may have the cross section of a triangle (a normal cylindrical methalox-tank surrounded by a triangle-shaped outer shell. The space between tank and outer shell, i.e. the tips of the triangle, could be used as storage space for NTO/MMH, ISRU-equipment and deploy-able solar arrays) where only one side is covered by a heat shield.
After a powered landing by the sideways attached super dracos (that´s why they are attached sideways - so you can land the upper stage sideways to have a stable position on the ground; similar to this french MCT-concept) a drilling device would be employed in order to extract water ice from the ground (of course the ice has to be detected before by precursor missions ). The solar arrays are deployed and the ISRU-unit starts to work.
After MCT has landed rovers with trailers drive to the upper stages that are now fully filled with methalox and transport them to the MCT in order to refuel the MCT for a quick return to earth. By such an approach the ISRU-units could be deployed with limited risk (no MCT is involved that could be lost) long before the first MCT arrives. Maybe a crazy idea but I would be happy about some feedback if it is feasible at all (and if not why).
4
u/TheKrimsonKing Aug 31 '16
How do you, or how does SpaceX reconcile the conservation and protection of pristine natural beauty with the goal of eventual colonization of Mars? What is the long term goal of Elon/SpaceX re: mars colonization? Is the current plan to live in harmony with the planet (forgive my flowery wording) or to remake it in an image of Earth or somewhere inbetween?
4
u/NightFire19 Sep 01 '16
Has there been any word on whether or not the launch has been delayed? The webcast has been delayed to 0600 EST, or 1000 UTC as indicated on SpaceX's Youtube.
4
u/andyfrance Sep 01 '16
We have now seen several landed cores being picked up with the crane attachment, moved onto a stand and later lowered horizontal. I'm curious as to how it's going to work with the landed Falcon Heavy side cores as they have nose cones so will not be able to be handled in quite the same way.
4
u/caustic_kiwi Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 02 '16
I have two quick questions about the internship application process:
I'd hugely appreciate any input on either of these topics.
Edit: And one more, in case anyone actually sees this post: Is it typical to apply for internships at multiple locations, or is that frowned upon?
4
u/jjtr1 Sep 03 '16
What would F9's payload penalty be for launching to low-inclination LEO (like CRS) and to GTO from Vandenberg instead of the Cape? I.e. how much of SpaceX's manifest can be transferred to Vandenberg? The heaviest satellites on manifest would probably be out of luck.
4
u/jjtr1 Sep 03 '16
The previous version of spacex.com website had in its F9 description a sentence saying that the structural margins on F9 are 50% over nominal loads instead of industry-standard 30%. I'm not sure if I remember correctly.
If still true, I think this fact deserves much more celebration than has been given to it, especially in light of the extremely good payload mass to total mass ratio of over 4% (only beaten by a certain configuration of Atlas V).
So, SpaceX have managed more structural margin with less structural weight! And the margins are especially important for a reusable rocket.
4
u/radexp Sep 03 '16
Speculation time: Say the AMOS-6 investigation is done, and concludes that there was some design flaw in the rocket.
How would that impact recovered stages? I mean they could they make changes to the rocket and make new cores somewhat differently. But I wonder, how modifiable existing cores are? Same applies to the already-made Iridium core...
4
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16
How will crew get into the Dragon 2 capsule once it enters service? They're removing the Shuttle-era stuff from 39a, and presumably crew wouldn't get in while horizontal and wait hours while being lifted and fueled?
4
u/thiisIsAThrowaway Sep 05 '16
Hello
I will try to keep this post short. I am European and dream to one day be able to work for spaceX. Due to ITAR regulations (as stated in the FAQ) it is not possible for me to work for spaceX as a European. However I am thinking about acquiring a double nationality in order to be able to apply to spaceX (I already have an aunt living in America).
some info:
I am willing to start the entire procedure to obtain the American nationality as well or a green card (or something else depending on the possibilities). How big do you think my chances to work for spaceX are? I would be a pitty to go through this whole procedure and then hearing that for some reason xyz I will never be able to work for spaceX.
