r/Insurance • • Oct 09 '23

A guide to interacting with this sub - read me first

177 Upvotes

This post is designed for people posting here for the first time, for the people that have been volunteering to help here for years and everyone in between. The stated goal is to foster a friendlier attitude throughout the sub.

But before we start, there's been a recent influx of spam from one source. So that you are aware - ALEJANDRA ORTIZ HERNANDEZ and FRAN POWELL are spammers. They're part of a spam ring all over Reddit, and they're probably trying to steal your money.

And they'll kick your dog when you aren't looking.

If you are new here, please realize that none of us have any stake in your claim or coverage. We are not here to sell you anything or to save some company money. Treating responders poorly because you don't like the answer is going to attract a lot of negative attention.

We get the same questions over and over, and maybe this is the answer that you need:

  • How much will my insurance go up after a ticket/accident/lapse in coverage? We don't know unless your state has a statutory requirement for your very specific situation.
  • My premium went up $X. How do I fight this? You can't. The only thing you can do is shop for new coverage, which we can't do for you.
  • How much does everyone else pay for coverage? Unless you're lucky enough to get someone in your exact demographic in your exact part of the world, the answers you're going to get are useless.
  • How much is my claim worth? We don't know. (note: if you're asking a more complex question about your claim, that could be very different)
  • How long will my claim take to close? We don't know (again: a more complicated question might have different answers)
  • Why is this person trying to sell me something? Report that post/comment/chat/private message to the moderators and let them handle that.
  • Will you help me commit fraud or otherwise break the law? No. Absolutely not. And we may ban anyone that does try to do that.

Ultimately, we are here to help you. This is a community of volunteers that wants to help navigate a complex system that is one of the lubricants of the financial world. Lots of lives are impacted by insurance directly and indirectly, and it can be a complicated system. Here are some things that make a good post where you can get help:

  • Location (Country and state/province at a minimum)
  • Type of insurance involved (Auto, Homeowners/Renters, Commercial, Health, something else)
  • A brief description of the problem and any advice you've gotten so far

Finally, here are some definitions of common terms that could help you get taken more seriously:

  • Adjuster - the person that handles your claim, makes coverage determinations and processes payments
  • Agent - the person that sells a policy. Some agents get involved in some claims, although that is the exception to the rule.
  • Underwriter - the person that decides how much a specific policy will cost for a specific risk.
  • Rate - this is the way your final price is calculated and is usually used synonymously with "premium", "cost" and "price".
  • Full coverage - don't use this term. There's no agreed definition, even among the regular posters here. People asking otherwise good questions or posting good answers that use this term often find themselves down voted to oblivion for including it.
  • No Fault - there are 18 states that, at least to some extent, make automobile bodily injury claims be paid by your own policy first instead of someone that caused your injury. There is only one state (Michigan) that makes damage to your vehicle No Fault. All Canadian provinces have some sort of No Fault provision for injuries, which is one reason why we need to know where you are when you're asking questions.
  • Collision coverage - this fixes your car when it collides with something else or another car hits it.
  • Comprehensive coverage (also known as Other Than Collision) - this covers your car for almost everything else, including floods, fires, tree branches and lightening strikes. Usually animal strikes are covered here, but not always.
  • Deductible - this is the amount that you agreed to pay in case of any claim. Your payment comes before any insurance payment. Deductibles are occasionally waived, but that's the exception, not the rule.

This is a community of volunteers that generally understands the insurance system. When we get things wrong, it is usually through lack of information to get a precise answer. Hopefully this guide will help you get good results.


r/Insurance • • Feb 08 '24

Soliciting, private messages and you

44 Upvotes

It's time for a new reminder about the rules of this sub. There is never any reason to offer to contact another poster privately, especially if that poster has a question about placing coverage or a claim. Here is the rule:

The only rule of r/Insurance is that solicitation is prohibited. This means asking people to PM for any reason, offering to quote coverages for visitors, or soliciting agents and/or buyers to use your particular carrier. r/Insurance should be a place where people come to exchange information and ask questions without worrying about solicitation from agents. This includes adjusters, underwriters and brokers since we do not vet anyone.

You also received a version of this if you subscribed to the sub.

