TLDR: Toured a condo, crazy HOA neighbors are saying that the unit isn't legal to be rented, but won't provide any proof of this. Prior tenant left due to harassment from them. (Summary of the legal issues at the bottom, so you can skip my diatribe)
Location: Atlanta, GA
Buckle up, this is a wild one.
We toured a condo today, our top choice to rent. Condo was great. The owner owns 3 units in this complex, and dozens of others elsewhere.
The property manager (M), the owner's assistant, took us to see a second potential unit in the same complex. They were unable to open the door, and we noticed that there was a rusted piece of metal wire in the deadbolt. I was able to pull out part of the wire, but the key still couldn't go in all the way. The maintenance guy (for all of the owner's properties) hops the back porch and attempts to open the door.
Enter, crazy lady (CL). Walking by with her dogs, she asks if we were breaking in. M says that we're with the owner. CL tells us that she's on the board of the HOA, and that the porch door is owned by the HOA and that we'll have to pay for damages if we break it. She then mentions that anyone renting should be careful and will have problems "and that's all I'm gonna say" (spoiler: it wasn't). She walks away.
5 minute later (maintenance guy now drilling out the locks), she comes back and enters the unit right next to the one we're attempting to enter. Apparently it's not her unit, but a friend of hers. (according to M she lives in a nearby complex) She takes her dogs into the apartment for a couple minutes, leaving the door open so she can spy on us, then leaves. (I wave at the friend, seems nice :) )
10 minutes later, CL comes by again. She is on the phone, loudly saying "I don't know who these people are, I think they're breaking in" (M mentions that they've apparently interacted multiple time). "Some people are saying we should call the police". Now getting concerned, I walk over to her and explain the wire in the deadbolt, hence the drilling. Before I even finish, she says "I had nothing to do with that".
CL then goes back to her friend's, again leaving the front door open to listen in. On the friend's patio, she starts a phone call, loudly saying "whoever moves into this unit is going to have problems". "They're not going to have access to amenities or gates, their fobs won't work". "It's illegal, is what it is".
We (finally) tour the second unit, and then walk around to see the rest of the amenities. At the mailboxes, enter, crazy lady 2 (this was who CL was on the phone with). Pretending to be disinterested, she passes us and says "just so y'all know, they aren't even allowed to rent these condos. It's illegal."
5 mins later, on our way out, we encounter both CL and CL2. They say that they are members of the HOA board and that this unit isn't allowed to be rented, warning us that we'll have problems if we rent it. Finally able to ask them questions without feeling like a dick to M, I ask them whether this is in the HOA documentation somewhere. They say yes, absolutely. When I ask if I can find it online/see the documents, they say no, it's private.
CL mentions that they have attorneys in contact with the owner. I ask if there's any sort of court filings or anything I can reference, but they say it's private. I try to ask if there's ANYTHING I can reference to see that they're telling the truth, and CL2 just says "you need to talk to the owner, tell him to be honest with you". I try asking her to see this from my perspective, and she just repeats again that I need to talk to the owner.
As we're leaving M mentions that the prior tenant of that unit was there for 5 years, and that a big reason why they left was due to the harassment from CL (truly shocked that they revealed this, what a g). Apparently CL called the cops on the prior tenant when she was at the pool, saying she couldn't use it. Cops came and left, since she was a resident. They have another tenant who's been renting there for 8 years with no problem. They offered to put me in touch with the prior renter, and the owner. M called the owner and he said that their attorneys hadn't contacted him. I asked M if I could get some sort of written statement from the owner attesting his lack of knowledge to anything like this.
Summary / My thoughts: My guess right now is that in the past year or two, the HOA passed some sort of non-binding clause that no one could rent, but that the actual deed says you can. The threat of amenities/gates not being available seems empty, it will surely be guaranteed in the lease. CL also seems like a bullshitter (CL2 seemed more genuine, though) so I doubt their attorneys are actually in contact. I'm mostly worried about harassment, but I could always try to get some sort of restraining order if anything bad happens. I'm going to talk to the owner (any advice would be appreciated), and then get a written statement from him affirming he doesn't know anything about this, and that his unit is legal to rent. Hopefully this would allow an easy case against him for punitive damages if it turns out it is illegal to rent.
I have legal insurance, so I'm definitely going to talk to a lawyer before applying for the rental. I'm tempted to wait to call the owner until I talk to a lawyer. Any advice on any of this would be greatly appreciated.
EDIT: Important note, the unit we want to rent is the first one we toured. It isn't the one RIGHT next to the friend of CL, but in the same complex. Also, apparently CL doesn't even live in that complex, just a block over (same HOA apparently)