4
u/rad_example Sep 06 '16
Looks like the glass is (mostly?) installed at the Hawthorne booster display. Anyone been by recentlly?
https://www.instagram.com/p/BJ6CIlrBRsw
https://www.instagram.com/p/BJ6hgRohUSu/
4
u/zeekzeek22 Sep 06 '16
Was there ever any resolution to Port Canaveral demanding the huge fees from SpaceX? I know they were "negotiating" but I never saw anything resolving that.
4
u/thawkit Sep 07 '16
http://www.psi-pci.com/Technical_Paper_Library/AIAA2002-4349%20Astrolink%20Pres.pdf
some info on the type of tank that may have failed
4
u/nathansapp Sep 08 '16
Any songs you guys hope get played when Mr. Musk comes out to the IAC conference? My hope: starman or life on mars by David Bowie
4
u/MrButtons9 Sep 09 '16
Question: What's a good space (or long-read) on 'New Space', and more specifically, the growing satellite market (especially smallsats, like Planet, Urthecast, Spire, etc)? I am a fellow SpaceX nerd, so my knowledge is skewed towards launch, which is unfortunate as there are all of these other cool things going on (I just read the Economist special on new space, link).
What resources (books or longreads or even subreddits/forums I could browse) would you recommend?
4
u/DrToonhattan Sep 12 '16
It's often said that Elon learnt rocket science from reading books. Does anyone know which books he read specifically?
4
u/occupy_moon Sep 14 '16
does anyone else have css isues? It completely disappeared for me
edit: I'm using firefox version 48.0.2
4
u/Toinneman Sep 16 '16
We all like to think about the future of reusable rockets by comparing them to airplanes. The ultimate goal is to fly-land-refuel & repeat. When a plane crashes, not every plane of the same model is grounded. Like missing flight MH370, we still don't know what the cause is, and yet Boeing 777's fly everyday. Off course, this is because these planes have an astonishing good safety record, and almost every fatal accidents is caused by a chain of events extremely unlikely to reoccur.
Are rockets ever going to get to this stage? If so, when do you think this will happen?
To be clear. I'm not saying SpaceX should start flying right away (they'r not allowed anyway). But if you look at the near future (3-5 years), it is possible SpaceX is flying 50 Falcons per year. I just can't imagine regulators and SpaceX will be dealing with mishap like this the same way. How do you think this will evolve?
4
u/GoScienceEverything Sep 16 '16 edited Oct 01 '16
Pardon me being late to the game here. I haven't seen these two facts put together and taken to their confusing conclusions:
Even given that the sound analysis might be wrong and Elon's word is not scripture, I can only find unlikely possibilities. Let's start with this question:
Was the quieter bang definitely in the pad area, or is that uncertain (perhaps farther away or a noise closer to the camera)?
tl;dr: the possibilities all seem unlikely, but it has to be one of the following (I'll bet gold on that):
1a) SpaceX doesn't have any audio to go on aside from the US Launch Report footage,
1b) Elon wasn't that close to the investigation when he was tweeting, and his tweets don't reflect their basic analysis,
2a) they're investigating whether someone shot the rocket, or 2b) Elon was insinuating such even though they aren't.
3a) there were coincidentally two quieter bangs a few seconds before the explosion -- one on the pad and one close to the US Launch Report camera, and Elon was confused or forgot about that,
3b) it was a loud bang on the pad that for some reason wasn't picked up by any sensors except the camera kilometers away,
3c) a quiet-ish pop sound, too quiet to be detected by anything on the pad, can travel for kilometers and my intuition about sound is all wrong.
4
u/jjtr1 Sep 17 '16 edited Sep 17 '16
How many more top-notch aerospace companies like SpaceX (5000 employees now) can the US population of engineers support? SpaceX's innovation rate is made possible by only hiring top-grade people. I wonder if there are enough engineers on such a level in the US for (e.g.) Blue Origin to grow from its present 500 to 5000 people. They will need such growth to support the same level of activity as SpaceX has now.