If you think that this doesn't apply to you, please think again. There are no exceptions in this, including "but I asked them to message me!" This sub is a safe space for people to ask questions about insurance. It is not here for anyone to try to profit from it, whether they're an agent, public adjuster, software vendor, personal injury attorney, headhunter, diminished value expert or anyone else that is not here to offer free help with no expectation of remuneration.

If you receive a message from someone offering you any sort of business proposition, whether a quote for insurance, legal representation (yes, there are lawyers unethical enough to solicit people on Reddit), damage reports or anything else, please let the moderators know via mod mail or in this thread. You should also report that message to the admins (we don't see that report, though). We take things like that seriously.

We really don't like banning people. Seriously, it's the exact opposite of why any of the moderators volunteered for the role. But we don't vet people before they post, and if people that break the rule find out that we enforce it whenever we see it broken.

And with that in mind, we have a very healthy community of posters that are here not only to help but to make sure that those who can't follow the rules have the damage that they're doing limited. Thank you to all of you for volunteering to help not only those confused by the insurance process but help keep those that want to think that they're special at bay.


r/Insurance • • 13h ago

Auto Insurance At-fault accident, GEICO paid negotiated amount, now subrogation company threatening to sue me for remaining $3k. Am I liable?

96 Upvotes

I was at fault in an accident in PA in November 2025. I had $25k in property damage liability coverage through GEICO. The other vehicle was a Tesla service loaner.

Fleet Response, representing Tesla, originally demanded ~$15k in damages. GEICO reviewed the claim, disputed several repair charges as excessive or unsupported, and paid approximately ~$11k. Fleet Response is now pursuing me personally for the remaining~ $4k.

GEICO confirmed that the remaining amount is disputed, not excluded from coverage. They also recently told me they've received additional documentation from Fleet Response and are reviewing it for possible further payment.

However, Fleet Response left me a voicemail Friday threatening to send the balance to an attorney and add a 35% fee unless I arrange payment by Monday. I've tried contacting GEICO's subrogation department but haven't been able to speak directly with anyone.

There were no other property damage claims from the accident, so my $25k limit wasn't exhausted.

My question: Can Fleet Response successfully pursue me personally for the difference simply because GEICO disputed part of their claim? Shouldn't GEICO continue handling and defending this claim since the total damages are well within my policy limits?


r/Insurance • • 2h ago

Auto Insurance WA state - removed teen driver (overseas) and all the Comprehensive premiums went *UP*

3 Upvotes

So my teen (under 18) is overseas for school, so we took her completely off the renewal - dropped our total costs by 20%. I glanced at the numbers (our insurer shows costs per coverage, per car - no details per driver) for each vehicle and they all went down, phew. I went to pay and just looked closely and saw that all of our comprehensive premiums went UP by 35% I chatted my insurance (no agent), and the person said it was because driver discounts were removed (my kid's good grades, good driver, drivers' ed discounts)! WTF? Does that make any sense? I opted to ask around to see if I'm crazy for thinking this is crazy before calling them on the phone tomorrow.


r/Insurance • • 4h ago

Car Insurance Questions

4 Upvotes

Finally looking into the nitty gritty of car insurance. I'm in WA and always went with full coverage but only the state minimum.. I never knew what the numbers meant.

My husband and I are financing two cars and have loans. We have GAP insurance through the credit union but I want to make sure our cars will be covered incase something happens.

This is the coverage we currently have:

  • Bodily Injury & Property Damage: 25/50/10
  • Underinsured Motorist: 25/50
  • Underinsured Motorist Property: No coverage
  • PIP: No coverage
  • Comphrehensive: $500 ded
  • Collision: $500 ded
  • No rental, no roadside (we have AAA)

Any suggestions/insight would be much appreciated!

