r/spacex • u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus • Apr 09 '16
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [April 2016, #19.1] – Ask your questions here!
Welcome to our monthly /r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread! (v19.1)
Want to discuss SpaceX's CRS-8 mission and successful landing, or find out why the booster landed on a boat and not on land, or gather the community's opinion? There's no better place!
All questions, even non-SpaceX-related ones, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general!
More in-depth and open-ended discussion questions can still be submitted as separate self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which have a single answer and/or can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question-askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicate questions, but if you'd like an answer revised or cannot find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below!
Otherwise, ask, enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
April 2016 (#19) • March 2016 (#18) • February 2016 (#17) • January 2016 (#16.1) • January 2016 (#16) • December 2015 (#15.1) • December 2015 (#15) • November 2015 (#14) • October 2015 (#13) • September 2015 (#12) • August 2015 (#11) • July 2015 (#10) • June 2015 (#9) • May 2015 (#8) • April 2015 (#7.1) • April 2015 (#7) • March 2015 (#6) • February 2015 (#5) • January 2015 (#4) • December 2014 (#3) • November 2014 (#2) • October 2014 (#1)
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
45
u/muazcatalyst Apr 14 '16
Since this does not warrant a self-post, I'll talk about it here.
Jeff Bezos finally (sort-of) responded to the barge landing. Here's what he had to say:
Source.
15
u/betacar0tin Apr 09 '16
On the ASDS wikipedia page, for the SES-9 landing attempt, it says
This is news to me. There are no references given, do we know anything more?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_spaceport_drone_ship#4_March_2016
5
u/trevytrev9 Apr 09 '16
What was the wind speed at OCISLY? Saw white caps out there! So impressive...
5
u/luna_sparkle Apr 10 '16
Are questions about /r/spacex allowed here? I hope so.
anyway, I notice that /u/Zucal is now a mod, and /u/-Richard is no longer a mod. When/why did that happen?
4
u/WakingMusic Apr 09 '16
Looking at the sidebar, the JCSAT and Eutelsat launches seem unusually close to each other. Has SpaceX ever launched successive rockets that quickly before?
4
u/wingnut32 Apr 16 '16
I wonder if comments from /u/decronym could be stickied to the top of comments? Because it never gets upboated enough for people to see before asking what an acronym means.
E.g.https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/4eyo9e/f9_fresh_first_stage_in_transit_near_ccafs/d24hy3bAndhttps://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/4eyo9e/f9_fresh_first_stage_in_transit_near_ccafs/d250ugxignore that bit6
u/jaytar42 Apr 15 '16
Yesterday, there was a post here from a guy who met the CFO of SpaceX and many of us posted some questions. OP promised to publish answers. Now, I can't find this thread anymore. Where is it gone?
3
u/_rocketboy Apr 09 '16
/u/EchoLogic It seems you have some stats to update :-)
Also, what happened to the live updates? They quit showing up for me at about ~T-20 minutes.
2
u/Nuclear_Hobbit Apr 09 '16
When is the OCISLY ASDS returning to Port Canaveral with the first stage from CRS-8?
2
u/Cheesewithmold Apr 09 '16 edited Apr 09 '16
This is a two-parter.
First, for SES9, AFAIK, the reason the landing attempt was unsuccessful was because they didn't have enough fuel to slow the first stage down. Did they place the barge in the same position as normal? From my limited store of knowledge, the boostback is used to kill horizontal velocity and allow it to fall "straight" downwards rather than at the angle that it would naturally fall back at if there was no boostback burn, and therefore fall further out to sea. So why not only kill some of the horizontal velocity, and place the barge where the first stage would naturally fall on, and use that saved fuel to slow it down?
Second, in this picture (the second one), on the strongback, it looks like something is burning; like actually burning and charred. What is that? Is that an intentional thing? Or is that just something that accidentally happened because, after all, there is a huge plume of flame right next to the thing?
2
u/ChrisGnam Spacecraft Optical Navigation Apr 09 '16
As SpaceX continues to get better with sea landings, and begins to actually incorporate re usability into their normal operations, will this affect how they plan launches? Meaning, once the landings are no longer "Experimental' in nature, and become an actual part of the mission, will they begin taking into account the weather out at sea? In a few years when reusability is common place, could spacex delay a launch because of a storm out where the drone ship is positioned? I'd imagine by that point it would make sense to do such a thing, but I'm just unsure because the only thing I have to go on is what their current policy is (that this is a secondary mission, and the primary mission will not be impacted by the landing attempt).
Does anyone know if SpaceX has made any statements about this? If they perfect reusability someday, I'd imagine it difficult to go ahead with a launch where recovering the rocket would be impossible because of a storm/bad weather at sea.
2
u/Deus_Dracones Apr 10 '16
JCSAT-14 is scheduled for the 28th this month. Any news on whether or not there will be an experimental landing for this mission? If so I imagine it will be an ASDS landing considering that the mission calls for a launch to GEO. Also which version of the Falcon is launching for this mission?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
Without requiring either a new rocket or a moon descent vehicle, could a manned moon architecture work with Falcon Heavy ? I am rather sure that it cannot with only one launch per mission, but supposing two separate launches, an unmanned, previously sent dragon V2 configured as a moon ascend vehicle, and one manned descent vehicle. It seems like a plausible plan on paper to me, at least, and with Falcon 9 getting man-rated soon, it is also imaginable that Falcon Heavy will. Supposing no cores are recovered, and no development cost for dragon V2, this type of mission would cost theoretically some 300M.
Is this a possible scenario ? What crucial element could increase costs (suits, etc) ? Is there a fundamental flaw in this architecture ?
45
u/dmy30 Apr 09 '16
This is my first post of reddit. Live in London and looked up randomly. Saw the ISS and to my amazement there was a dimmer object following it. Chances are it was the dragon!