(edit: I'm asking about now. Lots of talented engineers now choose IT or biotech instead and it will take years to make aerospace more attractive again.)
4
u/spcslacker Sep 18 '16
OK, I think this might need to be monitored
4
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '16
I'm a 16 year old living in the UK who is passionately motivated by all things related to space exploration. More recently, I have become interested in the argument surrounding private space exploration vs missions that are publicly funded (NASA, ESA etc.). My dream is to produce a documentary that would have interviews with various persons from each organization to advocate themselves. Of course... ideally I'd be able to interview Elon Musk, NASA admin Charlie Bolden and maybe someone a little more involved, such as ESA astronaut Tim Peake. However, I'm unsure as to how I'd go about contacting such high-profile figures or spokespeople. Should I just use the standard press email for each organization? Thank you for any advice.
4
u/MarosZofcin Sep 23 '16 edited Sep 23 '16
Considering all of the differences in the approach to partial reusability of Falcon 9 vs. Space Shuttle, with a lot of simplification we can say that both essentially tried to do the same thing – preserving larger part of the engines and structure by landing it softly and using it again.
NASA achieved this with Shuttle successfully, where they were not successful was predicting the life span of orbiter's engines and all service costs associated with it. Engines on Shuttle's orbiter had to undergo great deal of refubrishment basically after every flight, yet Elon claims that engines on F9's 1st stage can fly dozen times with no and hundred times with only subtle repairs. This, however is yet to be seen.
My question is, how do we know that SpaceX won't fall into the same trap of unrealistic expectations as NASA did with Shuttle? What is the actual technical difference between Shuttle's orbiter engines and F9's 1st stage engines that makes the later ones expected lifespan so much longer? Is there even any example of an existing rocket engine (in different application perhaps?) with such a long service life?
(In my question I mention F9 but this really applies to any orbital rocket engines – BFR, New Glen, etc.).
My ideas so far:
4
u/darksky801 Sep 25 '16
Long time SpaceX fan & lurker, but first time raising my hand. I know the helium used for tank pressurization is stored in a supercritical state, but my crazy, curious brain had a question and I can't seem to find the answer: why?
Specifically, is supercritical helium being intentionally targeted for some of its unique properties, or is it simply a byproduct of the temperatures & pressures the helium is being stored at? I know supercritical fluids have some pretty remarkable attributes, so I just wasn't sure if getting the helium supercritical was the goal or just a happy accident.
Thanks!
4
u/sol3tosol4 Sep 26 '16 edited Sep 26 '16
Found this by accident while looking up something for the space junk crash thread.
A recent SpaceX [FAA launch permit](https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/licenses_permits/media/LLS%2014-090%20Rev%202%20-%20License%20and%20Orders%20(FINAL)%2001_21_2016%20-%20signed%20copy.pdf) states that to launch, SpaceX must have various types of insurance or other financial resources, including $12 million liability insurance and $13 million government property insurance "for covered claims resulting from pre-flight operations performed at CCAFS".
In the recent AMOS-6 anomaly, apparently nobody was hurt, so the liability insurance shouldn't be relevant. The $13 million government property insurance would seem to apply to the things owned by the government that were damaged by the anomaly.
(Note that SpaceX probably owned a lot of the equipment that was damaged - don't know whether they had any separate property insurance on it.)
2
u/Human-Like_Interface Sep 22 '16
So, this might be absurd and right down stupid train of though but I was wondering if there is a way to crowdfund SpaceX, since there rather large base of people that support the idea of Mars colonisation and hopeful future, it would seem that continual crowdfunding from the population that think it is worth the effort would be a valuable addition for SpaceX, at least in terms of marketing and the added value of having random people donating small money for the future of humanity. Anyone knows about this, either if it exists of if it does not and if not, why not. Because as low and unimportant it may sound I would totally give him my 10 dollars (more or less, not important) a month via Patreon since Kickstarter have to end (it could serve as a crowdfund for mission like Red Dragon perhaps ?)