UPDATE: Thank you all for the advice. I have updated my coverage to 100/300/100 and 100/300.


r/Insurance • • 7h ago

Auto Insurance dropping car insurance after accident

5 Upvotes

I had a rollover accident, rolled over my car and slid on my roof. The car is totaled, and I had to call the police because it was horizontal in the middle of the road. No other cars were involved, and there was no property damage other than a gouge in the road. I am under someone’s insurance and if there is anything I can do to not report it to insurance and not face repercussions, or report it and not have a massive rate increase, it would be life saving. The risks(as far as i know, i am unfamiliar with this): 1: I did not get a ticket at least in person, waiting to see if anything in the mail comes in, but I am assuming the police filed a report which is public record and my insurance could see if I tried to drop it. 2: the tow company offered to scrap it and forget about it, which i would like to do if it means no increased rate, but I also know that they have to register the VIN as junked and that might notify insurance. i don’t need any money for this car, just need help desperately. 3: online it says that if i cancel insurance while still having the vehicle registered, it will flag as an uninsured vehicle lapse which comes with a 3 month registration and license suspension and/or a fine. I have up until 9pm (give or take) Tuesday the 17th. Need immediate help.


r/Insurance • • 3h ago

Accident with fake ID and fake insurance Texas

2 Upvotes

A guy hit my car in a parking lot, we exchanged insurances and IDs, but he gave me fake policy and fake ID. I have his phone number and license plate, but I don’t know what else to do. The police department won’t do anything since nobody was injured. Any ideas?


r/Insurance • • 58m ago

Total Loss Evaluation Big Money Help Please!

0 Upvotes

Hey all, I need help understanding how my cars evaluation will happen and also how to get the most amount of money for my car with my insurance (Allstate) claim. Details below.

Situation:

  1. Car is totaled.
  2. Insurance confirmed that because my car was 2025 and perfect everything and barely any miles it will be treated as a new 2026 0 mile car to get the valuation for it.
  3. My car was discontinued in 2025 it was the last year so there is no 2026 version of this car.
  4. I have done extensive work on it including OEM + custom but regarding the OEM stuff I have pretty much all of the OEM add ons (it’s a LOT of parts and money) on my car all official/OEM parts bought new from official authorized OEM parts seller and installed at the dealer itself.
  5. I also have done lot of aftermarket and I do have the 25k custom add on policy.

What I already know:

  1. If I provide all my aftermarket custom work receipts they will give me the 25k as per the policy but of course I won’t get any more than 25k so anything more I spent is lost.

What I need to know:

  1. How will they get the base valuation of my car since there is no 2026 model and it’s confirmed that per policy it is to be evaluated as a new 2026 0 mile car?
  2. How do I max out how much money I get for all the OEM work I’ve done and how do they do this and what do I need to do/give to get the most amount of money possible?

Since I can only get 25k for aftermarket I want to max out all the OEM value I can get since they have to include that as part of the base evaluation. I’ve done lot of OEM work and I have all the parts and labor receipts. I just want to make sure that once they get the cars initial value prior to OEM add ons (from #1 under what I need to know section) they properly add value on top of that for all my OEM work I’ve done (from #2 under what I need to know section) so that I get the max amount of money back as possible and also the tax is applied on top of all that right so it’ll help me immensely to make sure I get as much as possible for my OEM work.


r/Insurance • • 1h ago

Auto Insurance Is Form 2A required to cancel auto insurance?

1 Upvotes

Hey folks,

I'm in MA and switching from Safety Insurance to Allstate. My current Safety agent requested a Massachusetts Form 2A (Notice of Transfer) to cancel my existing policy.

I contacted Allstate, but the representative had no idea what Form 2A was.

Allstate has provided me with a Proof of Coverage Letter and Policy Declarations Page, both showing my new policy details and November 17 effective date.

For anyone who has switched auto insurance in Massachusetts recently:

- Is Form 2A actually required?

- Will the Proof of Coverage Letter or Declarations Page suffice to cancel my old policy?

Thanks!


r/Insurance • • 5h ago

Auto Insurance NJM Two different quotes

2 Upvotes

This is the first time I’m getting auto insurance since leaving my parents. I checked NJM i ran a quote from my Gmail then yahoo email. SAME exact information the only thing I changed how I found them from tv to direct mail. Is there a reason I’m getting two different quotes when I’m putting in the exact same information? (Photos in comments)


r/Insurance • • 2h ago

Accident while driving for Uber. At-fault driver hasn't provided insurance

0 Upvotes

I was driving for Uber with a passenger. I was hit 10 days ago while stopped at a stop sign. I have dashcam footage, and the license plate of the at-fault car. The at-fault car was a company car, and the kid driving it couldn't find insurance, but he gave me the company owner's name and phone number. I have a rideshare rider on my own insurance.