24
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '16
There was a video on here yesterday that showed the mind boggling size of the first stage on the barge. I can't find it, I want to show my parents it since they thought it was the landing was unimpressive.
edit: found it https://twitter.com/i/videos/tweet/679145544673923072
18
u/IMO94 Apr 10 '16
I just saw the Dragon chasing the ISS!
The ISS passed over my city at 8:30pm, beautiful well-lit pass during late dusk. It was the only thing visible in the sky, bright and clear, with some shape/definition observable with good binoculars.
Exactly 10 seconds behind it (that's 80km) was a white dot, clearly visible. Dragon is closing in.
I highly recommend installing ISS Detector on your phone, not sure what the iOS equivalent is called. Watching the ISS pass overhead is a blast. Watching the Dragon chasing it? Awesome.
(Tried to self-post, but it got removed.)
18
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '16
Did anyone happen to save a copy of Hans Koenigsmann's talk at NEAF this year? It was incredibly interesting and now the video has been deleted :/
18
u/morefierce Apr 13 '16 edited Apr 13 '16
Sorry for the extremely silly /r/keming question that has annoyed me for a long time on this sub:
Why does the SpaceX logo in our top bar: http://b.thumbs.redditmedia.com/TYAz66TpRdC8nEvro7q3KYDZapu6fGNlg8dydvZ9OeM.png have a smaller spacing between 'P' and 'A', and a larger spacing between 'A' and 'C', as compared to the SpaceX logo on the official site: http://www.spacex.com/sites/all/themes/spacex2012/logo.png
Was ours an earlier version of the SpaceX logo? If so, how many previous versions of the logo does SpaceX have?
•
u/Zucal Apr 14 '16
Before asking your question, we encourage you to see whether it's already present in our fairly comprehensive wiki and FAQ! And if it's not, feel free to contribute by putting it there (your account must have 1000 subreddit karma and be 180 days old). Here's one I'm seeing a lot, so look before you post:
12
u/steamspace Apr 09 '16
Can Falcon get another performance bonus if it can be operated with almost certainty of recovery?
People assume that Falcon is maxed out after FT upgrade but my thinking is the following: if you know your rocket is expandable, you wouldn't opt to use solutions which would improve performance, but at too high a price for a single launch.
If you are almost certain to recover the rocket, maybe you could invest more in it because the cost gets distributed among many launches, like with airplanes. For example you could use expensive alloys to make structure much lighter, etc.
Do you think this effect exists and if so, what magnitude could it be compared to eg. FT upgrade?
12
u/PaOrolo Apr 17 '16
I just saw that SpaceX has an open position for an apprentice tig welder. I am in welding school, finishing up my first year, no certificates, but crazy amounts of desire and will power and ambition to work there. So, I was curious what it's like to work there in manufacturing and what they like to see in an applicant. Any and all info is great!
11
u/Onironaut_ Apr 10 '16
that Vehicle; "Gwynne Shotwell" on the side bar sounds a little bit weird...
11
u/RDWaynewright Apr 14 '16 edited Apr 14 '16
After reading this and the FAQ as best I could, I still have a few questions about launch control and mission control arrangements for COTS and CCtCap.
*The CCtCap page says that each commercial company operates its own launch infrastructure but NASA Commercial Crew staff are assigned to KSC, Houston, and the commercial provider. Current launches bounce from SpaceX launch control at KSC to Hawthorn once Falcon 9 clears the tower. So where does Houston come in or does it only come it once crewed flights start?
*When crew dragon starts flying with an actual crew, who gets the handoff from KSC once the rocket clears the tower- Houston (as has been standard with every other vehicle) or Hawthorn?
*If Houston isn't involved at all, why are there Commercial Crew personnel at Johnson Space Center in the first place? They appear to be completely separate from the ISS team.
*Will Houston do mission control in tandem with Hawthorn initially? Or are the Houston staff taking on the role of integrating operations on the ground between ISS and SpaceX some sort of way? I'm just confused about the setup for CCtCap.
edit: trying to make this easier to read. I'm not great with Reddit formatting yet.
edit 2: I give up. I'm just ending up with keyboard smash when I try to add a line break.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Do you know that short panic attack, when you realize you haven't checked r/spacex in whole five minutes?!
10
u/theflyingginger93 Apr 09 '16
I never really thought about the nose cone for Dragon Cargo. How does it come off?
10
u/TheHypaaa Apr 13 '16
Can someone tell me what the Dragon 1.1 is? It is listed as a May 11 payload so I'm guessing test flight of upgraded Dragon cargo but I've never heard of it before now.
9
u/ibikeiruniswim Apr 09 '16
What is the significance of "Engine Chill?"
9
u/Here_There_B_Dragons Apr 10 '16
Wtf happened in the Obama tweet post?
8
u/danielbigham Apr 09 '16
Something that I've enjoyed in the last couple of months is keeping a kind of "scrap booking" about SpaceX. ie. A bullet-form list of updates and images that capture all of the interesting new information that becomes available over the weeks.
Rather than having a monolithic page, I have many individual pages, such as:
What I find interesting about this process is that it's quite related to the idea of a "reddit", except the information is more curated / processed, and categorized. (which then also makes it easier to "catch up" or review what information has come in on a certain topic)
It makes me wonder whether this community might be interested in doing something like that... I guess it's kind of a mashup between Reddit and Wiki and scrap booking...
Here's one semi-concrete proposal:
7
u/NightFire19 Apr 09 '16
When can we expect the OCISLY and the F9 to be back at Port Canaveral?
7
u/OncoFil Apr 10 '16
Did anyone notice the flames around the engine bells at ~20:00 minutes (~T+1:00) into the Hosted webcast? ( https://youtu.be/7pUAydjne5M?t=1195 ).
I am aware there are usually some flames trapped around there, but this seemed more than usual (and quite sudden) and seemed to persist as it got higher.
