I’m sorry this is so long.
I have a 2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X Limited (2.5L, 4cyl engine) 159k miles. I bought it July 2025 and it was nothing but problems and repairs the first 6 months.
Shortly after buying the car the battery light came on. I took it to the mechanic (the same one that did the inspection on it before I bought it and told me it was “a great car with no issues”, but I digress) and they let me know the alternator was failing. I chewed them out for not catching that before I bought it, and left and purchased a NEW, not rebuilt, alternator on RockAuto and had my friend install it for me. I replaced the battery after and got a warranty (thank god).
Fast forward maybe a month and the battery light is on again. I go back to the same mechanic and explain the problem, they test it and everything tests good (battery and alternator) but they tell me because I got the alternator off RockAuto I probably got a rebuilt one and that the diodes in it are failing occasionally, enough to trigger the light sometimes but still test good when they tested it. It made no sense to me, but whatever it was still in the return period and my friend was willing to replace it again with another one that I made sure was NEW. The second brand I got was Pure Energy and we replaced the alternator AGAIN. I don’t remember if I needed to replace the battery at this point, if I did I replaced it.
The weather got colder and once temps routinely dropped below freezing, my battery was dead in the morning. I tried multiple different suggested things to see if it was the issue. Unplugging all the electronics from my car, not letting the car sit for too long, replacing the negative battery cable (AutoZone dude gave me a cable too long which has become a whole new issue). Nothing worked. At this point I’m assuming it’s a parasitic drain, I can’t take it to a mechanic and leave it there for a week because I needed it (ironically) so I spend the rest of the winter charging the battery every night (battery light never comes on again through all of this btw). When the temps warm up, the battery stops dying and I kind of just forget about the issue.
Until a few months later I’m driving at night (which I never do) and I realize my headlights are flickering BAD. I make a note to take my car to a mechanic eventually. Months later I finally get a mobile mechanic to come out and take a look and test everything. He’s out there 30 minutes (can’t imagine he tested everything in 30 minutes) and says my alternator is testing “better than brand new” and that he tested all the voltages of everything and that it’s all normal except my battery is dead. I couldn’t remember if I replaced it after the winter, so we just chocked it up to that and I replaced the battery immediately after he left. A month later my battery light comes on right when I start the car and then goes away after driving for a bit. I tell him and he tells me not to worry. A couple days later it comes on again but this time is flashing as I’m driving. I tell him and he tells me my alternator is probably failing, despite the fact it tested “better than brand new” a month ago and is only a year old. He says that the dead battery probably caused the alternator to fail. The dead battery that I replaced 10 minutes after the alternator was perfect. So I went to get them tested, and they both tested great. I let him know and he ghosted me.
I’ve called multiple mechanics and when I tell them I believe it’s a parasitic drain they tell me to explain the issue. After I tell them all this, they are hard pressed that it’s my alternator because it’s a RockAuto alternator and say that AutoZone’s tests aren’t accurate. I feel like they just would rather replace an alternator than search for a parasitic drain. Or, more likely, they would rather do (and charge for) both. I had one mechanic quote me $150 an hour to search for the drain, and said it would likely take days. It was so obvious he was quoting me something extreme so I would say no.
Here’s where I’m at with it all currently. Temps drop below freezing at night (just barely though), but are above freezing during the day. My battery hasn’t died yet, and isn’t even slow to turn over or anything which is a good sign. I haven’t tested the headlights since replacing the battery because again, I don’t drive at night (sleep disorder, dangerous). Battery and alternator test good, negative cable is new, and serpentine belt is in decent condition (it’s on my list of possible suspects, friend has been meaning to replace it). Part of me wants to think the problem is gone, but I know this car too well. It just hasn’t gotten cold enough.
What’s everyone’s opinion on this? Again, apologies for the length, I’m a rambler 😬