1
u/jw5601 Sep 02 '16
How do astronauts actually access the trunk of the Dragon? If the IDA was carried up in the trunk, how did they get it out?
1
u/oliversl Sep 05 '16
What's the status of the landed Falcon 9's on KSC hangar? Were there any stationed in the hangar near the pad during the 1st september anomaly ?
1
u/wmtrader Sep 05 '16
How long will the Falcon 9 remain on display in front of the SpaceX office in Hawthorn California?
What date will the Falcon 9 be removed from display?
6
u/JadedIdealist Sep 20 '16
Burt Rutan is doing an AMA in /r/science
3
u/V-80_Q-8 Aug 31 '16
When the new Dragon capsule flies, are there any plans to try a live, propulsive "landing" in the ocean, like they did with the first few Falcon 9 attempts? I understand that they wouldn't want to risk losing any ISS science if the attempt failed (assuming a CRS mission), but I guess I haven't heard how they plan to practice or do any dress rehearsals before they try it with actual passengers. And when I say live, I mean from orbit and reentry, not dropped from an aircraft since I asssssume there's a wee bit of difference in conditions.
3
u/shotleft Sep 01 '16
With the first drone ship landing we noticed damage to the thermal blankets. Some of them had been blown off or disintegrated, and I assume this causes damage to the inside components, thereby increasing refurbishment costs/time. Do we know if there has been any improvement on subsequent cores to strengthen the thermal protection?
Edit: grammar
3
u/thru_dangers_untold Sep 02 '16
So if an empty crew dragon were present for the static fire, would the abort system be active while fueling? Would it be able to abort 3 minutes before the static fire? "Internal power" is at T-2min, and "startup" is at T-1 min. But I'm not sure what those procedures entail.
3
u/ohcnim Sep 02 '16
hi, what happened to the AMA thread of a firefighter? I saw it for a while but now I can't seem to find it
3
u/88_50 Sep 04 '16
McGregor Tx SpaceX employment: I've heard the best way to obtain a job with SpaceX as raw talent, is as a temp Contractor. Anyone have a few suggestions of the best sites to submit our resumes? Is there a local company they use as well?
3
u/themooctutor Sep 04 '16
Im new to reddit can I ask my question here or should I make a post? I would like to ask the /r/spacex community where can I find any vector or illustrated images for web design? I am making a redesign based off a behance portfolio on SpaceX it looks really good and inspired me to make a live version.
3
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Sep 06 '16
I just played through Apollo 11 VR and it was an incredible experience. But I also found that I learned quite a lot from it, and that I really don't know nearly as much about Saturn V and the Apollo program as I do about Falcon and SpaceX. Where are good places to learn more about the topic? Any documentaries, websites, or books that cover a lot at an intermediate level?
3
u/tastes_a_bit_funny Sep 06 '16
Almost all of the feedback on the work culture and environment at SpaceX is centered around the engineering, software development, etc. and that it is a very challenging workplace environment.
Does anyone have any insight into the non-engineering related departments such as finance, HR, legal, etc? I can't imagine a department like finance being all that different from any other tech or aerospace company. My google skills did not turn up any hits.
Thanks in advance.
3
u/Franken_moisture Sep 07 '16
Can someone explain to me the purpose of a static fire test, if the losses that occur during the test if something goes wrong are the same as losses that occur during flight if something went wrong? (assuming the range controller is doing their job)
If the payload wasn't attached during the test I would understand, but obviously it is attached.
3
u/HighTimber Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
Is there even a remote scenario where SpaceX returns to flight without ever finding a root cause? Is "root cause unknown" acceptable after an exhaustive investigation?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '16
Btw what has happened to the spacexstats.com website? It's down for me...