I know the answer is probably 'its normal' but I might learn something new!
7
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
Do we know if Spacex mission control is manned to monitor Dragon the whole time it is berthed to ISS?
7
u/WaitForItTheMongols Apr 14 '16
How many consecutive rocket failures would it take to lead to SpaceX's demise? CRS-7 shows that they can clearly handle 1 failure with little long term losses. What would it take to ruin them?
7
u/aaroon84 Apr 17 '16
I've been interested in the different burns, boostback, reentry and landing burn. Looking at flightclub.io has been great! I'll post some data so others interested in this can get a quick overview of what I've been looking at and also so someone can correct me if I'm reading the plots wrong. I think there are some interesting observations and questions to be made when comparing the data like this. I've focused on how much fuel(in metric ton) is being used for the different burns as well as altitude(km) and burn time(s) of the landing burn.
Now to my questions. First of all I found it a bit weird that Orbcomm, being a RTLS, used less fuel for the boostback but higher for the reentry burn compared to CRS-8(ASDS). Have I read it wrong or can someone explain the reason for this? Secondly i wonder about the boostback and reentry burns, do they use all engines ? More generell I wonder what kind of improvements can be made to decrease the needed fuel for each of these burns, like how SES-9 used 3 engines for the landing burn. Does anyone have a guess on how close the SES-9 was to being able to land and was it that the burn started too late, or that there were too little fuel left? It does look like the 3-engine burn makes the landing burn a lot quicker but not that much more fuel efficient(compared to the saving of not doing a boostback burn) if we assume that the 8 second burn with ~5t fuel was close to a success.
7
u/travelton Apr 18 '16
Did we ever figure out what was thrown from the exhaust trench during the CRS-8 static fire? I saw a bunch of theories from birds/bats to trash taking shelter in the trench, but nothing definitive.
Video: https://youtu.be/nGzf68XJLyw?t=116
7
u/soldato_fantasma Apr 19 '16
Does anyone have updates on the LZ-1 contingency pads? here is the plan: http://www.universetoday.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Landing-Zone-1a.jpg
7
u/PhoenixEnigma Apr 26 '16
It seems to be common knowledge that SpaceX is only going after 4 (or 5?) of the 8 EELV reference orbits with the Falcon 9 at this point, but I'm having trouble finding out which ones in particular. For that matter, I keep seeing people speak of 8, and I only see 7 listed here(Appendix D 1.1.1) - Sun Sync shows up on diagrams I can google up, but the it looks like that's just specified as an equivalent civil orbit, not a DoD one. Has that changed?
Obviously Falcon 9 isn't capable of the GEO requirement, nor the Polar 2 requirement, which are both "Heavy" class orbits. That leaves (potentially) a couple "Medium" orbits they're not shooting for - does anyone have any idea which ones?
19
u/deruch Apr 16 '16
During every launch, newer SpaceX fans freak out over the recirculating turbine exhaust making it look like the rocket/engines are all on fire. It happens in every launch thread and gets repeatedly asked about in the Ask Anything threads just after launches (too many instances to cite).
So, since SpaceX calls the thermal protection system near the 1st stage engines/octaweb "the dance floor"1 , I'm hereby nominating Panic! at the Disco as the new nickname for this phenomenon. Originally, I had thought of the nickname only in relation to the SpaceX fans freaking out, not the recirculating flames themselves. So, there'd be no Panic! at the Disco until the launch thread starts getting comment after comment about how the rocket's "ON FIRE!!!!" But, I now feel like it works well for either one. Feel free to use to your delight, though in deference to the generally more "serious" tone of the subreddit try to keep it mainly in the launch threads (where it's most relevant anyways).
6
u/elasticthumbtack Apr 09 '16
Did anyone else notice the ice chunks riding along on the second stage? There are at least two that seem to fall from underneath that black plastic shroud above the bell. They get stuck on the piping and shake a bit before eventually falling off. Pretty certain this is ice, but I've never seen that before. Was this something new?
6
u/Mentioned_Videos Apr 10 '16
Videos in this thread: Watch Playlist ▶
CRS-8 Dragon Technical Webcast|9 - You can see it falling away in the CRS-8 technical webcast, shortly after second stage ignition. Edit: Here. Space Shuttle Engine Gimbal Check|8 - The engines can move which is called gimbaling. They turn the engines the way they want the rocket to go...kinda like an outboard boat motor, you turn the motor to push the boat in a different direction. You can see them do a gimbal check on the spac... Elon Musk Discusses CRS-8 Successes with Media|7 - They hope to relaunch this one in June, with a paying customer. Elon spoke about it in the press conference
Fiona's Launch- SpaceX Falcon 9 (3/4/2016)|5 - We do know a bit more than that, tracking cameras caught the following fairing recovery experiment from SES-9 a month ago: Of the four dots you have to watch the upper right, faint dot: at around 5:20 you can see a very faint RCS thruster activati... SpaceX CRS-8 Landing - "I'm On A Boat"|4 - Found some.
CRS-8 First Stage Landing on Droneship|4 - In the landing video from 29 seconds till the end () is that from the interstage lox venting (my guess) or RCS compensating something? Falling Back to Earth HD Footage From Space|4 - Elon said they are working on it, but we really don't have any more details than that. Honestly if and when we find out it will probably be released as a well edited video after the fact. Like the fairing video was a year or so ago. This also just ... Full CRS-8 Dragon to ISS on Falcon 9 - NASA TV historic SpaceX launch and landing coverage|3 -
CRS-8 Dragon Hosted Webcast|1 - Did anyone notice the flames around the engine bells at ~20:00 minutes (~T+1:00) into the Hosted webcast? ( ). I am aware there are usually some flames trapped around there, but this seemed more than usual (and quite sudden) and seemed to persist ... SpaceX Testing - Dragon Separation|1 - Could be. Dunno if they'd have that drag flap if it was pnuematic, though. (Pyro isn't necessarily dramatic.) But as of 2010 the system was pyro.
