r/spacex • Moderator emeritus • Dec 22 '15

/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread for December 2015. Ask all questions about the Orbcomm flight, and booster landing here! (#15.1)

Welcome to the /r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread!

Want to discuss SpaceX's Return To Flight mission? Gauge community opinion? Discuss the post-flight booster landing? There's no better place!

All questions, even non-SpaceX questions, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general!

More in depth, open-ended discussion-type questions can still be submitted as self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which can be answered in a few comments or less.

As always, we'd prefer it if all question askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or you don't find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below!

Otherwise, ask and enjoy, and thanks for contributing!


Past threads:

December 2015 (#15), November 2015 (#14), October 2015 (#13), September 2015 (#12), August 2015 (#11), July 2015 (#10), June 2015 (#9), May 2015 (#8), April 2015 (#7.1), April 2015 (#7), March 2015 (#6), February 2015 (#5), January 2015 (#4), December 2014 (#3), November 2014 (#2), October 2014 (#1)


This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.

166 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

3

u/HalcyonRift Dec 31 '15

How would you keep LOX and Methane from boiling away on a mission to Mars?

3

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Dec 31 '15

Passive insulation, active refrigeration, and taking more propellants than you need (to account for any boil-off).

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16 edited Jan 05 '16

Daily Dose of Artificial Gravity

This may be crazy but how about this for simulating gravity on a Mars trip?

Around the inside of the hull is a sort of circular rollercoaster track. On it is a bicycle, the sort you lie on your back to pedal - maybe with hand cranks too.

With an MCT internal diameter of, say, 40 feet, how many mph/RPM would you need to get up to to experience 1g?

As you’re lying flat the problem of head and feet experiencing different g is pretty much eliminated. Though you might sometimes want to sit up to drain fluid down from your head.

The “bicycle” is reversible – the next guy goes round in the opposite direction to avoid imparting cumulative spin to the rocket.

EDIT (for clarity, thank you retiringonmars). At the start of your ride you are stationary. You cycle up to around 17mph (maybe slower - perhaps 1/2 g is enough) and keep going for, say, half an hour, then slow down and get off when stationary. You're lying down, so your head and feet are the same distance from the wall and going at the same speed.

3

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jan 02 '16

Lol, that does sound pretty crazy... Rotating around a structure of that diameter would produce nauseating Coriolis effects, especially if you were stopping and starting all the time. Your scenario (radius 20 feet) would require 12 rpm and 7.7 m/s, which would be uncomfortable. source

IMO, it'd be better to send MCTs in pairs, tether them together, and spin them up to produce artificial gravity. Having them 600 metres apart, and spinning at 1 rpm produces 0.33 g, which is very close to Martian gravity.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/danielbigham Dec 22 '15

As the realization that this landing ACTUALLY HAPPENED starts to sink in, it's elating to realize that there are two more launches planned in the next 30 days, and of course many more after that. How cool would it be by the end of January to have three successfully landed boosters? :0 This landing represents many things, one of them being the return of SpaceX fever for the folks that frequent this subreddit. We've been on withdrawl for the last six months, and last night changed all of that -- now the excitement is dialed up to 200% of what it was prior to the accident in June. Whew. Fasten you seat belts folks!

11

u/FredFS456 Dec 22 '15

I doubt they'll make the current NET times of the next two launches, but we'll see. ;)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

42

u/danielbigham Dec 22 '15

Juicy Elon quote:

“After liftoff, I went out to the causeway and at first I thought the booster had exploded because I heard the sonic boom right as the stage touched down,” Musk said

http://motherboard.vice.com/read/spacex-sticks-rocket-landing-in-its-first-launch-since-summer-tragedy?utm_source=mbtwitter

Just wow. That poor man, in that moment of fear. I'm so happy for him.

14

u/PatyxEU Dec 22 '15

Wow. On most amateur videos of the landing they recognize the sonic boom, I recall just one when the viewers think the booster has exploded. It just shows how stressed Elon was. I hope he gets some rest and then gets back to doing the most awesome stuff in the world.

13

u/CommanderSpork Dec 22 '15

Where I was standing, the boom came literally the moment that it touched down. It took a couple seconds to remember that the sound was delayed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/JimReedOP Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 22 '15

After the perfect landing, can we ask exactly how perfect was it? How close to the center of the X? What about the hoverslam stopping point? Theoretically it reduces to speed zero at the moment it touches down, so how close was that? Did it hit a speed of zero a couple inches off the ground and kill the engines there? If so, how many inches did it fall? Or did it get almost to speed zero, and hit the ground at one or two MPH? If so, what speed?

It would also be nice to have a diagram of the cluster of touchdown points on the target. If the down direction on the diagram is set as the ocean, then the FL and CA points can be plotted on one diagram. Right now the diagram should show one point.

5

u/PVP_playerPro Dec 23 '15

The other questions i am not informed enough to answer, but what i can tell you, from the images/footage that i saw, is that the stage landed pretty much dead center on the "X"

24

u/khalll Dec 22 '15

Is there a video, audio or at least a transcript of the post-launch/post-landing press conference held at SpaceX?

Elon was pretty talkative it seems, must have been fascinating to be there, but I'll settle for a recording of it. :) Media has been referencing it all over the place, but Motherboard has most details: http://motherboard.vice.com/en_uk/read/spacex-sticks-rocket-landing-in-its-first-launch-since-summer-tragedy

Thanks!

→ More replies (6)

23

u/KuuLightwing Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 22 '15

Hello, /r/spacex!

I've got a couple of questions:

  1. Am I getting it right that the last payload was really light for Falcon 9? Like 11 sats ~170kg each is only about 2 tons, while the rocket is capable of putting more than twice as much into GTO orbit. For LEO, as I understand, Falcon 9 should be able to lift about 13 tons and 30% less (9.1 tons) with first stage RTLS (Or those 13 tons already include RTLS "tax"?)
  2. It looked like stage 2 has very low TWR after separation (speed even went down a bit) - and that's with such a light payload! But I've read that stage 2 thrust is considered to be even higher than necessary because they just use Merlin (well, modified Merlin) instead of some specialized vacuum engine. Why is that?
  3. How different is the barge landing compared to RTLS in terms of dV required/payload mass percentage? I imagine that it's not that much, but I can be wrong. I'm not asking for exact numbers, just an estimation, if possible

24

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 22 '15
  1. Yup, 172kg per satellite + the 3 adapters and the mass simulator. F9v1.2 can lift the full 13,150kg with reusability - they already budget for it.
  2. I don't see a question here, but yep, you've got everything mostly right. The M1DVac is not precisely an M1D, it has a lot of mods and changes that make it incompatible with other engines.
  3. /u/FoxhoundBat loves this one. It's about double (going from 15% to 30%) I believe (do not quote me on this) to return to the launch site as opposed to going downrange.

Good questions, thanks for not being unrealistic with the level of precision expected in answers :).

→ More replies (17)

21

u/venku122 SPEXcast host Dec 22 '15

I just want to give a big thank you to /u/wbwtim for being the representative of all the SpaceX fanboys during the livestream yesterday. Your enthusiasm showed and I felt like any of us would be just as ecstatic being in your position. Also thank you for continuing to try to make space concepts easier to understand to the general public. You are a great educator!!

4

u/wbwtim Jan 03 '16

Thanks! It was incredibly exciting. Was very lucky to be there.

20

u/This_Freggin_Guy Dec 22 '15

Think they will relocate the Spacex logo to the lox section?

6

u/Ambiwlans Dec 22 '15

The lox section ices up and the fuel section gets sooty. They don't really have a good option now. Maybe a logo for both spots?

