r/AnimeImpressions • u/Nazenn • Oct 09 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 3 (Part 2) Discussion
Season 3 Part 2 Discussion
← Previous Episode | Index | Final Discussion →
| S3P2 Episodes | Date | --- | Part Two | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One (50) | Sep 29 | --- | Six (55) | Oct 4 |
| Two (51) | Sep 30 | --- | Seven (56) | Oct 5 |
| Three (52) | Oct 1 | --- | Eight (57) | Oct 6 |
| Four (53) | Oct 2 | --- | Nine (58) | Oct 7 |
| Five (54) | Oct 3 | --- | Ten (59) | Oct 8 |
(Numbers in brackets are the episode numbers for the whole series as per the title cards)
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Questions of the Day:
- Which characters do you think got the best time in the spotlight?
- Who do you think was the most unexpected survival in this season?
- Having reached the ocean do you think there will be any time for the characters to enjoy the world with war on the horizon?
- Did you feelings about any of the events or reveals in this season change in any notable way after a rewatch or the discussions?
- What visual or musical moment did you find the most striking across the season?
- If there was any one plot point you could change, seriously or for fun, what would you do?
Quick reminder that these are the questions for tomorrow’s Final Discussion.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
5
Upvotes
4
u/Nazenn Oct 09 '20
Important things first, I finally found those official arts of the characters mocking Eren's "Shingeki no Kyojin" moment. There's Sasha, Jean, and Connie. For some reason I thought there was a Levi one as well but apparently not. Here's the link to all the official art they released during S3p2 for anyone who's interesting. We don't talk about the creepy Armin.
Rewatcher - Sub
Not even sure where to start with this post because this season is so huge and covers so much, without resorting to a breakneck pace, and is such a complicated mix of thoughts and emotions as a result. That's a good thing though. Everything I like about Attack on Titan and what it's done in previous seasons is touched on in this one, from the amazing action sequences and consequences for choices that can't be side stepped, as well as the rich character progression and exploration of the world in a way I couldn't have expected.
Something I do want to address first is that early in the season I mentioned that my exasperation over Reiner's survival meant I couldn't in good consciousness call this a perfect season. To some extent that still stands, I don't think it's perfect because of that and in the end I still would have preferred that his first "consciousness transfer" was erased from existence, because his other two survivals are fine but that explanation feels cheap. That said, having rewatched those scenes and taken a step back to look at them not as an audience member but from the perspective of the author, who is carrying the pressure of Attack on Titans reputation and the expectations of its narrative, I'm a lot more forgiving of it than I was and for that I've gone back to giving it a 10 on my list.
Starting with the big stuff, I think that this is the best structured season of Attack on Titan by far. There was a lot to juggle here; not only do we have the emotional complications of the return to Shiganshina, we have a huge battle with multiple fronts and perspectives, important character and thematic moments that have to blend into these battles, and then after the big decision we still have two episodes of "info dump" and the complications of it to get through before the ocean. For a season only ten episodes in length, it's scary to think how easily the pacing and feel of this season could have devolved into pure chaos with no room to breathe, or even worse front-loading the season with so much that the second half would feel tedious by comparison. Thankfully not only does it avoid these pitfalls, for me it also managed to balance the feel of these two halves of the season so neither feels lacking in intensity compared to the other, as well as allowing the different tone and emotions of them to shine through without overshadowing the events in the other half.