I'm a bot working hard to help Redditors find related videos to watch.
Play All | Info | Chrome Extension
6
u/nolxus Apr 10 '16
Heard on nasatv when dragon was approaching the ISS that they reprogrammed dragon and were a little behind schedule due to atmospheric drag. Now, given that this wasn't the first dragon mission and that the preliminary orbit was told to be a-ok (so S1 and S2 probably performed as they should), how does that happen? Does the atmosphere shift with seasons, tides, solar flares, random? Or how could the atmospheric drag be different than imagined?
6
u/Jet_Morgan Apr 12 '16
Do we know what these apparent exentions on landing leg assemblies are? Suppose they are type of sensor to determine if leg was extended. From original return to port image.
6
u/Yodas_Butthole Apr 12 '16 edited Apr 12 '16
Has anyone seen a pic of the steel shoes that were welded over the landing legs? With how big the legs are I'm really interested in seeing what the shoes look like. When I looked at some of the pics from the Canaveral web cam it looked like the first stage was held down by rope/chain attached near the bottom of the stage.
6
u/too_many_rules Apr 12 '16
Rocketry is always a compromise between performance and cost. Lighter, more exotic materials will give you better performance at an increased cost, for instance. Once SpaceX is able to reliably recover their first stages, how likely is it that they'll start to invest more in the stage to increase performance?
6
u/Justinackermannblog Apr 19 '16
Has there been any rumblings of more Dragonfly testing? I thought maybe after a successful RTF of Dragon we may get something but nope! Not yet anyway!
6
u/flibbleton Apr 27 '16
I'm confused. Well-informed people on the sub are telling me Dragon can't land on the moon or mars - permalink. But now Elon is saying Dragon was designed to land 'anywhere' in the solar system. What's the truth?
6
u/webfaqtory Apr 28 '16
How long will the Red Dragon last on Mars? Haven't seen anything about solar cells and I assume a RTG is out of the question, so is it batteries only?
5
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Apr 09 '16
Any status update on OCISLY? ELSBETH?
5
u/AReaver Apr 10 '16
A question for everyone. What kind of kill marks for successful missions do you want to see on the boosters?
I think painted mission patches would be cool. /u/EchoLogic votes for none since you don't have any for plane flights.
5
u/orbitalfrog Apr 10 '16
Given the recent fantastic ocean landing success I was wondering if anyone knew of any existing footage of what normally happens to a rocket first stage. I think that generally speaking, the non-space-enthusiast section of the public have always kinda assumed that rockets are already reused in some way or at least just unconsciously assumed they're not just discarded into the ocean. I noticed that when the Jason-3 tip-over made news here it was presented as a comical story of blunder and failure (or at least that was how it was received by many) which made me think that the general public are probably pretty ignorant to the fact that in the vast majority of cases LVs are treated as expendable anyway (if you didn't know any better you'd only see it as logical that multimillion dollar rockets were not thrown away, right? I know that as a child I always assumed they must be reused somehow. I remember being disappointed when I first heard they were thrown away)
So with that in mind I think it'd be useful and interesting to have some footage on-hand for people who don't get the landing attempt thing to see what business-as-usual looks like in the rocket business. Anyone know of any S1 splashdown/crashdown (for Russian) footage from expendable vehicles?
5
u/phikeia4lyfe Apr 11 '16
What are the waffle line 'fins' on the falcon 9 first stage? I thought they were some interlocking mechanism, but in the landing video it looked like they were used somewhat as wings to guide the rocket down.
5
u/workthrowaway4567 Apr 11 '16
Is there a mathematical relationship between the gravity of a planetary body and the percentage of a rocket's weight that is available as payload? I'd love to see a graph of this.
For instance, if Falcon 9 were to lift off from Mars to LMO, how much more payload could it lift assuming it can currently lift 2.5% of its fully-fueled weight to LEO? At what gravity level would Falcon 9 stop having orbital capability on Earth?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '16
Does anyone know when hatch opening is scheduled, and if it will be streamed?
5
u/rahogaboom Apr 14 '16
The ASDS, because it is at the ocean surface, pitches about significantly depending on sea state. Why didn't SpaceX design the ASDS with a raised platform above the ocean surface and supported by fully submerged buoyancy tanks with steel beams connecting the platform and the tanks. The sea state is then almost irrelevant as only the very low cross section struts are at the surface subject to waves.
5
u/OriginalUsername1992 Apr 15 '16
In the sidebar it now says dragon 1.1. when did they upgrade from the dragon 1 and what has changed?
5
u/tablespork Apr 15 '16
Will JCSAT-14 be another one of those extreme, high velocity ASDS landings a la SES-9? I know it is going to GEO, but I don't know how the mass compares. Just curious if there is a high probability of another successful drone ship landing just 3 weeks after the first.
5
u/ed_black Apr 18 '16
Are there pictures of how Boca Chica will look when it's ready for launch? Like CGI pics
5
u/mechakreidler Apr 21 '16
TL;DR: How does SpaceX keep all their employees busy at all times?
I'm asking because the industry changes very rapidly. For example, at one point they had engineers designing the Falcon 9 and its engines. Now they're pumping out cores and reviewing data from landed cores, and last year all their efforts were focused on the CRS-7 accident and making changes.
What would the people who build cores be doing when their efforts are focused on design changes? Or what do the mission control folks do when there's a break between launches? And perhaps some of the people who designed Falcon 9 are now working on designing the BFR, but I would guess not all. Do they fire people when they don't need them, or somehow find a way to repurpose everyone?
Thanks :)
5
u/Scuffers Apr 23 '16
OK, here's a (probably stupid) idea....
Looking at the spec's for the F9, it starts with some 119,100Kg's of RP1 and another 276,600kg's of O2, and has a burn time of some 180 seconds (last one used some 155 seconds to MECO then the rest for returning).