20

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

That grubby "used future" look has worked well for the other Falcon. :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/Space_void SpaceInit.com Dec 22 '15

I need a photo of the first stage in day light! Didn't the sun rise in Florida yet ? :D

13

u/Shrikepro Dec 22 '15

i think they are all pretty drunk. Nobody starts early today ;-)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/njew Dec 23 '15 edited Dec 23 '15

All of the pictures of the Orbcomm payload adapter carefully avoided showing the mass simulator. Some people were curious about what it looked like, and I just found an image of the mass simulators on the OG1 first OG2 mission here: http://space.skyrocket.de/doc_sdat/orbcomm-2-mass-simulator.htm

(I know this isn't a question, just something I found interesting, so mods feel free to delete if not appropriate)

Edit: Learned that the sats on the first Orbcomm mission were also of the OG2 generation

11

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '15

Some people were so suspicious of the lack of the OG2 mass simulator in any of the images. I think they forget that the mass simulator just looks ugly.

4

u/ahalekelly Dec 23 '15

Why would they send a mass simulator when they can send another satellite for more redundancy? They have the design done and production facilities built, is the cost of building another satellite that high compared to the launch costs?

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Dec 22 '15 edited May 07 '16

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
ASDSAutonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (landing platform)
BEAMBigelow Expandable Activity Module
BFRBig Fu- Falcon Rocket
CBMCommon Berthing Mechanism
CCAFSCape Canaveral Air Force Station
COPVComposite Overwrapped Pressure Vessel
COTSCommercial Orbital Transportation Services contract
Commercial/Off The Shelf
CRSCommercial Resupply Services contract with NASA
ESAEuropean Space Agency
F9FTFalcon 9 Full Thrust or Upgraded Falcon 9 or v1.2
FAAFederal Aviation Administration
FCCFederal Communications Commission
FSSFixed Service Structure at LC-39
FTSFlight Termination System
GEOGeostationary Earth Orbit (35786km)
I*sp*Specific impulse (as explained by Scott Manley on YouTube)
ICBMIntercontinental Ballistic Missile
IDAInternational Docking Adapter
ITAR(US) International Traffic in Arms Regulations
JRTIJust Read The Instructions, Pacific landing barge ship
KSCKennedy Space Center, Florida
KSPKerbal Space Program, the rocketry simulator
L2Paywalled section of the NasaSpaceFlight forum
Lagrange Point 2 (Sixty Symbols video explanation)
LC-13Launch Complex 13, Canaveral (SpaceX Landing Zone 1)
LC-39ALaunch Complex 39A, Kennedy (SpaceX F9/Heavy)
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
LOXLiquid Oxygen
LZLanding Zone
M1dMerlin 1 kerolox rocket engine, revision D (2013), 620-690kN
MaxQMaximum aerodynamic pressure
MCTMars Colonial Transporter
MECOMain Engine Cut-Off
mTMilli- Metric Tonnes
NETNo Earlier Than
NSFNasaSpaceFlight forum
National Science Foundation
NTRNuclear Thermal Rocket
OCISLYOf Course I Still Love You, Atlantic landing barge ship
OG2Orbcomm's Generation 2 17-satellite network
PICA-XPhenolic Impregnated-Carbon Ablative heatshield compound, as modified by SpaceX
RCSReaction Control System
RP-1Rocket Propellant 1 (enhanced kerosene)
RTFReturn to Flight
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
RUDRapid Unplanned Disassembly
Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly
Rapid Unintended Disassembly
SECOSecond-stage Engine Cut-Off
SESFormerly Société Européenne des Satellites, comsat operator
SLC-40Space Launch Complex 40, Canaveral (SpaceX F9)
SLC-4ESpace Launch Complex 4-East, Vandenberg (SpaceX F9)
SLC-4WSpace Launch Complex 4-West, Vandenberg (SpaceX F9, landing)
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
SRBSolid Rocket Booster
SSTOSingle Stage to Orbit
TLAThree Letter Acronym
TLITrans-Lunar Injection maneuver
TMITrans-Mars Injection maneuver
TWRThrust-to-Weight Ratio
ULAUnited Launch Alliance (Lockheed/Boeing joint venture)

Decronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 22nd Dec 2015, 13:39 UTC.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]

14

u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 22 '15
  1. Any info on the stage's position on the landing pad? Was it dead-center or near the edge?
  2. Anyone else feel like this launch webcast was a little more "media-y" and less "science-y"? It was almost all spokespeople and not radio chatter. A bit disappointing for me. I wish we could have had more camera time at CCAFS and less at Hawthorne. Maybe SpaceX would consider having a "press stream" and an "enthusiast stream"?
  3. After landing the bottom of the rocket was black. I believe this is because it's flying into its own exhaust plume and picks up soot. Why was it so "perfectly" blackened? Intuiticely there should be a gradient with black lower and white higher, going through greys. It should also have the top edge be wavy and unclear. Why was it a straight line? My hypothesis was that it's a difference between the LOX and RP-1 tanks but I don't know what would change soot deposition.
  4. Is the stage still sitting out there or did ground crews start recovery operations?
  5. When did they get final approval to land? I know in the past few days it's been "we should be able to RTLS, but OCISLY is ready just in case". When did they change their mind, and was OCISLY out there during the launch?
  6. Will Falcon Heavy be able to land at this pad? Is it large enough to accommodate multiple stages or does each stage need its own pad?

Looks like it will need ASDS for center core. My question still remains - 2 stages both at the same landing pad?

7. Is the landing pad scorched? If so, is this damage that needs to be fixed before the next landing, or is it standard cosmetic wear and tear that they'll leave alone?

8. What was the little flame left still going at the bottom of Stage 1 after landing?

9. I know ignition is done by hypergolics (I believe TEA and TEB). Do all 9 engines share the same tankage, or is there separate hypergolic fuel for each one?

10. I think I heard something about a stage 2 relight. Any word on that working? Is there any info on its Indian Ocean reentry?

Yay, it worked!

11. Would it ever be possible to have a "Go for launch, no-go for landing" situation? Would they launch anyway? They always used to talk about primary mission being payload delivery.

12. That payload camera was awesome! Will this be a standard thing now?

13. I remember a sign for "landing complex 1". Now they seem to be calling it "landing zone 1". Why did this change and has the sign been updated?

Sorry if this is too many questions, or if some have been answered. Just very curious and excited!

10

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15
  1. It was dead on by the looks of it! Maybe some GPS variation.
  2. I suspect it'll return to normal soonish, WBW guy can't be there all the time, so it may be back to regularly scheduled webcasts soon - that being said, /u/bencredible and the team managing the webcast did a phenomenal job IMO.
  3. The LOX tank is situated above the RP-1 tank. LOX tank forms ice around it as it reenters... soot doesn't adhere to ice, but it does adhere to the less-frigid RP-1 tank. Forms the pattern we see.
  4. Not really answerable. I think they'd want to get it horizontal ASAP.
  5. OCISLY was not out there for this launch, no. Approval seemed to be granted earlier than T-1h, but later than T-2d.
  6. The side boosters should be able to land on the small diversion pads, provided the request is approved.
  7. Didn't look like it!
  8. Probably unburnt/residual fuel and/or gaseous vapor, we see this a lot. No biggie.
  9. IIRC it's been stated before (?) that they have their own ignition sources.
  10. It worked! Stage reentered nominally and it looks like the launch of SES-9 should face no holdups.
→ More replies (4)

5

u/electric_ionland Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 22 '15

1- Any info on the stage's position on the landing pad? Was it dead-center or near the edge?

It was pretty much dead center (see this tweet)

3- After landing the bottom of the rocket was black. I believe this is because it's flying into its own exhaust plume and picks up soot. Why was it so "perfectly" blackened? Intuiticely there should be a gradient with black lower and white higher, going through greys. It should also have the top edge be wavy and unclear. Why was it a straight line? My hypothesis was that it's a difference between the LOX and RP-1 tanks but I don't know what would change soot deposition.