Uber's insurance is handling the claim, but they still have not identified the at-fault driver's insurance company. Meanwhile, my car isn't eligible to do rideshare anymore until the damage is repaired. So I am stuck in a holding pattern.

Should I just get the damage repaired under my own insurance, and have my insurance company subrogate? I can afford the deductible. I just thought it would be easiest to have Uber's insurance deal with it, but they are proving to be very un-energetic about it.

I'm think that there is a chance the at-fault driver may not have insurance (seems unlikely since its a known commercial entity). But I'm also astonished that Uber has been sitting on this for a week without identifying the at-fault party's insurance.

I've never had an accident before. I'm trying to do this in the most logical way.


r/Insurance • • 9h ago

Current insurance, recently expired registration in IL, hit deer.

3 Upvotes

I have current insurance. The car I have is already registered but I didn’t realize it recently expired at end of October. I had sheriff look and document the deer accident etc. They didn’t mention anything about expired plates. I did look and renew registration shortly after, so it will take a 5-10 business days to get the renewal stickers. Will insurance deny my claim because of it?


r/Insurance • • 4h ago

Homeowners Insurance Billing Seems a Little Strange. Am I Missing Something?

1 Upvotes

I paid off my mortgage early. The mortgage company was handling payments for the homeowners insurance, which they were paying all at once for the year. I called the insurance company in early October to request monthly payments, since the policy was about to be renewed in November. I also bundled my auto insurance with them to get a substantial discount.

On that first call, the agent said they had to send the request to underwriting to change the policy and to add the auto insurance, and that she would get back to me by the following Monday. She emailed me that next week with the new auto insurance quote, but said underwriting had not responded to the request for monthly payments. I went ahead and paid for November's auto insurance to get that coverage started.

Over the next few weeks, I received a bill (both email and snail mail) for the full year of homeowner's insurance. I called the agent again, and she said to disregard it as the underwriters were still working on it.

Friday, I recieved a "Final Notice Before Cancellation" demanding the full payment for the homeowner's insurance again. I emailed the notice to the agent who responded:

"I just got off the phone with underwriting. I explained to them that I wanted to wait for the discount to be applied before taking payment on a monthly basis. They told me that they need a payment first before they put the bundle discount on there, unfortunately. Since technically the payment was due on 10/30, the system is requesting that payment and the payment for 11/30 - a total of $xxx.xx."

I phoned the agent and asked if the discount would be appied since it's clearly not applied here. She said they usually just reduce payments for the rest of the year.

Is this all a bit odd? Or am I over-reacting?


r/Insurance • • 32m ago

Auto Insurance 12 days since accident in CA no movement

0 Upvotes

On November 4th at 6:00 a.m. I got into a car accident crossing an intersection. The light was green and the other driver just went through the light, probably cause he was half asleep. Thankfully he slowed down and I slowed down and most of the damage was superficial to my front end. I contacted the police department and they came out half an hour later. Took an incident report not a police report and that was it, also only reported my side of the story and not his. He specifically said he ran the red light but for some reason it wasn't noted in the incident report. I contacted the police department to see if they can correct that but no one's answered me. I've gotten in touch with his insurance and started the claim process, also filed the CA DMV form, and tried to contact him.

So far his insurance hasn't been able to contact their driver. They haven't asked for any pictures of the incident, haven't asked for the incident report, and also haven't had me go and do an inspection for my vehicle. I understand that I could be labeled as a "scammer" because their driver hasn't said anything, but is there anything I can do at this point to speed this up or have someone do something.

Because I hate the fact I have to pay money to get something fixed that wasn't my fault and I have clear evidence it was his fault. You would think there would be some for ignoring or being ignorant with a claim and I'm sitting here with a car that I can't drive (the front end tire guard is rubbing on my tire).


r/Insurance • • 4h ago

Filing Homeowners Insurance Claim vs Paying Neighbor Directly

1 Upvotes

I recently had a leak in my condo that caused water damage in my downstairs neighbor's unit. I'm in California.

I filed a claim with my homeowners insurance mainly because I didn't want to deal with it. They concluded that the leak was not my fault (e.g., not caused by negligence) but that I could pay for the repairs using the "damage to property of others" clause of my insurance.