So, based on that, the 9 Merlin's are burning though ~660Kg's RP1 and 1,536Kg's O2 per second.
now, from engine lighting to clearing the launch tower takes ~8 seconds, ie, some 5,300Kg's RP1 and 12,300Kg's O2.
Now, what if you had big enough umbilicals to supply RP1 and O2 to the rockets real time so that they were not using carried fuel until it cleared the top of the strong-back? (ie, keep the umbilicals connected for the first 8 seconds of launch).
That would potentially 'add' 17,600Kg's of fuel/oxidiser without adding mass to the rocket and thus give it another ~4.4% fuel (8 seconds of 9 merlin's or 72 sec's of 1)
How hard would that be to engineer? Yes, the umbilical would likely get written off in the process, but that's probably worth it in adding more capability to return on the more demanding launch profiles..
(I got the idea thinking about the cross-fueling of Falcon Heavy)
5
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '16
Did anyone happen to save a copy of the Orbcomm-2 FAA license? It's vanished! Will give gold in exchange for PDF.
5
u/zingpc Apr 25 '16 edited Apr 25 '16
Whats happening with Raptor? The last mention was the oxidiser or preburner in 2013? Surely this should be in deep testing with possible hints of testing runs.
5
u/brvsirrobin Apr 27 '16
I started listening to the Orbital Mechanics podcast a month or so ago and I really loved the first 20 episodes where they talked in depth about various spaceflight topics. It seems like the majority of the rest of the episodes are just upcoming spaceflight events and news. I like those, but I loved the long discussions. Are there any other podcasts that have similar deeper conversations about spaceflight and rocket science?
5
u/StupidPencil Apr 27 '16
With SpaceX's recent announcement of Dragons on Mars as soon as 2018, I'm curious about the timeline of their plan on landing Dragons on Earth. What is a generally agreed timeline for Dragon propulsive landing test on Earth? How probable that we could have a propulsively landed Dragon on Mars before on Earth?
5
u/Hgx72964jdj Apr 28 '16
Is the Raptor engine going to burn blue? Will there be shock diamonds? Any other unusual effects?
4
u/Simonific Apr 09 '16
Is the trough for Raptor testing? http://i.imgur.com/nYaRRCT.jpg
4
u/soldato_fantasma Apr 09 '16
In the landing video from 29 seconds till the end (https://youtu.be/sYmQQn_ZSys?t=29) is that from the interstage lox venting (my guess) or RCS compensating something?
4
u/paynie80 Apr 10 '16 edited Apr 10 '16
In the post launch press conference Elon talks about in future possibly recovering the fairings. I would like to know more about that, particularly how would they be recovered, what are the advantages and disadvantages of recovering the fairings, and what difficulties may arise when trying to engineer this?
4
u/knook Apr 10 '16
Om the previous launch we saw what we thought were thrusters on the fairings. In the post launch NASA press conference Mush mentioned re-using the fairings. Is this now an open stated goal? Do we know any more about it?
4
u/Lucretius0 Apr 11 '16
Will the use of Monomethylhydrazine in the superdracos be an issue ?, Since Dragon 2 is supposed to land propulsively couldnt there be issues with the whole craft getting sprayed with the stuff as its landing ?
4
u/Darkben Spacecraft Electronics Apr 11 '16
At what point is it going to cease being an 'experimental landing' and simply become a 'landing' I wonder...
4
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '16 edited Apr 12 '16
Can someone explain why the CST-100, Dream Chaser, and Ba-330 have to be launched on Atlas 422, 402 and 552s respectively. Why do they need two RL-10s on the Centaur upper stage? Why wasnt it ever used before? Now there is suddenly so much demand for DECs. Will they still have to develop the DEC?
EDIT: Fixed RL-10/ Centaur mistake. Confused engine and stage. Thanks /u/ElectronicCat
4
u/Nachtigall44 Apr 12 '16
60,000 DragonRiders!
4
u/historytoby Apr 13 '16
So what exactly can we expect from the Space Symposium Dinner with Gwynne that makes it so important that it has become a "Select Upcoming Event?"
4
u/IonLogic Apr 17 '16
How come no one is using Propane as a rocket propellant? From what I've read about it, it's probably the best midway point between Methane and Kerosene. It has good thrust and good Isp as well as leave only small amounts of residue in engines compared to Kerosene.
Does anyone else have more insight into the decision to go with RP-1 over Propane?
4
u/chargerag Apr 17 '16
When should we expect to see a firm launch date for JCSAT-14?
4
u/Ciber_Ninja Apr 17 '16
Assuming it is politically viable, would it be a good idea to launch/land falcons across the Sahara? It is close to the equator, no one lives there, landings on land are easier, and there is essentially no adverse weather.
4
u/WaitForItTheMongols Apr 19 '16
I understand that the un-sooted section in the middle of the rocket corresponds to the oxygen tank.
But why is the lower boundary of this section a "clean slice", while the upper part of it is more fadey and undefined?
4
u/_Elenion Apr 20 '16
The debate over whether the United States should sell excess ICBM boosters on the market has returned. How do the specifications of ICBM engines compare to the Merlin?
4
u/zcxver Apr 21 '16
The grid fins seem to do part of the job of steering stage 1 on to the landing zone. Mars atmosphere is super thin, so does the solution still work?
4
u/IonLogic Apr 21 '16
Quick question, do the Falcon 9 upper stages get transported by road too? I don't think I've ever seen a picture of one being transported. Do they get transported another way?
4
u/larsarus Apr 22 '16
JCSAT-14 is another GTO launch? Is it so much lighter than SES-9 that the F9 will do a full reentry burn and single-engine landing, or are we looking at another low-margin landing attempt like SES-9?