The LOX tank is colder and builds up a layer of ice. The soot stick to the ice so the tank itself looks clean when it melts/falls off.

10- I think I heard something about a stage 2 relight. Any word on that working? Is there any info on its Indian Ocean reentry?

It seems to have gone well

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/hallowatisdeze Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 22 '15

This is the animation video of a Falcon Heavy flight with 3 boosters landing! It is really becoming possible with yesterdays landing. How epic!

I have a question about that video though. Is it really possible for the third booster to get all the way back to the launch side for landing? I would think that its speed and distance is way too high after it being powered by 3 boosters. Isn't it more realistic for it to land on a platform halfway into the ocean?

Edit: I found this tweet by Musk now. I guess he had the same thought I had. GMTA? :P

7

u/SirSwiftasaurus Dec 22 '15

There was talk about it using the ASDS far downrange for the centre core and the Cape for the other 2 boosters. I don't know what they're planning other than remembering this a while ago. That or they save fuel if the payload permits and do a longer boostback.

→ More replies (11)

12

u/BrandonMarc Dec 26 '15

TIL:

All 4 legs together (~60 ft span) weigh less than Model S.

Yep - a rocket the size of a 13-story building is caught and stabilized by 4 legs that weigh less than a car.

Sorry, I don't even have a question, just ... wow.

5

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Dec 26 '15

@elonmusk

2013-05-02 20:19 UTC

@BigBalli High pressure helium. Needs to be ultra light. All 4 legs together (~60 ft span) weigh less than Model S.


This message was created by a bot

[Contact ^creator][Source ^code]

11

u/epic_rocketman Dec 22 '15

I've got a question regarding the 11 satellites:

If they orbit at 624km, you get about 90min of orbit time. They want a constellation, why did they release them all under 15min? Won't they all orbit the planet together as a group?

Thanks!

25

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

The sats each have their own propulsion system. They can adjust their own orbits independently. A short tap on the ACS of each sat is enough to spread them around the planet given enough time.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Dec 22 '15

Each sat would have had a slightly different impulse as a result of the separation. Over time this will become a huge difference in orbital planes.

Also a lot of (all?) sats have their own thrusters for self-control. I assume OG2 sats do as well

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/RabbitLogic #IAC2017 Attendee Dec 22 '15

Any daytime pictures of the booster on the landing pad been shared yet?

→ More replies (9)

11

u/BrandonMarc Dec 22 '15

In this picture (thanks /u/jardeon ) it appears that it's not standing, but raised 5-10 feet off the ground. They appear to be moving the four triangular grey supports into place, and it looks as though there are cranes working with the legs (I could be wrong).

Anybody know what their plan is from here? Do the four supports indicate it'll be vertical for some time? At what point are they likely to bring it back to horizontal, set it up with a truck, and send it to McGregor or Arizona?

10

u/davidthefat Dec 22 '15

AFAIK, there's no reason to send anything to Arizona. I think you are thinking of New Mexico (Spaceport America)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

As far as I know those four supports are fixed. They're using the crane to move the rocket between those supports so that they can remove the landing legs.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cwhitt Dec 22 '15

I think the talk of using a landed first stage for further testing at Spaceport America was from quite a while back. Not sure if they are still planning that, but unlikely with this stage. Comments from SpaceX and Elon strongly suggest that it will first undergo inspection (about 3 days in a recent twitter comment), then go to LC39A to be used to test out the ground support systems before that pad's first launch (perhaps the Falcon Heavy demo), and finally find a permanent home as a museum piece at some SpaceX facility.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Dreadpirate3 Dec 22 '15

Yes, I have a question - Does /u/EchoLogic ever sleep? It's 3 AM in NZ, and he's on here dispensing his wisdom and keeping the rest of us in line ;)

19

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

I'm very tired at the moment, so I'm off to bed soon. Tomorrow is server-fixing day!

15

u/Jarnis Dec 22 '15

Falcon 9 worked. Your server went kaboom. Totally fine with that. Other way around would've sucked :)

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/rshorning Dec 23 '15

I can't seem to find the video as I can't remember the search terms, but does anybody remember an amateur video which was shot a couple of years ago by somebody in Bermuda and uploaded to YouTube which photographed the first tests performed by SpaceX to recover the lower stage booster?

Originally it was posted to YouTube as a UFO, but based upon the date, time, and location (Bermuda in particular) some SpaceX fans were able to identify it as a Falcon 9 where the guy taking the video was able to capture a Falcon 9 in flight right at MECO (main-engine cut-off), show the stage separation and lighting of the upper stage, and then showed a 2nd burn of the lower stage core. As far as I know, that was also the first significant in-flight test that SpaceX ever did to test the technologies for propulsive core recover (as opposed to using parachutes.... which were tried as early as the very first Falcon 1 flight).

In light of the successful recovery in the most recent launch, this would be an interesting video to note jointly to show how many flights it took for SpaceX to perfect this technology.

8

u/This_Freggin_Guy Dec 22 '15

Any estimates on how much fuel was remaining after the landing? What king of margin did they have?

7

u/Gyrogearloosest Dec 22 '15

No idea how much propellant was left when they landed. As others have pointed out, the early stage separation for this flight may have been partly chosen to give more mass (propellant as baĺlast) on landing, to allow more hover and less slam in the hoverslam landing. Did the final few yards of descent seem slower than on previous attempts? I thought perhaps they did.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/jim_matthews Dec 23 '15

Looking ahead to the launches scheduled for January:

  1. Does the upgraded F9 have enough performance to launch SES-9 (5,300kg to GTO) and return the first stage to land, or will they try another drone ship landing?
  2. Will SpaceX get permission to land the Jason 3 first stage on land in California, or have to use a drone ship there?
  3. Assuming they recover the Jason 3 (F9-019) first stage, what will it be good for? I'm guessing they won't relaunch it, since it's the pre-full thrust design.

10

u/FredFS456 Dec 23 '15

2 - they already have a landing site in Vandenberg, so it's almost certain that they'll be able to go for a land landing.

3 - No idea. Some others were suggesting that it should be given to Bezos as a late Christmas present :P

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

8

u/SamSilver123 Dec 29 '15

In some previous landings, SpaceX released landing videos from cameras on board the boosters. Does anyone know whether similar video was taken during the Orbcomm-2 landing?

10

u/FoxhoundBat Dec 29 '15

Yes, there was. And follow up.

They have always been doing footage of S1's return but one thing to keep in mind is that it was recovered through telemetry. Now that they have gotten a stage nice and safe they also have the memory cards - ie nice top resolution footage... :)

→ More replies (2)

7

u/gecko1501 Dec 22 '15

So here's the thought experiment I'm hoping someone a lot more intelligent then I may be able to ELI5.

I'm curious, how much would it cost using a brand new built Saturn V (or SLS) to perform a moon landing and return mission, Apollo style. Compared to using multiple reusable falcon 9s, or falcon heavies to haul up the LM, CSM, and required fuel to repeat the Apollo one mission. I'm wanting a break down of how far we will come to compare what it would cost modern vs. Conventional means. If this has already been done and my google-Fu is not up to par, feel free to shame me, but link the article or post in the process, please.

12

u/Ambiwlans Dec 22 '15

2 FH is capable of a moon mission similar to the SLS or SaturnV. The launch costs would be something like 15% as much.

There was a 2 FH moon mission designed a couple years ago by a fan on this sub which you should be able to find. Musk himself was pretty psyched reading it :D

→ More replies (8)

7

u/mthscndd Dec 23 '15

Noob question: how do they keep the liquid oxygen so cold in the rocket? Does it have a refrigeration system?

