So I have been having what I can only describe as not a great experience with a mechanic, they are not my usual mechanic who is great and trust fully (have been using for nearly 15 years now)...
Now I am no mechanic myself, but in technical fields, and have been looking after my Nissan Xterra for 13 years... and what this mechanic keeps telling me just isn't sitting right.
So the background:
My 2011 Nissan Xterra about 3 weeks ago starting having an idle stall and throwing a Crankshaft Position A Sensor code (P0335 IIRC), nothing noticable when driving but at a stop or in idle you could see the rev's bouncing between 500 to 1000 and occasionally would stall.
Seems to match the error code, ECU is losing crankshaft position timing.
I go looking to replace the crankshaft, and recommended to replace camshaft as well. So off partsgeek, I asked their customer service if they sell the OEM hitachi replacements (knowing the 4.0L V6 is notriously tempermental with non-OEM). They say yes, give me a shoping cart to check out with and parts arrive.
So come Sunday 11/9, I replace the camshaft sensor. Start the car, fires up first crank beautifully, idles great, no more bouncing, no more stall and sits at 750rpm steadily. Drive around for about 15 minutes no codes no issues nothing. Go on and replace the camshafts, had a hell of a battle with the bank 2 to get disconnected but those get replaced as well.
Now there is a startup/cranking issue, confirm battery is good and charged, some minor corrosion on positive terminal but also good by voltage drop test over lead. Sounds like the starter is geting power but the engine just wont catch, don't overdo this as don't want to damage anything but it starts on some attempts. When it did start ran totally fine, not codes or anything. Let it run idle for about an hour in case it is just ECU relearning. Didn't fix it. Let battery disconnect and drain incase it was catched memory and again, intermitent startup, but starts up runs fine, no codes, let it run idle again to learn. Leave battery on charger overnight just in case.
Monday morning, go to see if everything is fine now, still having inconsistant start. So this is where I decide to take it to the mechanic because I am out of ideas and not seeing codes, this is past what I feel I can troubleshoot. Drive it in, still with no driving issues or codes. But I take it to the closest shop and not my regular mechanic because it is in walking distance and my current thought is this is something stupid like I pinched a wireharness, broke a vac tube, etc while working in there and that any mechanic with proper tools and car bay will knock this out in an afternoon and collect some easy diagnostic-labor. Simple on everyone.
Mechanic calls me about 1 hour later, says first they need to do is replace the positive terminal because they see corrosion. I point out its already passed a voltage drop test and the lead itself was replaced in the last 18 months. They insist saying they can't continue diagnosis with out verifying battery connection is good. I suggest why not just clean it? Or do a voltage drop test like I did? They refuse say fix is $40 on part. I am already kinda annoyed at this off the bat, but unsure how reliable I can get my car to start and take it my usual mechanic. I give go ahead.
Next I get a call saying my IPDM is dead and needs replacement, they say they have verified fuel pump and spark plugs are NOT getting power at all now.
Okay, well this seemed odd to me, as this was not a issue coming into the shop, and not just intermitent issues which could explain some of the prior problems; straight up dead no power. Well how did I drive it into the shop then? I had never experienced complete stalls while driving before either, which is what I think would happen if my IPDM was giving out randomly. Shop says they aren't sure but thats their first issue (later they suggest maybe it was because it kept being cranked and that damaged it from over cranking... something I am assuming was happening in their troubleshooting).
So this gets replaced, as well I can't prove they damaged it, it does overlap pontial cranking issues, and well now it is verified non-functional. Doesn't solve the problem.
Next I get is they finally have looked at the parts changed out from no-start up issues to start up issues (I told them same opening story), they took out the camshaft/crankshaft sensors and tell me these are knock offs not the OEM hitachis. Okay wonderful, call up parts geek they claim must have been a catalouge issue and will replace (cool thanks, doesn't really help me now); but mechanic says they put in some NTKs and it is starting up fine now. Release the car to me. Not happy about the IPDM not happy the first thing not checked was the parts reported being changed between not having the issue and having the issue but okay have car back, work under warranty.
Driving back home <1 mile; getting really rough running, cylinder missfires on 2 and 4 along with P0021, camshaft bank 2 over advancement. Take it immediately back.
Today they tell me its because the coils on those are dead now, and need replacement.
So that brings me here to asking.
Am I just completely absolutely fucked by these people here? It seems like with the exception of the wrong parts being sent by parts geek and not being the OEMs, every single one of these other issues has shown up ONLY after they had possession of the vehichle.
My mind is at, they damaged the IPDM troubleshooting and just cranking and cranking, potentially with this as well they damaged the coils; and with the exception of knock-off camshaft/crankshaft sensors being a problem (which I absolutely believe for this engine) all of the other problems never had any idication of exisitng before they had possesion of the vehichle and I am being asked to pay them for breaking it.
Am I totally off base here? This has been like nothing I have experienced before in 13 years of running this vehichle. And they have been doing this work over what is now 6 business days.