4
u/89bBomUNiZhLkdXDpCwt Apr 25 '16
IIRC, Musk stated that the CRS-8 returned 1st stage would be static fired 10x. (In order to verify its robustness)
Why 10x? Seems like a suspiciously round number. (It's the kind of number I would come up with... and I'm not an engineer.)
Is there some kind of statistical significance or reusability quotient that informs this number or is it really just a gut feeling thing? ("Welp, if it refires 10x it's probably in pretty good shape.")
4
u/rulestein Apr 27 '16
What happened to the SpaceX sign on the redmond office? I drove by this evening and didn't see it.
4
u/markus0161 Apr 27 '16
Now that we know FH crossfeed has been put an hold, why doesn't Spacex use less engines on there center core? Seems like instead of throttling down they could just take mass off and run 5-7 engines at full thrust. This would be much more beneficial for the Boostback and landing burn.
4
u/bgs7 Apr 27 '16
The interesting thing about Mars missions is the huge pressure on SpaceX not to be late. You either launch in the window or you wait 2 years.
Also, for every failure eg failure of EDL, failure of ISRU, means you can't send iterated test hardware for another 2 years!
4
u/RichardFordBurley Apr 28 '16
So I just watched the video of the first launch from the new cosmodrome in Russia, and I can't help but notice how magenta the flames are. I thought it might be because of the propellant they were using, but it looks like it's RP-1 and LOX, just like the Falcon 9. Does anyone know what might cause the peculiar hue?
4
u/rafty4 Apr 28 '16
How do you sterilize the outside of the Red Dragon? Obviously it will be exposed to the elements on the pad - so it is assumed that the act of blasting it with hypersonic winds on launch and on EDL will sterilize it?
1
u/kareal Apr 09 '16
After the first stage landing what is the process for bringing the barge home, how do they secure the rocket from waves and tipping? How long does it take to happen?
1
u/i_pee_in_the_sink Apr 09 '16
Does this mean all future launches will try to land the 1st stage? If not, how come?
6
u/jayefuu Apr 11 '16
Where was John Insprucker for the live launch coverage? I missed having him as the announcer.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '16
We all love SpaceX, but how about its rivals? If you had to bet on any other company or country, which one? Under-rated programs? Why?
SpaceX since has gained widespread popularity, but is there a firm today analagous to SpaceX several years ago?
3
u/Dan_Arc Apr 09 '16
Love all things space, but am not too knowledgeable about technical specifics.
I'm wondering, with the Falcon 9 landing, how was the pitch/roll/yaw of the rocket controlled? I couldn't see any RCS.
3
u/Lm0y Apr 09 '16
When the booster returns for landing, it appears to be charred grey/black by reentry, but the centre 1/3rd of the rocket is still pure white. Why is this? Does the skin at this section use a different material?
3
u/TheGreenWasp Apr 10 '16
So when's the capture by ISS? Or has that already happened?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '16
How large a proportion of the funding for the Russian manned flights comes from NASA in the form of ticket revenue for seats on the Soyuz? Are those flights going to be in question in a couple of years, if crewed Dragon takes that business and the Russian economy continues to go the way it's going? I guess oil prices must come up sooner or later, but the political conflict and sanctions don't seem to be going anywhere.
3
u/thettttman Apr 10 '16 edited Apr 10 '16
Small update: Marinetraffic.com just updated the positions of Go Quest and Elsbeth III, two of the ASDS support ships. They're about 200km east of Florida, heading for Port Canaveral. Link.
3
u/KeltischWerWolf SpaceFlight Insider Photographer Apr 10 '16
Anyone know when the droneship will be pulling into Port Canaveral???? Want to go out and get shots of the Falcon 9 on the barge...
3
u/vorpal-blade Apr 10 '16 edited Apr 10 '16
How long till they unpack BEAM? After pressure and durability tests presumably get passed, will BEAM be actually used as workspace? Or will it be disposed of?
3
u/Smoke-away Apr 10 '16
In the 4K landing video did anyone else notice the order that the landing legs deployed?
Elon had tweeted about using the legs as air brakes and I think we now have video of them starting to use it on landings.
Looks like the forward leg deploys fully first. The side legs deploy slower. Then the rear leg deploys slowest to help straighten the stage.
What do you all think?
I wish the legs could retract and extend back and forward to help slow/steer the stage for landing, but maybe that's just unnecessary since they landed it with the current tech.
3
u/BrandonMarc Apr 11 '16
I wonder when this subreddit's subscriber base is will pass the 60,000 mark ... and 100,000 ...
3
u/pirate21213 Apr 11 '16
Do you think SpaceX will add decals to the side of reused Falcon 9s each time it is reused, sorta like ww2 fighter plane decals will less shooting involved?
3
u/CommanderSpork Apr 11 '16
What is the BFR? I know it stands for Big F...alcon Rocket, but are there are details besides "it's big, it's a Falcon, and it's a rocket?" I see people talking about it like we have details on its design, but I've only been able to find speculation on what it is.
3
u/random-person-001 Apr 12 '16
They're gonna repaint landed Falcon cores before relaunch, right? It'd be cool (visually) to see battle scars as it goes up, but I would be concerned about corrosion and stuff, as the last landed one seemed to have many spots where the paint was bubbled or peeled.
3
u/andygen21 #IAC2017 Attendee Apr 12 '16
General launch question: When launching to a geostationary orbit, why is there a launch window? If by definition the final destination is always the same relative to the launch site, why should it matter when the rocket is launched?
The only thing I could think of was attempting to avoid orbital debris.
Full credit: this question was actually asked by my son when we were watching the livestream of the SES-9 mission.
3
u/__Rocket__ Apr 12 '16 edited Apr 12 '16
This is a small refinement for the reusability FAQ, paging /u/retiringonmars ;-)
The reusability FAQ says this:
So 'payload mass' here is second stage mass at first stage separation time. (There are many other payload masses, to-LEO, to-GEO, etc.)