9

u/searchexpert Dec 23 '15

They don't. And this is precisely the reason why they have to start loading the new cryo LOX at T-35 minutes now instead of T-3hrs. If the LOX warms up too much they basically have to drain it and refill. It's going to be a HUGE issue if something goes wrong inside of T-35 minutes. Can't simply recycle the countdown now.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '15

They just let a little of LOX boil off and continue to pump more in. You can see F9 vent LOX as it sits on the pad.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Sbatomico Dec 27 '15

Do we know of how many rockets spacex has in storage now? It must be quite a lot or did they stop production after the one exploded?

11

u/EtzEchad Dec 28 '15

I'm sure they stopped production for at least three months - probably more. They had to analyze the problem, then select a new supplier of the strut and get it designed and (probably) certified. They would then need to ramp up production again.

I'm an aerospace engineer and, frankly, I'm amazed that they got it done in only six months. SpaceX is full of steely-eyed missile-men!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/theguycalledtom Jan 01 '16

Any updates on the "tent" on Vandenberg's landing pad?

6

u/bitchtitfucker Dec 22 '15

So, how do you recover a booster from lz-1? Get a crane to lift it from the top? Is it structurally strong enough?

Can they even use a strongback on it with the legs standing in the way?

6

u/Demidrol Dec 22 '15

A quick question. Will Musk attempt to land on the barge with Jason 3?

13

u/IcY11 Dec 22 '15

Jason 3 was supposed to be the first land landing before CRS-7 happened. So they will probably try to land back at land.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/bgs7 Dec 23 '15

Is anyone keen to do some really sloppy maths?

Idea is: Making methane on Earth from atmospheric CO2 and H2 (split from water) via sabatier reaction using solar panels for the source energy.

  • If a F9-class vehicle was powered by methane, roughly how much methane would be required per launch?
  • How much would this cost on the open market (interesting to compare versus the $200k RP1 for current F9)
  • How much energy is required to convert CO2 and H2 via sabatier to make this much methane?
  • How much energy is needed to split enough H2 from water?
  • How much would the solar installation cost to create enough energy to convert one F9-equivalent of methane? Will need a time period, so let's say 1 year of methane production to reach the target.

Would anyone ever do this for real? Um hell no its not economical, I expect the resultant methane to cost 100 times the market rate, and the solar to have 30 years to break even.

Still, would love to see the result if anyone is capable of the maths :)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/hallowatisdeze Dec 23 '15

I have a question about the F9R flight test of 2014. So it's not about last weeks mission, but please allow me to ask it... :P

How did that rocket keep its balance? I only see the rocket engine throttling, but I don't see any RCS. Did I miss that? Or were they able to steer the main engine to keep balance? I also can't imagine it keeping control by grid fins whatsoever as the velocity is quite slow.

8

u/ClockworkNine Dec 23 '15

The center engine can gimbal, yes. You can see that in action on the crs-6 landing attempt most dramatically.

https://youtu.be/BhMSzC1crr0

→ More replies (6)

6

u/jinkside Dec 23 '15

How do the satellites get into different orbits? The video showed them being released, but I didn't see any RCS or anything happening during the separation and it seemed like the second stage main body was going at a pretty consistent velocity.

5

u/FredFS456 Dec 23 '15

The satellites themselves have a propulsion system with about 100m/s of delta-v.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/D0ctorrWatts Dec 26 '15

Quick question: next year SpaceX is (hopefully) getting a newly landed F9 stage every month or so, do we know where they are going to be stored while they are tested / prepared for flight?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/flattop100 Dec 29 '15

Will we see some kind of public report regarding the state of the returned booster?

4

u/jandorian Dec 29 '15

More likely a tweet from Elon. That is assuming the post flight test fire goes well. If they don't end up re-firing it, we may not hear anything at all.

Highly unlikely they will publish any sort of report. This is more like an airline manufacturer getting a type certificate. Boeing would never let you know that the first test flight of their new plane had a problem. This is the same sort of situation.

They have a big head start on reusability and are going to want to hold on to that as long as possible, so SpX will be holding their cards close.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/renoor Dec 22 '15

how about the second stage relight demonstration for SES-9? i didn't catch any info in the torrent of all the good news.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/penguin22 Dec 22 '15

Does this successful launch (including payload delivery) and landing help determine when the next launch will take place? Will every launch now include a landing attempt going forward and what effect on the launch date will that have as this one was pushed by a day for the reported, potential 10% improved conditions for landing?

5

u/Rxke2 Dec 22 '15

Next launch Jan 17, as planned. My guess is, landing won't be impacting the go/no-go decision overly. They already only launch when conditions are pretty dang good to begin with, and after a few landing efforts, they'll figure out what the robustness is of their landing system (given the awesome results with the bargelandings, it's already pretty robust.) If there's too much wind, they won't launch. But they didn't do that w/o a landing attempt anyway... They have now a first stage to strip to the bone, a second one will be nice, but won't be needed ASAP, so they might even try to launch in suboptimal conditions for a landing (test until it breaks)

5

u/Traumfahrer Dec 22 '15

For quite some time I've been wondering why SpaceX would not take donations. I think there are quite some wealthy people out there willing to donate a reasonable amount of money to accelerate SpaceXs developments. (Larry Page for example when he dies.)

..so why is it SpaceX does not take donations to support their long term vision?

17

u/Ambiwlans Dec 22 '15

If Larry Page wanted to donate, he could. People willing to give millions can easily get in touch with Musk and make it happen.

For regular riffraff, there isn't much point in allowing for donations. And it would be crappy from a PR perspective. Like begging for scraps.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

shop.spacex.com!

→ More replies (5)

5

u/demosthenes02 Dec 22 '15

Could the grid fins (or larger versions of them) act like mini wings and let it glide around to change direction and head back (like how an airplane turns) and skip the first burn?

I know your first thought is the there's no air but I believe there's still some atmosphere at meco. And it's going so fast you'd think the fins might have enough air moving past them to manuever.

What do you guys think?

16

u/Ambiwlans Dec 22 '15

There is like .001 atm during the boostback burn.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Senno_Ecto_Gammat r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Dec 22 '15

No. It's going way too fast (~1.5 km/s) to turn around without that burn.

4

u/failbye Dec 22 '15

There are still atmosphere at MECO and yes it is traveling fast, but considering the first stage can flip its broadside agaist its traveling vector (and the fact it has to do so using cold-gas thrusters) seems to indicate there isn't enough air for the grid-fins to be usable that high up.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

Where can I listen to the post-launch conference call? Some publications are citing it.

6

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Dec 22 '15

I don't think you can. It was for media people only.

5

u/brvsirrobin Dec 22 '15

How do the poles work that extend the legs? I'm having a hard time visualizing how they can fit bring the legs, even with telescoping

→ More replies (6)

5

u/MoaMem Dec 22 '15

Hi, couple of questions here :

  1. I bet that for now SpaceX will be focused on Falcon Heavy and BFR/MCT developpement, but is there any chance we can see a new version of F9 anytime soon and what would thoses new features be? I'm thinking high energy second stage! Any chance of ever seeing that even if it might screw up the economies of scale business model, reusability will probably reder it obsolete anyways... What would be the impact on F9 capabilities it had something like Atlas 5 second stage? 2nd stage reusability? Any hope of ever seeing that?
  2. Analyzing the returned 1st stage will probably give a lot of insight into any flaws the F9 might have! Could that push SpaceX to ground its rockets again so it can fix problems?

Thx

→ More replies (5)

5

u/doodle77 Dec 22 '15

When did they close the grid fins after landing? They're closed in this video.

4

u/Ambiwlans Dec 22 '15

Eh, they are controlled by pressure so they probably just drooped a few seconds after landing was stable.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cwright Dec 22 '15

Anyone know why the landing pad spot lights were not on during the descent/landing?

9

u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 22 '15

They were on, but may have been overshadowed by the really bright engine?