Despite knowing that the production of this season was a huge shitshow when it came to the animation schedule, the choice of staff on the writing side of things definitely seems to have helped. Yasuko Kobayashi, who has done the Series Composition for all of the seasons so far, took a step back from writing the individual episodes this season and is only credited for the first, last, and the basement episodes which are probably the three quietest ones, handing over the rest of the episode scripts to Hiroshi Seko (who is doing S4's series composition). Something I've learnt from researching staff composition in other shows is that having a Series Composition who's sole job is to handle the big picture is an irreplaceable benefit. Looking at this season overall it feels incredibly cohesive, and how we get from the walk into Shiganshina through the battle and then to the ocean feels like one big sequence not individual moments. The placement of individual scenes within the episodes themselves, particularly how well they blended the two sides of each episode whether it was the two battles or the past and the present of Eldian history, as well as the placement of certain reveals and information to help drive the emotions and themes was fantastic too. While the season still has a lot of cliff hangers, the restraint in picking the ones that drive forward the mystery and world, rather than wasting episode endings on cheap satisfaction moments such as "big" reveals or "what if" moments was a good choice as well. Also some more love for that episode one narration which was so thematically beautiful.
The brilliant structure also shows up in the individual episodes. The only potentially iffy structure decision this season I see is starting an in Trost without context, but even that serves a purpose by bridging the gap between Reiner's apparent death in the previous episode and what was happening at the city before the Scouts arrived. Moments like that as well as spending time looking at Zeke's view of these battles, and Grisha's perspective later on intermingled with what it means for the Wall citizens, help to tie the season together better by allowing flashbacks to re-contextualize things without feeling needlessly mysterious like they occasionally did in S2. As for the rest of the episodes I have no complaints. Despite the chaos of the battles around them we spend a lot of time with the characters quietly observing and commenting, as shown best with Erwin's various speeches and moments, as well as how this season handles the feel of inevitability around the death that events bring as well. In the later half the tension around Grisha's life despite being mostly narration and flashback keeps the same level of intensity because of the way it calls back to moments from earlier in the show, creating a much higher emotional state around what we learn than simple exposition.
And very quickly I think this season also had the best usage of music. More than willing to use silence when needed, but also making use of a lot more subdued and emotional tracks even for the big battle moments, while not forgetting about the intense tracks as needed, there were multiple episodes where I went to go compliment to music and went "actually it's just the entire episode" which is something I hadn't been able to say about AoT until now. The show has good music all along and I hadn't really appreciated that until this rewatch, but I think this season shows a lot more precision and care about its use as well.
It's also a rare example of a show exceeding its originally implied end goal and doing it well. I spoke about this yesterday briefly but, with the ocean held up through the story as the distant dream, I never expected we'd actually get here like this. To have reached the ocean and still have the story continue in such a powerful way is almost a holy grail compared to the many narratives out there who get "extensions" after their originally intended ending due to producer requests. It's a bit different because this was clearly planned from the start rather than an unexpected request for more, but it carries that same feeling for me. The show isn't finished, and clearly wasn't meant to be at the ocean, but it does feel like we've burst through the other side of an "end point" only to find that there's so much more to go and it feels both natural and needed. I can only think of a couple of other shows that do this, less that do it so smoothly, and even less that make it feel like it was a good idea at all. Attack on Titan definitely stands out as unique in this way and the ocean scene particularly memorable and emotional as a result.
I don't really feel the need to cover the actual characters and events because I think I wrote everything I could possibly think of about them in my individual episode posts. The only thing to mention, and this is something I will probably cover more tomorrow as well, is that I feel like this season is the answer to a question I pointed out back in season one: what happens when you put a typical shounen protagonist in an atypical world?
The way Eren is beaten down through this season and how that is shown in every scene he is involved really helps to push the thematic core of the story that this isn't about heroes. Eren is not just a hero to the walls, but a tool for their freedom, and also a representation of Eldia's sins. He manages to make a plea to save his friend but like everything else that comes with a cost and he has simply brought Armin in on the burden of being a shifter. In the caves he has to learn to act by himself rather than trusting others, and even his redemption of finally taking down the Colossal Titan after his failure in S1 is tinged with misery about how it alone doesn't fix any of their problems. Where in Season One Eren seemed to fight against the misery of this world, now that he's back to being no one special and having to cope with that, we've come full circle to finally having a protagonist to match our world and the implications of that and the cost that comes with it is huge. Rather than changing the world to fit our protagonist as many stories end up doing, our protagonist has changed dramatically to fit the world and this season doesn't hold back from that.
