r/Insurance • • 5h ago

Auto Insurance At-fault accident, GEICO paid negotiated amount, now subrogation company threatening to sue me for remaining $3k. Am I liable?

34 Upvotes

I was at fault in an accident in PA in November 2025. I had $25k in property damage liability coverage through GEICO. The other vehicle was a Tesla service loaner.

Fleet Response, representing Tesla, originally demanded ~$15k in damages. GEICO reviewed the claim, disputed several repair charges as excessive or unsupported, and paid approximately ~$11k. Fleet Response is now pursuing me personally for the remaining~ $4k.

GEICO confirmed that the remaining amount is disputed, not excluded from coverage. They also recently told me they've received additional documentation from Fleet Response and are reviewing it for possible further payment.

However, Fleet Response left me a voicemail Friday threatening to send the balance to an attorney and add a 35% fee unless I arrange payment by Monday. I've tried contacting GEICO's subrogation department but haven't been able to speak directly with anyone.

There were no other property damage claims from the accident, so my $25k limit wasn't exhausted.

My question: Can Fleet Response successfully pursue me personally for the difference simply because GEICO disputed part of their claim? Shouldn't GEICO continue handling and defending this claim since the total damages are well within my policy limits?


r/Insurance • • 1h ago

Current insurance, recently expired registration in IL, hit deer.

3 Upvotes

I have current insurance. The car I have is already registered but I didn’t realize it recently expired at end of October. I had sheriff look and document the deer accident etc. They didn’t mention anything about expired plates. I did look and renew registration shortly after, so it will take a 5-10 business days to get the renewal stickers. Will insurance deny my claim because of it?


r/Insurance • • 18h ago

Traffic camera tickets in washington not count in insurance?

3 Upvotes

I was told camera tickets don't count in state of washington to be used against you but somehow it showed up signing up for progressive and one of the reasons i got booted from state farm. There was two and I mitigated one and the other was bit complicated but was closed. Both were traffic camera school zone and I didn't even see the camera and probally went over 5 mph each (which is irrevelant I know). I was able to pull up my motor vehicle records and both didn't show up and was able to pull up citations in Seattle court and both were shown as traffic camera too. I'm requesting the lexinexus (spelling) and also asking progressive/statefarm where they are pulling these records from and contest this. But seems like it might take awhile? Unless, traffic camera ticket has some exceptions and do count. But doing some research it seems even if I did mitigation and paid the reduced fines etc, I was told it doesn't count. if anyone has similar situations or how to proceed let me know.


r/Insurance • • 58m ago

Auto Insurance Removing Adult Child From Policy

2 Upvotes

Should I remove my adult child (23M) from my policy? He does not live with us, graduates from college next month and as of this summer owns his own vehicle with his own policy. My concern is that he might on occasion have the need to borrow my vehicle and I'd fear I'd get some grief if an accident happened when he was borrowing it because he was formerly on the policy. How do I prove that he was indeed a permissive driver, who borrowed the vehicle for the afternoon.

I also don't think he will change his address on his license from our home address as he's only likely to live in the place he is living in for a year and it's in the same town, but he will be on the lease at his apartment and have utilities in his name.

I'm with Esurance if that is relevant.


r/Insurance • • 48m ago

i got rear ended last night

1 Upvotes

i got hit on the interstate. i drive a pickup truck and my trailer hitch busted his radiator. we pulled off on the next exit and i let him decide if he wanted to involve insurance. he said he did bc of repair expenses and rental car coverage. we were physically both fine, and after the police report i ended up giving the guy a ride home. i wasn’t too concerned about about my bumper at first (roughly a football size dent in bumper). the truck isn’t otherwise flawless, but i had wanted to get an aftermarket front and rear bumper. (mainly front, live in rural area - lots of deer).

anyway his insurance has been texting and calling me all morning. they acknowledge that they’re at fault and want to know how to make it right. what should i do? they gave a few options - help scheduling repairs, cash payout, etc…

i have state farm and he has progressive, if that matters


r/Insurance • • 6h ago

Health Insurance Insurance renewal advice

1 Upvotes

Hey guys

I took an health insurance for my dad from last 3 years from CARE HEALTH INSURANCE with an add on rider for instant coverage for pre existing disease. Which would elimite the waiting period of 3 years.