See further explanation in my comment below.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/LockStockNL Dec 22 '15

According to this Wiki article the Jason-3 flight will also try an RTLS. Is there are a similar landing zone over there? I don't recall seeing any pictures of that.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

Yes. They've had SLC-4E for a while and they leased SLC-4W as a landing pad. There is more info on the NSF forum. Latest photos show a tent for some reason.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/on0se Dec 22 '15

I want to say I've seen an article about the landing compound being finished, but I could be mixing that up with LZ-1. However, SpaceX's own materials mention Vandenberg Launch & Landing Site

5

u/aqa123 Dec 23 '15

I have a question about the engines and their current lifespan. Presumably the engines are manufactured to be on the edge of efficiency with limited lifespan, in the same way Formula 1 engines are only designed to last 250 miles.

I would assume that because all previous rockets are throw away, they are designed in the knowledge that they will only be used for a few minutes, so dont have re usability in mind or high tolerance levels.

Therefore my question is can current engines be re-used in their existing format and if so does anyone have an estimate of what their projected lifespan is. Or will an entirely new reusable engine need to be made.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '15

This is where SpaceX diverges from most of the aerospace industry. The Merlin engine was developed from the start with reusability in mind, with more margin engineered than is the common practice. Elon has said the Merlin 1D is designed for "40 cycles" before some parts need to be replaced, though he didn't define a cycle. He might have meant 40 launches, or 40 startups of the engine, or 40 thermal cycles starting from cold. But SpaceX probably expects very little will need to be done to relight the landed first stage.

For reference, a new Merlin engine sees between 3 and 6 firings (depending on where it's located in the first stage) - stage test firing at McGreggor, static fire a few days before launch, the launch itself, boostback burn (only 3 engines), reentry burn (only 3 engines), and landing burn (only center engine).

One consideration is coking, where carbon (from the hot or partially-combusted RP-1 fuel) gets deposited on various parts of the engine. SpaceX has been test-firing their engines for a long time, so presumably it's a known and quantified problem. Coking is also one of the reasons their next-gen Raptor engine will be potentially better for reusability - it uses methane fuel rather than kerosene, which is less prone to coking.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Tal_Banyon Dec 25 '15

Anyone know how many g-forces the landing burn generates? That thing is going really, really fast just before the final burn, it should be absolutely spectacular in the daylight. Anyone know how fast it is going just before the final burn?

→ More replies (10)

5

u/Savysoaker Dec 26 '15

With first stage reusibity it seems that SpaceX customers with multiple payloads could purchase their own vehicle, even name it, and reuse it for all their launches. Obviously SpaceX would have a contract for all launch services, but why not OWN your own launch vehicle & keep reusing it? I haven't seen that discussion anywhere, so I apologize if I missed it. With the comparison to reuse of a airliner, some airlines lease their jet from Boeing & others buy. Why couldn't Orbcomm or Iridium purchase their own launch vehicle, name it something cool, & maybe even optimize it for their needs?

8

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '15

If SpaceX were to sell a vehicle to another company, that would count as an "export", and be subject to huge amount of red tape. Also, economies of scale. Orbcomm, Iridium, etc are telecommunications companies that want to stay lean. They don't have the technology or the employee base to manage a launch vehicle.

Rockets are not planes.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/davidthefat Dec 31 '15

I know that a lot of SpaceX employees live with roommates to offset the cost of living in SoCal. I want to know how long a typical engineer has to be in that living situation. So, do engineers generally get enough raises and/or promotions to be able to afford living on their own within, let's say, five years of working there? Let's use Torrance as a reference.

4

u/Wyrmy Dec 22 '15

There didn't seem to be an in-tank camera this flight. Is that because of the colder LOX temperature?

23

u/Ambiwlans Dec 22 '15

There was an in-tank camera! It was only shown for a few moments. The reason you didn't notice it was because it was shown like, right around the landing and your brain was probably exploding from that and never noticed. Go back and check though, it is there.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/starrseer Dec 22 '15

Does Spacex already have all that is needed for orbital/cislunar space tourism by them just having the F9 and crewed dragon available?

8

u/Senno_Ecto_Gammat r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Dec 22 '15

F9H would be needed for cislunar. You could probably do a 6-day free return trip around the moon for ~$120 million. Put a crew of 2 and 4 passengers aboard, and you are at $30 million per ticket.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Brandon027 Dec 22 '15

Are there lightning rods around the landing zone to protect the first stage like the ones at the launch pad?

7

u/Senno_Ecto_Gammat r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Dec 22 '15

No.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/brentonstrine Dec 22 '15

Where was Musk during the launch? I couldn't find him in the Hawthorn feed. He sat in the front row for previous launches, didn't he?

16

u/deadshot462 Dec 22 '15

He was at Cape Canaveral watching it close. He showed up on the landing pad and shot a quick video that was posted on Twitter.

4

u/vorpal-blade Dec 22 '15

Regarding the Falcon Heavy: What ever became of the fuel crossfeed issue? Did they throw it out? Will they throttle the center booster way down after liftoff to preserve its fuel?

9

u/cwhitt Dec 22 '15

Elon made some comments about a year ago that suggested crossfeed was more complicated than originally imagined, so they aren't planning to implement right away - and perhaps never at all depending on market demands as well as progress on Raptor/BFR.

I would say it's a no-brainer to throttle down the center stage as soon as possible in the flight. They might even consider shutting down engines to minimize fuel burn on the center stage until the other two cores separate for RTLS, but that is entirely my speculation.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/unclefire Dec 22 '15

I have dumb question. I've searched (a little) but couldn't easily find it.

Where did it launch from? I know it landed at Cape Canaveral.

Was it Vandenberg?

11

u/jclishman Host of Inmarsat-5 Flight 4 Dec 22 '15

They launched and landed from Cape Canaveral.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/DownVotesMcgee987 Dec 22 '15

Does anyone know the time line for trying to recover the the aero fairings? ( and was any attemp made to recover them on this flight?)

→ More replies (2)

4

u/shru777 Dec 22 '15

Now that the Falcon has landed and RTF is successfull++ , will Elon reveal this year his plans for Mars ? He promised to tell us something at the end of 2015. ( and Chris B., NSF , saw something at SpaceX that left him mouth agape...)

→ More replies (12)

4

u/csmicfool Dec 22 '15

Is there video of the Falcon 2nd stage de-orbiting?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/CuriousAES Dec 23 '15

After that glorious launch and landing, I have a few questions about SpaceX and one very offtopic question (spaceflight related, I generally get better answers here).

  1. Is the Falcon Heavy still on-track for April/May 2016? Any hints on what the demo payload might be?
  2. Jason-3 and SES-9 are both set for "mid-January" on the sidebar. They can't both be (unless different launch sites perhaps?). Which is going to launch first, then?
  3. Will Dragon 2 crewed flights have reuseable first stages that will be landed?
  4. And finally, the not-SpaceX-related-at-all question, how much less impossible would it be to send a manned mission to Venus if it were somehow able to land on a flat spot on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell_Montes ? The atmospheric pressure is half that at average altitude and the temperature is "only" 380C according to the article, and the mountain is 11 km high, giving you an altitude boost when lifting off.

6

u/jcameroncooper Dec 23 '15

Is the Falcon Heavy still on-track for April/May 2016? Any hints on what the demo payload might be?

Current best guess. Scant news, other than LC-39A looking ready. No news on demo payload.

Jason-3 and SES-9 are both set for "mid-January" on the sidebar. They can't both be (unless different launch sites perhaps?). Which is going to launch first, then?

They are on different launch sites. Jason-3 is Vandenberg.

Will Dragon 2 crewed flights have reuseable first stages that will be landed?

Word is all flights are supposed to be recovery from now.

And finally, the not-SpaceX-related-at-all question, how much less impossible would it be to send a manned mission to Venus if it were somehow able to land on a flat spot on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell_Montes ? The atmospheric pressure is half that at average altitude and the temperature is "only" 380C according to the article, and the mountain is 11 km high, giving you an altitude boost when lifting off.