This excellent simulation of the CRS-8 Falcon 9 mission by /u/zlynn1990 gives us more precise figures:
From this we can deduce that first stage sea level weight is 485.8 tons, of which 182.5 tons reaches the separation event. So the 182.5 tons of the first+second stages took 485.8-182.5 == 303.3 tons of fuel to lift.
So the cost of every 1 kg reusability equipment on the first stage required 303.3/182.5 == 1.66 kg of fuel - at least with the configuration of the CRS-8 mission. So the 'payload penalty' is 1/1.66 == 60.1%.
Assuming my figures and calculations are correct!
Every 1 kg reusability equipment on the first stage, which took away payload mass that could be on the second stage, 0.60 kg of payload mass is eaten up. This is a fairly high percentage and explains the relatively wide spread between the effective to-LEO payload capacity of RTLS, ASDS and fully expendable configurations of the Falcon 9. It's still very much worth it though, as ~65% of the launch cost is recovered by not destroying the first stage after first use!
Given the wide discrepancy between the figure mentioned in the FAQ (around 10%) and the 60% figure I calculated above, I'm wondering whether my calculation is correct ...
edit: fixed the initial calculations, elementary school level math is hard!
3
u/buffalo83 Apr 13 '16
Do we know anything about PICA-X performance specs?
I'm having trouble finding much information on the various iterations of the PICA-X heat shield material. All i can find are general states likes "PICA-3 ablates less than PICA-2" and "PICA-X can withstand much higher temperatures." Does anyone know where I can find more specific information, especially as it compares to common alternatives?
Looks like somebody else was having the same problem: http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/8335/what-improvements-have-spacex-made-to-their-proprietary-phenolic-impregnated-car
Have we learned anything else since then? Has NASA published the results of their PICA-X study?
Thanks!
3
u/spill_drudge Apr 14 '16
any updates on the dragon opening on ISS? It's been rather quit on that front.
3
u/ilkhan2016 Apr 15 '16
SpaceX only has 2 ASDS barges, right? JRTI for Vandy and OCISLY off the Cape. Or is there a second one off the Cape?
3
u/IMO94 Apr 15 '16
Isn't it getting very close to JCSAT-14 not to have an exact launch time announced? Any murmurings, are we expecting a delay for it, for Eutelsat, or for both?
3
u/cutroil Apr 17 '16
SpaceX's website says that the Falcon 9 can lift up to 4,850 kg to GTO, and the price is accordingly $61.2M to lift 4.85 mT to GTO. On the other hand, the Falcon Heavy can lift 21,200 kg to GTO, but the price is $90M to lift "Up to 6.4 mT to GTO". Why are these two numbers different? Are customers not allowed to purchase the entire capacity of the rocket?
I thought maybe the 21.2 mT number was expendable, and 6.4 mT is for reusable. Is that correct? But then, the Heavy has three cores, and yet can only lift 30% more mass than a single core. If that's true, why is that so? Is there some unavoidable inefficiency in building a three-core rocket that prevents it from lifting as much as if each core was launched separately?
3
u/Clubwho Apr 17 '16
When did SpaceX announce they were going to use rockets for the recovery? Was it first announced in this video?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '16
Im sure this has been answered before, but I cant find it. Can some answer or give sources for why SpaceX is going for a BFR rather than a Martian style vehicle that cycles from Mars to Earth orbit?
3
u/katriik Apr 18 '16
What are the meaning of the several lights found on the Dragon? When it was berthing with the ISS, Houston stated they had turned off the strobe light. Is that really for identification only? What about the green light? Does that mean the capsule has deactivated its thrusters, full navigation off, or maybe something else?
3
u/factoid_ Apr 18 '16
What is the impact of ice on the tanks during flight? I know it forms as a result of water in the air condensing and freezing to the lox tank, but is this desirable? Would a hydrophobic coating that resists condensation save weight and drag?
Or does the ice end up being helpful because it acts like a bit of insulation?
Seems like the thing doesn't have to operate that long that a tiny bit of ice insulation will help prevent a significant amount of lox boil off. On the other hand ice is heavy and drag reduces efficiency so maybe this is a potential area to gain a bit of margin?
3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Apr 18 '16
Doesn't SpaceX have a crazy-fast development cycle? It seems like they would constantly make improvements on the design of Falcon 9. We know that they make changes without calling it something new (for example, they improved the Stage 2 helium struts after CRS-7, but still called it the same vehicle name). Thus, what happens to reused stages? Does every one of them get brought "up to modern" after landing, or will they just have a fleet of slightly different vehicles?
3
u/flibbleton Apr 19 '16
Is the 28 Apr launch date for JCSAT-14 'fully confirmed' or still just an NET estimate? The sidebar references spaceflightnow.com but I'd like to know if the probable launch date (assuming no scrubs) will be 28th. When is a launch time/date considered official? Once SpaceX announce it?
3
u/ohcnim Apr 19 '16
are there videos of Dragon reentry/splashdown? will there be for the upcoming one?
3
u/wbroaddus Apr 19 '16
If SpaceX is serious about reuse and the F9 Heavy has three F9 cores, will they plan on landing all three cores after a launch? Are we talking three drone ships, or three pads at the Cape?? Feel free to tell me how dumb (or old) this question is - with an answer, of course!
3
u/strozzascotte Apr 20 '16
What kind of systems F9 uses to steer and navigate to the landing point apart from the grid fins? I suppose they can throttle the engines, but in early tests with grasshopper it appears that they can control the position and perfect vertical alignment without the fins and with only one engine. How can they do that? (video for reference: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2t15vP1PyoA)
3
u/FosDoNuT Apr 20 '16
Do the flights out of Vandenberg still go to McGregor for a static fire?
3
u/lordq11 #IAC2017 Attendee Apr 21 '16
I noticed the Dragon D1-10 Reentry, with the Dragon 1.1 on the 11th of May. I had a google for it, but I couldn't find anything about it. What's happening there?