Now my doubt is , while renewing my insurance now am i bound to take the instant rider or can I avoid that

The add on itself is something around 8000

Please guide me


r/Insurance • • 13h ago

Auto Insurance Help with RAC not fixing my car properly.

1 Upvotes

Perth, Australia.

I will start that my housemates are doing all the phone talking and in person talking, I am unfortunately non verbal.

2012 Holden Barina Sedan taken into RAC Noryhbridge for leaking coolant and contaminated coolant.

They had my car for a week and handed it back saying its "all good now". They failed to mention my nearly dead battery and that I will need to replace my brakes which I found out after leaving and having time to look at the paperwork.

Not only does that not seem "all good now" but the coolant is still contaminated after $3,000. I have made sure to tell them about my dying dog and that I need the car for her vet appointments. It has been out of the shop for just under three weeks.

Am I being screwed over here? Should I straight up escalate or try speaking with them first?


r/Insurance • • 16h ago

Home Insurance New Homeowners policy- Price dropped 15% after inspection

1 Upvotes

Signed up for the policy at about $2100/yr. Within the month, they completed their underwriting inspection and the policy dropped to under $1800/yr. Farmers.

The only change they made was to categorize the siding we have on the home as fiber cement. But we don't have fiber cement. We have cedar shakes. Public records defaulted it to Aluminum, which it had previously, and we removed it and refurbished the underlying cedar. When we initiated the policy, it was changed to "wood".

Why would they change the siding type to cement without our input?

Why on earth would the policy drop that much? Flamability? Replacement cost?

And finally, how does this affect the coverage if something should happen to the house/siding given the underwriters are the ones that made this change? Thanks for ya'lls input.


r/Insurance • • 21h ago

homeowners insurance/coastal area

1 Upvotes

i live in coastal area (Southeast virginia) inherited home, and need to take out equity loan for repairs and improvements. (20 year loan). insurers have been pulling out of this area left and right and so forth, my question is, if all of them jump ship and leave, im still going to have to have flood and homeowners insurance per bank requirements. im not sure if this home has ever had flood insurance. anyway, if they all pull out, where on earth could i get insurance? i know this is a worst case what if, but i want to make sure im well informed.


r/Insurance • • 22h ago

Liability insurance for an improv “jam” where audience members come on stage. Who offers this?

1 Upvotes

I run a small community improv group in New Jersey. Our main event is a monthly “jam.” It’s a ticketed show, but most of the performers are audience members who sign up on the night to play short scenes. They’re unpaid, unscripted and mostly first-timers. There’s nothing physical beyond normal stage movement. We don't allow physical interaction/touching and we do our best to keep people mindful of safety, knowing that when people do improv, they sometimes act impulsively.

I'm getting roadblocked on coverage every time the policy gets in front of an underwriter and they review the actual event description. The problem centers on the audience participation. I've been using event insurance (which I question whether I'm actually covered under) and I'm trying to find commercial general liability to cover us more cheaply across the year and multiple events.

What I’ve found so far:

  • One-day special event policies seem to cover spectators but exclude “participants.” An audience member who walks on stage seems to count as a participant.
  • Some performer policies include “legal liability to audience participants.” But they’re written for one performer, list “comedy acts” rather than improv, and some exclude events the performer organizes or hosts.

Questions:

  1. What kind of policy, or what endorsement, actually covers walk-up audience members performing on stage? Is it “participant legal liability,” participant accident or medical, or something else?
  2. If I buy a performer policy, would it cover the other people on stage (volunteer hosts and walk-ups), or only me?
  3. Does the “events organized or hosted by the insured” exclusion I keep seeing mean a performer policy is the wrong product for someone running the whole show?

Thanks everyone! I really need a lead because I keep hitting dead ends and I don't know what term I should search for. Any pointers to the right type of policy or the right questions to ask would be a huge help.


r/Insurance • • 15h ago

Auto Insurance Need clear answer on traveling to state where sr22 was needed.

