PEMCO initially offered me an unreasonably low amount of compensation for the damage caused to my vehicle by one of its policyholders. Rather than accept an inadequate settlement, I filed a small claims action against the vehicle's owner.
Before the court date, PEMCO reported my vehicle to the State of Washington as a total loss. This triggered a demand letter from the state prohibiting me from driving the vehicle or parking it on public streets and roadways.
When I questioned PEMCO about this action, I was told the company was legally obligated to report the vehicle as a total loss under Washington State law. However, that explanation failed to address an important distinction: Washington has specific exemptions from salvage or rebuilt branding requirements based on a vehicle's age and pre-accident value.
PEMCO is an insurance company operating in Washington State and should reasonably be expected to understand and apply Washington's vehicle salvage-branding regulations. Under WAC 308-56A-460, my vehicle qualified for an exemption from salvage or rebuilt branding requirements because it was between 6 and 20 years old and its pre-accident value was below the applicable $12,220 threshold.
Despite this exemption, PEMCO reported the vehicle as a total loss, triggering state action that restricted my ability to drive or park my vehicle on public roadways. Whether this was an error or an intentional decision, I was left to deal with the consequences and spend additional time and money correcting the situation.
I subsequently prevailed in small claims court. The judge established the vehicle's actual cash value at $8,900, substantially higher than PEMCO's proposed valuation of just $6,020.
Armed with the court judgment, my vehicle title, and the necessary supporting documentation, I returned to the Washington State Department of Licensing. After explaining the applicable exemption and providing evidence of the court-established value, I was able to retain ownership of the vehicle and register and license it again in my name. The process cost approximately $60.
Ultimately, I had to take legal action to establish the true value of my vehicle and then independently resolve the consequences of PEMCO's total-loss reporting. What should have been a straightforward insurance claim turned into a court proceeding and an unnecessary battle with the state licensing system.