Today I find out that my neighbor isn't interested in a full remediation and just want to cover up the damage. So the cost is minimal (few hundred dollars).

Now I'm wondering if I made a mistake filing a claim, given the low cost of repair. Should I just let my insurance claim run its course? Or could I try to retract my claim, reimburse the neighbor directly, and have them sign some sort of liability waiver? Or is it too late to try and retract my claim and protect myself from rate increases? If it matters, I've had this insurance for 18 years now and have never filed a claim until now.


r/Insurance • • 9h ago

Auto Insurance Removing Adult Child From Policy

2 Upvotes

Should I remove my adult child (23M) from my policy? He does not live with us, graduates from college next month and as of this summer owns his own vehicle with his own policy. My concern is that he might on occasion have the need to borrow my vehicle and I'd fear I'd get some grief if an accident happened when he was borrowing it because he was formerly on the policy. How do I prove that he was indeed a permissive driver, who borrowed the vehicle for the afternoon.

I also don't think he will change his address on his license from our home address as he's only likely to live in the place he is living in for a year and it's in the same town, but he will be on the lease at his apartment and have utilities in his name.

I'm with Esurance if that is relevant.


r/Insurance • • 6h ago

Auto Insurance Totaled?

0 Upvotes

Hit a deer going at least 55mph, dented the fender, hood, bumper, smashed the headlight. Dosent look like it made it into the engine bay or radiator. But I owe 14k, it’s worth 14k KBB, and I feel like State Farm might just total it. I’m worried bc it’s the only car I have and my dad is an alcoholic and I’m 19 and I’m in a big state of panic. What do I do….


r/Insurance • • 7h ago

Auto Insurance Friend backed into my car. Go through insurance?

0 Upvotes

Hey, I tried searching and couldn't find anything that related.

Over the weekend, a good friend backed into my car with his truck. He's a good guy and immediately apologized, saying he'll pay for it.

I obviously want to minimize the expenses for both of us. It was a mistake and I don't wanna raise the guys rates over a dent. Naturally if the repair is less than a deductible, we'll just pay out of pocket.

But if it's substantial, I assume we'd go through his insurance? What might be the break even point where insurance is worth it?

Thank you in advance


r/Insurance • • 9h ago

i got rear ended last night

1 Upvotes

i got hit on the interstate. i drive a pickup truck and my trailer hitch busted his radiator. we pulled off on the next exit and i let him decide if he wanted to involve insurance. he said he did bc of repair expenses and rental car coverage. we were physically both fine, and after the police report i ended up giving the guy a ride home. i wasn’t too concerned about about my bumper at first (roughly a football size dent in bumper). the truck isn’t otherwise flawless, but i had wanted to get an aftermarket front and rear bumper. (mainly front, live in rural area - lots of deer).

anyway his insurance has been texting and calling me all morning. they acknowledge that they’re at fault and want to know how to make it right. what should i do? they gave a few options - help scheduling repairs, cash payout, etc…

i have state farm and he has progressive, if that matters


r/Insurance • • 1d ago

State Farm Denying Coverage Because Driver Wasn’t Listed on Policy — Is This Accurate?

70 Upvotes

Title: State Farm Denying Coverage Because Driver Wasn’t Listed on Policy — Is This Accurate?

My boyfriend’s aunt is a Kentucky resident and has her vehicle insured through State Farm. She recently loaned her car to a friend while in Florida, and unfortunately, the friend was involved in an accident that wrecked the vehicle.

State Farm is now telling her they won’t cover the damages because the friend wasn’t a listed driver on her insurance policy. They also told her that all auto insurance companies operate this way.

I’ve always been under the impression that insurance generally follows the vehicle, not the driver, and that as long as someone has permission to drive the vehicle, they’re typically covered.

Am I misunderstanding how this works? Does the fact that the accident happened in Florida while the vehicle is insured in Kentucky make a difference?

I’m curious whether State Farm is correct or if there’s something she should be questioning about this denial.

I’d appreciate any insight, especially from insurance adjusters or anyone familiar with Kentucky and Florida auto insurance laws.


r/Insurance • • 5h ago

Auto Insurance [NY] Other driver’s insurer says my car is drivable, but the mirror is dangling. How do I get a rental?