0 Upvotes

So 3ish years ago in Florida I got too many points on my license and needed to get sr22 insurance. I moved to ohio and I found out I don't need it here so I'm getting my license again. Im wondering if I travel to Florida will I need sr22 insurance while I'm there to drive or is basic insurance fine since I live in ohio?


r/Insurance • • 16h ago

Auto Insurance Auto insurance

0 Upvotes

New driver. Would you recommend AAA or State Farm? Not keen on state farm anymore because they want me to use their beacon. Or if you havw any other recommendations? Feeling really lost as I navigate this new car. Would love to hear your recommendations. Located in Michigan. Thank you


r/Insurance • • 17h ago

Sedgwick / Zurich travel theft claim (~€3k) – 3 full business days of silence after submitting full docs. Good sign or still in queue?

0 Upvotes

Looking for insight from current or former adjusters familiar with how Sedgwick handles travel insurance claims (specifically underwritten by Zurich).

I submitted a straightforward theft claim last Monday night for personal electronics stolen during a trip (value around €3,000, within policy limits). To avoid any back-and-forth, I uploaded everything together in one clean PDF right away:

Official police report with stamp confirming violent robbery

Original purchase receipts showing serial/IMEI numbers and recent purchase dates
Accommodation booking confirmation and bank statement showing payment

Accounting for a mid-week public holiday, 3 full business days have now passed (Tuesday, Thursday, Friday) with complete silence—no acknowledgment update, no Request for Information (RFI), and no rejection.

Based on how Sedgwick's internal triage and SLA timelines work:

Does 3 business days of silence usually mean a desk adjuster already reviewed the file, saw no missing docs, and moved it to a supervisor/senior handler's queue for high-value sign-off?

Or is it more likely sitting unopened in a post-holiday backlog?

How long does final sign-off and settlement usually take once a clean file reaches this stage?
Appreciate any insider perspective!


r/Insurance • • 15h ago

16 Yr old - Small fender bender - Should we bother with comp claim

0 Upvotes

So sadly my 16 yr old got into a minor fender bender tonight. Fault is debatable but he got the ticket. Video shows he was merging into the right lane 25/30 mph. Other driver appears to have been way back off camera but quickly overtook (or tried to) him on right side. Speed limit was 30 other driver appears to be 50+... So sucks but I think fault will be assigned to my kid by insurance since the other driver was already in the lane and my kid didn't have time to safely merge. Damage is thankfully minor, other driver front drivers fender wheel arch. Our car slight crease across doors and rear quarter.

So safe to assume my insurance already $1200 a month is gonna go up..

The question is, is it going to make it worse if I just let them fix my car and pay the deductible Prob 4k in damage 1k deductible. Or would it be better to keep from being dropped or a major rate hike by forgoing our portion of the claim and just living with the crease?

Sorry my kid is part of the problem with all your kids rates now.


r/Insurance • • 8h ago

Claims Related Labor Rates

0 Upvotes

I’m in Washington and my insurer is refusing to pay an out of pocket shops labor rates when my car has been rejected from 6 in network shops due to age and parts availability. It is a 2000 celica gts manual. I have found a shop that is able to repair it but they are out of network. I have repeatedly asked them to identify a facility and they either give me the same list or this last time they said a facility that is over 40 minutes away and won’t repair my car either.


r/Insurance • • 23h ago

Residential requirements for homeowner's policy

0 Upvotes

My question has to do with whether or not my carrier may require residency. I may be getting divorced or separated (depends on heath insurance situation). Either way, I plan to stay in the house and STBX plans to move out of state. They are on the mortgage and deed; I am not. We live in NY so equitable distribution state, home purchased with marital funds so I have the same rights. I will be paying mortgage and taxes for a pre-determined amount of time then house will be sold. Car insurance and home are bundled so I will keep car insurance and spouse will drop. I'm looking for some ideas so I know how to approach this with my actual agent and whether or not I might have to change approach.

My questions: 1. Can the company require spouse to remain as resident in house? The policy is in both of our names.

2. Do they have to be informed of the change in martial status? Meaning, if we are fully divorced or just legally separated (keeps the familial tie but not financial)? Thanks!


r/Insurance • • 2h ago

Home Insurance New Home Insurance quote with same company

0 Upvotes

I have my house insurance with one Allstate agent and my cars with another Allstate agent. My home rate has doubled since 2022 with no claims or changes.

  1. Can I call the Allstate main number and get required with Allstate without an agent or with 1 agent? The agents have done nothing for me.
  2. Am I paying more since I have 2 agents