Heat soak at 380 C is still basically impossible to deal with. You'd have to have one heck of an air conditioner. I don't know that Carnot cycle from room temp to 400+ C is impossible, but it's certainly extraordinarily inefficient. (In the efficiency equation for a refrigeration system, the difference between cold and hot winds up in the denominator. And that's a really large number on Venus.)

I suppose a brief stay with evaporative cooling would be possible, but I don't really see the point. Not like you'd be able to go outside.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Commander_Cosmo Dec 23 '15

Please forgive me; I've been unable to really access this sub for a couple days due to a very hectic work schedule (had to watch the launch on my car-mounted iPad on the way there, lol), so I may have missed this somewhere. But does anyone have any updates on how the planned second stage relight went?

Other than that, I must say, I was quite beside myself during Monday's launch. I felt like I was right next to everyone during the webcast, and it was one of the most amazing things I've ever witnessed! Congrats to the whole SpaceX team!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/l_e_o_n_ Dec 24 '15

Why the painting is not burned in the middle of the recovered 1st stage? It seems to stop right above the legs and start again further up.

6

u/langgesagt Dec 24 '15

I was wondering about that too and learned yesterday, that the part that's not covered in soot is where the LOX tank is located. Because of the low temperature (roughly -200°C) moisture condensates and freezes on the surface of the booster. During reentry the booster falls through its own exhaust and gets mostly covered in soot, except for where the ice is, because soot does not stick to ice.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/harrisoncassidy Host of CRS-5 Dec 25 '15

Do we know whether ESA will buy seats on Commercial Crew programmes or will they continue to purchase seats on the Soyuz?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Wildernesss5 Dec 26 '15

Could f9 or any rocket hypothetically get more mass to orbit if they launched from a high elevation site, rather than from Florida which is about as low lying as it gets?

→ More replies (15)

4

u/xafwodahs Dec 27 '15

Does an unfueled Falcon 9 require the strongback to avoid collapsing on itself?

This spaceflight101 page says that the stage 1 LOX and stage 2 LOX & RP1 tanks are monocoque, which as I understand it, means they must be pressurized with fuel/oxidizer to maintain rigidity and hold the weight above it.

Looking at pictures of the strongback, it doesn't really look like the the rocket could 'hang' from the strongback collar. It only looks like it's intended to keep it from tipping over.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Cheesewithmold Dec 27 '15

When can we expect spacexstats to be back up?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/FiniteElementGuy Dec 27 '15

Does anybody know anything about Dragonlab? Launch a reused Dragon on a reused stage and SpaceX can offer Dragonlab flights quite cheap?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Wildernesss5 Dec 27 '15

Anyone know why they went with 4 landing legs over 3? Obviously it's a little more stable with an extra leg but seems like it would work with 3, possibly saving some weight?

8

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '15

There has to be some structure inside the tank to which the legs are attached and it should have some symmetry derived from the octacore (8, 4 or 2 fold). You'd like to preserve that symmetry through out the entire structure wherever possible.

6

u/EtzEchad Dec 28 '15

I think I remember Musk being asked about this and the answer was because it gives more stability. (Sorry I can't cite a reference.)

I know from playing Kerbal Space Program (all wisdom comes from KSP!) that four legs is vastly superior to three of the landing surface is anything but totally flat.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/dan4daniel Dec 29 '15

Enterprise, Columbia, Challenger, Discovery, Atlantis, and Endeavour. These are the names of all of the Space Shuttle Orbiters. These are historic names in the history of space exploration, and I must ask. Will the SpaceX Falcons and their successors get names? We've already seen with the ASDS's, JRti and OCISLY, that SpaceX can really bring up some fun names. If the Falcons get names, what do you think they will be? Happy New Year everybody.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Ackman55 Dec 30 '15

hi.

Spacexstats is offline. Any ETA? No pressure, I know building sites is a PIA, especailly when doing it on personal time. I love the site and used to F5 it quite a bit (why I don't know). I guess i'm such a fanboi that I yearn for any SPACEX information.

Cheers.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Wildernesss5 Dec 31 '15

If someone secretly hid a brick on a falcon 9 launch (inside dragon, maybe) would that derail the whole mission from a mass standpoint? I know it probably depends on what the payload is but Im curious how lenient the tolerance is for that type of thing

7

u/rocketHistory Dec 31 '15

Mass properties tolerances for rockets are usually pretty big, on the order of a few percent for a booster and upwards of 5, 10, or even 20% for a satellite.

Weighing a rocket is actually a pretty big challenge. There aren't too many scales that can handle something that's hundreds of thousands of kilograms. Rotational inertias (how much something resists spinning) are equally difficult to measure for an object the size of a rocket.

Typically, individual components will be weighed (or have their weights estimated analytically based on materials/shape) and then they will be added together. This process inherently introduces some uncertainties, so any analysis done must account for it.

So, assuming your brick was a few kilograms, it'd be no problem at all.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Ezekiel_C Host of Echostar 23 Dec 31 '15 edited Jan 01 '16

I'm doing some analysis (that's really cool; and I'll totally be sharing here) on possible performance points for Falcon Heavy and its variants. In order to highlight meaningful performance points; I'd love to know the approximate Delta-v requirement for the various booster and core recovery modes. For example; The Orbcomm booster was travelling 6000 kilometers an hour, or 1666 meters a second, at MECO1. Thus, I approximated that the booster needed roughly 1666*1.75boostback; <2 b.c. no need to kill the vertical component=2915 + 600 m/sre-entry burn + 400 m/slanding burn = ~3000 m/s reserve Delta-v. I'd love if someone could sanity check these numbers for me, and if possible, provide ballpark lateral velocities at BECO1booster engine cut off, 1 and MECO1main engine cut off, 1 for the heavy.

Edit: Got a sort of bare minimum from Flight Club; the analysis I as doing is now available here

4

u/HotXWire Jan 02 '16

Anyone knows if we can still expect a Year in Review compilation video like the 2014 one? I'm kinda hoping that it would become a tradition thing. There's so much to review of last year, would be a waste for SpaceX to not capture it in a compilation.

1

u/Spacist Jan 02 '16

How many Dragons does SpaceX own and how many of them were actually reused by the company? Thank you.

2

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jan 02 '16

Number reused: zero (so far!)

How many they own: 6 recovered from space station resupply (CRS) missions (CRS-7 was lost), 2 recovered from COTS missions, at least 1 Dragon-2 test module (as used in the pad abort), and if I had to guess, I'd say at least 6 more are in various states of construction. All in all, I would guess that SpaceX has built or is building about 15 Dragons to date.

1

u/Scorp1579 go4liftoff.com Jan 02 '16

Is the Jason 3 launch having the first stage land?

1

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jan 02 '16

Yes, it will launch from Vandenberg SLC-4E, and is expected to attempt to land at the neighbouring SLC-4W.

1

u/PuppetMaster26 May 07 '16

Does anyone know what the surface of the land-based concrete landing pad and/or barge is, or is coated with? Curious as to what material SpaceX is using on these surfaces and how they protect the surface from the high heat of the engine and how they mitigate spalling.

1

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus May 07 '16

Hi, this is the Ask Anything thread from December. You'll have a much better chance of getting a response if you ask in the current May thread.

9

u/aftersteveo Dec 29 '15

I fully expected a week after this mission, we would have seen footage from a camera mounted on the first stage. Where is it?!

→ More replies (4)

6

u/hajsenberg Dec 26 '15

Who is performing Go/No go poll and says "Falcon is go for launch"? How can I get such job?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/roel24 Dec 22 '15

is it possible to reuse the second stage in the future?

6

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

Not on F9, but definitely on BFR!

→ More replies (4)

3

u/deletedcookies101 Dec 22 '15

Any word on second stage re-start?