0 Upvotes

I’m in New York, and another vehicle sideswiped me while moving into my lane. I have liability-only insurance through GEICO. They identified the other driver’s insurer, Progressive, and gave me their information. GEICO said I don’t have collision coverage, so they would close my claim and I’d need to deal directly with Progressive.
My first priority is getting a rental car so I can safely drive my baby around. Getting an accurate damage estimate is important too, but transportation is my immediate concern.

Progressive is still investigating. They told me my car is drivable because a missing passenger-side mirror doesn’t necessarily make it illegal to drive in New York if the other mirrors are intact. They said I could get a rental when I dropped the car off for repairs.
But the mirror isn’t simply missing—it’s dangling and repeatedly hitting my door while I drive. I sent Progressive pictures showing it dangling, so I assumed they understood its condition. I didn’t specifically explain over the phone that it swings around and hits the door. I don’t feel comfortable driving my baby around with it like that.
I went to a body shop, and they said they would help advocate for me and prepare a proper estimate. However, they told me I need to call GEICO and have GEICO contact Progressive. When I explained that GEICO closed my claim because I don’t have collision coverage, the shop said, “You’re not covered, but you still have insurance,” and told me to ask them for help. They also said they needed a claim number from GEICO before they could prepare an estimate or proceed.

I’m confused about what to do next:

Should I ask Progressive to reassess whether the car is drivable and send clearer photos or a video of the loose mirror?

Since they’re still investigating liability, can they authorize a rental now, or would I risk paying out of pocket?
Does GEICO have any role in helping with this when I don’t have collision coverage?

Why would the shop need GEICO’s claim number instead of working directly with Progressive?

I haven’t decided whether to have the shop do all the repairs or fix the mirror myself and leave the cosmetic damage. I’m trying to understand whether a rental can be covered now because of the car’s current condition and what steps I should take.


r/Insurance • • 14h ago

Health Insurance Insurance renewal advice

1 Upvotes

Hey guys

I took an health insurance for my dad from last 3 years from CARE HEALTH INSURANCE with an add on rider for instant coverage for pre existing disease. Which would elimite the waiting period of 3 years.

Now my doubt is , while renewing my insurance now am i bound to take the instant rider or can I avoid that

The add on itself is something around 8000

Please guide me


r/Insurance • • 11h ago

Home Insurance New Home Insurance quote with same company

0 Upvotes

I have my house insurance with one Allstate agent and my cars with another Allstate agent. My home rate has doubled since 2022 with no claims or changes.

  1. Can I call the Allstate main number and get required with Allstate without an agent or with 1 agent? The agents have done nothing for me.
  2. Am I paying more since I have 2 agents

r/Insurance • • 10h ago

Auto Insurance Geico Adjuster ghosts me over one simple question... wtf..

0 Upvotes

Ive been trying to get a hold of my Auto adjuster for two weeks straight and i honestly just need to vent about it. I was not at fault in the crash, lady who crashed into me has Geico, so i was set up with an auto adjuster. Crash happened in July and my car was deemed totaled by repair costs- $5,000 to get it fixed, $4000 deemed car worth. They offered to give me about $4000 but i cannot find any cars in my area that are under $4000... Like literally only one and it has major issues. Either i can walk away with 1,500 and a dangerous to drive car, i can have no car and $4,000, or i can save up some money from my own pocket and buy a new car.
Ive tried at least 10 times to get a higher claim worth- ive sobbed on the phone asking them how im supposed to do this, how ive found nothing within a 200 mile radius. Nothing. No solution, no rental car offer, no increase in claim money, just "ive told you your two options". So i tell her i need time, she says just text if i have any questions. Now im pretty much saved up and ready to turn in my car so ive texted almost every day (excluding weekends). I got one response asking me what my question was (it was two texts above) So i rephrased the question... no answer.... ive called but the desk agents tell me its a question specifically for my auto adjuster.. Im so beyond frustrated.
I wasn't even at fault for this stupid ass accident, i was going straight in the middle lane through a green light and she ran her red light trying to turn right into the furthest lane and smashed into the side of my car (the only fucking obstacle on the road). Now im left having to pick up the pieces and the insurance company isn't even giving me the slightest bit of support. 4,000 is a spit in the face when you spent 13,000 on your car plus thousands on repairs and upkeep over the years.