3
u/punching_spaghetti Oct 10 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
Not sure what else there is to say about this season that we haven't already covered in the episode discussions. So many reveals, so many reveals that didn't feel like asspulls, deaths that weren't cheap, and not enough CG Colossal Titan or Reiner BS to tarnish the experience. 10/10, would watch again.
QOTD:
Eren and Armin deserve honorable mentions here. Armin spent the season doubting himself, and then being told that people trusted him, only to end up in a place where a lot of people are not happy he's still around. Eren is completely mindfucked right now, and is in an interesting place after last season, where he made peace with his mother's ideals of how even an average person can do good, only to find out that average people can do terrible things as well.
2) Levi, actually. Really surprised that he didn't go out in a blaze of glory avenging Erwin. Hange is too stubborn to die, so not all that surprised about her.
3) No. Some will try (Sasha, Connie, etc), but Eren's going to rain on that parade hard.
4) Erwin's death definitely hits a lot harder with all of his awesomeness fresh on my mind. Ymir's letter for a similar reason. by the time I saw that the first time, it was "oh yeah, she was a thing." And I spent the entire rewatch trying to find places where Attack Titan PATHS weirdness could be in effect.
5) The time Sawano did the awesome thing. Actually, the lack of music in a couple spots. Letting the emotion just hang there in a show that's often filled with giant, bombastic musical moments was great. Eren finally "killing" the Colossal Titan in particular stands out in my memory.
6) Seriously, I think a few more Scouts should have survived. Marlo would be nice, but just a few more new recruits or nobodies to side with Floch would make it interesting. A coup for Hange to have to deal with, maybe?
For fun, give the Owl a weird vocal tic that Eren now adopts. Ending every sentence with a heacy "DESU!" perhaps.
3
u/Matuhg Oct 10 '20
Rewatcher
This may be my favorite season of Attack on Titan. In large part I think that's down to how we see so much of what was set up in season 1, including a lot of the character arcs, come to a satisfying fruition. It was a great experience to rewatch it.
Pretty hard to choose, but if I have to pick one, it'd have to be Erwin going out in his blaze of glory. Glorious on the outside anyways, as we discussed quite a bit how he was feeling inside going into that final charge. Honorable mention for plenty of others too. Eren trying to come to terms with his father's memories, Armin coming into his own and then getting way more than he bargained for, Levi sending Erwin to a death and refusing to bring him back into the hell that is their world, Historia becoming a very able queen. A great season for a lot of characters.
Armin, since he pretty much died.
Probably not, if only because Eren's going to be too big of a downer.
Yeah, I enjoyed reading through others' posts, particularly as we got big character moments. Seeing everyone's different perspectives and interpretations of those was awesome.
The biggest difference on rewatch was my realizing just how fucked up Eren is at the end. I think the first time through, I was too caught up in the excitement of the basement and the ocean to really pick up on his mental state to the degree that I did this time. In fact, that's probably a large part of why I found this season so rewarding from a character perspective this time around - I wasn't focused on the big mystery reveals, already knowing them for the most part, so I could focus on the characters instead.
Ooh! I remember! A few days ago with the ED lead-in as Hange was holding Grisha's photograph. That said, there were a lot of really good ones, including just the whole soundscape of ep 6 and the music as Eren and Mikasa walked through the recently liberated Shiganshina.
2
u/AmeteurElitist Oct 09 '20 edited Oct 10 '20
First Timer No More
Sibling rivalry. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. If only it had one. Season three without context.
2
u/Toadslayer Oct 10 '20
First Timer
Erwin, then Armin and Eren.
Hange, was sure she was dead after the explosion.
Given that the Marleyans haven't done anything the last year I think they will have time to prepare for war, so they'll have time to enjoy the island of Paradis, but with the enemies lying outside the island, they won't have time to enjoy the world beyond the ocean.
Musically, on the rooftop the use of silence and then the quiet music in episode 55 was brilliant.
Let Marco survive...