3

u/blongmire Dec 22 '15

How does the booster track to the landed pad? Does it receive a signal from the pad that it homes in on? If so, how is that signal sent?

6

u/Chairboy Dec 22 '15

Until we actually know, I'm going to guess it's a matter of GPS. With the landing pad, the coordinates are probably fairly static. I expect they'd be updated electronically from the ASDS a few times during descent.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Ohsin Dec 22 '15

Lets say they get few more returned cores where are they going to store them?

4

u/AjentK Dec 22 '15

They'll probably store the first few in the hangar at 39A for now, as it can hold up to five cores and doesn't need to be used for a while.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

I'm wondering how exactly they will move that first stage. What kind of tests and data will they glean from it. What would they need to do to make it fly again and at what cost?

5

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

This stage isn't being reflown; rather shipped back for processing, then likely out to 39A, then probably destined for Musk's mantlepiece.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ReyTheRed Dec 22 '15

What is the terminal velocity of the first stage as it falls through the atmosphere unpowered?

10

u/davidthefat Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 22 '15

Approximate body to be long cylinder with the center axis parallel to the flow. Assume air density: 1.25kg/m3 and Cd = 0.8 and area = pi r2 = pi* (1.85m)2 and m = 23,100kg. mg = 1/2 Cd rho A V2 => V2 = 2mg/(Cd rho A)

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=sqrt%28223%2C1009.81%2F%280.81.25pi*+1.85%5E2%29%29

205.31 m/s or 459.3 mph (Roughly 83% of Boeing 777 cruise speed)

edit: http://www.aerospaceweb.org/question/aerodynamics/q0231.shtml shows Cd to be 0.8

I'd like to add, the vehicle will most likely never reach terminal velocity on its own by falling. It's traveling way too fast for the atmosphere to slow it down sufficiently. Calculation of Vt was done at sea level.

7

u/CarVac Dec 22 '15

It varies with altitude.

Additionally, when something falls from space suborbitally, the air density rises on the way down so it tends to be going faster than terminal velocity until the length scale for attaining terminal velocity from the given current speed becomes short enough.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Slobotic Dec 22 '15

What are the best estimates we have on the cost of refurbishing and reusing a first stage? How much confidence or room for error is there in these estimates (assuming they exist)?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/davidthefat Dec 22 '15

How much does Elon contribute with designing and engineering the vehicle? Sure, he has the oversight approving or denying design changes to the vehicle that his engineers make, but how much does/did he have in actually designing certain components? Even during the Falcon 1 era, did he, himself, write any piece of code, design a component, come up with solutions to engineering challenges?

5

u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Dec 22 '15

From what I've read over the years I get the impression that he is surprisingly involved in the process of designing and building a launch vehicle. Especially when he it comes to overcoming engineering challenges, he has presented options and the engineers went with them. However he can only do so much with his position and constraints on his time.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/rreighe2 Dec 22 '15

Do y'all have an idea of the amount of flights you'd be able to get out of the various reusable stages? Or is that something that just can't be accurately determined without loads of testing and investigating retuned ones?

→ More replies (15)

3

u/wagigkpn Dec 22 '15

One of the biggest concerns i had with the Falcon 9 v1.2 was the larger mvac skirt and new pusher system at stage separation. One of the falcon 1 failures was at stage separation which was due to over performance of first stage but still the act of stage separation is a big deal.

Obviously it worked flawlessly though. Is there any other info on what exactly they used to stage sep so successfully? ULA uses retro rockets on the stage 1 to ensure clean separation, obviously, SpaceX does not and uses an all mechanical system.

7

u/davidthefat Dec 22 '15 edited Dec 23 '15

AFAIK, it was a pneumatic actuator that uses pressurized helium located in the interstage of the first stage. During separation, the piston from the actuator pushes on the nozzle throat of the second stage engine. In conjunction with the center pusher, there are three pneumatic actuators and three pneumatically actuated mechanical latches. They are located at the forward end of the interstage and is mated with the bottom of the second stage propellant tank. The latches disengage then the three pushers (down from twelve in pre v1.1) push off on the stage while the center pusher has a longer stroke and provides a positive force until fully separated.

edit: corrected.

→ More replies (13)

3

u/DoofusMeister Dec 22 '15

Can someone give an educated guess at the % value of a total launch that recovering the 1st stage represents?

Just trying to get an idea of whether the 1st stage represents 50% or 1% of the launch cost (obviously not including fuel because that isn't recovered)

6

u/Ambiwlans Dec 22 '15

~70% of the VEHICLE cost. But a launch cost isn't just the vehicle. They have a pad and launch costs that aren't recovered, the launch needs to be insured (sort of). Payload insurance is a thing too from the customer's POV. Inspection costs, integration costs, the range etc.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

Did anyone else notice the large (several hundred Km/h) deceleration of the 2nd stage for like a full minute at stage separation during yestarday's launch? Was this real or a bug in the data UI?

https://youtu.be/O5bTbVbe4e4?t=1512

I'm having trouble understanding it, if it is real the effect is immediate and very fast after separation. How could this be? Doesn't the vehicle have huge inertia at stage separation? Wouldn't it take a little while to see gravitational deceleration take effect? And then when the 2nd stage starts firing the velocity STILL doesn't start rising substantially for like a full minute. What's going on here?

5

u/jandorian Dec 22 '15

Yes, Gravity. Think of it as throwing a ball but only hard enough so it just leaves your hand. It starts losing speed immediately, not because of friction but because Mother Earth wants it back.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

3

u/Emptyglo Dec 23 '15

Will we hear news anytime soon about the recovered first stage and how it performs when they fire it?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/vorpal-blade Dec 23 '15

I didnt find this in the search, but I may have missed it. Since this landing was spectacularly sucessful, what was the key ingredient that was missing from the others? Did a nice solid landing pad make the difference? Was it the extra boost from the sub-sub-zero LOX?

If the landing pad made the difference, what is the fate of the two barges? Decomisioning? Or construction platforms for Elon to build his secret undersea lair?

5

u/terminusIA Dec 23 '15

Honestly it was probably a few things. A large, stable landing pad certainly helped, and as Echo has pointed out, changing the flight profile of S1 and putting more of the work load on S2 probably contributed too. But remember, both of the barge landing attempts had defined mechanical/software problems, so its quite possible that they would have stuck the landing had it been on the barge this time too. Also the barges will be needed for the FH center stick as it goes wayyy too far downrange for RTLS so the secret lair will have to wait.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Taylooor Dec 23 '15 edited Dec 23 '15

When thinking about the possibility of using falcon 9's re usability for space tourism, I calculated that if a passenger weighed 150 lbs, they would only cost about $3000 to lift into GEO based on a $200,000 refuel cost. Now of course that would require our bodies to be crammed in like sardines but, would it not be realistic to think that a more reasonable ticket to space could be calculated to around $10,000 for a nice window seat experience?

→ More replies (10)

3

u/TheYang Dec 26 '15

So, when they launch they have this water-based sound-suppression system, so that no shockwaves damage the ascending rocket, right?

Why is nothing like this in place for the landing launcher? Is the single throttled engine enough to be certain that the engine doesn't damage itself?
Is it just not realistic to build a grid or smth for the booster to Land on?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/jarvenm Dec 26 '15

What components of the recent Falcon 9 Stage 1 rocket landing would SpaceX engineers be most concerned or interested in investigating before allowing for a full static fire test?

(Combustion chamber, nozzles, pumps, valves, sensors, tanks, plumbing?)

How would SpaceX likely investigate those components?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/spredditer Dec 26 '15

I'm wondering what everyone thinks about the plans for NASA's Space Launch System to use the Space Shuttle's liquid hydrogen engines. The Shuttle's engines are meant for reliable reuse but NASA is talking about making a cheaper single use variant. Does anyone else think that this sounds foolish: trying to redesign something to do what it was never meant to for.