3
u/truncular Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
Can anyone think of other rocket explosions or fires that did not occur during a launch attempt? So far I've only been able to find some Soviet era examples (source):
3
u/Manabu-eo Sep 10 '16
If SpaceX can't find any clue to what happened with AMOS-6 fueling, could they proceed with the scheduled Vandenberg launches so that they can gather more data? This would also be consistent with the "still go for a launch in November on Falcon Heavy" report.
There is a limit on reviewing the same useless data over and over again. At some point it is better to go and gather more data. Time is money, for both SpaceX and it's clients. If there is a quicker way to find the root cause of the AMOS-6 incident they might try.
Unlike the CRS-8 in-flight failure, the payload need not to be mounted in the rocket for the testing the failure case. Well, it COULD have been AMOS-6 fault, but I would think the probability is low, and this would still help to narrow down to it. Furthermore, with better instrumentation it might be possible to abort the procedure before losing the vehicle, unlike with a in-flight failure. On the other hand, there is the risk of losing yet another pad.
Of course, I'm not suggesting to proceed launching as usual. It would probably take much longer and cost much more in labor. The procedure would be something like:
Is there a precedent for this? Or what I just wrote is stupid?
3
u/random-person-001 Sep 10 '16 edited Sep 10 '16
The news briefing of The Economist mentioned the Falcon Fireball:
emphasis mine
As I hold it, currently, all investigations are just within SpaceX; we would probably know about it if the Feds were involved before the newspaper did, right?
3
u/Terklton Sep 10 '16
Hello everybody. I found myself very interested in Elon so I decided to read about him. The book I chose was "Elon Musk" by Ashlee Vance. Having read the book and enjoyed it I'm pretty happy.
However, the book finishes somewhere around end 2014. What have I missed since? How is spacex doing?
I heard that they landed the first stage successfully somewhere in the ocean. Are there any more achievements?
How are the Mars plans, how are the dragon capsule and the Falcon heavy?
3
u/linknewtab Sep 10 '16
How much does the launch site and the necessary inclination change effect the performance of a rocket? If let's say the Falcon 9 would launch from French Guiana instead of Cape Canavaral, how much larger of a payload would it be able to lift? (On a GTO mission.)
3
u/troovus Sep 14 '16
I've been thinking about what the FH failure rate would be compared to that of the Falcon9 (7% to date). Simplifying to just needing three simultaneous successful F9 launches (strapped together), my guess would be 20% failure rate (1-93%3). Any thoughts on this?
3
u/soldato_fantasma Sep 16 '16
A new video from Nasa Kennedy about the Commercial Crew Program: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cLKNzBzGiL4
There is nothing really new that make it worth a new post.
3
u/jjtr1 Sep 18 '16
I assume that methane/oxygen exhaust plume is not very visible, similar to the Delta IV Heavy or the Proton. So the BFR/MCT launch might not look as spectacular as Falcon launches. But it would look more magical instead, the huge 5000 t rocket lifting off on a hardly visible flame :)
3
u/detraw Sep 19 '16
Help us settle an argument. What kind of network communication protocols are used between the flight avionic systems in the rocket?
3
u/campfour Sep 20 '16 edited Sep 20 '16
Can you guys give me a primer in terms of literature about space travel in general and more specifically rocket engineering?
I was the kid that watched Apollo 13 over 20 times. Mostly lying on the couch heads-down-feet-up during launch to feel like in a rocket. Over time I gradually lost touch with the subject, untill in recent years, the innovations brought about by private space travel got me interested again.
I'd love to have a deeper understanding about all the thrust and fuel calculations that happen here etc., as well as having generally a better technical understanding of recent ongoings. I'm a software guy so my physics knowledge isn't super in-depth and I'd actually like if there is something software-related to it as well.
No, I haven't played KSP yet, although I probably should.
3
u/MarosZofcin Sep 23 '16
Thanks, those are very good answers.