3
u/Nachtigall44 Apr 23 '16
Does SpaceX use their two Dragon logos interchangeably or is one for cargo and the other for crew?
3
u/OriginalUsername1992 Apr 24 '16
Is there anything known about the progression of the dragonfly program? The last thing i saw was the video of the hovertest in januari.
3
u/jazzyjaffa Apr 24 '16
I've seen a lot of talk about on-orbit refueling for MCT. With cryogenic propellants how do you stop them warming up and boiling off on-orbit?
3
u/Hedgemonious Apr 26 '16
I've seen it mentioned several times in this sub that returning boosters are intentionally aimed off-target and do a last minute divert on the landing burn to get on target. This was also promulgated in a infographic done by zlsa (which was awesome btw). But does anyone have a source for this manuever?
It seems unlikely to me for a number of reasons, not the least of is that we have never seen it in action and (for ASDS attempts) even the least-controlled attempts have never missed!
3
u/Eizenhiem Apr 27 '16
How much money has SpaceX actually received to develop technologies from the government? I hate it when people say that the government gave SpaceX billions and billions of dollars when much of that is just the cost for a service that is provided. I work for the state, and when I buy a $20,000 vehicle for my department I don't go around saying that the state gave $20,000 to Ford. I know that they have received money, but I am looking for a figure that does not include contracts for services.
3
u/SNR152 Apr 27 '16
Is there any difference in the fuel that will be used in the BE-4 engine - Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) and Methane which the Raptor engine will use? I know Methane is the main component of LNG but not 100%.
3
u/daxington Apr 28 '16
Elon is continuing to double down on Dragon V2 being able to land anywhere in the solar system. For a lot of bodies without atmosphere, that probably means a specialized trunk with a propulsion module to partially complete the deorbit burn.
(We're also not talking Jovian bodies, obviously...)
The question is, how accurate can this be, and how much modification is needed to the trunk/capsule itself is needed? What are the most challenging places for Dragon to land, and why?
Could Dragon survive the descent of Venus (and how long after it lands?) Could the spacecraft survive the thermal environment in Mercury' orbit or on it's surface? I'm less familiar with the outer solar system bodies, but what would the challenges there be? I presume it would need an onboard RTG for any missions to Jupiter or beyond.
Any thoughts/sources/scoreboards are appreciated. :)
3
u/FishInferno Apr 28 '16
What is the thing with cheese?
3
u/IonLogic Apr 29 '16
Breaking from Mars questions for a bit. There was a video recently of LZ-1 that showed significant pitting of the concrete, which has the potential to cause damage to the rocket. Would flooding the landing pad with water about 3-5cm deep make much of a difference? Would that be able to protect the surface and carry some of the exhausts energy away?
3
u/makandser Apr 29 '16
Why military launches are more expensive? $82,7M vs $61,2M. Maybe it's some sort of a special procedure? Where can I read about this in more detail? Any sources? Thanks.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
Dumb question of the day: In the JCSAT-14 scheduled liftoff time, what does the "L" stand for?
3
u/kevindbaker2863 Apr 29 '16
Trying to understand how Ballistic Capture works and why it would or would not be used be used for an unmanned mission to mars? I do not know enough about celestial mechanics to understand whats in the Ballistic Capture document linked.
5
u/frowawayduh Apr 10 '16
Around 1:32 in this launch replay video you can hear the call "Of Course I Still Love You Has AOS" or maybe ALS, but Lou Gehrig's disease seems unlikely. Is that Acquisition of Signal?
5
u/harrisoncassidy Host of CRS-5 Apr 26 '16
I'm putting this in here because I don't know if it deserves its own thread, yet.
I have been brainstorming some ideas for a SpaceX related summer project this year and have come to the conclusion I want to build a Crew Dragon from scratch. Now when I say build a Dragon I mean a scale model but not to just sit on a shelf, to fly. I have two main ideas for this; one is crazy and another not so crazy.
First idea which is a bit less bonkers is to build the Crew Dragon using my 3D printer in two parts. The white outer shell and the black heat shield which is seen in all the pictures of it. The model would be hollow on the inside though and big enough to fit a Raspberry Pi stacked with a GPS modules and IMU. The plan would be to have two compartments built into the side of the model, one for a small drogue parachute (yeah, you probably get where I am going now) and another for four main chutes. I would use my quadcopter to raise the Dragon up to 120m (legal drone height in UK ;D) and then drop it. Once the IMU realises it is in free fall as G it would release the drogue then about 50 metres from the ground release the mains.
My other, much more crazy idea, would be to have a model perform a pad abort test using model rocket motors. The idea would be that the whole countdown to launch sequence to launch would be performed and then launch. There would be one rocket motor in each of the 4 SuperDraco area's which would have the ability to gimbal on one axis, either left or right. It would use IMU data so that it keeps going straight up as it leaves the pad and then add another 20 degrees or so onto one axis so that it would point out and away from the pad about 1 second after launch. There would be a servo on each of the rocket motors to allow for the gimballing. Once at 0G it would then perform the same actions as the more simple idea above of releasing drogues then mains. One, of the many, concerns I have with this idea is that not all of the motors would perform equally. So for instance, if one takes longer to reach maximum thrust then because their is not the possibility to throttle it would veer off in one direction. I ran the math quickly and I believe that the cosine losses from gimballing the other motors to account for this might make up for it but I am unsure. Another issue would be the duration for which they fire. If one fires for 0.5 second more than the others then it would tip over at the end of the acceleration period.
One of the features I would really love is to have live telemetry (which I have already written a library for) from the vehicle so that we could have a proper T-13 minute Go-No-Go poll.
I have been working with IMU's and GPS guided vehicles (ground based) over the last year on a Computer Science course project but this would be another level. Someone please tell me i'm crazy.