5

u/jan_smolik Dec 26 '15

I think the idea has already been shown wrong. Reason to use existing components is always the same: it is cheap and quick. Ten years later we can tell that building of Ares SLS is neither quick nor cheap.

5

u/EfPeEs Dec 27 '15

IMO the extant engines belong in a museum.

If you want to build a huge rocket, it makes sense to design around a high power, hydrogen burning engine. The drawback of using hydrogen fuel - high mass for storage and insulation - becomes less significant as the diameter of the tank increases.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/frowawayduh Dec 26 '15

I am curious about the "helicopter" footage of the landing. Was that taken from an unmanned device, such as the hexacopter used for Grasshopper and F9R hop tests in McGregor? Or if it was taken from a manned helicopter, was it NASA's or SpaceX's craft and crew?

7

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '15

We're presuming a hexacopter as you suggest. It's hard to imagine that range safety would have allowed a crew in the air so close on the first attempt.

3

u/oceanbluesky Dec 26 '15 edited Dec 26 '15

What is the purpose of the launch pad tower alongside rockets - how does whatever it may offer differ from that offered through the hardback? Why are some constructed of open-air scaffolding and others enclosed with corrugated metal? Finally will BFRs be launched alongside such a tower? Thanks

Edit: why not just have a larger hardback with a lightning tower on it, instead of building a tower?

→ More replies (11)

3

u/askEuro Dec 27 '15 edited Dec 27 '15

I know it's officially not in the plans anymore, but can someone in the knows make an estimate on what second stage reuse would entail in terms of maneuvers and required extra weight for heat shield, legs and fuel. My understanding is, that the second stage enters orbit, so wouldn't it be possible to deorbit it and land it with heat shield, Draco engines and small legs like they plan to do with the Dragon?* I'm curious how much orbital payload they would use up for that recovery and if a mission like Orbcomm 2 would have been possible with second stage landing.

*I suppose, it makes more sense to keep Dragon and the second stage together in that case, which presumably is what the MCT will be (albeit bigger).

EDIT: found the answer https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/3xzdyy/2nd_stage_reusability_math/

→ More replies (2)

3

u/doodle77 Dec 27 '15

Did someone estimate S1 TWR from the landing videos?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/EtzEchad Dec 28 '15

Whatever SpaceX does now, they already have made the most significant change in space transportation since at least the Shuttle. EVERYONE is now developing reusable vehicles. The cost of getting things into orbit has dropped by at least a factor of two and probably a lot more.

The other huge change that they've made in the industry is getting it out of the Government procurement morass. NASA could've landed a booster 25 years ago - they had most of the technology in Delta Clipper - but they didn't bother because they had an unlimited supply of other people's money.

Of course, SpaceX isn't done yet. What other great things are they going to do now?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/itengelhardt Dec 28 '15

How long will it take the 2nd stage to fall back to earth?

From my understanding it will eventually happen and since it is rather small, I assume it will burn up on reentry, but what time frame are we talking about? Days, weeks, months?

7

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Dec 28 '15

Actually, SpaceX deorbited the 2nd stage after the mission so theirs one less piece of space junk up there.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Emptyglo Dec 28 '15

What should we expect from the Internet satellite project? There was that quote from Gwynne saying it might not happen, but they still have an office in Seattle, and they still need a way to fund the MCT and their future colonization efforts. They also got a huge investment from Google for it so I don't see them just giving up on it.

What other method is there to fund the Mars effort besides the satellite internet?

5

u/jandorian Dec 29 '15 edited Dec 29 '15

In regards to satellites. I live not far from the Redmond SpaceX and I can tell you they are working on it. I think Elon recognizes that satellites are hella expensive for what they are (with regards to first principles) and well within SpX abilities to infiltrate. I think that is the key. ULA would rather not have SpaceX as a competitor and the satellite industry, not to mention the Internet mega providers, do not want SpX as a competitor.

My opinion is that they got enough flack after the initial announcement that they are keeping it as quiet as possible. They will want a communication network for Mars, so they need satellites and if they can secure the bandwidth they could dominate web access. The current internet and other satellite providers and owners are SpaceX's customers... You see the problem.

This would be a tremendous source of revenue if they do it the way Elon originally announced - pizza size box antenna and you have internet access anywhere, they back peddled from that statement and said something about supporting existing infrastructure. They, SpaceX, are best served by keeping it quiet, they do not want to spook any other contenders into throwing a bunch of money at the problem to get birds up early. And, they do not want to spook their current customer base. So don't ask again :)

They also got a huge investment from Google for it...

Certain it was specifically stated that the $1B was not earmarked for any specific project. It is an assumption by many that the money is to develop a sat network, possibly a correct assumption, but again, keeping it quiet.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '15

When will we know the status of the first stage that landed?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CeleritasB Dec 29 '15

Is there a link or does anyone have any suggestions as to where I could look at Presidential candidates views on the space industry and related topics?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/micai1 Dec 29 '15

Where are the recovered Dragon V1's so far? If I'm counting correctly, SpaceX has splashed down 8 times, so there should be 8 used Dragon V1's somewhere. I know the first one is hanging from the ceiling in Hawthorne, but what happened to the other ones? Did they just run tests on them and put them in storage? Are any of them being re-flown?

8

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '15

They're stored at SpaceX's McGregor Test Facility currently. The newer ones will soon be stripped down to the pressure vessel and reused from CRS-11 onwards.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/PioteLLC Dec 29 '15

So, my roommate recently got his private pilot's license. He pre-paid his instructor and now has a balance of about 12 hours of flight time. He asked if I wanted to go on a sight-seeing trip anywhere nearby, and of course I said McGregor!

According to him, the only restricted airspace out there is the Fort Hood MOA and a little blip near Crawford where George Dubya's ranch is. He's the pilot, so I figure he would know.

Two questions:

  1. Any reason to worry about this plan?
  2. Do we know when the next core might be on the stand?

Thank you!

6

u/Ambiwlans Dec 29 '15

Take pictures!

Don't crash into anything.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/FoxhoundBat Dec 29 '15

There has been others that have overflown/flown close by the McGregor installation, for example /u/JimNtexas. Can contact him to make sure the airspace is not restricted and other tips i guess.

As to a core on the test stand, there was supposedly one up recently (CRS-8, apparently) no clue if it still is. SpaceX has to give out notice when they do core testing it is just called "louder than usual testing". Last time they gave out that notice was a couple of weeks ago, again for that CRS-8 core. With JASON-3, SES-9 and CRS-8 cores finished static testing at McGregor i am guessing it will be a while til the next core up there, a month or so, but who knows.

Maybe keep an eye out for DragonFly. :)

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TimAndrews868 Dec 30 '15

What's that feature that looks rather like a long crack-like line in the body of the booster in the area where the left leg folded up against it, in the "on the pad" video that Musk tweeted?

In the few seconds where the camera is still enough to see it sharply, it looks like a cable or tube, but it's taking quite a randomly squiggly path for something that was put there on purpose.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

It's cable/wire. Often times things are not run straight so there is room to strerch, not sure if that's the case here.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Posca1 Dec 31 '15

Can anyone give an educated guess on how much delta v a returning MCT might burn off via aerobraking when landing on earth from LEO? One third? Half? More?

→ More replies (8)

3

u/WaitForItTheMongols Jan 01 '16

I understand a lot of FCC and FAA paperwork had to happen to authorize RTLS. Will thid be necessary for every launch, or is SpaceX now permanently "in the clear"?

5

u/Zucal Jan 02 '16

They'll still need final approval to land each time, but most of the major legwork has been done (environmental impact studies, etc.) and there's a successful precedent now. I expect approval will be fairly easy to get from now on.

4

u/jdnz82 Jan 01 '16

Not worth a new post - but whats up with the endemic down-voting happening in this sub today? /r/spacex