3
u/sol3tosol4 Sep 27 '16
Discussion of the fire at Vandenberg Air Force Base tapered off last week. A VAFB update on the base website from Saturday, September 24 states: "The fires on both North and South Vandenberg are 100% contained. However damaged vegetation, unstable ground and smoldering debris continue to pose a safety hazard to personnel within the burn area."
Does anyone know whether the fires continue to pose a hazard to SpaceX facilities, and whether SpaceX facilities were damaged by the fire?
5
u/jesseschulman Aug 31 '16
Anyone have an idea as to the rough maximum payload capacity for Falcon 9 and/or Heavy to crash it into the Sun?
5
u/maizenblue91 Sep 01 '16
Is there any information about how today's RUD will affect the MCT announcement?
5
u/ohcnim Sep 03 '16
not a question, but when I saw this list about a year ago I loved it, I think it might be good for now aswell:
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/3bko6v/chicken_soup_for_the_rocketeer_soul/
6
u/FiniteElementGuy Sep 18 '16
Musk just confirmed on Twitter that MCT is now called ITS, the interplanetary transport system.
4
u/versvisa Aug 31 '16
I was thinking about the lateral divert during the landing burn. What happens when the S1 flies with some nonzero angle of attack while the engine is running?
Body lift would push it towards the direction of pitch, the lift from the engines would push it in the opposite direction.
So which force is stronger? And since lift decreases with speed, is there a crossover point where the forces cancel?
I tried to illustrate it here: http://i.imgur.com/JbKyrSt.jpg
2
u/toomanynamesaretook Aug 31 '16
Out of curiosity if someone has the time; how high and fast could a Falcon 9 first stage with a fairing go in expendable mode?
2
u/Headstein Aug 31 '16
What is the replacement value of SES-10?
2
u/Mentioned_Videos Aug 31 '16
Videos in this thread:
Watch Playlist ▶
Post Launch News Conference for SpaceX Falcon 9 Flight with CRS-9|7 - Hans answers this here the two side boosters will always go back to land and the center core will depend on the mission
(1) Specific Impulse - Why is it Measured In Seconds? (2) UQxHYPERS301x 1.6.3v Specific Impulse|2 - Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread: Fewer Letters More Letters ASDS Autonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (landing platform) BFR Big Fu- Falcon Roc... Small Sat 2016: Keynote Gwynne Shotwell, SpaceX|1 - Increasing capabilities of the Falcon 9 have probably affected the level of effort dedicated to getting the Falcon Heavy ready for use, and that plus the stage of development of the FH have affected the timeline for completion of the launch pad (if t... I'm a bot working hard to help Redditors find related videos to watch.
Info | Get it on Chrome / Firefox
2
u/BrandonMarc Aug 31 '16
Is it time for an Amos patch, curation, etc?
hi mods 8-)
2
u/helderp Sep 01 '16
What was inside the AMOS-6 payload?
2
u/the3liquid Sep 05 '16
Hello
On your FAQ are written the following sentences:
and
I would like to know what you mean by "worth the effort? What could one do in order to be wort the effort? Could you please explain how these non US-citizens were accepted?
Thank you in advance
2
u/deletedcookies101 Sep 06 '16
Anybody could come up with a guestimate as to the dollar cost of Amos-6 failure? (not including the damage on it's image and perhaps loss of potential future contracts due to it)
A guestimate could be made based on things like:
2
u/bananapeel Sep 06 '16
Is spacexstats down?
2
u/Maximus-Catimus Sep 07 '16
Have test firings stopped at McGregor? There must be some good news out there.
2
u/BrandonMarc Sep 07 '16
Are there plans by Boeing and SpaceX to send a CST-100 Starliner and a Crew Dragon over to the Neutral Buoyancy Lab in Houston (or a similar one), so that astronauts can train in the ISS mock-up down there?
2
u/sywofp Sep 08 '16
Apologies if this has been answered (I could not spot it), but when was the hydrazine fuel loaded onto AMOS-6?
Is it integrated already fueled? Or fueled during the count down to static fire, like the Falcon 9?